When you're a PhD historian writing an article, but you choose the first cheap fan-made alt-history map you find on google images to be your heading image
That last map kinda looks like a colored version of "If the Central Powers won WW1" as it shows Mexico having the land promised by Germany in the Zimmerman telegram (Arizona, New Mexico and Texas) or where the Brest-Litovsk treaty is withheld. Although I can't defend the author, he has a PhD cmon
@@Vrangelrip Or that Newfoundland _and_ Labrador were a single british colony, thus it would be weird for _only_ Labrador to have been an ally without its more populated other half.
4:32 Our geography teacher gave us this and I made a joke about how Spain is deformed: Spain was hit in the Basque and now his Castiles (close to rib in English) hurt.
There are other things wrong about the map, like Ukraine and Belarus being independent. South Africa, British Raj, Egypt, and Brazil are also not being labeled as part of the Allies. Italy did eventually join the Allies, but that was after the Allies started their invasion of Italy. Saudi Arabia was neutral in WW2, but is labeled as part of the Allies in this Map.
Another thing that should be pointed out is that Armenia, Georgia, and Azerbaijan are shown as independent, *even though those three countries did not gain independence until the USSR collapsed in 1991.*
Textbook editor: "Hmmm I need a map for my history textbook" *googles map *first page filled with lavishly detailed maps "hmmm... no." *goes to page 10 *shows a mom posting the USA drawing her 5yo made on facebook "ah, great! this map will be excellent for my textbook!"
I love how everything else was so screwed up on the last map that Tigerstar didn't even mention that Canada wasn't included as an ally in WWII and apparently only Newfoundland was participating in the famous liberation of Holland.
As a Hoosier, I am offended. Let's call them Antihoosiers instead. (For those who don't know, people from Indiana are called "Hoosiers". There are at least three guesses why and they all sound ridiculous; nobody knows the term's origin for sure, but given how ridiculous the name is the origin is probably also ridiculous..)
5:50 ah yes that one time where texas fought with Germany against the USA You know right? Honestly all the maps including Germany tend to be the most messed up and goofy looking.
I know you're joking but the map depicts Texas being part of Mexico, not being independent. Plus the map is "trying" to show only the Allies, that doesn't mean that the grey countries would be the Axis or even the Central Powers.
@@digitalizedmind1216 I acknowledged the fact that it was a joke and I made a comment on it. No need to scold my behavior or actions. I didn't attack anyone nor am I doing anything wrong.
@@subatenome Ok i'm not trying to be offensive because that's how i'd get you to ignore me, I just want you to know there is no point to explaining why a joke is wrong. It's not funny and most if not all of the people that read it already know
@@digitalizedmind1216 There doesn't need to be a point for me to say anything, I made a comment on the joke and that's it. I don't care if it's not funny or if most people already know the contents of my message, and that btw is a bit of an assumption on your part. Neither you nor I know how many people know or care about my comment. That is still irrelevant to this conversation since I don't care in any case.
I like how that last map forgets that Canada was an Ally, except for Labrador, a subsection of a province that has fewer people in it than my apartment block.
Papa New Guinea isn't a part of Australia anymore? Then what was their obligation from stopping the Japanese there? (Other than the obvious launching point to Australia.)
Bizarrely enough, I've seen another map where Kyrgyzstan and Tajikistan were absorbed by China. They even took the time and effort to include Liechtenstein, as well as correctly placing South Sudan.
I think that weird US-Mexico border on the last map includes the states that Germany promised Mexico in the Zimmermann telegram. Which is also from WW1, not WW2.
1:48 it changes every year but stage 21 , the last one , alaways ends with Champ Elysees in Paris . But it remains roughly structured the same each year , 10 flat or hilly stages in northen France( or neighbouring countries ) 10 mountainish stages and the 1 flat in Paris
2:44 I took that course last year and had that textbook. I can verify, the borders throughout the entire book were that bad. In fact, I would contest that that wasn't even the worst one in there. There was a map of colonial America that gave the United states all land up to the St. Lawrence as well as Newfoundland and Greenland.
Update on that nope/10 map: The site just ditched the map entirely and removed the author's bio. Instead of a map, there's now an image of the Yalta Conference between Churchill, Roosevelt and Stalin.
3:10 every IB student knows that they must uphold the superiority of their program over AP while simultaneously complaining about how much worse they have it than anyone else.
"Speakin of which, this video is sponsored by..." *Everybody sweating nervously with finger on the right arrow button "..no" *gasp, lets go of right arrow button
4:00 I have a globe very similar to that that I got at a garage sale for like a buck. It was so sloppy I figured it was either a beginner metalwork project or a depiction of the world at somepoint between the breakup of Pangea and the last ice age.
That first map looks (from the typeface) a lot like something from the UK Mirror or Express papers. Haven't seen a copy of either in so long that I can't pin it down, though.
3:00 Of course. In that run, I rushed Lithuania to annex it along with the rest of the Baltic so I could reform the PLC and gain the production power needed to defend against Germany. AP strats.
First one in and the hyperventilation option for my laughs is already coming out. I live in Indiana, too.. That's just what living here be like. You not from here, and you say so outloud, and deadass everyone is just like "WH A T ?!?!?!?"
Could the map at 2:49 of Poland in 1920 be referring to the Polish invasion of Lithuanian-controlled territory, where at one point Poland invaded Vilnius?
![⭐ฮิตในTikTok!! ( มะมะมะหมูเด้ง MooDeng ) Ver. แดนซ์ ReMix BY [ ดีเจกิต รีมิกซ์ ]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/4noyAoMa7bQ/mqdefault.jpg)
When you're a PhD historian writing an article, but you choose the first cheap fan-made alt-history map you find on google images to be your heading image
Judging from the type of website it is, the article writer may not have had any idea about the map attached to it. At least, until now.
PhDs mark you as being educated, and intelligent when it comes to your field. That does not necessarily extend into the details.
Bad rep is good rep. That Ph.D. guy is tricking you all to see his website to bring in ads revenue. Quite a 3D chess move.
@@gordontaylor2815 Though, it might be a good idea to at least check the website afterward.
Labrador both broke free for Newfoundland, but fought by itself, without any Canadian aid?
3:38 my hometown is under water. Thanks, I hate it.
oh heyy
What is your hometown? Also, I love your videos!
The Paradigm well obviously in the caspian sea
kings and generals where you live
@@AnuDugala maybe greece judging by the profile picture
That last map kinda looks like a colored version of "If the Central Powers won WW1" as it shows Mexico having the land promised by Germany in the Zimmerman telegram (Arizona, New Mexico and Texas) or where the Brest-Litovsk treaty is withheld. Although I can't defend the author, he has a PhD cmon
Yeah, but I am amazed that someone with a phd would not know the borders, you would at least know that Canada participated in WWII
He's a traveler from another timeline
He is an Ottoman empire fanboy and added an alternate history map of the Central Powers winning WW1.
@@gheorghitaalsunculitei9146 There's always a possibility that he uploaded this map as a joke
@@Vrangelrip Or that Newfoundland _and_ Labrador were a single british colony, thus it would be weird for _only_ Labrador to have been an ally without its more populated other half.
This man truly is the Menace of Maps
The cartography criminal
Map menace, map menace, map map map menace
the map menaces are clearly those inept cartographers that made the maps in the first place
Map sommelier
He’s the MoM
"Kuwait is absorbed by Iraq"
Saddam approves
4of92000 *The 19th province of Iraq is absorbed by Iraq.
@@carlosmarte428 The branch is returned to the tree
@@Meirstein * Plays "Land of the two rivers" *
There is no Kuwait in Baghdad Sing Se
@@wildfire9280 bruh
"this video is sponsored by! no one"
lol
Thought he was going to say, “this video is sponsored by NordVPN.” How Ironic that would be.
@@JustanotherrandomTom That's the joke.
VPNs aren't illegal in Turkey.
@@katitobyt ok
4:32 Our geography teacher gave us this and I made a joke about how Spain is deformed:
Spain was hit in the Basque and now his Castiles (close to rib in English) hurt.
Ay, mis castillas
Wait wasn't Castile also an old Spanish nation?
@@hueylong7989 yes, so were Navarra and Aragón
About the Allies of world war 2 map. I'm pretty sure that Canada was fighting in WW2 for the allies... long before either the US or Soviets Lol
Places like India, South Africa, and more are also missing from the blue, and Italy isn't clearly labeled.
There are other things wrong about the map, like Ukraine and Belarus being independent. South Africa, British Raj, Egypt, and Brazil are also not being labeled as part of the Allies. Italy did eventually join the Allies, but that was after the Allies started their invasion of Italy. Saudi Arabia was neutral in WW2, but is labeled as part of the Allies in this Map.
@@Cyber_kumo The Soviet Transcaucuses region is also independent. They wish.
Apparently Only Labrador was an Ally. Apparently Canada fought for Axis.
Another thing that should be pointed out is that Armenia, Georgia, and Azerbaijan are shown as independent, *even though those three countries did not gain independence until the USSR collapsed in 1991.*
And apparently on the Tour De France map, Andorra and Monaco don’t exist either. Don’t forget about them
Stay
@@tahalifedive139 where is that map from
@@tahalifedive139 omg... i think im gonna 🤢🤢
@@schaumerrikk9859 me too
no stop it i found you on 5 different videos today
As a native Hoosier, I really appreciate the first map 😂
“Wait, it’s all Hoosiers?”
“Always has been.” *cocks gun*
I am a proud Hoosier, nothing like wondrous Corn Fields and road construction... and whatever Gary is trying to do
Let’s Go!
I know really unexpected cuz I just found this channel
Jakeb Henry “whatever Gary is trying to do”
Say they’re from Chicago?
4:47 Texas: "Aight, imma head out."
I cant belive the republic of tejas reformed!
Textbook editor:
"Hmmm I need a map for my history textbook"
*googles map
*first page filled with lavishly detailed maps
"hmmm... no."
*goes to page 10
*shows a mom posting the USA drawing her 5yo made on facebook
"ah, great! this map will be excellent for my textbook!"
"I know the Dutch have to worry about floods, but I don't ever remember the floods winning that badly." HAH!
Global warming for the win?
They just need a plan!
The floods redeployed all the water from the Mediterranean for an all-out assault to finally destroy their bitter rivals.
*Sad mill noises *
It's clear they sacrificed their homeland in favor of conquering the whole Mediterranean
I love how everything else was so screwed up on the last map that Tigerstar didn't even mention that Canada wasn't included as an ally in WWII and apparently only Newfoundland was participating in the famous liberation of Holland.
Not even Newfoundland. Just Labrador.
1:55 The Dutch didn't lose to the floods, the sea lost to the Dutch. The white is obviously the Netherlands.
Ah yes, the XKCD New Netherlands.
As someone from Chile, yeah no we don't have a pregnant coastline.
Lmao
T H I C C. C H I L E
That Allies of WW2 looks like a map made for some kind of alternate history.
2:10 - OMG I've seen this map. I stopped watching the Netflix documentary after I saw this in the first episode.
What's the documentary called?
@@mows6356 I think it’s “Greatest Events of WWII in Colour”
@@drm9694 oh ok, thanks
Same
Yup same. After like 10 min I have seen TWO of these (I also sent EmpTigerstar 2nd one with Anschluss) I laughed and turned that off
2:15 - I watched that documentary. It's WWII in Color on Netflix. I lost my sh*t when I saw that map, I couldn't control myself.
Let's be realist : American is a so confusing name, so let's recall them Outdianans!
As a Hoosier, I am offended.
Let's call them Antihoosiers instead.
(For those who don't know, people from Indiana are called "Hoosiers". There are at least three guesses why and they all sound ridiculous; nobody knows the term's origin for sure, but given how ridiculous the name is the origin is probably also ridiculous..)
The syntax in this comment hurt my brain.
It’s ironic because Indiana comes from lands ruled by Indians, so even us Hoosiers are outdianans.
Lol, this just attracted some of the few other Hoosiers on TH-cam.
Casual Hoosier Cornfeilds and Road construction 4 life
5:44 good to see that even though Canada abandoned the allies in WW2, we can always count on Newfoundland.
3:27 Forget Mali, what the hell happened to to Tanzania?
forget tanzania
tf happend to chad
they got no more chin
Looks like Uganda lost a war against Tanzania
East Africa has almost been achieved
Ethiopia borders Tanzanian Uganda. Gross.
Forget all that, what happenee to poor georgia and Azerbaijan?
5:50 ah yes that one time where texas fought with Germany against the USA
You know right?
Honestly all the maps including Germany tend to be the most messed up and goofy looking.
I know you're joking but the map depicts Texas being part of Mexico, not being independent. Plus the map is "trying" to show only the Allies, that doesn't mean that the grey countries would be the Axis or even the Central Powers.
@@subatenome bro it's an inside joke, just laugh and keep scrolling
@@digitalizedmind1216 I acknowledged the fact that it was a joke and I made a comment on it. No need to scold my behavior or actions. I didn't attack anyone nor am I doing anything wrong.
@@subatenome Ok i'm not trying to be offensive because that's how i'd get you to ignore me, I just want you to know there is no point to explaining why a joke is wrong. It's not funny and most if not all of the people that read it already know
@@digitalizedmind1216 There doesn't need to be a point for me to say anything, I made a comment on the joke and that's it. I don't care if it's not funny or if most people already know the contents of my message, and that btw is a bit of an assumption on your part. Neither you nor I know how many people know or care about my comment. That is still irrelevant to this conversation since I don't care in any case.
2:40 Hungary's bird
1:07 He had us in the first half, not gonna lie
Damn, how much did you get paid for that sponsorship?
Patreon/10
at least 3 dollars
6 and amount of something.
He got paid exactly no
He got paid X amount.
"Kuwait is absorp by Iraq"
Hmmm where did I see this before 🤔
Indiana/Outdiana sounds like something Romans would do.
I like how that last map forgets that Canada was an Ally, except for Labrador, a subsection of a province that has fewer people in it than my apartment block.
5:50 ah, yes, our most steadfast ally, the part of what is now Saudi Arabia where literally nobody lives
The capital (Riad) is actually there lol
It's just the part that wasn't a part of the Ottoman Empire.
The infographics show's maps are looking more terrible every day
Just like their content.
sadly true XD
@@MMFan2004 they were always terrible
“allies of world war 2”
italy
>blue
yes, but no
And Poland is apparently non existent, not even as an Ally, and somehow the Soviets are counted in..not to mention the rest.
Italy did join the Allies late in WW2.
Brazil was the only SA country to fight at WW2 but hey, let's ignore
Papa New Guinea isn't a part of Australia anymore?
Then what was their obligation from stopping the Japanese there? (Other than the obvious launching point to Australia.)
Oh hey, and Finland is also part of the allies.
True but also false, depending from what era this map is from.
Bizarrely enough, I've seen another map where Kyrgyzstan and Tajikistan were absorbed by China. They even took the time and effort to include Liechtenstein, as well as correctly placing South Sudan.
2:39
I watched that documentary and everytime they showed this map. I had to look away in despise and shame.
How could they mess up this badly?!
I think that weird US-Mexico border on the last map includes the states that Germany promised Mexico in the Zimmermann telegram. Which is also from WW1, not WW2.
top tier ww2 map
hold on...
4:30 the Suez Canal tripled in with is so boats don't get stuck.
2:07 Yay the map I send :) I knew you make good use of it ;)
Also, Labrador apparently decided to declare independence from the dominion of Newfound and joined the war on it's own.
3:31 . Didnt even cover the mess in the Malaya peninsula lmao.
in 2012, we briefly lost terrain in our own country when we conquered mare nostrum from Neptune.
never spread your windmills too thin.
5:10 love how Newfoundland seceded from Canada to join the allies.
Well it was actually part of the UK at the time.
4:35 I laughed at that joke more times as I would like to anticipate.
This no one is surely a worthy sponsor, I'll make sure to try them out.
4:34 those earthquakes really do be hitting hard these days
1:48 it changes every year but stage 21 , the last one , alaways ends with Champ Elysees in Paris . But it remains roughly structured the same each year , 10 flat or hilly stages in northen France( or neighbouring countries ) 10 mountainish stages and the 1 flat in Paris
“It’s also like 2020, in that it’s bad and has several mistakes”
- EmperorTigerStar
I never thought I'd hear you even mention that the IB program even exists
4:53 Bruh that's the lands Germany said they'd recognize that Mexico owned on the Zimmerman Telegram
4:40 South America do be looking kinda thicc tho
5:13
Relax, they just love Kaiserreich
2:44 I took that course last year and had that textbook. I can verify, the borders throughout the entire book were that bad. In fact, I would contest that that wasn't even the worst one in there. There was a map of colonial America that gave the United states all land up to the St. Lawrence as well as Newfoundland and Greenland.
based
2:40 in this map Ukraine is also given the part of Carpathia, which belonged to Czechoslovakia until after ww2
Tiger-daddy: Speaking of which this video is sponsored by-
Me: oh no
Tiger-daddy: *No-one*
Update on that nope/10 map: The site just ditched the map entirely and removed the author's bio. Instead of a map, there's now an image of the Yalta Conference between Churchill, Roosevelt and Stalin.
3:10 every IB student knows that they must uphold the superiority of their program over AP while simultaneously complaining about how much worse they have it than anyone else.
My exact thoughts. As an IB student this is true.
5:10 wwii if kaiserreich was put on speed and the ottomans were buffed 450%
My favorite sponsor: *No one*
And since when are we in Siberia? Bruh
But you would be, if you could!
These are just the rightful borders of north korea, but the western imposters unlawfully claim it
You are everywhehe
damn, that "sponsored by noone" remark got me. you definitely produce sponsor worthy content man, keep up the awesome videos!
"Speakin of which, this video is sponsored by..."
*Everybody sweating nervously with finger on the right arrow button
"..no"
*gasp, lets go of right arrow button
I was expecting this to be a video on meme maps instead historically/geographically incorrect maps. No worries, I enjoyed it still! Good video.
3:02 Also, there was no such thing as the "General Government of Poland", it was just the General Government, run by Germans..
4:00 I have a globe very similar to that that I got at a garage sale for like a buck. It was so sloppy I figured it was either a beginner metalwork project or a depiction of the world at somepoint between the breakup of Pangea and the last ice age.
"Kuwait is absorbed by Iraq"
*Laughs in Baathist*
Normie
3:58 can't believe you didn't mention the fact that half of Indonesia is missing in that.
Is it me or his Badmaps sounds like Batman?
Probably only me, sorry.
They kinda do
There is a city of Batman ..
There is an actual city in Turkey called Batman.
1:43 Brittan: Am I a joke to you
Mexico in the Allies of ww2 map had the borders promised to them by the Germans lmao.
The Allies of WW2 map was real in my friend's Hoi4 playthrough.
5:33 also ukraine and belarus arent parts of USSR for some reason
0:50
Xi Jinping: Write that down! WRITE THAT DOWN!!!
You can’t embarrass the Ap test it’s run by the college board
Theres quite some maps where China just annex some-stans on internet
Finally someone talked about that
I'm a fan of the fact that only Labrador apparently fought in WW2, and not Newfoundland or Canada.
that's because the rest of Canada doesn't exist.
4:12 this globe looks more like pangea rather than earth
1:01 even the data is wrong. As a turk, VPN isnt banned here.
Kaçak kullanıyoruz
@@HD-np7eb valla ben bir tane vpn uygulamasi indirdim onu kullaniyorum. Ama kacak mi degil mi bilmiyorum
1:38 I guess Atlantropa succeeded in this map’s world?
It's a little known fact but the first map is actually the election map for Kanye
2:55 oh i recognise this page! we used these books in history class
1:07 I was about to skip lol
Ayy lmao wasn’t expecting the IB reference.
That first map looks (from the typeface) a lot like something from the UK Mirror or Express papers. Haven't seen a copy of either in so long that I can't pin it down, though.
5:45 looks like a "What if Germany won WW1 map."
4:50 Not only that, this is a template used on MapChart, a map-making map. They used the 'World - 1914' template.
PhD dude submits that map and has his article published, and my stuff got rejected because of a grammar mistake...
3:14 I have the exact same globe and I have a keychain globe that has like a thousand errors more than that one, which has like 100 errors.
3:00 Of course. In that run, I rushed Lithuania to annex it along with the rest of the Baltic so I could reform the PLC and gain the production power needed to defend against Germany. AP strats.
2:24 that map also shows that germany envelops the rhine at the south, which is wrong, the Rhine is the border between switzerland and germany
4:33 I spat out my drink
I like that your channel is named after one of the most famous and devious characters/villains in the Warriors series.
How is it that so many maps can just have countries missing. My AP US GOV and Politics map was missing Tunisia
3:24 Literally have this exact same ball, two of them actually lol.
5:00 Apparently Labrador in Canada, not even Newfoundland And Labrador, just Labrador, was the only contributing province in WW2. Seems Legit.
Seeing how this was in my recommended, I was 100% expecting this to be either GMod or TF2 lmao
1:12 actually VPNs are mostly legal in China
When I saw the first image, I would believed it....
3:24 I had a ball like that: Czechia, Slovakia and Hungary were together and were called something like "Siwana"
First one in and the hyperventilation option for my laughs is already coming out.
I live in Indiana, too.. That's just what living here be like. You not from here, and you say so outloud, and deadass everyone is just like "WH A T ?!?!?!?"
I love your bad maps series. Thank you
5:00 could this be a "German victory in WW1" alternate history map?
Could the map at 2:49 of Poland in 1920 be referring to the Polish invasion of Lithuanian-controlled territory, where at one point Poland invaded Vilnius?