When Shelby asked to see 'her', she was seeing who they would think she wanted to see. Like how would they know she wanted to see Toni when they weren't on the island? How would they know they're together, except if there were cameras. If you know what I'm saying. I didn't get this at first either, until somebody told me. Shelby is sooo smart.
That's why shelby doesn't lash out. Last time she did lash out, her friend commited suicide. Becca was already in a dark place. Shelby blames herself, she did push becca to that point but she already in a dark place. Shelby story broke me
I always took the whole him saying that she could get her teeth fixed as him saying that she should work to fix her sexuality. Cause before he said god only made beautiful, he said it to tell Shelby that her teeth didn’t make her any less perfect, but once he found out that god had made her into something that he didn’t think was beautiful, he was like, “it doesn’t matter how much it hurts to fix it, we have to fix it.” Which is sort of a metaphor for conversion therapy. This is why Shelby was upset after he said this, but she was hiding it under a fake smile.
I can’t relate to everything Shelby goes through but I know too much of most of those feelings. I’ve been having problems with my feelings for other girls and I’m a Christian so I can’t you know. In fact when I first figured out what I was feeling I was terrified of rejection of judgment and of being ostracized. Now I believe as Christians we are supposed to love everyone no matter what they do, we should love the person not their choices. But many people won’t see it that way. I also struggle with perfectionism and having to be perfect or I’m a failure and no one will love me. So when I started to have these feelings, I was scared and felt awful. But now everyday I still struggle with it all but I have to remind myself God loves us no matter what we do, and he always will
Did you notice that we never learn the reason why Shelby is on this trip in the first place? Her father says that the plan for the summer is to fix her teeth (which obviously didn't happen) and not to send her on some girly vacation (which is weird anyway, given her "situation"). So something must have happened that the actual plan failed and she was sent there. I'm curious if we'll find out in season 2. Well, except Shelby's parents were told that this trip is something like conversion therapy. Then it would actually make sense and her teeth were really the metaphor for it in this scene.
the way I grinned all the way through you talking about the guess who. if that isn't the most iconic thing I've seen all week I honestly don't know what is. ok yes I also couldn't stop smiling for most of the rest of the video
UHHHHHH ALICE??? I would straight up love to see your whole board of sapphic Guess Who & am genuinely about to spend 18 hours (physical art's not my strong suit hahahahahaha) making something similar of my own but to be honest, Imma have to include at LEAST your first row of characters - iconic.
@@AliceLinehan i was on Instagram and someone said that it’s kind of to say how his character is. Like they said it means that he’s willing to throw away the whole thing because he didn’t like a part of it. But that’s just what the person who said it feels like it could mean.
02:40 - 02:46 *Regular Toni:* 🤬💢 *In Love Tony:* 🥺💖 02:55 - 03:00 😱 #Shelbald Also...I didn't remember she was limping.😲I wonder what happened to her! 05:14 I just noticed there are *3* crosses behind the kids O___O __05:21__ and _another one_ on that door!!How many fucking crosses do you need,man?Are you a vampire slayer?!?X-PP Also... 05:18 - 05:20 because that's what it is.😡💢 12:40 I'm probably dumb,but if it wasn't for the trigger warning at the beginning of the episode I would have never guessed Becca had killed herself. I'm gonna say this just once and I'm gonna keep it cool and simple:I *HATE* Shelby's father.🤬💢And no,he has *no* good intentions at all! 14:12 - 14:17 This.😢💔 15:55 - 16:00 Same thing I thought!😵
XD I love your custom guess who. I couldnt make out the backrow though. Do you have a better pic of it on your instagram? Also, Im loving your reactions to all shows on your channel! :)
the thing with shelby and her backstory is when her dad tells her he doesnt want her to be alone and that whole scene, i dont agree with what hes saying whatsoever but that was the nicest possible way he rly could have put it. and yet shelby freaked on becca calling her oversexual and other things that were just so horrible. and even till the end becca was so nice to shelby even after all she said and shelby just walked off anyway. bit weird
Her dad saying he didn't want her to be alone was because he couldn't accept her being in a relationship with another girl. Shelby freaked on Becca because she was freaking out about herself and her home life, and her dad's judgment of her.
When Shelby asked to see 'her', she was seeing who they would think she wanted to see. Like how would they know she wanted to see Toni when they weren't on the island? How would they know they're together, except if there were cameras. If you know what I'm saying.
I didn't get this at first either, until somebody told me. Shelby is sooo smart.
Yeah exactly, it was a test :)) I also think the allergic reaction was planned for Leah to escape, I'm so excited for season 2!
Ooooo I hadn't thought about that at all, that's such a Leah train of thought to have in the most Shelby way possible!! If that makes sense hahahahaha
Ohh I got confused cuz who did Shelby mean by when she said she was going back to “her” when she was talking to Toni on the island?
@@Retroworld-lk8so She was talking about the 'her' she was before the island saga happened :)
@@kiomi8659 OHH thank you sm :)
That's why shelby doesn't lash out. Last time she did lash out, her friend commited suicide. Becca was already in a dark place. Shelby blames herself, she did push becca to that point but she already in a dark place. Shelby story broke me
I always took the whole him saying that she could get her teeth fixed as him saying that she should work to fix her sexuality. Cause before he said god only made beautiful, he said it to tell Shelby that her teeth didn’t make her any less perfect, but once he found out that god had made her into something that he didn’t think was beautiful, he was like, “it doesn’t matter how much it hurts to fix it, we have to fix it.” Which is sort of a metaphor for conversion therapy. This is why Shelby was upset after he said this, but she was hiding it under a fake smile.
“shelby was upset but hiding it under a fake smile” she def seems to do that a lot
This seems really correct. Also it's super dangerous if you've not completely matured, so it's definitely also a punishment
@@georgeurmomtho I'm pretty sure that could sum up her entire character
I always took it as a metaphor and that the dad was sending Shelby to conversion therapy
That's exactly what he meant by a "summer camp"
"shark week for Rachel" LMAOO
“Are they both going to just be sitting diagonally?”💀
"Jesus she's trashed." Notice that Toni isn't laughing about it, she's super concerned about Shelby's well being.
I really really appreciate the gayness on that guess who board. My heart just melted on the fact that I know almost everyone. 🥰
Also Shelbald
hahahahahaha
your reactions to the wilds honestly make me so happy 😍
thank you xx
Please remember to keep the comments spoiler free guys!
Hate that it is almost over. Have been loving your reactions.
I can’t relate to everything Shelby goes through but I know too much of most of those feelings. I’ve been having problems with my feelings for other girls and I’m a Christian so I can’t you know. In fact when I first figured out what I was feeling I was terrified of rejection of judgment and of being ostracized. Now I believe as Christians we are supposed to love everyone no matter what they do, we should love the person not their choices. But many people won’t see it that way. I also struggle with perfectionism and having to be perfect or I’m a failure and no one will love me. So when I started to have these feelings, I was scared and felt awful. But now everyday I still struggle with it all but I have to remind myself God loves us no matter what we do, and he always will
Did you notice that we never learn the reason why Shelby is on this trip in the first place?
Her father says that the plan for the summer is to fix her teeth (which obviously didn't happen) and not to send her on some girly vacation (which is weird anyway, given her "situation").
So something must have happened that the actual plan failed and she was sent there. I'm curious if we'll find out in season 2.
Well, except Shelby's parents were told that this trip is something like conversion therapy. Then it would actually make sense and her teeth were really the metaphor for it in this scene.
Since we know that Gretchen is a big fat liar, it is entirely possible she told Shelby's dad that it was a gay conversion camp.
the way I grinned all the way through you talking about the guess who. if that isn't the most iconic thing I've seen all week I honestly don't know what is.
ok yes I also couldn't stop smiling for most of the rest of the video
i think that was the best episode but the next one **chef's kiss**
Dot IS the unsung hero. Say that!
that guess who board is a thing of beauty
UHHHHHH ALICE??? I would straight up love to see your whole board of sapphic Guess Who & am genuinely about to spend 18 hours (physical art's not my strong suit hahahahahaha) making something similar of my own but to be honest, Imma have to include at LEAST your first row of characters - iconic.
do itttttt
This episode is heartbreaking :(
Thumbs up for King Princess on your guess who board.
5:21 Why the booooowl ?
I know that's suspect behaviour
@@AliceLinehan i was on Instagram and someone said that it’s kind of to say how his character is. Like they said it means that he’s willing to throw away the whole thing because he didn’t like a part of it. But that’s just what the person who said it feels like it could mean.
Shelbald🥰🤩😀
We’re closeeeeeeee I can’t wait for you to see the other two your gonna be shocked
been waiting all week for this ahhhh
FUCK the vine in between I screamed
02:40 - 02:46 *Regular Toni:* 🤬💢 *In Love Tony:* 🥺💖
02:55 - 03:00 😱 #Shelbald Also...I didn't remember she was limping.😲I wonder what happened to her!
05:14 I just noticed there are *3* crosses behind the kids O___O __05:21__ and _another one_ on that door!!How many fucking crosses do you need,man?Are you a vampire slayer?!?X-PP Also... 05:18 - 05:20 because that's what it is.😡💢
12:40 I'm probably dumb,but if it wasn't for the trigger warning at the beginning of the episode I would have never guessed Becca had killed herself.
I'm gonna say this just once and I'm gonna keep it cool and simple:I *HATE* Shelby's father.🤬💢And no,he has *no* good intentions at all!
14:12 - 14:17 This.😢💔
15:55 - 16:00 Same thing I thought!😵
god i love shelbald not more than leah/sarah but shelbald is amazing
your vids r so good!!! i super enjoy watching your reactions. also love the guess who :-)
oh shit is what I said after Becca and Shelbys kiss
XD I love your custom guess who. I couldnt make out the backrow though. Do you have a better pic of it on your instagram? Also, Im loving your reactions to all shows on your channel! :)
yaaaaaassss
Hey have you seen legacies?
Love ur vids
thank you x
@@AliceLinehan omg
the thing with shelby and her backstory is when her dad tells her he doesnt want her to be alone and that whole scene, i dont agree with what hes saying whatsoever but that was the nicest possible way he rly could have put it. and yet shelby freaked on becca calling her oversexual and other things that were just so horrible. and even till the end becca was so nice to shelby even after all she said and shelby just walked off anyway. bit weird
When Shelby's father said:"I don't want you to be alone."I replied:"Then *don't-fucking-leave her-alone* you bigot homophobic asshole!🤬💢"
Her dad saying he didn't want her to be alone was because he couldn't accept her being in a relationship with another girl. Shelby freaked on Becca because she was freaking out about herself and her home life, and her dad's judgment of her.
Hello first