Dearest Coach Rozette, plz plz keep being frank and honest, and don't change anything in the way you review all these performances! I just can't express how much I love it, I really appreciate the real comments you gave(based on all the stuff you heard), and the masterful demonstration and precise description and explanation, thank you so much, love ya! btw Your singing is also masterful, touching, and beautiful.
Please continue to keep your candor and authenticity! ❤The reason why I like this channel very much is that the focus of the program is on discussing the real skills of singers. I have benefited a lot from this. If the show is not about a candid discussion of technique, but about pleasing the fans of these singers, who wouldn't just praise them? Then the show loses all meaning.❤
I love what I have been watching so far since when I started to watch your channel. Thank you for everything that you bring to us. I can feel the passion and honesty, so plz don’t change anything and continue whatever way that you are doing right now. Love you,
Just be real, this is the main reason why I like you. The reaction video that I love is not the exaggerated expressions like other reaction channels. It is about the honest and informative review that the coach given. I will back you up for being true
Dear Rosette, I really enjoy that your authentic style of reviewing these videos . Please keep the original way! To me, knowing the trick of the edited music productions would not stain their impressions or their credibility. 好了英文能力只能打到這裡,😂 對我而言,看您的影片我學到很多音樂欣賞和唱歌的技巧和細節,但妳對細節和藝術的追求並不打擊人,反而讓人有信心去思考怎麼運用我們每個人獨特的身體樂器,探索身體能製造出的美妙音色。而我想,沒有太多後製修飾的影片更能服務學習的目標。因此可以理解您期待看到較少後製處理的演出。 謝謝您和Jkai老師投入那麼多時間製作觀看和點評。讓一個三十好幾的阿姨我😂竟然有動力克服五音不全長年不敢在ktv拿麥克風的魔咒,試著拿起麥克風唱歌聽聽自己的聲音。 深深祝福,也希望你們在TH-camr這條路長長久久,讓我們有幸一起進入音樂道路
Rozette, you know this is one of my fav live performance of all time, Tia, beautiful! I would cry every time i listen to this, i think that's because i resonate with the lyrics. :)
as a layman curious about the technical side of all things vocal, hearing all that you have to say about each performance you review is what i really appreciate. love it when you pause to show us the artifacts/pitch deviations you're hearing - it helps many of us untrained ears. also, since the format here is audiovisual it'll be odd to ignore and not point out the mismatched lips (especially like in this one where it's so obvious) 😅. hope you guys keep doing what you want to do. always lovely and fun to hear you (and when you make j too haha) sing!
I really wish you could make comments on Tia's 开往春天的地铁 and 存不存在 from the show "I am singer", which are the best of her performances to me. I felt in love with her singing because of these two songs !
I wish to hear both true and honest comments and reviews AND (if you identify the performance as pre-recording) your review of the singers’ performance in pre-recordings (it’s still their singing and does to certain extends show their vocal techniques and abilities). Love
I don't think that's the original version of Forever Young by Alphaville, not Rod btw. They kind of add the old song into the mix to make it more interesting~
推薦老師觀看Tia在《2020歌手•當打之年》所表演的原創曲目〈存•不存在〉在此曲目中能聽到更多的Belting 。 It is recommended that teachers watch Tia's original song "Existence·Not Existence" performed in "2020 Singer·The Year of the Fight". You can hear more Belting in this track.
please be frank and honest on whatever you feel like to say. I think one of the most valuable point of your review is on how the music industry works in professional way. I really enjoy these videos and learning both singing skills and music production.
actually according to some BTS vidoes in tiktok and the report of the on-site audience, the singers Tia and David in this case, are singing for real. The thing is that, in Chinese music shows, they prefer to record another track after the performance and replace part of the audio where the singers forgot the lyrics to make it to the best. Thats quite common nowadays.
This is a song by a Taiwanese singer-songwriter called Eve Ai. You can check her out! Btw, at the end of the song they mixed the chorus of Alphaville's Forever Young. The intro of this song (the cello part) is also the outro of Alphaville's Forever Young.
The short mixed melody after chorus is not ROD STEWART song "Forever young" but Alphaville " Forever Young". You should clarify the fact for respecting the originator.
I would like to know if there is autotune, prerecorded, or live in a performance. Because i want to know if i am right when singer voice don’t match their face and energy. It really show how much more talented a singer is. Just be true to yourself.
The audio may be edited but definitely not prerecorded. She was not good at lip-synching and her prior prerecorded performance was totally out of sync.
Yes, she is famous in improvisation, almost every time she sang differently. So coach might see something happened because of the video and audio making.
我喜歡老師像現在這樣,坦率真誠的點評,我不會覺得老師是在"批評"誰,老師一直都非常中肯好的壞的有什麼說什麼,這才是最棒的地方。希望老師不要因為某些粉絲的話難過,我們永遠支持您!!
懇請Rozette老師絕對要堅持初衷!用妳最專業、最漂亮的話語,將妳對人聲音樂的知識和解析分享給大眾,這樣才能提升大眾對這個專業領域的常識和音樂素養,也唯有如此才能讓我們更能貼近老師、認同老師對這些作品所做的評論。非常感謝Rosette老師為我們帶來這麼多精彩的Reaction,妳真的很棒👍👍👍👍👍,我非常支持妳!
袁婭維在我是歌手當打之年的歌很值得一聽
Dearest Coach Rozette, plz plz keep being frank and honest, and don't change anything in the way you review all these performances! I just can't express how much I love it, I really appreciate the real comments you gave(based on all the stuff you heard), and the masterful demonstration and precise description and explanation, thank you so much, love ya! btw Your singing is also masterful, touching, and beautiful.
終於做《Forever Young》的reaction了!感謝真實的評論,重新編曲及和音都讓老師融化了。這首合作沒拿金曲真的非常可惜…
非常認同老師說的 ,希望老師繼續保持做自己❤
Love how you commented, be real and that’s how we can learn to appreciate music!
谢谢老师指导我们更能理解学习
請老師保持原始的面貌,暢所欲言,這正是自由世界賦予我們每個人的權利!
當然是希望老師誠實說出自己的感受,同時我們也能學到真實的知識不是嗎?
任何表演都是經過編排的
經過老師的了解與分享給觀眾們理解,這又何嘗不是讓大家也都在吸收進步嗎😂
而且老師已經非常有禮貌了,通過老師的用詞就可以知道老師不希望因為講解歌唱技巧傷害到任何歌迷
忠言逆耳,老師加油~!
陶喆真的是才子
That the reason why we are here! Please don’t change
喜歡老師的專業及真誠,這是多棒的評論❤
这首歌是我最喜欢的之一,编曲,歌唱都非常好
謝謝老師 因為有您的真誠坦率的評論 讓樂壇越來越好 也越來越進步。希望繼續保持這樣的方式與風格 制作更多的影片 感謝您
So nice and professional of you! Looking forward to see more vedio of Tia's live show, she was more than that in these performance you've seen.
Please continue to keep your candor and authenticity! ❤The reason why I like this channel very much is that the focus of the program is on discussing the real skills of singers. I have benefited a lot from this. If the show is not about a candid discussion of technique, but about pleasing the fans of these singers, who wouldn't just praise them? Then the show loses all meaning.❤
從中國好聲音時就很喜歡Tia
R&B 很強的女歌手
還是老話一句,欣賞老師不吹不黑,真實點評❤
請老師用自己喜歡的方式,支持老師做自在真實的自己👍
簽到影片下方給你們點個讚👍
遇廣告看完看🈵
Best reaction program I have come across. Love all your reviews!
就是喜歡老師坦率真誠的點評,希望老師用自己喜歡的方式就好
i'm so much enjoying what you observe and share. Rozette you're like a door to a lovely singing world !
I love what I have been watching so far since when I started to watch your channel. Thank you for everything that you bring to us. I can feel the passion and honesty, so plz don’t change anything and continue whatever way that you are doing right now. Love you,
喜歡老師的真實點評 支持您的堅持!
這首寫得很好很好聽的歌是艾怡良寫的
I like the realness,the truth
後期重錄也是有可能的,上次袁婭維唱的靠近也是事後在錄音室重錄搭配原本的畫面重製播出
真實。是我一開始看這個頻道的原因❤
Just be real, this is the main reason why I like you. The reaction video that I love is not the exaggerated expressions like other reaction channels. It is about the honest and informative review that the coach given. I will back you up for being true
Just be yourself. That's why we love watching your reaction reviews.
Dear Rosette, I really enjoy that your authentic style of reviewing these videos . Please keep the original way!
To me, knowing the trick of the edited music productions would not stain their impressions or their credibility.
好了英文能力只能打到這裡,😂 對我而言,看您的影片我學到很多音樂欣賞和唱歌的技巧和細節,但妳對細節和藝術的追求並不打擊人,反而讓人有信心去思考怎麼運用我們每個人獨特的身體樂器,探索身體能製造出的美妙音色。而我想,沒有太多後製修飾的影片更能服務學習的目標。因此可以理解您期待看到較少後製處理的演出。
謝謝您和Jkai老師投入那麼多時間製作觀看和點評。讓一個三十好幾的阿姨我😂竟然有動力克服五音不全長年不敢在ktv拿麥克風的魔咒,試著拿起麥克風唱歌聽聽自己的聲音。
深深祝福,也希望你們在TH-camr這條路長長久久,讓我們有幸一起進入音樂道路
Rozette, you know this is one of my fav live performance of all time, Tia, beautiful! I would cry every time i listen to this, i think that's because i resonate with the lyrics. :)
Say what you want to say is the best way! Keep it going, don't change a bit!
Love and appreciate your honesty ,keep up with the good work ❤
as a layman curious about the technical side of all things vocal, hearing all that you have to say about each performance you review is what i really appreciate. love it when you pause to show us the artifacts/pitch deviations you're hearing - it helps many of us untrained ears. also, since the format here is audiovisual it'll be odd to ignore and not point out the mismatched lips (especially like in this one where it's so obvious) 😅. hope you guys keep doing what you want to do. always lovely and fun to hear you (and when you make j too haha) sing!
Please keep saying what’s on your mind with the unvarnished truth. Always appreciate your true comments.👍
1.大陸的歌唱節目為了追求完美,大多用一些技術、方法呈現,本來就是公開的秘密。但也都是歌者本身的聲音無誤。為的就是避免現場一次直接來,萬一出麼狀況,會很尷尬,且無法挽救。
2.希望老師還是衷於本色,這樣的節目才會有您的特色。若有類似情形仍然可說,但不必過於糾結,反而變得無話可說;觀眾也無須糾結,當知道只是完美的呈現,不代表假唱,也不代表歌手沒那個實力。
3.同時我也知道,每次的評論僅是針對"當下" "那首歌"的呈現而言,並不能完全代表該歌手的真正評價。
I really wish you could make comments on Tia's 开往春天的地铁 and 存不存在 from the show "I am singer", which are the best of her performances to me. I felt in love with her singing because of these two songs !
keep it real , you are doing a good job
I wish to hear both true and honest comments and reviews AND (if you identify the performance as pre-recording) your review of the singers’ performance in pre-recordings (it’s still their singing and does to certain extends show their vocal techniques and abilities). Love
希望老師能保持初心 真實地說出妳聽到的一切 因為那就是我喜歡妳的原因 如果妳避開了某些妳想說而怕得罪某人粉絲的真實話語 那我只要看歌唱節目就好了 何必來妳這邊聽妳的解說分析 我知道老師曾遭受過某些腦殘粉的攻擊 但我建議杰凱不用把這些聲音翻譯給老師聽 讓她永遠保持在一個最公平客觀的立場去點評 畢竟她也不會去中國市場 也不用怕掉粉 我相信真的的鐵粉都是希望妳說真話的
好棒的講解 雖然有不足 但還是給滿該稱讚的地方。
本來就不是要看老師糾錯藝人演唱,而是點出平常人不會注意到的地方 真的很棒 最近看好多好多這頻道影片 收益良多 好棒👍
希望老師繼續保持,喜歡的觀眾就會留下 不用特地討好所有的觀眾而改變呀
不喜歡的自行會離開…
Nice!! Please do the reaction to the original version ❤
Can come out one episode on Tia’s performance on the song “盛夏光年”, can hear a lot of her belting in that song
強烈建議老師聽聽Tia的阿楚姑娘(比賽版)和開往春天的地鐵 我覺得是她最好的兩個現場 她也是被林憶蓮認證 新生代唱功最好的女歌手
所以說,只有你自己覺得,全部的人都知道她假唱,你在這邊講她唱功….
@@dashingno6所以你说的假唱指的是别人用她的声音ai做成她唱的吗?
@@tia842 所以對嘴不是假唱囉?
我喜歡tia的歌 但一是一 二是二 預錄不是假唱的一種?
@@dashingno6你上中国节目就要按照人家的规矩来,人家叫你预录难不成你能唱现场
我支持誠實講出老師想講的就好. 我覺得老師很中立.沒有任何偏頗吧. 現在都一堆後制/修音的. 講出來讓大家了解一下分別之處也不是壞事.
喜歡老師的點評,真實❤、
推荐歌曲-谭维维(乌兰巴托的夜)
這版本真的與原版本真摯情感表達,相差甚遠。
希望老师能做一期 她的阿楚姑娘
I don't think that's the original version of Forever Young by Alphaville, not Rod btw. They kind of add the old song into the mix to make it more interesting~
推薦原唱艾怡良在紅白的版本 真的好喜歡這首歌( •̥ࡇ•̥ )!
th-cam.com/video/pRG9ATBNHl0/w-d-xo.htmlsi=ZE8IWhdoifXD9spV
覺得可以做forever young 的比較.ᐟ.ᐟ
@CZ Media
可以請老師評茄子蛋、蕭敬騰嗎?謝謝
想看老師點評唱歌總是感情充沛的楊宗緯😊
這首歌真的很美,創作者是艾怡良,或許老師會喜歡她的歌曲?
希望老師可以聽聽看tia的淒美的,是我很喜歡的版本
經典合唱演出❤想起陳奕迅和孫楠於香港電視節目(翡翠歌星賀台慶)合唱的英文歌Without You,既有玩味亦有少許競技性質,希望能聽到老師的中肯點評,相信她會覺得interesting
能看一下張碧晨的live嗎? 她說出道表演 歌手表演
請老師聽原版
推薦老師觀看Tia在《2020歌手•當打之年》所表演的原創曲目〈存•不存在〉在此曲目中能聽到更多的Belting 。
It is recommended that teachers watch Tia's original song "Existence·Not Existence" performed in "2020 Singer·The Year of the Fight". You can hear more Belting in this track.
之前好像点评过了?
@@micheaalheng6397 上次的曲目是〈Love Can Fly〉一樣是Tia的原創曲目,但兩首的風格截然不同,〈存•不存在〉更偏向pop,Tia在《2020歌手•當打之年》經由荒井十一等人重新編曲後,也改變唱法,使用了更多Belting去做演繹。
@@hugh4482 之前好像真的“存·不存在”了。刚刚找了一下应该是被下架了。😂
@@micheaalheng6397 《2020歌手•當打之年》的Reaction影片時常被版權攻擊而下架🥲
Review those live concert vid instead of tv shows.
The audio quality may not be pleasant to be heard but much worth to be reviewed.
please be frank and honest on whatever you feel like to say. I think one of the most valuable point of your review is on how the music industry works in professional way. I really enjoy these videos and learning both singing skills and music production.
actually according to some BTS vidoes in tiktok and the report of the on-site audience, the singers Tia and David in this case, are singing for real. The thing is that, in Chinese music shows, they prefer to record another track after the performance and replace part of the audio where the singers forgot the lyrics to make it to the best. Thats quite common nowadays.
周深的錯位時空
可以请老师评价一下孙燕姿、林忆莲吗!!!!
希望能有tia 「開往春天的地鐵」講解影片🥹🥹🥹
希望tia的粉丝帮我顶上去,麻烦作者和老师多看一些tia的视频,麦克风离嘴很近是她的个人特色,她每一个唱歌的片段都是这样的,不可能她每一个都是忘词预录的吧!还有老师说的嘴型不对其实那是tia的个人咬字方式,前面主歌部分tia唱歌基本嘴巴不怎么张开不代表嘴型不对,我是理性粉丝并不是抬杠,只是希望老师多看几个视频再判断麦克风和嘴形,谢谢
而且前面被安排给老师react的影片好几个都是10多年前的tia连出道都还没刚初登场比赛 时间一直反复乱跳 让老师已经有个既定印象tia的唱法是怎样的 这样根本就已经不客观了 是人都会审美疲劳 老师会感觉好像tia一直都很不稳定 我觉得那个印象塑造成这样已经无力回天
@@nickcheong5305对的,主要前面找的视频都不是她唱的最好的,老师现在对她的印象不是特别好,但没关系,老师第一次听深深唱歌的时候还说这种风格不是她喜欢的,最后还成为深深的粉丝,我相信tia总有一天会被认可的
@@nickcheong5305对的,主要前面找的视频都不是她唱的最好的,老师现在对她的印象不是特别好,但没关系,老师第一次听深深唱歌的时候还说这种风格不是她喜欢的,最后还成为深深的粉丝,我相信tia总有一天会被认可的
這有好什麼好講的,ㄋ❤欣賞Tia,是你的自由,不需要別人的認同,老師他們就是做最真實當下第一次聽的評論,沒有人說Tia唱功不好,請你搞清楚,老師只是針對這首歌而已,而且講這首歌是預錄,這是事實,這根Tia實力好壞無關
去想像,老師為什麼不說黃綺珊那首離不開你是預錄的呢,你有老師音樂的專業,預錄就預錄
想看老師聽艾怡良
想聽forever young
This is a song by a Taiwanese singer-songwriter called Eve Ai. You can check her out!
Btw, at the end of the song they mixed the chorus of Alphaville's Forever Young. The intro of this song (the cello part) is also the outro of Alphaville's Forever Young.
Wish to see you listening to Jay Chou
trailor这首 歌还做不做 好棒!加油!
同样的歌曲Tia还有一个live版本的,一个小哥弹吉他,她唱
老師的點評很好呀~
很喜歡老師·
真誠直接
只是稍微跟老師不同的論點~我覺得應該是後期修音~但應該不會是預錄
想看老師點評袁婭維唱靠近🫡
這首記得是陶喆編的~
开往春天的地铁和golden安排上嘛~~
老師很厲害一聽就知道有沒有修音
The short mixed melody after chorus is not ROD STEWART song "Forever young" but Alphaville " Forever Young". You should clarify the fact for respecting the originator.
想看老師react 丁噹的千年之戀
Please check out Eve Ai! She composed and wrote the lyrics for this song all by herself and of course there are other songs to check out too!
I would like to know if there is autotune, prerecorded, or live in a performance. Because i want to know if i am right when singer voice don’t match their face and energy. It really show how much more talented a singer is. Just be true to yourself.
可以請老師評價周深跟薩頂頂唱的 左手指月 嗎 謝謝
想听一期评孙楠的
推荐袁娅维的开往春天的地铁,还是芒果台的制作好一些,谁也不知道到底是有什么情况。但确实我有时看到一些片段tia 需要看提词器。还有就是有可能老师个人对她一些转音这种类似的风格吧不是很中意,太类似欧美的风格了。但对于一个我这样的听众来讲,相比别的艺人,tia 在自己的专辑上更能融合不同的元素与年轻人共鸣,包括mv和视觉,不会和很多国内的抒情歌一样大同小异,可是因为大环境听众还是更喜欢她翻唱一些流行曲目在节目中。更希望的是国内的歌手都更有自己的特色,像lexie 那些音乐是有创意并且可以下载,而不是都只会翻唱度日。周深JJ 这种更多的是自己有好听的歌,别人的歌也唱得好确实厉害。当然因为这个频道也有所限制,大多数还是live来听。
跪求蕭敬騰REACTION! 從星光到現在 很值得看
廢
@@dashingno6 強
推
不論人品跟政治立場
他的唱功也很值得拿出來評論
我更喜歡單依純那個版本,希望老師能看一下
好像看他看劉雨盺歐,感覺老師會愛上
支持老师保持真实!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
and求review 张敬轩Hins Cheung!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
老師 ! 世界上真的嘢有好多人唔想聽唔接受,做番自己專業的評論就得㗎喇 !
片中的Forever Young 不是rod stewart那首,是樂團Alphaville的歌,不知道為什麼會聽不出旋律有所不同
The audio may be edited but definitely not prerecorded. She was not good at lip-synching and her prior prerecorded performance was totally out of sync.
Yes, she is famous in improvisation, almost every time she sang differently. So coach might see something happened because of the video and audio making.
跪求 米希亞
雖然看預錄也可以學到許多歌唱技巧
但是其實我本身也是喜歡聽live多於預錄的 因為情感的感受完全不同
曾經以為我不會喜歡素人那一集 因為裡面沒一個我認識的 但是我發現我錯了 我反而很認真的關注他們的表現 想要從老師的評語中了解他們唱的好不好聽的關鍵在哪裡
但是如果是修的太嚴重的 感覺不是評唱功而是評百萬修音師的功力了😂
如果是一味吹捧歌藝的頻道 他們的受眾應該是歌手的粉絲 而不是想要求知的觀眾 我不知道這個頻道哪種觀眾群多 也可能都有 因為我看著看著也跟老師一樣變周深粉了😂
最後建議up主還是可以稍微幫老師篩選一下live的影片 雖然你一直強調你們兩個都是第一次看到影片才能有最真實的reaction 但是鏡頭都只有照到老師 沒有照到你啊 所以你是不是第一次看到沒有關係吧😂
Do yourself please,because that’s why I like this channel 👍🏻
th-cam.com/video/VTDnr8qtjLM/w-d-xo.htmlsi=vrfaMord4s-FixHB
Tia這場的表現真的很厲害,給老師看看❤
Alphaville forever young
David arraged this.
所以电视观众说应该这个那个,修音的。和现场观众投票的是两回事。
Sure!!!!!!! Please be honest for the video reaction !!
因為你們看的都是"節目製作出來的演唱版本" 如果是Reaction演唱會版本的就可以比較容易是真實的 但目前這個頻道裡大多數的人是沒有能力辨別現場跟後期的人
他們只希望推薦給你們他們覺得很好聽很厲害的歌曲 但發現被揭密後歌手形象破滅可是他們不會去怪他們的偶像 只會怪你們都在黑
這些節目並不一定都是預錄對嘴的 但有些可能錄影的當下是唱現場的 但節目為了好看會在後期去修音修瑕疵甚至不會跟歌手講
你說的後期修音跟老師說的預錄式(對嘴假唱)完全不同概念 你看看央視春晚能有對嘴的情形出現嗎? 央視春晚是直播節目 當下就播出去了 所以完全沒有修音的問題 但是要上春晚 你得彩排6..7次 即使前五次都ok 但是第六次出現問題 央視馬上會把你節目取消 因為後面還有很多備選的節目
歌手假唱 我覺得是對自己 對觀眾的不尊重 以袁的實力 我沒想到她也會假唱 也許是要配合陶喆吧 我猜
@@里夫-l1b 我不知道你是想護航什麼
預錄也可以修阿 前面幾期也有聽過節目裡的片段也可以聽得出來被修音
另外春晚假唱我就不說有多少新聞是他們自打嘴巴的了
我倒覺得也不是要配合陶喆 只是節目要求高質感要他們對嘴罷了 要說誰配合誰還很難說呢!!!!(至少我看過陶喆現場演唱的)
@@mau2089 沒有人說那樣不好或不行,重點是老師要reaction的是現場真實人聲的表現,根本就沒有要reaction一首完美無缺從CD播放出來的、人工數位化過後的、預錄好的曲子。