when i completed the mrs p quest i was like "yeah they should just make this a part of the true ending quest at this point it just works so much better"
I mean true ending is the OG of all secret endings. But Mrs P has so much more lore. True ending we only got why Mr P made the infection my accident, it was a great start but Mrs P ending gives us when, why, before the infection and how much Mrs P meant to Mr p making the Mrs P ending so much better.
I think this quest was less about the lore, and more about the relationship of the potatoes. I actually expected the relatio to be quite toxic, with P not caring about his wife until she got sick, but they actually had one of the most healthy relationships in all of fiction.
Ms.P Hard Took Long for devs VERY ANTICIPATED. Absolutely Great Mr.P Medium We were the one that took long VERY VERY ANTICIPATED. The search for it was insane dawg 💀 (i did not study for exams to get it) Absolute Cinema for me its very balanced.
6:44 I mean, is it really fair to compare a skin that came out five years ago versus the skin that came out five days ago I don’t think so. Personally I would compare them for the last category on which one made the biggest impact for piggy or which one is more iconic so Mr. P would win in that sense and I think it’s really unfair to compare them skin wise
The mrs p skin quest is way more complicated but unique from the other quests, and it hypes you more than the other quests because its been a long time for the skin to arrive, the only bad thing is that THE FRICKIN NPC IS HARDER THAN THE SKIN
Comparing the two based off of the skin design isnt fair because mr p was made before epic tank was the designer and mrs p was made by epic tank probably
Mr p was made by minitoon himself when he also had a much smaller dev team and it started with minitoon IK3AS and optikk only 3 people I don't know how much piggy's dev team grew by plant chapter I know bslick joined at that point (guy over the music that you hear in secret endings or credits) but I know it was way smaller than it is now also piggy book 1 skins was a lot different than book 2 which you could imagine with how better graphics book 2 has also there's an 5 year difference.
Obviously mrs p would be better in terms of quality (such as not having to reset the entire quest if you died once) because it was made by a team of people not just 1-4 people Do wish that most of the old piggy models got this sort of quality change but that would take ages now
I wished more people realized that since everything in book 1 was done by mostly 3 people minitoon he made most of the book 1 skins and built a lot of the chapters IK3Es helped build 9 maps and assisted minitoon with Making 3 other and came up with the sliver paw idea and her and minitoon came up with the inslocince (I probably spelled that wrong) Piggy's dev team as rn I'm pretty sure is well over 10 people I'm pretty sure or more so ofc a skin 5 years later is gonna be better
@@EluoVERSAUCE I know that's why I said I wished more people realized that the other part of my comment is for people who is hating on the Mr p skin who may not of know the original dev team.
no way your comparing a 4 year old quest that was made by Minitoon and this one with alllot more devs and the graphics,designs ,animations all better then how they were then
Mrs p 2nd quest was literally guessed, if it wasnt solved on the 1st day then it would have most likely been solved the 2nd. Mrs p quest had like 1 whole step and there was many hints pointing to city, i was always surprised no one found out sooner tbh
If I'm honest, I didn't like the Mrs. P quest nearly as much as the true ending, the Mrs. P quest was a bit.. weird, and I like the true ending due to it explaining how the infection happened, not about some love between potatoes. The Mrs. P quest, was insane, but not in a good way, Having to put in codes and the color puzzle is just.. Bad, the plant part of the Mrs. P quest, finding the parts of the Mrs. P portrait was, again, pretty bad, then the 'Memory' Part of plant being replaced in the Mrs. P ending, which is a good change, but the way you finish mainly ruins it, finding hearts to make them run into each other is kind of Goofy in my opinion, maybe if instead of hearts it was a picture of the other one you had to give to one might have bade it better, but I just liked the True Ending way more.
I get that but I really don’t think it was bad. Some parts of it are just hard to do by yourself! And while the ending is a little goofy, I thought it was pretty enjoyable!
Gonna one ohnest, if it wasn’t for someone in the server called ‘GamingIsMyTherapy’ I would never have gotten to the puzzle piece part, Thanks to him, I skipped straight to the puzzle peices, we haven’t gotten them all in time sadly. And he had to leave Respects to GamingIsMyTherapy
In my opinion true ending clearly wins. The quest is more logic, mr p skin is way cooler in my opinion ( i just hate mrs p shes so disgusting ) also mr p matches more with the game
I don’t think we should count skins considering Mr. P was made in 2020 and Mrs. P in 2025
Yeah there's honestly a big difference and piggy and his dev team has gotten better at making skins and ect
The quest for the Mrs. P NPC in Build Mode has a ton of lore, more than the True Ending that's for sure.
Fr
@@PiggyGuy just edit the comment
@@spr3out I'll lose the heart
@@PiggyGuy what does the heart mean to you??
true
4:16 two potatoes slamming their faces against the barn door
absolutely beautiful
Exactly 🥹
when i completed the mrs p quest i was like "yeah they should just make this a part of the true ending quest at this point it just works so much better"
I just noticed Mrs. P's flower on her hat is at the same place as TIO's flower on his tophat too. Is it a coincidence?
Hmmm I didn’t even think of that!
That's not a flower tho, it's an insolence eye.
@@IrrufTheWolf Try looking at it in APRP, it will look like a flower with the insolence eye colours.
it should have been released on valentines day tbh
The quest brings a tear to my eye,when the skin came out I ofc had to get it and so for the miss p npc and till this day I’m still so tired 😴
I mean true ending is the OG of all secret endings. But Mrs P has so much more lore. True ending we only got why Mr P made the infection my accident, it was a great start but Mrs P ending gives us when, why, before the infection and how much Mrs P meant to Mr p making the Mrs P ending so much better.
I think this quest was less about the lore, and more about the relationship of the potatoes. I actually expected the relatio to be quite toxic, with P not caring about his wife until she got sick, but they actually had one of the most healthy relationships in all of fiction.
@@donutmaxgaming9674 It was pretty beautiful honestly!
I just realized in the distorted section its not our memories its mr p memories
4:16 Benjerizer has made the advancement [The Birds and the Bees]
6:59 i think they were testing this with duocara spinning his head after kill
Ms.P
Hard
Took Long for devs
VERY ANTICIPATED.
Absolutely Great
Mr.P
Medium
We were the one that took long
VERY VERY ANTICIPATED.
The search for it was insane dawg 💀 (i did not study for exams to get it)
Absolute Cinema
for me its very balanced.
Dont stop studying because there were youtubers already searching for it
Agreed and In my opinion the Mrs P quest Is one of the best overall
But also to do the true ending you need to beat all book 1 chapters on the first place
although i sufferd in this quest because of how bad my teams were,it was pretty worth it in the end
6:44 I mean, is it really fair to compare a skin that came out five years ago versus the skin that came out five days ago I don’t think so. Personally I would compare them for the last category on which one made the biggest impact for piggy or which one is more iconic so Mr. P would win in that sense and I think it’s really unfair to compare them skin wise
Will I Hate Both Of Them Because It Feels like a feather dream...
We been waitting 5 years
The mrs p skin quest is way more complicated but unique from the other quests, and it hypes you more than the other quests because its been a long time for the skin to arrive, the only bad thing is that THE FRICKIN NPC IS HARDER THAN THE SKIN
My dumb a thought the title was
I tried getting the Mrs P skin on QuestVr
@@HunTerVR-1 least lie
4:17 At the end we finally get potato reproduction ending
6:20 Don´t remind me it was horrible and so unfair for those who worked so hard to get the quest
Fun Fact: You can get Mrs. P and Mr. P at the same time.
This is basically what the true ending should have been
Comparing the two based off of the skin design isnt fair because mr p was made before epic tank was the designer and mrs p was made by epic tank probably
It is a bit unfair, but I still think it’s a valid criticism!
Mr p was made by minitoon himself when he also had a much smaller dev team and it started with minitoon IK3AS and optikk only 3 people I don't know how much piggy's dev team grew by plant chapter I know bslick joined at that point (guy over the music that you hear in secret endings or credits) but I know it was way smaller than it is now also piggy book 1 skins was a lot different than book 2 which you could imagine with how better graphics book 2 has also there's an 5 year difference.
When will you be streaming next
Probably this weekend!
You just earned a new subscriber 😀👍
Thank you!
I didn’t even do the carnival or hospital thing and I still got the skin
Obviously mrs p would be better in terms of quality (such as not having to reset the entire quest if you died once) because it was made by a team of people not just 1-4 people
Do wish that most of the old piggy models got this sort of quality change but that would take ages now
So far only Bunny did
@danaugg9183 As well as Kona and sheepy and tigry
I wished more people realized that since everything in book 1 was done by mostly 3 people minitoon he made most of the book 1 skins and built a lot of the chapters IK3Es helped build 9 maps and assisted minitoon with Making 3 other and came up with the sliver paw idea and her and minitoon came up with the inslocince (I probably spelled that wrong)
Piggy's dev team as rn I'm pretty sure is well over 10 people I'm pretty sure or more so ofc a skin 5 years later is gonna be better
@jeremystarling9885 Yea duh thats what i said
@@EluoVERSAUCE I know that's why I said I wished more people realized that the other part of my comment is for people who is hating on the Mr p skin who may not of know the original dev team.
Erm actually you need to get every book 1 badges to get the ms p photo under the purple car🤓👆
@SomeAverageGuy YOU NEED TO LEAV-
GET OU-
Its been 5 years i think
Imagine someone doing that two quest at same time 💀
That would be insane!
Hey do you remember me? Last night we met and I was bluebear.
Of course!
Literally public servers are just servers of noobs who use tnt to go to the part with ghost doggy and ghost bunny
Play on private server
Mrs p doesn’t get sicker with the kills it’s after a bit of time
she gets sicker over time not every kill, jsut so u know
I figured that out when I was getting footage of her! Thank you though!
@@benjerizer C:
no way your comparing a 4 year old quest that was made by Minitoon and this one with alllot more devs and the graphics,designs ,animations all better then how they were then
It shows how much Piggy has grown over the years!
4:19 lol i would've crashed out if i were you there
Oh believe me I did
Its funny because mr p took 2 whole weeks and mrs p only took 2 hours for her skin
I think we’ve just gotten A LOT better at questing 💀
Mrs p 2nd quest was literally guessed, if it wasnt solved on the 1st day then it would have most likely been solved the 2nd. Mrs p quest had like 1 whole step and there was many hints pointing to city, i was always surprised no one found out sooner tbh
I gotta say this,Mr.p is a bit dumb in the story, Mrs.P is somewhat better
He was just a dude that tried saving his life it got out of hand and he went mad he was more naive than anything
@@jeremystarling9885 I guess you're right about that Jeremy
Tbf Mrs P is better because it’s newer, you can’t say they wound t make the Mr P quest better if it came out now?
They definitely would!
If I'm honest, I didn't like the Mrs. P quest nearly as much as the true ending, the Mrs. P quest was a bit.. weird, and I like the true ending due to it explaining how the infection happened, not about some love between potatoes. The Mrs. P quest, was insane, but not in a good way, Having to put in codes and the color puzzle is just.. Bad, the plant part of the Mrs. P quest, finding the parts of the Mrs. P portrait was, again, pretty bad, then the 'Memory' Part of plant being replaced in the Mrs. P ending, which is a good change, but the way you finish mainly ruins it, finding hearts to make them run into each other is kind of Goofy in my opinion, maybe if instead of hearts it was a picture of the other one you had to give to one might have bade it better, but I just liked the True Ending way more.
I get that but I really don’t think it was bad. Some parts of it are just hard to do by yourself! And while the ending is a little goofy, I thought it was pretty enjoyable!
I enjoyed them both honestly
I don't know why people always compare stuff
i have beat this like 16 times😅
You can just put both endings together
Dude forgot that one came out five years ago and one didn't
I didn’t forget! I still think it’s a valid comparison because it shows how far Piggy has come as a game!
I have a friend called Cat he was 8th
7:05 Its actually the round timer
@@IPlayBrawlstarsWowie it’s both.
Can you try doing true ending with the mrs.p quest
benjerizer is so cute
Like the skin, really don’t like the quest for Mrs.P. The NPC quest really didn’t do it for me.
My favorite is true ending
Want to. E friends😢😢😢
I like how instead of looking for the code we just guessed it 😂
(Btw i was the person who figured out the hospital code :D)
cheese
I was sadly the 48th to get the skin
poley came before mr p
Mrs P npc quest
Can someone help me get ms p? (In my opinion Ms p is better. Why she’s better is. the npc and skin I don’t care about lore)
Mrs. P Quest better
Agreed!
Both are good
Agreed!
The Mrs. P quest quest made Mr. P my least favorite character in the game-
But he was such a caring husband!!!
@ Fair enough.
He was a caring husband, plus he didn't know that the potion would make a whole chaos on the world.
Your basically comparing a quest from 2020 to different and better scripter team making a quest in 2025
I mean yeah, but they’re still comparable and it shows how far Piggy has come!
I perfer mr p quest
Is this a permanent event?
I'm not too sure actually!
well dang it, I’m guessing it’s not so il just do the event when I have time soon, hope I’m not to late
@Spec_Draws You're definitely not too late! It just came out!
Gonna one ohnest, if it wasn’t for someone in the server called
‘GamingIsMyTherapy’ I would never have gotten to the puzzle piece part,
Thanks to him, I skipped straight to the puzzle peices, we haven’t gotten them all in time sadly. And he had to leave
Respects to GamingIsMyTherapy
@Spec_Draws W player!
I perfer Mr. P
OH MY DAYS
Im 40k in the world😈
In my opinion true ending clearly wins. The quest is more logic, mr p skin is way cooler in my opinion ( i just hate mrs p shes so disgusting ) also mr p matches more with the game
IT IS SO HARD NOOBS KEEP RUINING IT
Private servers are free!
@@benjerizer i got it
First comment can i get a pin? Pis❤
W Ben!!
I was the 27th one to get it
Congrats!!!
@@benjerizer thanks!!
@numberoneangel frrrrrrr