She got 300s in gidle's OT6 time and 700s after just 1 full album and 2 mini Albums. That is a huge improvement imo. After I NEVER DIE she also never got 2s like in Relay, Put It Straight and What's Your Name
Minnie - Main Vocalist, Sub Rapper. Soyeon - Main Rapper, Main Dancer, Vocalist, Center, Leader. Yuqi - Main Dancer, Lead Vocalist, Lead Rapper, Fotg. Miyeon - Main Vocalist, Visual, (Rapper?) Shuhua - Lead Dancer, Vocalist, Sub Rapper, Visual.
LATATA Dollar Maze Hear me HANN Put is straight Blow your mind Uh-Oh Lion Oh my god Maybe I'm the trend DUMDi DUMDi HWAA DAHLIA Last dance TOMBOY Never stop me Villain dies Liar My bag Nxde Change Dark (x-file) Ninety nine Queencard Lucid All night Paradise I DO I want that Eyes roll Tall trees Wife Super lady Doll 🔛 🔝❤
@@wellatalenio9890I mean they likely would’ve tackled these concepts (besides Tomboy) with her in the group anyway. But I don’t think Shuhua would’ve ever had her big boom if Soojin stayed.
soyeon is the ace of group and minnie is the ALL ROUNDER, she is main vocalist, great dancer and stage presence, also a great rapper and composer. she deserves first position 🩷
She doesnt.Minnie is a straining nasal stylistical singer whose notes are always nearly strained.Minnie is an allrounder but so is Miyeon(who is undoubtly the best vocalist in the group) and Yuqi an ace who is the 2nd best vocalist.So never understood the hype around Minnie
@@lusinearzumanyan2604 miyeon is not an allrounder lmao her dancing skill is the worst out of the group, so is her stage presence. Thats why she gets the easiest steps when she is center and most of the times is on the edge.
fans are very hypocrite when it comes to Miyeon they literally want sub vocalists get more parts than the main vocalist miyeon lol she is undoubtedly the best vocalist but she is fourth in ot5 distribution lol
@@ΜουσικήΙδιοφυΐα yea fr Miyeon gets 1st place: "poor Shuhua she gets no lines" Shuhua gets 1st place: "This is so unfair a sub vocalist has more lines than the main vocal!!"
6:59 WHAT OMGGG A MAIN VOCALIST IS LOWER THAN THE SUB VOCALIST OMG AFOJSAFOPDSJGDSLJGSDG really I am getting used to seeing all my biased members getting less lines no matter what their positions are lol jeongyeon miyeon ningning jisoo ryujin jihyo
thats the ranking when you arent counting literally 75% of their career into the equation, shes third overall in a group that isn't vocal heavy, theres a reason why minnie and soyeon have more lines, its cuz their vocal tones and abilities are more in line with gidles music, also in what world do ningning, and jihyo get few lines like please get a grip, not every main vocalist needs to have the most lines overall, if that were always the case, might aswell be a soloist
@@omarbirkdar5536 in the ot5 distribution she is fourth, doesn't it matter?? she has even less lines than sub vocalists like yuqi and soyeon lol even talentlessshuhua will get more than her in the future lol stop being hypocrite girl.
@@omarbirkdar5536 it doesn't matter she is third overall look at that gap of 300+ seconds with minnie, if she's a main vocalist, miyeon is the other main vocalist, it's you who don't understand anything. and the majority of the parts who make you third now are from the ot6 songs in which she was treated like a main vocalist COMPARATIVELY. In ot5 tracks she is fourth lol toxic minnie stan
Chocado que a Soyeon não tá com a maior parte das linhas-- E ela deveria falar pra amiga dela shuhua fazer mais aulas de canto, pra ela conseguir encaixar mais linhas dela na produção
i know they aren’t a vocal based group but they aren’t rap based either. Miyeon has to be in top3, what do you mean she is 4th in the ot5 songs overall??? only higher than the member who can barely(?) sing……..
I think they are rap based (?) I dunno but I think Wife, Dollar, My Bag is all rap-centered And most of their tracks have a rap verse in them. Even some songs like Uh-Oh, Luv U are pretty much rap-centered
@@pineappl3pizzzasoju The first column is the average amount of seconds the members have for each song they participated in. The second column is the percentage of their average comparing it to others (It’s like a circle graph that you see after the end of a line distribution). What’s inside the parenthesis is the difference between the average line distribution and the line distribution overall (From the percentage of the overall line distribution to the percentage on average).
Poor Miyeon.Debut since 2018,she only got 1st place 7 time.She is the best vocalist in Gilde and Soyeon didn't use Miyeon voice properly.Soyeon overusing Minnie voice almost in every song.Miyeon didn't get 1st place in Title Song is a crime.She trained many years for this treatment???She deserve many 1st place in Title Song.❤
Wasn't she first in Dumdi Dumdi? And her difference to Soyeon in latata is barely 2 secs. (Not using it as an opposite to a you said, cause I agree, just technical details I wanted to add 😅)
miyeon shines in lot of TTs compared to minnie, minnie can ever rap better than miyeon and her voice is more versatile its obvious she gets more lines. there is no “overusing” here lol half of the bsides are composed by minnie herself.
You clearly don't know much kpop... Specially 2nd generation! Aaah, and there's someone here at the comments that actually did the percentage distribution and is actually fair! Not to mention first place is,the main vocalis, so twice fair!
![ITZY ~ All Songs Line Distribution [from DALLA DALLA to UNTOUCHABLE]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/2eP-0Mvd8k8/mqdefault.jpg)
![ITZY ~ All Songs Line Distribution [from DALLA DALLA to UNTOUCHABLE]](/img/tr.png)
![TWICE ~ All Songs Line Distribution [from LIKE OOH-AHH to STRATEGY]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/5iqc8dxzvl8/mqdefault.jpg)
![PUBG X (G)I-DLE - NINETY NINE [Special MV]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/iiiU5I8b3co/mqdefault.jpg)
WE SAW A THOUSAND AT OUR SHUSHU
and I was also killed by the fact that she overtook Soojin only at the end of I feel....
Shuhua deserve this!!!
It took so long for her🤧
She got 300s in gidle's OT6 time and 700s after just 1 full album and 2 mini Albums. That is a huge improvement imo.
After I NEVER DIE she also never got 2s like in Relay, Put It Straight and What's Your Name
Main vocal can rapping
Main rapper can Highnote
Main dancer as lead vocal
Main visual as main dancer
Yuqi should be main vocal with miyeon
@@tp5510no minnie and miyeon main vocalist
@@myelriex.Yuqi is a better vocalist than Minnie
@@iamk-poptrash6497nooooo
@@dark__ssparks She is tho
500s
1. Minnie - Uh oh
2. Soyeon and Miyeon - Light my fire
3. Soojin - Lion
4. Yuqi - Moon
5. Shuhua - Escape
1000s
1. Minnie - Dahlia
2. Soyeon - Tomboy
3. Miyeon - Already
4. Yuqi - Dark (X-file)
5. Shuhua - 7Days
1500s
1. Minnie - Reset
2. Soyeon - Allergy
3. Miyeon - Play Buldak
4. Yuqi - 7Days
2000s
1. Minnie - Doll
2. Soyeon - Rollie
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
It’s so funny seeing Shuhua just rise to the top on number of 5th places and then seeing Minnie and Miyeon disappearing in number of 6th places 😂😂
Shuhua needs MORE LINES 😢😢😢
Minnie - Main Vocalist, Sub Rapper.
Soyeon - Main Rapper, Main Dancer, Vocalist, Center, Leader.
Yuqi - Main Dancer, Lead Vocalist, Lead Rapper, Fotg.
Miyeon - Main Vocalist, Visual, (Rapper?)
Shuhua - Lead Dancer, Vocalist, Sub Rapper, Visual.
Miyeon could be a sub rapper instead of rapper and shuhua could be rapper instead of sub rapper.
You forgot a member.
@@FatFrogs she's no longer in the group but i think she was either a sub or lead vocalist
@@idkwhattoputhere616 Soojin was the main dancer,sub vocalist and lead rapper
Miyeon值得更多
她是主唱
希望下次回歸
讓她唱第一
因為她的歌聲
真的很穩定~~❤
yes but minnie is a main vocalist too
@@clara_are_roses Minnie have a lot of lines so she don’t need to give her more lines but miyeon need because in ot5, she only got 4th
為什麼面姐沒有那麼多分配………..
Yuqi也值得更多，因為她是領唱，也是 gidle 中唯一一位既會唱歌又會說唱的人
LATATA
Dollar
Maze
Hear me
HANN
Put is straight
Blow your mind
Uh-Oh
Lion
Oh my god
Maybe
I'm the trend
DUMDi DUMDi
HWAA
DAHLIA
Last dance
TOMBOY
Never stop me
Villain dies
Liar
My bag
Nxde
Change
Dark (x-file)
Ninety nine
Queencard
Lucid
All night
Paradise
I DO
I want that
Eyes roll
Tall trees
Wife
Super lady
Doll
🔛 🔝❤
OT6 FOREVER NEVERLANDS❤
Other members lines : 📈📈📈📉📈📈📉📈📉📈📈📈📈📉
Shuhua lines : 📉📉📉📉📉📉📉📉📉📉📉📈📉📈📉📉📉
Soojin lines : 📉📉📈📈📉📈📈📈❌❌❌❌❌❌❌❌❌
She really went /\/\
During Flip It and Doll lmao
Soojin lines : 📈📉📈📉📈📈📉📈📈📈📉🚫❌❌❌❌❌❌
Got the whole comment section laughing bro.
When the number of 5th place :
Shuhua : I'm comingg
We miss soojin's voices so much ! 🤧
@@wellatalenio9890 I respect your opinions!!
@@wellatalenio9890I mean they likely would’ve tackled these concepts (besides Tomboy) with her in the group anyway. But I don’t think Shuhua would’ve ever had her big boom if Soojin stayed.
Listen to her solo then bye
Shuhua is really that idol to consistently rank last
im so glad shuhua has 2 songs with most lines now!!
5:17 the EXACT moment of glory for shuhua stans
Miyeon needs more lines😢
its 69 like and i dont want to ruin it😂😂
shuhua*
@@Athenya555 shuhua only asked cube to give her less lines cause her korean pronunciation is not so good
As long as soyeon makes their song she won't give lines to her colleagues.
@@Athenya555and miyeon is a main vocalist
soyeon is the ace of group and minnie is the ALL ROUNDER, she is main vocalist, great dancer and stage presence, also a great rapper and composer. she deserves first position 🩷
Yuqi also
She doesnt.Minnie is a straining nasal stylistical singer whose notes are always nearly strained.Minnie is an allrounder but so is Miyeon(who is undoubtly the best vocalist in the group) and Yuqi an ace who is the 2nd best vocalist.So never understood the hype around Minnie
Yuqi is the actual ace and all rounder
@@lusinearzumanyan2604 minnie has a siren voice ❤❤❤ its so dreamy and beautiful, i love hearing her sing
@@lusinearzumanyan2604 miyeon is not an allrounder lmao her dancing skill is the worst out of the group, so is her stage presence. Thats why she gets the easiest steps when she is center and most of the times is on the edge.
Shuhua has remarkable number of 4th places. Quite an achievement.
Miyeon deserve a lot of lines because of her main vocal position!!
1st comment! Can i get a pin ?
fans are very hypocrite when it comes to Miyeon they literally want sub vocalists get more parts than the main vocalist miyeon lol she is undoubtedly the best vocalist but she is fourth in ot5 distribution lol
@@ΜουσικήΙδιοφυΐα literally!!
@@ΜουσικήΙδιοφυΐα yea fr
Miyeon gets 1st place: "poor Shuhua she gets no lines"
Shuhua gets 1st place: "This is so unfair a sub vocalist has more lines than the main vocal!!"
No one said that @@rippydodoonokmu
@@slaaaayyy23 yeah literally every kpop fan on line distribution comments lmao
How did Shuhua only beat soojin right before the HEAT album😮😮😮,she needs more lines!😢
She chose not to have lines especially during 0t6 because her Korean was not good back then
Soyeon be bouncing from first to last in I burn era like XD
Minnie deserves all her lines ❤
6:59 WHAT OMGGG A MAIN VOCALIST IS LOWER THAN THE SUB VOCALIST OMG AFOJSAFOPDSJGDSLJGSDG
really I am getting used to seeing all my biased members getting less lines no matter what their positions are lol
jeongyeon miyeon ningning jisoo ryujin jihyo
thats the ranking when you arent counting literally 75% of their career into the equation, shes third overall in a group that isn't vocal heavy, theres a reason why minnie and soyeon have more lines, its cuz their vocal tones and abilities are more in line with gidles music, also in what world do ningning, and jihyo get few lines like please get a grip, not every main vocalist needs to have the most lines overall, if that were always the case, might aswell be a soloist
@@omarbirkdar5536they will never understand it.
@@omarbirkdar5536 in the ot5 distribution she is fourth, doesn't it matter?? she has even less lines than sub vocalists like yuqi and soyeon lol even talentlessshuhua will get more than her in the future lol stop being hypocrite girl.
@@ΜουσικήΙδιοφυΐα looks like you literally read nothing about what i said but ok, keep complaining, im sure thatll help
@@omarbirkdar5536 it doesn't matter she is third overall look at that gap of 300+ seconds with minnie, if she's a main vocalist, miyeon is the other main vocalist, it's you who don't understand anything. and the majority of the parts who make you third now are from the ot6 songs in which she was treated like a main vocalist COMPARATIVELY. In ot5 tracks she is fourth lol toxic minnie stan
Slayyyyy ❤😊
Doll and Flip It, SHUHUA IS THE FIRST!!!
Miyeon (2018 - present)
Minnie (2018 - present)
Soojin (2018 - 2021)
Soyeon (2018 - present)
Yuqi (2018 - present)
Shuhua (2018 - present)
Minnie ❤🧡💛💚
Fun fact: Shuhua has more lines than Jisoo 😂😂😂
Bc Gidle have more songs
Chocado que a Soyeon não tá com a maior parte das linhas-- E ela deveria falar pra amiga dela shuhua fazer mais aulas de canto, pra ela conseguir encaixar mais linhas dela na produção
K-pop팬인 한국인입니당.영상 정말 재밌네요!
Shuhua queen of last place
Amamos
I miss soojin but now she is solostis ❤❤❤
SHUHUA : 7:12 ___________________ 7:30
i know they aren’t a vocal based group but they aren’t rap based either. Miyeon has to be in top3, what do you mean she is 4th in the ot5 songs overall??? only higher than the member who can barely(?) sing……..
I think they are rap based (?) I dunno but I think
Wife, Dollar, My Bag is all rap-centered
And most of their tracks have a rap verse in them. Even some songs like Uh-Oh, Luv U are pretty much rap-centered
Soyeon in "i burn"🙂 ⬆️⬇️⬆️⬇️⬆️⬇️
Miyeon Minnie Soyeon: race to the 1st place
Yuqi: Im here Still here
Shuhua: ______________
Soojin: ...
Average Line Distribution per song
Minnie: 32.3 | 20.6% (-2.1%)
Soyeon: 30.4 | 19.4% (-2%)
Miyeon: 27.7 | 17.7% (-1.8%)
Soojin (+2): 26.5 | 16.9% (+8.4%)
Yuqi (-1): 24.1 | 15.4% (-1.5%)
Shuhua (-1): 15.7 | 10% (-1.1%)
Variation: 22.5% (-2.5%)
Color of Zone: Green
Key
Gold (Very Fair): 0%-10%
Green (Fair): 10.1%-29.9%
Yellow (Normal): 30%-59.9%
Orange (Unfair): 60%-94.9%
Red (Very Unfair): 95%+
What does the | first.column | second column % (and inside parentheses %) mean?
@@pineappl3pizzzasoju The first column is the average amount of seconds the members have for each song they participated in. The second column is the percentage of their average comparing it to others (It’s like a circle graph that you see after the end of a line distribution). What’s inside the parenthesis is the difference between the average line distribution and the line distribution overall (From the percentage of the overall line distribution to the percentage on average).
Il y a vraiment une inégalité avec shuhua
3:09 SOOJIN UNNIE...!
It's actually sad that main vocalist Miyeon was first less times than sub vocalist Yuqi.
Yuqi is a lead vocalist
@@Kdistributionsshe got demoted
@@crazerrazer6778 oh yeah i notice now😭
@crazerrazer6778 I agree,but now she is a D- and miyeon is a D,so Yuqi kinda deserves those lines
@@BABYMONS7ER_AHYEON yes and the deep voice fit a lot the songs
Now the positions be like:
Minnie: Main Vocalist
Soyeon: Main Rapper, Leader
Miyeon: *Sub Vocalist*
Yuqi: *Main Vocalist*
Shuhua: *Lead Vocalist*
In what world is Shuhua treated as Lead Vocal 💀
@@lachainedestrucsnulle1211😂
Maybe Sub-Vocal & Lead Rapper
In last dance soojin stand still not turn to gre after tomboy she became grey bacause in last dance theres soojin but she dosent have a line😊
Can you make distribution of Japanese songs of gidle?
Anyone else who thinks whats in your house sounds like 2nd gen
can u do this series for tws
YESSS MINNIE FIRST
Miyeon deserves sm better
What?shuhua needs to more lines
Where's Abracadabra?
all mem 1000s+,shuhua sing very litte and minnie 2000s+ ?
Shuhua sings so much for her singing ability. I would prefer her to sing even less lines
@@marvel3734i love shuhua but have to admit that this is true 😭 i always worry for shu everytime they have to sing live
@@marvel3734 morrendo kkkkkkk
i would not except minnie to have more than soyeon
Minnie is main vocalist while Soyeon is a sub-vocalist 😂
@@lushiesminnie is lead vocal and miyeon is main vocal
Stay mad
Im waiting yuqi to be third maybe second and I don’t think so, but maybe first
Lol, Minnie would still first in overall line distribution tho, Yuqi was still least in overall line distribution dude
Yeah but recently yuqi is getting a lot of lines
Never would happen
@@redenoseo6375 Yuqi deserves more lines
Poor Miyeon.Debut since 2018,she only got 1st place 7 time.She is the best vocalist in Gilde and Soyeon didn't use Miyeon voice properly.Soyeon overusing Minnie voice almost in every song.Miyeon didn't get 1st place in Title Song is a crime.She trained many years for this treatment???She deserve many 1st place in Title Song.❤
Wasn't she first in Dumdi Dumdi? And her difference to Soyeon in latata is barely 2 secs. (Not using it as an opposite to a you said, cause I agree, just technical details I wanted to add 😅)
miyeon shines in lot of TTs compared to minnie, minnie can ever rap better than miyeon and her voice is more versatile its obvious she gets more lines. there is no “overusing” here lol half of the bsides are composed by minnie herself.
@@Juliana-tf7zh
Soyeon is first in Dumdi Dumdi.
See RandomK line distribution.
Miyeon was second in Dumdi Dumdi.Soyeon pass Miyeon with last line.
@youngeunie6064 ah, thats right! But sane case as latata...
How does that matter kiddo ? cry . Solo stans like you are the absolute worst @@youngeunie6064
what does ot5 mean? i need to know.
5 member grp. So, G-idle originally had 6 members (OT6) and now its OT5 cause of the scandal
app?
Flourish
Can you please keep quiet
Where is Queencard?
Vocal•
1•Miyeon
2•Yuqi
3•Minnie
4•Soojin
5•Soyeon
6•Shuhua
Rap•
1•Soyeon
2•Yuqi
3•Shuhua
4•Minnie
5•Soojin
6•Miyeon
Dance•
1•Yuqi
2•Soyeon
3•Shuhua
4•Soojin
5•Minnie
6•Miyeon
Visual•
1•Shuhua
2•Soojin
3•Miyeon
4•Yuqi
5•Soyeon
6•Minnie
Popularity•
1•Yuqi
2•Minnie
3•Soyeon
4•Soojin
5•Miyeon
6•Shuhua
Lines•
1•Minnie
2•Soyeon
3•Miyeon
4•Soojin
5•Yuqi
6•Shuhua
The way this is sooo wrong.
Vocal
1.Miyeon
2.Yuqi
3.SOOJIN
4.Minnie/Soyeon
5.Shuhia
Rap
1.Soyeon
2.Yuqi
3.Minnie/Miyeon
4.Shuhua
5.Soojin(she has never rapped)
Dance
1.Soojin
2.Yuqi
3.Soyeon
4.Shuhua
5.Minnie
6.Miyeon
SP.
1.Soyeon
2.Soojin
3.Minnie
4.Yuqi
5.Miyeon
6.Shuhua
Visual
1.Miyeon
2.Yuqi
3.Shuhua
4.Soojin
5.Minnie
6.Soyeon
Sw.
1.Soyeon
2.Yuqi
3.Minnie
4.Miyeon
5.Soojin
6.Shuhua
Minnie is better than miyeon
Um soon in was main dancer
Shuhua hasany lines for her position.
Only sub, no lead or main role or center. Although the basic thing is that she can't sing at all
I bet she sings better than you-
@@tiggertheanimal I am also a lot better singer and it's not my job.
She is a joke
@@tiggertheanimal how did he manage to have more likes in his comment then you
@Isaac-c4l Cause people are either too lazy to look at replies, or people are toxic, or both-
bully shuhua?
Le sserafim is not sakura its eunchea
One of the most unfair line distributions in the industry.
?
❓
Don’t forget everglow
@@juiceyrain5176 Ah yes
You clearly don't know much kpop... Specially 2nd generation!
Aaah, and there's someone here at the comments that actually did the percentage distribution and is actually fair! Not to mention first place is,the main vocalis, so twice fair!
Para que cube hizo debutar a Shu??? Se nota que no está a la altura de las demás, y ella debut bastante jove.