Arfa Khanum Sherwani की Viral Speech, “मोदी-काल से पहले भी थी Media में सांप्रदायिकता”
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 24 ก.ย. 2023
- पूर्व IPS अधिकारी अब्दुर्रहमान की किताब Absent in Politics and Power : Political Exclusion of Indian Muslims के लॉंच के मौक़े पर द वायर की सीनियर एडिटर आरफ़ा ख़ानम शेरवानी ने भारतीय मीडिया में धार्मिक और जातिगत भेदभाव पर अपनी बात रखी
Join The Wire's TH-cam Membership and get exclusive content, member-only emojis, live interaction with The Wire's founders, editors and reporters and much more. Memberships to The Wire Crew start at Rs 89/month. / @thewirenews
I am also working on a book "How To empower minorities " specially who are facing anti -movement, economic apartheid, mob lynching, verbal lynching, persecution and so on such issues .
Talking about Sikhs, Jains, Parsi, Buddhist, atheist?
SUPERB ALL INDIANS FOR INDIANS
Minority means only peacefulls, that too approx 25 crores
Over 50 killed in Pakistan blast on Nabis birthday. Eating biriyani and producing babies. No education
Some comments are still divisive ..your irresponsible persecutions and lynching may spread to other part of world( west,Australia,Canada) same to minorities indian Diaspora ..
Please note it..
Very emotional and accurate speech that can be delivered only by an intellectually superior human being and purely peofessional journalist, which is Dr. ARAFA KHANUM SHERWANI. Thank you fir expressing yours and your community's pain through these times.
If Hindus that are facing religious persecutions in Pak/Afghan/ BDesh are given visa by the government to live in India under CAA., WHATS WAS YOUR PROBLEM? Hindus around the world have one homeland-INDIA Also - how many Muslims have lost their citizenship under CAA?
@sjraniga
I am not convinced from your opinion about our Hindus community. You are talking out of context, and thoughts are prejudiced.
Arfa madam a great journalist, full of knowledge, dare devil, explaining the dangerous situation for minorities, and still burning the lamp of hope.Great.
Well said !!
lol she is a pawn of muslim brotherhood
Not only Muslims , to all.
Female jaichand😂😂😂
It's a good observation that the protest against Godi media has started late,for whatever reasons, but it is a good initiative. Thank you madam, for that wonderful speech.
Good speech
आप लोकतंत्र की असली पत्रकारिता कर रही हैं।
देश में आपके योगदान को एक दिन पूरी दुनिया माने गी
I watched it 2 days back & appreciated it more than any other speech infact Arfa's analysis in the speech is far better than Owaisi or Manoj jha who were also present in that book launch ! Journalists like this lady deserves a lot more credit than we usually give 💐 Too Good !!
Absolutely !!
Waisi ji sahi kam kar raha hai
May I ask your views on The genocide happened against Hindu Kashmiri pandits ? Come on...Why is that while talking about Humanity you talk about only Muslims?
@@radhasade I am with you on this as i believe in Justice more than anything else. Unfortunately we don't have credible leadership which makes our good deeds invisible but individually we're not against innocents.
सुनहरी पंक्तियाँ...
"आप मुस्लिम जर्नलिस्ट है, न जाने क्यों अब मैं इसे ताज की तरह पहनती हूँ"
अल्लाह आप की हिफ़ाज़त करे |
Kalla Tent Nahi pehna Begum ne
Allah naraz hogga 😢
Q? Kya kahyna chattay hoo???
It isn't fight for survival of any community but survival of civilised society based on harmony n peace.
You are right brother. I may be wrong but I feel she is trying to communalize the whole scenario. There are definitely some incidents happened which imparalised the democratic system and as a secular country we should reach out to each and every citizen with true and clear facts and figure Irrespective of faith but not the the way she does here. We know her as a journalist not as a religious speaker.
Phele kashmiri pandits ka badla lenge uske baad ye sab sochenge
Na its fight against bharatiya sanskriti supporters mean fight against bjp only
आरफा जेहादन है, यह कभी भी कश्मीरी हिंदूओं के दर्द पर नहीं बोली, सभी सेकुलर जेहादी और वामपंथी एक जैसे ही होते हैं
The Reality is Majority of Indians are mesmerized by BJP
OBC/ST/SC who are thinking they are hindu's are getting slowly economical and educationaly marginalised
They are slowly deprived of Education and employment
But they are enjoying marginalization of Muslim.
Well done Arfa . This was a long time comming . Every decent Indian stands with you. Mad respect to you . Love and light to all our Muslim brothers and sisters . You have contributed so much to this country and we are prroud of you .
जब कोई प्रधान मंत्री चुना जाता है तो वो किस एक पार्टी या किसी विशेस कम्युनिटी के लिए नही बल्कि पूरे देश। के लिए चुना जाता है
😂but mualims do not vote for Modi so why will modi work for them?
किया असा हो रहा ह भाई ह
@@dipoboyrogu9366 still he do
You are a gem of India .May Allah SWT reward you abundantly for your fair and just journalism . So glad that a muslim woman is such a good journalist. I love you dear Dr Arafa Khanam Sherwani. May Allah protect us all.
Salute to this lady... despite dirty and filthy lang of bjp she is doing her honest work !!
She is putting her self in danger situations
Love from Punjab ❤️
@sydmohe keep crying and spread propaganda, bt one day you will accept Islam when you decide to seek truth
@suriyhaprakhas356 only godi media is honest 😁😁😁😁
Why she is still roaming free despite spreading propoganda?
Nice to listen from your heart madam Arfa. May god bless you.
Very nice speech delivered. Thank you Arfa ji.
आरफा जी, आपकी निडर पत्रकारिता और बेबाक शब्दों के लिए आपको नमन 🫡
Someone said, " Communalism of 1947 has become Nationalism of 2023. Let's change it.
In 1947 nation divided in the name of religion muslim got there separate nation but nation of hindus got hijacked by secular it will be changed.
@@samratroy7100you are wrong or rss minded!! India never divided by religion base... It was used for dirty politics by British ruler. Hindu Muslim Dalit Adivasi sikh Easayee all are brothers of our beloved country thank you.
@@mdabduljabbar4755 I don't know what history you have reading everyone knows our nation divided in the name of religion for proof Pakistan and Bangladesh also exist in this world.
@@samratroy7100 There is no history book in favour of your thoughts Sir if it is then please give reference....I think this type of discrimination (thoughts) is spread out only for power of politics that is need not for our country..In this way gradually we push our country back. Unity in diversity is the only power of our country we should remember. Thank you sir.
@@mdabduljabbar4755 read history of partition of india I can understand why you are trying to fool other.
I appreciate your style of speech, even you can make your opponent viewers as your very attentive and captive audiences. I admire your sensible and seasoned speech.
Powerful outstanding speech respect and salute to arifa madam 🙏🙌👍
Arfa ji is a model for journalists especially Muslim journalists, she is a voice of people who socially, economically, politically, educationally are at the lowest level of marginalisation in India. Her journalism and analysis is always based on the truth and facts that's why people who believe in majoritism, communalism, terrorism can't digest it.
Arfa khanum such an outstanding journalist in contemporary India.
What a great speech. It gives positive energy to me being a Muslim.
Yes, you Muslims certainly need some cheer up...but that's not going to be enough😂😂
@@sydmohe no I don't think congress removed Hindus.. if it would have been the case then there will be no Hindus left till now during the congress reign of 60 years. Congress never did the politics of religion like BPEE doing.
@snyxpr4618 nope ,congress only did the politics of minority appeasement unlike BJP
@@SatyaVani-fq1fl you are right . No hindu is bombing Muslims. No hindu is doing suicide bombing in masjids. They have done all this for 40 years. They have brought this change. I was indian,now I am hindu
True quote by Arfa khanam jee i salute your courageous reporting in Ara of undeclared emergency ❤
Ms Arfa Khanum is not only a brilliant journalist but also a great intellectual person. The main responsibility of any intellectual person is to stand with the ordinary people and question power, she is one of the boldest faces to stand with people and question the power in India. India is fortunate to have her as a citizen, journalist, and intellectual voice.
Arfa khanam always a true journalist.
आरफा जी आपने पत्रकारिता को शिद्दत से निभाया है।
धन्यवाद🙏💕
Bechari ko kyun boukhala k pagal bana k rakhna chahate ...tumhari jhooti tarif ko such samajh kar aur khudd ko innocent samajhkar ....jal kar khaak hogi Ammijaan meri
Absolutely correct. You are right, we are wid you Arfaaji, WE ARE PROUD OF YOU!
Amazing Speech❤ It is not about Hindu or Muslim or India or Pakistan. IT IS ABOUT BEING HUMAN
Well said!!! That notion of being a human has disappeared completely in India. It is sadden my motherland had turned to be everywhere and everyone fight each others based on religions. Mr Godi had unleashed the devil 😈 against minorities.
hello bot
Excellent comments 💯👍
First tere khud ko mahabharat me, ramayan, puranomo me, Aaj tere jaise log khud ki jaati me kitne himsast history check karo, Aaj ke din USA or Europe countries me check karlo Islam ko public khubool kar rahi hai, go check through internet, tere jaise log ke wajhe se aaj India me problem pyda ho rahe hain
Being human is super
Salute you for your fearless, truthful, and to-the-point journalism/activism on the situation in India. You are very clear about communalism. It is not a new phenomenon, as you said it was under wraps, hidden, and not celebrated like it is now. I remember it vividly while studying at DPS when Salman Khursheed was the head boy and I was in 5th grade, Dr. Zakir Husain was president of India, I used to be taunted with slurs like "Mulla". Where did the 5th graders learn to call someone"Mulla." I also remember we never had any discussions at home about Hindus or Hindu religion. As an Indian Muslim, I don't identify myself as Muslim, my Identity in my mind is Indian. I don't hate Pakistan, I have no ill will toward Pakistan or the people of Pakistan, I would like to conclude with an observation about my Hindu friends here in the Washington DC area. They have the same hatred toward Muslims as it is in India and this is destroying their families. When you have hatred inside you you will self-destruct, if this is any consolation for Muslims, LOL!
Very Great Journalism ❤❤❤
Madam you have done a very great job by giving such an exllent speech 😊
She have Leadership Skills ❤❤❤
Very emotional and facts about Indian negative politics
A very learned, cultured lady, with extraordinary demeanour, also truthful, unafraid journalist. God bless her!!!!
Madam,
Do humbly appreciate the time, effort, and passion that you have towards journalism. Pray that God be with you and protect you 🙏
Arifa ji every enlightened knows what is going on in our country. You are playing your role honestly and we keep on doing this novel work. The days are not far-off when we will get rid of this problem. Jai hind Jai INDIA INDIA zindabad.
Very emotional speech by medam ❤❤❤
Excellent speech I believe that every man should work for them who need your support against some evils
Very nice👍supperrrr speech Arfa khanamji.
Arfa Khanum
Madam आप भारत की सबसे उम्दा पत्रकार (Journalist )हो मेडम आप के साथ भारत की 75%जनता है
“People Who Say Communalism Began From 2014 Wish to Hide Sectarianism Since 1950”-Asaduddin Owaisi
I am 100 percent with you bu 2014 k baad zyada tar sector me me tabahi dekhne ko milta hai
Owaisi toh bjp ko help kar ke malai kha raha hai
@@vaishalipedram2745
Ye sirf kahne ki baat hai
Tumhare mutabiq Owaisi ko chunav nahi ladna chahiye
Agar hum dharam aur rajniti ko alag kar sakein toh is desh ko bahut aage le ja sakenge
आपका भाषण अद्वित्य अतुल्य विशेष एवम अनूठा अवशोषित था/है! हम देख/सुनकर साराभोर हैं! ये दिल को छुए बिना नहीं रहा! मस्तिष्क को झकझोर दिया! मन करता है कि एक बार और शुरू से सुना और देखा जाए! हर बार जहन शब्दों के नए अर्थों को खोजता है | लाइनों के बीच में कही / अनकही गई बात को समझने का मन करता है| समय का पता ही नहीं लगा कि कब प्रोग्राम शुरू हुआ और कब पलक झपकते ही संपन्न हो गया | जितनी भी प्रशंसा की जाय कम लगती है |
अरफा जी आपको नमन | क्षमायाचना |
Fantastic speech 👏👏..
The situation of minorities not only watched by international community but active actions must be done in today's India
Over 50 killed in Pakistan blast on Nabis birthday. Eating biriyani and producing babies. No education
Yes you must do ghazwa e Hind right? Shirk must be removed right??😂😂😂😂 Even though Your own nations are precariously in peril 😂😂😂
Walla hu Khairul Makireen!
You are not alone India is with you
Amazing Speech, Excellent very very great presentation Madame.
Thanks for the best sentences you spoke.
Let us not get desperate.
India is a very good country for us.
We are proud, fortunate, blessed to be born and remain here.
More power to you Aarfa Ji, prayers for ur success, health and prosperity and above all reporting truth.
Great speech 👏👏👏👏👏👏
Hindu musalman Sikh issai sab ek hai bharat mei..
Lekin sirf apni apni dharam ke dalalo ne ye lakire khis diya hai ki ek dharam dusre dharam ke khilaf hai..
Ye ek bura waqt hai ! Dhol jayega...
Atsi dour aayenge...
Burai jar se khatom hone wala hai isiliye ye thoda bura waqt chal Raha hai...
Nafrat batne wala khud ki zindegi ko alvida kehne se pehle khud hi sabko bhai saara hote huye dekh ke jayega...
Ye nafrat baatne wala sab ek koone mei hoga aor mat ki bhikh mangega ! Lekin sab ko bhai saara hote huye dekh ke jaayega...
Wohi hogi unlogo ki saza ....
Trust me....
I don't
She's one of the finest Journalists in the country.
To save Indian Democracy, Intellectual Journalists those who dare to ask questions of public interest should be given political representation to phase out elected dictatorship
Salute to you ma'am for your clarity n outspoken-ness. Really ...the emotion in ur voice can be felt. Support to you always ❤
Absolutely Right Mam. Amazing speech❤️❤️❤️
Well said Arfaji. Even this phase will pass!!
Phase
@@kwikstage-lakshminarayanan Typo!! Anyway you got the msg.
Sherwani is great and excellent generalist who speaks without any fear.
Huge speech!
Very bold and honest upload of TRUTH and REALITY...!
This is our beloved BHARAT..!
Salute for enriching us.
Support you mam for your struggle against hate
I always admire and respect your feelings and your socio journalism.
Amazing and beautiful speech. Hat's off to you.
Arfa ji main hindu hun par aapki har ek lafz se talluk rakhti hun. Main apne muslim bhaiyon ke dard se behad aahat hun.
जब घर का मुखिया ही घर के सदस्यों में भेद भाव और फुट डालेंगा तो वो घर का हाल क्या होंगा.... आप खुद अच्छी तरह समझते हो... 🇮🇳 🇮🇳
💯👌
Bold brave guts
Undoubtedly she is a great journalist.Hats off to her.
Salute u Arfa mam 👍❤️❤️
Excellent speech 👏
Good speech
उम्मीद ही इंसान को जिंदा रखती है। 👌
Arifa U R great journeylist women in India. I proud of U.
Gentle but powerful speech.. the genuine anguish shows the immense damage that the Modi era along with the Godi media has been doing to this great country.
Nice 👍 to see National development and economic growth and progress do not matter at all to you! Shara'ah probably does + Ghazwa e Hind 😊
Walla hu Khairul Razikeen!
Qur'an 7:178 naazil on you alhamdulillah is beautiful, awesome.😊
Amazing True speech of brave lady ...I proud on your Parents Specially your respected Father who made you such a highly integrity and brave Journalist and gifted to us(the society) Salute them
Hats off to you. Your words are priceless in these times of expression crisis.
Arfa ma'am you said really well
Absolutely correct 😊
Bibi Arfa khanum sherwani sahiba tuhanu salam 🙏 from Punjab
आरफा मेम आपको साच्ची ईमानदारी पत्रकारिता करने के लिए दिल से धन्यवाद,।
❤❤❤ Great Speech ❤❤❤
Arfa ji I appreciate ur hard work for Society.
Salam hai Aise Journalist ko ... History yaad rakhe aap ko ❤
She is nation,s pride , torch bearer of independent journalism,, an unmatched treasurer of humanity ,
Great speech madam, you have touched the hearts of a sane human beings. Being a Muslim I remember an Ayah from the Qur'an which says the creations plan on this planet but the almighty also plans and the best plan is from the mightiest God. . Let s stay stead fast ...
Fearless and brave lady, a rare gem.
अरफ़ा जी, मैं आपके द्वारा रखे विचारों से सहमत हूँ, समय चुनौतिपूर्ण है, परन्तु भारतीय मुस्लिमों का मुस्तकबिल कोई एक व्यक्ति, कोई एक दल तय नहीं कर सकता!, यह भारत है।
शेरवानी जी आप हकिकत में शेरनी है जो सच्चाई देश के जनता के सामने बेवाक तरीके से रखती है व काबिले तारिफ है ।आपका जज्बे को बार बार सलाह करता हूँ ।
Well done ✅ Arfa mam ...well said 🤗
Arfa ji SSA nice can you make one video on Sikh religion and 1839 Sikh empire 1849 to 1947 to 1984 to 2023 ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤ Muslim need to unite in India and find good leader ❤and Dalit to sc st obc and good general need to unite ❤
Why? How many videos have you made on muslims? You have enough representation in India.
@@Shaggy-8392 brother I don’t have news channel and waheguru know I don’t have any problems with Muslim Hindu or Dalit or any other religion and yes I’m 100 % Khalistani
Thanks Arifafor the superb analysis of the reality of contemporary Indian politics.
एक सच्ची पत्रकार हैं. जबरदस्त रिपोर्टर और हिंदी उर्दू मजबूत पकड. Like fluent
Absolutely true
If work for the deprived and they call you biased, take that as an Award’.
Gandhiji worked for ‘Unto this last’. He was called Mohamad Gandhi.
Zabardast spech allah aap ki hifazat kare
Brave and great lady who always stands for truth without fear and greed ....
I am moved beyond words!
Historical speech ❤❤❤❤
A k sherwani
zindabad zindabad आपके जैसा कोई नहीं Allah aapki hifazat krey😎🍒😎🍒
Powerful speech by an intellectual journalist.
Almost tears trickling down my eyes.
ماشاء allah, الحمد للّه
Arfa ji, You are a bold and a brave lady.
This speech is an eye opener for all Indians, Congress supporters or BJP supporters. Your analysis are thorough and unbiased.
Very nice mam इतिहास के सुनहरे अक्षरों में आपका नाम लिखा जाएगा
Her words are priceless ❤
Thank you Arfaji for the thought provoking speech which is a wake up call for millions of sane Indians to reflect where India is today .