Just so you all know, this was a one time deal. I will never be taking requests from you again. If you want me to do that pledge to my patreon, it's one of the cheapest perks.
Honestly, the video part where you talk about the one person spamming you combined with this comment (especially the first part), makes it sound like you're reprimanding all of your viewers for what one person did. It doesn't come off very nicely at all. I was actually taken aback a little reading it after what I've gotten to know of you so far on your channel. It comes off pretty aggressively within the first two sentences. I understand promoting Patreon, that's totally fine as Patreons deserve perks for their support. However, basically toning it the way you did then adding that at the end just comes off extremely harsh and then a bit... "paywall-ish". Not everyone has money to afford even small things like this, especially during this time. I don't blame you for being resentful and annoyed with the person spamming you channel, that's flat-out bullshit and they would honestly be forcibly removed if it were my channel. However, I think occasionally taking requests for special events or reaching certain goals or even as the extremely infrequent surprise to keep in touch with your fans would be a great compromise. If that's not something you'd want to do, that's totally fine too. I just felt, trying as hard I could to read "I will never be taking requests from you again" after addressing everybody, it was just difficult to read with any kind of neutral tone. That's how I feel anyway, as someone fairly new to your channel.... I'm just trying to be honest, not confrontational. It's your channel so do whatever you feel is necessary. I do agree that people shouldn't spam that garbage and it annoys the living hell out of me seeing it everywhere else.
look siats bigger if 11 meters 90 million years and 66 million years like 17 meters, like moors 90 million 5 meters and 66 years millions 12.30 meters t rex same MOROS as the biggest archonotoaurus equal to 15 meters, bigger giganotosaurus 18 meters, spinosaurus also bigger 20 meters think how it is 66 million years there is if it has carchadonotosaurues 145 -66 million years it has a larger FAMILY carcha-gigas but not disappeared bone search working is bone dust more difficult
@@perhapsawhitemale8144 the t rex isn't fully evolved and it is small:other dinos:kalm Siats is gone:kalm SIATS IS GONE!!!?!: Panik Rex: welcome to my house y'all. You know the rules and so do I Trike and ank: constantly laughing
Since it was literally discovered only as a fragmentary specimen, it is impossible to clearly determine what lineage it belongs to, let alone what it looks like.
All of the evidence that I gathered from other scientists, and studies of the original specimen shows that this animal was a Neovenatorid! It also had these enormous arms and claws, based off the possibly related Chilantaisaurus.
Y’know, with its very recent presence in the Jurassic World toyline, something tells me we might actually see this dinosaur show up in Camp Cretaceous and by extension, Jurassic World Evolution or its supposed sequel.
If none of those, I had an idea to make it the main rival to Gorgosaurus in a story idea I had. Not particularly accurate, I know, but could be interesting as a "allosaurids surpressing tyrannosauroids."
I love how in depth and detailed your videos are. I always learn so much from them. Your channel is great for people like me who are big time paleo-nerds but don't have any formal education in that sort of thing, cus the info you share is advanced enough that I'm not usually familiar with it already, but its still simple and accessible enough that it doesn't go entirely over my head
I firmly believe that neovenatoridae is a separate few-off species group like the Allosaurids which shared features with both Allosaurids & carcharodontosaurids. Siats might actually be a carcharodontosaurine since shaochilong was discovered in Asia dating to 92 million years ago.
I actually like Siats Meekerorum more,since it's a Carnivore only discovered rather recently back in 2013,and was the first Allosaurs,that I even heard of.
Allosaurids were nothing to play with, their skull had a hyoid similar to wood peckers, so it was built to slam its head violently on its prey. Allosaurids also had a massive gape. On top of that, their claws were also built for killing, not just in assisting with mating. Back when we only had one continent, Allosaurids took over the world, after the continents broke apart and some mass extinctions we saw other theropods proliferate.
Ooh siats is an amazing dinosaur not many people don't know about. Really great you made a video on it. Next video could you do an archosaur like smok (might be a dinosaur though) or arizonasaurus.
I could imagine that Siats telling the Moros pair, "Hey! I'm the big guy around here, so don't even think you can snag my meal." No wonder it lived in the Mussentuchit area.
Actually there is a Tyrannosauroid premax tooth from the Cloverly Formation where Acrocanthosaurus is found there for hinting at the presence of them where Acrocanthosaurus lived
I hope they manage to find a more complete specimen, I'd really like to know what this thing might have really looked like and which side of the Carcharodontosauridne tree it belonged to, if it even was a Carcharodontosaur at all.
This is incredibly ironic I actually made a comment on the timeline of allosaurs and tyrannosaurs on the most recent 7 DOS vid like yesterday or two days ago and you answered the question having prepared for this vid at least a week before today. Thanks
Yes! I have been waiting for this one, quite the definition for underrated and underacknowledged theropod, isn't it ironic that tyrannosaurus had average qualities at least length wise compared to whole theropoda ? :) bahariasaurus next?
The Morrison has early small tyrannosauroids too. Stokesosaurus was a early tyrannosauroid. But the actual tyrannosaurs seem to have been imported from Asia.
Timimus is a really tough one, I'd personally say its not diagnistic as since its discovery it has bounced around therapoda like a pinball and every time we get a better understanding of contemporary ecological assemblages elsewhere in Gondwana it pops out and lands somewhere else. I'd personally be inclined to think tyrannosauroudea did not get established in Australia and its more likely a dromeasaur, or some member of ceratosauroidea. Or possibly another megaraptoran.
The cedar formation definitely needs more coverage because I'm interested in learning about the species that coexisted with Siats. I would really love to have more detail about the fauna that this particular theropod existed about and its own video course.
Wow I didn't not know about that Siats only have a few fossils? Wow I thought Siats was full complete. I just learned something new and I did not know that he belong to Allosaurus and Carcharodontosaurus I just learned something new from your videos Great video I like it. Keep making fascinating videos.
At around 2:17 E.D.G.E mentions a 2 part series about Acrocanthosaurus, however I can't see the card that's surpossed to pop up. Are the videos deleted, or if they're not can anyone link me them?
There was a mass extinction around 90 MYA. The rising sea levels wiped out huge spinosaurs and Allosauroids. Afterwards, the small tyrannosaurs must have ballooned up in North America and Asia to quickly fill the vacuum. This never happened in the southern hemisphere as abelisaurids and megaraptorans were next in line. They, however, never quite reached the ceiling theropod size. But then again, high sea levels means smaller landmasses resulting in smaller animals. Dromies IMO were never really contenders for apex predator spot. They had too many features that would have handicapped them as long as abelisaurids and megaraptorans were around. Just like how flightless predatory birds couldn't compete with mammals.
Looking at the African plains as a comparison, I think the predator balance is good. Too many large predators cannot be supported by the number of large herbivores. Look at the way predators feed on a fresh kill, gorging immensely and then resting. Large predators must have larger prey. They likely worked in small packs and had a hierarchy also. Really, there is nothing new under the Sun! Enjoyed the video.
We don’t really know what the arms of Neovenator were exactly like, because they weren’t preserved, and neither are those of Siats. But it’s believed they both had long arms and huge claws, based off of the thumb claw and humerus 🦴 of the related Chilantaisaurus from Asia.
Just imagine how many dinosaurs are still undiscovered or relatively unknown. Who knows, we could be completely wrong about the looks and living style.
@@realmikeholman That is a very interesting theory. I would love to see that theory develops in the future. It definitely could be a very big possibility.
@@CreatureChallenge It’s a big possibility for a few species, but a good way to check is by cutting open the fossils and examining the cells which can show the animals approximate age
Hmm, I do wonder, did ceratopsian evolution was an indirect part of the decadence in the Allosauroid Dinosaurs at some point in the Cretaceous? Considering they were very dangerous herbivores to hunt and Allosauroids were not adequate to hunt them, unlike the Tyrannosaurs
Do you think you will get to Ornimegalonyx or Tyto Gigantea at some point in the future? Just wondering because I can't seem to find any decent info on either species. I've asked other TH-camrs but no reply or even a sign of it were given.
hello! cool video. austroraptorcabazai here, thanks for featuring my work, but PLEASE ask me for permission before using my work in your videos in the future! big big thank you for crediting me however. i do believe we have spoken in the past before, but i would still prefer if you kept me up to date when my work is used. if you would like to get into contact with me, i can be contacted via. discord, twitter, or deviantart.thanks!
Well the apex predators in the late Cretaceous of Gondwana was likely never Tyrannosaurids instead it went from Allosauroids to Megaraptorans to Abelisauridae
Just so you all know, this was a one time deal. I will never be taking requests from you again. If you want me to do that pledge to my patreon, it's one of the cheapest perks.
Honestly, the video part where you talk about the one person spamming you combined with this comment (especially the first part), makes it sound like you're reprimanding all of your viewers for what one person did. It doesn't come off very nicely at all. I was actually taken aback a little reading it after what I've gotten to know of you so far on your channel. It comes off pretty aggressively within the first two sentences.
I understand promoting Patreon, that's totally fine as Patreons deserve perks for their support. However, basically toning it the way you did then adding that at the end just comes off extremely harsh and then a bit... "paywall-ish". Not everyone has money to afford even small things like this, especially during this time. I don't blame you for being resentful and annoyed with the person spamming you channel, that's flat-out bullshit and they would honestly be forcibly removed if it were my channel. However, I think occasionally taking requests for special events or reaching certain goals or even as the extremely infrequent surprise to keep in touch with your fans would be a great compromise. If that's not something you'd want to do, that's totally fine too. I just felt, trying as hard I could to read "I will never be taking requests from you again" after addressing everybody, it was just difficult to read with any kind of neutral tone.
That's how I feel anyway, as someone fairly new to your channel.... I'm just trying to be honest, not confrontational. It's your channel so do whatever you feel is necessary. I do agree that people shouldn't spam that garbage and it annoys the living hell out of me seeing it everywhere else.
Awwwww man I wanted to suggest a borophagus video
look siats bigger if 11 meters 90 million years and 66 million years like 17 meters, like moors 90 million 5 meters and 66 years millions 12.30 meters t rex same MOROS as the biggest archonotoaurus equal to 15 meters, bigger giganotosaurus 18 meters, spinosaurus also bigger 20 meters think how it is 66 million years there is if it has carchadonotosaurues 145 -66 million years it has a larger FAMILY carcha-gigas but not disappeared bone search working is bone dust more difficult
Saurophaganax maximus allosaurus larger as 12-13 meters 150 million years as equal larger 185-145 always until the end
Lame
Siats Guy will be carried down in the EDGE myths for eternity
Long live the Siats Guy, The man, The myth, The legend.
His calls heard for miles
Siats: Ruling over North America
Tyrannosaurs: NICE PLACE YOU GOT THERE
All other large Carnivores:
“(Chuckles) I’m in danger.”
*It's free real estate*
@@perhapsawhitemale8144 the t rex isn't fully evolved and it is small:other dinos:kalm
Siats is gone:kalm
SIATS IS GONE!!!?!: Panik
Rex: welcome to my house y'all. You know the rules and so do I
Trike and ank: constantly laughing
@@kingofallgodzillas9901 I kinda feel this is deserving of r/wooosh
@@perhapsawhitemale8144 r/woooosh for not understanding my joke
"Raptor punching bag Tenontosaurus." Yeah, I feel really sorry for that guy.
Today's equivalent would be impala
I cannot tell you how much I love the name 'Mussentuchit'. I can't even imagine how many jokes the people digging there must have made about it.
Don't get me started on the mineral that was found in cummington and got the glorious name of cummingtonite.
well,
the guy who request Siats is the "Do the Manda" guy of EDGE comment section
Do the roar*
@@Sea_Leech it's a reference to wikizilla comment section when ppl just spam "where's manda kaiju profile?" on every wikizilla vid
@@TangmoMopet oh
Nice usage of Walk like an Egyptian
That along with the cameo of Joseph Joestar
Yes my favorite dinosaur!! This dinosaur was found an hour away from my house so i’m kind of biased, but Siats is one interesting Cretaceous Allosaur!
Since it was literally discovered only as a fragmentary specimen, it is impossible to clearly determine what lineage it belongs to, let alone what it looks like.
Therefore, it is not valid to restore it with a pair of bony protrusions above its eyes like Allosaurus.
I love how you put jojo character's in the size comparisons it really cool
4:13 *OH MY GOOOOD*
Hoory SHIT!
YOUR NEXT LINE IS "Ohhhhh noo!"
FluffyYutyrannus that seems overreacting for me cos it’s not as big as T-Rex
Edit: but the title does say it lived before T-rex so fair enough
@@prehistoricfanboy101 It's a JoJo reference. EDGE often uses JoJo characters when showing a human for scale.
lifdohop oh I thought it’s from Harry Potter
All of the evidence that I gathered from other scientists, and studies of the original specimen shows that this animal was a Neovenatorid!
It also had these enormous arms and claws, based off the possibly related Chilantaisaurus.
Y’know, with its very recent presence in the Jurassic World toyline, something tells me we might actually see this dinosaur show up in Camp Cretaceous and by extension, Jurassic World Evolution or its supposed sequel.
The stars have truly aligned.
I hope so too. Siats is such a cool dinosaur
@@altithoraxperotorum5133 and underated
If none of those, I had an idea to make it the main rival to Gorgosaurus in a story idea I had. Not particularly accurate, I know, but could be interesting as a "allosaurids surpressing tyrannosauroids."
I have no idea why, but I just came to love Siats more and more as time goes on. Hope we find more remains about it soon.
I love the artwork you dig-up for your videos.
I love how in depth and detailed your videos are. I always learn so much from them. Your channel is great for people like me who are big time paleo-nerds but don't have any formal education in that sort of thing, cus the info you share is advanced enough that I'm not usually familiar with it already, but its still simple and accessible enough that it doesn't go entirely over my head
The Mustn’t Touch It Member 😂
Right? My inner eight-year-old has not stopped giggling.
4:31 Not gonna lie that one yellow figure looks like Joseph Joestar
He is
That is him
Thank you !! honestly I was waiting for this video for long, Siats Meekerorum was an amazing beast !!
It's my favorite because I love to imagine a pack Moros attack a adult Siats.
They wouldn't do that.
How come no one is cracking jokes about the "must'nt touch it" formation?!
Because : *C'ant touch this*
A lack of fossils doesn't mean the predators weren't there.
I firmly believe that neovenatoridae is a separate few-off species group like the Allosaurids which shared features with both Allosaurids & carcharodontosaurids. Siats might actually be a carcharodontosaurine since shaochilong was discovered in Asia dating to 92 million years ago.
North America : Siats vs Moros
Europe : Neovenator vs Eotyrannus
Asia : Ulughbegsaurus vs Timurlengia
Chinese : Sinraptor vs guanlong
AH i see you edge putting in Walking like an Egyptian as background music
i got you im sure I'm not the only one that caught that right
I actually like Siats Meekerorum more,since it's a Carnivore only discovered rather recently back in 2013,and was the first Allosaurs,that I even heard of.
Allosaurids were nothing to play with, their skull had a hyoid similar to wood peckers, so it was built to slam its head violently on its prey. Allosaurids also had a massive gape. On top of that, their claws were also built for killing, not just in assisting with mating.
Back when we only had one continent, Allosaurids took over the world, after the continents broke apart and some mass extinctions we saw other theropods proliferate.
Cursed woodpecker
This animal is underrated
I would love to see a video dedicated to Albertosaurus and its relation to Gorgosaurus
bardcore walk like an Egyptian was not expected but it was welcome
Thread of appreciation for Siats Guy (Jac).
The background music at the start is walk like an Egyptian
Ooh siats is an amazing dinosaur not many people don't know about. Really great you made a video on it. Next video could you do an archosaur like smok (might be a dinosaur though) or arizonasaurus.
...... Dinosaurs ARE archosaurs?
@@shosha101390 They are not sure if Smok is a dinosaur or not.
@@smokecity6889 understood, but regardless it’s still an archosaur, since all dinosaurs are archosaurs
@@shosha101390 i know
I could imagine that Siats telling the Moros pair, "Hey! I'm the big guy around here, so don't even think you can snag my meal." No wonder it lived in the Mussentuchit area.
Actually there is a Tyrannosauroid premax tooth from the Cloverly Formation where Acrocanthosaurus is found there for hinting at the presence of them where Acrocanthosaurus lived
PREACH!!
source?
To be honest, I never knew about Siats until I found one of the Jurassic World toys. Never knew I'll learn about one from a toy.
Do you realize that this sets a precedent for the people that are considering to pester you to make a video on their favourite subject?
Yea...it won’t work again tho
@@EDGEscience We'll see about that!! Can you do a video on Elasmosaur please? lol
Can you guys stop harassing him? Like fr
@@shriyanv4407 I'm sure they joking
@@shriyanv4407 why wouldn't he want video ideas and feedback from audience
I hope they manage to find a more complete specimen, I'd really like to know what this thing might have really looked like and which side of the Carcharodontosauridne tree it belonged to, if it even was a Carcharodontosaur at all.
I pictured it as a Neovenatorid Leigh Megaraptoran like hands, and claws.
This is incredibly ironic
I actually made a comment on the timeline of allosaurs and tyrannosaurs on the most recent 7 DOS vid like yesterday or two days ago and you answered the question having prepared for this vid at least a week before today.
Thanks
So if Siats never went extinct, then Tyrannosaurus would have never existed. Huh.....
Ah! That Acrocanthosaurus is from the Houston Museum of Natural Science! It’s my second favorite skeleton there after the mosasaur!
Siats is pretty interesting it might be related to Carcharodontosauraide
A few Siats teeth have been found.
Where?
I so dig the Recorder version of Walk like an Egyptian!
Yes! I have been waiting for this one, quite the definition for underrated and underacknowledged theropod, isn't it ironic that tyrannosaurus had average qualities at least length wise compared to whole theropoda ? :)
bahariasaurus next?
The DORUK can you block me please? I'm asking nicely. Please do it.
Can you make a video on Deltadromeus please
I know that it's fragmentary but a video on it would be cool
Yeah I'd also like to learn some more about Deltadromeus 😀
2:14 I love this acrocantosaurus image 🤣
The Morrison has early small tyrannosauroids too. Stokesosaurus was a early tyrannosauroid. But the actual tyrannosaurs seem to have been imported from Asia.
I like huge theropods with huge arms and claws! I like them better than those with tiny arms.
This channel is very energetic!
4:11 oh my goooood
Timimus is a really tough one, I'd personally say its not diagnistic as since its discovery it has bounced around therapoda like a pinball and every time we get a better understanding of contemporary ecological assemblages elsewhere in Gondwana it pops out and lands somewhere else.
I'd personally be inclined to think tyrannosauroudea did not get established in Australia and its more likely a dromeasaur, or some member of ceratosauroidea. Or possibly another megaraptoran.
I couldn’t stop singing walk like an Egyptian when watching this
The cedar formation definitely needs more coverage because I'm interested in learning about the species that coexisted with Siats. I would really love to have more detail about the fauna that this particular theropod existed about and its own video course.
*Cryolophosaurus and Concavenator I hope one day you will make Videos about both Carnivores. Also Great Video My Friend keep it up☺*
Wonder how he feels about the Siats Meekerorum toy from Mattel?
Wow I didn't not know about that Siats only have a few fossils? Wow I thought Siats was full complete. I just learned something new and I did not know that he belong to Allosaurus and Carcharodontosaurus I just learned something new from your videos Great video I like it. Keep making fascinating videos.
At around 2:17 E.D.G.E mentions a 2 part series about Acrocanthosaurus, however I can't see the card that's surpossed to pop up. Are the videos deleted, or if they're not can anyone link me them?
Siats: exist
Saurophaganax: Are you challenging me
3:05
Best name for a dig site ever
Siats is my older sister’s favourite dinosaur, but for the wrong reason…
4:11 OH MY GOD!!!!!!!JOTARO,ITS A NEW DINOSAUR STAND USER!!!!!
4:10 Is thay Joseph Joestar? With Purple Hermit on his arm?
That intro song was a banger.
There was a mass extinction around 90 MYA. The rising sea levels wiped out huge spinosaurs and Allosauroids. Afterwards, the small tyrannosaurs must have ballooned up in North America and Asia to quickly fill the vacuum. This never happened in the southern hemisphere as abelisaurids and megaraptorans were next in line. They, however, never quite reached the ceiling theropod size. But then again, high sea levels means smaller landmasses resulting in smaller animals.
Dromies IMO were never really contenders for apex predator spot. They had too many features that would have handicapped them as long as abelisaurids and megaraptorans were around. Just like how flightless predatory birds couldn't compete with mammals.
I heard that Neovenatorid arms are still pretty long. And they could still have a large thumb claw.
I only recently found out about Siats and it's already my 3rd favorite animal
Tyrannosaurus: Where is my enemy I want revenge on him
Kpg extinction: im is you enemy
Another small ornithopod was Oryctodromaeus.
Looking at the African plains as a comparison, I think the predator balance is good. Too many large predators cannot be supported by the number of large herbivores. Look at the way predators feed on a fresh kill, gorging immensely and then resting. Large predators must have larger prey. They likely worked in small packs and had a hierarchy also. Really, there is nothing new under the Sun! Enjoyed the video.
I kept hearing "musn't touch it."
We don’t really know what the arms of Neovenator were exactly like, because they weren’t preserved, and neither are those of Siats.
But it’s believed they both had long arms and huge claws, based off of the thumb claw and humerus 🦴 of the related Chilantaisaurus from Asia.
Just imagine how many dinosaurs are still undiscovered or relatively unknown. Who knows, we could be completely wrong about the looks and living style.
Jack Horner actually believes that 2/3 of every dinosaur is miss-classified and are actually juvenile versions of adult dinosaurs. i.e. dracorex
@@realmikeholman That is a very interesting theory. I would love to see that theory develops in the future. It definitely could be a very big possibility.
@@CreatureChallenge It’s a big possibility for a few species, but a good way to check is by cutting open the fossils and examining the cells which can show the animals approximate age
Is that walk like an Egyptian? Playing in the back ground.
I'm glad I'm not the only one who flocked to this video after seeing that comment repeatedly in other vids xD
Nice, I've not come across this dino before.
"Mustn't touch it!"
I heard a rendition of "Walk like an Eygptian" at the beginning. :)
I like the soundtrack version of Walk Like An Egyptian.
Hmm, I do wonder, did ceratopsian evolution was an indirect part of the decadence in the Allosauroid Dinosaurs at some point in the Cretaceous?
Considering they were very dangerous herbivores to hunt and Allosauroids were not adequate to hunt them, unlike the Tyrannosaurs
Is that first song after the intro “walk like an Egyptian”?
hey edge can you make a video on siats please i am begging you please for the love of all make a video on siats
Can u do an episode about nanotyrannus
Re: Timimus, it's classification is debated. I've seen it described as a Dromaeosaur, Tyrannosaur and an Ornithomimid.
Do you think you will get to Ornimegalonyx or Tyto Gigantea at some point in the future? Just wondering because I can't seem to find any decent info on either species. I've asked other TH-camrs but no reply or even a sign of it were given.
9:25 nice isle reference
Eotriceratops episode?
hello! cool video. austroraptorcabazai here, thanks for featuring my work, but PLEASE ask me for permission before using my work in your videos in the future! big big thank you for crediting me however. i do believe we have spoken in the past before, but i would still prefer if you kept me up to date when my work is used.
if you would like to get into contact with me, i can be contacted via. discord, twitter, or deviantart.thanks!
this channel rules
I'm disappointed and angry that I didn't already know this existed. Now do Quinkana fortirostrum
is that "walk like an egyptian" playing in the background??
Well the apex predators in the late Cretaceous of Gondwana was likely never Tyrannosaurids instead it went from Allosauroids to Megaraptorans to Abelisauridae
I met this creature and I Siats my pants.
Amazing videos love the channel
Oh Wow I’m in the video
He gave you a shoutout!
Do another video on Siats
WE WUZ COELUROSAURS N SIATS!
Joseph Joestar!
Thanks for the informative videos.
All the evidence I gathered points it being a Neovenatorid with enormous arms and claws.