Chapters: 00:00 Introduction 01:34 Puppies Who Whine 02:16 Dogs Who Need to Go Potty 02:57 Dogs Who Want to Go Outside & Play 04:30 Dog Who Whine Because They Are Bored 06:04 Remote Collar Caveat 08:10 Older Aging Dogs Who Whine
I also find that in general telling dogs what to do, instead of only what not to do helps a lot. For example, any time you've interacted with the dog in some way and the interaction ends, they can be a little like "ok, what now?" and not know what to do next and whine a bit.
I agree 100% - love your post. Back in the early 1980's when I was training in Schutzhund I started talking to my dogs during training (and quietly during a competition). I would tell them what the next exercise was going to be i.e NOW THE JUMP. - it works when you have a good relationship and have done it 500 times :-)
I got a second "free" rottie from CL. She briefly whines when I put on a restraint. It doesn't matter if it's a prong, flat, or e-collar. And she whines when corrected using any of them. She was a puller during walks. But now she walks attached to my tac rig and is doing better. But even at the lowest setting she whines out loud. My assessment is she was never conditioned to understand correction. And was given space when she whined. She's a big dog. And is very obedient. But I have walk rules too, hehe. She is getting much better on walks and I'm in no hurry. I just thought I'd mention my whiner.
I leave the room as soon as there is a whine, and then come back after about 10-15 minutes. It doesn't take long for him to get the message that his whine does the opposite of what he wants.
I dont really agree with this. I dont thi its breed specific. I bred GSDs for 35 years and didn't have have one dog with a whining issues. Michael is a Malinois person. But with that said I dont remember him saying that - if I had I would have disagreed with him. He and I disagree on the subject of German Shepherds as a breed.
I had a Dutch Herder x Malinois who whined way more than your dog, but only when he was trying to control his impulsivity (usually around training or food times). It was ear-splitting and we called it Kettle Mode (like a whistling kettle!) 😂
I know what you mean - but these are not the dogs I am talking about. My Stella (14 year old border terrier ) whines all the time. I almost think s he doesnt know she is even doing it. Bit there certainly isnt any reason for it that I can see, maybe it dog dementia
He has you well trained :-) Pip (our chihuahua) would love to rule our house. She is now 3 or close to it. She is very responsive to find out that she gets put in her expen when she gets out of line. I bred GSDs for 35 years (retired from that 15 years ago) I now have 3 little dogs (plus one very tough GSD) I think I need to do a video on training small dogs
Your mother should teach you manners or put you on medication. I looked at your horse video on yourchannel. I own horses and have most of my life. You need lessons on not using a BIT and a tight reign - I ride my horse with a halter (no bit) and teach it to give to pressure so we seldom have or need a tight reign. As far as I am concerned using a bit on a hore is way way way worse than using a vibration settling or low level stimulation on a horse. So "GO GROW UP".
Chapters:
00:00 Introduction
01:34 Puppies Who Whine
02:16 Dogs Who Need to Go Potty
02:57 Dogs Who Want to Go Outside & Play
04:30 Dog Who Whine Because They Are Bored
06:04 Remote Collar Caveat
08:10 Older Aging Dogs Who Whine
I also find that in general telling dogs what to do, instead of only what not to do helps a lot. For example, any time you've interacted with the dog in some way and the interaction ends, they can be a little like "ok, what now?" and not know what to do next and whine a bit.
I agree 100% - love your post. Back in the early 1980's when I was training in Schutzhund I started talking to my dogs during training (and quietly during a competition). I would tell them what the next exercise was going to be i.e NOW THE JUMP. - it works when you have a good relationship and have done it 500 times :-)
I got a second "free" rottie from CL. She briefly whines when I put on a restraint. It doesn't matter if it's a prong, flat, or e-collar. And she whines when corrected using any of them. She was a puller during walks. But now she walks attached to my tac rig and is doing better. But even at the lowest setting she whines out loud. My assessment is she was never conditioned to understand correction. And was given space when she whined. She's a big dog. And is very obedient. But I have walk rules too, hehe. She is getting much better on walks and I'm in no hurry. I just thought I'd mention my whiner.
I leave the room as soon as there is a whine, and then come back after about 10-15 minutes. It doesn't take long for him to get the message that his whine does the opposite of what he wants.
Your dog is doing a good job of trianing yiu 🙂
@@efrawley55 Not if he doesn't whine anymore.
Then theres the breeds who whine and dont know it. I remember a michael ellis seminar where he addressed this. Shepherds and malinois were mentioned!
I dont really agree with this. I dont thi its breed specific. I bred GSDs for 35 years and didn't have have one dog with a whining issues. Michael is a Malinois person. But with that said I dont remember him saying that - if I had I would have disagreed with him. He and I disagree on the subject of German Shepherds as a breed.
My shepherd is a whiner in the car…she must be afraid when I go in the store, etc. I wish she was more confident.
I had a Dutch Herder x Malinois who whined way more than your dog, but only when he was trying to control his impulsivity (usually around training or food times). It was ear-splitting and we called it Kettle Mode (like a whistling kettle!) 😂
I know what you mean - but these are not the dogs I am talking about. My Stella (14 year old border terrier ) whines all the time. I almost think s he doesnt know she is even doing it. Bit there certainly isnt any reason for it that I can see, maybe it dog dementia
For the nervous dog, Charlotte's Web CBD dog chewies is miraculous.
There are times when medication can really be beneficial. But with dogs that whiles every day - I wouldn't recommend drugging them every day
My chihuahua terrier is so needy. He needs attention all the time. He's 7 pounds and runs the house.
He has you well trained :-) Pip (our chihuahua) would love to rule our house. She is now 3 or close to it. She is very responsive to find out that she gets put in her expen when she gets out of line. I bred GSDs for 35 years (retired from that 15 years ago) I now have 3 little dogs (plus one very tough GSD) I think I need to do a video on training small dogs
I've never seen your videos before. You pissed me off at E-collar.
OK slick. You need to either grow up or get on medication.
Your mother should teach you manners or put you on medication. I looked at your horse video on yourchannel. I own horses and have most of my life. You need lessons on not using a BIT and a tight reign - I ride my horse with a halter (no bit) and teach it to give to pressure so we seldom have or need a tight reign. As far as I am concerned using a bit on a hore is way way way worse than using a vibration settling or low level stimulation on a horse. So "GO GROW UP".
So?