@ShouTeR 이악물고 내가아니까 인기많음ㅋ 하네.. 은비가 브이앱에서 어쩌고 저쩌고 한건 궁금하지 않고 객관적인 근거를 가져와요 ㅋㅋㅋ 멜론 순위라든가 음방 1위라든가 뮤비 조회수 몇히트라든가요 거기다 여기 있는 사람들만 해도 대부분 있지 에스파 스테이씨 빼고 모르는 분위긴데 ㄷㄷ 이게 진짜 내가 우기는거임?
It’s so cool to see a new performance of Black Mamba nearly a year after they debuted. They’ve been working hard. (Same with Next Level obviously, but that one is more recent 😊)
I think is totally incredible the fact that we hear they sing almost 100% live but their voices are totally stable, absolutely no wrong note while doing a perfect choreography 😱👌😍 And their visuals are no joke
Giselle is absolutely stunning Winter Facial expressions and her cute hair Ningnings PERFECT vocals like she is a talented maknae Karina's vi- (died before I could finish the sentence) AESPA BEST ROOKIE GIRL GROUP IN ALL OF KPOP
Guys, this is not live... I've been in k-pop for many years and sadly, most of these shows are pre-recorded :/ Because it's very hard to dance and sing at the same time, even for trained people. They would be simply out of breath... I don't want to bring these idols down, so no offence :) I just want people to stop delude themeselves
@@mio8765 I wholeheartedly agree with you, fans fight with each other which group sings better while we don't even have opportunities to hear them live...
@@aleksandradrozdzal1717 No comparison at all, just recommendation. Do you know about Pink Fantasy? They have really intense choreography with live vocal in all performances. Check out their stage Poison❤️ They are from a really really small company thus they are very underrated🥺
this is literally a group where every member is your bias. They are all so perfect and talented at singing dancing and over stage presence. They kind of remind me of shinee in a way lol
So, I have been watching the Savage Camerawork Guide on repeat and I noticed that Winter, Giselle, and Karina's clothes look similar in this stage performance. But Winter's top is the exact same one so far while Karina's top is also the same one but with an additional accessory (vest).
Maybe it is taken the same day... Is INK Concert live or pre recorded? If it's pre recorded then there is a big possibility that they recorded both videos on the same day...
@@고앵이불 난독증 있냐 두번째 문장은 너 말고 sm 라이브 안함 이라고 한 애한테 글쓴거다. 그리고 스테이씨가 ㄹㅇ 라이브고 이건 라이브처럼 보이게하는 ar ㅇㅈㄹ 하는데 그게 깐게 아니라고? 본인이 라이브 한다고 말하는데 '응 ar' 이게 깐게 아니다? 참 신기하네^^
Their vocals are no joke but let's not spread misinformation by saying theyre singing it live when theyre clearly not. Nevertheless, this group is indeed talented and a complete package 🥰
they aren't singing live. When you move like that on the stage, your voice shakes and a singer has to compensate. Their sound is solid, fluid, and flawless. They are lip sincing.
¡ATENCIÓN MY! Tenemos metas para antes del primer aniversario del debut de aespa Black Mamba - 200 millones Next Level - 200 millones Savage - 100 millones Forever 50 millones ¡DIFUNDAN LO MÁS QUE PUEDAN!
네 명 다 진짜 보면 볼 수록 너무 예쁘네•• 앞으로가 더더욱 기대된다 ㄹㅇ
Jidkw
Yes
@マユミ💕 1
뭐라노
Yeah！I tink so！！
ningning’s hair color and that beautiful light blue top looks so good together
Ko
Oh my god winter is so different on and off stage, her gaze could kill while she's on stage, it's soo good
Jk
designer outfit and style so marvelous
Nh
D1k2fA5
에스파 노래는 처음 들었을땐 대체 이걸 노래라고 낸건가 싶을 정도로 희한하다 싶었는데 좀 지나니까 확실히 매력있고 에스파만의 유니크함이 돋보이는 듯
에프엑스도 글코 레벨 빨간맛도 그렇고 전통인듯
웬만한그룹들은 몇년전껀데 에스파는 만들어진지얼마안돼 2021년이구나.. 근데 이렇게 인기많은게 신기한다.. 에스파노래 중독성죽임.. 카리나.지젤 존귀.존예.. 윈터.닝닝 카리스마.존귀
@ShouTeR 로켓펀치랑 위클리는 누구여.. 인기 많다기엔 인지도가 좀...
@ShouTeR님은 에스파,있지,로켓펀치,위클리,스테이씨에만 관심이 있어서 그렇죠 당신이 안다고 다 인기있는 건 아닙니다
@@shiningshanny5459 위클리 로켓펀치가 걸그룹임??
@ShouTeR 로켓펀치? 위클리?
첨 들어보는데
@ShouTeR 이악물고 내가아니까 인기많음ㅋ 하네.. 은비가 브이앱에서 어쩌고 저쩌고 한건 궁금하지 않고 객관적인 근거를 가져와요 ㅋㅋㅋ 멜론 순위라든가 음방 1위라든가 뮤비 조회수 몇히트라든가요 거기다 여기 있는 사람들만 해도 대부분 있지 에스파 스테이씨 빼고 모르는 분위긴데 ㄷㄷ 이게 진짜 내가 우기는거임?
Karina's charisma is outta the world, she's captivating.
It’s so cool to see a new performance of Black Mamba nearly a year after they debuted. They’ve been working hard. (Same with Next Level obviously, but that one is more recent 😊)
매번역대급 신인들이 나온다하지만 이번에 정말 역대급인듯 노래도난해한듯 하지만 중독성에 각자 캐릭터 독보적이고 몬가 끌리는 아이들 너무 매력있다 내가 이래서 스엠을 못떠나
I will never get over how stunning winter looks here 🥲🖤
The outfit, the live vocal is so stable and especially the visual omfgd they are stunning.
FACTSSSSSS
Are you sure it's live? Each performance is exactly the same, weird.
it's pre-recorded
口パクだってすぐ分かるよね。😅😓不自然過ぎる
its not live; I don't think it is
every performance sounds exactly the same so I'm assuming its pre recorded
their backup dancers are so pretty, their dancing is so sharp and smooth, and their outfits are so cool
I think is totally incredible the fact that we hear they sing almost 100% live but their voices are totally stable, absolutely no wrong note while doing a perfect choreography 😱👌😍
And their visuals are no joke
Maybe bcs they´re actually not singing live? xD
There is no way someone can sing perfectly with this choreo
ningning has cute voice irl but when she's on stage her voice is so powerful. like hOw
하 진촤 김민정 미친거 아냐??? 물론 다른멤버들도 너무 좋지만 김윈터 어케 이쁘고 잘생기고 귀엽고 노래 잘하고 춤도 잘추고 다해???ㅠㅠㅠㅠ 그냥…사랑한다고… 오늘부로 킬링파트란 김윈터가 부르는 모든 파트가 킬링파트이다.
the stage presence is so insaneeee
THESE CHOREOS W THE VOCALS WOWOW
Wellll. you do realize that this is lip synched right??
Giselle is absolutely stunning
Winter Facial expressions and her cute hair
Ningnings PERFECT vocals like she is a talented maknae
Karina's vi- (died before I could finish the sentence)
AESPA BEST ROOKIE GIRL GROUP IN ALL OF KPOP
definitely
vi- what?
@@sara-saracoglu I think visual
@@joshuaaf oh- thank you
@@sara-saracoglu np!
Their vocals ON POINT
IKRRRRRRR
Guys, this is not live... I've been in k-pop for many years and sadly, most of these shows are pre-recorded :/ Because it's very hard to dance and sing at the same time, even for trained people. They would be simply out of breath... I don't want to bring these idols down, so no offence :) I just want people to stop delude themeselves
@@aleksandradrozdzal1717 oooofsss thanks for letting us know, had no idea
@@mio8765 I wholeheartedly agree with you, fans fight with each other which group sings better while we don't even have opportunities to hear them live...
@@aleksandradrozdzal1717 No comparison at all, just recommendation. Do you know about Pink Fantasy? They have really intense choreography with live vocal in all performances. Check out their stage Poison❤️ They are from a really really small company thus they are very underrated🥺
몇번을 듣는지 모르겠다..ㅎ...중독 오짐
Giselle is now officially my bias
ew
@@eggshell100 shut up I bet you can't even dance like her look like her rap. Like her
same she is my bias too 😊
@@eggshell100 ew yourself troll
Mine ningning and bias wrecker karina
Karina looks like Barbie doll, ethereal 💗
And Giselle is soo damn cool.!
I still can't believe that they are singing live, God, their vocals really enchant me
Can't never move from black mamba so powerful
지금 하교하는길에서 지금 집 왔는데 계속 보고있는중.. 이 정도면 나 에스파에 미친걸까..
this is literally a group where every member is your bias. They are all so perfect and talented at singing dancing and over stage presence. They kind of remind me of shinee in a way lol
i love the way giselle said "beulack mamba" omg too cute
I love karina's hair it looks so silky and smooth
도대체 언제 하는지 몰라서 못 봤는데, 올려주셔서 감사합니다.
첨 컨셉보고 애니메이션이랑 실물 비교 되면 어쩌려고 했는데, 애니메이션 보다 더 이쁠줄이야... 실력도 외모도 역대급 😍
All of them are gorgeous and talented
my first girl group I got really hooked since their debut
@Johan Setiadi haters gonna hate 🤣😘thank u for watching n commenting 😘
@Johan Setiadi but it looks like you are. 🤣 but its ok no biggie, I accept ur opinion to them just keep it to yourself. 😘 no hate spread love 🤣HAHAHA
I'm ligit obsessed with how Winter says next level honestly somethings wrong with me.
These vocals are real.
I didn't even watch the video and was doing other things while I let it play. It really shows and they are GOOOOOOD.
It's pre-recorded, not live
에스파는 4명 다 참 참신하고
파워풀하고 독특하다
보컬.춤 ,랩 모두 시청자들을
발광시킨다
그냥 다 빨여들어감
책임질사람 없음 👍👍
완벽 그자체..
So, I have been watching the Savage Camerawork Guide on repeat and I noticed that Winter, Giselle, and Karina's clothes look similar in this stage performance. But Winter's top is the exact same one so far while Karina's top is also the same one but with an additional accessory (vest).
Thats the first thing I notice when I first watch the camerawork!!
@@jpyo2545 took me awhile to notice, I've been listening and watching it on repeat until I stumbled upon their previous performance by accident.
It's good to recycle and repeat clothes as long as they're comfortable and pretty
THAT'S THE FIRST THING I THOUGHT!
Maybe it is taken the same day... Is INK Concert live or pre recorded? If it's pre recorded then there is a big possibility that they recorded both videos on the same day...
OWEMJI, NINGNING IS SO GORGEOUS! 🥺
NingNing’s hair looks so nice ☁️
2:20 ningning's voice has got me goosebumps
헐 라이브도 쫀득쫀득하게 잘한당 ,,💓💓
@@행운-e3f th-cam.com/video/1rAseoyUPLM/w-d-xo.html 억까 오지넼ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
@@행운-e3f 타팬인데 에스파 라이브는 인정해야지 솔직히
@@고앵이불 ar이고 mr 이고 잘 모르지만 걍 실력 있으면 되는거 아님? 그리고 구지 좋다는 댓에 안티짓 해서 라이브 인증 영상 보여줬는데 뭐가 문제임?
@@고앵이불 난독증 있냐 두번째 문장은 너 말고 sm 라이브 안함 이라고 한 애한테 글쓴거다. 그리고 스테이씨가 ㄹㅇ 라이브고 이건 라이브처럼 보이게하는 ar ㅇㅈㄹ 하는데 그게 깐게 아니라고? 본인이 라이브 한다고 말하는데 '응 ar' 이게 깐게 아니다? 참 신기하네^^
@@고앵이불ㅄ아... 앵콜을 이어폰을끼고다시들어봐라 라이브처럼보이는 ar ㅇㅈㄹ아직도하고있다면 넌 귀가그냥 막힌것이야 고음에서 다 뚫고나오는거 안들릴수가없는데 ㅋㅋ
윈터 보컬 블랙맘바 부르는 거 보니까 계속 더 탄탄해지고있네..미쳤다
즤구젤리 미모 머야 천사가 내려왔네
천국은 누가 지켜 마이 앤젤
GISELLE Y UR SO PRETTY?? IM AGONNA CRY😫💗
닝닝 진짜 라이브 잘한다
뭔가 에스파는 최대화질로 안 보면 억울해
Winter stage precence is amazing 😍😍😯😯
역시 에스파....완전 잘함 ㅎㅎ~~
i miss black mamba performance so much i'm glad they performed 2 songs here :)
Aespa all members outfit are amazing😍 they are all talented 🥰 and they all are pretty😍❤
이번 22년 트렌드는 에스파다!
닝닝은 말할때늠 귀여운데 노래할땐 너무 멋졍 ㅠㅠㅠ
라이브 완전잘하네,..
와...진짜 다 이쁘다...~~
Both performances of aespa on that concert was superior
Karina is sooo pleasing to watch👀 i love her
Omg they are already so good even tho they are still rookies, and when i watch aespa’s performances it’s very satisfying as always
Yeah they're on another next level...
모두모두 이쁘구 노래두 잘하구 춤두 잘 추구 인기가 계속 올라갈거 같아영~^^♡♡
These are my two favourite songs. I still get goosebumps from these
th-cam.com/users/shortsgwKlyxYT-z4
닝닝 라이브,,💗
나만 김윈터 저 착장 좋아하나? 진짜 멋지고 귀엽고 예쁘고 다 해
단발 블랙맘바 겁나 좋다 밑으로 내려갈때 머리카락 나풀거리는거 귀엽고난리 1:44
역시 짱스파가 미래다•••
GISELLE MY QUEEN
윈터는 볼때마다 말티즈같다 ㅋㅋㅋ 예쁜데 귀여워
Their vocals are no joke but let's not spread misinformation by saying theyre singing it live when theyre clearly not. Nevertheless, this group is indeed talented and a complete package 🥰
Grandiosa Agrupacion Pop - Electro , sus videos de estilo futurista 🌏👑🎵
they become more n more better with every comeback even they are alreadyyyy...............................theses girls are my death
THEY ARE SO PRETTY!!
Giselle is body goals. She is stunning
I love these girls so muchhhh
aespa be singing live and this stable not even a year after their debut, damn y’all we stan queens
its pre recorded;-;
ningning is soooo pretty and gissele looks so cool
Every one: Next level...
Winter: Next levul... xD
(This "levul" has been shaking in my head for 4 months lol)
This was so amazing ,my fav live performances 💕
Ningning high notes are just amazing 💜💜💜
Winter's outfil is so cool
지젤 진짜 핫걸이야 와ㅏㅏㅏ 너무 이쁘당
Aespa best gg for me
윈터 진짜 귀엽고 순둥하게 생겼ㅅ는데 내 카톡 잘 씹을거 같음
아 너무 좋아
I watched this a lot and now im sure their mic is on. They have loud background music/audio whatever but the mic is on
they aren't singing live. When you move like that on the stage, your voice shakes and a singer has to compensate. Their sound is solid, fluid, and flawless. They are lip sincing.
이노래가 뭐가 중독된다는거 야!수같은 나를 느껴
Winter vocal 😩❤
지젤 너무 예쁘다🥰
Their vocals NO JOKE
thank for made this video💘
Um I LOVE all of their outfits!! I want them allllllll
Winter is the prettiest❄️
Vocals for dayssss
Their voice was so pawerfull...even the background can't hear any
I love aespa! I am a big fan of you~
04:54 지젤 움직임 너무 섹시해
¡ATENCIÓN MY!
Tenemos metas para antes del primer aniversario del debut de aespa
Black Mamba - 200 millones
Next Level - 200 millones
Savage - 100 millones
Forever 50 millones
¡DIFUNDAN LO MÁS QUE PUEDAN!
wah I remember this stage...legendary
Winter to their stylist : Damnn this is what i want.
진짜이쁘네 감탄
Karina is queen but I have to say Giselle looks Incredible
I think winter best vocal and visual
Nope
legendary
NINGNING's vocal is soooooooooo good
ชุดเเอ่มม่ะซาเว่ด!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!