Just as with heresy, there are degrees to schism. I agree that the SSPX is not in a state of "Formal Schism." However, I think the evidence that they are material schismatics is pretty overwhelming.
I think the evidence that the teachings of Vatican II is in material (if not formal) schism is even more overwhelming. Likewise, evidence of John Paul II as a material heretic is also overwhelming.
Someone already commented this, but the Sung Mass shown at 0:45 and 3:28 is not SSPX, but by the Cannons Regular of St. John Cantius.
"Ad Maiorem Dei Gloriam"!
Pode explicar para que serve a peregrineta dentre os paramentos litúrgicos dos acólitos nesta ocasião? Não tenho entendimento neste assunto,
Just as with heresy, there are degrees to schism. I agree that the SSPX is not in a state of "Formal Schism." However, I think the evidence that they are material schismatics is pretty overwhelming.
I think the evidence that the teachings of Vatican II is in material (if not formal) schism is even more overwhelming. Likewise, evidence of John Paul II as a material heretic is also overwhelming.
you chose a video of a Holy Mass from Canons Regular of st. John Cantius and put the FSSPX logo there
which one
@@NecroOrthodoxy 0:52
Because the SSPX doesn't have very many beautiful Churches...
@@CatholicNicklas Yes, they have some, but a lot of them also are chapels and not churches.
@@piotrjozwiak7951 True, but their liturgy is not the best...they do something different on servers side that no one else does it.
Sspx is cringe. Fssp and icksp is where it’s at
no
I doubt they'd exist without sspx
That's thanks to sspx who had to go live in the alpine mountains!!
@@NecroOrthodoxy ok. Stay in your schism then 👌
@@NecroOrthodoxy enjoy being a schismatic 👌
make a copitc edit
join my zoo
Le décorum y est l'esprit NON Abbé Daniel Maréchal
Pure polytheistic worship, standing bending and stuff...weird
wait till you find out the jews prostrated themselves before the ark of the covenant
You don't bow and stand before God to show respect? Dang, you have no respect for God.
This is the way Christ taught Christians to worship, he did not say to break from the heavenly liturgy established in the ancient nation of Israel.
❤🙏
Nella Santa Madre Chiesa Cristiana Cattolica Apostolica Romana l'azione più importante è l'inginocchiamento.