Sir you are very powerful in ca coaching industry If you make representation on this practical difficulties to the council member it will have a huge impact
Will All Due Respect Sir, Lots of Respect and Thanks to You to Respected Sir. Commendable Glimpse of wisdom. You have showed your wisdom and cover approximately all the problems which is being faced by all types of old/new/group1 passed/ only group 2 appearing student, impossible to demonstrate and apply all 7 subject indepth knowledge in short span of exam times in IBS PAPER which ultimately very very very difficult to pass CA FINAL EXAM specially for Old CA FINAL Student who is pursuing more than 10 year and invested their entire youth. It will be very disheartening and sorrowful to leave ca course due to IBS. You are torch bearers and have a Soloution oriented approach. Its my humblest request to you that Sir please Do Something and derive such solution as soon as possible in terms of Coverage of Limited Content of Syllabus in such a manner which do not require additional time to prepare GROUP 1 Subjects for Old Pass Out Student during 2008 to 2020 or only preparing GROUP 2 exam, Level of IBS Exam, Structure of Question Paper etc in terms of no of case study etc
IBS is like jack of all master of all! Specialization in a particular subject is required for indepth knowledge. Making khichdi of every subject is not practical at all! This is very bad move by ICAI by combining everything in one paper.
Sir, my Inter group 2 results got hold because of writing good feedback to icai in last may 24. Later after a week got results via mail after writing to them again. So informing icai also looks have impact on us. Only luck factor with deep knowledge may work in paper 6.
Respected Sir As i knew from the inception of CA EXAM in India to till NOVEMEBER 2023 CA FINAL EXAM, No Such Subject and exam was conducted by INSTITUTE to pass CA FINAL Group 2 which require combined or integrated knowledge to pass the Last Paper of CA FINAL GROUP 2 EXAM Just like IBS at present. So why or beloved Institute is doing injustice at this point of time for their own Final Student which They Have not done in the history of CA FINAL EXAM in terms of GROUP 2 LAST PAPER. This Requirement of having expert level knowledge of All 7 Subjects of CA FINAL to pass IBS Exam is prima facie against the Institute's own Policy with regard to become a CA, i.e. In order to pass CA exam student is required to appear and pass Final Exam either in Any of Group or Both Group simultaneously. In this case Syllabus Content of IBS PAPER is NOT LIMITED TO THE EXTENT OF CA FINAL GROUP 2 REMAINING SUBJECTS but expanded and touched the Group 1, so how it can be said that this paper is a part of Group 2 only previously held exam of ca final group 2.
I feel the institute of chartered accountants of India introduced this paper for a reason and it is really helpful in building the nation and making good CA.
Sir, jo log 1st group pass ho chuke hai, 2-3 saal pehle, unke liye ye sir dard bana hua hai, at least ek syllabus bta te ki ye syllabus hai, isko padna hai, without syllabus 1st group ko samajhne me hi 6m lag jayega, jo ki sambhav nhi hai
Your suggestion to limit the syllabus for multi subjects to be equivalent to one subject contents is really a good and practical approach otherwise ICAI must have to dump IBS.❤
Ab samay a gaya hai ki ICAI bataen ki FIRST GROUP ME SE kin-kin chapter mein se IBS me aaega yah bataye hamara ICAI 😊😊 kyoki 2nd group wala to 2nd group ki hi preparation krega 😮
My view Pls insert SCMPE and Law (Not in SPOM) And elective paper must be remain IBS In case Law and SCMPE not in SPOM .So students easily understand Law and SCMPE
Then they should dissolve 2 groups and just make one group with 6 papers,so students will study everything to clear ibs. Give 2 days holidays in audit & Dt.
A frank review of the ca final ibs exam. 1) These are not case studies. These seperate questions asked in exam clubbed together to dupe students. 2) The paper setter was very lazy to set paper and he just bring in different topics to old cases. 3) Cases dont make students to think analize the scenario and the inference from which the question is asked. If student is able to tell from which page or topic the question is asked then its not case study questions then its an exam question. 4) Case studies provide a scenario and student has to think and decifer the correct awnser which can change based on the logic if the student. The costing SPOM paper had better case study which demanded the in depth knowledge and application. 5) The paper was a ver lazy approach of examiner to ask the questions. I will give a 4 out of 10. Not a CA final level paper. Examination board should not focus on bringing the results down or making things tough for stundents by throwing a googly suddenly after some straight balls. Rather they should focus on getting CA who are able to decifer and decide the best decision in any scenario.
Mera Ca final Group 1, 2 saal pehle complete kr liya hai.. Mera Group 2 me Idt ek saal pehle exempt ho gya... Har attempt me course change ho rha... Question add ho rhe.. Amendments ho rhe... Kaise pass ho ??
sir when will classes start for ca foundation september 2025 attempt??...... and are there any scholarship tests which one can give for scholarship in foundation coaching from vsi?
My suggestion is to remove the IBS paper completely and include Set C as open book elective paper with 30 MCQ and 70 descriptive.3 hours.The IBS have no logic.Self paced mode include set A B and D only.Anyone should notice it to institute immediately.
Paper needful toh foundation mei maths ka bhi nhi tha...it's just there to test ur aptitude...n still it's a good paper of IBS.. I'll say remove auditing
Sir Institute ko itna hi multi talented banana hai to ibs ko open book kyo rkha hai. Practical life me waise bhi ca banane k baad itni kabiliyat ho jati hai ki wo kisi bhi subject se related problem ko solve kar sakta hai
Sir aapko lagta h koi sunega 😂 Koi nhi sunne wala Andhon ka raj h ye aur behre organisations chala rhe h Jbtk andha sun k behre ko batayega jbtk kitne students ka carrier barbad ho jayega . Aur ye blndr ICAI ne jo kiya h use pta hona chahiye ki isse Institute ki durdarshita pe Sawal khada ho gya h .
This paper should not be included in CA final but it can be make compulsary like GMCS training after completing CA. In which then they may ask questions so that students can do this free mindly.. asking concepts where student is appearing only for group 2 only then how can answer questions of group 1 concepts tell me.. ❓
Perveen sharma sir claim IBS paper is very easy, students have lack of knowledge of concept, only perveen sir team are providing concept and students will surely pass the exam.
Sir you are very powerful in ca coaching industry
If you make representation on this practical difficulties to the council member it will have a huge impact
I totally agree with you sir
Thank you very much sir, for being one of the few to address the practical difficulties faced by CA students. Your efforts are truly appreciated. 🙏
Thanks for taking into account the problems of students sir
Very well said sir ...
Only faculty with logical view 🙏🏾
Will All Due Respect Sir, Lots of Respect and Thanks to You to Respected Sir.
Commendable Glimpse of wisdom.
You have showed your wisdom and cover approximately all the problems which is being faced by all types of old/new/group1 passed/ only group 2 appearing student, impossible to demonstrate and apply all 7 subject indepth knowledge in short span of exam times in IBS PAPER which ultimately very very very difficult to pass CA FINAL EXAM specially for Old CA FINAL Student who is pursuing more than 10 year and invested their entire youth.
It will be very disheartening and sorrowful to leave ca course due to IBS.
You are torch bearers and have a Soloution oriented approach.
Its my humblest request to you that Sir please Do Something and derive such solution as soon as possible in terms of Coverage of Limited Content of Syllabus in such a manner which do not require additional time to prepare GROUP 1 Subjects for Old Pass Out Student during 2008 to 2020 or only preparing GROUP 2 exam, Level of IBS Exam, Structure of Question Paper etc in terms of no of case study etc
Very nice vedio...
Sir please a vedio on way of mailing to icai...
Thanks for this video
I agree with u who had cleared Group 1 in old syllabus
Good suggestion sir in a very polite way
Agreed with your suggestion.
IBS is like jack of all master of all!
Specialization in a particular subject is required for indepth knowledge. Making khichdi of every subject is not practical at all!
This is very bad move by ICAI by combining everything in one paper.
Yes sir good suggestions .. icai ka ibs is now a meme material
Sir, my Inter group 2 results got hold because of writing good feedback to icai in last may 24. Later after a week got results via mail after writing to them again. So informing icai also looks have impact on us.
Only luck factor with deep knowledge may work in paper 6.
Respected Sir
As i knew from the inception of CA EXAM in India to till NOVEMEBER 2023 CA FINAL EXAM, No Such Subject and exam was conducted by INSTITUTE to pass CA FINAL Group 2 which require combined or integrated knowledge to pass the Last Paper of CA FINAL GROUP 2 EXAM Just like IBS at present.
So why or beloved Institute is doing injustice at this point of time for their own Final Student which They Have not done in the history of CA FINAL EXAM in terms of GROUP 2 LAST PAPER.
This Requirement of having expert level knowledge of All 7 Subjects of CA FINAL to pass IBS Exam is prima facie against the Institute's own Policy with regard to become a CA, i.e. In order to pass CA exam student is required to appear and pass Final Exam either in Any of Group or Both Group simultaneously.
In this case Syllabus Content of IBS PAPER is NOT LIMITED TO THE EXTENT OF CA FINAL GROUP 2 REMAINING SUBJECTS but expanded and touched the Group 1, so how it can be said that this paper is a part of Group 2 only previously held exam of ca final group 2.
Bro your letter is good but . I think lack professionalism. Love to know if u will make any further changes
Sir it is really good
I feel the institute of chartered accountants of India introduced this paper for a reason and it is really helpful in building the nation and making good CA.
When 5 Subjects Concept are Tested Individual,
Then there is No Need of IBS,
Instead Of IBS,
Institute should Bring Law & Scmpe.
Also Law & Scmpe is of no use as no CA is practicing these subject and not jobs in these subjects...
Sir, jo log 1st group pass ho chuke hai, 2-3 saal pehle, unke liye ye sir dard bana hua hai, at least ek syllabus bta te ki ye syllabus hai, isko padna hai, without syllabus 1st group ko samajhne me hi 6m lag jayega, jo ki sambhav nhi hai
Your suggestion to limit the syllabus for multi subjects to be equivalent to one subject contents is really a good and practical approach otherwise ICAI must have to dump IBS.❤
My self clear group 8 year ago . I have read group 1 now ..i thought still final both group pending group 1 cleared no use now
Ab samay a gaya hai ki ICAI bataen ki FIRST GROUP ME SE kin-kin chapter mein se IBS me aaega yah bataye hamara ICAI 😊😊 kyoki 2nd group wala to 2nd group ki hi preparation krega 😮
Sir, for IBS they should frame defined syllabus chapter wise for all subjects, so that student who has cleared group 1 can also plan study.
Whats the logic in having one more common paper for subejcts that are being tested for 100 marks already...🙆♂️
My view Pls insert SCMPE and
Law (Not in SPOM)
And elective paper must be remain IBS
In case Law and SCMPE not in SPOM .So students easily understand Law and SCMPE
IBS ko fully objective type kr dena chahiye with negative marking rather than ki 4 hours m paper likhna hai
Students who are trying to pass only Gr 2, IBS is really really tough and irrelevant for them. So many books need to carry for IBS exam.
Then they should dissolve 2 groups and just make one group with 6 papers,so students will study everything to clear ibs. Give 2 days holidays in audit & Dt.
A frank review of the ca final ibs exam.
1) These are not case studies. These seperate questions asked in exam clubbed together to dupe students.
2) The paper setter was very lazy to set paper and he just bring in different topics to old cases.
3) Cases dont make students to think analize the scenario and the inference from which the question is asked. If student is able to tell from which page or topic the question is asked then its not case study questions then its an exam question.
4) Case studies provide a scenario and student has to think and decifer the correct awnser which can change based on the logic if the student. The costing SPOM paper had better case study which demanded the in depth knowledge and application.
5) The paper was a ver lazy approach of examiner to ask the questions. I will give a 4 out of 10. Not a CA final level paper. Examination board should not focus on bringing the results down or making things tough for stundents by throwing a googly suddenly after some straight balls. Rather they should focus on getting CA who are able to decifer and decide the best decision in any scenario.
i m in found so should i leave this hell course
Ibs1 for group1 basis
Ibs 2 for group2 basis
Mera Ca final Group 1, 2 saal pehle complete kr liya hai..
Mera Group 2 me Idt ek saal pehle exempt ho gya...
Har attempt me course change ho rha... Question add ho rhe..
Amendments ho rhe...
Kaise pass ho ??
My dt is exempt but thinking’s to quit now as grp 1 was cleared 10 yrs bk
@@seema.purohit17....you are not required to quiet.... Only IDT and Open book remaining... please clear it in upcoming attempts
Hope they will add grace marks for this attempt if they want don't pass max than they don't allow us
Sir what about who had cleared gr 1 in old syllabus
sir when will classes start for ca foundation september 2025 attempt??...... and are there any scholarship tests which one can give for scholarship in foundation coaching from vsi?
Fir ibs ki kya jarurat thi
Waise bhi jitne practicing ca hai practical life me bina ready rekner dekhe koi case solve krte hai kya
My suggestion is to remove the IBS paper completely and include Set C as open book elective paper with 30 MCQ and 70 descriptive.3 hours.The IBS have no logic.Self paced mode include set A B and D only.Anyone should notice it to institute immediately.
Excalty
Sir is se teek old course me isca tha ek grup pe pta tha kitna padna h ...yha jo bacche sach me phle 1st grup nikala unke liye katin hi gya h
It has to remove from the syllabus
Yes correct
Paper needful toh foundation mei maths ka bhi nhi tha...it's just there to test ur aptitude...n still it's a good paper of IBS..
I'll say remove auditing
Sir Institute ko itna hi multi talented banana hai to ibs ko open book kyo rkha hai. Practical life me waise bhi ca banane k baad itni kabiliyat ho jati hai ki wo kisi bhi subject se related problem ko solve kar sakta hai
Sir aapko lagta h koi sunega 😂
Koi nhi sunne wala
Andhon ka raj h ye aur behre organisations chala rhe h
Jbtk andha sun k behre ko batayega jbtk kitne students ka carrier barbad ho jayega .
Aur ye blndr ICAI ne jo kiya h use pta hona chahiye ki isse Institute ki durdarshita pe Sawal khada ho gya h .
Group group khelna band hona chahiye it is good decision of icai ibs
Tumhara Group 2 clear ho gya.?
@@shubharthibardhan4721that's why
This paper should not be included in CA final but it can be make compulsary like GMCS training after completing CA. In which then they may ask questions so that students can do this free mindly.. asking concepts where student is appearing only for group 2 only then how can answer questions of group 1 concepts tell me.. ❓
Perveen sharma sir claim IBS paper is very easy, students have lack of knowledge of concept, only perveen sir team are providing concept and students will surely pass the exam.
Ask Perveen sir to carry all books to the exam hall and write the exam.
Please share mail ids to whom we send a request
Praveen sharma toh keh rha hai easy tha ibs