There is no difference, they were making fun of the hopes and work of the people in the parliament. Earlier they used to sing poetry, now they abuse each other. Instead of making policies and doing some important work. They were wasting time of the whole 130 crores people who have selected and sent them to parliament
@@PastEventsTV Opposition is not crap but the government is trash of crap. They never answers the questions asked and if they do so they lie blatantly.
@aniketarya5253 It was good previously because one party was smart and knew its duty. Manmohan Singh congress. Now your Modi BJP is so shmless it takes no responsibility, no duties and just blame others. Monitors duty is to keep class quite and if not take the asked topic to discussion. But BJP is so coward that it can't even talk about those topics an so they chose to stop discussion and blame others. Monitor itself has no will to answer the question but to stop the sessions.
@@Mirrorlashwhat happened to the one caught with 3000kg of RDX? What happened with the IPS who was giving safe pass to the terrorists into India l. Both happened during bjpee regime u motherflower.
education does not define the sophistication or behavior of a person, the super educated MPs of Congress resort to yelling and howling more often than the supposed "uneducated" Ruling party leaders
Why worry? Kapoors and Akshay Kumar can ask Modi questions about mangoes and music. Not questions fit for the position of a PM but questions nonetheless. After all, aren't we curious if non-biological beings also have earthly interests?
This level of decency in politics is not even known to today's generation.. Irrespective of the fact whether one supports him or not .Respect for this man is unquestionable..!!❤
@@ChandrabhalRoy What decency? Whole opposition was jailed and word secularism was forcefully inserted in to the constitution Maybe that's decency according to you
What else can be expected from illiterates? Under the Brits all Indian languages were marginalized. Today the Modi regime has taken the mantle to discredit all languages except Hindi.
these were self made individuals and had respect for each other, those born with silver spoon thnk they shuld be given power as birth right and mistreat others
With due respect, us samay har samay gali nhi dete the pm ko opposition wale ... Seedhe maut ka saudagar, evil dictator ye sab nhi bolte rehte the... Yar ab socho... Modi government sirf 8 ammendment kiya hai usme bhi sabme congress ka bhi sehmati tha... Fir bhi ye log ilzaam lagate hai samvidhan badalne ka... Batao kab tak respectful behave karta modi aise logo ke sath... Atal ji seh gaye the par har koi utna nhi sehta (aur sehna chahiye bhi nhi)
Wah kitny wzadaar log thy. Sushma g brother studied with ex Pakistan foreign minister Sartaj aziz in Lahore and she met with him like a sister. Look at her smile. Manmohan g from Chakwal and what a nice n humble person ❤true gems respect from Pakistan ❤
Time when Nation had Sikh as a Prime minister and president as a Muslim " phir bhi Hindu khatre m nahi tha par aaj Hindutva ki sarkar hone k baad b Hindu khatre m h...." What a joke
To be honest I am lucky that in my childhood I saw LOK SABHA channel, where I watched Legends, Sushma Swaraj ji, Atal Bihari Vajpayee ji, Manmohan Singh ji, ❤ That time when each one was respected, yes we have negatives in every time, but that time was a true democracy ❤
When legends sit in their deserved place! Even Parliament becomes heaven ♥️ I pray to god both Manmohan Sir and ma'am should take rebirth as they were in this life and continue to serve the nation as they were doing. Om nama shivaya
One of the GREATEST PRIME MINISTERS OF INDIA. AN ECONOMIST , FORMER GOVERNER OF RESERVE BANK OF INDIA . A MAN OF PATIENCE , ENCYCLOPAEDIC KNOWLEDGE AND A GOOD FRIEND OF RAGHURAM RAJAN FORMER RBI GOVERNER AND AN ECONOMIST. BUT NOT MUCH SPOKEN FOR HUS GREATNESS SINCE HE NEVER BLEW HIS OWN TRUMPET AND WAS CONCENTRATING ON DEVELOPMENT OF COUNTRY. RAREST OF THE RARE.
RIP sir...we need an educated prime minister like you who can understand the problems of middle class families & who can save the families from looting of Modi & Sitaraman.
India's Top level scams of all time happended when Singh Saab was PM. Sad but it's true. He was an intelligent person indeed. But he was Puppet used by Antonio Mailo and "Rahul Rajiv Feroz Khan"
Educated, cultured and respectful leaders we have had both in the ruling and oppostion over a long period of time. The difference of opinion was conveyed so respectfully with a touch of humor with no personal abuse.
My goodness what a way to read poetry in no time superb video as am watching from pakistan it's more pleasure for me that both honourable members not in world now know finest urdu as both had read some lines of it for Manmohan Singh I can understand he was born here in chkwal had preliminary schooling here but to my surprise samsha had good command at urdu well god bless them
Interchange of high class from well learned Parlimentarians 👏👏👏 But the funniest part of the clip is The Congress President clapping vigorously as if she understood the exchange 😝😝😝
Night and day difference in today's parliament
Tomorrow will be more dangerous
There is no difference, they were making fun of the hopes and work of the people in the parliament. Earlier they used to sing poetry, now they abuse each other. Instead of making policies and doing some important work. They were wasting time of the whole 130 crores people who have selected and sent them to parliament
Right because the opposition is crap now
@@PastEventsTV Opposition is not crap but the government is trash of crap. They never answers the questions asked and if they do so they lie blatantly.
@@PastEventsTVopposition? the leader of opposition was thrown out parliament if congress would have done BJP would not had even born
....... RESPECT!!....When parliamentary discussion was not only decent but also effective.
Compare kar lo se aaj se..jab lop gandhi family h jinka main motive hota h parliament ko band karo..😂😂
@aniketarya5253 It was good previously because one party was smart and knew its duty. Manmohan Singh congress.
Now your Modi BJP is so shmless it takes no responsibility, no duties and just blame others.
Monitors duty is to keep class quite and if not take the asked topic to discussion. But BJP is so coward that it can't even talk about those topics an so they chose to stop discussion and blame others.
Monitor itself has no will to answer the question but to stop the sessions.
becoz bjp was in opps and it let the ruling party to speak
@@aniketarya5253feku❤ tadipaar❤ jumla❤ anpadh raja❤ WhatsApp university ❤ camerjeevi❤
Ghonchu
Congress parliament me faltu hungame karti hai@@comichero853
Such sophistication, love and respect at both ends.
Felt the same :)
Sahi hai..
Muslims are ungrateful towards indians ans indian culture but this is the only country of peace
Rest of tht world,. Muslims are killing Muslims.
Go to Pakistan your real country. This has no place for people like you who are ungrateful invaders. As a Muslim you are only an invader parasite
Ye possible tha kyunki bjp oppostion m thi..
People insulted him for his mannerisms but he was just old! He was still extremely intelligent
And also shook hands with freedom fighter Yaseen malik
@@Mirrorlash😂
@@Mirrorlash modi sarkar taliban se sambandh bana rahi hain wo kya hain
@@Mirrorlashwhen modi formed Govt with Mehboob mufti ,where were u ,Licking shit of that feku
@@Mirrorlashwhat happened to the one caught with 3000kg of RDX? What happened with the IPS who was giving safe pass to the terrorists into India l. Both happened during bjpee regime u motherflower.
Sushmaji's smile when he started his Sher... Just love it.. she went from super angry to just admiration.
Add her dear friend
Sir had one of the greatest mic drop moment in history of parliament ❤😂
Actually his shayari made no sense as her reply.
Tera iq km hai😂
Wo bol rha hain ki time do mereko main kaam krta hu😅@@mr.history1605
@@mr.history1605You really need to pay more attention to language classes now.
@@DataCrusade1999 tu samjha Dena , agar teko aya hai to
@@mr.history1605 No. You're talking as if you're paying me. Go learn otherwise F-OFF
There was a time when educated, wise and polite persons belong to the parliament both in Ruling and Opposition parties...
THEN HOW DID AN UNPAD ITALIAN BECOME SUPER PM THE SAME TIME?
@@SECULARBADWAhave same respect idiot. She is an Indian citizens.
education does not define the sophistication or behavior of a person, the super educated MPs of Congress resort to yelling and howling more often than the supposed "uneducated" Ruling party leaders
The same way an uneducated thief is ruling over slaves like you.@@SECULARBADWA
@@SECULARBADWAstill that italian part of our parliament,what about ur umpaid mother? Is she achv anything? Or busy in producing bhadwa like u?
Rip both true nationalist leader Smt. Sushma Swaraj ji and Dr. Manmohan Singh ji
Sorry mate, only one. Other used to just tell lies. Now you tell me, who is who.
@@zeeshana4444 सिंह साहब शेर थे सुषमा कभी उनके आसपास भी नहीं आ सकती।
@@zeeshana4444 Only the katwas canhave such views
Singh is king 👑. I love manmohan singh ❤❤@@zeeshana4444
The way Late Sushmaji said that shayri, suits to the current government.
Bro late manmohan Singh ji
Perfect...
Currency & Corruption at it Best
But the reply by late PM was much more excellent.
@@vinodurs2942in current situation the speaker om birla would have cut mic in order to safe his supreme leader.
@@MAKRAM-sw5uv ONE SUPER PM WAS HIDING INSIDE HOSPITAL TO SAVE HERSELF ONLY RECENTLY 🤣🤣🤣
The way Sushma jee smiled 😊😊
This is the power of Urdu language bring opposing party together with smile
Gone are the days PM subjected to questions.
Why worry? Kapoors and Akshay Kumar can ask Modi questions about mangoes and music. Not questions fit for the position of a PM but questions nonetheless. After all, aren't we curious if non-biological beings also have earthly interests?
@@Komorebineeded😂😂
So modi jo do not answer now? Watch his lectures
@@KomorebineededSTILL DRUG ADDICT PAPPU NEED A RELAUNCH EVERY FORTNIGHT 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Yeah gone are such intelligent leaders. That's why only nuisance in parliament by opposition
Compare this to the gaali galoch these days.
Kyuki tab do gujju nahi the parliament me😂😂😂
@@harrypotter12r44ek Shahabzaade bhi nahi the
@@harrypotter12r44GUJJU NE HI TERA ITALIAN SUPER PM KO MAAR BHAGAYA HAI
Because aaj congress opposition m h...or main motive hota h parliament ko band karwana.
@@aniketarya5253kui ki samne government aaj bhi blame game khelti
Few sensible words have more power than yelling lies
This level of decency in politics is not even known to today's generation.. Irrespective of the fact whether one supports him or not .Respect for this man is unquestionable..!!❤
@@ChandrabhalRoy What decency?
Whole opposition was jailed and word secularism was forcefully inserted in to the constitution
Maybe that's decency according to you
Today under modi regime even urdu language considered as anti national 😄
What else can be expected from illiterates? Under the Brits all Indian languages were marginalized. Today the Modi regime has taken the mantle to discredit all languages except Hindi.
😂😂😂
Urdu IS anti-national. Just because they used it in the past does not absolve it.
Baat to sach hai magar Baat hai ruswai ki 😢
@tariqshafi6745 Bhai - jaahil logon se kaisi ruswai? Jo log zuban ko dharam aur deen mein baant dete Hain, un ko sun kar unsuna karna behtar hota hai.
these were self made individuals and had respect for each other, those born with silver spoon thnk they shuld be given power as birth right and mistreat others
Back when Ruling and opposition used to have respect for each other and healthy politics was practiced in the parliament .
With due respect, us samay har samay gali nhi dete the pm ko opposition wale ... Seedhe maut ka saudagar, evil dictator ye sab nhi bolte rehte the... Yar ab socho... Modi government sirf 8 ammendment kiya hai usme bhi sabme congress ka bhi sehmati tha... Fir bhi ye log ilzaam lagate hai samvidhan badalne ka... Batao kab tak respectful behave karta modi aise logo ke sath... Atal ji seh gaye the par har koi utna nhi sehta (aur sehna chahiye bhi nhi)
Wah kitny wzadaar log thy. Sushma g brother studied with ex Pakistan foreign minister Sartaj aziz in Lahore and she met with him like a sister. Look at her smile. Manmohan g from Chakwal and what a nice n humble person ❤true gems respect from Pakistan ❤
ऐसे महान इंसान सदियों में देश को मिलते हैं।
अलविदा डॉक्टर साहब
Very gentle and polite PM I have ever seen! RIP the master of Economics
Two legendary icons, nothing but respect.
So much love from Pakistan 🇵🇰 for those two legends
Why love from Pakistan? May you are mahajir.
@@madzidle bhai urdu Shairi sun kr keh rahe hein hum. We pakistanis love a Good Urdu Shairi battle. It puts smile on our faces.
What a great, soft spoken and humble person he was. Brought India to economic road.
We lost the most educated PM to least one. Shame
@@AmritZoad MOST EDUCATED PM WAS CHAPPRASSI TO ITALIAN ANPAD SUPER PM
Educated PM who looted the nation.
And both were equally as bad
Time when Nation had Sikh as a Prime minister and president as a Muslim " phir bhi Hindu khatre m nahi tha par aaj Hindutva ki sarkar hone k baad b Hindu khatre m h...." What a joke
SIKH PM OR PUPPET PM?
@SECULARBADWA bhai nafrat mei kya rakha hai
@@DavinderKaur-go5wi Sacchai kaise nafrat ho gayi ?
@@SECULARBADWA .. Just shut up .. Dont insult the dead people atleast..
😂😂😂😂😂😂 hindu khatre me hai😅
Manmohan ji presented Budget with so many anecdotes and shyari that he made the difficult issues across the opposition easily
When that silent kid of the class starts to speak its over for everyone
Wonder when the parliament was filled with such great parliamentary speeches and wisdom.. Mela loot liya Manmohan sir ne.....❤❤❤❤
How cute, adorable and awe-inspiring 😂😢
Two legends are in temple of democracy.❤
When a gentleman used to speak zero and acted max. RIP Dr Sahab 🙏🙏🙏😭😭😭😭
Respect for both leaders, sitting in opposition,the way of communication truly shows how educated they are, and Madam Sushma smile is wonderful…
Two great leaders.how respectful and graceful
I thinks this was last time I saw sensible and educated pm and opposition leader🎉🎉😢
Abe madarse me padhne walo tum Dharti chapti batate ho aur education ki bat karte ho😂
@VansNarayan Abe penis aur bandar ki pooja karne waalo yeh tumhare bas ki baat nahi 😄😄😄😃🤣🤣🤣
Abe sangh me jaane wale. Tu skirt khud pehenta hai or dusro ko moral policing karta hai chomu. Whatsapp chaap.
@@VansNarayanSahi bola, yeh lodu ki kopdi mein sirf aur sirf aathanki bara rehta hein 🎉
@@VansNarayan Hate monger haha
Look at that smile on sushma ji❤😊
Wonderful maturity to communicate the issues with sensitivity
What a thorough gentleman…I miss these days of Indian parliament…Now it’s a circus !
This is poetry of Allama Iqbal (R A)❤❤❤
Bohat umda ❤❤...what people they were 👏🙌
Sweetness of Urdu language and Urdu peots.
People said that he was a silent prime minister, but he was the last prime minister to do press conference.
Om shanti
To be honest I am lucky that in my childhood I saw LOK SABHA channel, where I watched Legends, Sushma Swaraj ji, Atal Bihari Vajpayee ji, Manmohan Singh ji, ❤ That time when each one was respected, yes we have negatives in every time, but that time was a true democracy ❤
Good old days when parliament used to be parliament, not history class like now a days...
A correction:
PSEUDO-HISTORY class! 😅
Gone the days when the prime Minister used to shake hands with terrorists like yaseen malik
When legends sit in their deserved place! Even Parliament becomes heaven ♥️
I pray to god both Manmohan Sir and ma'am should take rebirth as they were in this life and continue to serve the nation as they were doing.
Om nama shivaya
These were actual leaders, politicians without having any grudges against their opposition... Past golden era.. That finished in 2014
❤❤❤❤Om shanti❤❤❤❤❤❤
Wah wah wah
Waaaaah Urdu❤❤❤❤❤❤
Love you Doctor saahab.. we truly miss you😢
BOLE TOH KYA BOLE WAH MAZZA AA GYA 👏😔 aankhir lajawab kr diya 💯 % YE AAP HI THAY 👏😔 aap JESA KOI NHI KOI NHI 🙏🇮🇳😣♥️💐💐💐😥💔
One of the GREATEST PRIME MINISTERS OF INDIA. AN ECONOMIST , FORMER GOVERNER OF RESERVE BANK OF INDIA . A MAN OF PATIENCE , ENCYCLOPAEDIC KNOWLEDGE AND A GOOD FRIEND OF RAGHURAM RAJAN FORMER RBI GOVERNER AND AN ECONOMIST. BUT NOT MUCH SPOKEN FOR HUS GREATNESS SINCE HE NEVER BLEW HIS OWN TRUMPET AND WAS CONCENTRATING ON DEVELOPMENT OF COUNTRY. RAREST OF THE RARE.
When Parliament wasn't toxic
Sri manmohan singh ji is an apt person whose pic should be on our currency...
Ohh bhyiiii😂😂😂😂😂
0:37 "teri rehbari ka "sawal" hy",baqi sher zabardast kaha
Wow, amazing, indeed, amazing!!!
Love from Pakistan Lahore 🇵🇰
When the silent and introvert speaks...everybody listens and appreciates.
These intellectuals..yes that was an era❤
1:00
مانا کہ تیری دید کے قابل نہیں ہوں میں
تو میرا شوق دیکھ، میرا انتظار دیکھ ❤
Ati sundar. Bahut khoob
This episode of question and answer in our parliament will be a history, always memorable and an example of decency down the generations.
RIP
RIP sir...we need an educated prime minister like you who can understand the problems of middle class families & who can save the families from looting of Modi & Sitaraman.
Why? To encourage rampant corruption forever? 😂
India's Top level scams of all time happended when Singh Saab was PM.
Sad but it's true. He was an intelligent person indeed. But he was Puppet used by Antonio Mailo and "Rahul Rajiv Feroz Khan"
Very trie
No to stop legalizing corruption.
@@shrini04modi government is the most corrupt government
So much said in so few words, such a good environment, credit to both Government and opposition of that time
Miss those days when democracy was practiced in spirit not only just books!!
What Respect
Such a gentleman ❤❤
Educated, cultured and respectful leaders we have had both in the ruling and oppostion over a long period of time. The difference of opinion was conveyed so respectfully with a touch of humor with no personal abuse.
Please upload the full video bhai ❤❤❤😊😊
Urdu is beautiful language ❤
All I can say is respect 🙏 history will judge you kindly, great stalwart of India. ❤
Calm poise class ... this is how a PM should be . Respect 🙏
Waaaaaah waaaaaaaaaaaaaah what a reply waaaaaaaaaaah.....sir you are a very intelligent man ....waaah
*TWO GEM POLITICIANS. OM SHANTI* 😢
Leaders with communication skills, wittiest and patience are valued by public and emulated by the young upcoming leaders
My goodness what a way to read poetry in no time superb video as am watching from pakistan it's more pleasure for me that both honourable members not in world now know finest urdu as both had read some lines of it for Manmohan Singh I can understand he was born here in chkwal had preliminary schooling here but to my surprise samsha had good command at urdu well god bless them
Thanks for liking comment
Look at the respect and discipline. Amazing.
So beautifully expressed by our PM
Why I'm watching agn n again
Real man🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
What a terrific answer for response
Wah wah sir ji tusi great ho👍
Awesome, absolutely amazing, and out of this World. 😂
Interchange of high class from well learned Parlimentarians 👏👏👏
But the funniest part of the clip is The Congress President clapping vigorously as if she understood the exchange 😝😝😝
Genius with a literary sense
Really aced
Thank you for reminding us on how the parliament is supposed to go..
Class 👌
Back then when PM talked about kaam ki baat not mann ki bakwas
It's up to you .not for majority who voted him .
Respect to this legend ❤
Woooh
History is much much kinder than he ever imagined himself
As a Pakistani, I truly respected this man and what he's done for India & regional peace ❤
Rest in Peace sir 🙏
It takes two to tango ...you certainly dont hear the opposition howling above his voice.
Respect for both from Pakistan. Such dignified people.
Great❤❤❤
Those days😢😢❤❤
Dr. Saheb ko pahli baar muskurate hue dekha... Love ❤❤
two great personalities,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,one as a politician and other as a FM.
Goes to show how rich Urdu language is
Yes doctor saab hamne intazaar kiya aur apne karke dikhaya.......