Kashmir Files propaganda and the sham of BARC ratings | TV Newsance 164
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 24 มี.ค. 2022
- This week, we look at every major news channel running amok with the recently resumed television ratings by the #BroadcastAudienceResearchCouncil. The clamour around which channel made it to the top was finally settled. Spoiler alert, it’s all of them. Arnab took the cake, of course, with a long and breathless name-calling tirade.
When not claiming to be number one, news channels were busy playing sidekicks to the state machinery that put its entire weight behind the propaganda film of the year, #TheKashmirFiles. We look at their not-so-subtle PR campaigns, with a tadka of drama. And the complete decimation of the idea of “facts”, taken apart piece by piece, in relentless nightly tamashas.
To recover from this din of disinformation, we spoke to a journalist who actually reported from Kashmir during the late ‘80s and ‘90s - Alpana Kishore, who worked for Newstrack.
For those interested in engaging in the topic in a more detailed manner, here’s a few resources:
NL Hafta: www.newslaundry.com/2022/03/2...
Reporting from #Kashmir, 1989 to 1994: • Reporting from Kashmir...
Companion piece recommended by Alpana Kishore: www.newslaundry.com/2022/03/2...
--
#TVNewsance is Newslaundry’s weekly media critique and political satire show. We watch Hindi and English TV news so you don't have to! If you like what we do, don’t forget to subscribe to Newslaundry: www.newslaundry.com/subscript...
Also, get a chance to interact with Manisha Pande and the team. Join us on Telegram for exclusive updates on #TVNewsance: t.me/TVNewsance
Follow and engage with us on social media:
Facebook: / newslaundry
Twitter: / newslaundry
Instagram: / newslaundry
This is a prime example of when we go to extremes to intellectually resist something, we develop biases.
Lavde Quran padh. Intteleectual ki jhaant. Saala gaddar.
Exactly 💯
And I justify being biased. Hate towards 1 section is because leftist are biased always, they close their eyes when their narrative is in danger.
But it is about how needs to be reported to how it's getting reported.. example Godhra incident film ban, but now this film getting promoted by govt.
Someone says ," If you don't have any point to make, use sarcasm to hide your emptiness". This video is perfect example of that.
But who says facts are facts ?
@@necessary1017 😂😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣
I almost believed it, your comment..
Well tried.
If you don’t have any point to make, talk to Beerbiceps podcast
Someone also said kashmir files was not perfect because it didn't give rss it's credit for creating tension in kashmir that's called ghosh babu ka dimag ka emptiness 😂
I am a muslim and heres what I have to say- Defending yourself/your beliefs is *not* a reason to deny the pain, trauma and history of others. Saying "no this did not happen" is a disrespectful and painful jab at those Kashmiri hindus who lost their families and friends in the massacre and needs to be stopped, immediately. As muslims, let us remember that each time we deny the facts and figures of this event, we are doing the exact same thing thats been done to us whenever we have spoken about Islamophobia. The violence that took place against the Kashmiri pandits was horrifying, disgusting and shall remain a trauma for generations. At the same time, using this movie to start another war against muslims of this generation who did not have anything to do with the violence is also stupid. I personally know Muslims who saved Hindu friends and neighbours during the exodus by hiding them in their hours moreover Kashmiri militants are also responsible for the deaths of thousands of Muslims too. Let's remember that there are good and bad people in every home, community and religion. This movie is a lesson for the government to take action BEFORE such mass crimes take place and to reinstate Kashmiri Hindus BACK to their homes as soon as possible. Instead of wasting money on useless projects like demonetisations, changing names of cities or the farmers bill, WHY IS JUSTICE TO KASHMIRI HINDUS NOT BEING PRIORITISED? The government is busy inciting violence between communities, instead of taking actual action to give justice to those who have been hurt.
Thank you so much for your input; huge respect for you 🙏🏼
So, that's the thing : the intention of the movie was NEVER to spread hatred against innocent muslims. Smal spoiler alert lol but towards the end of the movie, they do mention that there were innocent muslims also killed by the terrorists.
When a movie raises a voice for victims, we should understand and feel for the victims, not become selfish and make it about religion. The terrorists made it about religion; we should NOT. we should put aside the religious aspect and have empathy. That's how we come together
Well there are more bad PPL on one side
@@drvren030 i agree with you 100%
@@Arjun17 there are more than 2 billion of us, if there were bad people on this side you'd be dead
@@Arjun17 more people means nothing. There’s no unity there. Whereas Ms r United all over the world. If a cartoon is drawn in one country entire world erupts. Soldiers in other countries literally die.
Hs have lost Afghanistan, Pak, Bangladesh, Burma, Indonesia. ✝️ lost Syria, Egypt, Iraq, Iran, Philippines partially etc. They even lost Spain for 800 yrs.
U r comparing a plague to a mosquito bite.
Actually he is a male version of barkha dutt.
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 बरोबर बोला तू
What makes you think it's a 'he'?
I'm sorry, you can't just assume things like this okay?! How do you know that he is a MALE version? And how do you know anything about Barkha Dutt?
Barkha Dutt is a beautiful human being okay?! Aunties look at her and say "arree barkha, kisi ki Nazar na Lage" . She walks like an angel, and speaks as if she's singing. Barkha is lovely 💕💕 no one dare say anything about her
EDIT: looks like there are some dumbasses who didn't understand lol so, reminder : this is complete SARCASM
Lol
@@drvren030 Bc kitne andhe ho tumlog😂
Literally kashmir file exposed you without showing current situation 😂
How?
@TJ P And you have a brain. Ya fir mogoj dholai?
@@sauron2000000 I am not a right winger, I watched the movie with an open mind. It's really this kind of journalism and war of narratives that the movie talks about. Facts are not facts because people ingest, assimilate, analyse and then interpret it based on their narrative. The ideology that you subscribe will taint your glasses. If you have assumptions you can never reach the truth. The movie leaves on you to decide if the genocide happened or not. Its a really good film.
@@queenv3973 Nobody can ever reach the truth. Probably Nathuram Godse did not kill Gandhi. You are right. Facts can never be facts.
Do you consider the events shown in the movie to be facts?
@@queenv3973 so u watch republic tv 😂😂😂
I dont understand, you're saying the events shown in the movie didn't happen? I actually read all the articles covering these events , Anantnag genocide, Girija Tickoo rape and brutal murder, and various other events. These articles are actually there. Please talk about those instead of just labelling it with names
This video is itself the propoganda of ideologues. You've woken up. It is you to understand that this will keep going on, because it has been in the past. Figure out what else you are blinded to!
Read The curfewed nights
While making a mockery of other Indian news channels, the presenter spared no thought of actually interviewing the KPs who were the actual sufferers. Instead, he preferred asking this question from a lady not even living in India and has no KP connection. However, when mob lynching happens, all hell breaks lose for central govt.
Doesn't suit their narrative, hence they obviously didn't care to cover it.
Every event shown in the movie was real, even the last killing in which they came in counterfeit uniforms asked KP from the village to come out of their home and line up. 11 men, 11 women and 2 children were gunned down in cold blood - it is actually the Nadimarg Massacre in 2003. Which main stream media never highlighted and fake anchor like this call it propoganda.
Yes, Newslaundry is right. The truth of kashmiri pandits was so well covered are talked that me and my all friends never heard of it till now as an Indian throughout my life but The Genocide of Jews are known to every classmate since class 9th, which is not even an Indian issue. I am not comparing the two genocides but none was less heartshaking than the other.
Welcome to indian education system actually yeh sab janbujh ke hote hain contractor strategy galti karo usse ache se mat karo taki next time bhi contract mile aur thik kaam karke usska credit khao kashmiri muslim hindu politics started by none other than congress but iske bich main tang adaya tha rss aur hindu mahasabha after committing such grave crime how they're not listed as terrorist group is beyond reasoning the secularism is today's getting attacked because of these raita wing forces i hate them totally they were able to convince everyone because people mostly prefer to hate muslim due to their culture and heritage bei of invaders even though they won fair square and under religion no one should complain like they never used to do when hindu were conquering each other themselves shows the hypocrisy of both hindu and muslim society tbh muslim are to be blamed too but congress is the main by not eliminating such toxic people they've done biggest sin for indian future this same toxicity is still getting carried because of these politicians
Kashmir files is an excellent movie showing what really happened to Kashmiri Pandits....the brutal killings,rapes,them being forced to do many other things etc
The Indian media promoted the movie but not in the right way,they were just making it worse by being too dramatic...I repeat this has to do with the news channels and ofc the Government.No offence to the movie here.I said that they were being dramatic...ie it's because any of them never talked about how we as a very diverse country should be more conscious and cautious of the circumstances that arise out of religion chauvinist...the riots and mass killings on the name of religions.
This movie truly deserved huge support so that people can be aware of such exodus but the media failed to capture people's mind and make them understand how the religious extremism can bring this much issues.
In case of Kashmir at that time it was not the religion Islam but the severe extremism that led to all that's happened.In future I wish there won't be any such serious issue in the name of religion and its extremism ,caused by any particular religion.
We shall never forget that we are Indians before we are Hindus,Muslims, Christians,Sikhs etc
Indian army raped Manipur women and girl . They protests in naked with holding slogan "indian army rapist " . Shall we make movie and promoting violence against indian army ?? . North indian people need to calm down and educated their empty brain .
I would never term it as an excellent movie , rather it's a propaganda for the increase in hate for muslims . It would have been good if it's showed that at the same time 1865 muslims were killed along with 89 kp's. The ratio is quite sustainable, right? Or still I am missing something??
it was definitely Islam. The people who escaped Kashmir that time are still alive today. 1990s isn't too far away. And they said this themselves - it was on loudspeakers - Ralive, Tsalive ya Galive. In Kashmiri language it means - convert, die or leave. Convert here implies converting to Islam. Islam played a big role in this. you can't deny that
@@poetry5032 many more than 89 KPs were killed and 600000 left their homes. Keep trying though.
@@hidum5779 yeah just put any number and assume ill believe you right? According to you more than 89 kp's were killed ( let's take 200) and 600000 houses were outleft ( btw such an illogical statement of yours 😂😂).....by this logic more than 1600 muslims residing there were killed in the same time period residing in Kashmir , so how many houses would have been left?? 😂😂 .......you defn can't answer that cause' you're illogical and you know that 😂😂
Although i have been an admirer of NL but here i totally disagree on Kashmir issue, fck context nothing can justify killing of innocent people be it hindu or muslim.
They won't understand. Still they are glorifying those bastereds who says "Since we dont have jobs in good positions we preffred to hold the gun and kill the affluents".
waiting for 1984 files and 2002 files :) genocides cannot be justified
@satish Nair
@sonu singh yes,
@sonu singh th-cam.com/video/yNHyH7oB3qQ/w-d-xo.html not gonna contact hasty directors like him :)
@sonu singh better
All my Kasmiri Pandit friends have actually supported the movie.I've studied in a school chain established by KPs in Delhi-NCR. Many teachers and students over there were KPs.
No wonder....your youtube activities clearly calls you out as a right wing supporter when you defend the way the government is monetizing assests while claiming lack of any so far...!
The KPs I know, know deep down that BJP was complicit at the time. Apathetic. Just like on a world stage to Ukraine now. Nothing new. Desensitized to human suffering. But will opportunistically emerge to gain votes and power.
@@birdsong2631 exactly. What URI has done in 2019, Kashmir files will be doing the same. After 2024, this whole story will just vanish just like SSR's case.
@@mohammedmujammilshaikh4546 ..u want Gujarat files...definitely we should watch Gujarat files afterall its all started after Godhra train burning and everybody knows who did that and which community did that....and Kashmir files didn't said anything that muslims killed kashmiri pandits...it only shows that how millitants killed kashmiri pandits and film also shows that militants also killed those muslims who supported kashmiri pandits.....rather than saying propaganda we should accept the truth and both upa or nda govt. themselves are responsible for all this horrible incidents
Lol librandus replying to your comment are testament to the fact that they are irked with ppl not believing this propaganda video that claims piece of reality as propaganda ! #irony
Dear News Laundry 🤷🏽♂️ Jali na 😂😂 by Movie 🎥 Popularity 😂😂
When you're so hateful against a certain party you lose your humanity! This guy is a prime example of that
Just because politicians are taking about dosent make a true thing false
I am a kashmiri pandit and whatever has been shown in movie is absolutely true . We have seen it and faced it
Just because political party and journalists are taking about it dosent make the plight of Kashmiri Pandits false .
Rather than focussing on what political party and journalists are saying you should be more focussed on what should be done for those who suffered .
In nutshell both you and other side are using this for your agenda but nothing for those who suffered.
Yes true.. This movie has exposed alliegance of these so called neutral channels.. I used to follow them diligently.. But the stand they've come up with for this movie.. Has ensured that they are not neutral but actually biased towards Congress and left
A heartfelt apology to u and ur family for ignoring the inhuman atrocities happened.
No matter what the political parties say, ur story has reached the masses.
Sane citizens of this country stand with u.
Hope the resettlement process shall start soon, and we all will contribute to revival of kashmir as "fountains of knowledge".
Don’t waste your time explaining this to urban naxals.
News laundry is a congressi channel...thays y
Agreed, have been a follower of Newslaundry for quite some time. One good thing about this movie is that these self proclaimed neutral channels have been exposed. Very disappointed to see Newslaundry also belonging to that category. Probably the Deshbhakt has maintained the most balanced approach in this matter.
News in India is polarized. News laundary is no different.
Yeah newslaundry is so different it creats online JNU.. 😂
@@Somethiinglike exactly, actually i wont say this, but when he said about Stan and umar... I am dam sure this is pathetic...
No ....Proganda is being presented as News in india ... Its not polarized. .
True, just like godi media is there we have left wing media like this channel. Everyone pushes propaganda as per the needs of their backers.
@@EdwinTyler then what should we name them? Lodi media?🤣🤣
I am so glad guys really ,That in comment section you are totally with the truth even we are the regular viewers of NL.
This is what they call admitting truth not caged in propaganda♥️❤️
you guys consume news from newslaundry? bruh!
So kashmiri pundits apne house esliye chor gye q ki inhe maza a gya tha
@@bhaveshtochabbra6853 and its spitting facts unlike godi media
P)
80 % of bad things happening because of bjp rss modi
You guys are no different from godi media. Everyone fulfilling their own bias. Truly the worst episode of NL.
100% disagree with you on this... not liking individual is different and undermining a genocide is different... The fact that most of the hindus all over India was unaware about this genocide till now is a shame. Agnihotri and team made everyone aware about this exodus which was hidden by Media, intellectuals and governments, Bollywood for so many years. One should ask questions to them that why you guys have hide the facts instead of saying that this will create hatred...Important thing to understand is criticising terrorism will not spread hatred but ignoring & supporting it will ! I think these kind of brave movies should get the hype it deserves and It should be respected....
Lefts main motive is to divide the country, what u expect more
@Bhadwa Modi false narratives
@Bhadwa Modi I don't want to acknowledge or reply to a person who doesn't have the guts to put his/her name in youtube account.
Mooz (L3m) Majority=EXTR3M 1STS DOMINATE,MODERATE Mooz (L3ms) =irrelevant
There r 0 MOOZ (L3M) MAJORITY NATIONS where ALL 3 CONDITIONS r fulfilled
-nation is secular democracy
-minority Numbers don't decline
-minority=PM
MOOZ (L3ms) deny rights to minorities which
MOOZ (L3ms) ask when they r minority
The genocide never happened .....4-5 people were killed and they have made a film calling it genocide ! Clearly a propaganda ! Kashmiri pundits left kashmir long back ......it's all sanghi propaganda !
I watch your episodes regularly but you've lost me on this one. If you're so confident that this film diverted from facts, which you emphasized so much in this episode, you should've pointed out the exact misinformation shown and given us the actual facts, just like how you do in other episodes with the misinformation shown on other channels on any topic. What context is your ex- boss talking about? Is she trying to say that the atrocities on kashmiri pandits were justified in a particular context? Nowhere does this film blame Muslims for all of it. It says terrorists or Islamic terrorists, all through. Terror must be condemned regardless of the underlying belief/ cause/ faith/ religion. I never expected your channel to be so insensible, insensitive, and biased!
Hmm he said listen to the podcasts on NL halfta. And the exact context they were talking bout was state sponsored terrorism by Pakistani Govt because of loose border control at that time.
The problem with Kashmiri Files isn't whether it's entirely true or false the problem with it is that it paints everything white or black it show that every Muslim is a live and walking TIMEBOMB who may explode and kill Hindus for no reason.
The fact that you r literally so riled up about the fact that she called called the movie narrow POV is not digestible to you.
I understand why you are so emotional after watching the movie after all you saw some really disturbing stuff.
But you should understand that it's the Job of JOURNLIST to show different POV's.
what world you living in. do you really thought news laundry was unbaised??? daily many hindus get killed by muslim they never cover them. there channels only runs proganda to justify muslim misdeads at any cost. her ex boss was saying she was there. but you know who was more there its kashmiri pandits families. who supported this film for showing truth.
Mooz (L3m) Majority=EXTR3M 1STS DOMINATE,MODERATE Mooz (L3ms) =irrelevant
There r 0 MOOZ (L3M) MAJORITY NATIONS where ALL 3 CONDITIONS r fulfilled
-nation is secular democracy
-minority Numbers don't decline
-minority=PM
MOOZ (L3ms) deny rights to minorities which
MOOZ (L3ms) ask when they r minority
This is a congress funded channel
Plz watch hafta for that. This is a snippet
Well tried brother , great attempt of sabotaging the movie essence with smart tactics .
Fact -
1. Indians watched this movie because they wanted to watch the movie, it didn't happen because agnihotri made it or Modi supported it but people watched it because they wanted to know what has happened in Kashmir with kashmiri pandits .
2. Maybe director of the movie is opportunist , but the movie was amazing . It was totally based on facts. Good screenplay , dialogues and cinematography.
2. the opportunists are those who made "shikara".
Ok but tell me why this movie is all about Brahmins?? Did non-Brahmins and non-Hindus not suffer?? Were non-Brahmins and non-Hindus not killed?? Don't they need justice as well?
Goverment can praise the movie but can't make it successful until the audiences feel it is their story. Please stop questioning the ability of the Indian audience.
when gov. is prasing something..its political in the first place
@@vreviews4u657 So all the movies promoted by kejriwal were political?
@@vreviews4u657 search who jumped first politically.. u peaceful people never rests, it was just a film untill maulana felt it spreading hatred, than Kerala cong came than all the so called saviors of secularism the librandus came than obviously bjp had to come
@@shubhsinghal4364 firstly, try to sense msg those films are giving, they arent targeting any specific community (nor such fucked up slogans are raised on them) and secondly, yes thats also political because in the end that will affect the type of image he is trying to build for his party.
@@vreviews4u657 The messages behind was to show the truth of the so called peaceful people.
I get your point but still the movie depicts what happened with kashmiri pandits in the most factual way possible , the irony is that the facts are soo gore and gruesome that many are not able to accept it 🙂 .
I know bcoz im a kashmiri pandit. The facts i have heard from my grandparents are more brutal.
@MHW yes all locals kashmiri muslim are in support of terrosits. kashmiri hindus betrayed by their own neighbours. only those kashmiri muslims are not in there support who is in indian government jobs.
@@ASHISHSHARMA-cg4nc chor do Yaar mulleh ki jal rahi hai. Hahaha
@MHW then why there are no or very less kashmiri pandits or hindus there ??? And muslims still live there in huge numbers? In the movie there was clearly said many muslims were killed too...but only those who would speak about India or raised their voice in support of pandits. Maybe u were incapable of absorbing that type of info
Film has shown truth but half truth.
That is dangerous.
Have u seen twitter videos filled with hate speech agianst one whole community ie. Muslims of india.
They r being held accomplice.
Remaining silent during times of injustice is not good but it has reasonable explaination. It could be due to Fear, threat to life of witness , personal hate ,etc.
It is not that simple that kashmir has hindu-muslim problem.
It has geopolitical angle which has a big player pakistan and isi , it has politcal angle governance angle as well.
It has societal angle too.
It is not simple for a parochial mind to comprehend such a complex issue.
I was also hurt but i am not going to say it happend just bcoze of muslims. I will not hate anyone from that community.
I am not that evil who will avenge from others.
Films are way to express.
They have last longing effect in minds of people who watch it.U can either give message out of it or use it as tool of propaganda.
It is better that they must be balanced with some message and lesson to tell puspose why we chose such a topic specially a films on sensitive topics like these.
Director vivek earned 200 crore and now what. How it will benefit people who were actually affected.?
The only reason kashmir files became such a massive success is only because u can feel the honesty and sincerity with which its done. The feeling u experience are raw and genuine. U can relate quite easily. The fact that so many liberals are desperately trying to downplay the content or abuse the makers, actually is proving the point that the movie conveyed
Then why dont you ask your beloved PM what he did for those pundits in the last 8 yrs being a PM, was he so scared of 20%, he gave you 1 lollipop and you 80% are still enjoying that without any thought
@@azizahmedkhan669 The 80% : "Us Indians"
The 20% : "Us and Them" , This is what happens when religious Institutes teach separatist ideology to Kids
@@azizahmedkhan669 He has done one of the biggest things that should have been done a long time back. 370 and 35A was thrown out of the window for good. Completely decimated the ecosystem and the political parties that destroyed kashmir in the first place.
@@alienfromsaturn8909 my question is why your sympathy erupted only after watching this movie after 30yrs, were you not aware of this, what stopped you to raise your voice and why no question and demand for their benefits, atleast demand the producer to donate the movie earning for the families of those pundits, let's see how honest was his intention of making this movies, I challenge you to ask him this
@@azizahmedkhan669 The sympathy was always there but the problem really was that how the evils of jihad were concealed for so many years. Everyone knew bad things happened with pundits but nobody knew the extent. It never felt like a personal loss till today. This is why vivek deserves the respect he is getting
Asking producer for donation is just silly. He has done a great favor by simply bringing this lesson in history in front of all indians. He should be admired and appreciated for it and he deserves every rupee he earns for this effort. As a movie maker, he could have chosen any topic but he chose this one. So hats off to him. He has already done enough in the last 4.5 yrs and many generations are going to watch this movie in future. Whether he chooses to donate more or not is his personal choice.
He literally has redefined cinema in many ways. Hope more movie makers understand the pulse of the nation and follow suit
Thanks!
I feel bad for this shitty newslaundry. My condolences to them.
I feel bad for your parents
I fail to see how Vivek Agnihotri is making it about him. Dude even if he was, why not focus on the issue? At least now? Why is it a problem if he’s making money, it’s a movie, not some charity? Salman khan and Karan johar can make movies based on patriotism and mint crores, this director making money is the problem? You guys are amazing at shifting the focus away from the central issue, so hard at work 👏
I watched The Kashmir Files a couple of days back. There is no such thing as propaganda/Islamophobia in the movie. The movie throws light on the Kashmiri Hindu Genocide without any sugar-coating. This is a masterpiece.
There maybe no propaganda in the movie but the people who made it surely are using it as a tool to facilitate chaos and hatred for muslims
89 se ab tak 1 lakh se zyada muslims shaheed kiye gaye kashmir mein indian forces ki janab se 7000 se zyada aurto ki izzat looti gayi ijtamai qabray mili asli genocide wo hai
@@emamularfeen4940 The movie makers just showed the truth. Nothing else. If you can't digest it, that's your problem
@@saifali-qj2hs Muslims were not killed because of their religion.
But Hindus were keeled because of their religion (some journalists, intellectuals, politicians even justified Hindu Genocide)
That's why it comes under Ethnic cleansing and Genocide.
*I am not denying the deaths of Muslim brother
Yes, that genocide happened. No body is denying that. But the fact that, some people are taking advantage to increase TRP and their profit through that horrible massacre is undeniable and pathetic to see.
Also, pointing this movie, our "beloved" hypocrites are further dividing so they can secure votes/seats next election.
Now that fact is, what do our Sufferer Kashmiri Pandits got? 𝗡𝗼𝘁𝗵𝗶𝗻𝗴. No return to their homeland, no financial help, nothing. This movie perhaps showed the genocide but also increased the pseudo hate to another community. That's why they are saying it certainly has a hidden propaganda.
Great work vivek agnihotri sir ❤️🙌
Bro they are saying movie is propaganda but ye log ye nhi bata rahe hai ki ye wala scene nhi hua hai like convert run and die ki masjid se nhi bola gaya hai aur bhi scene like chawal wala thats enough to expose these anti india and Anti Hindu People then they called Others news channel as Godi Media waah
Why are you trying to use small clips and justify that this is it? Like this is how you explain things to the audience, or have you been in Kashmir in 1990 and seen everything that happened? Your Content representation is amazing, but don't sell yourself by showing partial clips to make a peaceful community happy! Grow UP :)
Exactly man! Even I was wondering whether how can you talk of "context" in a video and then stripping other news clips off their context to prove your point! Even they need to listen once ki "Kisi mahapurush ne kya Kaha tha..."😀
U both are smart to notice that... scroll, print, wire, NL.... congress funded channel... they will portray Hindus as culprit. Make fun of Sadhus.....y don't they make fun of a Muslim cleric???
Dude, what are you talking about? I watched the film and watched your whole 3 part video "Reporting from Kashmir, 1989 to 1994", which was recommended by TH-cam algorithm :)
I don't think film missed on it's point of what Kashmiri Pandits went through, in fact only a tiny portion of it is shown, It is not a documentary, it is a film.
But brother movie me kabhi dikhaya hi nahi k us vaqt BJP support vali janta government thi jo rajyapal the wo bhi BJP supported janta dal ke the to jis sarkar ka kam hota he ye sab rokne ka usne to kuchh nahi kiya!!! Ye sabse bada point to movie me miss he??!!! Vivek agnihotri ji keh rahe he puri movie fact base he to ye sabsa bada fact knyo chhupa liya gya???
You are a perfect case of ‘educated’ bhakt. By your own admission you saw all parts of Kashmir reporting and are confirming that the film does show what was in the report but just a ‘tiny’ part as its a film. And how convenient you missed the whole point of the show, which is the claim by none other than PM of the country that ‘truth’ is coming out after 30 years and blaming opposition and ‘media’ for hiding the truth. If reporting is old and BJP has been in power for a good amount of time as the Pandit issue continue who’s PM blaming?
@@user-bf6ul8ok1s The movie is made from the human angle. Whoever dies, it's still a tragedy. But bollywood failed to show all these years what happened to kashmiri pandits. Even now one film is made and chutiyas like you are getting your panties in a bunch to trivialize this movie and the events. Saying this movie shows the truth doesn't negate whatever else happened in kashmir. Dumbass.
@@Shahbaz7771khan BJP came in power Dec 1989 and Exodus happened on 19 Jan 1990, situation was difficult to control because murder and rapes were already started back in 1985/86. Farooq Abdullah resigned as CM of JnK and government voidness provide proper time to JKLF to execute final plan of Exodus and Massacre. Jagmohan was governer who was appointed by Indira Gandhi not BJP. You are not pointing on 19 Jan and government in central but situation was planned by Farooq and JKLF.
@@anandpurwar3830 ye in Jese logo ko mat samjha...ye Pagal Hain sare.
You too termed the TKF "propaganda" film. Why do you think I will trust your words and not the "1st/2nd generation" of the victims or the victims themselves??
So true.. I am a kashmiri pandit.. In their quest to go against Modi. They'll also go to any levels.. Whats the difference btw them and godi media.. I liked deshbhakt akash Banerjee n lalla top much better..
True. Ive seen even the non right leaning Kashmiri hindus explaining their pain. And NL saying something was "Fully reported" is so blatent, when even today so many facts aren't reported at all in Mainstream media; when back then there was barely any other source except politically surpressed media. Journalism can never be without a bias, because journalism isn't 'only' report of facts but more of opinions. So why do we believe words of a 'Journalist' from kashmir and not the words on Kashmiri hindus?
I do agree that the news anchors don't leave any opportunity to claim their channels as topmost and such harping from the rooftop every moment is undoubtedly nauseating
@@rashikakaul1098 you're fooling yourself big time if you think that Akash Banerjee, NewsLaundry, etc are Neutral. Look carefully and their hatred for dharmic civilization would come to the forefront. Do you think they hate BJP because of the economy and inflation? Haha!! They hate it because it has traditionally been a face of Hindu assertiveness. That's all. And it's a big roadblock to the Mulla-Marxist-Missionary nexus.
@@aman___004 well said Aman Bhai 👍👍
I can't believe they call it propaganda even after knowing what happened to the Pandits , Sab ka time aata ha aa ka bhi aae Newslaundary
Dekhte jao
BJP is very clever, They have do nothing for Kashmiri Pandit in 8- 9 years, Only discounts movie taxs for movie maker but what about kashmir pandit ? Ask your PM fool, Every one talking about kashmir film but in reality kashmiri Pandit life will never change and government also don't want it 😏😏
@@bngmax6023 ek cheez seekh lo tumko agar tatti bhi na ho to bhi tum bolna BJP ki wajah se nahi horae ha.
Dekhna hojaega
Looks like someone's paying him well 😂 this guy can't even accept that the movie spoke the truth. Damn
th-cam.com/video/rFC8_S_USjM/w-d-xo.html
Bollywood is literally like the curriculum for most Indians. Padmavati was a great example of how gullible indians are. Imagine if Pakistan was never made and india was one. We would probably hate the chinese( oops we already do!).
Asking 50% profits is like, me asking you my 50% 4G bill for watching your video 🤪
True ...
he is not asking 50% for himself. Its for KPs who were suffered.
If the movie is made just for entertainment, its not logical to ask for sharing profits, but as they are making political movement with that movie and telling that movie has been made for KPs, then they can asks for profit sharing, if they really cares, they should donate and if not, then they should stop doing politics over the movie
@@pranavthote8641 , Hollywood shared profits when movies were made on Holocaust? Take example of this guy, he is making videos on many issues, is he sharing his TH-cam money on the movements he is covering. It doesn’t work like that, any motion picture will have production values to meet.
Irony of us Indians- when you are in public you are a socialist and when you are alone you think like a capitalist.
@@pranavthote8641 and what would center or SC will do
Why Newslundry and NDTV never gives 50% of their profit to victims of their reported cases , why SRK ,sallu , Aamir etc.dont give 50% of their movie collection to their virtual fake victims in India, why only Hindus as re targeted for impoverishmemt .
I feel bad for the pandits who are being mocked in this Left vs Right battle. While it is true that the plight of pandits has not received as much attention as the Gujarat riots or the plight of Km's, both of which are frequently discussed. The film has raised awareness of what transpired in the valley with KPs among the general public. It shouldn't be called as a propaganda film.
If the film was left as a film and the usual advertisement like a Bollywood movie it would have been alright. But, the film is backed by the government, their supportive media channels, loads of right-wing portals, and thousands of new hate posts created to promote the film. And this is why it's a propaganda film, similar in style to the ones done in the Natzi regime..
@@movi12 if showing the truth..awaring people about it is propaganda thn you are deluded mate... You have lost the plot and simply u r MK Gandhi of Moplah Massacre pity
th-cam.com/video/VsDhlCBCD7Q/w-d-xo.html
@@movi12 because of ye picture normal release hi ni hui 😂😂 didn't u get it yet boycott kiya Bollywood ne screens ni mili distribution ni mila cases hue multiple Abe un sab se zyada in sab ne publicity ki hai is movie ki 😂😂 Bollywood jis topic par bolta hai us reaction ko koi ni sunta jis par chup hota hai us par zyada reaction milta hai
@@movi12 bro ur brain need bornvita
Gujarat riots were riots. this was ethnocide. which part did you not understand?
How dare Arnab compare his "hardship" with what happened to Kashmiri pandits
this is nothing new. His reporting is always reactionary.
When you use “TKF”, in your title to get views for a video that is supposedly talking about propaganda. This is absolutely why the movie was and is necessary.
Ok FASCISTS
I love how the editor ensures navika's background music for all her screen time
i have reach to a point where even seeing navika in a picture my brain starts playing the bg music
Haha, navika is synonymous with drama
This islamists’ slave portal tried it best to mock the genocide by funny music and what not, shows these are not journalists but dirty warms. They are not targeting a movie but a genocide which took place by islamists with in India and hundreds of people got raped or butchered in the name if Allah. It can be repeated, beware of these islamists.
Hahaha
कभी सास भी बहु थी
वाला टोन है
I have heard the story of a Kashmiri pundit a couple of years back. Till date it was the most horrific thing I have heard. I haven’t had the courage to watch the TKF because I know deep down the reality was actually far worse.
You think it’s propaganda? What is seriously wrong with you mate.
Did you actually know how many died that time.. 1700 and do you also know how many were pandits in them search. And don't be Andhbhakt
News laundry is a great example of potraying half news in whichever way they are told.
If we talk about BJP you make it nations matter,
If we talk RSS you make it India's religious matter,
If we talk about the movies direction/and narration you make kashmiri pandits matter...
Who the hell are you, are you nuts...
Watch jai bheem see there pain and suffering too. This community is facing same situation from 1000 of years. There homes are burn there women are raped and men are killed.
@@Abhishek-hk3ql This is naxal laundary where they preach an Islamo - Leftist narrative. TKF shows directly what can be in 2.4 hr movie but it's woefully short on depicting actual atrocities that happened during the time on Kashmiri Hindus and even moderate muslims.
About alpana's "context"
Lol....how can instablity be the context of a religion based genocide??? Instablity results in anarchy, violence between state and public not religious persecution.
Separatist movement was also there in North East. North easterns did not kill people in the name of religion. They targeted army and govt officials. Their organisations did not have names in the name of religion.
There is no kashmiri terrorist organisation named like "kashmir liberation front".... Most of the names are like Hizbul mujahideen ( army of God) , jaish-e-mohammad ( army of prophet).
All the cases are now being opened justice will be served
I don't think entire background of the Kashmir can be shown in a 3 hr movie. The point of making The Kashmir files was to show the pain of the Kashmiri pandits which was not covered in depth. And the reaction of Kashmiri pandits post watching the movie itself shows the way they relate to the movie. Also, like NL team, many people are disappointed with the movie because it has only underplayed the the pain of Kashmiri pandits.
usme kisine nhi r@ndi rona nhi Kiya
More than that, the calls for banning the movie or considering it to be harmful are as senseless as using it in the form of a political tool..a nice initiative was destroyed because of both the types of factions 🤦🏻♂️..and the cherry on top is the comparison with Schindler's list
Being a kashmiri pandit.. I am overwhelmed to see support in against of this video and in favour of the movie.. Thank you for believing us more than this channel
Movie ese hi bnti hn chomu
The truth is that all of these people don't give a shit about KPs or Kashmir's history. The news channels care about the narrative and propaganda and are worried about satisfying their bosses, while the filmmakers, producers care about the financial return from the movie.
Hi NL, I make a point to watch every episode of yours and frankly I respect the type of reporting you guys do, but I can't wrap my head around this one. In the video you agree that the KPs have gone through those horrific times and I understand it's a sensitive issue to be discussed, but I can't understand how in the same breath you deem the entire movie as a "propaganda". You do realise how demeaning that is to the pandits who actually went through that ordeal, how their emotions are bursting out in movie theatres. They are not crying because someone made a "propaganda" movie on them, but they are crying because their pain is now atleast being portrayed in a mainstream movie.
You might assume it's a "propaganda" just because the context for the exodus is not shown in the movie nor does the movie mention jagmohan or bjp. Let me ask you this, did you ever see a collective meltdown by the pandits or other hindus when movies such as Haider or Mission Kashmir came out? Even these movies and many others showed only one aspect of the pain of Kashmiris and willfully ignored the pain of pandits. But you never saw people collectively declaring these movies as propaganda. Please do not water down the pain of the people genuinely affected by this dark episode of history.
Are you saying those movies are propaganda, like this movie? Or that none of them are?
Both of those movies by the way, do not claim to be based on actual events.
Haider in fact is actually a retelling of Hamlet.
The basis of Sekhri calling the film propaganda is because it blames all Muslims, leftists and JNU students(!) for the Kashmiri Pandit exodus and massacre, while conveniently leaving out who actually was in power at the Centre and in the state. Further, BJP has been in power 14 years out of the 30 odd years since the event. So solely blaming leftists (who have never held power independently or in majority) for the continuing plight of the KPs? That's a clearly deliberately skewed picture that exonerates the BJP and rightwing parties, HENCE why it can be dubbed propaganda.
Bruh cause the movie is made by that PSYCHO Agnihotri.
Like rest of the Channels NL never had the maturity to see the things for what it is! If it was made like Jodha Akbar, Shikara, Padmavad and any other movie BULLYWOOD have ever produced, of course in the name of bhaichara and covering both the sides, NL would have soothing opinion. I mean, who the hell are you to judge a situation? Your responsibility is to bring the facts forward and the individuals watching you will shape up their opinion by themselves.
@@sujith6289 if facts are only brought forward for people to form opinions on them, then why bother at all? Why not only circulate opinions? Bro, what I mean is, fact - by definition - is what is the case. You're not allowed to form opinions at all! Unless you wish to subscribe to Vivek Agnihotri school of thought that facts are not facts.
Why would movie blame jagmohan? KP are themselves thankful to him . The guy wrote letters informing center on situation of kashmir. And BJP ? Lol . They were not even in power . They were giving support from outside. Will you blame blame Janta Dal United , if something goes wrong in Kashmir?
Ppl who says Kashmir is not interegal part of India are infront of you ..newslaundary shame on you
Where did he say that?
The Kashmir files is based on real life events that happened in the past, I don't think it's something to be joked about or made fun of.
But no one can deny Kashmiri Files was a long due truth thats the world was not aware of, whatever you say but Kudos to Mr.Vivek Agnihotri for showing the reality, things happened the way it is and to correct it one needs to acknowledge it first, nor deny nor trying to keeping it low will correct the wrong.
How it is reality when the data shown in the movie contradicts the data of home ministry and RTI. There are still 808 pandit families living in kashmir, this movie didn't show the facts
more like just knew a little until a movie over it was made. like barely ppl knew about the case of 'Jai Bhim' or how many ppl hardly know detailed of "godhra 2002" or even seem to forgotten the so big controversy of 'Hijab'. we humans are real forgetful. and too gullible to be influenced over how we percieve.
Seems this channel is part of lutyens cartel aka urban naxal with gross leftist thoughts
Mooz (L3m) Majority=EXTR3M 1STS DOMINATE,MODERATE Mooz (L3ms) =irrelevant
There r 0 MOOZ (L3M) MAJORITY NATIONS where ALL 3 CONDITIONS r fulfilled
-nation is secular democracy
-minority Numbers don't decline
-minority=PM
MOOZ (L3ms) when they become majority deny rights to minorities which
MOOZ (L3ms) ask when they r minority
@@Zahra.07 Movie is based on interviews of people rather than data of Ministry. Go and ask kp family everyone are able to relate with the movie
This dude news laundry is itself totally biased. When someone showing in it's film one person' s side that is fine . No body questioned Haider, mission Kashmir, fiza, film makers to show kashmiri pandits side
Those films you mentioned here never claimed to be based on real incidents.
As I know fiza is fully fantasy film and Haider was an adoption of Shakespeare's Hamlet.
@@TheAmitkhandekar really your argument is just this...........a film based on Kashmir in the era of 1990 doesn't talk about the genocide of Kashmir pandit and shows us why terrorists picks guns and kills innocent people because they are oppressed is just fine because they said 'its not based of real incidents'
@@TheAmitkhandekar btw do watch the news laundry articles on haider
Yeah biased like indian ppl, whatabout Gujarat case when 2000 muslims were burnt alive
What about 1 lakh kashmiris killed and u cry for 399 pandits killed
What about mass rape in kashmir by indian armyin kunan pushpora
What about Jammu muslims that were killed in 1000s by hindu extremists
Nivedita Menon-th-cam.com/video/mdmxHTDJ5qk/w-d-xo.html
Bitta karate-th-cam.com/video/VsDhlCBCD7Q/w-d-xo.html
Girja tikoo-th-cam.com/video/hHw_dA5e4OA/w-d-xo.html
Yasin Malik-th-cam.com/video/mzJuuxOVzHQ/w-d-xo.html
Bk ganjoo ravi khanna-th-cam.com/video/ydfZ0VgGNXg/w-d-xo.html
Inki real story use hui thi Kashmir Files mai
Exodus video-th-cam.com/video/7tXX7caN2tU/w-d-xo.html
This film got promoted only after its release....This is a true story if it's true you should respect it...This movie is a masterpiece if you watched this movie you will never say it's a propaganda..
I can feel hypocrisy in you too...all are same no difference
Jhoothi khabar ko dikhana utna bada gunah nahi hai ... jitni sachi khabar ko chupana hai and thats what vivek agnihotri had done in film.
I agree the story of kashmiri pandit is true bas usmai vivek ne apna agenda ghusa diya hai
Selena, Learn about Parzania too. Then talk about hypocrisy.
Movie is a total propaganda.
Nope, The movie was full on propaganda, I am not denying what happened to Kashmiri Pandits but this movie is a propaganda
@@avinash_1341 real id se aa mulle
Whatever may be the "Context"....
Sectarian Killings and Genocides cannot be justified under any garb. It is the paramount Crime.
Some blame to the painful outcome can be attributed to the mishandling of state elections and other prevelant political issues by the centre and the state.
However the role of Islamic clergy or Radical Islamization of the culture of Kashmir had a much much larger role.
Interference of Pakistan (Mostly through pseudo-religious comradary and terrorism training) and the incompetence of the govt. agencies in mitigating the threats led to what we see in the film.
Yes killings cannot be justified by self victimizing
True.. Bro I am also kashmiri pandit.. I am overwhelmed by support in the comment section... I thought followers of newslaundry may believe its propaganda. I am glad people aren't.. Thank you for believing us
@@rashikakaul1098 @Rashika Kaul you're fooling yourself big time if you think that Akash Banerjee, NewsLaundry, etc are Neutral. Look carefully and their hatred for dharmic civilization would come to the forefront. Do you think they hate BJP because of the economy and inflation? Haha!! They hate it because it has traditionally been a face of Hindu assertiveness. That's all. And it's a big roadblock to the Mulla-Marxist-Missionary nexus.
@@rashikakaul1098 may i know what propaganda have they did in this video unlike it's other counterparts?
@@livelifekingsize..9945 And where did you get this stat from?
Arnab has gone bonkers ! Luckily, the man didnt cry. This is Indian journalism at its lowest.
Sibling rivalry, man !
Aatankwadi gatividhiyon mein aage !
Everyone is no. 1, not no. 2.
No one in the sense of chutiyapa and randapa🤣🤣🤣
I thought it's the same everyday, isn't it!
This islamists’ slave portal tried it best to mock the genocide by funny music and what not, shows these are not journalists but dirty warms. They are not targeting a movie but a genocide which took place by islamists with in India and hundreds of people got raped or butchered in the name if Allah. It can be repeated, beware of these islamists.
In last 7 years paltu media is at his height...FEKU is only blamed for this. He is the father of GODI
There are two types of Media in India: Godi Media and Lodi Media.. and there is no such "Independent" Media left in India... So start accepting your identity of being Lodi Media with as much grace and honesty as the Godi Media houses do 🙏🙏
EXMuslim from Kashmir here - when I was small child i often asked my Parents and elderly villagers why do we have these abandoned Temples ( Where Locals would also Urinate on Shiv Ling and call it Demons Cave )and many many broken burnt Abandoned Houses they simply replied there were group of Evil people who used to worship Shaitan so Allah had to punish them ;; I was curious since then ; and also would wonder How does Allah do this ;; and when I gradually grew up I began to research and found out that it's not Allah but our own people who were involved in this Genocide ;; I also came to know many Muslims who were also killed because they were interested in Indian Govt Jobs and some who supported Hindus ;; ; they problem with Journalist / Politician's / General Public in Islamic Majority region is they are all united and they do not allow any other Voice to come up apart from that of their when they have their agenda of Jihad ( Gazwa E Hind ) ;; Did you know you can search any old News paper in World you will only hear news of Atrocities on Kashmiri Muslims by Indian Army and they are often reported one sided and exeggerated by making Muslim appear the worst of Victim who needs all urgent support..
And Islamic Prachers like Zakir Naik ; and local Mullahs of Kashmir always spread hatred against Indian Army ...My msg to felloe Kashmiris if we join Pakistan we are going to be loosers it's a Bankrupt Country where Chinese have invested and indebted it so heavily it is very less likely it will ever come out of Poverty if we choose independent nation how will we be able to function ?? What if China or India Attacks us with its Army ?? So I believe we are safe with India and let's hope we make Kashmir what it was which is only possible by giving up Religous Fanatcism which is spread by our Mullahs day and night.. and if any one does Critical Questioning on Islamic Scriptures one will easily understand that Islam is Man made Religion Eg There's a verse in Quran Muhammad was attracted to Zainab , the wife of his adopted son Zaid. Muhammad received a revelation from Allah that he should marry her. Muhammad’s adopted son divorced his wife so that Muhammad could marry her. Allah abolished adoption in Islam so Zaid was no longer called son of Muhammad. How convenient ?
Muhammad had sex with his slave girl when his wife Hafsa cought him on her bed. Muhammad made a oath to his wives that he would stop having sex with his slave girl. But Muhammad received a revelation from Allah (Surah 66:1-2) absolving him from the oath so that he could have sex with his slave girl.
Muhammad wanted to divorce his wife Sauda who had become old and plump. But she requested the prophet not to divorce her and gave her marital priviledges , her nights to Aysha , Muhammad’s favourite wife.Muhammad received a revelation from Allah ( Surah 4:128) praising his wives for this arrangement.
Muslims claim that Quran is the eternal word of Allah. These verses prove that revellations were from Muhammad ‘s own mind. Muhammad justified his sins. Quran can not be the word of Allah.
These news channel reporters have even sold their souls for TRP 😂
The authenticity of Alpana's reporting is also equally questionable as of todays reporters. Even she is not an authority on the topic. Her view are her personal just like the views of any other media of today.
remember Barkha dutt
Why the duck you take these NL people seriously?
*If Kashmir was well reported in 90's then current generation and even previous generation shouldn't lack context, lol.*
Most of these things are even missing from History Phd studies and research papers and thus calling it well documented in itself is quite a propoganda.
I’m sorry there is no context or deeper thinking when it comes to barbarism that happened there. Unless you don’t think what happened to Kashmiri Pandits was barbaric. Some times I guess being too smart and intellectual is a bad thing. Some times it is better to look at things in a binary fashion.
There is no debate about the barbarism. The debate is about milking a tragedy to earn crores, and promote phobia.
@@lspforindia No such thing as Islamophobia. Islam is a jewish lookalike death cult, and should logically be feared.
@@lspforindia there can be debate on policy. But debating on truth is stupid. What he suggests is stupid! People were killed and made refugees. And a bitch comes a says “context”. This is called putting doubt wer der is nothing to doubt about. They are trying to white wash their sins.
@@lspforindia Did VRA know his movie make crores? It was a modest movie with NO publicity.
@@lspforindia .. .. What kind of phobia??
You have fallen so low
From Criticising a Political Party to Criticising own Nation & make mockery of Pain and suffering of Thousands People.
Bravo 👏
Propaganda movie made to earn money by selling agenda and pain of pandits is not called " Criticising own nation ".
It's the Vivek who is feeding on the corpses of pandits and mocking them for own benefits
While the context is important, one cannot argue against anything bad that has been done in the past. We should not shy away from talking about serious issues like Kashmiri Pandits exodus even if it triggers a certain section of the society.
Unless you feel the same about other sections of society and there grievances, then you are a hypocrite. Your last sentence shows that you possibly hold a bias.
@@devianadkar7969 We should remember the history. Forgive but never forget and have sympathy towards any marginalized section of the society. Now tell me where do you see bias here? As a true liberal who is conscious about social issues one should feel and talk about all sections equally not just one.
This is very interesting, a film is being called a propaganda without any reference whatsoever to it's contents. This is crazy.
Yes, because no matter how real any movie is, it is never "advertised" on news channels, even if they r documentaries. Also a movie can never show full context of so big genocide and cruel things, and they r saying it's whole truth.....also it's very loud in media that this reality was hidden from the world...?like wtf? Now if u don't study history, whose responsibility is it to tell u what happened? I don't think we need to know every bad thing happened in thee world, and if we do, them READ HISTORY!!!
Bro, I was born in Srinagar in the early 90s... my grandfather (Lt. General Retd. PVSM,AVSM,VSM) who was a Major General then was the chief of staff of the Kashmir Valley-based Corps Headquarters. .... my whole family can attest that things were shown out of context and without thorough insight or background research in the film. Also, the time timeline of things were grossly muddled up ( half the things shown in the movie did not even happen at all or did not occurs in the late 80s- early 90s. This film is emblematic of an extremely heavy handed and erroneous representation of actual facts in the garb of ideology.
Shame on you abhinandan sekri...you justified the KP exodus! Thank God you and your news laundry is a small irrelevant organization so frankly no one takes you people seriously! You ppl are no different from bitta karate
just wow. So film maker didn’t say this is a true story, or what he’s showing you follows a timeline, also had poor budget yet PM and CMs are lining people up to watch the movie. I don’t know if this is not propaganda then what is. kudos to you for accepting openly you don’t care about truth.
@@sarthakkukreti2444 😂😂 abdul puncture wala making up stories.
Watched the entire video, waiting for the part when you guys actually explain how the movie is a propoganda. I understood your point that the mainstream news media is going bonkers. But come on News Laundry! for how long are you going to only talk about the mainstream media segment? Without even mentioning about what's shown in the film, do you think by playing some funny background music and showing cheaply edited clips of the director, you'll manage to deviate the minds of your viewers? The title of your video and the content within has contradicted itself. It's amazing how certain media segments including yours are trying their best to come together and call this movie a propoganda. Some did so even before the trailer of the film had launched.
There have been a few movies earlier which claimed to show the 'truth' regarding the atrocities which were committed against the indigenous people living in the Kashmir valley, it's ironic they managed to do so without even a single mention of the crimes which actually happened and conveniently glossed out over the genocide of Kashmiri Hindus. I wonder where were you then NewsLaundry? Despite the confidence of the makers of this movie right from the word go. As opposed to the usual escapist and evasive disclaimers, this movie's disclaimer does not distance the makers from the movie. Instead they own upto it which shows the faith in their research.
As the nation talks about the plight of Kashmiri Pandits today, I could see your so called 'concern' when you talked regarding the earnings of the film to be distributed. I say, show some more of this 'concern', for the sake of your 'independent' and 'true' news coverage. Kashmir Genocide is just one chapter among the many other dark events this country has witnessed. I challenge you guys to talk about these issues as well
1) Noakhali Massacre
2) Direct Action day
3) Hyderabad Razakar Massacre
4) Moplah Massacre
5) Bengal Famine
Can you do that for us NL? Can any of your other media allies do it for us? Are you guys running out of replies or maybe, uhm propoganda?🙃
Sincerely,
A concerned Indian. (or a Bhakt/Sanghi/IT cell bot in your 'context') ;)
The para you've written you are just same in the line who is praising the movie, i think you just don't understand what newslaundry want to say that just don't make your perception just by watching a movie because the director has it's own agenda you can se his interview with saurav dwivedi of lallantop you can see understand why our pm and everyone praises this movie kyunki bhai chunaw aa rhe aur bjp ko 80, 20 ka khel khelna h.......i hope u understand. Just read a book "Our Moon has Blood clots" by Rahul Pandita.
👌🏻👌🏻👌🏻
@@rajaryan2638 Kashmir: It's aborigines and exodus, My frozen Turbulence in Kashmir these are two more books we all should read, agreed. BJP praising the movie for votes agreed as well, but when it comes to declaring certain content as propoganda you need to talk about the content first and maybe the situation hovering around it later we can see only the later has been discussed without specifying which section of the film convinced these guys that it's fake.What about certain media outlets, politicians who are going to the extent of denying the genocide to support their views and just to oppose the government?
@@digvijaypatil9438 So what you want that these type of movies make and burn our country you can see the people's video after watching the movie how the threatening to minorities is it okay for anyone or for country.....this movie is only made to make money to play with our sensitive feeling and make most out of it just try understand man.
@@rajaryan2638 There should be room for debate, discussion, talk amongst people of all kinds of ideologies and thinking rather than mindlessly cancelling each other out so that there won't be any need to make another new movie after 32 years and cry who's wrong and right. Being a media student I've had my own share of healthy discussions with my teachers inspite of differences in our thinking and even my friends who are from the minority. Not every incident which happened in this country was just for a political or economic gain, many have been based on the indigenous civilization as the target and it's destruction the sole motive. You have the right to disagree with me but i would strongly suggest you to read about the topics I've mentioned in the ending of the main comment. As far as a conversation is concerned if we choose to be silent on everything as if it has never happened, we will become a society which has no understanding of it past, which will live in an incoherent present and hurtle towards an indeterminate and potentially bleak future.
Anyone interested in becoming like newslaundry .In order to do it you just have to follows easy steps given below:-
1)you can show half-truth or sugar coated truth.
FOR EXAMPLE:-
Daughter > Can I go to the party?
Father > Have you asked your mother?
Daughter > Of course.
Father > Okay then.
In reality,The daughter’s half-truth (or lie by omission) is that she omits to say her mother said « no ».
2)Deny those who are not on your side and labeled them something you don't like such as unbhakt,hindutva nationalist,islamophobia
3)if small fraction of community or someone from that community is doing something wrong then cherry picked it and put the blame on whole society for it.
4)If you are on losing side then become the victim.
5)Make illogical controversy of trending topic in order to be famous.
6)you can also be famous by pleasing the minority community and displeasing & angering the majority community
Long time viewer, and first time commenter. I have loved NL and especially the interviews. I remember seeing this video last year and was surprised that I was unable to remember any criticisms discussed therein. Hence I revisited the video today, sorry to say that while the jibe at Godi Media was good and humourous, the Kashmir Files criticism seemed to stem from a place of personal angst and not objective reporting. Of course, hats-off to the reporter for Newstrack who covered the story way back when but to say that one must understand the context is like saying that the first 30 minutes of Schindler's List should have tackled the 'usurer' trope of European Jews, the rise of the Weimar republic and the disposition of the kaiser. No context can justify killings. I was hoping to see that you would say, "Oh this particular scene has been exaggerated" or This is factually incorrect. But for all the cheeky comments of "Who said facts are facts?" you did not provide any alternative facts or refute the claims of the movie, rather shielded yourself by "context matters". I would have even taken a "The movie isn't well made and should have done a better job of explaining the context" but to say that this is factually wrong is, well, factually wrong.
If you want the viewers to not to believe them , why should anyone believe you ....
Don't believe anyone, hear both sides then research on your own to form your personal opinion. That is my thinking.
You asked a valid question bro...👏
@@arindamkaushik2054 Absolutely correct 👍
Simple, anything the current government (of whatever political party) says is propaganda because they want to stay in power so always be critical of media houses which are supporting the ruling party this blatantly.
UPA govt was shit no doubt about it but the media was critical of it and questioned it but now look at the so called number one channels. Why do you think buying the media was the first thing Modi did?
Because they present facts. lol bro you got eyes ?
Never seen such a cricticism of a film. In dilemma if the actors were paid well or the editor! I did watch this movie just the way I watched padmavat, but a human can connect with the honest reactions of viewers. It’s a great movie!
Mera Thumb Rule toh yahee kehta hai ki jisey Newslaundry gaali de, tum usey hi vote do...
Definition of Andhabhakt loool
@@TheNaser786 tujhe kya lagta hai? Name calling se tu humaara perspective badal dega? Vote toh Modiji ko hi jaaega. Ukhaad le jo ukhaadna hai...
@@TheNaser786 aur tu kya chaahta hai? Akbaruddin Owaisi ko jitaana?
Now after these days i got to know what kind of biased news handle is NL.
The fact is 'there has been some atrocities committed in Kashmir which was unheard before' people are either using this movie for their interest or actual support! But after watching NewsLaundry, it seems that this channel also used the same comic / stupidity to make it news worthy for those who enjoy stupidity!!! Welcome to the world of TRP Bro!
'"..here has been some atrocities committed in Kashmir"
That are not some! They are huge in numbers and well documented in UNO, Human Rights Watch & Amnesty International. Since 1947 thousands of Kashmiri Muslims killed, put in jails, children orphaned & women raped by Indian forces.....
Unfortunately Indian Govt & Media censored/ filtered them before these facts reached to local Indians.
How can a youtube channel work for a TRP ?
@@sandeshdugje4320 Clicks dude!!! More clicks more popularity...
@@rokun3167 lol I dot think you understand how they are funded or even how your logic works.
If they wanted clicks they would simply go the agnihotri way as it would appeal to more bhakts. lol you're such a bot.
@@nadeemahmed7060 no indian army is the most discipline . You must have got this false info. from pakistan journalist.
All that has been said in this video needed a disclaimer that they sympathize with the community and feel bad that it happened in our country. None of that happened. So whatever point the person is making, looks like nothing more than propaganda.
Exactly
If you think that anyone india actually feel bad for the kashmiri pandits, then you must know that india is a country where we even cry on fictional movies. A movie named 'Jay Bhim' came in limelight for some time and peoples actually felt bad and then what? Now something new is here and may be in next couple of months something else will come and that will be in trend. Being sentimental because of a movie shows that how much we know about history and how much we care. People forgot about Bhopal too. Now if someone make movie on Bhopal tragedy then it will be also on trend and everyone will show there tears. These are not tears of empathy, this is something like making money of real stories and having entertainment.
@Invisible Truth for every extremist. You mistakenly replaced extremist with islam...
@Invisible Truth start of what? Using some tragedy to make money and make it a political item to win election?
@Invisible Truth because this way even upper caste hindus can be declared cruel for still practicing discrimination, but we know they all are not same. It's actually education what lacks. And if any content in society makes you hate some part of community then it's not the solution, you are just creating another exodus and a chance for film markers to make movie for some other community and earn money.
Luteyans at their best😂😂
The movie is getting the love that it deserves and Kashmiri Pandits are supporting it. Finally their story has been told.
I've seen the Vivek Agnihotri's interview on NL. NL is just showing on clip of 'who says Facts are facts?' repeatedly. But the context on which, Vivek is completely different. It's like someone saying only 89 KPs were killed and some thousand migrated, and present everyone with this fact. But was it really a fact. That's why WHO SAYS FACTS ARE FACT? bolne ko to in medieval times Sun used to revolve around earth and that was a fact .. But is it the fact ?? Bolne ko to NL is a subscription based model and true journalist reside here and that's a fact but WHO Says this fact is a fact?
Tere last naam se hi pta chl rha h k tu khi phado me apne baap ki kamai kha rha h..bhkto ne kl bhi goo khaya tha or aage bhi khaenge...bhakt anpdh hi rhemge chahe jitni mrji english likh le
Dear Alpana Kishore, no context can cover killings of innocents, that too in such brutal manners. So, for tkf it was not necessary to show the context but what it tried to show was the violence inflicted upon innocent hindus that too in a tonned down way. Reality of violence was still not shown.
I am a fourth generation kashmiri pandit myself living in West Bengal ....This is not our first exodus from our own motherland ...This is the seventh exodus...Except Zain al abidin all other izlam_ik rulers were tyrants and imposed shariat on K@f¡r (non believer) as per guided in Qur_'an...This channel is a hardcore urban m@-oist channel running on CC-P Yuan and G-hadists nexus.
Learn about ¡$l@m & Chomunism before it ends !ndi@n civilization
1) Zafar heretics 2) Sachwala 3) Apostate prophet 4) Neeraj Atri 5) Jaipur dialogue 6) Ex Mu$l¡m Spartacus
Lol.. your reply made no sense whatsoever. Now get the hell out.
@@rafiahmed7694he's adding on to it. And its true.
Shame on you abhinandan sekri...you justified the KP exodus! Thank God you and your news laundry is a small irrelevant organization so frankly no one takes you people seriously! You ppl are no different from bitta karate
@Bhadwa Modi buddy in all that Massacre you talked about the state was responsible not the people who were staying there and when you fight in the name of azadi and you dont even consider indeginous people and later on you commit a crime on them that is not only brutal its inhuman lets take the godhra as well even when that happened the people who were hindu neughbour did not betray these people while in kashmir neighbour betrayed them that was the main reason this had to be addressed in visual medium now with regards to freedom if you actually wanted freedom you would have involved dogras, hindus, as well however it was not required and only wanted islamic state hence it becomes important to remove vigilantes that protest it as even when india freedom movement it was not raised for one community and i am not supporter of bjp but i am supporter of indic civilization.
Sad that you are severely underplaying plight of kashmiri hindus in the garb of context I don't think anywhere in the world liberal media is so insensitive to victims and please tell me in what context is the things that happened to kashmiri hindus is okay to underplay
True no one discussed actuall proceedings who were responsible for murder ...why manmohan called Yasin Malik.
Newslaundary worst episode
Yes, I thought them to be neutral but they're not.. They're just like godi media.. But of cong n left.. I appreciate content on lallantop and deshbhakt akash Banerjee.. On the kashmir files being kashmiri pandit myself
@Susan Joseph exactly
@Jagdish Rajpurohit sham for center, you serious?
Newslandry salute to ceo of this channel man with atmost respect never ever u can buy nor bend them great respect from south india
Newslaundry filters media ... Why not TH-cam things ... ?
Like dhruv rathee and string
Aktk and quint ..etc ..
Great way of saying "Bas hum hain ji" is liye news zinda hai...!!! great way to praise yourself... and give yourself medals.... awesome..!!
just look at genuis Arnab showing world how big he is and how much better he is than other news channels, instead caring about education, employment, poority of india he cares about trp that he is 200percent bigger 😂😂
Wah modi ji wah .
Can anyone please fact check ―
Abhinandan sekhti's neighbours says that his Abhinandan's mom has spent her life in the kotha on the GB Road between 1980 to 1995. And Abdul was her regular client in those days.
Ive seen even the non right leaning Kashmiri hindus explaining their pain. And NL saying something was "Fully reported" is so blatent, when even today so many facts aren't reported at all in Mainstream media; when back then there was barely any other source except politically surpressed media. Journalism can never be without a bias, because journalism isn't report of facts but more of opinions. So why do we believe words of a 'Journalist' from kashmir and not the words on Kashmiri hindus?
Kashmir files movie was a real slap on the face of these journalists trying to hide the truth! Now no non Hindu person is talking about supporting Hindus or kashmiri pandits where are those bunch of morons who expected support from us instead when something went wrong with them cuz they know keeping their mouths shut ryt now is the only best option for them since they can't go against it cuz the movie comes with proof of their real colours of their ancestors!
I tend to agree even though I'm pretty left leaning myself, wiki says only about 80 kashmiri pandits were killed but as someone who has talked to many families who ran away from kasmir the real number seems to be much larger and abhinandan calling it exodus instead of genocide is a big turn off.
But well you can't agree with someone on EVERYTHING so that's that I guess
@@akutenshi6946 yeah just 80-90 is a figure that could be obtained by RTI which entirely based on administration at that time which was really very poor . Many left kashmir and many stayed out of which many died ...whose bodies couldn't be recovered . So in such scenarios it's better to go with true victims ....thats is our kashmiri pandits ....and its a true genocide not just exodus (because definition of genocide does not only include physical killing , it also include mental torture that specific community goes through )
@Dilshad what does your label have anything to do with the conversation?
Expound.
Shame on you abhinandan sekri...you justified the KP exodus! Thank God you and your news laundry is a small irrelevant organization so frankly no one takes you people seriously! You ppl are no different from bitta karate
He was requested by the pandits to be their voice !! He interviewed 700 first generation Kashmiri victim families before making this movie!! And I know some families personally.
I thought news laundry was unbiased. Disappointed ☹️
Lol chalo koi nai, der aaye durust aaye
take a few days to reconsider yoour life if you think so. there is no unbiased news channel in the whole world tbh. but to think an openly propagandic channel as unbiased is too much.
Can't you see the fact that kashmiri who been through it are coming out. In large numbers and telling there story and you are saying that a reporter ( i don't know that she did there) is more reliable and has better perspective of what has happened in Kashmir than the actual people who been through that....and your channel is so called better than the rest...
KPs are going and watching but the movie is made by Vivek who is clearly self confessed agenda driven person. Films are at the end of the day work of creativity and art. That news report by the lady doesn't seem like a work of art and creativity. I have watched the original. Also I recently saw a report on some KPs also claiming that Bollywood is trying to mint money from our misery, where is the ground level action, where is the rehabilitation in the last 3 decades. So there are KPs with both views. Which one to believe?
@@yashy7610 @Yash Y file are work of creativity and art but that doesn't not means they are not true....art has always been a way of expressing truth and providing a voice so that it reaches masses ... isn't it. And these so called report ..... are you kidding me.... everyone present a reporte tha t favour there agenda....and indra gandhi herself accepted what has happened with KPs letter is openly available , can check yourself ....so i don't know who these fack / bought KPs are you taking about.....and rehabilitation has not happened till now does not mean that it should never happen in future .....and this is the reason we need movie like these to bring the suffering to people to public ....so that they can get what is denied of them.
Lol google panun kashmir criticizes Amit Shah. Listen what KPs living in Kashmir are actually saying. 🤦
@@yashy7610 Some KP s? Show us one! Haven't you seen hundreds of KPs thanking n blessing the director for finally showing their truth? Truth has no agenda!
@@kukkisri leave him, he is in denial. I wish one day the same thing should happen to him then only he will get to know FACTS!!??
Arnab Goswami comparing his experience of being in jail for five days to the exodus and mass murder og Kashmiri Pandits - there is no higher insult. It proves that these news anchors and filmmakers feel nothing for Kashmiri Pandits and are interested in making money out of their tragedy.
One news anchor out of thousands does this and then you claim "all journalists are bad and use money" Surely they do but not all do this ONLY for money reason. Can say same about print or other medias who jumped in hathras but can't come here in rajasthan (crimes on dal1ts are very high here)
laundry hi karte rahna apane pichvade ki.....mirchi aur bhi lagegi aane vale time me. 😉
Usko koi drugs do.
@@Sanjay-ub7eq If all crimes on Dalits are reported our news media won't have time for anything else. Just check the statistics of NHRC for that. And Indian government and Indian media is ignoring it, whichever party comes to power. Hathras was reported not because if happened in UP, it was because of the nature of the case. The victim was denied treatment and died, police burnt her body, the parents couldn't even see the body, the entire Valmiki community got offended - these visuals was shocking. And to top it, no political party leaders were allowed to visit the place and Hathras was guarded with heavy police force. Dalit leaders were challenged openly. Why was Nirbhaya Rape given attention? It was because of the nature of the crime. Rape cases of Bishop Franco is reported by the independent media houses, so was the case of Bhavana. If one gos by the logic that only cases from BJP ruled states are given focus, these wouldn't be highlighted right? And what Arnab said was unforgivable. And all the media houses scream nobody spoke about Kashmiri Pandits. Which of these channels spoke about Pandits all this time? Did they at least have a hashtag campaign? Did they pressurise the government to speed up the return of Pandits to the valley? Where were they until this movie? Newslaundry, which is run by many journalists from Newstrack did cover the issue much to chagrin of the government then. Vivek Agnihotri has referred some of the footage and recreated it.
@@benjaminnetanyahu8582 I don't need a movie to teach me history. I feel bad for humam tragedy and when it happens to my Indian brothers and sisters I feel it even more. All one needs is empathy. But Arnab, who compares his five days in jail with the plight of the Pandits, hardly feels any.
If for rw we have something called godi media, for lw extremist we have “lodu” media
Liberandu media
17:18 how could she says that kashmir could break away from India ye to possible hi nahi tha bcz jab tak nehru ji zinda the unhone 40 -50% indian constitution ko waha sanshodhan se parid kar diya tha aur fir indra gandhi ji ne abdula ke sari sarte ko side dustbin mai rahke 70-80% constitution waha parid kar diya tha aur now present govt did it 💯% so constitutional way kashmir is integral part of india facts prove me wrong here
The "constitution" doesn't mean anything. It's not god.
I've never understood people like you who quote the constitution like it's the Bible or Qur'an or something.
Especially when the whole point of Kashmir breaking away is to be free from the constitution or country.
A big supporter of NL. I think the videos from the series "reporting from kashmir" are absolutely marvelous. True journalism. However, If the film is based on propagandist agenda, your review is one too - we have to accept that kashmir has been reported in an angular sense historically. Look at CNN BBC or any international news media outlet - they have completely missed out the exodus. Its like if the sufferer is of a certain religion, its more of a suffering than if it is from some other. Peddling non sense is not proprietary to any side - all sides involved in kashmir reportage should realise this
They are nothing but left ki godi
@@Arthur-od9wz lol
the godi are the scum of the society
these people are rather doing the gods work
True! It's high time people realise that going extreme left or extreme right is only going to make you a propagandist! Stick to rationality and call out bull shit on either sides. No one is fighting a war here, and certainly no one is going to emerge as a winner. We are all in this together, and together we should support rationalism!
It's good to show history and I am pro for it.
But there were many reasons it might have not come to limelight them..many more things happened at that time like Nellie, hashimpura, I think some nagaland issue as well...
Don't know why but perhaps 1980s and 1990s was such a time where certain news were ignored
My thoughts exactly. Thank you for articulating it so well.
Good to see so-called "neutral" news channels of India getting rattled after the release of the movie. The whole Left ecosystem is shaken and going bonkers in covering up the mess. It's the beginning of the awakening. You won't be able to stop it.
It's completely a false narrative that the Kashmir Genocide was hidden, ask your parents, didn't the news cover it? The VP govt. was criticized hashly for it.
Epic
@@arkodeepdutta1324 yes my parents don't know what kps faced. bjp breaked alliance with vp singh governent and made him resign.
@@arkodeepdutta1324 no they don't know.... Many criminals are free even after accepting their crime on TV. Not single criminal was punished.
I quit watching news channels 1 month ago but today I realised I was right.
FACT & THE #KashmirFiles - By Namrita and François Gautier
As a young journalist, I covered the Kashmir separatist movement approximately from 1989 to 2002. This opened my eyes like nothing else would. In those days, the entire Western correspondents' corps would periodically descend to Srinagar from Delhi to cover the events in Kashmir. At some point, because of the strife, there was only one hotel open in Srinagar, the Adhoos on the Jhelum Bund. The foremost voice in those days was that of Mark Tully, the bureau chief of the BBC News عربي, and an internationally recognised journalist. The Indian National Congress government was then accusing #Pakistan of funding, arming, financing, and training inside Pakistani Kashmir, the Indian Muslim militants (JKLF in those days), and then sending them back across the LOC border to create havoc. Mark Tully’s contention was that it was not true. And in this, he was followed not only by the entire Western correspondent group, but also by most of the Indian newspapers and magazines, stringers, and correspondents in Kashmir (like India Today).
I was the lone voice that felt it made sense, and wrote so not only in the French and Swiss papers (Le Figaro) I was working for, but also in articles in the Hindustan Times, Indian Express and Bombay’s tabloid Blitz. The ethnic cleansing of the Kashmiri Hindus (the term ‘Pandit’ is misleading) shocked me beyond belief: I saw for the first time that a people in the name of their exclusive and intolerant religion, could kill, rape, maim, and chase out another people from a different religion, who had lived side by side with them for generations. Till today, the plight of the Kashmiri Hindus hounds me.
In 2004, I received in the Parliament of India, at the hands of Prime Minister Atal Bihari Vajpayee (photo) the Nachiketa Award for Excellence in Journalism. With it came a cheque of 50,000 rupees and I decided to use the money to curate for the first time an exhibition on the plight of the Kashmiri Hindus www.factmuseum.com/kashmiri-pundits/). This exhibition was opened in Habitat Centre, New Delhi, by Srisri , L K Advani, and was visited by numerous leaders of that time, including Murli Manohar Joshi, Dr Karan Singh, and many others. We then travelled India with this exhibition: Bombay, Calcutta, Bangalore, and Chennai. Then, thanks to the help of Sri Sri Ravi Shankar we showed it in many parliaments around the world: Scotland, England, Germany, Poland, Israel, and others, and in 2011 in Capitol Hill, Washington, which led to a US Congress resolution, taking notice of the plight of the Kashmiri Pandits. This was the first time that the ethnic cleansing of the Kashmiri Hindus was brought into the public domain, much before the film #KashmirFiles
I am also proud to say that shortly thereafter, my wife and I put up an exhibition - the first one ever - on the Hindu holocaust www.factmuseum.com/hindu-genocide-over-the-years/ from the Hindu Kush, where 500,000 Hindus died, while being taken as slaves to Afghanistan, to Mumbai 2011. This exhibition is now permanently housed at the FACT Museum (the Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj Museum of Indian History, Pune), which Namrita and I started in 2012 on 5 acres of land donated by @srisri. It was not enough for us to have only the Hindu holocaust exhibition and the Kashmiri Hindus Habitat Centre replica, we decided also to show - as they were - the tyrants who were instrumental in that genocide, We have for instance, a unique exhibition on the Goa Inquisition (www.factmuseum.com/the-portuguese-and-the-goan-inquisition/) another one on Aurangzeb based on his own records, and one on Tipu Sultan (www.factmuseum.com/tippu-sultan/) has been unnecessarily and unjustly glorified.
Some of these exhibitions brought trouble; the one on Aurangzeb www.factmuseum.com/aurangzeb-as-he-was-according-to-mughal-records/ for instance, which we also opened in the Habitat Centre in Delhi, was closed down by the police in Chennai and seized for 6 months after the descendant of the Nawab Arcot who came to see it and complained to his friend Stalin, now Chief Minister of Tamil Nadu, that it was offensive. He was particularly angry at the depiction of the razing of the Somnath Temple, a painting which was based on an edict (firman) of Aurangzeb, which he had approved and stamped with the Emperor’s seal. @narendramodi, who was then the Chief Minister of Gujarat heard about it in an article published by The Hindu, and called me to Ahmedabad. He subsequently flew to Bombay in 2016 to open our Shivaji Maharaj exhibition 'www.factmuseum.com/chhatrapati-shivaji-maharaj-a-hero-for-modern-india/ with Sri Sri.
Shivraj Singh Chouhanj Vivek Agnihotri The need of the hour for Hindus is to unite, as at present there is an onslaught on this ancient universal spirituality that knows all and accepts all.
News Laundry talking about Propaganda. 🤣🤣 Irony at its best.👏👏👏 The film's clear objective was to showcase the plight of Kashmiri Pandits. If it was series drama, it could have the another side of the story as well. But whatever shown in the movie was truth and nobody can deny that. Even after watching all the chaos around the Islamic countries be it Syria, Iraq, Lebanon, Afghanistan, Yemen, Somalia where people are suffering due to radicalisation of their religion and questioning the significance of it is really absurd.
News laundry launders fake news for money ..
The films objective was to radicalize people and make money for people.
Showing a small percentage as your POV doesn't make something legitimate.
Why are there Kashmiri Pandit organizations who are speaking against the use of such a film for propaganda ?
Ye khud kis ki godi par baith k reporting karte h ...everyone knows this...bolne do bechare ko ..dukh toh bht hua hai inko
the movie showed 4000 kashmiri pandit have died due to this exodus and you know what it's just 300 kashmiri pandit who have died due to that exodus 😂 ... now hope you'll get the proganda subject
@@agnostic_aarif4676 4000 mare ya 400 ...genocide is genocide..tmlogo ki kaum me hi problem hai ...you are literally justifying what happened to kashmiri hindus..seriously..yahi allah seekha raha hai tm jaise chutiye ko
Support kashmiri Pandits.
Denounce the tragedy faced by them being used as a political tool
Support them like the last 30 years? The tragedy they faced is being the subject of the movie?
Seriously !! what's wrong with these channels??? They don't sound like journalist but more like actors not even the good ones.
Next tihari is Arnab after Sudhir tihari.... Legend got the point 😂
Sorry my "intellectual brother" you tried a lot but couldn't convince me to ponder that "the facts are not facts".Each and every facts of this movie are real and all the testimonies(The confession of the real terrorist,the pain of kashmiri refugees and so on) are present on You Tube.It was indeed a genocide not only an exodus.I think the prime intention of this movie is to depict the trauma of kashmiri hindu pandits in 1990 and it has hit the nail on the head.I didn't find any facts in this video that denies the real facts depicted in the movie.Presenting the debates and interviews in a hilarious way is a good strategy for making people ponder the movie as a propoganda.
Moreover the film has got a very less promotion,there is not a single poster of this movie in our Village.
We know how the news channels run in most of the countries but in this concern I'm thankful to the Indian news channels for promoting this movie .
Social media runs on an algorithm so if you have already considered the movie as a propaganda you will get to see videos and posts that asserts the movie as a propaganda and if you search for the ground reality you will get to see all the real facts and concerned testimonies.
I don't know why you are against of Vivek Agnihotri sir even I didn't know him until 11th March but I'm thankful to him because for him now I'm aware of my history which is not written in my history book.
Just a word for u @subham shortz .. poor boy grow up...!
@@Tayyeba_Tahir you should grow up
"Each and every facts of this movie are real and all the testimonies"
Really? Let See
- Just 30 to 80 Kashmiri Hindus died during 1990. Then how this film lying about GENOCIDE?
- In film it is tell that 24 Kashmiri Pandits were gunned down under Rajiv Gandhi central government in 1990s.. But in realty this killings took place in 2003, under the Bharatiya Janata Party-led government headed by Atal Bihari Vajpayee. (Obviosuly a BJP politically agenda movie.)
- An Indian Army officer wife cased against film in court on faking her husband death.
- In film it is show Nadimarg village in broad daylight and shoot Kashmiri Pandits straight into an open grave as their Muslim neighbours watch.
But in reality! It happened in Night & no one saw this as every one was sleeping at that night according to local people of Nadimarg.
There are so much other things! You should must read:
scroll.in/article/1019863/here-are-five-things-the-kashmir-files-gets-wrong-about-kashmir
@@nadeemahmed7060 han gujrat aur bhagalpur me bhi bas 5-10 musalman mare the
@@jairajputana938 Yup i can confirm the same I am from Gujarat and in Godhra kand 10 muslims were killed
Hi NL, In one of the earlier interviews, we got to know Alpana was a replacement in the region for Manoj Raghuvanshi, who had to leave because he was very well recognized for his reporting and getting death threats for his videos. Don't you think this counts under suppressing the press ?
They have become so woke so they will oppose modi no matter what
You have answered your own question.
this comment deserves more likes.
Mooz (L3m) Majority=EXTR3M 1STS DOMINATE,MODERATE Mooz (L3ms) =irrelevant
There r 0 MOOZ (L3M) MAJORITY NATIONS where ALL 3 CONDITIONS r fulfilled
-nation is secular democracy
-minority Numbers don't decline
-minority=PM
MOOZ (L3ms) when in majority deny rights to minorities which
MOOZ (L3ms) ask when they r minority
This is an important fact. If only Archana gave the 'context' under which she got the job to report from Kashmir, NL would not have a limb to stand on
I don't understand what was so funny(background music) about the media talking about this movie, didn't people talk about Lagaan, Life of Pai or other such my movies ever, this was one of the most serious content n u should be talking about that and not who is endorsing it. . Other movies doing good business are RRR, KGF etc, so u can talk about what need to be changed in bollywood then the shit that u r presenting which makes no sense
This channel has an agenda. Think about it
Amazing work 🔥
Hi I regularly watched and follow newslaundry and i liked there work .....first thing i would like to clear that I am totally against what our mainstream media doing in modis era......but one thing I would like to put that कि जब भी हिंदू लोगोंको मारा जाता है हमेशा हम secular लोग granted लेते है....अब आप कितना भी secularism के झेंडे gaado ये बात तो आपको समझनी ही होगी की मारा तो उन्हें इस्लामिक terrorist ग्रुप ने ही था ना......आप ये बात खुल कर नहीं करते.....ये secular लोगों का दोगलापन है.....आज दुनिया के इस्लामिक देश uthakee देखलो (pak,बांग्लादेश) वहां की हिंदू population कम क्यों हो रही है इसपर भी तो हमे चर्चा करनी पड़ेगी की नहीं......भारत के मुसलमानों को तकलीफ देना बिल्कुल गलत है........लेकिन जहां पर भी मुसलमान majority है वहां हिंदू लोगों की क्या स्थिति है वो भी तो देखना पड़ेगा कि नही ......अगर आपका secularism ये नहीं discuss करना चाहता तो.....sorry to say but you are pseudosecular
Can anyone please fact check ―
Abhinandan sekhri's neighbours says that his Abhinandan's mom has spent her life in the kotha on the GB Road between 1980 to 1995. And Abdul was her regular client in those days.
@@massoneman hey dont drag anyone's mother into this.....this is very wrong
@@ashish3505 ये newslattrine इसी लायक हैं.. वामपंथियों को इस हद तक बेशरम बना दिया जाता है.. इन्हें कितनी भी गालियाँ दे दो.. इन्हें कोई फर्क़ नहीं पड़ता। इनके लिए माँ, बहन, बीबी और whore में कोई अन्तर नहीं है। इनके लिए equality, My choice, liberal... Etc.. जैसे chutiyapa के पीछे सब जायज हैं
Mooz (L3m) Majority=EXTR3M 1STS DOMINATE,MODERATE Mooz (L3ms) =irrelevant
There r 0 MOOZ (L3M) MAJORITY NATIONS where ALL 3 CONDITIONS r fulfilled
-nation is secular democracy
-minority Numbers don't decline
-minority=PM
MOOZ (L3ms) when in majority deny rights to minorities which
MOOZ (L3ms) ask when they r minority
@@massoneman facts are facts😂
Dear NL, Bengali people are very peace loving and soft spoken people. Do not judge us seeing him 🤣🤣🤣.
Goswami is assamese. Although Assam er manush ra awesome hoy, ei Gandu ta bitikichhiri hoyeche
@@shudha5214 I totally agree 🤣🤣
@@shudha5214 please translate karo
@@overhaul3579 Assamese are Awesome, but this Di*khead is uncouthly
There are two types of Media in India: Godi Media and Lodi Media.. and there is no such "Independent" Media left in India... So start accepting your identity of being Lodi Media with as much grace and honesty as the Godi Media houses do 🙏🙏
I am sad because of some peoples criticise kashmir files
Don't you think actual Kashmiri pandits know the issue better than so called "journalist" that says I was there
"Beta ye kurta tumhare liye pehna hai.. " 😂😂😂😂😂
I am a regular viewer of newslaundry, just wanted to know when everyone talk about Gujarat riot no one talk about context.. everyone blames hindu but when it comes to other sect, everyone starts talking about context. I dnt know how it justifies the killing on both side.
I too observed the same ..why this hypocrisy!!
I agree with you
Pain of people can't be ignored no matter whether they are hidus or muslim..we should talk about both sides..I can feel the pain of kashmiri hidus as I personally know few off them.. justice should b served.jai hind jai bharat..
Nobody is saying that in Kashmir, all muslims were completely innocent. No, they were not. But when talking about Kashmir the mainstream refuses to see the context. This same mainstream has completely and utterly forgotten incidents like Gujarat riots! He is just pointing out Gujarat riots and similar incidents where Hindus inflicted pain which has been completely ignored and forgotten by the mainstream. First, acknowledge it happened before we can go into the contextualities
Because the context of GOdhra burning, is not a justification for the killing of innocents, see the videos detailing the reporting, they are not denying that Muslim bigotry was behind the violence, but it was not the only thing.
Nothing justifies exodus/genocide, but when people want to use a tragedy to only target one communitiy and orchestrate further violence, there is a problem. Have you seen some of the things said after the movie is over?
@@purnimapurnima8054 soros and wipro is funding such channel they are working for radical left communist missonary marxist they are against hindus
I thought this channel was great for showing facts and proper news.. but now I realised they are only not even clear what they want to say and how they mixed both topics.. this is not the way you saw some sensitive topic like this.
a great punch, tv news has not even praised this much on Bapu anniversary