Genial..... No entiendo de tecnicismo, solo sé que la voz humana es el instrumento mas precioso que existe, a mi humilde entender. La señora Garanca canta muy bien en nuestra lengua y se ex`presa con una corrección y estilo... magnifico.. Gracias Doña Elina
Estoy verdaderamente asombrado, de la sabia discusión de los expertos en el bel canto, que si la mezzo no canta bien, o si el barítono tampoco, pues que baje dios y lo vea, ella está dentro de las tres mejores del momento y nada digamos del barítono, el mejor de los últimos tiempos, señores, déjense de jugar a entendidos y dedíquense a admirar a los intérpretes.
Mister Opera, singing is not about volume or the "size" of the voice! It is about the integrity of the music and the sincerity with which it is portrayed. Voices differ, how boring it would have been if all singers sounded the same. Elina Garanca has a beautiful lyric mezzo voice and she sings with absolute musical accuracy, clarity of diction and deep feeling, without having to distort sound for effect, as so many so called "great" singers do.
are you in all your senses Ida? No one is speaking of size as such. No one is speaking of voices having to sound the same. She is flat... and she does not have Bel Canto anywhere near in her swallowed placement. she is a light lyric at best and shouldn't be trying anything anything beyond rosina. now... i do have to ask what your nationality is since you mention... of all things!!!!! ''''clarity of diction'''!!! are you ok???? taking your meds?
@@williamadolphe7921 perhaps you should do some soul searching, your criticism borders on abuse and does not warrant a decent reply. The critique of art or anything else, for that matter, should always refrain from emotive and abusive language. Speaking of which, ms Garanca speaks several languages fluently, which indicates an innate affinity for languages. Employ some basic respect for others. It would serve you well.
are you kidding me? you never heard real Italian singers in your life time! this is a voice that cannot surpass, maybe Rosina... at the heaviest... and she tires Leonora? let us not speak of the patches she shows all over her voice!
she is flat in 'naaa-aaaando' and 'possedeeee-eerti' and i am not even beyond the first phrase. Barbieri, Stignani, Berini, Cossotto, would have never, ever have done that.
Opinion of the voices is fair game. Criticism of another person's attempts to communicate in a foreign language however might be construed as bad manners.
Genial..... No entiendo de tecnicismo, solo sé que la voz humana es el instrumento mas precioso que existe, a mi humilde entender. La señora Garanca canta muy bien en nuestra lengua y se ex`presa con una corrección y estilo... magnifico.. Gracias Doña Elina
Estoy verdaderamente asombrado, de la sabia discusión de los expertos en el bel canto, que si la mezzo no canta bien, o si el barítono tampoco, pues que baje dios y lo vea, ella está dentro de las tres mejores del momento y nada digamos del barítono, el mejor de los últimos tiempos, señores, déjense de jugar a entendidos y dedíquense a admirar a los intérpretes.
Muy bien dicho. Y además las comparaciones fastidiosas.
corpo, equilibrio,uniformita',un colore brunito che mi tocca l'anima. Che voce meravigliosa !NessunA NOTA BRUTTA!
Elina! You are the best of the best!
Beautifully performed selections abound in this concert.
A kegyencnő...micsoda dráma! Beleborzong a történetbe az ember... Csodálatos előadás!
SIMPLY... PERFECT. BRAAAAVAAAA!!!
Maria Alexandra Paez-Pumar Perfect 😍
She has a lovely voice!🥰👌
Pensaba que ya nadie se atrevía a dar esta ópera en italiano. ¡Bravo!
There are a few times when being monolingual is wonderful. So far they're not charging me for translations. That's most fortunate.
Mister Opera, singing is not about volume or the "size" of the voice! It is about the integrity of the music and the sincerity with which it is portrayed. Voices differ, how boring it would have been if all singers sounded the same. Elina Garanca has a beautiful lyric mezzo voice and she sings with absolute musical accuracy, clarity of diction and deep feeling, without having to distort sound for effect, as so many so called "great" singers do.
clarity of diction? where?
Maybe some people are tonedeaf😉😁
are you in all your senses Ida? No one is speaking of size as such. No one is speaking of voices having to sound the same. She is flat... and she does not have Bel Canto anywhere near in her swallowed placement. she is a light lyric at best and shouldn't be trying anything anything beyond rosina. now... i do have to ask what your nationality is since you mention... of all things!!!!! ''''clarity of diction'''!!! are you ok???? taking your meds?
@@brigittabrundlmayer9747 yup! this sounds awful... but ida thinks that swallowed non descript diction is clarity of italian diction!!!!
@@williamadolphe7921 perhaps you should do some soul searching, your criticism borders on abuse and does not warrant a decent reply. The critique of art or anything else, for that matter, should always refrain from emotive and abusive language. Speaking of which, ms Garanca speaks several languages fluently, which indicates an innate affinity for languages. Employ some basic respect for others. It would serve you well.
Лео Нуччи принимал участие в концерте в честь Образцовой в Большом театре. Биссировал только он!!! Браво, браво, браво!!!
Perfeita! Bravo
o mon Fernand, tous les biens de la terre! maravillosa mezzo soprano - quisiera oirla en francés.
th-cam.com/video/jEQUXg7RAUM/w-d-xo.html
Magnificent! All this negative dissecting of her voice going on here must be a poor consolation for those without any talent.
are you kidding me? you never heard real Italian singers in your life time! this is a voice that cannot surpass, maybe Rosina... at the heaviest... and she tires Leonora? let us not speak of the patches she shows all over her voice!
@@williamadolphe7921
*You* are kidding you.
Katherine Prongos
Exactly so!
Talentless geeks love playing "critics"; it's the only pleasure they'll derive from the Arts.
@@davegreene8588 nope. listen carefully.
@@davegreene8588 LOL. as talentless geeks try to sing the praises of talentless singers.
Поёт так, как будто ему это ничего не стоит!
Grandes lecciones de canto todas ellas
Элина Гаранча Кабалетта Леоноры Гаэтано Доницетти!
MEGA START
Это вершина совершенства !
Абсолютно верно!
Это я говорил об Элине Гаранча
1:50 自分用
she is flat in 'naaa-aaaando' and 'possedeeee-eerti' and i am not even beyond the first phrase. Barbieri, Stignani, Berini, Cossotto, would have never, ever have done that.
She cuts the aria..why? Not like she was even trying....yawn
No high C what a shame
Elvira Ceresoli and Marian Anderson did a better job with this emotively and technically.
MINI-fake mezzo!
ЗАТКНИСЬ, ГНИДА !
What you mean?
You mean: "What DO you mean?"? She is no dramatic mezzo, as she is not a true mezzo.
I mean precisely what I wrote: MINI-face mezzo. If you know anything about voices, you will understand.
Opinion of the voices is fair game. Criticism of another person's attempts to communicate in a foreign language however might be construed as bad manners.