I like this cast, but I feel like you should've added Fries. (He's definitely a main character / all-star in BFDIA) and from the looks of it he'll also merge too.
I would really like to see how Woody deals with Teardrop. I know Woody is much braver now but Teardrop is the whole reason why Woody got the top part of him chipped off. I'd like to see conflict between the two where Blocky and Eraser try to make the 2 on good terms.
This feels more like a fan favourite season rather than an all stars one but these dynamics are very interesting the only thing I would change is swapping donut with needle since she has more chemistry with that team with pencil pin coiny and with people on other teams like pen and ruby
@Bean545 interesting, honestly Needle probably would've been better then Donut, but I wanted less bfdi representation, since there were already a lot of bfdi characters.
i disagree on a lot of the cast, specifically remote/taco/pen/tree/stapy all of them are characters generally liked by fans but they've never been as important or as popular as essentially the rest of the cast taco while being important to presplit, had terrible reception (on the tacobook arc) and was not very important in postsplit. a reunion with book (much like any storyline with stapy, who is also here) is better left to a regular season plus i feel like some lock-ins for allstars are missing, mainly rocky and BH, just on topping a popularity chart (BFDIA voting & BFB 13) even if their popularity has fallen off, rocky is important enough in BFDI's history to be an allstar, and BH had massive focus in TPOT other picks i have would be loser (massive relevance to several characters and presplit), winner and clock (TPOT. also personal bias), david (joke character rep & scoring unnaturally high in popularity polls), grassy (fits the bill on being popular), and spongy
I would imagine jacknjellify would want characters to do stuff with, what would they do with rocky make him vomit for the 200th time?? Also I think the cast is perfect it has good dynamic. And as of black hole I'm pretty sure his popularity has drastically decreased as of then. Edit:also rocky is a pretty hated character and is considered bland he got eliminated early during TPOT as well. That voting popularity was also during bfdia literally over 10 years ago.
@@animationawesome- rocky has been relevant before (BFDI merge and BFB 13, 14 etc). saying he just vomits is like saying eraser is "just a jerk". while it may be the WAY that they perform jokes, it's not their entire personality. also the word "bland" is misused literally all the time in the fandom. it doesn't mean "character i don't like", it means (IN THIS CONTEXT) "lacking personality". rocky (whenever he isn't written out of an episode) has been strongly characterized as both childlike and also a nuisance. compared to foldy (who i believe is the only bland character in BFDI) rocky's far from bland even though the popularity polls are relatively outdated now, that doesn't change they USED to be the most popular--if liy and stapy get spots for being eliminated, BH and rocky should get spots also the cast dynamics are FAR too played out. you got every trope--firey and leafy, coiny and pin, GB and TB (and BB, repeating a better name than that), blocky and woody, lollipop and literally everyone on her team besides blocky's group (who should not have made it all in, let alone be all on the same team) for an all-star season, keeping everyone in their formed groups without much variation is extremely disappointing
@@white_tiger2669 I disagree with you here, Rocky is bland and has no character, Grassy could be used in the same context here he is written as childish and sometimes a nuisance and heck even he the character I expected least to get development did. Rocky got nothing and is nothing. Regarding the popularity polls that is still the past. People don't like those characters anymore. The time were rocky was popular was the same time were flower was hated and nearly all the TPOT fan favourites were disliked too. And for the all-star cast sometimes they just need to wrap things up. It's called a all-star for a reason, they are obviously gonna put people like that when they are pretty much the face of the show 🤷♂️
@@animationawesome- saying rocky and grassy are anything alike besides the surface level childness is...yikes. grassy is shown wanting to be helpful from literally his introduction in BFB 1 and has not once intentionally hindered his own team (disregarding 8ball) and rocky has been shown to (knowingly or not) be a nuisance in universe. and rocky having no character or personality is objectively false. not even in a "they technically appear on screen and do things (that could've been said by anyone)" way post BFB 11 foldy has. rocky being oblivious to the trouble he causes is characterization. rocky doing challenges (mostly in BFDI merge) in an unorthodox is characterization. rocky is a unique character, and being unorthodox or not receiving development (like half of BFB did) doesn't make him have "no character". you can dislike a character without literally making up reasons and regarding the popularity polls being outdated; sure, but having less fans (not being no.1) than before doesn't mean they aren't all-star material. black hole has more relevance in TPOT than anyone already in this cast has in their season besides GB, TB, fanny and basketball. both of their peaks of popularity (BFDI-post TPOT 3 for rocky and BFB-TPOT 7 for BH) were so long (reminder these periods of times were YEARS) and their popularities eclipsed a lot of the cast already in this season. if characters who are far past their peak like donut, or characters who are here just cause they don't have many haters or fans like taco or stapy can make this cast, characters who defined a whole ERA of BFDI definitely deserve a spot the all-star season is not the place to put in characters JUST to wrap things up. that's what regular seasons are for. that goes against the seasons theme...of all stars. plus, a lot of these picks are not "the faces of BFDI" on any level. remote, taco, stapy, pen, basically everyone i mentioned in the original comment are just characters who don't have many haters. doesn't mean they're iconic enough to be an all-star. tbh 28 characters is way too much for a BFDI all stars season
very flawed, stapy being there makes like no sense, all-stars season should have all-stars, you can redempt stapy on another season. Also why would basketball pick snowball to spite golfball, she dosen't like snowball either, she's smarter than screwing herself over out of spite
Tbh I personally hate how characters that are just popular rn are considered all stars like ex Fanny she had like 2 good episodes and now she is a all star
I like this cast, but I feel like you should've added Fries. (He's definitely a main character / all-star in BFDIA) and from the looks of it he'll also merge too.
Cool, all stars cast and voting method
Team Overgrowth is stacked
Wow, this is actually the best all stars I've seen yet
I would really like to see how Woody deals with Teardrop. I know Woody is much braver now but Teardrop is the whole reason why Woody got the top part of him chipped off. I'd like to see conflict between the two where Blocky and Eraser try to make the 2 on good terms.
Eraser would not give a molecular f*ck
This feels more like a fan favourite season rather than an all stars one but these dynamics are very interesting the only thing I would change is swapping donut with needle since she has more chemistry with that team with pencil pin coiny and with people on other teams like pen and ruby
@Bean545 interesting, honestly Needle probably would've been better then Donut, but I wanted less bfdi representation, since there were already a lot of bfdi characters.
Personally i like thus cast but i feel its missing a few maybe fries,Lightning,Ice cube,Winner and maybe price tag
Cool vid!
Great video u deserve a new sub for it 👍
@@jordananimates Thanks, Jordan. It's nice to see you here. I've liked your videos for a while now, they are usually pretty cool, and interesting.
I have been thinking of using that system for my object show
Nice teams!
No Needle? You’re so cooked
Epic this is is so epic oh so epic I like it
Thankyou for mentioning me and for saying those nice things about my series, TPOT Weekly! I Love the hypothetical cast btw!
Thank you so much, and keep up the good work on your show
I love the way you did the elimination style so I might use it in my object show too!
(With credit)
Please respond to my Braclety audition :(
@@patatespatates2247 Me?
@@Cam_boom no deandiaz
I don't think it was a good idea to put Pencil on the same team as Pin because Pin hates FreeSmart, but this video was good
I get the pencil storyline first she pushed book and ice cube away then it was bubble and kind of ruby
i love team blizzard
8:12
Ah yes, my favorite character
*wooody*
I want tune,waffle and lego brick out of evil leafy
So you can add stapy but not match?
Puffball where?
cool
3:05 gyatty💀
Fries ain’t there so this video is already red flag 😅
i disagree on a lot of the cast, specifically remote/taco/pen/tree/stapy
all of them are characters generally liked by fans but they've never been as important or as popular as essentially the rest of the cast
taco while being important to presplit, had terrible reception (on the tacobook arc) and was not very important in postsplit. a reunion with book (much like any storyline with stapy, who is also here) is better left to a regular season
plus i feel like some lock-ins for allstars are missing, mainly rocky and BH, just on topping a popularity chart (BFDIA voting & BFB 13) even if their popularity has fallen off, rocky is important enough in BFDI's history to be an allstar, and BH had massive focus in TPOT
other picks i have would be loser (massive relevance to several characters and presplit), winner and clock (TPOT. also personal bias), david (joke character rep & scoring unnaturally high in popularity polls), grassy (fits the bill on being popular), and spongy
I would imagine jacknjellify would want characters to do stuff with, what would they do with rocky make him vomit for the 200th time?? Also I think the cast is perfect it has good dynamic. And as of black hole I'm pretty sure his popularity has drastically decreased as of then.
Edit:also rocky is a pretty hated character and is considered bland he got eliminated early during TPOT as well. That voting popularity was also during bfdia literally over 10 years ago.
@@animationawesome- rocky has been relevant before (BFDI merge and BFB 13, 14 etc). saying he just vomits is like saying eraser is "just a jerk". while it may be the WAY that they perform jokes, it's not their entire personality. also the word "bland" is misused literally all the time in the fandom. it doesn't mean "character i don't like", it means (IN THIS CONTEXT) "lacking personality". rocky (whenever he isn't written out of an episode) has been strongly characterized as both childlike and also a nuisance. compared to foldy (who i believe is the only bland character in BFDI) rocky's far from bland
even though the popularity polls are relatively outdated now, that doesn't change they USED to be the most popular--if liy and stapy get spots for being eliminated, BH and rocky should get spots
also the cast dynamics are FAR too played out. you got every trope--firey and leafy, coiny and pin, GB and TB (and BB, repeating a better name than that), blocky and woody, lollipop and literally everyone on her team besides blocky's group (who should not have made it all in, let alone be all on the same team)
for an all-star season, keeping everyone in their formed groups without much variation is extremely disappointing
@@white_tiger2669 I disagree with you here, Rocky is bland and has no character, Grassy could be used in the same context here he is written as childish and sometimes a nuisance and heck even he the character I expected least to get development did. Rocky got nothing and is nothing.
Regarding the popularity polls that is still the past. People don't like those characters anymore. The time were rocky was popular was the same time were flower was hated and nearly all the TPOT fan favourites were disliked too.
And for the all-star cast sometimes they just need to wrap things up. It's called a all-star for a reason, they are obviously gonna put people like that when they are pretty much the face of the show 🤷♂️
@@animationawesome- saying rocky and grassy are anything alike besides the surface level childness is...yikes.
grassy is shown wanting to be helpful from literally his introduction in BFB 1 and has not once intentionally hindered his own team (disregarding 8ball) and rocky has been shown to (knowingly or not) be a nuisance in universe.
and rocky having no character or personality is objectively false. not even in a "they technically appear on screen and do things (that could've been said by anyone)" way post BFB 11 foldy has.
rocky being oblivious to the trouble he causes is characterization. rocky doing challenges (mostly in BFDI merge) in an unorthodox is characterization. rocky is a unique character, and being unorthodox or not receiving development (like half of BFB did) doesn't make him have "no character". you can dislike a character without literally making up reasons
and regarding the popularity polls being outdated; sure, but having less fans (not being no.1) than before doesn't mean they aren't all-star material. black hole has more relevance in TPOT than anyone already in this cast has in their season besides GB, TB, fanny and basketball. both of their peaks of popularity (BFDI-post TPOT 3 for rocky and BFB-TPOT 7 for BH) were so long (reminder these periods of times were YEARS) and their popularities eclipsed a lot of the cast already in this season. if characters who are far past their peak like donut, or characters who are here just cause they don't have many haters or fans like taco or stapy can make this cast, characters who defined a whole ERA of BFDI definitely deserve a spot
the all-star season is not the place to put in characters JUST to wrap things up. that's what regular seasons are for. that goes against the seasons theme...of all stars. plus, a lot of these picks are not "the faces of BFDI" on any level. remote, taco, stapy, pen, basically everyone i mentioned in the original comment are just characters who don't have many haters. doesn't mean they're iconic enough to be an all-star. tbh 28 characters is way too much for a BFDI all stars season
Dang, these comments could be made into a whole script for a video,
also, I'm just kidding btw.
Why didn’t coiny choose needle before firey???
Dang I forgot needle isn’t here why?
how is match not in all-stars
hi!😊
@@skittlemationsyt hey
honestly I think season 6 should have no season 1 contestants
I feel like we've seen enough of them
But its an all stars season
@@Felloffbike im talking about season 6 in general
Stapy and remote aint all stars even though i love them. Ice cube, match and needle should be in this cast too over them.
very flawed, stapy being there makes like no sense, all-stars season should have all-stars, you can redempt stapy on another season. Also why would basketball pick snowball to spite golfball, she dosen't like snowball either, she's smarter than screwing herself over out of spite
Eh Snowball could be a valuable player, since he's a strong and athletic character, but I slightly agree
ok
Yeah, Stapy should not be an all star member, Fries should’ve been, even DAVID deserves the spot more.
Liy is not all star worthy (yet at least)
Remote as an allstar when Fries has a higher rank than her😅
GRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR
@@CloudimationsOffical Yeah probably, but idk, she was just more of an unexpected pick.
I guess fries can take stapy’s place but idk which team he can be on
ofc your talking about fries
@@skittlemationsytbro doesn’t know how to stop talking about Fries 💀
wheres marker
@@fs2t21linkaiwingp3 it’s a all-star series
Tbh I personally hate how characters that are just popular rn are considered all stars like ex Fanny she had like 2 good episodes and now she is a all star
But besides that great video
Fanny has been the goat since she was introduced wdym…