His & Her Circumstances/Kare Kano | Review and Analysis

แชร์
ฝัง
  • เผยแพร่เมื่อ 28 พ.ย. 2024

ความคิดเห็น • 77

  • @ginnylin
    @ginnylin 5 ปีที่แล้ว +51

    They have done a Fruits Basket remake. This manga deserves a better remake. I wish we could crowd fund it. It was a really amazingly written manga wish superb but realistic characters. Everyone was so flawed and relatable. I read it at a time when I was about the same age as Arima and Miyazawa so I could really relate to the angst. Even now, I think I think I can relate to the adults and their poor decisions in the story. I just read through some of the KareKano manga today because I was watching the new Fruits Basket. Fingers crossed for a remake...

    • @tanjiroukamado5766
      @tanjiroukamado5766 4 ปีที่แล้ว +4

      I remake would be amazing. Kare Kano had very creative visual shots and storytelling even thought the animation was iffy at times -- expected of Hideaki Anno's directing work. I want to see Arima falling for Miyazawa again.

  • @SeaCow1g
    @SeaCow1g 6 ปีที่แล้ว +135

    The first 18 episodes of Kare Kano is still the best romance anime ever made.

    • @heavymetal1ization
      @heavymetal1ization 5 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Giotis Filopanos yup

    • @burrito_san
      @burrito_san 4 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Yep

    • @tanjiroukamado5766
      @tanjiroukamado5766 4 ปีที่แล้ว +8

      I watched it a couple of years ago when I was still in grade school...now I'm in college, I just rewatched it 2 days ago and holy fuck now I remember how intense the storyline was. I read the manga and it gets DARK, really really DARK. Still one of the best and most realistic romance anime of all time.

    • @everythingwillbe6904
      @everythingwillbe6904 4 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@tanjiroukamado5766 What happened in the manga. I want spoilers so it's ok

    • @arrianneallado574
      @arrianneallado574 3 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Can you share where can I read free manga version of this anime?

  • @analogaudiorules1724
    @analogaudiorules1724 3 ปีที่แล้ว +17

    What i really liked about it was not only the humor, or how well the characters were written, but also the fact that it used cell hand drawn animation, that just looks far better then digital animation that is typically aided by cgi these days, to me it just lacks character when compared and is far to sterile, i like seeing those little mistakes, or the cells moving scene by scene, even the washed out colors, they need to make shows with hand drawn animation again, it is just more pleasing to the eyes even dispite every now and again seeing little defects, it just shows an actual human being worked on the damn thing, it seems more expressive, even if it is limiting in some ways, it only makes people more creative. The art style besides how it was created is great as well in general, the character design was pretty badass.

    • @Sparkys_World-0
      @Sparkys_World-0  3 ปีที่แล้ว +6

      Couldn't agree more. Its probably the most visually engrossing romcom ever made.

    • @anigatari8753
      @anigatari8753 3 ปีที่แล้ว

      Well, if you asked any animator that animated the characters by hand, they rather use current CGI-aided animation technic than hand drawn animation, because animation by hand is tiresome.

  • @WalkingGirlKoi
    @WalkingGirlKoi 8 ปีที่แล้ว +41

    This is still one of the best shoujo anime I have seen... Until the end, really. I can overlook this, though, due to the realistic writing of the main characters and even some of the minor ones. It's a real shame that Masami Tsuda thought the focus on comedy was simply too much, which I highly disagree with. While some scenes were exaggerated (the episode where Tsubasa kicks a car into the air), but I feel that it helped the story progress during the more slice of life movements.

  • @despiera
    @despiera 7 ปีที่แล้ว +115

    This show needs a remake. Badly.

    • @theAraAra
      @theAraAra 7 ปีที่แล้ว +15

      Yes. Some part of me wishes Anno went to remake Kare Kano instead of making Eva movies. NGE was great as it was; whatever flaws it had. But Kare Kano never got a movie that tied up loose ends (like End of Evangelion did for NGE)

    • @ALocalClown
      @ALocalClown 6 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      Yeah, I'd rather a second arc/sequel movie than a remake. No point tossing all that character development away.

    • @MarkQuick0411
      @MarkQuick0411 6 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Manga ended really satisfying though

    • @MarkQuick0411
      @MarkQuick0411 6 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Also episode 18 ohhhhh so dorable made me cry
      Also best parts are when the emotions are genuine to the point that it made me blush

    • @user-nu2vc9mp5j
      @user-nu2vc9mp5j 5 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      @@theAraAra why remake, the orignal was fine they need to finish it. but the author of kare kano had different views from ano thus it was stopped

  • @Trixiethegoldenwitch
    @Trixiethegoldenwitch 9 ปีที่แล้ว +75

    Hehe yup... this is exactly how a first-time viewing of the show seems to go. I wrote a nearly identical (though far less detailed) review the first time I watched it back in '08. The last stretch of episodes is truly disappointing...
    at least, the first time. After 7 years to get over the initial shock, I rewatched the show. I skipped all the recap scenes, and then I got to the last 8 expecting the worst... but it wasn't really *bad.* Like, if you think of the show as ending in ep 18 (which would have been pretty satisfying of an ending), and then think of the rest as like an omake, then it's not so bad. I think those episodes are only annoying because 1. they're like half the speed of pacing compared to the rest of the show, and 2. the lack of conclusion. The actual plot points raised aren't bad though, and the characters are still great. I've seen much, much worse from final arcs... see the 12-episode filler arc of Nadia which completely ruins the characters to the point that the amazing ending doesn't even have impact anymore.

    • @Sparkys_World-0
      @Sparkys_World-0  9 ปีที่แล้ว +8

      Yeah, I feel like it definitely would have stung less if I saw it coming. It just sucked that the very moment I really started loving this show was when it turned on me. Also realising that Tsubasa's step family was never gonna be brought up again was the most frustrating thing, so watching them waste episodes on anime-original stories about stalkers was particularly infuriating

    • @napsylev6922
      @napsylev6922 9 ปีที่แล้ว

      I'm only 12 episodes in, I got hyped because Digi kept hyping it up, I've been on a down low in terms of anime lately, ever since watch 70 since Christmas. I'll finish it eventually and probably enjoy it more with my expectations set.
      Great vid dude.

    • @joemuis23
      @joemuis23 8 ปีที่แล้ว

      +Subsonic Sparkle what song did you use at 8:26?

    • @Sparkys_World-0
      @Sparkys_World-0  8 ปีที่แล้ว +3

      Ramen King by Pink Guy

    • @aii5748
      @aii5748 7 ปีที่แล้ว

      most shoujo manga inspired series are like this (sadly). whenever you start one get ready to switch to the manga. ao haru ride is a good example of this

  • @Cosmic92929
    @Cosmic92929 7 ปีที่แล้ว +16

    I loved the anime but the ending was just 😩

    • @MarkQuick0411
      @MarkQuick0411 6 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      Robert Villarreal
      After Episode 18 its Finished
      And then I had to read the manga
      The later arcs in the manga get surprisingly emotionally intense then the show ever was and it tugs and rips at the heart strings I almost died

  • @HANI-wo1be
    @HANI-wo1be 4 ปีที่แล้ว +8

    If there are anyone who wants to continue by reading manga, start from book 7.

  • @tauhidershadKUFNAFLORAN
    @tauhidershadKUFNAFLORAN ปีที่แล้ว +4

    Kare Kano: A tale where a girl and a boy fall in love with each other, but also they heal each other's trauma and shortcomings. The girl does more in this part. SPOILER(It can be found in Wiki): Before they get married because of a shock pregnancy from Yukino, Arima finally resolves his parental issues with his own biological parents. Sadly the anime ended SUPER ABRUPTLY, because the director didn't want to do it anymore.

  • @ashthedood9169
    @ashthedood9169 9 ปีที่แล้ว +4

    Glad I went here after Ninouhs stream, inconsistent voice over & video editing aside you're going for a detailed non-consumer type review style. We need more of this in a search engine full of samey reviewers.
    [EDIT] Also yeaaaaah His & Hers is my favourite romcom of ever in anything. I do agree with your point about this reaffirmation of what the characters are feeling being a bit too heavy, I forgot how much they did it even in comparison to EVA on my recent re-watch.

  • @brokensnatched2094
    @brokensnatched2094 6 ปีที่แล้ว +3

    I wish the series was complete I mean man this was the first and only anime I have watched

  • @shayoko6
    @shayoko6 9 ปีที่แล้ว +15

    *General*
    What i love about this show is that it did not rely on fan service at all to get attention.
    but focus on romance and characters.that said i do wish that it ended quicker...
    being that it is a romance show dragging it out is pointless.even more so when the main goal of the series
    is achieved early on.
    but if i were to pick the part i disliked the least about it. is that this is another one of those shows that
    deny the right for a female to be a strong character...Yukino starts impressive able to be at the top of pretty much everything she puts her mind to...but as it goes on her emotions toward Soichiro seem to make her...lose confidence in her ability to do
    some things...like in ep 17 when she says "even i can make him happy" what the hell is this? that line means that she has no
    self confidence which is bullshit :/ where is the girl who knew she could get what she wanted though hard work!?
    *overall*
    This had potential to be great they fucked it up really bad...it should of ended earlier and had closure...
    *notes*
    i have heard the manga is better then the anime. it has 102 chapters (completed)
    apparently the director focused more on comedy then the original source had and the author was upset so no second season/
    *whats wrong with this anime?*
    *ep7*
    the teachers getting involved in students personal lifes
    the teachers calling there parents
    the teachers saying there grades are not not enough despite being ranked 13 and 3 >.>
    the teachers acting like school is more important then connecting with people
    *ep9*
    the random bitch girl that starts shit
    the mob of girls who are jealous
    Yukino shes her boyfriend patting the head of another girl and is insecure (she seriously cant trust him?
    despite not having a single dam reason to distrust people?)
    why is a middle school girl in high school? (Tsubasa)
    *Ep12-13*
    tsubasa is being a spoiled brat...are all Japanese teens like this? no not even she is first year in high school...
    so she is fucking 15 years old acting like this! its unreal!
    *ep14-15*
    recap episodes (the second half of 15 finally goes back to the story
    *ep16*
    Yukino's dad was having sexual thoughts of her...
    Yukino's dad was rubbing Kano (youngest daughters) ass...
    *ep17*
    Yukino....has fallen so much since the start...now she cant even talk properly...and runs away to avoid problems...
    the awesome girl during the earlier stages of the show is gone and replaced with a worthless coward. who has no confidence
    in herself...she keeps regressing as a character and its really painful to see....
    even tho it makes no sense at all Yukino was worried that Soichiro wouldn't accept her feelings...
    she already should of been aware that he loved her a LONG time ago...
    *ep18*
    the mindset that a child should be blamed for thier parents mistakes...
    that wasn't a kiss! hat was sucking face!
    hats don't fly!
    the shows not over even after they had sex...
    *e19*
    What in the name of all that is unholy!? this is some of the laziest animation ever.
    were talking like manga style or lower at times! the art for this episode is horrendous for a anime!
    *e20* (back to normal)
    a fat white chibi turned into a skinny dark guy with a deep voice!?
    who loves Soichiro!?
    *ep23*
    Yukino got exited...over...kendo...?
    they only have a week to get everything for their play ready...they are all amateurs...so why the fuck are they wasting time and money on karoyoki...
    *ep24*
    is tsubasa...retarded?...she has the body of elementary schooler and the way she acts...she is supposed to be in high school...
    how the hell did she pass the exams?
    in whose head is the conversation between Yukino and Soichiro happening?...since its not really happening it makes no sense..nor can this actually develop the characters or anything...
    we have the ending credits around halfway thru the episode and have ANOTHER recap!?
    *ep25*
    the episode starts with a real recording of a road. looking down at it while moving forward pretty fast.
    that reaction to a stalker...what the actual fuck?
    i...i don't even know what the fuck is going on anymore...
    the 2 girls that were spying on kano when she met the girl...don't they have ANY SHAME!?
    *ep26*
    most of it is still pictures sometimes black and white others 1 color. there is some normal colored parts.
    this episode does not conclude the main couples issues (well the guys issues...)

    • @KpopStan2009
      @KpopStan2009 5 ปีที่แล้ว

      Akemi Homura There was this one episode (I don't Know which but it was near the last few of episodes) There was so much going on one time arima's double self is talking to him and there is much drama and then right after it goes to the girls having a funny conversation or something and then arima sees that guy in the hall, doesn't talk to him, drama then her sisters having a funny conversation then arima thinks by himself some weird sh*t that he doesn't want to lose her or something and then again classmates having a funny conversation and then the episode ended without ever explaining what happened and what that drama was about. I'm so confused over that episode what's going on... I don't know if I even put it in Chronological order, bc it's so confusing to remember those details, cuz those whole episodes in the end are all confusing.

  • @VashdaCrash
    @VashdaCrash 8 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    You got hit hard by the gainax ending haha
    Great video.

  • @gabriele.3161
    @gabriele.3161 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    I crashed a Kazuya Tsurumaki autograph event for him to sign my KareKano DVD. Now it’s my prized possession. It’s nice to revisit this video of yours bro, I trust you’re doing great and hope you’re always having fun !

    • @Sparkys_World-0
      @Sparkys_World-0  2 ปีที่แล้ว

      I haven’t rewatched this vid in years, I’m curious if it holds up. Currently working on my biggest video project ever; not about an anime but my favourite game. I hope you’ll look forward to it!

  • @adebayox4031
    @adebayox4031 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    Might watch this

  • @tinatruong6157
    @tinatruong6157 5 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    i love the manga over the anime ....b u t i t s m y o p i n i o n n n n n

  • @eroche12
    @eroche12 2 หลายเดือนก่อน

    And the music......

  • @TheBravePotato1
    @TheBravePotato1 ปีที่แล้ว

    Very interesting to see just how much of this info about the production of this anime being eventually proven false

  • @crono3015
    @crono3015 8 ปีที่แล้ว

    Well, shit. Knowing that the show is pretty much incomplete, does give me much reason to watch it. Oh well.

  • @violenciarivas7797
    @violenciarivas7797 7 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    I had to slow the video to understand :'v

  • @HamoodyDarbaDoody
    @HamoodyDarbaDoody 8 ปีที่แล้ว

    LMAO WTF near the end you used the beat to Fried Rice by Franku hahaha

  • @someguy7513
    @someguy7513 7 ปีที่แล้ว

    I read the manga and thought it was good

  • @mikecoolgreen
    @mikecoolgreen 6 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    Came straight to this video after watching kare kano, was really disappointed with being so invested to a story then for it to do a 180 to some neon genesis bullshit. Stuff like that draws me away from enjoying anything else besides those naughty scenes

  • @nallavan1522
    @nallavan1522 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    Is it happy or a sad ending??

  • @zacharythoennes5973
    @zacharythoennes5973 4 ปีที่แล้ว

    what is the music used at the beginning?

    • @Sparkys_World-0
      @Sparkys_World-0  4 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Palmtree Panic Past from Sonic CD!

  • @dafuq7569
    @dafuq7569 6 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    *sigh* at least I know why the show went down hill after episode 18

  • @Zistheone2
    @Zistheone2 5 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    This show kind of feels like Umaru if you replace the otaku elements with a love story plotline.

    • @JayAreAitch
      @JayAreAitch 3 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      This is the most shallow take I have ever seen

  • @user-nu2vc9mp5j
    @user-nu2vc9mp5j 5 ปีที่แล้ว

    show dont tell isnt common concept in japenese writings. as they prefer to detail explain their feelings and thoughts.

  • @arcueid9480
    @arcueid9480 3 ปีที่แล้ว

    Pls tell me the song at 1:36

    • @Sparkys_World-0
      @Sparkys_World-0  3 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      “Manuals” from Sonic Gems Collection.

    • @arcueid9480
      @arcueid9480 3 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@Sparkys_World-0 ty

  • @Razuri_Zeev
    @Razuri_Zeev 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    I just finished the series.
    It was love at first sight when I first watch it in muse asia.
    Weird that I love this old anime despite this all cool anime coming out. But it was a disappointment when I getting near to finish watching the series.
    The Ending sucks!
    I like the ending song but the last 3 episode was wasted. They should come to the conclusion. It pains me to love an anime and hurt at the end.

  • @heavymetal1ization
    @heavymetal1ization 5 ปีที่แล้ว

    I was so upset by how disappointing the ending was

  • @ngoclan28
    @ngoclan28 5 ปีที่แล้ว

    Phim tên tiếng việt là gì

  • @rawdasalmataman7908
    @rawdasalmataman7908 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    Yeah the finale was like not really a proper ending.
    I like all the characters they are all interesting but we don't get an ending that showed us how did everyone of them end up like .
    The ending was maybe the worst and maybe the only bad aspect I hate about the series the ending didn't show us a conclusion to the story or the characters.
    This anime and the characters deserve a better conclusion to their character arcs.
    This anime needs a remake.
    Also in the end it is like Aruna didn't get any character development okay This was harsh I understand why he was jealous from the guy.
    I just mean the lastest episodes were so messy and this was just inferorating to watch.
    I still like the anime but still it deserves better.
    That just got me thinking
    Did the manga made a conclusion to the story?
    Is the manga even good?

  • @AlainGasga
    @AlainGasga 6 ปีที่แล้ว +5

    Kare kano>>>toradora!

  • @rawdasalmataman7908
    @rawdasalmataman7908 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    I still don't understand.
    Did anno write kare kano?
    This anime deserves better.

  • @plasmabat718
    @plasmabat718 8 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    I really fucking hate romance anime, or romance anything for that matter, it's like some deeply buried shard of glass starts trying to work its' way out of the center of my heart, but I feel compelled to gather data on how to be human.
    So overall message: trying to appear perfect is fucking stupid and pointless and doesn't get you anything good(well yeah), it's way better to just express your true feelings, opinions, and thoughts to people(pretty damn obvious), and don't put up walls?
    Okay, but then you definitely shouldn't fucking just go around and tell anyone and everyone your true feelings, opinions, and thoughts; You've got to make sure you can trust them first, take it slow, reveal small things at first.
    And also, WHAT THE FUCK ARE THE CHANCES THAT YOU'LL HONESTLY FIND SOMEONE THAT HAS COMPATIBLE WEAKNESSES AND STRENGTHS TO YOU? IT'S LIKE FINDING ONE SPECIFIC PUZZLE PIECE IN A PILE OF ONE HUNDRED DIFFERENT PUZZLE PIECE SETS. Seems like it's pretty goddamn rare, and the stranger you are, the rarer it gets.
    Also I hate this fucking message that's like: "The only way you can heal your psychic scars is by falling in love"
    SO FUCKING NONSENSICAL.
    I'm going to go play some video games or something to help me calm down. GODDAMMIT. WHAT THE FUCK.

    • @crazy3d
      @crazy3d 7 ปีที่แล้ว +7

      Are you a sociopath?