PGurus is dedicated to bringing you content that is unique, worthy of your time and helps shape the thought process of Young India, *VasilThrisKeias* - that is our commitment to you. Please 𝗦𝗵𝗮𝗿𝗲/ 𝗟𝗶𝗸𝗲 and 𝗦𝘂𝗯𝘀𝗰𝗿𝗶𝗯𝗲 to our channel and click on the 𝗕𝗲𝗹𝗹 (🔔) button.
I am Dalit and has been taught a different version of history but what what yours channel is showing with evidence, I am totally amazed. Major General Saheb is final onslought on me. Shree Iyer even though you are Brahim , I will remain indebted toward you till my last breath.
Hey buddy let's not delve into this narrative , not seven decades after the Brits left us !!! There's no debt to be taken care of !!! Jai Bharat , Jai Sanatan !!!
Kumar Ankit Ji : there is no caste / creed called Dalit. That is a tag to make you think you are not the same as any other Indian. Find your roots and be proud of who you and your forefathers were. Best Regards.
my dad comes from lahore pak and his family had to move to India leaving their lands and life in the mountains. I have wondered often what his ancestors were and what they did - living in these rough terrains.....i lost dad to covid and thought i had lost the one connect i had to his world and history. so happy to see this...this has reignited hope to understand the world of my father and ancestors...can we please please please have a book and a series to expand on this. i am from the publishing world and will be absolutely delighted to help such a project...
What an insight into civilisation and trade routes and cultures. This was actually the akhand bharat. Thanks to gen Rajiv for this intellect sharing with maps. India's heritage is what is going to make it strongest.
My god! , It was great to hear MG Rajiv !!! . It is like going on a tour on geo politics. Too good. On true sense this is the best video I had ever heard.
I have heard Sri Rajivji on DEf talks with Aadi...I have subscribed to that channel... it is a really good intellectual platform that I strongly recommand
Very informative. I feel India should up the antenna in Heritage diplomacy follow it scrupulously with on ground implementation. May pay rich dividends.
Sri ji. Request to bring more and more such our Indian experts to educate us to have clear cut ideas about the countries surrounding us. Even a politician who wants represent a Parliament constituency should have knowledge so that he / she can discuss in depth about our foreign policy ( means how to protect our national interest and expand our relations with business establishments) . Our Parliament members should not be like Telugu parliament members, they know only robbing public money through their membership)
India needs to be in Central Asia. But should come as a unique force with an unique perspective, not with the overlordship/burden of some other forces.
All the STANS namely Uzbek, Tajik,, Kazakh etc were part of Ancient Cultural Bharat. Maa Kaikeyi Bharstas mother was from the Caucasus region, the region of the present day Stans. Maa Gandhari was from Kandhahar in Afghanistan. STHANA is the Sanskrit term for Pradesh or place. Even in much earlier days beyond 2500 ago Asafoetida or Hing came to other regions in Bharat from these regions and it does still come from there. Saffron comes from Kashmir. Many other condiments like pepper, cardamom etc come from Kerala. Rice used to be cultivated extensively in the present day South India region, Bengal, Bihar and Eastern UP. and wheat in the Northern part of the country. So there was a huge connectivity across these regions even extending into Tibet and China. There were well developed sea routes to various countries of the Indian Ocean Region. The very fact that the Indian Ocean was called as Sindhu Maha Samudram amply illustrates the importance of the Sindhu Culture across thd present day Indian Ocean.
Thanks for this podcast We knew very less about Central Asia.. Gen Rajiv enlightened us. The ancient kingdoms maps and his explanations were fantastic. Can you please share the individual maps / slides as we could not read them during the conversation.?
Excellent coversation, revealing amazing intricacies. See Iyerji, could kindly share ur contact details for furthering the efforts you are undertaking with aplomb.
The last republic day meeting of all the 5 central Asia heads of states at Delhi was cancelled due to covid I think. In SCO, we can not discuss with all of them freely since China will be there. Its high time for India to have deeper understanding with all five of them both economically and militarily
There is a variant of Jyotisha (Indian Astrology) called Tajaka or Tajika with rules similar to Persian astrology that is still used today. Most of the Tajaka texts that we know about today were written by Neelakantha who is believed to have been from around present day Tajikistan. Also the name "Uyghur" which represents the inhabitants of what is today called XinJiang is a corruption of the Sanskrit "Uttara Kuru" which has been mentioned numerous times in the Dasha Rajana and even in Mahabharata.
Major Gen says gas pipeline not = oil pipeline. Elmer says gas pipeline = oil pipeline , only pressure matters and that he has worked in the industry. Sree Iyer, please enlighten us as to what is the truth or missing nuance here.
36:18 Some of the oil rich areas in Iran are sunni and there was an insurgency there the year after Khomeini returned. This culminated in Iranian Arab separatists taking over the Iranian embassy a year later in London and making demands of independence which a few days after had to be stormed by the SAS.
India should have greater relations with Central Asia. But should approach as a unique force with an unique perspective, not with the overlordship/burden of some other forces
I would say the presence of continious Russia's influence in Central Asia and its hegemony is a boon for India in the long run... it presently is the circle of influence for the Russians.... India should only try to compete China.... I believe in the long run a minor war will engulf which will create ripples in the entire Central Asian region... Right now Central Asia wants to unite and create a big country.... which is detrimental to Russia, China and to some extent India as well...
Its should be called "Uruk" veda! Did this col. Todd figure his own native residing geography's druids, Arthur and three enchantments? For all the time he spent in India, could have wisely been used by him to decipher out Ang/Ra/Az ancient identity!
I agree with Shree iyer in his question on Iran about Zoroastrianism. I did not like Major's response to this. Even though Islamic cleric ruling, Iran is no longer a Muslim majority. We all know it will not happen in a hurry and that was not the question. This simple question was not answered well/correctly by Major.
You are such a knowledgeable person, how can you talk of common heritage from an Islamic country whose people are taught to convert the whole earth into Allah land. Are you genuflecting like Gandhi at our tormentors? No more idiotic sermons of Aman ki Asha that have caused more harm than good.
Allah and Christ are not Sanatani..they are Saitani...here Rajivjis mundi is Khaali.... I respect Rajivji as a great expert in defence, geopolitical and geoeconomic affairs but his understanding on Sanatan is as naive and deracinated as any average Bharatiya... Sanatan is ETERNAL...jo beech me aata hai wah beech me hi chalajaata hai Jisko aadi madhya aur anth nahi hai wah sanatan hai... Siva,Vishnu,Sakti,Ganesh, Surya and Skanda and their infinite local forms and names are sanatan vedic Paratmans saguna forms...the entire panthion of vedic gods and darshanas are equally applicable to these six sampradayas only... Buddhism,Jainism and Sikism are Romantic/deranged forms of Sanatan.called paakhand Allah aur Christ Saitani hai...Duniya ko is ka koi jaroorat nahi.. inko.Mlecha kaha jaata hai First we must be clear in not including Adharmic elements in to Sanatana dharma there were and still are some extreme negative vaamachar elements in Sanatan dharma ...but tey are not as demonic as Saitani desert Evilizations
Yeh ekum bahuda..... slok Sanatan Dharm ke different Panthh ke liye aya tha na ki Deen ya relegion ke liye. Ek baar Ex-muslim Sameer, Sachwala ya Ex-muslim Sahil ko sun lo sara pata chal jayega....
We want more of Maj Gen Rajiv Narayanan.
PGurus is dedicated to bringing you content that is unique, worthy of your time and helps shape the thought process of Young India, *VasilThrisKeias* - that is our commitment to you. Please 𝗦𝗵𝗮𝗿𝗲/ 𝗟𝗶𝗸𝗲 and 𝗦𝘂𝗯𝘀𝗰𝗿𝗶𝗯𝗲 to our channel and click on the 𝗕𝗲𝗹𝗹 (🔔) button.
Mind boggling depth of knowledge & clarity of Vision !!! Thank you Gen Narayanan & Shree ji !!! Jai Ho !!!
Our pleasure! Thank you for your kind words, *viveksheel chhibber* - do *share/ subscribe/ like* and click on the *bell icon* for notifications.
Yes, truly.
I am Dalit and has been taught a different version of history but what what yours channel is showing with evidence, I am totally amazed. Major General Saheb is final onslought on me. Shree Iyer even though you are Brahim , I will remain indebted toward you till my last breath.
Ankit also follow Prof RV interviews. He asks simple question, if dalits were oppressed why wasn't there a single caste war in so many thousand years?
Hey buddy let's not delve into this narrative , not seven decades after the Brits left us !!! There's no debt to be taken care of !!! Jai Bharat , Jai Sanatan !!!
Kumar, we are all one and the same. We are Human beings first, with mutual respect towards one another.
Ankit you see Major seheb talks in DEF TALKS as well. The maps and his narration will blow your mind and make you wonder how US can analyse like this
Kumar Ankit Ji : there is no caste / creed called Dalit. That is a tag to make you think you are not the same as any other Indian. Find your roots and be proud of who you and your forefathers were. Best Regards.
I learn something new everyday through your channel Sir
Major General Rajiv Narayan video is always a treat to watch full of facts and data and strategies. I used to watch him regularly in DefTalks. 🙏🙏🙏
my dad comes from lahore pak and his family had to move to India leaving their lands and life in the mountains. I have wondered often what his ancestors were and what they did - living in these rough terrains.....i lost dad to covid and thought i had lost the one connect i had to his world and history. so happy to see this...this has reignited hope to understand the world of my father and ancestors...can we please please please have a book and a series to expand on this. i am from the publishing world and will be absolutely delighted to help such a project...
What an insight into civilisation and trade routes and cultures. This was actually the akhand bharat. Thanks to gen Rajiv for this intellect sharing with maps. India's heritage is what is going to make it strongest.
Thank you, Gen.Saab & Mr. Iyer ! 🙏🏻🙂
thanks Sree ji for this wonderful interview with rajiv sir. what an eye opening to our past history. pranams to both of you
Thanks Sree Iyer ji and Rajiv Narayanan ji for this simply beautiful video. One has to go through this video atleast twice. SALUTE and thanks.
Brilliant Brilliant Brilliant information, analysis and education provided to us by Gen Sahab 😊👌🏽👌🏽🙏🏽🇮🇳🚩
Gen. Rajiv vires are eye opener always, salute Sir.always like conversations.
Great show...well informed guest and the anchor
Thank you very much gen rajive
My god! , It was great to hear MG Rajiv !!! . It is like going on a tour on geo politics. Too good. On true sense this is the best video I had ever heard.
Very insightful educative narration by Gen Rajiv Narayanan.
I have heard Sri Rajivji on DEf talks with Aadi...I have subscribed to that channel...
it is a really good intellectual platform that I strongly recommand
Major Gen Rajiv Narayanan speaks with his conviction & very peacefully than any presenter till now (exclude Prof. R. V - who speaks from Heaven !!
You can see Major seheb talks in DEF TALKS as well. The maps and his narration will blow your mind and make you wonder how US can analyse like this
It’s Major General Rajiv Narayanan. You might’ve made an inadvertent error. Kindly rectify. Cheers!
Oh come on, everyone has their flair! 😂Can't compare Bheema with Arjuna.
@@sathyat6760qqqqqqqq😢🎉😅aqAqqqqqqq❤😊
Iiiii
Getting persons who can distill their experience and information is incredible. Loved it, Sree Iyer Sir.
❤❤❤ Sree Ji
It's a wealth of Geopolitical knowledge derived from the wealth of Sri Rajiv Narayan. I express deep appreciation & gratitude...
Excellent . East coast USA’s . 6.30 pm , Thursday .
Bravo...I am from Boston and I didn't know about the Albert Einstein Institute..I just checked it.. it's true!
Always a pleasure to listen to Major Gen Rajeev Sir. ❤❤
After 2024 elections, Maj Gen. Rajiv sir should be given very important positions in defence or foreign ministries.
Absolutely cracking discussion with Maj Gen (R) Rajiv Narayanan!
Great . live it up Sir . Thank you sir and our respectful Namaskar to General Rajiv Sir .
Hatts off. He is gem 💎 wanna see many more of him. Fan boy ❤
you see Major seheb talks in DEF TALKS as well. The maps and his narration will blow your mind and make you wonder how US can analyse like this
We know nothing about our potential to grow along with Central Asia. Truly fascinating.👏👏
Excellent,
Gen Narayanan 🙏🙏
A wonderful talk and appreciate the good General to share some references to further my knowledge.
Massive research and excellent views.
Unbelievable information for. Common man.tks
Brilliant discussion. This podcast is top notch.
I always wanted to learn about Central Asia. This seems to be a good starter.
There is a new book on Central Asia , » The Great Game « how Russians also wanted to invade India .. and British created Pakistan as a buffer state ..
Fantastic fantastic ❤🎉
Wonderful knowledge. Thanks for enlightenment. Rajiv sir, please give us your insights and share your history knowledge as often as possible.
Thank you. Please spread the good word about this channel, *@rakeshn5070* . Also, tell your family and friends to *Subscribe* and *Like* this channel.
Maj Gen Rajiv's grasp on history is fantastic and this education should be included in our NCERT history textbooks.
Awesome information. Thank you
Truly fantastic conversation. Let us have more of it soon. Great listening.
🙏🙏🙏👏👏👏👍👍👍🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
great conversation...we gained a lpt of information, Thank you!
Thanks
Yes people to people approach is good and healthy and can surely change even a hard core Islamist .
Very informative. I feel India should up the antenna in Heritage diplomacy follow it scrupulously with on ground implementation. May pay rich dividends.
Sri ji.
Request to bring more and more such our Indian experts to educate us to have clear cut ideas about the countries surrounding
us. Even a politician who wants represent a Parliament constituency should have knowledge so that he / she can discuss in depth about our foreign policy ( means how to protect our national interest and expand our relations with business establishments) . Our Parliament members should not be like Telugu parliament members, they know only robbing public money through their membership)
Thanks for doing this program. Highly informative.
India needs to be in Central Asia. But should come as a unique force with an unique perspective, not with the overlordship/burden of some other forces.
All the STANS namely Uzbek, Tajik,, Kazakh etc were part of Ancient Cultural Bharat. Maa Kaikeyi Bharstas mother was from the Caucasus region, the region of the present day Stans. Maa Gandhari was from Kandhahar in Afghanistan.
STHANA is the Sanskrit term for Pradesh or place.
Even in much earlier days beyond 2500 ago Asafoetida or Hing came to other regions in Bharat from these regions and it does still come from there. Saffron comes from Kashmir. Many other condiments like pepper, cardamom etc come from Kerala. Rice used to be cultivated extensively in the present day South India region, Bengal, Bihar and Eastern UP. and wheat in the Northern part of the country.
So there was a huge connectivity across these regions even extending into Tibet and China.
There were well developed sea routes to various countries of the Indian Ocean Region.
The very fact that the Indian Ocean was called as Sindhu Maha Samudram amply illustrates the importance of the Sindhu Culture across thd present day Indian Ocean.
Great Debate 👍
Super.enjoyed it. Thanks🙏
Super super super
Thank you so much
Thanks for this podcast
We knew very less about Central Asia.. Gen Rajiv enlightened us.
The ancient kingdoms maps and his explanations were fantastic.
Can you please share the individual maps / slides as we could not read them during the conversation.?
Info and knowledgeable
Excellent coversation, revealing amazing intricacies. See Iyerji, could kindly share ur contact details for furthering the efforts you are undertaking with aplomb.
very interesting details,
The last republic day meeting of all the 5 central Asia heads of states at Delhi was cancelled due to covid I think.
In SCO, we can not discuss with all of them freely since China will be there.
Its high time for India to have deeper understanding with all five of them both economically and militarily
Awesome Info!
There is a variant of Jyotisha (Indian Astrology) called Tajaka or Tajika with rules similar to Persian astrology that is still used today. Most of the Tajaka texts that we know about today were written by Neelakantha who is believed to have been from around present day Tajikistan. Also the name "Uyghur" which represents the inhabitants of what is today called XinJiang is a corruption of the Sanskrit "Uttara Kuru" which has been mentioned numerous times in the Dasha Rajana and even in Mahabharata.
Source please. Would love to read more. Thanks
interesting
👌👌👍👍
Major Gen says gas pipeline not = oil pipeline. Elmer says gas pipeline = oil pipeline , only pressure matters and that he has worked in the industry. Sree Iyer,
please enlighten us as to what is the truth or missing nuance here.
36:18 Some of the oil rich areas in Iran are sunni and there was an insurgency there the year after Khomeini returned. This culminated in Iranian Arab separatists taking over the Iranian embassy a year later in London and making demands of independence which a few days after had to be stormed by the SAS.
India should have greater relations with Central Asia. But should approach as a unique force with an unique perspective, not with the overlordship/burden of some other forces
🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟
👌👌👌🙏🏼🙏🏼💐‼️🇮🇳
I think we be ready for akhand bharat atleast in textbooks by 2027
I would say the presence of continious Russia's influence in Central Asia and its hegemony is a boon for India in the long run... it presently is the circle of influence for the Russians.... India should only try to compete China.... I believe in the long run a minor war will engulf which will create ripples in the entire Central Asian region... Right now Central Asia wants to unite and create a big country.... which is detrimental to Russia, China and to some extent India as well...
WHAT A KHICHARI : TEN KINGS WAR TO CHINA/ PAKISTAN ; FERGHANA TO CHAHBAHAR, EVERYTHING COOKED TOGETHER.
HAZARASP CITY ( KARAKALPAKIA). KA ASPIAN (CASPIAN SEA).🎉
Its should be called "Uruk" veda!
Did this col. Todd figure his own native residing geography's druids, Arthur and three enchantments?
For all the time he spent in India, could have wisely been used by him to decipher out Ang/Ra/Az ancient identity!
Would that be Partha and Madhya? Where was Bactria?
I agree with Shree iyer in his question on Iran about Zoroastrianism. I did not like Major's response to this. Even though Islamic cleric ruling, Iran is no longer a Muslim majority. We all know it will not happen in a hurry and that was not the question. This simple question was not answered well/correctly by Major.
Interesting, we can go to war torn Afghanistan, talk to the people bottom up and do what they need. But we can’t do that in our own country.
the India Chineese map behind Gen Rajiv is wrong, please ask him to remove it...
Map of India is wrong Gen Rajiv. Hope you will throw that away!!
TERMEZ TO HAIRATAN PO LIYA, SWAMI.
You are such a knowledgeable person, how can you talk of common heritage from an Islamic country whose people are taught to convert the whole earth into Allah land. Are you genuflecting like Gandhi at our tormentors? No more idiotic sermons of Aman ki Asha that have caused more harm than good.
P Iyer is talking like a kid. The religious conversion gang are ruthless. Soft talk like we are sanatanis, why they're into conversions will not help.
Allah and Christ are not Sanatani..they are Saitani...here Rajivjis mundi is Khaali....
I respect Rajivji as a great expert in defence, geopolitical and geoeconomic affairs but his understanding on Sanatan is as naive and deracinated as any average Bharatiya...
Sanatan is ETERNAL...jo beech me aata hai wah beech me hi chalajaata hai
Jisko aadi madhya aur anth nahi hai wah sanatan hai...
Siva,Vishnu,Sakti,Ganesh, Surya and Skanda and their infinite local forms and names are sanatan vedic Paratmans saguna forms...the entire panthion of vedic gods and darshanas are equally applicable to these six sampradayas only...
Buddhism,Jainism and Sikism are Romantic/deranged forms of Sanatan.called paakhand
Allah aur Christ Saitani hai...Duniya ko is ka koi jaroorat nahi.. inko.Mlecha kaha jaata hai
First we must be clear in not including Adharmic elements in to Sanatana dharma
there were and still are some extreme negative vaamachar elements in Sanatan dharma ...but tey are not as demonic as Saitani desert Evilizations
Yeh ekum bahuda..... slok Sanatan Dharm ke different Panthh ke liye aya tha na ki Deen ya relegion ke liye. Ek baar Ex-muslim Sameer, Sachwala ya Ex-muslim Sahil ko sun lo sara pata chal jayega....