Maurice said In an interview that after Andy died....and they went back to their studio to record....he was playing notes on the keyboard and Robin and Barry and himself just started crying and they couldn't record for a while....but they really wanted to do this song for Andy because he was their brother and they loved him and they missed him. He was going to join them. Maurice said he called to wish Andy a happy 30th birthday and he was staying with Robin at his house and Robin told him he can't come to the phone...because he had gotten high. Maurice said he was very mad about that because he had been doing so well and everyone was trying to help him. Robin said people kept saying he needs tough love and that's what he tried to do with Andy....it was not what he wanted to do. Barry was disappointed that Andy had undone all he had worked so hard for over the year. When Andy passed away they all said that was guilt and hurt they had to live with. Robin also said some people need to feel and be told they're loved more than others to feel good about themselves. Barry said in an interview after Robin died....,"I would give up all the music and the songs and the fame just to have my brothers back here with me again. The quarrels we had that seemed so important at the time mean nothing. I have to keep going to honor our dream as kids and to keep their memory and presence alive ." ..Robin once said in an interview " If you think someone has done something good....tell them..if you love someone....tell them because that could make all the difference in their life.... don't take anyone you are friends with or family or a relationship you're in for granted because you will regret it Don't be afraid to show how you feel.'". They said after they wrote this song....they had to do it several times to get through it without crying. Thanks Chad for your reaction.. Sorry this comment is so long. .
@@susieq9801 I didn't know that....they all wanted him to get his life straight and join them....so sad his addiction took control and it didn't happen.
@@cynthiadaves1933 - Andy was living in a cottage on Rob's estate so he felt partly responsible but should not have. He tried to keep him in check but simply couldn't. If someone is determined and addicted enough nobody can stop them. They said for all of his cheerful demeanor Andy was insecure and terrified he would fail his brothers. What a burden to try to live up to them.
Maurice mentioned that but Andy was not high but drunk, because alcohol was the drug he could find in a little town like Thame. Andy kicked the drugs but was not able to get rid of alcohol and his heart was so weak already - he did not tell anybody he had a heart condition, nobody expects a young man of 30 to die
I live in Miami and I will never forget one late afternoon in 1986 when I & a group of friends were on a yacht & we sailed behind Andy’s home. The windows were open and we could see a large screen tv playing. The captain told us that Andy lived there & suddenly Andy ran out to the dock, waving & smiling at us, as if he were genuinely happy to see his fans and interact with us. That’s a day I will never forget. He had moved here to Miami from LA to be close to his brothers & was set to join his brothers in 1988 as the official fourth Bee Gee. He passed away before it happened. His genuine smile & happiness to interact with us is a memory I will never forget. I wish I could’ve gotten to know him and his brothers. They have always been so humble & truly appreciative of their fans. I get emotional, even cry sometimes, when hear this and a few other songs. Thank you Chad, for sharing their wonderful music with all of us.
the latest BARRY GIBB song for his brothers is another tear jerker, its called END OF THE RAINBOW, " goodbye amigo my fair weather friend, from humble beginnings right through the end " thats the saddest part of the song for me
This is the song that Barry wrote specifically for robin as he neared the end of his life and Robin's wife asked him to come to his bedside and sing it to Robin so he did. You know how hard that had to be!
MO said that they had a hard time singing this in concert because it would change their moods for the rest of the show so they were dedicate another song for Andy
Wish you were hear was the song they wrote for Andy. They couldn't hardly do it live they cried on stage one time maybe the first time they sang it live. The audience applauded for a long time the guys were in tears. Love this it is very emotional. Thank you Chad you are great!!
Chad, your words at the end were so wonderful and I hope that everyone heeds your advice and patches things up with a loved one that they're not on good terms with before it's too late and the opportunity has passed them by. Even at Robin's funeral, Barry, in his beautiful eulogy to his brother, said this about their sometimes turbulent relationship with each other. "We were laughing all the way. Sometimes crying. God knows how much we argued. Even right up to the end we found conflict with each other, which now means nothing. It just means nothing. If there's conflict in your lives - get rid of it." Wise words from two very wise men. Loved your reactions this weekend and will be waiting all week for what you have in store for us next weekend.Thank you, Chad.
This song always makes me cry and it’s one more reminder to make sure we say what we need to say to our loved ones. One never knows when it will be the last time.
He was not getting on with Andy at the time of his death. Barry has said the last time he spoke with Andy he was giving him “tough love” to try stop his drug use and drinking. He said he still feels terrible about that.
@@katie-didellis2437 Tough love *might* have helped Andy had it been implemented years earlier. But that's only a guess. Like their mom Barbara stated; "Yes, Andy died clean, but it Was the drugs that killed him. It just took 10 years to do it." I was pretty surprised to hear Barbara acknowledge that. That had to be a hard realisation for her. I think all the brothers felt guilty that they could not save their kid brother. Probably Barry felt the weight of it the most, being the eldest and being so close to Andy. Very Sad.
@@gloriamaryhaywood2217 the brothers, I think learned, because when Mo had his problem with alcohol Barry and Robin said they used tough love. Watch the fighting back episode of Mo's story. Makes you love him even more.
@@katie-didellis2437 Oh, I've seen that episode with Lynn Redgrave several years ago. Like Barry said, when Mo came to see him he was met with a brick-wall. It was like "Nobody's smiling at your drinking anymore more, Mo!, Oh, and by the way You're Fired!" Barry said that was a very painful but necessary thing to do. I know that both Barry and Robin Had to have been asked to participate in that interview by Mo himself. No way would they otherwise have spoken out against their brother. They tried the same kind of tough-love thing with Andy, but it was just too little too late.💔
Yeah this is such a beautiful sad song that the brothers wrote for their brother Andy and Maurice said in the interview that it was hard for them to perform Wish You Were Here cuz they would think of Andy passing away so they instead would perform Our Love Don’t Throw It All Away cuz they would feel Andy’s presence in a happy feeling 😭
Beautiful song.. Song writers, performers, and a brother. This was the brother's way of going through their grief. When Andy died at Robin's house in England, Robin said he was in bad shape. Each brother tried to call Andy. Maurice was told by Robin that he was not able to even take the call. When Barry called later, he was angry with Andy and told him to get himself together, practicing tough love. Barry said it was the last time he talked to Andy and he has to live with that. From Larry King Weekend in 2002 interview.
Those brothers left us so much great music to bring us joy and warm our hearts.Not only that,but some very sound lessons about life in general.They shared so much of themselves the good and the bad,the ups and downs.Thanks guys .Such a special group.
I just got home from church, worked the sound booth for a viewing of a very good man who passed on. And here are Chad's selections for the afternoon. Unique coincidence, beautiful song. And, tomorrow is the funeral service, so I'll be running audio/visual in the booth for that, but I watch people interact warmly over fond memories as they listen to the music and watch the visual slide show that was prepared. It is much better to remember the good things and to enjoy one another's company in times when someone has passed. Remember, they aren't suffering the ills of this world anymore and we'll see them again eventually, provided your faith. Our loved ones never truly leave us, they are always within us, in our hearts.
Heartbreaking song for anyone to relate to by the brothers. The pain is definitely heard and felt in this tribute to Andy. They wanted to remember the true Andy as we all should, no matter how he passed, what he battled or what has been said will not bring him back. The brothers lost one of their own and the world lost a great talent, an amazing and gentle soul.
I'm older now (64) and I am losing friends, family and favourite celebs (that I of course didn't know). Songs such as this one brings back the memories of when we were together. Once gone, the memories are all we have. If we are talented enough to put it into song and verse then it becomes somehow immortal. Songs like this makes one think. Good reaction.
Just beautiful and sad at the same time. Thanks Chad for doing this song. It does make you tear up. My sister died unexpectedly and she was the person in the world who was the closest to me. Yes all siblings fight but it's true you love them no matter what. Tell your family and friends what they mean to you . You may not get the chance. My world has not been the same since. The Gibb brothers all so special and how we still miss Andy, Mo and Robin.
What a good song I can't get enough of listening to Chad ... it really has an splendid musical arrangement ... it's perfect ... the chorus and Robin's voice saying "IT'S NOT WHAT IT SEEMS.". it's sublime ... Congratulations ... !! 👏👏👏💪💪💙💛 💙💛💙
Barry said that the falling out he had with Robin was that Robin took this song and performed it on a solo album "Magnet". He deeply regretted the argument I think I identify with this song and the family conflicts when it comes to addiction. I also am from a family that siblings were caught in the cycle of addiction ultimately causing death. You can never control other people's behavior, and the guilt you feel over it is very sad. I used their music to help me through some tough times. Thanks for showing the humanity of the Bee Gees
My sister took her own life 31 years ago and it feels like it was today. We were close so it was a major shock to me and I still don't know what I could have done to stop her. To this day I rack my heart and brain. It's like they say that when a person takes their own life they aren't thinking about those left behind and those left behind are often left with guilt because you just wish you could have done something or in the case of those who were not getting along you wished there was no fiction. In my case I was close with her but evidently I was too close to see the forest for the trees. I love her and miss her daily every day and I'm so grateful she was my sister Terry Lee.
This is a beautiful 💔💔💔💔 song chad. Mom & dad & 5 kids, im the only one left & im the oldest. Love this song i play it for my family to. Thank you chad, 🎶🎶🎶🎶🎶🥺💕💕💕
It is hard to listen to this song because I feel sad for the Gibb family and also for the loved ones I have lost. I can understand why they could never sing this Live! It is a poignant and beautiful song that can be hard to listen to without feeling sad!
Didn't ever they play it live? I'll tellya, they did. But only twotimes, so it's been very hard for them emotionally. First time was in Kiel, Northern-Germany, to find on YT. Second time was in Salzburg, Austria and I was there. Open air event, roundabout 20000 visitors to their One For All-tour on that evening. The brothers had tears in their eyes, at the end of that song. The crowd was calm about 10 seconds, followed by standing ovations, lasting for nearly two minutes. That was great and a deep running experiance.
Pretty sure I saw Robin perform it when he was out on his own after Maurice died. Some televised thing, maybe when he performed at a July 4th concert in DC.
Out of the most excruciating pain comes often the most beautiful of creations... As I listen to this tribute, my heart aches for Sir Barry Gibb, and his older sister, Leslie Evans (nee Gibb...) - pain is the price we pay for having Loved... Over the years, the fact that the three brothers weren't able to perform this musical eulogy to baby brother Andy in public, only made me admire them even more... 💖💖💖 THANK You Chad, for another marvelous Bee Gees weekend - once again, it brought me down my very own Memory Lane, spanning from my early childhood to late teens - a trip I always enjoy! Looking forward to Your next reaction, my Friend!💕
Barry said in an interview that he wasn't speaking with any of his brothers when they died. He said that was his biggest regret. I know they loved him very much as he did them.
Please listen to Robin singing Ellan Vannan it will pull at your heart strings one of his best ❤ Listen to the version with the King William’s college choir so moving
It took weeks for the the guys to record this all the way through without crying, and then doing it in concert was something they just never could do. Andy was supposed to join them and this was to be the first album. I heard Barry and Mo mention a couple of times how Andy's face was supposed to have been on the cover, too...😪 I'm sorry, can I just be HONEST? This history pisses me off, too! 😡 Apparently, Andy knew of his heart problem for TWO YEARS and said NOTHING. Additionally, Mo had had stomach issues for a couple of months and SAID NOTHING! Damn it! They might both still be HERE! As a former nurse/EMT, a mom, grandmother, and great-grandma, I just wanna shake somebody! People, DON'T BE STUPID, PLEASE! 😢
Ooh. This is a stab you in the heart and twist the knife painful song. It was on a compilation of funeral type songs right after Princess Diana died. It played at my sister’s funeral. Wrecks me every time.
Andy's death was tragic. Out of control, too much too soon as often happens. A shame people didn't seem to learn from what the older boys encountered but he was an adult and they could only do so much. His siblings were close in age and had each other in tough times. In the ambulance he asked his mother "Can I die from this?" Andy collapsed at Robin's home in Thame where he was living and where they tried to make him behave. When Robin was told Andy was gone he thought they meant he had left the hospital, but he was dead. Robin said perhaps it was karma for their success. His later songs "Days of Wine and Roses" and "All we have is Now" no doubt reflect the losses they endured, especially the loss of Mo who everybody loved. His own death was horrific and dragged on for at least two years. I saw an awful photo of him skeletal and wrapped in a blanket. Mercifully Mo went quickly but too young. We can all learn from Barry's eulogy at Rob's funeral...Robin and I fought all the time but it all means nothing now. Get rid of it.
There,'s 6 months that my loved husband Elio, moved to heaven. I know he is very well, but I miss him so much...I miss him ...At the right time God will call me to re-encounter him for ethernal life.❤️
This was written for Andy, the brothers took a long time before they could sing this,, you should watch the live version, behind them is the life of Andy ❤😢 Andy went to live at Robins and died there, big regrets,it happens, Barry felt especially bad as his last words to Andy were so harsh, beautiful song ❤❤❤
Hello Chad. Thank you for reacting to this beautiful but very sad song. I like.the.song But it' makes. me sad because I think of my son I lost. And those Barry has lost.i wish the same thing.
Thank you, Chad for this weekend experience and these emotional words. It is a pleasure and a privilege to be able to listen to you. Until next weekend stay healthy and love life everyone. Greetings from the other side of the pond.
I'm 67 and have been to many concerts from David Bowie, Madonna, and Bruce Springsteen just to name a few. I only wish I could have seen the Bee Gees in concert. Seeing and listening to your reactions channel has been fabulous 👋👋👋
Gif you can find the concert when they played this- I’m sorry I can’t recall which one but you would really like it there’s a bittersweet surprise to it
Oh Chad! Increible lo que compartes estos genios monstruosos que siempre hicieron sentirme en otro lugar transportarme donde sus letras y melodias !! Increibles armonias de voces conjugadas ..armoniosas no no no hay ni habra jamas una definicion de lo que significaron a la musica que hoy y de por vida extrañara..gracias Chad un placer enorme!!
Chad,darte gracias es poco sentir ya estoy mal acostumbrada, pero me gustaria que si pueras a aquellos que amamo a Bee Gee,podernos compartir, "Comence una broma",del inigualable Robin a quien adore del comienzo en la espectacular gira "Spirit tour" de 1979, su voz un regalo de los angeles!! Gracias nuevamente y saludos!!!
Now this one always makes me want to cry, written for Andy, he died so young & I was so crazy for him. We were around same age. This one hurts, at their concerts they would show videos of Andy, first couple times I saw it I cried. Is it odd to cry for someone I never really met but feel like it after following them all for years. 😢💔
They tried one time to do this song live and broke down and couldn't do it, it hurt them so bad when Andy died , i remember Mo said in an interview it took them so long to get through the recording in the studio because they just kept crying , and finally Mo said they just pulled it together on the last try and that was this you are hearing . Andy was supposed to join them in the group for this album and become the fourth Bee Gee but it wasn't meant to be :(
Beautiful song but so painful. I read Mo went to the studio after Andy passed and started the musical part. The brothers became so emotional and had to wait a few weeks to complete the song. Also heard this song was so emotional for the brothers that they could never perform this live. Not sure if true but what I heard. Melts my heart. Definitely hits home after losing several of my family members.
They actually performed this live at the beginning of the 1989 World Tour but it was too emotional and they chose "How Deep Is Your Love" as their dedication to Andy for the rest of the tour. That entire album was so polished and smooth (Barry pretty much abandoned the falsetto for the entire album). Barry should do a remix, though, like he did with the concert audio from that tour. The new sound has a much warmer feel than the 80's mix which tends to sound a bit cold. Try "End of the Rainbow" from Barry 2016's solo album. That was his tribute to Robin.
*_FOR MY FULL BEE GEES PLAYLIST, FOLLOW THIS LINK BEFORE MAKING REQUESTS:_* th-cam.com/play/PLSnNE4tdNL-rR68vDdLHlOD-HXQ_vHUHE.html
Maurice said In an interview that after Andy died....and they went back to their studio to record....he was playing notes on the keyboard and Robin and Barry and himself just started crying and they couldn't record for a while....but they really wanted to do this song for Andy because he was their brother and they loved him and they missed him. He was going to join them. Maurice said he called to wish Andy a happy 30th birthday and he was staying with Robin at his house and Robin told him he can't come to the phone...because he had gotten high. Maurice said he was very mad about that because he had been doing so well and everyone was trying to help him. Robin said people kept saying he needs tough love and that's what he tried to do with Andy....it was not what he wanted to do. Barry was disappointed that Andy had undone all he had worked so hard for over the year. When Andy passed away they all said that was guilt and hurt they had to live with.
Robin also said some people need to feel and be told they're loved more than others to feel good about themselves. Barry said in an interview after Robin died....,"I would give up all the music and the songs and the fame just to have my brothers back here with me again. The quarrels we had that seemed so important at the time mean nothing. I have to keep going to honor our dream as kids and to keep their memory and presence alive ." ..Robin once said in an interview " If you think someone has done something good....tell them..if you love someone....tell them because that could make all the difference in their life.... don't take anyone you are friends with or family or a relationship you're in for granted because you will regret it Don't be afraid to show how you feel.'". They said after they wrote this song....they had to do it several times to get through it without crying.
Thanks Chad for your reaction..
Sorry this comment is so long.
.
Andy also smuggled in booze at Robin's, got drunk and knocked out most of his teeth in a fall.
@@susieq9801 I didn't know that....they all wanted him to get his life straight and join them....so sad his addiction took control and it didn't happen.
@@cynthiadaves1933 - Andy was living in a cottage on Rob's estate so he felt partly responsible but should not have. He tried to keep him in check but simply couldn't. If someone is determined and addicted enough nobody can stop them. They said for all of his cheerful demeanor Andy was insecure and terrified he would fail his brothers. What a burden to try to live up to them.
Thanks so much for sharing this. Definitely words of wisdom to live by.
Maurice mentioned that but Andy was not high but drunk, because alcohol was the drug he could find in a little town like Thame. Andy kicked the drugs but was not able to get rid of alcohol and his heart was so weak already - he did not tell anybody he had a heart condition, nobody expects a young man of 30 to die
I live in Miami and I will never forget one late afternoon in 1986 when I & a group of friends were on a yacht & we sailed behind Andy’s home. The windows were open and we could see a large screen tv playing. The captain told us that Andy lived there & suddenly Andy ran out to the dock, waving & smiling at us, as if he were genuinely happy to see his fans and interact with us. That’s a day I will never forget. He had moved here to Miami from LA to be close to his brothers & was set to join his brothers in 1988 as the official fourth Bee Gee. He passed away before it happened. His genuine smile & happiness to interact with us is a memory I will never forget. I wish I could’ve gotten to know him and his brothers. They have always been so humble & truly appreciative of their fans. I get emotional, even cry sometimes, when hear this and a few other songs. Thank you Chad, for sharing their wonderful music with all of us.
Well done, most have never heard this! One of their best songs ever!!!
Played this at my mothers funeral. This is the boys at their very best. One is my all time favourite album.
Chad you have such a old and loving soul..
the latest BARRY GIBB song for his brothers is another tear jerker, its called END OF THE RAINBOW, " goodbye amigo my fair weather friend, from humble beginnings right through the end " thats the saddest part of the song for me
This is the song that Barry wrote specifically for robin as he neared the end of his life and Robin's wife asked him to come to his bedside and sing it to Robin so he did. You know how hard that had to be!
Listen to Robin's Sydney
MO said that they had a hard time singing this in concert because it would change their moods for the rest of the show so they were dedicate another song for Andy
Wish you were hear was the song they wrote for Andy. They couldn't hardly do it live they cried on stage one time maybe the first time they sang it live. The audience applauded for a long time the guys were in tears. Love this it is very emotional. Thank you Chad you are great!!
Hi Chad!! This is a song for everyone's lost loved one's. For me it's both beautiful and painful.💙
Love this song although it is sad... lyrics so meaningful... thank you Chad for the reaction..
I have collected more than a million of songs over the years but I always keep coming back to The Bee Gees.
Chad, your words at the end were so wonderful and I hope that everyone heeds your advice and patches things up with a loved one that they're not on good terms with before it's too late and the opportunity has passed them by. Even at Robin's funeral, Barry, in his beautiful eulogy to his brother, said this about their sometimes turbulent relationship with each other. "We were laughing all the way. Sometimes crying. God knows how much we argued. Even right up to the end we found conflict with each other, which now means nothing. It just means nothing. If there's conflict in your lives - get rid of it." Wise words from two very wise men. Loved your reactions this weekend and will be waiting all week for what you have in store for us next weekend.Thank you, Chad.
This song always makes me cry and it’s one more reminder to make sure we say what we need to say to our loved ones. One never knows when it will be the last time.
The beginning is carosel music because Andy liked them.
He was not getting on with Andy at the time of his death. Barry has said the last time he spoke with Andy he was giving him “tough love” to try stop his drug use and drinking. He said he still feels terrible about that.
Double guessing our actions is not good. tough love is probably what Andy needed but his health was so compromised that his time was over.💔😢
@@katie-didellis2437 Tough love *might* have helped Andy had it been implemented years earlier. But that's only a guess. Like their mom Barbara stated; "Yes, Andy died clean, but it Was the drugs that killed him. It just took 10 years to do it."
I was pretty surprised to hear Barbara acknowledge that. That had to be a hard realisation for her.
I think all the brothers felt guilty that they could not save their kid brother. Probably Barry felt the weight of it the most, being the eldest and being so close to Andy. Very Sad.
@@gloriamaryhaywood2217 the brothers, I think learned, because when Mo had his problem with alcohol Barry and Robin said they used tough love. Watch the fighting back episode of Mo's story. Makes you love him even more.
@@katie-didellis2437 Oh, I've seen that episode with Lynn Redgrave several years ago. Like Barry said, when Mo came to see him he was met with a brick-wall. It was like "Nobody's smiling at your drinking anymore more, Mo!, Oh, and by the way You're Fired!" Barry said that was a very painful but necessary thing to do.
I know that both Barry and Robin Had to have been asked to participate in that interview by Mo himself. No way would they otherwise have spoken out against their brother.
They tried the same kind of tough-love thing with Andy, but it was just too little too late.💔
Yeah this is such a beautiful sad song that the brothers wrote for their brother Andy and Maurice said in the interview that it was hard for them to perform Wish You Were Here cuz they would think of Andy passing away so they instead would perform Our Love Don’t Throw It All Away cuz they would feel Andy’s presence in a happy feeling 😭
Beautiful song.. Song writers, performers, and a brother. This was the brother's way of going through their grief. When Andy died at Robin's house in England, Robin said he was in bad shape. Each brother tried to call Andy. Maurice was told by Robin that he was not able to even take the call. When Barry called later, he was angry with Andy and told him to get himself together, practicing tough love. Barry said it was the last time he talked to Andy and he has to live with that. From Larry King Weekend in 2002 interview.
Those brothers left us so much great music to bring us joy and warm our hearts.Not only that,but some very sound lessons about life in general.They shared so much of themselves the good and the bad,the ups and downs.Thanks guys .Such a special group.
If ever a song conveyed love,pain and regret,this is it.💕
I just got home from church, worked the sound booth for a viewing of a very good man who passed on. And here are Chad's selections for the afternoon. Unique coincidence, beautiful song. And, tomorrow is the funeral service, so I'll be running audio/visual in the booth for that, but I watch people interact warmly over fond memories as they listen to the music and watch the visual slide show that was prepared. It is much better to remember the good things and to enjoy one another's company in times when someone has passed. Remember, they aren't suffering the ills of this world anymore and we'll see them again eventually, provided your faith. Our loved ones never truly leave us, they are always within us, in our hearts.
The video to this is touching and beautiful
Am I first? 🙄. He died so young. 😪. Heartfelt song.
It's a good thing I'm not on camera, because I'm an ugly crier. The song is a treasure. I just can't listen without feeling sad.
***R.I.P. Andy, Maurice, & Robin*** Your music will live forever in our broken hearts 💔 💔 💔
Heartbreaking song for anyone to relate to by the brothers. The pain is definitely heard and felt in this tribute to Andy. They wanted to remember the true Andy as we all should, no matter how he passed, what he battled or what has been said will not bring him back. The brothers lost one of their own and the world lost a great talent, an amazing and gentle soul.
Each time I hear this song, I just can't stop my tears..
Esta hermosa canción de BeeGees, es para cerrar los ojos, sentirla y dejar escapar nuestros sentimientos.
Such a beautiful and emotional song. So touching. Thanks for sharing this wonderful song and your great reaction, Chad.
I'm older now (64) and I am losing friends, family and favourite celebs (that I of course didn't know). Songs such as this one brings back the memories of when we were together. Once gone, the memories are all we have. If we are talented enough to put it into song and verse then it becomes somehow immortal. Songs like this makes one think. Good reaction.
MY HEART FAVORITE
Tribute too Andy, but Love Their blend...Barry's tone.
Where Barry gets low and high...
Miss my mother.
Just beautiful and sad at the same time. Thanks Chad for doing this song. It does make you tear up. My sister died unexpectedly and she was the person in the world who was the closest to me. Yes all siblings fight but it's true you love them no matter what. Tell your family and friends what they mean to you . You may not get the chance. My world has not been the same since. The Gibb brothers all so special and how we still miss Andy, Mo and Robin.
Raw love stripped to core, asking for mercy begging for love again... heartbreaking.
Thank you Chad
What a good song I can't get enough of listening to Chad ... it really has an splendid musical arrangement ... it's perfect ... the chorus and Robin's voice saying "IT'S NOT WHAT IT SEEMS.". it's sublime ... Congratulations ... !! 👏👏👏💪💪💙💛 💙💛💙
Barry said that the falling out he had with Robin was that Robin took this song and performed it on a solo album "Magnet". He deeply regretted the argument I think I identify with this song and the family conflicts when it comes to addiction. I also am from a family that siblings were caught in the cycle of addiction ultimately causing death. You can never control other people's behavior, and the guilt you feel over it is very sad. I used their music to help me through some tough times. Thanks for showing the humanity of the Bee Gees
My sister took her own life 31 years ago and it feels like it was today. We were close so it was a major shock to me and I still don't know what I could have done to stop her. To this day I rack my heart and brain. It's like they say that when a person takes their own life they aren't thinking about those left behind and those left behind are often left with guilt because you just wish you could have done something or in the case of those who were not getting along you wished there was no fiction. In my case I was close with her but evidently I was too close to see the forest for the trees. I love her and miss her daily every day and I'm so grateful she was my sister Terry Lee.
Truly sorry for your loss. Thanks for your feedback on the channel.
There’s a video and they show old videos of Andy. A must see!!!!
This is a beautiful 💔💔💔💔 song chad. Mom & dad & 5 kids, im the only one left & im the oldest. Love this song i play it for my family to. Thank you chad, 🎶🎶🎶🎶🎶🥺💕💕💕
It is really a beautiful song.
So sad, but so good because it’s the incomparable Bee Gees😢
It is hard to listen to this song because I feel sad for the Gibb family and also for the loved ones I have lost. I can understand why they could never sing this Live! It is a poignant and beautiful song that can be hard to listen to without feeling sad!
Didn't ever they play it live? I'll tellya, they did. But only twotimes, so it's been very hard for them emotionally. First time was in Kiel, Northern-Germany, to find on YT. Second time was in Salzburg, Austria and I was there. Open air event, roundabout 20000 visitors to their One For All-tour on that evening. The brothers had tears in their eyes, at the end of that song. The crowd was calm about 10 seconds, followed by standing ovations, lasting for nearly two minutes. That was great and a deep running experiance.
Pretty sure I saw Robin perform it when he was out on his own after Maurice died. Some televised thing, maybe when he performed at a July 4th concert in DC.
He did...and changed the words a bit for Mo
Out of the most excruciating pain comes often the most beautiful of creations...
As I listen to this tribute, my heart aches for Sir Barry Gibb, and his older sister, Leslie Evans (nee Gibb...) - pain is the price we pay for having Loved...
Over the years, the fact that the three brothers weren't able to perform this musical eulogy to baby brother Andy in public, only made me admire them even more...
💖💖💖
THANK You Chad, for another marvelous Bee Gees weekend - once again, it brought me down my very own Memory Lane, spanning from my early childhood to late teens - a trip I always enjoy! Looking forward to Your next reaction, my Friend!💕
Barry said in an interview that he wasn't speaking with any of his brothers when they died. He said that was his biggest regret.
I know they loved him very much as he did them.
Great and beauty Bee Gees' song. Thanks.
Beautiful and so sad!
Beautiful Andys song. So sad. Now the otgers are gone, and Barrys standing alone. Just a beautiful song.
A tear jerker. Sometimes I wonder how Barry made it through. 😩
Please listen to Robin singing Ellan Vannan it will pull at your heart strings one of his best ❤ Listen to the version with the King William’s college choir so moving
Hi Sandra great recommendation Chad has already reacted to that! Heres the link
th-cam.com/video/_VeH6ffdus0/w-d-xo.htmlsi=QSVK8wTd75VZ2TTb
Thank you Chad for reacting to this and especially your words for us all to remember. Great job !!!
It took weeks for the the guys to record this all the way through without crying, and then doing it in concert was something they just never could do. Andy was supposed to join them and this was to be the first album. I heard Barry and Mo mention a couple of times how Andy's face was supposed to have been on the cover, too...😪
I'm sorry, can I just be HONEST? This history pisses me off, too! 😡 Apparently, Andy knew of his heart problem for TWO YEARS and said NOTHING. Additionally, Mo had had stomach issues for a couple of months and SAID NOTHING! Damn it! They might both still be HERE! As a former nurse/EMT, a mom, grandmother, and great-grandma, I just wanna shake somebody! People, DON'T BE STUPID, PLEASE! 😢
Ooh. This is a stab you in the heart and twist the knife painful song. It was on a compilation of funeral type songs right after Princess Diana died. It played at my sister’s funeral. Wrecks me every time.
So sad, but so beautiful. Thanks, Chad. ❤
A beautiful song! Good choice.
Andy's death was tragic. Out of control, too much too soon as often happens. A shame people didn't seem to learn from what the older boys encountered but he was an adult and they could only do so much. His siblings were close in age and had each other in tough times. In the ambulance he asked his mother "Can I die from this?" Andy collapsed at Robin's home in Thame where he was living and where they tried to make him behave. When Robin was told Andy was gone he thought they meant he had left the hospital, but he was dead.
Robin said perhaps it was karma for their success. His later songs "Days of Wine and Roses" and "All we have is Now" no doubt reflect the losses they endured, especially the loss of Mo who everybody loved. His own death was horrific and dragged on for at least two years. I saw an awful photo of him skeletal and wrapped in a blanket. Mercifully Mo went quickly but too young. We can all learn from Barry's eulogy at Rob's funeral...Robin and I fought all the time but it all means nothing now. Get rid of it.
Beautiful...heartfelt. Honest. Heartbreaking.
I lost my sister two months ago and this beautiful song tugs at my heart. Your reaction was definitely heartfelt. 💔
Sorry for your loss 🙏🏻❤️
@@SijpieSijpie Thank you.
Heartfelt condolences
So sorry for Your loss... May You have people to lean on, to see You through this difficult time, no matter how long it takes...💜
@@gabyehebrecht7435 Thank you, Gaby. 💕
There,'s 6 months that my loved husband Elio, moved to heaven. I know he is very well, but I miss him so much...I miss him ...At the right time God will call me to re-encounter him for ethernal life.❤️
bee gees crying every day
I think they only played this in concert once or twice because it was too difficult for them to get through the song
Essa música é um hino aos nossos ouvidos! Muito linda!❤❤❤😍😍😍😍👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
Thanks Chad! ❤😘
Love this song! Thank you Chad!😘🇮🇹
So glad you did this one.... always makes me cry, even more so after losing one of my brothers 😪
Beautiful and so sad 💔.
The video is even better to watch!! You can not just hear the emotions but see it as well!!! Immortality is fitting as well!!!
This was written for Andy, the brothers took a long time before they could sing this,, you should watch the live version, behind them is the life of Andy ❤😢 Andy went to live at Robins and died there, big regrets,it happens, Barry felt especially bad as his last words to Andy were so harsh, beautiful song ❤❤❤
This song was also part the 9th track of the 2nd CD of "Diana, Princess of Wales: Tribute"
This is such a great song. This album made me a Bee Gees fan. I had this song on repeat back in the days.
Una perfomans increible..!!👏👏👏👏
Hello Chad. Thank you for reacting to this beautiful but very sad song. I like.the.song But it' makes. me sad because I think of my son I lost. And those Barry has lost.i wish the same thing.
It is an splendid melody .. Congratulations Chad .. !! 👏👏💪💪💙💛💙💛
Thank you, Chad for this weekend experience and these emotional words. It is a pleasure and a privilege to be able to listen to you. Until next weekend stay healthy and love life everyone. Greetings from the other side of the pond.
I'm 67 and have been to many concerts from David Bowie, Madonna, and Bruce Springsteen just to name a few. I only wish I could have seen the Bee Gees in concert. Seeing and listening to your reactions channel has been fabulous 👋👋👋
Emosiona este tema..no me cansa escucharlo..!!👏👏👏👏💪💪💪💙💛💙💛💙
My brothers also didnt get along. But when One got bone cancer they made up before he died. Was so glad that happened.
Gif you can find the concert when they played this- I’m sorry I can’t recall which one but you would really like it there’s a bittersweet surprise to it
Missing the 3 3 brothers 🌹🌹🌹Love to you Barry❣️
The song describes the final moments of the Bee Gees and the fights between them.
So beautiful. Thanks Chad ..
Amooooooo! Essa música é linda demais!👋👋👋👋👋♥️♥️♥️♥️🌷🌷🌷
Look at Robin on that album cover. 🥰🥰🥰🥰
He was so cute, and he had the most soulful eyes.
@@amymarckel420 my favorite video where I can watch his eyes all day is. The Singer Sang His Song. Hubba Bubba 😂🤣😂
You may not have noticed but they basically sang the whole song in unison. Almost never happens.
Great job and beautiful words Chad. Truly is something to think about.
Oh Chad! Increible lo que compartes estos genios monstruosos que siempre hicieron sentirme en otro lugar transportarme donde sus letras y melodias !! Increibles armonias de voces conjugadas ..armoniosas no no no hay ni habra jamas una definicion de lo que significaron a la musica que hoy y de por vida extrañara..gracias Chad un placer enorme!!
Chad,darte gracias es poco sentir ya estoy mal acostumbrada, pero me gustaria que si pueras a aquellos que amamo a Bee Gee,podernos compartir, "Comence una broma",del inigualable Robin a quien adore del comienzo en la espectacular gira "Spirit tour" de 1979, su voz un regalo de los angeles!! Gracias nuevamente y saludos!!!
Just Beautiful 🎶
Pure Love ❤️💯
This song does hit you in the feels. Plus brings back memories that I need to have.
Me trás lembranças de um passado com meu Pai, é uma sensação de Paz, cantores são aqueles que lhes tocam através da música, Bee Gees eu te amo ❤
Now this one always makes me want to cry, written for Andy, he died so young & I was so crazy for him. We were around same age. This one hurts, at their concerts they would show videos of Andy, first couple times I saw it I cried. Is it odd to cry for someone I never really met but feel like it after following them all for years. 😢💔
Great advice!
Que buen tema Chad..!!👏👏💪💪💙💛💙💛💙
They tried one time to do this song live and broke down and couldn't do it, it hurt them so bad when Andy died , i remember Mo said in an interview it took them so long to get through the recording in the studio because they just kept crying , and finally Mo said they just pulled it together on the last try and that was this you are hearing . Andy was supposed to join them in the group for this album and become the fourth Bee Gee but it wasn't meant to be :(
This song reacted all the deep love for the lost youngest brother Andy😂❤❤😂
I lost my mom in March, 2023. I listen to this in memory of her.❤
Beautiful song but so painful. I read Mo went to the studio after Andy passed and started the musical part. The brothers became so emotional and had to wait a few weeks to complete the song. Also heard this song was so emotional for the brothers that they could never perform this live. Not sure if true but what I heard. Melts my heart. Definitely hits home after losing several of my family members.
Loved this as well!
Tribute to Andy, and after soooooo sadly to Maurice, and Robin !! 💔💎🙏🇬🇧
Barry kissed a blood red rose and place it on top of Robin's coffin at his gravesite.❤😢
WTH? How'd do I not recognize this song? ok, my HS yrs were Saturday Night Fever 77-78 ....this was later obviously, but it's alien to me...HUH
Love this song. Sent you an email.
They actually performed this live at the beginning of the 1989 World Tour but it was too emotional and they chose "How Deep Is Your Love" as their dedication to Andy for the rest of the tour. That entire album was so polished and smooth (Barry pretty much abandoned the falsetto for the entire album). Barry should do a remix, though, like he did with the concert audio from that tour. The new sound has a much warmer feel than the 80's mix which tends to sound a bit cold.
Try "End of the Rainbow" from Barry 2016's solo album. That was his tribute to Robin.
Very good!! REACT LIVE OR DIE BEE GEES...