Russia: Old foe or new ally? | Head to Head
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 26 ก.ย. 2024
- In this episode of Head to Head , Mehdi Hasan talks to Natalia Narochnitskaya, a Russian historian and former member of the Duma, or Russian parliament, for the ultra-nationalist party Rodina (Motherland).
We discuss with her Russia's intervention in Syria and Ukraine and the annexation of the Crimean peninsula, and the consequences of these actions for its relationship with Western powers and NATO. We also discuss President Vladimir Putin's rule and examine the country's human rights record.
More from Head to Head on:
TH-cam - aje.io/4a46
Facebook - / ajheadtohead
Twitter - / ajheadtohead
Website - aljazeera.com/h...
Mehdi Hassan should interview Putin!
That idiot WILL interview Putin, as soon as he has oneway ticket on Elon Musk SpaceX to flee to Mars. Don't worry, I have friends in GRU, something "unfortunate" will happen to airlock or his cryotube with sticker on his space suit..."From Russia with Love"!
@@mikhailalexandrovichrimsky5501 Here comes the Russian boot
Mehdi got someone bash here
4 yrs on and Mehdi is proven wrong.
Wouldn't it be fun to see that fool torn to shreds by Putin?
- ..only one condition.
- What's the condition?
- ..that Ukraine doesn't enter NATO (doesn't? lol)
- Ukraine didn't enter NATO
- ...
MetalyxOfficial: “But the US/CIA NATO Hooligans have continued to Arm the Ukraine AZOV NeoNazi’s and Maidan TERRORISTS and have even sent in Erik Princes’ Blackwater mercenaries to continue their acts of TERRORISM against the mostly Russian citizens of East Ukraine. 🔥🇺🇸🔥🇬🇧🔥🇫🇷🔥🐍🔥🐀🔥💩🔥🤮🔥
They both in it together..they sit on their warm arses while ppl die.
Ukraine doesnt need to bea NATO member to install NATO infrastructure
NATO poisoned Stanley Meyers and his brother is a witness. They intended to poison the brother with the same tea, but when Stanley took one first sip, he grabbed his neck and proclaimed "They poisoned me!" And he ran out , falling down dead in the restaurant parking lot. Why? He invented the fuel cell and in combination with a Fractal Gear device had a car which runs on a cup of water for a year.
In a way, it happens they have
This host is next level.
Шикарно пропесочили старушку.
@J Annette успела выразить свою агрессивную шовинистическую сущность))
I am always mesmerized by the confidence and boldness of every guest in head to head. Way beyond Zlatan Ibrahimovich. Always interesting.
По словам этой женщины. Чечня, Дагестан, Татарстан, Башкирия и Якутия можете отделяться от России. Дальнии восток проведите референдум в состав Японии. Будете ездить на праворульках без растоможек.
Western drama !! You never talked of Iraq,Kosovo,Lybiya that western and USA had commited crime in humanity .
And Mehdi Hasan has also very vocally called out the US for all that you mentioned (except Kosovo I think).
All Russian allies and murderous dictatorships.
@@nickward230 He talked about kosovo too. He interviewed former french foreign minister, who was also a NATO beaurocrat who was send to Kosovo with international forces, and Mehdi grilled him hard for allowing atrocities against serbians. It was one of this series of interviews, and it's still on youtube.
The world begged the US to go into Kosovo
правильное замечание по поводу беспокойства России о потенциальном членстве Украины в НАТО:
«Если Россия не хочет, чтобы Украина стала членом НАТО, наверное, ей лучше было бы не заниматься военной интервенцией в этой стране.» (этот момент на 16:30 на этом клипе).
Действительно Россия своей интервенцией провоцировала (и провоцирует) именно то, что так сильно её беспокоит. Это абсолютно естественно и предсказуемо, что первым делом Украина будет бежать именно к НАТО за самозащитой от этой интервенции (и от дальнейшей интервенции) на своей собственной территории.
Станет ли Украина членом НАТО или нет -- это открытый вопрос. Но Россия делает всё от нее зависящее, чтобы подталкивать Киев именно к этому желанию и надобности.
Угу, действия России - лучшая реклама для НАТО. Может они там сговорились сидя за рюмочкой чая?
leh2012 Шоб нет,так да.Решили развалить НАТО с помощью Украины.Хороший ход , если так.
то же самое можно и про Америку сказать - ради экономических интересов она ставит свои интересы под риски через агрессивную внешнюю политику
UN and NATO are human rights abusers.
A prescient comment
Я посмотрел передачу целиком, она интересная. Обращу внимание на момент, который носителями английского-со-словарем не может быть замечен. У нашей дамы отвратительная манера речи и деревянный язык, это просто, на слух, Доктор Зло, "русский злодей" из кино. У всех остальных участников язык свободный и формулируют они гораздо более умело. Лучше всех путинизм защищал английский профессор. Нарочницкая при этом плыла по всем вопросам вообще, особенно про малайзийский самолет и убийства журналистов, а под конец, вишенкой на торте, обнаружилось, что она не владеет терминологией насчет пидородвижения - то что в ленте новостей постоянно. Не владеет терминологией, вы заценили? Это было избиение и макание в говно всю дорогу, абсолютно по всему кругу политвопросов, причем не просто этой тетки глупой, ее вытащили на помост представлять Россию. Не нашлось никого лучше. Я не говорю, что это незаслуженно, однако уж очень позорно. Империя Козла, даже в диванные войска некого рекрутировать, профессионалов нет.
+Sergei Buff Мутко стайл,Серег, ну не берут у нас нормальных людей в думу, хотя бы защищать на мировых площадках политику,к сожалению
+Sergei Buff Насосала на должность. Всегда убивало это "лет ми спик фром зе харт" в исполнении высших чинов.
Andrii Surzhenko Я английский преподаю,историю знаю, но меня на гос службе за родину - послали
Andrii Surzhenko Им нахер не нужны люди своей страны,которые готовы защищать ее интересы
+Sergei Buff Я не очень знаю английский, но все-таки понял почти все. Это не было похоже на макание в грязь. Это было похоже на то, что ее схватили за жопу и протащили по камням. Один камень - Украина, второй - ближний восток и еще куча мелких камней. А так - то я как и все не понимаю зачем она поехала на это, не побоюсь этого слова, шоу.
Mehdi is the man
+prince dos He is Indian
He is a Pakistani Muslim.
She knows what she wants to say but she doesnt know how to put it. Probaby cuz of her english
yeah I felt that too
Her English is pretty darn good tho
Hasan, on a neutral perspective, he didnt allow her to make a point. it rather looked like he was just blasting her in front of a pubblic
No, she just russian
Facepalm for Russia!
OWNED
+Trollytis
например Познер, с его идеальным английским, размазал бы араба
+asdfghjkldfg456 Очень вряд ли.
This should be a hot one!
I'm not pro russia, but I hate the interviewer constantly interrupting her and asking only suggestive questions.
What do you expect from a highly subjective interviewer from a highly adversarial social background? The dude's an Allahuakbar; he's attacking a White woman. What did you expect?
@@rubynibs The little Muslim boy must spout the propaganda that is NATO and US lies.
Ukraine should have hung on to those nukes instead of giving it back to Russia in '94!
True
So true. It seams we paid for service in advance and prepaid things are never to be get. Especially in case of Putin's regime which never helds to any agreements
I think they didnt have enough funds to maintain them unfortunately
You are not an objective interviewer....you are an abusive interviewer...you keep interrupting....I am not a Putin fan but I need to hear both sides objectively.
i am a Putin fan.He said {2015 US and Russia need to allie up.Peace thru force
He sai the middle east is in DEEP chaos.
Mehdi is more concerned with the Mehdi show and gotcha moments, humiliating interviewees. It's easy for him as a bright slick talker bouncing from topic to topic in his first language, while his interviewee has to be careful dealing with their second or even 3rd language. He's never shown such a disdainful approach to Qatari guests. Paycheck loyalty?
Put Peter Lavelle in the sit to give you some lectures. Please invite the right persons for good answers. Thanks to Internet & TH-cam.
+Jimipedia
плохая идея - спорить, не зная языка
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣mehdi is the best please please more head to head we need more
I don't remember this rage over Libya. I do remember that during the Iraq invasion people who could afford it found refuge in Damascus.
The destruction of Libya was planned by CIA just as the domestic war in Syria. I wrote several articles about that when the war started where I predicted today´s situation in Libya. when the war in Libya was said to be a success as Khadaffi was killed weapons and ISIS fighters were sent from Libya to Syria to destroy the Assad regime. You need to read other media then Fox :-)
You interviews really get to the meat... I love to listen and learn what sometimes is unreal reality.
And you ask the vary tough questions that need to be heard... wow... thing get hot but you keep the heat on...
this guy is incredibly rude to all of his guests, he's a jerk and you think that he's a good interviewer come on man 🙄
Imagine how Tony Blair would survive if he participate at this interview
damn she's gettin rekt.
+Bilbo Weer No she isnt you dumbfuck
Reg Varney
i think you haven't seen the video then.
+Bilbo Weer Ofc he hasn't, because he is shitting up the comments section for money, which weren't even indexed properly after the whole crimea fail.
You can read more on this there: globalvoices.org/2015/07/13/open-source-information-reveals-pro-kremlin-web-campaign/
+Oktavia Von Seckendorff haha Poroshenko openly asks Ukranians to join internet propaganda forces of Ukrain and if Russia does that than it`s evil propaganda) I wish i could get a job at Olgino but they are true professionals. They can make Ukranins cry by combination of several simple words .
+Василий ПечкинЪ Poroshenko nor Obama don't spend your $ billions for internet and news lie. gl supporting stealing from your pocket
Has he tried having a conversation with Putin then you'll see the real thing
Is Mehdi an interviewer or prosecutor?
I've never seen such rudeness. He constantly cuts her off, loudly speaks over her. She deserved better, I don't care if she is Russian.
yeah, but she is a cool russian lady who has no problems with that pressure. IMO her attitude makes her very believable and she easily won the debate ! :-)
What do you expect from a highly subjective interviewer from a highly adversarial social background? The dude's an Allahuakbar; he's attacking a White woman. What did you expect?
This lady just don't know how to tell lies.
True.
SHE'S.TOTALLY.DELUSIONAL....DUMA....ULTRA.RIGHT.WING...PRO.RUSSIA...GO.GO.GO.RUSSIA...!!!!
Mehdi does.
Respect to Mehdi for being well researched and tough in confronting her lies!
Watching this in 2019. Putin was right about Syria!
@Bobon Meiknob everything
@Bobon Meiknob Such is the charm of liberals. They will stay with their grades.
She's can't handle Mehdi Hassan.
perhaps because English is not her native language ! it is very difficult to be rushed and bullied in a foreign language !
And you can't handle English either ...😂😂🤣
@@worriedalot525 even native speakers cant handle Mehdi Hasan :))))
there is no way you can talk to a terror supporter
I love the way in which Russian speaks English.
Accent is so beautiful ....
I am russian , sorry for my goverment(
Watch out, Putin might throw in prison
To whom are you apologising?
why you are sorry ? russia is on right track.
I think if the citizens of all countries could get rid of a large part of their Governments and talk as a people we would all be better off. I hear/read many comments from nations across the world on how they hate their current Government including the US. The Governments all use the same tactic, just in different ways. That tactic, FEAR!!! Fear and Religion are 2 of the main ways to control a large population. If there is nothing to fear, they (The Governing Body) will create something to fear, which has been proven many times throughout History. Why can't we all just get along?? ;)
you're a disgrace to Russia.
Give her a chance to speak before you interrupt with information you heard on FOX
Prime Minister Azarov had left Kyiv before Yanukovych.
Love this woman. She’s soft spoken n does not get mad. She’s a great leader.
I don`t like the fact that the host doesn`t let people finish their say. I am not a big fan of Russia. But I am interested in their views. Let me hear them and don`t interrupt them...
Partly l, I agree with you, but I think he was also worried about the time. The issue was to vague, as well as the panel was making their arguments on so many topics...hard to fit in 47 min.
Irritating 😠 host.
Mehdi Hasan forgot to mention that Syria officially requested Russia's help to fight the insurgents - unlike US' unilateral intervention in Iraq, Libya and even in Syria.
Ok, so Russia was invited by a genocidal dictator who has killed 200,000+ civilians.
This is not head to head episode it's EAST vs WEST the journalists sounded stupid he was asking her childish question, the only good part of this program was the author he was not pro or against any party, the journalists was talking about what the HRW and the western media said not on Aljazeera TV or any other independent based facts it's all about who pointed the finger at who
Lol. Mehdi condemns Assad as a dictator, yet works for the Qatari dictatorship.
Is imam mehdi not aware of the "project for new American century"... If he was... He wouldn't be so harsh on Russia and Syria
Imam?
This is just whataboutism, as usual on critical discussions. Mehdi regularly calls on pro-US people and pretty much "roasts" them. Even in this video, he mentions how he invited a NATO official last time and had a fierce debate when the lady calls him "pro-NATO".
Just propaganda . The people is not stupid.
+Claudio Vial by Russia?
While there were funny moments in the interview, overall this was probably the most pointless head to head episode. she just lied blatantly throughout
Mehdi is that the way your boss told you to interview the Russian lady
Ноу криминалити.
:D
Completely torn apart. These guys are tidbits for skilled interviewers - completely unprepared and unaccustomed to real questioning unlike staged interviews in Russia. She's a collective image of Russia's mood - aggressive, easily irritated, blatant, egocentric and, mainly, stupid. Well done, Mehdi, well done.
god bless you natalia narochitskaya
I agree, I can’t stand to watch his interviews any more.
He ask them questions and then doesn’t let them answer
And talks over them.
This is not an interview! It is an interrogation!
Yeah, but that cool russian lady easily won the debate anyway :-)
It's not an interview. It's a lecture by Mehdi Nasan where he expects Natalia to agree or feel embarrassed. I'd love to have heard more of Natalia actually. That all looks more like manipulation than a professional interview. Really disappointed in Al Jazeera, not for the first time, though.
no wonder the US Govt doesn't want AJ - they actually ask hard questions & don't allow people to skate with BS answers
D Luch+ Thank you for saying the US Government and not it's citizens. For the most part the citizens do not like our Government for many of the same reasons citizens in other countries do. We need a peoples Government that is actually accountable to it's citizens!!
@@roberts.3055 5 star comment .
Despite the woman's broken English I gather that she is saying that before ww2 the Soviet Union proposed a treaty to the "west" (supposedly France and the UK?) which involved protection of countries surrounding Germany. Is there anyone here who knows what treaties she is refering to? Another treaty, less flattering to Russia, comes to mind though. The treaty I am thinking about would be the Molotov-Ribbentrop pact with Germany to split eastern europe between them.
Could you trust this man?
They made a pact with Germany to split Poland
I usually don't watch state-owned media because of the obvious conflicts of interest and biases and whatnot. However, Al Jazeera is a lot better at separating their views/opinions from truthful journalism. They aren't always perfect and not always without biased and you can always tell the Qatari view on every episode when watching this news network, but I honestly feel they are near the top of state-owned media. Like I said, I prefer private or public journalism. I do not like state-owned media generally. I'm actually a libertarian leaning person so me watching a state-owned news network is different. I can't stand RT news though, there biases are blatant and they lie and twist stories almost every single time. I truly respect Mehdi Hasan for his on his journalism. I mostly just watch the stories and debates that Mehdi Hasan is in. I feel as though he is the most honest and unbiased .
It does not matter what media it is when the live panel is staged and two pepole engage each others view . In this case Russian views and politics got destroyed with facts .
Oh great...then stop watching Fox, MSNBC, CNN and 30 others!
Remigius Polański
The lady successfully countered most of the misconceptions despite her difficulty with the language.
I love this series so much !
this series sucks and reeks of all false information
I used to like this guy but I now know he's just another puppet
puppet for who?
@@jaafarbouh2956 go ask him
If you blame someone !
Prove it.
Otherwise, Just shut up.
@@bilaldouglas726 you're clearly a bit simple. Why are you watching this and not 'Top 10 Bush prank' videos?
@@iqbalali5678 clearly u lost your way why waste time watching prank when u should be learning how to fear your Lord the you need to. I much rather do things that might benefit me wen I die. I'll stay simple worshipping and fearing my Lord... Keep watching ur pranks Mr complicated guy
If you people care about those Sunni Muslim in Syria and why not about those innocent Shia in Bahrain? Muslim always make trouble.
+abuaimen28 all nasty things you have mentioned comes from the terrorists. Saudi Arabia everyday barrel bombs schools, and hospital in Yaman but no one says anything. Im not taking anyone is side because I'm not Muslim, but Assad has right to defend his country. You said, in Bahrain innocent people do not suffer the way innocent people suffer in Syria and you came out with crazy figure. Have you ever asked yourself why is this happening? Before war started Syria, Syria was one the best country in the world but America didn't want them to grow rapidly and give free oil to America. Why do you think Saudi Arabia is a very close ally of America? Let me give the answer because your brain is not working, because Saudi Arabia feed America by oil, otherwise America treat those other Arabs.
+abuaimen28 haha Saudi gives to its people more than Assad. Firstly women have not got right to do anything in Saudi Arabia. Secondly they behead 200 hundred people each year. Is that what the Saudi gives to its people more than Syria?
+abuaimen28 House of Al Saud does not treat their people better than House of Assad that is because West and Americans are not arming the opposition groups in Saudi. If they did you will know how they will be beheaded in Saudi cities. Problem in Syria is that Americans and West are arming groups opposing Assad. Assad is killing people who have taken arms against his regime. It is simple and every regime on earth would do exactly the same but America, whose Middle East policies are devised in Israel are pretending Assad is simply bombing his own people. Israel is the evil in Middle East and responsible (via the Israeli-American neocon)for Iraq, Afghanistan, Libya and Syria.
Way to go Mehdi Hassan! You are the man!
this lady is not intellectually able the defend Russia
+Angelica Borshch That's why they had her on.
mkay
+Angelica Borshch. She is, its just that she has a so so poor case.
and you're not intellectually able to write properly....
John Pilbeam freak
Why ask the lady a question if you never let her answer, why always interrupting her? We the people of the world knows what's going on here. Thank God for Russia
Mahad, you should not be against Russia activities in Syria! I thought you knew more about the Zionism movements in the globe.
Russia far far worse than Zionism for Syria.
I wonder why they never talk about democracy, human rights, and gay rights in Saudi Arabia
Zionism is not the problem in Syria.
Fake journalism
Why does mahdi had an flip flop between issues just to look like he has a hard stand
I think the question got answered ..
These Al Jazeera hypocrites talk about Crimea. Lol can't they remember Kosovo? Which this channel applauded.
Point of this interview is very valid now ,taking in to account about whats happening in ukraine ..its almost like its inevitable
Her non chalance makes it more engaging to watch.
Stop to interrupt the guest avery answer let them allows to speaks
This issue are difficult there is so much we have to be happy they in fact are communicating the issues
Гениально! Эта дама как никто другой представляет лицо путинской России. В купе с ужасным английским и внутренним презрением к аудитории её можно приглашать во все передачи для демонстрации цивилизованной аудитории лица путинской власти. Браво, Нарочницкая!
Airl_SA Μη μη μη, а тебе бы,подтянуть грамматику.
Assad has no repressive regime.....Assad is an intelligent noble leader. Who pays you?
Gulf states and Israel (USA).
Came here after the Russia-Africa summit. Thumbs up to Russia. You have a lot of love and popularity in Africa. Soviet Union helped African countries get independence from The West and for that Russia will always be a friend of Africa. Dont be alarmed when you come across an African with the first name Soviet or Moscow lol!
Stay strong Mother Russia! Mamma Africa sees you!
respect Mehdi Hasan
Sure there are Fascist processions every January in Kyiv. The same sort of Fascist processions happen every November in Moscow & St Petersburg. The same in Warsaw too. That according to her logic would make Russia & Poland Fascist states.
Interviewer talking about human rights...
Why not talking about Human Rights in United Arab Emirates and Qatar (Al Jazeera headquarter by the way), which live under Sharia law?
gotta say, on the other side of mehdi arguing a complex issue, using second language as means of communication is tough
I’m not Ukrainian but i love Ukraine and Ukrainians.
Russian Trolls does not recognize logic and common sense. That's why so many dislikes. Kremlin Bots common here ))))
Nyet!!! We have manners! Normally we first wait for person speaking to finnish before next question! This idiot is like typical Western reporter, they love creating comical drama by rudely interrupt someone before they can explain, for THIS puts heavy pressure and nervousness on guest esp with hostile audience! Like she said is true, West DO wish Russians to vanish in Black Hole! Sorry IDIOT! That is OUR part of Earth, keep your demonic black soulless carcass away as it was by YOUR grave you call mouth that slandered that people seem to vanish who oppose us...DA! Watch out for our Black Hole!
This was an absolute embarrassing "interrogation"
Don't push the Slavs
This host was pumped up to bomb the panelists against Putin from the word go.
hats off to you mehdi hassan
very biased host! unsubed! what about Saudi? The are supposed to be 100 billion in arms sales in something like the next ten years to Saudi? Woman's rights, Ethiopian "workers" rights, the war in Yemen!
No point in mentioning Saudi Arabia here, the argument will go nowhere here, The best time to bring up Saudi, when the topic is about Saudi, this lady seems to not answer the question.
I am no apologist for Russia, USA, or any other power corrupt regime including Saudi. Power corrupts and absolute power corrupts absolutely. I am a free man and will speak as such. Salam to those who can still remember what it means and why humans were given the ability to understand it1
I prefer, though not always good at myself, the constructive critic as opposed to the adversarial approach. Or heaven forbid a constructive collaborative problem solving approach. Pie in the sky I supose
+Ben Parkinson Saudis? thought this was about Russia hypocrisy
the critico alternative libertarian media yeah Let's not talk about THE Saudis #being sarcastic#
Well... this video aged well 👀
Another great episode by Mehdi, it doesn't matter if it's US or Russia they all should be held accountable
The interviewer is annoying and isn't well informed
I'm shocked. There was a referendum in Chechnya. Why she did not mentioned about it? Chechens chose to stay with Russia.
Mehdi has to learn to let his guest's finish a sentence before pounding. He doesn't seem as informed on this subject as he should have been
This journalist is flawed in some way he does all this body language to distract the audience from paying attention to the answers being given and only wants to get his point across and relating issues that occupy different spaces and context in which they are derived from and by doing that he makes even the smallest allegation seem like the biggest thing ever. just look at him in every interview his shaking his head in disapproval making degrading sounds. i like his line of questioning but not his actions because the people he interviews really have good points but clouded by his movements,making it hard to hear the other view of the world. he plays a psychological game on the guest and impedes on their ability to effectively communicate like acting there answer half way as if he already knows what they are on about or as if he knows where the answer is leading to .. and he does this in every interview pro or against western interest
Mehdi Hasan is just brilliant journalist
Sounds like paid interview, in comparison to all other decent ones.. Really disappointed of Head to Head..
Mehdi Hasan was great in this discussion!
one of the funniest episodes of head to head ever. typical Russians, LOL
Her whataboutism is incredible
I never see the same questions being asked to US/Western administration apologists. Horrible patronizing questions from the journalist that wouldn't let the guest to complete her words!
Russia is NOT my foe. They are doing good things in the world.
Such as.....?
@@annechester770 They have a work visa with USA for students of University.They work here and do Great !!
@@annechester770 The liberation of Africa from neocolonialism
@@kiswahilikitukuzwe2547 Asante ssebo
Putin is the leader who care about his citizens and country. No leader is perfect in anyway.
Your questions are very preposterous and acutely partial.
Appreciate Russia for tremendous contribution towards world peace. I felt the US could have contributed more if she is not run after the economic benefits, if she is not run after the middle east oil... In the name of Human Right the US destroyed many nations where the people suffered 100 times more than the bring justice to the people...
Hope and pray that the countries like Russia, US, China, etc should work together for the world peace.
I don't think this was a fair fight really... Calling a lady who can barely express her viewpoints in English and who seems to be very bad at getting the point across to oppose such a brilliant debater like Mehdi is a quite a lame move from whoever chose her to be an oponent..
с переводом есть?
love russia respect for her trying to speak in English while interview just keeps interrupting herm
She wasn't interrupted until she started to be in contradiction with herself and just telling a lie as she did all the time of interview
Letting the woman answer the question before reading from foot notes and asking the next unrelated question mid-sentence would be nice. Watched another interview that went about the same way. No subdivision of culture, population and political leaders from the interviewer.
P0SlTR0N i noticed this too. The journalist seems to be quite hostile toward some of his guests. But not all.
Где можно найти это видео с субтитрами или переводом??дайте ссылку))
нашел перевод на русском?