Well yeah they are really good vocalists but do you know how sm trains their trainees?it's like pure hell tbh....that's why their vocals are another levels...
They chosed the right person from the beginninf, like chen and baekyhun from exo they only have 4 months training before debut, their vocals are very powerful.
im notapotato yes. And the result is so awesome. Its the price for a good result. Like if you want to be a champion you must to work really hard. Its the same.
@@nilachristina work hard?or torture THEM hard?they sing while running on treadmills and some already got their heads underwater while singing you think that's hardwork????they are forced to do that btw
im notapotato its the punishment. Punishment if they are late or make a mistake? I remember key said the coach make them singing while running when they late or made a mistake. Honestly if you watch dream high you can see that. I believe all the agency have that rules too, whats make SM different is they have all the A line coach. Like SM have the best coach for vocal, dance, etc. And they have a good sense too pick a good vocalist in audition.
I wouldn't even put Wendy in comparison to anyone here, tbh, but I love all of Twice and Red Velvet. Wendy is just on a whole other universe as a vocalist 😁😁😁
Ofc power house it says... Not tobe shade but lets be honest AMONG 3RD GEN frm B3 red velvet is way more better when it comes in music scene. Tho BP is Famouse but their only famous of being beauty standard thats why they are more on MODELING aspect than music scene.,As TWICE they just in low standard in music too theyre not even seeing them in any korean music flatform aside frm their stage. Red velvet has more previledge esp in kpop music bcoz they do more collabs frm various artist in korea unlike those 2..
Lunafreya Nox Fleuret, butt hurt reveluv who is jealous of bp and TWICE's success. TWICE has many talents. Chaeyoung is the most talented and can beat your faves alone. She can sing, rap, dance, compose songs, design her own shoes/bags, draw and she is an athlete as well. Can your red velvet do all of these?? And as for bp, they have talent too. I don't stan bp at all but saying that they are just models and have no talent is being delulu. Jennie can rap and dance, Lisa is a rapper and dancer, jisoo is an actress, lead vocalist and can rap too, rosé is an amazing vocalist and a lead dancer. Saying that rv is better and the others are untalented is just nonsense. It's not TWICE or bp's fault that rv isn't as famous as them.
Somebody just found put the truth. In songs have amazing harmony and vocal arrangement, Yeri is like the last element to make a good song becoming a masterpiece.
Finally someone said it! She is like the missing detail. I remember the days when I didn’t like her, but when they perfomed icc without her I was like where is my baby 😦? Something wrong here. Her voice is sweet and pretty sounds to me. I love her, I can’t imagine rv without her
she wasn't given a chance to showcase her vocals but in the last 2 years she proved her worth from her solo song to her live vocals .... I think she adds the sweetness
Lets be honest, Twice can sing (ofc, they have mouth) but they are not stable and powerful. Red Velvet is good at any concept. They can sing stable even if they are dancing. (Note that Red Velvet's dance is difficult) RV ftw RV- Real Vocal RV- Real Voice
Isabelle Chloe park pokoyong yu Now I know why nobody is defending TWICE in the comments. It's because their fans are helping TWICE gain more and MORE views, unlike stupid red velvet fans that are wasting time here!
Nayeon's Rabbit Teeth More views doesnt mean anything. If you are more talented , more people will like you :)) everyone is complaining how TWICE's level is so low. When majority says that , you should know why everyone feels that RV is better ..
+Nayeon's Rabbit Teeth hey rabbit teeth you say that red velvet fans are stupid? so what about you? stupid once, high viewers is doesn't mean they more talented. just go watch their mr removed and WAKE UP
Why are we comparing a group that comes from SM, where some vocals legends are trained, with a group that comes from a company that has alot of good-looking idols? Isn't this pointless?
Theyre the nation's girl group so they deserve being compared on different aspects. Isnt it shameful to have a nations girl group that has a trashy vocal lineup?
HEROBRINE GAMING just 'good' . rv choreo is way unique and dificult . no.1 gfriend no.2 rv no.3 twice thts the list for group dance but we cannot deny tht momo the only one that slay in dance
pika chan you know, trophy is just a thing. But the experience of being nominated for dance awards is more important than winning it. Dont't be boastful because of that 2 dance performance awards. By the way, SM cares a lot for RV. We all know that SM is a bigger company than JYP.
Sehun be like: "If you knew it why would you ask" For me, no one can beat SM Artists. Powerful vocals, overflowing visuals, amazing talents. I can't ask anything more💕
The only people that even come close to RV vocal line is MAMAMOO. And they are either slightly under or tied with them. But Wendy still kills them all.
most of the video is a comparison of rv's singing while dancing and twice sitting while singing but the winner is still rv when it comes to vocal and stability 😂
Everytime I watch RV videos. I go into deep thought and keep contemplating as to when the world will start appreciating genuine talent and versatality. BoA truly said it Popularity is like a bubble but talent is a never ending eternal river.
Seulgi and Joy are both better than Nayeon and let's be honest Wendy is better than any girl group idol from this generation. EDIT: Due to repetitive comments and bc some of y’all are pressed, I’ll add something. Firstly, I precised « from this generation » of Kpop. Which means I didn’t compare Wendy to skilled senior like Luna, Solji, Ailee, Eunji and so on. This gen goes Wendy > Yuju > Solar for me but there are other noticeable vocalists such as Yeonjeong and Seughee, etc. Secondly, Yes Mamamoo is an overall better vocal group compared to Red Velvet, but Wendy is still stronger than all of Mamamoo vocalists, even Solar. Thirdly, Yuju is a really talented singer but Wendy has a wider vocal range and her supporting voice is very stable. Jihyo has vocal power but really lacks technique and stability ((personally, Jungyeon is the best vocalist in Twice)), and we didn't see Rosé's full capacity yet so I can not say she's anywhere near even Joy. Thirdly, as to consider the « soulfulness and feelings » a vocalist delivers is very subjective and varies from on listener to another, I did only consider technical skills in order to make a fair comparison. If you're still pressed, please read the previous comments before adding your one bc parrots are tiring or chillax.
***** They are good, but Wendy is still wayyyyy more better. Yuju is very talented but Wendy has a wider vocal range, Jihyo has vocal power but really lacks technique and stability, and we didn't see Rosé's full capacity yet so I can not say she's anywhere near Wendy.
The only girls I rank close to Wendy are really Yeonjung(Wjsn/ioi) Solar(Mamamoo-Still only about solji level and not a taeyeon level so she's below by a little) And kinda Yuju who is on Solar level at most
i like red velvet. i like twice too. but.. i hate the fact when twice more popular than red velvet. because red velvet is more talented. i'm sorry for my english(:
이주연 i'm sorry but TWICE is the NGG. The only ones denying it are mostly sone lol. You can't choose the NGG. No one can choose the Korean NGG except koreans. The koreans chose TWICE so just accept it
@IDGAF HOE Ooh, now the "cocky Once" side of you is coming out! LOL Your overrated group's popularity is due to a reality show, and the fact that Koreans love aegyo and prettiness more than talent. Your other comments? *Yawn* They were all the same to me; fabricated nonsense about how you consider yourself a professional vocal analyst. Ah, I'm immature and ignorant for not agreeing with your nonsense? hahaha The comedic value of your replies are gold. As i said before, only delusional Onces believe Twice can sing. LOL, and only delusional Onces claim that Twice is the New Nation's GG. Everyone else knows that SNSD are the original legends that Twice can only dream of being. Nice try though. LMAO, I just can't get over how funny you are! You think Twice got their awards because they're actually talented? See my comment about aegyo and prettiness.
park pokoyong yu Now I know why nobody is defending TWICE in the comments. It's because their fans are helping TWICE gain more and MORE views, unlike stupid red velvet fans that are wasting time here!
Nayeon's Rabbit Teeth well, maybe we are wasting our times watching this 'useless' videos, but at least we're not wasting our times on things that is worth it. Anyway, its Red Velvet, they're not wasting their own talent.
Are u serious?!? Even Jihyo and Nayeon, the greatest vocal member from Twice is the same level with Yeri, the worst vocal from Red Velvet. Next (in this situation im telling Nayeon and Jihyo is actually not bad so im not telling Yeri's vocal is bad it's just she's the last rank at rv, but her skill is even more than Nayeon and Jihyo, who is the one can sing in Twice)
How can you compare Red Velvet with Twice? Surely Red Velvet won a landslide. Joy's example in Red Velvet is the third singer but if she's put in twice she must be the main vocal
No twice have talent momo has dancing machine talent can have Excellent graphic design drawing skills Mina can do ballet and can sing Nayeon have great talent in art, she can dance and sing, she is excellent at modelling and was a child model too Jeongyeon is highly skilled in cooking, she can sing too Tzuyu is really talentful and smart in studies, she is also really good at dancing Dahyun is really skilled at dancing, flexible and can rap Chaeyoung is really talented at doing charismatic and charming dancing and can rap plus she can sing vocal really nice Jihyo have excellent acting skills even won many awards for acting, she has a powerful vocal in singing too
hammer red and seulgi also is a dancing machine, she is surprisingly excellent as a vocalist that many people say that she could be the main vocalist, she has such charisma, she is the best performer in my opinion of the third generation, she has excellent drawing skills too. Irene is very flexible, can dance, can sing, is called the prettiest idol of the third generation, she also is such a good lider. Yeri can rap, she can dance, has sweet vocals, and she has a super sweet and soft personality. Joy is the sexy girl, she can rap, dance, and sing, she is the girl that can make you fall in love just with a glare, she also cares a lot for her members, and she is the sweetest girl in the world. Wendy is really smart, she can rap, has vocals from an angel, she is pretty, she can dance, and she has a beautiful personality.
@@lionheart1511 I Stan both groups and I know they are both Talented so stop trying to cause a fanwar when this person never even said anything bad about RV you are the only toxic person I see
actual reasons why rv is better (add more in comments if u want) 1. they have amazing breath support 2. amazing stamina while dancing and singing 3. live performances are above par (just as good as recordings) 4. don't rely on the MR too much 5. they're very meticulous in their training and it shows 6. they don't rely on visuals to get them far 7. they adapt quickly and listen carefully to their voices 8. they have RAW talent and they can all dance and rap if they needed to 9. synchronization is on point 10. they don't make excuses for when a performance isn't up to par. they work even harder Overall, redvelvet is a talent based group with a very amazing bunch of hard working girls. I hope they get even more recognition this year in all of twice the only stable one is jeongyeon, jihyo screams all her high notes and her breath support is horrendous.
I'm prefer to read comments section because i know everyone here agree that red velvet is on different levels with twice, just accept the fact that only jungyeon, nayeon and jiho who can sing in twice, in other side red velvet is slayed in every comeback
@@besttheangrynerd6741 hahahahah. You're right. I wanna laugh bcs every comments i saw that acc trying so hard to depend her fav. Lol. She too biased until she is deaf.
@@42inesperez they could sing,they have good vocal,they were stable, they improve,so what now?still need to bash them because they can't sing??(sorry for bad english)
@@42inesperez and I'm talking about Mina and Tzuyu do you think that they don't have talent?just visual?cause for me they have their own talent,they could dance both and Mina can sing while Tzuyu can rap isn't that talent?
I like Red Velvet and Twice both but Red Velvet is in another level. Red Velvet is a full package. Twice has only cute looks, while Red Velvet is cute and beautiful. In terms of voice only 2 or 3 of twice members can sing, like really! They are 9! While Red Velvet is only 5 yet they can all sing! This is just my opinion, as a fan it's just heart breaking to know that the most talented group is being left behind because of those aegyo. People now a days don't know what TALENT really means
Mika Manacsa it's much harder to manage a nine membered group.having a bigger group will make a member seem less significant.and it will be harder to choreograph dances,split the lines,and basically keep the whole group together without it falling apart.
ThatRottenOtaku Reminds me of another 9 membered girl group that went through much of the same problems. It was so utterly crippling for them that they produced to the most powerful vocal line in their generation, won over two hundred awards and caused a hallyu tsunami that swept Asia away from '09 onwards. Care to guess which group it is?
Spawn of Satin look,im not talking about snsd or comparing them with twice.you're completely going out of the subject here.all im saying is that it isn't as easy as this ignorant person thinks to manage a 9 membered group,or even a kpop group in general,and although yes,they aren't the best vocalists,they definitely ARE talented.
ThatRottenOtaku Talented in what way? Sure, I agree that twice has talent in absolute terms (same could be said for you and me). Depending on how loosely you define "talent" this could go up or down. However, *relative* talent is what really matters. They're talented, but not talented enough compared to groups like Red Velvet, and that's their shortcoming. If you score 90 on a 100 mark test and everyone else scores 97 to 100, you're the one getting an F (assuming bell curve). That's often the sad truth in life. I agree that it's not easy to maintain a 9 membered girl group, but that in itself is no excuse for poor performance.
Redvelvet Joy RV is queen Not really. Jihyo is better than her vocally. Her dancing is on par with Momo but they both are better in different genres. Seulgi can’t really rap. Twice has a lot more charismatic members. So yeah, that’s your opinion I just state facts tbh. 🤪
Momo? the one who looks like a guy? HAHAHAHA jihyo is not better than seulgi . WHEN IT COMES TO TALENT RED VELVET WIN AND WITHOUT JIHYO TWICE CAN'T EVEN PRODUCE SONGS.
Redvelvet Joy RV is queen Aw how sad, you’re obviously very immature. Sad for your fandom. Jihyo is better than Seulgi. If you actually knew a thing or two about vocal technique. You do forget Nayeon gets most of the lines?
I think Twice's songs are very catchy and LSS worthy hence why they are more popular. (And their visuals and they also came from a very well known company) But still... I think Red Velvet's popularity is rising everyday.... So proud to see people recognizing their talent
Lol, is this really a competition? red velvet is obviously amazing.Twice are just girls who don't sing doing aegyo all the time. The real talent needs to be recognized, RV queens 👑👑
twice best and every other group is shit "always lip sync"sorry but I've only seen them lip sync in Japenese ver. You are seriously the deaf one. BTW you are fucking up onces reputaion
@@skyllline24 twice is stable nowth-cam.com/video/jcIe_Gfrpcc/w-d-xo.html, also twice havent collab but they got ost to sing, i think they will collab now
Quêên gotta admit they had... But definitely not a major surgery... I ever heard Joy did surgery because of her nose (sorta slightly messed up, I guess?) and Irene did some minor surgery like deepen her eyelids or something... Mostly for enhancing themselves tho... As for Wendy, Seulgi, and Yeri... Nah, they ain't...
don't come at me with that 'they are still rookies they need to improve' sentence rv was stable in their debut time twice clearly need to be trainees again they aren't even ready to debut
Kiara O'Fallen if she trained for 10 years then she should be even better since so many onces defend twice saying that they are only rookies. if jihyo trained for 10 years she should be able to sing much better and not lip syncing almost every high note
not trying to bash but obviously definitely absolutely Red Velvet is up there both visual and vocal wise, their songs has that swag to it that it doesn't sound or feel cutesy as twice does that in my opinion, is the reason they're so popular! in short their aegyo is no joke,they're so fresh but both their songs and talent are no special. having nine members is a factor too
Twice do have talent, momo has dancing machine talent can have Excellent graphic design drawing skills Mina can do ballet and can sing Nayeon have great talent in art, she can dance and sing, she is excellent at modelling and was a child model too Jeongyeon is highly skilled in cooking, she can sing too Tzuyu is really talentful and smart in studies, she is also really good at dancing Dahyun is really skilled at dancing, flexible and can rap Chaeyoung is really talented at doing charismatic and charming dancing and can rap plus she can sing vocal really nice Jihyo have excellent acting skills even won many awards for acting, she has a powerful vocal in singing too
@baechu but they said it like it’s a fact. Yes I admit that red velvet has better vocals, but no one should discredit twices talent. Toxic red velvet stans love to put down other groups.
@baechu A lot of red velvet stans put down twice. “Red velvet is real talent. Twice is just popular. Twices vocals suck. Stan red velvet for real talen” etc.
Red velvet have true vocalist i mean seulgi is the lead vocalist and she's better than jihyo and jihyo is the main vocalist and i think that no one can sing like wendy in the new kpop generation.
lol sorry but no, Rose still has a long way to go. She and jihyo are probably on par but wendy? Wendy's level of vocal is too high for rose. This generation best female vocalist definitely goes to Wendy, Solar, Yuju.
I really hate the mindset that SM are all about looks like, have they forgotten the main vocals and former artists of sm? The lead vocals even come close. Can't deny that SM produces good vocalists. Over the top
I don't know but for me joy is better than jihyo, go watch her other cover. Seriuosly her technic is another level. She also can hit high note easily, but she is a type that very shy and afraid to show her ability.
BTOB Changjae hm honestly you may be right also joy is my redvelvet bias she has an amazing clarity to her voice i mean i dont know if she is better than jihyo but it is definitely debatable
Christian Estrella did you read the comment on you, european magazine choose seulgi n irene as asian beauty icon, you can watch many reaction fans in yt when they see rv.. irene is best visual of all gb, with suzy n yoona.. many artists always mention rv such as ftisland, cnblue minhyuk, btob, exo, joonyoung, monsta x etc. they interest with rv not only cause their talents, but their beauty
Wendy >>> all Twice members Seulgi >> all Twice members Joy > all Twice members Irene = all Twice members Yeri = all Twice members Thanks. edit!! oh damn i'm here after a year because of the comments and my opinion changed a bit, so i'm gonna leave it in here, i still strongly believe all of them are good vocalists btw. 01 wendy 02 seulgi 03 jihyo 04 joy 05 jeongyeon 06 nayeon 07 irene 08 yeri 09 sana 10 chaeyoung 11 tzuyu 12 mina 13 dahyun 14 momo k that's all stream seulrene's song and more&more when they come out
Jihyo is a better singer than joy and is around seulgi's level in terms of vocal technique. Jeongyeon, nayeon, mina, Tzuyu and chaeyoung all sing better than Irene and yeri while dahyun is around the same level. Wendy is obviously better than all of them tho, You could try being less bias.
But some company said Twice will like Snsd in the 2nd generation of girl group. Like duh? just because their song has a line that will be always remembered like knock knock, ooh aah, shy shy and tt but I think Red velvet, Gfriend or Mamamoo deserve more attention because of their talents and they tried different CONCEPT already from cute to matured. Even the rookie group Black Pink can win over them in talent. Visual is both essential to both companies but I think JYP need to focus also in talents to attract more people. My opinion only😊 Try to watch Red Velvet in Singderella you can see Irene and Yeri hitting a high note.
Lee Taeyong As a Buddy, i have to admit that RV member are on another level when its about singing. Like how can rapper like irene and yeri sing very well, even Irene sing tears reallyyyyy really good, not gonna lie. I hope Gfriend non vocal-line can follow redvelvet's skill in singing in the future
Just wait few years later, 1-2 years you can see why Twice can never reach SNSD level. What Twice has is the concept and catchy songs created by JYP. But truly they lack of real singing talent. The reason why SNSD can be that famous compared to all famous boy groups at their golden time is because they have both visuals and singing talents. All their members have good singing skills on average, and their lead vocalists ranked the best among idols (Taeyeon, Jessica, Seohuyn, Tiff). I like some Twice songs at first, but until now, all Twice songs are the same, and there are too many auto tones in their songs. Every year, there are lots of girl groups debuting which sing much better than Twice. Anw, it's just my personal opinion.
To all the people that said TWICE will be the next SNSD or something please stop because there is no group that will be SNSD even RV because SNSD is the group that no other GG can beat. Let's just say TWICE IS TWICE RV IS RV and other group to. But I love RV so much please give them more attention.
Yes😊 Red Velvet ❤💛💙💜💚💘 In my opinion the girls of twice are not as beautiful as they say they are a visual group, Tsuyu is cute but not beautiful and the others good are nice. It's just my opinion obviously in tastes everyone thinks differently. Red Velvet, Gfriend, Mamamoo and Blackpink I hope you give them the attention they deserve, they r very talented and beautiful.
honestly speaking, Red Velvet is on a whole other level, SM Vocalists are no joke, basically all their artists are excellent vocalists since SM is expert in that while JYP is more focused on performance and public appeal (no offense but JYP GG Main Vocals are average, even an SM GG Lead or Sub Vocal can compete with them but yet again JYP doesn't really focus on vocals a lot)
visual? i think you should watch sixteen btw jyp is the hardest company to choose an trainee etc. but please look at sixteen you'll understand why i said that cause jyp is not looking visuals
Maybe it's because TWICE members are already known through TV because of SIXTEEN. Maybe that's the reason why TWICE already had an impact when they debuted as a group
random fangirl I also think red velvet has good singers, but i’m glad your not like others who hate twice, and are bashing them for not being as good as red velvet.
random fangirl Eventough I think RV are Vocalqueens and talented af,there is no way that Joy is a better Vocalist than Jihyo.You can prefer Joy's voice but Jihyo is more skilled.
trian trion I know that Twice's MR-Removeds are bad,but I found (Don't know which anymore) one where she had this high note in Ohh-Ahh and it sounded actually good.She is loud but that's not bad and it's not screaming too.I know that Joy's Voice is good but I surely know that she couldn't hit that high note.Still like her Voice.But like I already said,you can prefer Joy's Voice if you want I'm not forcing you to like Jihyo's Vocals.
Pratisha Luchoo - For Quality (Talent) .. Red Velvet are totally Better than Twice. For Quantity (Popularity) Twice are bigger than Red Velvet. This is fact. I'm not bias.
hammer red - I don't say twice are untalented but in singing ,, Wendy is more more more better vocalist than jihyo (please once, Wendy is Queen of new gens vocalist) And in dancing,, for me, Seulgi is slightly better than momo. But momo is not that bad. But seulgi is better than momo. Twice are talented but if compared with Red Velvet,, Red Velvet are more talented than Twice. That's all I tried to said. Quality, Red Velvet own it better,,, Quantity, Twice own it better... Please once. It's really obvious. I'm not try to be bias here although I'm SM stand because Tiffany is Girls' Generation member and GG are under SM. But when I did a comparison, I won't be bias. I will tell the truth.
RV SLAYS, Even seulgi can beat them all. RV has talent, and Twice has popularity. but popularity can go as fast as it comes. But talent stands still.. RV JJANG!!!
Probably twice is more famous than red velvet but we can't deny that red velvet sings better than twice. Like if you are going to rank their skills in singing (disregard vocal tone since it is subjective) 1 wendy 2 seulgi 3 jihyo 4 joy / jungyeon Nayeon tends to sing with her nose.
IDGAF HOE ::: Seulgi struggles in her higher range and lack the overall balance but she is an agile vocalist with a good technique. Her mid range is great and has good support. Her lower register is exquisite. Jihyo, on the other hand, has good chest voice and has a broad range but she cracks on her high notes and she has a terrible breath control. TECHNICALLY and OBJECTIVELY, Seulgi is a better vocalist than Jihyo. If you think that Jihyo is better then I respect that. It’s your preference, but if we evaluate their singing abilities, Seulgi can sing with more versatility and fluidity than Jihyo. On a lighter note, Jihyo is improving every comeback and she will be a force when she is trained properly in singing.
Jihyo is not better than Seulgi lol. Jihyo has tendencies in her high notes it either loses its power or its become so flat. Lets not start how almost everyone in Twice sing with their nose. Its not already about the song or the genre. They already sung other songs with different genre and they still sing with their noses.
rv is still the best when it comes to vocal and dancing.
Jassleene Quebec And visual
Jassleene Quebec even visual
if you are comparing with twice yes but i think gfriend is the best when it comes to dancing
90scavoy THEY DIDN'T EVEN MENTION GFRIEND
And visual, and rapping
BoA said "Popularity is like a bubble, but true ability is like a river that is always there." .. I stan Talent RV❤
I'm Vulever Reveluv i love this omg
Produce 101 right? Real talent will keep after everything.
I'm Vulever Reveluv amen sister 🙆🏻
momo jungyeon and chaeyoung are really talented but well jyp hasnt let them show their potential ever since jyp sixteen
my green Doong Doongie true ❤
you know it's hard to beat SM vocalists right?
Well yeah they are really good vocalists but do you know how sm trains their trainees?it's like pure hell tbh....that's why their vocals are another levels...
They chosed the right person from the beginninf, like chen and baekyhun from exo they only have 4 months training before debut, their vocals are very powerful.
im notapotato yes. And the result is so awesome. Its the price for a good result. Like if you want to be a champion you must to work really hard. Its the same.
@@nilachristina work hard?or torture THEM hard?they sing while running on treadmills and some already got their heads underwater while singing you think that's hardwork????they are forced to do that btw
im notapotato its the punishment. Punishment if they are late or make a mistake? I remember key said the coach make them singing while running when they late or made a mistake. Honestly if you watch dream high you can see that. I believe all the agency have that rules too, whats make SM different is they have all the A line coach. Like SM have the best coach for vocal, dance, etc. And they have a good sense too pick a good vocalist in audition.
Just play wendy 'shine on me' it's will over
Truee😆😆😆😂😂
Yup ♥️
I wouldn't even put Wendy in comparison to anyone here, tbh, but I love all of Twice and Red Velvet. Wendy is just on a whole other universe as a vocalist 😁😁😁
@@eyebrowstj i so agree
Hahaha luv you😂😂
RED VELVET = REAL VOCAL , REAL VISUAL,
Irma Suryani Don't forget how awesome their dancing is!
Sarah Chan real v(d)ancing ! 😂
+Sarah Chan so awesome and also cool 😁
rv all the way
don't kidnap me no way
Christian Estrella no way what
StanTalent i will haunt ur dreams lol
don't kidnap me YOUR USERNAME AKDWGQJF
Your username, i'M SHOOk
My mom said, "don't ask the question that you already know the answers"
katy kim 😂😂😂😂
oh yeah. so.......................................RV win!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
lolalicot yep😂
yeah its twice
Red Velvet.
this is all im gonna say: there's a reason why red velvet members are given more osts 🤷♀️
They are actaully make songs or osts for dramas especially wendy
and collabs
Ofc power house it says... Not tobe shade but lets be honest AMONG 3RD GEN frm B3 red velvet is way more better when it comes in music scene. Tho BP is Famouse but their only famous of being beauty standard thats why they are more on MODELING aspect than music scene.,As TWICE they just in low standard in music too theyre not even seeing them in any korean music flatform aside frm their stage. Red velvet has more previledge esp in kpop music bcoz they do more collabs frm various artist in korea unlike those 2..
Lunafreya Nox Fleuret, butt hurt reveluv who is jealous of bp and TWICE's success. TWICE has many talents. Chaeyoung is the most talented and can beat your faves alone. She can sing, rap, dance, compose songs, design her own shoes/bags, draw and she is an athlete as well. Can your red velvet do all of these?? And as for bp, they have talent too. I don't stan bp at all but saying that they are just models and have no talent is being delulu. Jennie can rap and dance, Lisa is a rapper and dancer, jisoo is an actress, lead vocalist and can rap too, rosé is an amazing vocalist and a lead dancer. Saying that rv is better and the others are untalented is just nonsense. It's not TWICE or bp's fault that rv isn't as famous as them.
@@Lunafreya_Nox they are more into modeling than music because of YG not because they are only pretty shut up
Yeri may not be strong on individual vocal, but damn! She adds something you can't explain on Red Velvet's harmony.
Somebody just found put the truth.
In songs have amazing harmony and vocal arrangement, Yeri is like the last element to make a good song becoming a masterpiece.
It's funny cause the beauty of the harmony don't depends of the singers
Finally someone said it! She is like the missing detail. I remember the days when I didn’t like her, but when they perfomed icc without her I was like where is my baby 😦? Something wrong here. Her voice is sweet and pretty sounds to me. I love her, I can’t imagine rv without her
she wasn't given a chance to showcase her vocals but in the last 2 years she proved her worth from her solo song to her live vocals .... I think she adds the sweetness
@@reign0256 um okay
red velvet ofc
this is not even biased. twice needs some time
ReVel ARMY i spot bangtanvelvet😂
ReVel ARMY Agreeeeeeee
ReVel ARMY me too
I like how your picture is literally. A red velvet cake.
Lets be honest, Twice can sing (ofc, they have mouth) but they are not stable and powerful. Red Velvet is good at any concept. They can sing stable even if they are dancing. (Note that Red Velvet's dance is difficult) RV ftw
RV- Real Vocal
RV- Real Voice
GirlsRules BoysDrools you forgot RV=Real Visual
RV - Real Visual
GirlsRules BoysDrools "Not stable"
*Slams Likey mr removed in your face*
It'sAngel Well what do you freaking expect? This comment was four months go and of course they improved
Help Me You sound triggered 🤔 Ofc they improved, and yes it's been four months. Thats the point.
SM Idols eat the CDs I swear
Red Velvet 100%
Thanks! You choosed my Red Velvet even you are Once! I hope that Once and RedVeluv wI'll be more than the normal friends😊😊😊😋😋😋☺☺☺
Kelly OFFICAL CHANNEL Kim how do u know she’s a once??
1.Wendy , 2. Seulgi ,3. Joy 4. Irene , 5. Yeri I really like Red velvet voice
ME TOO
lol is this even a competition. RV definitely wins, they slay vocals
Isabelle Chloe park pokoyong yu Now I know why nobody is defending TWICE in the comments. It's because their fans are helping TWICE gain more and MORE views, unlike stupid red velvet fans that are wasting time here!
Isabelle Chloe nobody is defending twice because Ones themselves know the truth.
Nayeon's Rabbit Teeth More views doesnt mean anything. If you are more talented , more people will like you :)) everyone is complaining how TWICE's level is so low. When majority says that , you should know why everyone feels that RV is better ..
Christa Merete Savage
+Nayeon's Rabbit Teeth hey rabbit teeth you say that red velvet fans are stupid? so what about you? stupid once, high viewers is doesn't mean they more talented. just go watch their mr removed and WAKE UP
RV = Real Visual
RV = Real Vocal
"original visual"
@@twiceisqueensofkpop2386 yes, red Velvet original visual and best vocal hahaha
That's why velvet has two V's, visual and vocal!
yezsa hernandez but that’s kind of of offensive to twice by saying they had plastic surgery. we have no proof so you can’t really assume amytning
cherry_yeri they didn’t even mention twice
SM has the best vocalist artists .. Wendy has a vocal chord nodule yet she can manage to slay live.. very powerful voice..
Aiza Casimra whats a vocal chord nodule?
Why are we comparing a group that comes from SM, where some vocals legends are trained, with a group that comes from a company that has alot of good-looking idols? Isn't this pointless?
Rinie Kwon FINALLY SOMEONE AGREES! Why are they comparing them!!
:'D
Lmao SM has both so I guess this video is pointless
What were you saying? SM has both talent and visuals
Theyre the nation's girl group so they deserve being compared on different aspects. Isnt it shameful to have a nations girl group that has a trashy vocal lineup?
Tbh Wendy can beat 9 members of twice she can dance,rap and amazing,unique,stable vocal.
Yeri alone is enough to beat em
Irene Wanda Ddeulgi Joy Katie I feel bad for twice because what you said was just TRUEE
Irene Wanda Ddeulgi Joy Katie omg why so true
Irene Wanda Ddeulgi Joy Katie Yeri is such a queen though I'm sure she could take down most people singlehanded. We stan a versatile Goddess 👸🙌
EXO IS THE KING OF kpop I very much agree. RV ftw.
Can y'all stop saying rv won? I'm so tired of liking all your comments
Same
😂😂😂
Same 😅
Savage 😂😂
You had me in the first half man
RED VELVET ISN'T RV FOR NO REASON
RV: REAL VISUALS
RV: REAL VOCALS
revel woww i never realise that👍🏻
Good facts. Hahaha that's funny too
revel yeah
hahaha omg i love this comment
revel wow👑
red velvet choreography is more complicated and they're still more amazing than twice
Silvia nurfajri are you once.im once.twice has good dance compare to red velvet
HEROBRINE GAMING just 'good' . rv choreo is way unique and dificult .
no.1 gfriend
no.2 rv
no.3 twice
thts the list for group dance but we cannot deny tht momo the only one that slay in dance
Silvia nurfajri no. twice's choreography is more better than rv.
Christian Estrella did twice win anything related to dance ? whoopss no
pika chan you know, trophy is just a thing. But the experience of being nominated for dance awards is more important than winning it. Dont't be boastful because of that 2 dance performance awards. By the way, SM cares a lot for RV. We all know that SM is a bigger company than JYP.
Do you know what RV means?
It's Real Vocals, Real Visuals.
I bet real talents can fit in too.
Sehun be like: "If you knew it why would you ask"
For me, no one can beat SM Artists. Powerful vocals, overflowing visuals, amazing talents. I can't ask anything more💕
The only people that even come close to RV vocal line is MAMAMOO. And they are either slightly under or tied with them. But Wendy still kills them all.
In other words, I completely agree
Kresteeeyl Reyes periottttt
Frankie I agreeeee
@@frankie7313 Imagine if SM would offer mamamoo a 2 month lessons from them
mamamoo is already great just imagine that lol
most of the video is a comparison of rv's singing while dancing and twice sitting while singing but the winner is still rv when it comes to vocal and stability 😂
Everytime I watch RV videos. I go into deep thought and keep contemplating as to when the world will start appreciating genuine talent and versatality. BoA truly said it Popularity is like a bubble but talent is a never ending eternal river.
preach
Sm artist is so mysterious and a total package
100% truth
Truee omg
we all know the winner. RV is a complete package (real talented + beauty)
so you are saying that twice has fake talents and fake beauty. cmon let's be real here, we cannot compare rv and twice because they are all different
+Jan Sim
Lol why r u so triggered she didnt even said anything about Twice lmao
+Jan Sim actually twice singing thier song cutely its doesnt show the real voice
Hafiz Azili lol are you trying to defend twice rn? no offence but this video showed them singing other songs too
lol rv is higher than twice, everyone know that
Joy who's just a vocalist can beat some of the main vocals out there and that says a lot about RV.
totally agree
Not really
visual = red velvet
talent = red velvet
my opinion
+kaebsong ̣ fyi, irene is an ulzzang :) and tbh, almost every kpop idols did a plastic surgery, including twice lmao
kaebsong ̣ nayeon nose job you didn't mention
Joy That's a fact, baby dolls
irene and yeri improve so much, they're going to become a great singers also so stable
pd: i love joy's voice
Even Seulgi alone can beat Twices vocal no offense
Sweet Celynz If Joy's on a good day, even she can sweep TWICE.
Sarah Chan yeri is still young . shes still in her teens but once shes improved , she can slay all twice members too .
Sweet Celynz TOTALY AGREE KEKKEKE
Sweet Celynz TOTALY AGREE KEKKEKE
Sweet Celynz Agree
I’m just here to read comments on how great rv is
ikr i didnt even have to watch the video lmfao
Same.
1. Wendy 2. Seulgi 3. Joy 4. Irene 5. Yeri I really like red velvet voice my Queen red velvet 👑😘
Let's be honest...
If Seulgi/Joy/Irene/Yeri will be in any other group they would be main vocal
I just noticed that the list is in the order of who gets the most to least lines overall.
A slap in the face th-cam.com/video/AiyWpjeCRBk/w-d-xo.html th-cam.com/video/8vXsXd_OrWA/w-d-xo.html
@kate kunst same!❤️
Lol. Why we need to compare when Yeri herself can slay the whole Twice member with ability voice ,stable on live. Red Velvet level is so high
SM pls give RV a freaking reality show preach
yeri xD
SM pls give RV a freaking reality show omg you're right *hugs you*
you're right.. xD
everyone, you can jump to 13:33 .. bcz its the answer who the winner is xD
icilachannel _ can you tell me the name of the song that yeri sang?
Are you kidding me ??? Red Velvet is no.1
red velvet=5 vocal, 5 dancer, 5 rapper, 5 visual
that is a NGG should be
not just cuteness and all TBH
True
All of SM's idol are. They're great all rounder🔥🔥
@ANTONIUS PADUA HALIM who said anything about your lame ass faves?
@faiza ahmed who said anything about twice in the first place?
Does twice only have the cute concept out of all gg? Come on
Seulgi and Joy are both better than Nayeon and let's be honest Wendy is better than any girl group idol from this generation.
EDIT: Due to repetitive comments and bc some of y’all are pressed, I’ll add something.
Firstly, I precised « from this generation » of Kpop. Which means I didn’t compare Wendy to skilled senior like Luna, Solji, Ailee, Eunji and so on. This gen goes Wendy > Yuju > Solar for me but there are other noticeable vocalists such as Yeonjeong and Seughee, etc.
Secondly, Yes Mamamoo is an overall better vocal group compared to Red Velvet, but Wendy is still stronger than all of Mamamoo vocalists, even Solar.
Thirdly, Yuju is a really talented singer but Wendy has a wider vocal range and her supporting voice is very stable. Jihyo has vocal power but really lacks technique and stability ((personally, Jungyeon is the best vocalist in Twice)), and we didn't see Rosé's full capacity yet so I can not say she's anywhere near even Joy.
Thirdly, as to consider the « soulfulness and feelings » a vocalist delivers is very subjective and varies from on listener to another, I did only consider technical skills in order to make a fair comparison.
If you're still pressed, please read the previous comments before adding your one bc parrots are tiring or chillax.
Wendy is in Queen Ailee's level
*****
They are good, but Wendy is still wayyyyy more better. Yuju is very talented but Wendy has a wider vocal range, Jihyo has vocal power but really lacks technique and stability, and we didn't see Rosé's full capacity yet so I can not say she's anywhere near Wendy.
The only girls I rank close to Wendy are really Yeonjung(Wjsn/ioi)
Solar(Mamamoo-Still only about solji level and not a taeyeon level so she's below by a little)
And kinda Yuju who is on Solar level at most
the fact is that Wendy>Yuju=/> Mamamoo(3vocalist)>>>>>>>>>>>>>jihyo
jhay ar nalzaro solar and wheein of mamamoo>wendy>hwa of mamamoo
this generation vocal queen wendy
Amandhi Siriwardena i thought people called her rascist oof
*and Seulgi (she is a vocal queen too, she have unique,powerful an emotional voice)
+Chelsea Park she didn't really knew what she said was racist, she did come from Canada and she was influenced by her environment
she didn't apologized though
mokococolata Do you think she's allowed to apologize? (not defending her just asking)
I don't have to watch it.........
I know Red velvet wins!💋
Anime Girl same girl
Anime Girl sameXD
Anime Girl I think everyone in this comment section knows lol
Anime Girl same
Anime Girl Same, I only came for the comment section to confirm my expectation
People in the comments discrediting Yeri like... have you heard her covering Wendy's parts in their Japanese concerts? I can't wait for her to go solo
Yeri has a technique which is better than Tzuyu, Chaeyoung, Sana, Momo, Dahyun and Mina.
I can't wait for her solo too
@@yumyum8265 she already have one, “dear diary”
@@lxncexzs i love that song and she wrote it herself :)
@@hightree9295 thank you finally yeri’s vocals rap everything is better than twice
i like red velvet. i like twice too. but.. i hate the fact when twice more popular than red velvet. because red velvet is more talented.
i'm sorry for my english(:
Its Agriney Também acho mano
Its Agriney I agree
Its Agriney same feeling's i keep asking that way i like twice im reveluv and i stan red velvet but just why?!!!!
Its Dracula berro q tem br aq
agree😂
sorry to say this . but I think, we just need seulgi to compete against all twice members .
Woah! Yeah!! Hahahahha
AHAHAHAHAHAHAHAH
Norasyikin Faisal how dare you
Christian Estrella that's the truth . And I don't think jihyo can sing 'I Have Nothing' better than Seulgi .
Christian Estrella everyone know twice lead vocal just can be sub-vocal in others group, thats the truth
Red Velvet FOR THE WIN! 💙💚💗💛💜 admit it, they are really stable even when they are dancing. 🔥
Claudia TY and twices choreo is so easy compared to rv yet they still end up unstable. Ooops!!
+Lark Wong ikr XD
Red velvet :
Vocal ✔
Dance ✔
Visual ✔
RV slay🔥🔥🔥
Rizki Putri Arianti even rap
We bring the boys out :dddd omg really? Even rap? Ong
Even nayeon beauty your Irene abs yeri
@@playlistsbydholphinxx9076 ofc wendy's rap
Also wendy can rap 🌜
rap??haha twice is not good at also rap! Lol! :"3
sorry, but joy as third of vocalist in RV, is better than main vocal of THE NEW NATION GROUP
Muhammad Taufik who's the new nation group. The nation's group is snsd
Muhammad Taufik twice will never be the nation's group
이주연 i'm sorry but TWICE is the NGG. The only ones denying it are mostly sone lol. You can't choose the NGG. No one can choose the Korean NGG except koreans. The koreans chose TWICE so just accept it
Damn, these satzu feels I'm not a sowon and snsd is still on top. I can vote too and if you wanna be ngg you have to have talent
Damn, these satzu feels LMAO stop speaking as if you have any fucking clue what Koreans 'vote' as the nations girl group
Real talent is so much better than fame.
Min Suga say it louder for the people in the back girl
@IDGAF HOE Sure, I know what's sounds like real singing, and what doesn't.
@IDGAF HOE Ooh, now the "cocky Once" side of you is coming out! LOL
Your overrated group's popularity is due to a reality show, and the fact that Koreans love aegyo and prettiness more than talent.
Your other comments? *Yawn* They were all the same to me; fabricated nonsense about how you consider yourself a professional vocal analyst.
Ah, I'm immature and ignorant for not agreeing with your nonsense? hahaha The comedic value of your replies are gold. As i said before, only delusional Onces believe Twice can sing.
LOL, and only delusional Onces claim that Twice is the New Nation's GG. Everyone else knows that SNSD are the original legends that Twice can only dream of being. Nice try though.
LMAO, I just can't get over how funny you are! You think Twice got their awards because they're actually talented? See my comment about aegyo and prettiness.
Locksmith8889 Now I see why you’re so butt hurt. Because of NGG title that all of sudden replaced your favs? BAHA
Min Suga if that was your logic then you’re clearly standing the wrong people 🤣
Red Velvet = Real Vocals
Red Velvet 😍😍😍
Sorry but even with Wendy/Seulgi's vocals alone, Twice has no match...
no matter what red velvet the best
vocal than twice
wendy is the 2nd taeyeon in kpop
im sorry but twice still lacking in vocal
park pokoyong yu Now I know why nobody is defending TWICE in the comments. It's because their fans are helping TWICE gain more and MORE views, unlike stupid red velvet fans that are wasting time here!
Nayeon's Rabbit Teeth well, maybe we are wasting our times watching this 'useless' videos, but at least we're not wasting our times on things that is worth it. Anyway, its Red Velvet, they're not wasting their own talent.
park pokoyong yu saying that twice is STILL lacking in vocal is an OVERSTATEMENT. they don't have vocals. they have autotunes and lypsincs ahaha
Oh hi I'm here to report serious savagery here
Christa Merete HAHAHAHAHA
Are u serious?!? Even Jihyo and Nayeon, the greatest vocal member from Twice is the same level with Yeri, the worst vocal from Red Velvet. Next
(in this situation im telling Nayeon and Jihyo is actually not bad so im not telling Yeri's vocal is bad it's just she's the last rank at rv, but her skill is even more than Nayeon and Jihyo, who is the one can sing in Twice)
Just Because err. yeri improved alot
Just Because she still being better
there is no worst vocal in RV btw
MilkWndrlnd - Joschua by sayinh "worst" it means "weakest" in terms of vocal.
Yes. She can do it. She is main vocal if she's not at red velvet but at sm's new gg.
Red velvet is more talented than twice omg
No twice too is talented
Trueee
@@pratttlh when chinese speak english be like
@@pratttlh red Velvet is better group!!!!
@@amorzinhobb1730 no they are underrated
so sad for those ppl that are still sleeping on rv’s talent
we all know red velvet win
How can you compare Red Velvet with Twice? Surely Red Velvet won a landslide. Joy's example in Red Velvet is the third singer but if she's put in twice she must be the main vocal
Jihyo is better than Joy wtf and for me, Mina too
Irene the main rapper is a better singer than their main vocal, not that Twice is bad, just really lack of vocal training
RedveluvSone_95 yeah i am ashamed that they are called the ngg with this kind of singing
LMAO mina? are you kidding me?
tbh they dont have a chance, rv are able to do one of the most beautiful harmonies in the whole kpop
i was mentioning their beautiful and unique harmonies not titles, but i dont want to offend anyone so kudos for that to twice
Owww how about mamamoo the true vocal queen ewww
This isn't even a contest....Red Velvet is talent, TWICE is Aegyo......
No twice have talent
momo has dancing machine talent can have Excellent graphic design drawing skills
Mina can do ballet and can sing
Nayeon have great talent in art, she can dance and sing, she is excellent at modelling and was a child model too
Jeongyeon is highly skilled in cooking, she can sing too
Tzuyu is really talentful and smart in studies, she is also really good at dancing
Dahyun is really skilled at dancing, flexible and can rap
Chaeyoung is really talented at doing charismatic and charming dancing and can rap plus she can sing vocal really nice
Jihyo have excellent acting skills even won many awards for acting, she has a powerful vocal in singing too
hammer red all the member u talking about twice in here, Seulgi can do this alone and did well and more better than twice 😏
hammer red and seulgi also is a dancing machine, she is surprisingly excellent as a vocalist that many people say that she could be the main vocalist, she has such charisma, she is the best performer in my opinion of the third generation, she has excellent drawing skills too.
Irene is very flexible, can dance, can sing, is called the prettiest idol of the third generation, she also is such a good lider.
Yeri can rap, she can dance, has sweet vocals, and she has a super sweet and soft personality.
Joy is the sexy girl, she can rap, dance, and sing, she is the girl that can make you fall in love just with a glare, she also cares a lot for her members, and she is the sweetest girl in the world.
Wendy is really smart, she can rap, has vocals from an angel, she is pretty, she can dance, and she has a beautiful personality.
hammer red LOL, all the “talents” u listed are just parts of Seulgi’s talents xD Don’t believe me? Have a look at Seulgi paintings then?
@@lionheart1511 I Stan both groups and I know they are both Talented so stop trying to cause a fanwar when this person never even said anything bad about RV you are the only toxic person I see
actual reasons why rv is better (add more in comments if u want)
1. they have amazing breath support
2. amazing stamina while dancing and singing
3. live performances are above par (just as good as recordings)
4. don't rely on the MR too much
5. they're very meticulous in their training and it shows
6. they don't rely on visuals to get them far
7. they adapt quickly and listen carefully to their voices
8. they have RAW talent and they can all dance and rap if they needed to
9. synchronization is on point
10. they don't make excuses for when a performance isn't up to par. they work even harder
Overall, redvelvet is a talent based group with a very amazing bunch of hard working girls. I hope they get even more recognition this year
in all of twice the only stable one is jeongyeon, jihyo screams all her high notes and her breath support is horrendous.
Yoon Seok true I love jungyeon's vocal...
even my baby yeri can beat all twice main vocalist😂 STAN TALENT STAN REDVELVET. OK
so childish; my daughter yeri slay your faves. STAN TALENT STAN RED VELVET
Nayeon's Rabbit Teeth all these flavors in the world and you chose to be salty🐸🍵
BTS slays me everyday 24/7 _ THAT WAS SO SASSY I LOVE IT
Someone that can't choose one bias in BTS I like your name, ,,💜💜💜
She's talented but nope,not at all.
No one can beat to sm artist when it comes to vocal😎😎
Every group in sm has one or two member that always put on the list
of the best vocal
one of these nights mr removed is legendary
I'm prefer to read comments section because i know everyone here agree that red velvet is on different levels with twice, just accept the fact that only jungyeon, nayeon and jiho who can sing in twice, in other side red velvet is slayed in every comeback
@@besttheangrynerd6741 hahahahah. You're right. I wanna laugh bcs every comments i saw that acc trying so hard to depend her fav. Lol. She too biased until she is deaf.
@@besttheangrynerd6741 pls watch mr removed of dance the night away and you will realize that Mina and Tzuyu are the most stable duhh!😒
@@whoiseah they are all stable,but stable while dancing it's more complicated so that's not important but we're talking about vocal and not stability
@@42inesperez they could sing,they have good vocal,they were stable, they improve,so what now?still need to bash them because they can't sing??(sorry for bad english)
@@42inesperez and I'm talking about Mina and Tzuyu do you think that they don't have talent?just visual?cause for me they have their own talent,they could dance both and Mina can sing while Tzuyu can rap isn't that talent?
I like Red Velvet and Twice both but Red Velvet is in another level. Red Velvet is a full package. Twice has only cute looks, while Red Velvet is cute and beautiful. In terms of voice only 2 or 3 of twice members can sing, like really! They are 9! While Red Velvet is only 5 yet they can all sing! This is just my opinion, as a fan it's just heart breaking to know that the most talented group is being left behind because of those aegyo. People now a days don't know what TALENT really means
Mika Manacsa it's much harder to manage a nine membered group.having a bigger group will make a member seem less significant.and it will be harder to choreograph dances,split the lines,and basically keep the whole group together without it falling apart.
Mika Manacsa Your comment made my day I mean it's true RV has real talent
ThatRottenOtaku Reminds me of another 9 membered girl group that went through much of the same problems. It was so utterly crippling for them that they produced to the most powerful vocal line in their generation, won over two hundred awards and caused a hallyu tsunami that swept Asia away from '09 onwards.
Care to guess which group it is?
Spawn of Satin look,im not talking about snsd or comparing them with twice.you're completely going out of the subject here.all im saying is that it isn't as easy as this ignorant person thinks to manage a 9 membered group,or even a kpop group in general,and although yes,they aren't the best vocalists,they definitely ARE talented.
ThatRottenOtaku Talented in what way? Sure, I agree that twice has talent in absolute terms (same could be said for you and me). Depending on how loosely you define "talent" this could go up or down.
However, *relative* talent is what really matters. They're talented, but not talented enough compared to groups like Red Velvet, and that's their shortcoming. If you score 90 on a 100 mark test and everyone else scores 97 to 100, you're the one getting an F (assuming bell curve). That's often the sad truth in life.
I agree that it's not easy to maintain a 9 membered girl group, but that in itself is no excuse for poor performance.
THIS MAKES ME A PROUD REVELUV!!!!!!!!!
Seulgi is better than all twice member
and she is lead vocal
Lol...
Even joy
@@playlistsbydholphinxx9076 Jihyo is still better than Joy. But i still prefer Joy's voice, she has a very calming and honey voice.
Kunci Jawaban i haven't knew Twice well that time now i agree that Jihyo is better than Joy
Seulgi is better than Jihyo but Jihyo is better than Joy. Though Joy is a lot better than Nayeon. Nayeon should stop singing with her nose.
Red Velvet is my second Queen after Girl’s generation,and my third queen is Blackpink 😍😍😍😍❤️❤️❤️❤️
This is a Channel same like me haha
Same❤️
omg soooooo agreeeeee bc rv is unique and powerful bc of ir but bp is cool
My fave Groups
1-Red Velvet, Blackpink, Bts
Same
I love how Wendy is always smiling!! So cuteee
Yes, Wendy is a sun. ❤️☀️
Red Velvet >>> Twice
Wendy’s vocals can singlehandedly take down Twice tbh
Red Fruitloop without her the group is nothing tbh.
Seulgi alone could slay all your nine members in every aspect tbh.
Redvelvet Joy RV is queen Not really. Jihyo is better than her vocally. Her dancing is on par with Momo but they both are better in different genres. Seulgi can’t really rap. Twice has a lot more charismatic members. So yeah, that’s your opinion I just state facts tbh. 🤪
Momo? the one who looks like a guy? HAHAHAHA jihyo is not better than seulgi . WHEN IT COMES TO TALENT RED VELVET WIN AND WITHOUT JIHYO TWICE CAN'T EVEN PRODUCE SONGS.
Redvelvet Joy RV is queen Aw how sad, you’re obviously very immature. Sad for your fandom. Jihyo is better than Seulgi. If you actually knew a thing or two about vocal technique. You do forget Nayeon gets most of the lines?
Some ppl saying that Jihyo could out sing Wendy I- no. Wendy is the only kpop female idol with a full 4 octave range.
not to mention her vocal stability, taeyeon and baekhyun's daughter no doubt
I think Twice's songs are very catchy and LSS worthy hence why they are more popular. (And their visuals and they also came from a very well known company)
But still... I think Red Velvet's popularity is rising everyday.... So proud to see people recognizing their talent
Yee Eet oh my g! so true finally someone pointed it out
it's about talent.
Rising really but can't win against twice really!! Srysly??
@@cleomarocampo3303 can't win against what??
I don't understand why twice is more popular than red velvet
juni ko its all media play
juni ko it's because twice only visual capital + viewers and now we live in an age where viewers are more important than talent
Exactly! That's what I wonder too.... -.-"
juni ko same😔
ikr
Lol, is this really a competition? red velvet is obviously amazing.Twice are just girls who don't sing doing aegyo all the time. The real talent needs to be recognized, RV queens 👑👑
bangtanpink sooo true!! RV vocals are much better than twice!
@twice best and every other is shit ....are you saying that blackpink is lip syncing i think your twice does hahaaha btw red velvet wins
twice best and every other group is shit "always lip sync"sorry but I've only seen them lip sync in Japenese ver. You are seriously the deaf one. BTW you are fucking up onces reputaion
twice best and every other group is shit your name is just a bit too much. Stop apreading hate if you know its not true ♡
SAY IT LOUDER YES!!!!!
1000% RV wins!!!!!! Twice is just perfomer
Are you crazy?
@@skyllline24 twice is stable nowth-cam.com/video/jcIe_Gfrpcc/w-d-xo.html, also twice havent collab but they got ost to sing, i think they will collab now
@@skyllline24 i dont care if you lile twice or not, but by your comment its obvious you dont like twice
@@skyllline24 i never said i dont like rv, it may be your opinion but uts hurtful and its not a truth too
th-cam.com/video/OunicxEV9Xo/w-d-xo.html just enjoy it
red velvet is the best
RV :real vocal, real visual
Idk why twice is more popular than RV because in fact RV is more talented than twice
Luneta Khalisalfia “real visual” none of them had plastic surgery so?
Quêên gotta admit they had... But definitely not a major surgery... I ever heard Joy did surgery because of her nose (sorta slightly messed up, I guess?) and Irene did some minor surgery like deepen her eyelids or something... Mostly for enhancing themselves tho...
As for Wendy, Seulgi, and Yeri... Nah, they ain't...
Ken Kennedy Oh I was referring to Twice.
Kuein no one campare to some group
Because twice is more cute. Lol
don't come at me with that 'they are still rookies they need to improve' sentence rv was stable in their debut time twice clearly need to be trainees again they aren't even ready to debut
Geum Juyun im not hating on twice but Jihyo trained for 7 years and Seulgi too but Jihyo uses too much Lip sync while Seulgi just slays
Anthea Koh Jihyo trained for 10 years.
Kiara O'Fallen if she trained for 10 years then she should be even better since so many onces defend twice saying that they are only rookies. if jihyo trained for 10 years she should be able to sing much better and not lip syncing almost every high note
Anthea Koh agree
Anthea Koh Wendy has been a trainee for only 2 years tho
wtf even joy can outvocal all twice members lmao
i think she might be close but i’m pretty sure jihyo is still better and then jeongyeon/nayeon are around the same level as her
@@justcupcakeaka yeah probably jihyo is great
red velvet is better
not trying to bash but obviously definitely absolutely Red Velvet is up there both visual and vocal wise, their songs has that swag to it that it doesn't sound or feel cutesy as twice does that in my opinion, is the reason they're so popular! in short their aegyo is no joke,they're so fresh but both their songs and talent are no special. having nine members is a factor too
Twice do have talent, momo has dancing machine talent can have Excellent graphic design drawing skills
Mina can do ballet and can sing
Nayeon have great talent in art, she can dance and sing, she is excellent at modelling and was a child model too
Jeongyeon is highly skilled in cooking, she can sing too
Tzuyu is really talentful and smart in studies, she is also really good at dancing
Dahyun is really skilled at dancing, flexible and can rap
Chaeyoung is really talented at doing charismatic and charming dancing and can rap plus she can sing vocal really nice
Jihyo have excellent acting skills even won many awards for acting, she has a powerful vocal in singing too
I'm not a fan of RV but they totally won this battle
well , you should be a fan tho hahaha
Red Velvet is way better and prettier!!
You’re toxic. They’re all beautiful
@@darlingemi they only said prettier...not the only pretty group
@@lxncexzs they literally said red velvet is better and prettier.
@baechu but they said it like it’s a fact. Yes I admit that red velvet has better vocals, but no one should discredit twices talent. Toxic red velvet stans love to put down other groups.
@baechu A lot of red velvet stans put down twice. “Red velvet is real talent. Twice is just popular. Twices vocals suck. Stan red velvet for real talen” etc.
Red velvet have true vocalist i mean seulgi is the lead vocalist and she's better than jihyo and jihyo is the main vocalist and i think that no one can sing like wendy in the new kpop generation.
bp rose can
lol sorry but no, Rose still has a long way to go. She and jihyo are probably on par but wendy? Wendy's level of vocal is too high for rose. This generation best female vocalist definitely goes to Wendy, Solar, Yuju.
Even Seulgi is better than Rose
+Megan Lor nope. rose is better .she does not show her skill yet.
vocal queen even before debut
m.th-cam.com/video/0Q8vdSKaI80/w-d-xo.html
it's about 2 company.. JYP only focus on visual but SM focus on visual, voice and dance.. That's why RV can beat Twice easily..
Yesita Sipayung truth
Yesita Sipayung and sm also focus at attitude :')
Yesita Sipayung i guess you're right
I really hate the mindset that SM are all about looks like, have they forgotten the main vocals and former artists of sm? The lead vocals even come close. Can't deny that SM produces good vocalists. Over the top
Yesita Sipayung yes, jyp only look visual and sexy, sm more better than jyp
red velvet win
just because twice have a good visual and have more fans than rv it doesnt mean vocal of twice can be good too
Farra Syafrilia ikr . popularity and visual cant beat talent . well idk in this generation tho . smh
Farra Syafrilia thank you for your honest opinion for twice
Farra Syafrilia i think rv won the visual too...
even rv have better visual than twice. with makeup or not.
Farra Syafrilia but still RV is prettier lol
1. WENDY (Red velvet )
2. SEULGI ( Red Velvet )
3. JIHYO (Twice)
4. JOY(Red Velvet)
5. YERI / NAYEON / JONGYEON ( Red velvet yeri ) (nayeon and jongyeon Twice)
6. IRENE ( Red velvet )
(Rest is Twice)
7. MINA
8. SANA
9. CHAEYOUNG
10. TZUYU
11. DAHYUN
12. MOMO
100% honest non biased opinion
Hey this is real. Facts only. Up
Thanks for your real opinion, the comment section is tooooooo toxic
Subramani M np problem thx for liking my opinion ❤️
I don't know but for me joy is better than jihyo, go watch her other cover. Seriuosly her technic is another level. She also can hit high note easily, but she is a type that very shy and afraid to show her ability.
BTOB Changjae hm honestly you may be right also joy is my redvelvet bias she has an amazing clarity to her voice i mean i dont know if she is better than jihyo but it is definitely debatable
Proud of being ReVeLUV
I mean like, Twice is not that bad but, Red Velvet is on a WAYYYYY WAY higher level of vocals than them! I LOVE YOU RED VELVET ❤️❤️❤️
Mlpstop heart As an Once, I want to take and thank your opinion, because other seems rude.😔 Your girls slay btw😍
Twice has now improved
visual is real for red velvet, they have pure beauty, without make up still beautiful..
Alfi Nurul no. twice's members are more beautiful than any of RV's members
Christian Estrella haha are you kidding? Tell the koreans, they certainly choose rv.. even, the korean army like rv..
Christian Estrella lol even european magazine used irene and seulgi to represents asians bcs of their beauty
Alfi Nurul well it's the koreans. Did you forget that they are INTERNATIONAL ARTISTS? 😬
Christian Estrella did you read the comment on you, european magazine choose seulgi n irene as asian beauty icon, you can watch many reaction fans in yt when they see rv.. irene is best visual of all gb, with suzy n yoona.. many artists always mention rv such as ftisland, cnblue minhyuk, btob, exo, joonyoung, monsta x etc. they interest with rv not only cause their talents, but their beauty
Wendy >>> all Twice members
Seulgi >> all Twice members
Joy > all Twice members
Irene = all Twice members
Yeri = all Twice members
Thanks.
edit!!
oh damn i'm here after a year because of the comments and my opinion changed a bit, so i'm gonna leave it in here, i still strongly believe all of them are good vocalists btw.
01 wendy
02 seulgi
03 jihyo
04 joy
05 jeongyeon
06 nayeon
07 irene
08 yeri
09 sana
10 chaeyoung
11 tzuyu
12 mina
13 dahyun
14 momo
k that's all stream seulrene's song and more&more when they come out
yes!
True!
(In my opinon)
Irene>All Twice Member
Yeri>All Twice member
yev veluv
conclusion : All of the RV members are much more better than all of the TW members
Jihyo is a better singer than joy and is around seulgi's level in terms of vocal technique. Jeongyeon, nayeon, mina, Tzuyu and chaeyoung all sing better than Irene and yeri while dahyun is around the same level. Wendy is obviously better than all of them tho, You could try being less bias.
come on guys, red velvet's vocal is better than them🐱😅
Nur Farihah much better . . ilike R.V . .
Nur Farihah
I mean obviously xD
K
all the hate on yeri :( she has improved so much from these vocals
True she even has a solo song and she just has a overall unique voice
And now she’s been releasing a few covers on her channel. It’s amazing truly.
But some company said Twice will like Snsd in the 2nd generation of girl group. Like duh? just because their song has a line that will be always remembered like knock knock, ooh aah, shy shy and tt but I think Red velvet, Gfriend or Mamamoo deserve more attention because of their talents and they tried different CONCEPT already from cute to matured. Even the rookie group Black Pink can win over them in talent. Visual is both essential to both companies but I think JYP need to focus also in talents to attract more people. My opinion only😊 Try to watch Red Velvet in Singderella you can see Irene and Yeri hitting a high note.
Lee Taeyong As a Buddy, i have to admit that RV member are on another level when its about singing. Like how can rapper like irene and yeri sing very well, even Irene sing tears reallyyyyy really good, not gonna lie. I hope Gfriend non vocal-line can follow redvelvet's skill in singing in the future
Lee Taeyong YES! and u said my all time favorite girl groups😂
Just wait few years later, 1-2 years you can see why Twice can never reach SNSD level. What Twice has is the concept and catchy songs created by JYP. But truly they lack of real singing talent. The reason why SNSD can be that famous compared to all famous boy groups at their golden time is because they have both visuals and singing talents. All their members have good singing skills on average, and their lead vocalists ranked the best among idols (Taeyeon, Jessica, Seohuyn, Tiff). I like some Twice songs at first, but until now, all Twice songs are the same, and there are too many auto tones in their songs. Every year, there are lots of girl groups debuting which sing much better than Twice. Anw, it's just my personal opinion.
To all the people that said TWICE will be the next SNSD or something please stop because there is no group that will be SNSD even RV because SNSD is the group that no other GG can beat. Let's just say TWICE IS TWICE RV IS RV and other group to. But I love RV so much please give them more attention.
Yes😊 Red Velvet ❤💛💙💜💚💘 In my opinion the girls of twice are not as beautiful as they say they are a visual group, Tsuyu is cute but not beautiful and the others good are nice. It's just my opinion obviously in tastes everyone thinks differently. Red Velvet, Gfriend, Mamamoo and Blackpink I hope you give them the attention they deserve, they r very talented and beautiful.
honestly speaking, Red Velvet is on a whole other level, SM Vocalists are no joke, basically all their artists are excellent vocalists since SM is expert in that while JYP is more focused on performance and public appeal (no offense but JYP GG Main Vocals are average, even an SM GG Lead or Sub Vocal can compete with them but yet again JYP doesn't really focus on vocals a lot)
Ikr, it's funny to see ppl even dare to make a videos like this 😅
SM vocus on their talent,visual,voice
JYP vocus on their Visual
doesn't sm force most of there artist to get plastic surgery?
Baby Cakes lol rv is not plastic surgery fyi
Baby Cakes where the f did you get that information. Go look at their old photos.
visual? i think you should watch sixteen btw jyp is the hardest company to choose an trainee etc. but please look at sixteen you'll understand why i said that cause jyp is not looking visuals
JYP focus on personality ,,
why twice popular than red velvet
Redvelvet is very good in vocal rap and dance
I love Redvelvet
M. may because red velvet didn't do cute or aegyo that really love by korean...
agung arta Yes exactly!
I may have regretted what I wrote here before 👀
Maybe it's because TWICE members are already known through TV because of SIXTEEN. Maybe that's the reason why TWICE already had an impact when they debuted as a group
park sooyoung's husband but they werent that popular at first when they debuted
Joy is a better singer than jihyo so wendy and seulgi is like another level sorry i dont hate twice but this is the reality.
random fangirl I also think red velvet has good singers, but i’m glad your not like others who hate twice, and are bashing them for not being as good as red velvet.
random fangirl Eventough I think RV are Vocalqueens and talented af,there is no way that Joy is a better Vocalist than Jihyo.You can prefer Joy's voice but Jihyo is more skilled.
Danya Kasim can you show when or where is jihyo singing better than joy? Her high notes no more like as a person screaming not singing. Lol
trian trion I know that Twice's MR-Removeds are bad,but I found (Don't know which anymore) one where she had this high note in Ohh-Ahh and it sounded actually good.She is loud but that's not bad and it's not screaming too.I know that Joy's Voice is good but I surely know that she couldn't hit that high note.Still like her Voice.But like I already said,you can prefer Joy's Voice if you want I'm not forcing you to like Jihyo's Vocals.
Lol jihyo is the same level with seulgi and joy is nowhere better than jihyo and ofcourse wendy is on another level
I'm a fan of both groups but, everyone know that Red Velvet is better than Twice :v
But twice better than dancing;)
@@copyrighttt4550 my 🍑. Yeri alone can beat your dying dolphin momo
@@harshitadeshwal1305 Lmao dont be toxic i luv bot of them
@@harshitadeshwal1305 yeri can beat momo at dancing..🤣😂you're joking right
@@harshitadeshwal1305 but yeri can beat momo in...vocal tho
Seriously REDVELVET is better than TWICE.
Not better , both are better
Pratisha Luchoo - For Quality (Talent) .. Red Velvet are totally Better than Twice.
For Quantity (Popularity) Twice are bigger than Red Velvet.
This is fact. I'm not bias.
@@tiffanyyoung9377 true
@@tiffanyyoung9377 lol twice have talent, if not they wouldn't have been a singer
hammer red - I don't say twice are untalented but in singing ,, Wendy is more more more better vocalist than jihyo (please once, Wendy is Queen of new gens vocalist)
And in dancing,, for me, Seulgi is slightly better than momo. But momo is not that bad. But seulgi is better than momo.
Twice are talented but if compared with Red Velvet,, Red Velvet are more talented than Twice. That's all I tried to said.
Quality, Red Velvet own it better,,, Quantity, Twice own it better... Please once. It's really obvious.
I'm not try to be bias here although I'm SM stand because Tiffany is Girls' Generation member and GG are under SM.
But when I did a comparison, I won't be bias. I will tell the truth.
RV SLAYS, Even seulgi can beat them all. RV has talent, and Twice has popularity. but popularity can go as fast as it comes. But talent stands still.. RV JJANG!!!
A good example would be T-ARA. they were super popular but one scandal ruined it all.
Probably twice is more famous than red velvet but we can't deny that red velvet sings better than twice. Like if you are going to rank their skills in singing (disregard vocal tone since it is subjective)
1 wendy
2 seulgi
3 jihyo
4 joy / jungyeon
Nayeon tends to sing with her nose.
Seulgi is better tho and I would say joy and jungyeon are the same level
Same
IDGAF HOE ::: Seulgi struggles in her higher range and lack the overall balance but she is an agile vocalist with a good technique. Her mid range is great and has good support. Her lower register is exquisite. Jihyo, on the other hand, has good chest voice and has a broad range but she cracks on her high notes and she has a terrible breath control. TECHNICALLY and OBJECTIVELY, Seulgi is a better vocalist than Jihyo. If you think that Jihyo is better then I respect that. It’s your preference, but if we evaluate their singing abilities, Seulgi can sing with more versatility and fluidity than Jihyo. On a lighter note, Jihyo is improving every comeback and she will be a force when she is trained properly in singing.
Jihyo is not better than Seulgi lol. Jihyo has tendencies in her high notes it either loses its power or its become so flat. Lets not start how almost everyone in Twice sing with their nose. Its not already about the song or the genre. They already sung other songs with different genre and they still sing with their noses.
@@chaellegabato810 do you have an opinion on the jeongyeon v joy?
Y’all keep arguing about Seulgi and Jihyo’s rank, but you can’t deny that Wendy beats all of them 😂
hahahaha eyy facts