First-time reaction to "Wish You Were Here" LIVE by Pink Floyd
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 12 ธ.ค. 2024
- This performance left me speechless in the best way possible. Today we're watching a live performance of Pink Floyd singing their song "Wish You Were Here."
Watch the original video uninterrupted: • Pink Floyd - Wish You ...
Website: bethanyhickman...
Join the A-Lyst: / thevocalyst
#pinkfloyd #reaction #vocalcoach
For me, Pink Floyd often feels like nostalgia about a future you imagined as a kid but it never materialised. Or like longing for a past that never existed or that you never knew.
That was beautifully put. Thank you.
Hands down the best 1 line description of Pink Floyd's music I've ever read, well done!
The grass was greener
The light was brighter
With friends surrounded
The nights of wonder
David Gilmour's guitar work has always been about emotion rather than flash.
Yes. David’s solos really aren’t that difficult to play but they never sound as good as him because of his tone and dynamics.
David Gilmour has a somewhat unique ability to use his guitar to create poetry. Instead of using written imagery to create emotion he uses a combination of composition and a very deft control of technique to accomplish the same thing. I think that is a very large part of why you don't have to know english to feel transported away in a story by Pink Floyd's music.
Gilmour is one of the best guitarists that has ever lived and breathed. His playing is just so beautiful.
This song is a perfect example of what Pink Floyd music is great at. It doesn't tell you what to think. It opens your mind and allows you to feel what the musicians are feeling and thinking. It involves you in what's being performed and communicated.
Makes you find whet has always been there in yourself mate 👍 😉 ❤
The joy in Bethany's face!!!!
This song has me tear up every time I hear it as at age 60, I have lost so many loved ones and the sentiment of wishing they were here is a constant. David's ability to sing along with his guitar so perfectly is absolutely magical. Pink Floyd has been a favorite band of mine for most of my life at this point. Thanks for this reaction. ❤
Lori, that is so cool. I'm right right there with you.
@@loriwoodrow2711 yes, at 61 years now, I have very emotional responses to many Pink Floyd songs also. True genius blend of musicianship, songwriting, and lyrics😍
Roger's lyrics sung wonderfully. They made the best music together.
I hear you. Turning 60 next year. Saw them back in 1988 and this song gets me every time.
Oh Beth, your timing is excellent. This was the song played at my brothers funeral this week for a period of reflection and remembrance. It was one of his favourites. Thank you.
I'm sorry about the loss of your brother. What a great song to play at his memorial. Your brother obviously had great taste in music 🎶
I'm very sorry about your great loss. From now on, 'Wish You Were Here' will be a very strong link between you and your brother.
Heartfelt wishes from Germany
Great reaction, Bethany! Listening to Pink Floyd is always an experience. Seeing them live was an EXPERIENCE!
I never got to see Pink Floyd live. However, I did get to see Gilmour this past November on the Luck and Strange tour. He is still phenomenal.
It's ok to be speechless and overwhelmed. There has never been anything like Pink Floyd and there will never be again. I love what you do and how you do it
No other band lets you sink into dreams or float on clouds with their music. Their music finds a direct path from your ears to your soul.
I’ve been a guitarist for 37 years, and a fan of Pink Floyd and particularly David Gilmour for at least as long. If I had to pick a top 5 favourite guitarists of all time, depending on what day it is that list may change, but one thing that would remain constant is that David Gilmour would always be on that list. He is by far and without a doubt one of the most tasteful guitarists I have ever heard. His choice of notes, phrasing and emotional connection to the song is impeccable. Every solo is a song within the song. Breathtaking, like an enveloping warm hug from a long lost friend. He’s 78 now and still at the top of his game. Please also check out some of his recent recordings he has done with his daughter Romany on vocals.
Pink Floyd is ethereal. I'm almost 57 now, this song reminds me of all those lost along the way. Of how much I'd like to have another coffee with them. There are always some tears in hearing this.
For me, the melancholy of listening to Pink Floyd is something like the sweetness of being sad. Roger wrote, David gave soul.!!
Pink Floyd is one of the greatest rock bands ever. I agree, their music always puts me in a good mood.
I think it's feeling. They felt it, and it comes out in the playing, so we feel it too.
Seeing your joy in hearing this classic was perfect, you lit up when he started singing alongside his guitar. This song takes everyone somewhere else. Richard Wright on keyboards sets the atmosphere while David Gilmour’s guitar makes magic. While his guitar is critically acclaimed his vocals are underrated IMHO. Great reaction Bethany.
My dad used to listen to Ella Fitzgerald when I was a kid back in the 1950’s. That type of singing along with the instruments was called skat. You know, it’s never too late to be mesmerized by Pink Floyd. Hell, they’ve been doing that to us geezers for over 50 years.
Don’t worry about being flustered. David has been flustering me for over 50 years
Me too for about the same length of time.
Don't worry about getting the feels! They do that to everyone!
No apologies needed for lack of words.
It's what happens when witnessing greatness😊
Please, PLEASE, listen to more Pink Floyd. They are one of the best. Ever.
This song was written as a tribute to Syd Barrett who was one of the founding members of the Floyd. He went clinically insane from habitual psychedelic drug use. They essentially lost their friend to drugs and they wished he was still sane. Syd died in 2007.
So sad Syd was a beautiful soul
For me, Pink Floyd has always been food for the soul and can unexpectedly hit very hard. Wonderful.
Wish You Were Here is one of my favourite songs of all time and the album is also PF’s best imo. Remarkable they released such an amazing string of albums in the 70’s.
Your speechlessness... spoke volumes
If you want to get the full Pink Floyd experience, read about the album background. In the case of Wish you Were Here - absence is a key theme (missing someone, original frontman Syd Barret who suffered a mental breakdown; and something, purpose in life after making it to the big time with Dark Side of the Moon album), as well as disillusionment with the music industry and how it uses musicians like Syd for profit without caring about them or their wellbeing. This is expressed on the album's artwork (businessman with the face absent, man diving into a lake with absence of splash or waves, businessmen shaking hands with one getting burned). Listen to the album all the way through, it's a single work of art exploring these themes in one long thread. Doing this you will get an emotional connection to the music in a way not possible listening to a single song from the album.
Bethany,you rock! ❤ Peace
You have just reacted to my favorite Pink Floyd song. Your smile while listening to this said it all. There is a lot more Pink Floyd to go so keep going!
Every guitar wishes they had a David Gilmour for Christmas. Great reaction, and thank you for recreating our love for Pink Floyd through your eyes ❤
Floyd is a type of music all it's own. Jazz, blues, rock, folk all mixed in a way that Floyd can do
You just can't beat the sound of the 12-string guitar, both acoustic & electric.
there is a depth and wisdom that PINK FLOYD brings to you when you listen to it..... it's almost like that warm snuggle your grandfather gives you as he lovingly shares life experience stories w you, things that he lovingly knows you need to better navigate your world and life is it comes to you - the writing and examples of life that they share are all so common in experience you can't help to stop and reflect as you listen to them.
#TIMELESS
One of the most beautiful, and yet melancholy, songs of my life.
There's a soothing, cascading quality to the vocals that is incredibly relaxing and joyous to listen too. It's like you're gliding along atop the music like a comforting waterslide.
I saw Pink Floyd on this tour in 1994, and it remains the best concert I ever attended. The sound was stunning. David's guitar solos remain seared in my memory. What a show.
One of my very favourite songs. Gives me shivers whenever I hear it.
I love the intro to this. Imagine someone at home turns on the radio, there's a talk show on, they turn the tuning knob and there's a blast of classical, they tune again and there's a guitar tune they like so they pause on that channel. It's coming through a crappy radio speaker so it sounds tinny and far away but they like the tune and they pick up their own guitar and start playing along to it. And then they start singing about someone they miss and wish were still here.
This was one of the best concerts I attended, the build up and delivery blew my mind, thank you for the reminder.
I knew you would light up when he sang with the guitar!!
Pink Floyd are a genre all of their own . People may have preconceived notion of what they are prior to delving into their catalogue but they stand alone from all other bands . The lyrics are all important to listen to , the melodies will transport you to other places and Dave Gilmours guitar will touch your soul . The rarest of bands who will genuinely play with your emotions and even question life . Their albums are not individual songs , each track continues the story of the album from one track to another . Stay with them , they will stay with you for life .
ABSOLUTELY LEGENDS...THE BEST...🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷
Sometimes you don’t even need words…that’s what can make reaction videos so electrifying. Just seeing the joy across your face says everything. 😃
Makes you find whats always been in you and brings it out and you enjoy something that you not experienced ❤
I love it how young people are getting speechless to express how they feel listening to another best Rock Classic Album of all time - I grew up with Pink Floyd in the 70s and I felt the same way when the album came out...pure magic and so many overwhelming moments...it's the pure art! (btw I'm German and not perfect in English) 👍🙏❤
Honestly you really don’t just hear the music, you feel and experience the music with this band
Saw their Wish You Were Here tour in 1974. I love everything they have done. They and King Crimson are my all time favorites.
If transportative isn't a real word, when it comes to Pink Floyd, it should be. You're right, in a lot of cases their music takes you somewhere, and at least for me the mental imagery their music conjures up is pretty special. Don't feel bad about feeling flustered or emotional after listening to Wish You were Here, it's a unique, special, beautiful song, and those are appropriate reactions IMO. Thanks for reviewing this one, it's a special song for me.
Super reaction....you went back in time to be with all of us hearing it for the first time....
As beautifully evocative lyrics go, this one is hard to top. You nailed it. Pink Floyd were exceptional at transporting listeners into a different emotional realm.
"Transportative" 😍
Their music has been transporting me since I was a kid. It really is something you feel rather than simply listen to. Thanks for letting us into your Pink Floyd journey.
I saw them live back in the late 70's. One of the best concerts I've ever seen. It was a magical experience. David Gilmour says so much with so few notes. He's amazing !!!
Great reaction to the genius of Floyd !!
I started in the 90's listening to Pink Floyd, mostly their stuff from the mid to late 70's that everyone knows, but then in the early 2000's I started going back to the 60's and that sound is way different. Song's like Flaming, Julia Dream, Cirrus Minor have that more psychedelic feel but still the calmness this has. Then there are songs like The Gnome That feels straight out of Tolkien. Then they had songs like Bike, and Arnold Layne that are more fun, yet almost silly. It's all good mind you, but it gets even more diverse when you look at where they started.
I don't have kids or a wife... this song makes me wish I could give some of my years to my dog I had to put down. I'd give him enough years so we'd both die at the same time. I miss my buddy so much.
So sorry. Losing best buddies are the worst.
You are such a beautiful person Bethany. Love to watch your videos. Thank you!
Original Pink Floyd members declaration of love, for their lost bandmate and artistic bandleader, Syd Barrett,, 💔💔💔
So is "Shine On You Crazy Diamond", both songs are from the album, Wish You Were Here, from 1976.✨❤🔥🥰❤🔥✨
Pink Floyd is the one band that will do that to people. Not to worry, it just shows how effective their music is to the soul.
My appreciation for this band and their music is on a whole other level than it was when I was a young man. There will never be another band this profound.
What they always tapped into was just pure emotion, their songs speak to literally everyone. The magic I think is in the simplicity. You can’t exactly say he is a complicated or incredible singer or guitar player, but every note is still perfect and just right, warm like a blanket on a cold day. You can say say that about all of the instruments and band members, and the lyrics. Complexity through simplicity if that makes sense. This song in particular, is about “absence”, and musically there is absence in not having all this over the top instrumentation yet it is still sounds so warm, full, and emotional. I think you put it well when you said you can’t quite pick out what it is that makes their music so deep.
The very beginning you hear a muffled sound of someone turning the dial of a AM radio, it's a call back to when the members of Pink Floyd were just teenagers and how they would listen to the radio to try to figure out the chords of their favorite songs.
"Wish You Were Here" is a nod to one of the 4 founding members of Pink Floyd in 1964, Syd Barrett. Barrett developed a serious drug problem, (LSD and other mind-altering drugs), and mental issues which led to his demise. By the end of 1967 Barrett could no longer perform or even function as a person, mentally he was gone.
By 1968 his good friend, and friend of the band, David Gilmour, took over for Syd in Pink Floyd, he's the one singing this song. At this time of Floyd's career there are only 3 actual members of the band, the others musicians and singers onstage here are PF's touring band at the time.
The 3 members of PF are David Gilmour, (lead vocals, guitar), Nick Mason, (founding PF member,... drums, percussion), and Rick Wright, (also a founding PF member,... keyboards vocals).
I absolutely love this classic song. But the best thing in watching this video was seeing Bethany's facial expressions and emotional reactions. It is hard not to become emotional when listening to Pin Floyd.
One of my fav songs from my fav album, enjoyed your reaction Bethany!
Pink Floyd is pure emotion 🤘🤘
"We're just two lost souls living in a fishbowl......"
Masterpiece, FABULOUS lyrics speaking of their lost bandmate.
Thanks 🙏
Roger was a great lyricist.
I grew up with Pink Floyd. People call us "Boomers". Younger generations say we're out of touch. I believe that quite a few of us are more aware of life than people give us credit for. Teaching the meaning of love is beyond what can be taught. But removing the blockage in ourselves that blocks the awareness of love's presence is our objective, which is also our natural inheritance.
I've been listening to Pink Floyd since 1975, when they released Wish You Were Here. I have a whole collection of LPs, including film releases. No one will ever produce music like this again. They played from the soul for the good of the soul. Not for money. And that's why they made huge money and millions of people listen to them even after 50 years.
Creating a beautiful ambience that you just want to step into and float away. Yeah, I think you understand Pink Floyd just fine.
Pulse is such a great live performance captured for DVD and CD.
I feel that you always draw in Pink Floyds music, sitting there feeling free with all your feelings. They always touch my soul. The story behind this song is also gut wrenching as it is about Sid......
Roger's lyrics are the best part of this piece.
“We’re just two lost souls swimming in a fish bowl” melts me every time. I miss home.
Such a beautiful composition for quietly listening, skilful use of their musical skills that sets Pink Floyd apart from most other groups.
This was the song that led me to guitar, his slides, the slight bends varying the hammer on’s sometimes sliding down to a pull off other times bending to the note the mixture and variance was mesmerizing to me so Id sit and repeat it over and over till I had to let my hands recover. Well years later I have grown in my playing and in my appreciation to this song and Davids artistry thanks for giving me the other non guitar analysis, and his vocalized harmony with guitar are/were extremely helpful in connecting my voice and instrument to my hands and mind so playing becomes very natural and spontaneous feeling.
That's the power of Pink Floyd.
This is one of the few songs that can make me weep like a child.
Truly, a song for the Ages.
This was the last track, I think, that David sang with the guitar. It was something he did in a few earlier tracks as well.
Another thing that might surprise you is that while the solos in this song follow the general form that was on the studio recording, they are (semi) improvised live. I think this provides a huge clue as to why his solos are always so lyrical and melodic - he’s literally making his guitar sing.
Ahhh Bethany, a true hippie at heart ❤️
I knew you'd love it when his singing aligned with his guitar solo! Timeless song.
Ah, one my favorites. Amazing
So wonderful to see my favorite band bring such a beautiful smile to your face. Enjoy your Pink Floyd journey.
Pink Floyd is one of those bands of transformative music that's best experienced by listening to the whole album. They were one of the pioneers of the concept album in their genre of music. For this music, you do yourself a minor disservice by listening to it piecemeal with singles.
Listen to one of their albums all the way through.
You don't have to do a reaction of it. Just do it for yourself.
Love your first time reactions!! Keep up the terrific work❤️
Pink Floyd a fabulous experience to listen to,the album of the same name is a classic.
Takes you somewhere you've always had but you have never been there ..makes sense yeah 👌 ❤
Even if transportative is not a word (no red underline so looks good!), it certainly conveys the right thing.
Please don’t apologize for getting emotional! Witnessing you having a visceral reaction to music we know and love is why we come here. If want heartless and less and cold I’d read a magazine article
Longing for the past with an appreciation for the present... awesome tune it's actually my ringtone 🤟🎸🇨🇦
Their music is ethereal. Magic. Mysterious and mythical. A genre unto themselves.
This Band is one you want to dive in...no matter if it's deeeep end, come on, and have Joy with us
🤘😊🇫🇮💙🪄🎼✨💯👍
"Their music is so diverse"... yes! Pink Floyd is my favorite. Their sound has changed in different and interesting ways. Also, they had innovative ideas. For example, the song Us and Them (on Dark Side of the Moon) had echoing, at a time when there were no echoing electronics. Roger Waters recorded his voice with timed precision, and they laid that voice track down multiple times to achieve the echo effect.
8:50 - I love seeing your reaction to Gilmour harmonizing with his guitar. 😅 it is amazing.
They are Hypnotic. So peaceful. You need to do so many like Mother, comfortably numb etc The wall entire album.
Pink Floyd ia the perfect escape hatch to another sonic world. Been mine since I was a kid.
Long time Floyd lover. Never did get around to hearing Pulse or ADSOT. But that scat-solo singing is schweet.
String instruments often sing, cry, and soar just as much as the human voice. :)
This is a concept album, like the wall and dark side. It's like a play or a movie told through song. It's best to listen to the entire album with headphones, undisturbed. If one song moves you, the whole album will change how you see the world.
When looking at a guitar that is being held in the playing position, the string on top is (almost always) the lowest pitch and the string on the bottom is the highest pitch. The first guitar that comes in is a 12 string guitar. The four lowest pitched strings have another string right next to them that are tuned an octave higher. The last two high pitched strings also have accompanying strings that are tuned to the same pitch. Since it is nearly impossible to get all the strings tuned exactly, the 12 string guitar provides a very lush and full sound - filling in a lot more frequencies than a typical 6 string. It's kind of like playing 2 guitars at once with the second guitar playing an octave higher.
The sound from an acoustic guitar is very dependent on the wood that is used and how it is made. Even two guitars of the same model from the same company using the same wood can sound a bit different. So, when David starts playing chords on his six string, along with the 12 string, it is an amazing sound for him to layer his vocals over.
I imagine it as the guitars are making the softest, most luxurious bed you could imagine and David's vocals are the refreshingly cool, silk sheets sliding over the top.
A quote from Dave Mustaine, "David Gilmour can do more with one note than most other guitar players can do with the whole fretboard". Enough said.