The vinegar also removed iron, that's why it was rougher to the touch and had more pits. It also does something called "flash rusting" that means it almost instantly starts rusting when exposed to air so you would have to use a sealant. The rust remover one had less rust than the vinegar but was havier because the metal itself didn't get attacked.
This is a good idea. It will show that vinegar actually is dissolving the metal rather than just removing the rust. Also add a category of evaporust/monster mix to see if combining them helps/doesn't help at all.
@@squishy312 just my thought. Also to see do they poc mark it themselves like he noticed or was that just the rust being removed and left behind the holes
@@alexfarrell3250 I'm fairly sure you don't understand that this doesn't at all mean there isn't a liner, only that someone who knows wtf they're doing would pick a liner material that isn't susceptible to acetone degradation, same criteria for choosing the liner material for every container that does have a liner.
@@stinkycheese804 those cans don't have liners. Acetone does nothing to metal. I work with acetone on a daily basis for cleaning and painting. And those little gallon cans are super useful when you don't wanna walk all the way to the warehouse to get another 55 gallon drum. :Edit: I do realize that wasn't the point of your statement but I am just here to confirm that there is no liner in that specific brand as well as most cans we use.
The vinegar did remove more material. The rust remover is also known as a rust converter. Rust converter converts the rust into iron tannate. Rust converter is made from tannins...the shit from wood that stains everything near wet wood.
Clueless. Coke does perfectly fine at removing rust if you manually remove the bulk of it first. It's just an acid in a solution and the key thing here is how much acid is in the solution vs amount of rust. In this case, it was merely that the amount of acid in the coke was depleted before all the rust was eaten away, but you have to look at it from a cost perspective, how much would an amount of coke to get the job done, cost vs amount of rust remover specialty product. He used what, half a container of rust remover for a single piece of metal? Normally people would dillute it and agitate either. Just sayin', you must not know the relevant details nor have ever tried coke for this purpose because it does work, once you remove the bulk rust so you have enough acid in solution to handle what remains.
@@stinkycheese804 the point was to make it as easy as possible lmfao. The point was the NOT have tor remove the bulk of anything just put it in there and see which one does better.
And then you have to coat the remaining metal with a rust protector as you’ve completely removed the protective ferric oxide layer. Otherwise, it will significantly rust, even worse that before, almost immediately. You can actually see this in the video. The evaporust hasn’t re-rusted. The rust on the vinegar tube is *new* rust that formed after dunking it in the water to remove the old rust.
@@tamastarczy6262 I feel like Monster would be the best out of all of the other energy drinks he would try, I don’t see Redbull doing much, and I don’t see Rockstar doing much either so I think Monster would probably remove the most rust but that’s my theory so idk!.
Not so sure that leaving stuff outside to rust is a great effort, far more effort is spend on the rest of the video or any other. Leaving things sitting around, is what all your stuff is doing right now, lol.
Plot twist: Monster is just flavored evapo-rust that has been diluted Jokes aside, it was surprising to see just how potent every day items are against rust
This video was basically comparing a bunch of different versions of strong acids. Unsurprisingly, acid is good against rust. Muriatic acid will de-rust a bolt in like an hour.
Brings me back to the 80s, when green wasn't an ideology and mountain dew (i.e. actual dew from an actual mountain) was acidic enough to cause diarrhea.
Actually look at the coloring of the evaporust bar and the vinegar bar, there’s orange in the vinegar bar. That’s rust. That piece will rust faster than the evaporust. It may have numerically taken off less but it actually took off more rust and not just metal. Numbers don’t lie, but they also don’t tell the whole story. 😎😉
I wonder what cops would think if they ever came in Tyler's garage and seen a bunch of jars around filled with different colored liquids filled with metals. Meats. Gloves. Eggs. Etc
I’m part of many cast iron skillet groups and every group I ask about restoring my pans I’m told to do an e-tank. Basically using a car battery to charge the water to get the rust off. After watching your video I can’t thank you enough for showing an alternative by using vinegar. Thank you for your informative video.
Thanks for sharing, I’m a welder and repurpose things to create art and many other things. I’m always out looking for and getting unique pieces of metal and their always rusted to various degrees. Great to see how different things work. Depending on the look of the metal I want I’ll do different things either wire brushes that go in a drill. Recently soaked some things in a water vinegar solution and it worked incredible. You have to rinse all the vinegar off or it will continue to eat the rust and metal. After you remove whatever level of rust I then seal the metal by using different types of clear coat to preserve the look you achieved if you don’t seal the metal it will quickly rust again. Thanks again for sharing.,
Some old home cleaning and remedies still work pretty good. My aunt pours some boiling white vinegar down the drain with baking soda to foam up and help clean the pipes..also to help with any smells.
O use vinegar to remove rust all the time. I never leave anything in for 2 weeks. Usually a day or 2 will do it. Evaporust will neutralize and remove the rust in a day. The evaporust feels smoother because it neutralizes rust. The vinegar eats away the rust and the good steel. Which is most likely why vinegar lost a good deal more weight.
Love your stuff, Tyler. You never fail to give a smile plus good advice. If you wind up doing something similar, can you add CLR liquid to your tests? Maybe a test of several different brand name rust removers?
Instead of letting it sit outside, you can make a rusting agent, I think you use hydrogen peroxide, vinegar and salt, just if you decide to do another in the future. It rusts metal within minutes.
the vinegar and monster removed more weight but not more rust. They are acidic and therefor can eat through the metal. evapo-rust is not acidic, and will not eat through the metal. This is important information because depending on the application you could ruin whatever it is your restoring. If you use vinegar on an antique and it eats away your metal. You loose all profit from that restoration. If the surface of the metal provides grip, like a nut or bolt it will thread more loosely after being put in vinegar or. monster, and not secure properly. etc. I am fascinated that the master did so well at eating away the material! Im also surprised the coke did so poorly. very fascinating video Tyler!!
In your drying process the coke one could have easily picked up more rust, raw metal begins to rust immediately especially if left to dry, also glad I have been using the best thing to do the job. The pitting is already there the removal of the rust just reveals it. Thanks again for your time and hard work.
I used white vinegar on a rusty hammer, it left a little rust behind but a toothbrush took it RIGHT off. It doesn't take two weeks either, mine worked in 24 hours. Just remember it takes off protective coatings along with the rust, so be sure to wash the vinegar off and oil your tools after rust removal to give them some protection.
Could you test different energy drink flavors or types? Like for example, Monster, Monster Hydro, Monster Rehab, Monster XTRA? Or make a video involving leaving things in Bang, Monster, Reign, Redbull, NOS, and so on? I think itd be cool to see what happens, and to see if i should be concerned.
Another additional point to consider is whether the loss of material is that critical in a given situation. For example if I sandblasted a frame and it lost 10 % or even 19% (roughly what the vinegar removed in weight, right?) of the material, is that OK, depending on how thick and heavy the original frame was? If my frame (the outside of it at least, if it is boxed) was less rusty than the metal here in this example, maybe the vinegar would be OK to use IF it can remove the perhaps only 8 or 9 or 10% of the total metal material, within a given time period (hopefully less than two weeks), so I can paint the metal after the rust is removed. --What do you chemists or metallurgists guys have to add?
@@tamastarczy6262 not when you have seen this same comment 1000 times before and this isnt even the slightly better version of it that says they are in australia instead
With the vinegar you got to use baking soda to deactivate it after you have lefted it soak in the vinegar otherwise your tools will fall apart and anything longer than 24 hours in my own experience is a goner
Vinegar is a metal worker's friend. I use it to remove mill scale, rust, and other crap. It only takes really 8-24 hours if you scrub it or use a wire wheel.
Evaporust is designed to not eat the actual metal, only rust. It will darken metal if you leave it for too long almost like a stain. Vinegar has more pits because once the rust is gone it attacks the metal. Vinegar also has to be neutralized immediately so it doesn't flash rust like that. Easiest way is to scrub it with soapy water
The ones that did stuff were all acids. Vinegar did remove the most material, but Evaporust is formulated to mostly only remove the rust but the vinegar also removes some of the actual iron.
The blue on the bar is rust blueing. Like the finished they used on old firearms. Controlled rusting, converting ferrous oxide to ferric oxide. That bar will also be less likely to rust compared to the others.
@@totalmetaljacket789 yeah but acetone was just a poor choice. He probably just had some laying around. I've heard gasoline or diesel can actually remove rust but I'm not sure how well compared to these.
Wow, I am very surprised that the monster and the coke were so different, I kind of figured all soda or energy drinks would be the same, either it'd work or it wouldn't. I bet the benefit to the evapo-rust over something like vinegar or monster is that it works faster - if want to remove rust without leaving something in a jar for two week.
The bubbling happens with the energy drink and the coke because the rust is a really rough surface and it creates nucleation zones that causes bubbles to form on it's surface. Just like shaking it and stirring air into the soda creates these zones
My childhood SEGA Game Gear was virtually destroyed by battery fluids, as it was left with batteries inside since the mid 90s. I took it to a few technicians and they all declared it damaged beyond repair. Since there was no hope, I decided to open it up and leave the board in white vinegar for some time. After taking it out and with the help of a soft toothbrush, the game gear was alive again! I had to replace caps (as usual) and it now works perfectly with an LED backlit mod :D
you dont need to worry about monster being any worse for you than any other caffeine is- sure it cleaned rust off but. you dont typically have rust inside of you. Baking soda can remove heavy grease burn stains and odors, yet we still put it in baked goods. An ingredient being multipurpose doesn't mean it's bad to ingest. (cocacola is also a great bloodstain remover!)
I'd still say evaporust is the best option. Reusable and likely won't eat at the metal beyond the rust whereas vinegar is an acid and will likely go beyond just the rust if you're not careful. Idk about reusability. The monster one tho, surprising. However I don't think the peramiters were ideal for this test. I think you should have the weight before rust, weight before soaking, and then weight after.
---Additionally, after spraying vinegar on my frame, and it actually killed the rust, would I need to neutralize those areas--you know, neutralize the acid in the vinegar if it is left on the surface-- before painting it or protecting it with some substance? ---Would I add a solution of baking soda and water or just wash off the metal, let it dry and then get to covering it with paint? --Metallurgists, chemists? --or am I not making metallurgical sense?
Final results in % of total weight removed Monster 8% Evaparust 14% Vinegar 19% I am also shocked that vinegar done the best but I have to wonder maybe the Evaparust done it much faster or something making it more practical for real world use? Like maybe just rub it on, let it set a few hours then rub it off and your done? Never used this stuff so have no clue how it's suppose to be used or how fast it works but worth looking into I suppose.
Vinegar is a very good rust remover my brother soaks old cast iron frying pans in it and they look brand new after he oils them up and puts them in the oven a few times.
INHO one of your top comparison ever. I would suggest trying Muratic Acid against a 35% mixture of molasses and 65% water. Mix well. It might take much longer time though, like a several weeks to a month. The acids in vinegar, Monster and Coke are what dissolves rust. Obviously, some are better than others. Acetone is a solvent & I figured it would no nothing.
Acid is used in labs to dissolve/digest metals for testing. Acid and a little heat will dissolve most metals. Would have been interesting if you used that sulfuric acid from way back when.
the dedication with the "leaving five items in ___ for 30 days" videos was already applaudable, but a YEAR AND A HALF? bro thats COMMITMENT. amazing content my dude, you definitely deserve every one of your subscribers
The vinegar trick is meant to be done with cider vinegar. I use it for cleaning small rusty chrome parts and bolts etc. You're supposed to bath the parts in bicarb after to neutralise the metal afterwards or the vinegar keeps reacting and will cause excessive rust.
@@totalmetaljacket789 cider vinegar usually is slightly more acidic. It's also more alkaline which probably plays a big part in the neutralising stage and not stripping the iron molecules as much. I use it a lot for cleaning rusty chrome it does an amazing job honestly.
Vinegar has always worked good for me I often buy old snap on tools that are rusty and they just need to be cleaned up a bit set them in a bucket of vinegar for few weeks and come back oil them up and good as new
The vinegar also removed iron, that's why it was rougher to the touch and had more pits. It also does something called "flash rusting" that means it almost instantly starts rusting when exposed to air so you would have to use a sealant. The rust remover one had less rust than the vinegar but was havier because the metal itself didn't get attacked.
Bicarb works for neutralising the metal afterwards 👍
if you sand said tool after using vinegar than no rust forms
@@Deadchannel06 nice energy sword
@@genodedemon5109 Thanks
Do this same thing. Except put unrusted steel bars in. See if the bars come out shiny still/rusted/dull but unrusted/etc
This is a good idea. It will show that vinegar actually is dissolving the metal rather than just removing the rust. Also add a category of evaporust/monster mix to see if combining them helps/doesn't help at all.
@@squishy312 just my thought. Also to see do they poc mark it themselves like he noticed or was that just the rust being removed and left behind the holes
@@squishy312 combining these might be dangerous!
I thought the same thing he should do muriatic acid
Tyler: wonder if acetone reacts with metal
Also Tyler: *pulls out acetone in a metal can*
Depends if the metal can has a liner or not
@@fluffyunicorn7187 I'm fairly certain it doesn't due to many plastics being soluble in acetone
@@alexfarrell3250 I'm fairly sure you don't understand that this doesn't at all mean there isn't a liner, only that someone who knows wtf they're doing would pick a liner material that isn't susceptible to acetone degradation, same criteria for choosing the liner material for every container that does have a liner.
@@stinkycheese804 those cans don't have liners. Acetone does nothing to metal. I work with acetone on a daily basis for cleaning and painting. And those little gallon cans are super useful when you don't wanna walk all the way to the warehouse to get another 55 gallon drum.
:Edit: I do realize that wasn't the point of your statement but I am just here to confirm that there is no liner in that specific brand as well as most cans we use.
@@fluffyunicorn7187 Yeah, didnt think of that
The vinegar likely removed more material, whereas the rust remover only removed the rust
That is what rust remover does lol
My thoughts exactly.
The vinegar did remove more material. The rust remover is also known as a rust converter. Rust converter converts the rust into iron tannate. Rust converter is made from tannins...the shit from wood that stains everything near wet wood.
@@litmusaero2645 I think the point was the vinegar removed more material of the metal rather than just rust
@@litmusaero2645 Whoosh
Tyler pinning up rust remover against coke makes my day
May suck on rust but a great battery terminal cleaner diet coke tho works the best
Clueless. Coke does perfectly fine at removing rust if you manually remove the bulk of it first. It's just an acid in a solution and the key thing here is how much acid is in the solution vs amount of rust. In this case, it was merely that the amount of acid in the coke was depleted before all the rust was eaten away, but you have to look at it from a cost perspective, how much would an amount of coke to get the job done, cost vs amount of rust remover specialty product. He used what, half a container of rust remover for a single piece of metal? Normally people would dillute it and agitate either.
Just sayin', you must not know the relevant details nor have ever tried coke for this purpose because it does work, once you remove the bulk rust so you have enough acid in solution to handle what remains.
@@stinkycheese804 I'm not gonna read everything thing you said so I'm just gonna say I agree very nice
Like that shirt my guy 👌
@@stinkycheese804 the point was to make it as easy as possible lmfao. The point was the NOT have tor remove the bulk of anything just put it in there and see which one does better.
Vinegar doesn’t just remove rust though. That was 5 grams of good metal removed
Yeah, I think you also have to think about how much of the bar was actually rusted on each bar and how much of it was good metal.
And then you have to coat the remaining metal with a rust protector as you’ve completely removed the protective ferric oxide layer. Otherwise, it will significantly rust, even worse that before, almost immediately.
You can actually see this in the video. The evaporust hasn’t re-rusted. The rust on the vinegar tube is *new* rust that formed after dunking it in the water to remove the old rust.
Might’ve lost way more from using a grinder to clean the rust off though. Maybe that would be a good comparison
Look at his gloves, it eats the bar not just the rust
I totally agree with you
I'd like to see ''Which Energy Drink Removes Rust The Best?'' now. lol
At least it should be tried. Even if all turn out the same... BUT if not. Now that would be interesting. Give this one more upvotes! 👍
I agree
Yes
@@tamastarczy6262 I feel like Monster would be the best out of all of the other energy drinks he would try, I don’t see Redbull doing much, and I don’t see Rockstar doing much either so I think Monster would probably remove the most rust but that’s my theory so idk!.
We will have to wait another year and a half for the bars to rust.
Can we just appreciate this madlad for preparing his video for 1 year and a half !? You're great, I tip my hat to you
*tips fedora*
Tips top hat
Not intentionally.
@@614BlueBerry I'm case your new here he also waits an entire month for random crap in a jar
Not so sure that leaving stuff outside to rust is a great effort, far more effort is spend on the rest of the video or any other. Leaving things sitting around, is what all your stuff is doing right now, lol.
Plot twist: Monster is just flavored evapo-rust that has been diluted
Jokes aside, it was surprising to see just how potent every day items are against rust
This video was basically comparing a bunch of different versions of strong acids. Unsurprisingly, acid is good against rust. Muriatic acid will de-rust a bolt in like an hour.
"Looks like Mountain Dew" damn ig im drinkin that tonite
You'd be just as well of drinking monster Apparantly
Brings me back to the 80s, when green wasn't an ideology and mountain dew (i.e. actual dew from an actual mountain) was acidic enough to cause diarrhea.
As much Monster as I drink I should be all sparkling clean inside 🤯🤯🤯
Actually you should have diabetes
or an ulcer the size of texas :p
HAHAHAHA I have Neither I am Very Healthy
Michael Phelps drinks monster, too
Same
Actually look at the coloring of the evaporust bar and the vinegar bar, there’s orange in the vinegar bar. That’s rust. That piece will rust faster than the evaporust. It may have numerically taken off less but it actually took off more rust and not just metal. Numbers don’t lie, but they also don’t tell the whole story. 😎😉
I wonder what cops would think if they ever came in Tyler's garage and seen a bunch of jars around filled with different colored liquids filled with metals. Meats. Gloves. Eggs. Etc
Prob just think he's fuckin crazy lol ...jus hope they would do a smell test 😅
They put a bug and then hear :"Ok let's take the scale and start with the coke..."
They wouldn't arrest him until they found out he hates pickles.
I’m part of many cast iron skillet groups and every group I ask about restoring my pans I’m told to do an e-tank. Basically using a car battery to charge the water to get the rust off. After watching your video I can’t thank you enough for showing an alternative by using vinegar. Thank you for your informative video.
whenever i watch tyler i find happiness and im calm, just watching an experiment keeping my mind off stressful things in life.
me too
Simple and interesting science, no useless talks, straight to the point...
love it.
The Monster literally has the color of rust sitting in liquid.
Monster was probably originally a rust remover but the creator tasted it and liked it so here we go, monster energy drink.
@@junruluo4821 tea
If im not mistaken, youve never tested out hot glue. like test it against flex and/or gorilla glue.
We had a hot sauce that could remove oil stains from a concrete floor
Thanks for sharing, I’m a welder and repurpose things to create art and many other things. I’m always out looking for and getting unique pieces of metal and their always rusted to various degrees. Great to see how different things work. Depending on the look of the metal I want I’ll do different things either wire brushes that go in a drill. Recently soaked some things in a water vinegar solution and it worked incredible. You have to rinse all the vinegar off or it will continue to eat the rust and metal. After you remove whatever level of rust I then seal the metal by using different types of clear coat to preserve the look you achieved if you don’t seal the metal it will quickly rust again. Thanks again for sharing.,
what energy drink removes the most rust cause if monster does it cant be much different so now I'm curious
I have used vinegar for years to remove rust on axe heads and knives for restorations. Awesome video.
I'm getting to Tyler's videos earlier and earlier. I like it.😃
Some old home cleaning and remedies still work pretty good. My aunt pours some boiling white vinegar down the drain with baking soda to foam up and help clean the pipes..also to help with any smells.
The moster isn’t bad bc stomach acid would literally dissolve that whole bar of metal
lol!
Agreed @Sam Evans
That's not how that works...
That’s not true😂
Your supposed to keep it in there for 2 days otherwise the vinegar eats most of it
O use vinegar to remove rust all the time. I never leave anything in for 2 weeks. Usually a day or 2 will do it. Evaporust will neutralize and remove the rust in a day. The evaporust feels smoother because it neutralizes rust. The vinegar eats away the rust and the good steel. Which is most likely why vinegar lost a good deal more weight.
The warm ones are still reacting. The heat is caused by the engergy of eating the rust
Love your stuff, Tyler. You never fail to give a smile plus good advice. If you wind up doing something similar, can you add CLR liquid to your tests? Maybe a test of several different brand name rust removers?
Instead of letting it sit outside, you can make a rusting agent, I think you use hydrogen peroxide, vinegar and salt, just if you decide to do another in the future. It rusts metal within minutes.
Man, the amount of time you spend on these is crazy man. Appreciate you.
This is a episode of stuff in jars that i might actually use
the vinegar and monster removed more weight but not more rust. They are acidic and therefor can eat through the metal. evapo-rust is not acidic, and will not eat through the metal. This is important information because depending on the application you could ruin whatever it is your restoring. If you use vinegar on an antique and it eats away your metal. You loose all profit from that restoration. If the surface of the metal provides grip, like a nut or bolt it will thread more loosely after being put in vinegar or. monster, and not secure properly. etc. I am fascinated that the master did so well at eating away the material! Im also surprised the coke did so poorly. very fascinating video Tyler!!
it’s not really concerning when your stomach acid would dissolve the whole bar
and your teeths
@@einareinarsson233 that made my teeth hurt
Ever throw up and get that deeep stomach acid in your throat/mouth? Pure pain
@@domothebro2435 Literally half a second contact and it leaves your throat burning
In your drying process the coke one could have easily picked up more rust, raw metal begins to rust immediately especially if left to dry, also glad I have been using the best thing to do the job. The pitting is already there the removal of the rust just reveals it. Thanks again for your time and hard work.
Tyler: I'm gonna swish it around in the water to remove any drops of liquid
I used white vinegar on a rusty hammer, it left a little rust behind but a toothbrush took it RIGHT off. It doesn't take two weeks either, mine worked in 24 hours. Just remember it takes off protective coatings along with the rust, so be sure to wash the vinegar off and oil your tools after rust removal to give them some protection.
I think we need to see how multiple energy drinks would do against rust 🤔
It was warm because of something called exothermic this is when two chemicals react in this case rust and liquid and this makes them produce heat
project farm needs to teach this guy how to do a real test haha
I SAID THAT EXSACTLY LOL
Exaporust has inhibitors in it to prevent removing base metal after it eats all of the rust. The acids (vinegar and monster) just kept eating.
Tyler has discovered the ultimate diet the melt yourself from the inside monster diet
2:00 "Doesnt that just look appetizing" 2:02 "This monster looks dehydrated"
Hmmm
"I should really make this video... Hmmmm. But i wonder what would happen if i put shark teeth in mountain dew for a month"
I know this doesn't mean much but your comment made me laugh out loud for real lol!!! 🤣🤣
Now the question is, do any of these weaken the metal any? maybe the took rust off but is it worth it?
Acids will weaken the metal if you leave them long enough to start dissolving metal.
Watching this while drinking a monster. At least I know I'll never be rusty inside
Could you test different energy drink flavors or types? Like for example, Monster, Monster Hydro, Monster Rehab, Monster XTRA?
Or make a video involving leaving things in Bang, Monster, Reign, Redbull, NOS, and so on?
I think itd be cool to see what happens, and to see if i should be concerned.
I love how concerned he is about monster removing rust, while completely forgetting vinegar is food to.
Yeah. But you don't drink a can of vinegar.
@@Oxaxau speak for yourself
@@Oxaxau He eats pickles like they're going out of fashion (and those are made with vinegar)
Another additional point to consider is whether the loss of material is that critical in a given situation. For example if I sandblasted a frame and it lost 10 % or even 19% (roughly what the vinegar removed in weight, right?) of the material, is that OK, depending on how thick and heavy the original frame was? If my frame (the outside of it at least, if it is boxed) was less rusty than the metal here in this example, maybe the vinegar would be OK to use IF it can remove the perhaps only 8 or 9 or 10% of the total metal material, within a given time period (hopefully less than two weeks), so I can paint the metal after the rust is removed. --What do you chemists or metallurgists guys have to add?
"The coke did nothing. So thats a zero"
I see what you did there 😎
An old fisherman once told me that his seamen would work at removing rust from his boat once a month.
nothing like good old fashion elbow grease
Good to know Monster is keeping my insides rust free. They better add that to the can, they'll sell so much more.
2:57 tylertube: looks like mountain dew
Me: looks like pickle juice with carbanasin :)
The dislikes are from people watching this upside down
theres no dislikes tho???
@@malachi4838 its funny tho
@@tamastarczy6262 not when you have seen this same comment 1000 times before and this isnt even the slightly better version of it that says they are in australia instead
I'd say the dislikes were probably from the metal soaked in acetone and coke because they didn't get enough rust removed
The Coke believers will complain that he kept moving the jars around.
“How do we know which was Coke and which was Vinegar?”
With the vinegar you got to use baking soda to deactivate it after you have lefted it soak in the vinegar otherwise your tools will fall apart and anything longer than 24 hours in my own experience is a goner
Soak it, clean it, coat it.
That's your order of operations. Uncoated metal will rust right quick.
In fairness monster isn't sitting in our insides for 2 weeks at a time
Ya
Well, unless you drink 2 cans a day
And our stomachs have acid in them and have measures to protect you from that acid so monster wont do anything
This is going to be one of those vidios that's gonna blow up in about 5 years
My man went through a year just to make this video.
Vinegar is a metal worker's friend. I use it to remove mill scale, rust, and other crap.
It only takes really 8-24 hours if you scrub it or use a wire wheel.
Keep going I'm watching you from iraq 🤞 🇮🇶
My search history is filled with gaming, and then tylertube and I love it
On this episode, Tyler discovers removing metal makes the piece of metal lighter.
Evaporust is designed to not eat the actual metal, only rust. It will darken metal if you leave it for too long almost like a stain. Vinegar has more pits because once the rust is gone it attacks the metal. Vinegar also has to be neutralized immediately so it doesn't flash rust like that. Easiest way is to scrub it with soapy water
Are we all gonna ignore what an awesome shirt he has?
The ones that did stuff were all acids. Vinegar did remove the most material, but Evaporust is formulated to mostly only remove the rust but the vinegar also removes some of the actual iron.
You'v should try citric acid mixed with water, it also works werry well
The blue on the bar is rust blueing. Like the finished they used on old firearms. Controlled rusting, converting ferrous oxide to ferric oxide.
That bar will also be less likely to rust compared to the others.
I would have liked to see penetrating fluid or WD40 instead of acetone.
Terrible at rust removal. They're much better at prevention.
@@totalmetaljacket789 yeah but acetone was just a poor choice. He probably just had some laying around. I've heard gasoline or diesel can actually remove rust but I'm not sure how well compared to these.
One of the only TH-camrs dedicated to the craft❤️
He should have use a brush and tried cleaning them instead of seeing how much they weigh.
Tyler takes out all the bars, “alright now time to drink each jar.”
Why take a tetanus shot when you could drink monster
Rust on steel, or chrome: Use GoJo orange hand scrub cleaner and a piece of crushed up aluminum foil as a scrubber. Works the first time, every time.
Wow, I am very surprised that the monster and the coke were so different, I kind of figured all soda or energy drinks would be the same, either it'd work or it wouldn't.
I bet the benefit to the evapo-rust over something like vinegar or monster is that it works faster - if want to remove rust without leaving something in a jar for two week.
The bubbling happens with the energy drink and the coke because the rust is a really rough surface and it creates nucleation zones that causes bubbles to form on it's surface. Just like shaking it and stirring air into the soda creates these zones
First time watching and I just gotta say, great job! you really know how to keep your audience interested on the subject
Tyler Tube, the common mans, man. You do a great service with these kind of videos my good man. Keep at it buddy.
these videos are so time consuming. can we please appreciate tyler's dedication to these?
My childhood SEGA Game Gear was virtually destroyed by battery fluids, as it was left with batteries inside since the mid 90s. I took it to a few technicians and they all declared it damaged beyond repair. Since there was no hope, I decided to open it up and leave the board in white vinegar for some time. After taking it out and with the help of a soft toothbrush, the game gear was alive again! I had to replace caps (as usual) and it now works perfectly with an LED backlit mod :D
you dont need to worry about monster being any worse for you than any other caffeine is- sure it cleaned rust off but. you dont typically have rust inside of you. Baking soda can remove heavy grease burn stains and odors, yet we still put it in baked goods. An ingredient being multipurpose doesn't mean it's bad to ingest. (cocacola is also a great bloodstain remover!)
I absolutely love when you upload, I find your content interesting!
I'd still say evaporust is the best option. Reusable and likely won't eat at the metal beyond the rust whereas vinegar is an acid and will likely go beyond just the rust if you're not careful. Idk about reusability. The monster one tho, surprising.
However I don't think the peramiters were ideal for this test. I think you should have the weight before rust, weight before soaking, and then weight after.
If you can use a watch, acids work just fine.
---Additionally, after spraying vinegar on my frame, and it actually killed the rust, would I need to neutralize those areas--you know, neutralize the acid in the vinegar if it is left on the surface-- before painting it or protecting it with some substance? ---Would I add a solution of baking soda and water or just wash off the metal, let it dry and then get to covering it with paint? --Metallurgists, chemists? --or am I not making metallurgical sense?
Final results in % of total weight removed
Monster 8%
Evaparust 14%
Vinegar 19%
I am also shocked that vinegar done the best but I have to wonder maybe the Evaparust done it much faster or something making it more practical for real world use? Like maybe just rub it on, let it set a few hours then rub it off and your done? Never used this stuff so have no clue how it's suppose to be used or how fast it works but worth looking into I suppose.
I love these videos, I’m more prepared for legit anything
Vinegar is a very good rust remover my brother soaks old cast iron frying pans in it and they look brand new after he oils them up and puts them in the oven a few times.
Still on the ad and already know this vid is gonna be amazing
This channel is nice, it's a fun experimental and educational environment
mans started one video ALMOST TWO YEARS IN ADVANCE!!!!! you gotta respect the grind
INHO one of your top comparison ever. I would suggest trying Muratic Acid against a 35% mixture of molasses and 65% water. Mix well. It might take much longer time though, like a several weeks to a month. The acids in vinegar, Monster and Coke are what dissolves rust. Obviously, some are better than others. Acetone is a solvent & I figured it would no nothing.
Tyler: "Im gonna remove each bar out of the jar.."
ME: LOL, That rhymed.
Tyler: *That rhymed*
I just have to say I’ve watched you ever since your first vid 3 years ago, and it’s nostalgic looking at your old videos
Acid is used in labs to dissolve/digest metals for testing. Acid and a little heat will dissolve most metals. Would have been interesting if you used that sulfuric acid from way back when.
the dedication with the "leaving five items in ___ for 30 days" videos was already applaudable, but a YEAR AND A HALF? bro thats COMMITMENT. amazing content my dude, you definitely deserve every one of your subscribers
To answer your question, carbonated water or any carbonated liquid bubbles up more when it touches any kind of imperfections on any surface.
I think it would be cool to see you tackle some projects with cast iron. Apparently you can polish a cast iron pan to a mirror finish but not sure.
The vinegar trick is meant to be done with cider vinegar. I use it for cleaning small rusty chrome parts and bolts etc.
You're supposed to bath the parts in bicarb after to neutralise the metal afterwards or the vinegar keeps reacting and will cause excessive rust.
Cider vinegar won't be better unless you find some that's slightly more acidic.
@@totalmetaljacket789 cider vinegar usually is slightly more acidic. It's also more alkaline which probably plays a big part in the neutralising stage and not stripping the iron molecules as much.
I use it a lot for cleaning rusty chrome it does an amazing job honestly.
@@MaNNeRz91 The alkaline part is an actually great response. Gold star for you!
@@totalmetaljacket789 thank you sir! 🙌
i just love coming to a new tylertube video
White vinegar is generally used for curosion
Watched some of your older videos and it seems like you lost a bit of weight! Good job man, keep up the great content!
Vinegar has always worked good for me I often buy old snap on tools that are rusty and they just need to be cleaned up a bit set them in a bucket of vinegar for few weeks and come back oil them up and good as new