I qualified thrice upsc mains with zoology as optional and I wrote 3 mains in hcs with zoology as optional , in Haryana botany and zoology are less opted optionals , like in 2023 results announced in feb it was a jackpot for students with anthropology optional, these ppl got really lucky :) obviously they worked hard but others also worked v hard with different optional I was shocked to see many students in final list with anthropology as optional ., u never know what is with optional .. there is no scaling and rationalisation., and there is huge disparity wrt to marks .. one of my friend is topper from LSR and her optional was English literature and she never made it in hcs , she scored less marks in English nevertheless she is IAS now , under 50 rank So in our state services we aren’t v sure when it comes to optionals .. so it can be on lines of uppsc .. add extra papers.. make the paoer tough , let the most deserving and best win 🏆.. it can be level playing field and students will not feel betrayed by seeing the optional marks , THANKU and THANKU Amit sir for voicing the opinions in most genuine way🤗🙏🏻
Respected sir i'm also mathematics background student But if you want remove optnl sub,my suggestion is plz take haryana g.k sub so haryana students take benefits
Haryana ka students hi haryana ko smjhta h .. yha k culture ko smjhta h Jb other states khud ka GK ppr add kr k indirectly other students ki favour le rhi h to Hry govt ko b yhi krna chahiye Vrna saare UP Bihari hi ho jayega Hry m
Removal of option is partiality for science students...now they will only have to study only arts subjects..their graduation subjects seems waste now in civil services
If you are a science student and opting for civil services and that too in this is age of technology has already failed in my opinion and just trying to get employed
It shouldnt be removed but the difference of marks among various subjects can be reviewed….after all students have prepared alot for optional…it would be like waste of time and energy.
Optional shudnt be removed but its weightage can be decreased to 100 marks and there can be two papers of GS of either 150 marks or as it is now(200) of 2 hrs each
@@DrAmitAcademy Thank you Amit sir for your response. Q. Sir, mere gaon me ek bahan hai wo Hindi medium se preparation krna chahti hai.. kya aap Hindi medium se bhi HCS ya UPSC ka preparation me help krte hai ?
@@Hr11rock students k less hone se kya hota h? Humanities k Paper checkers ko bolna chahiye k agar answer theek h, and is covering every required aspect, then full marks should be given. Aaj kal +2 cbse arts ka result dekha karo, 500 me se 499 marks bhi aate hain. Sirf checking theek karne ki jarurat hai, na ki optional hatane ki.
@@P.S.... Aaisay 😂 nhi hota There is no perfect answer in humanities But in maths 2*2=4 So for scaling u need particular numbers of candidates like above 200 in every optional
@@Hr11rock scaling ki baat kar hi nhi rhe hain bhai.optional k paper checkers ka mindset theek karne ki jarurat h, pura answer theek hone par bhi 10 me se max 6-7 hi milta h. So this thing needs to be changed. Checkers ko model answer milna chahiye, and agar kisi student ne un sare points ko apne answer me include Kiya h, to use bhi 10/10 milna chahiye.
@@Hr11rock2019, cbse +2 topper Hansika shukla( Arts stream) scored 499/500. In history, pol sc, psychology her score was 100/100. Ye sabhi subjects humanities k hi hain. 2×2=4, I agree. Write a short note on F Duties. If you are writing all the duties, source, amendment, everything...then don't you think the answer also deserves 10/10. So the only need is to provide a model answer to the paper checkers and tell them to give full marks if all points are covered. Why maximum marks in humanities answer is 7/10 not 10/10. So, proper step by step marking is needed. That's all.
Optional removal is not wise solution according to me bcoz fir toh civil services will only be about humanities subjects ... There can be other solutions like Scaling... See ase toh non humanities background vale bol skte h ki arts valo ko undue advantage h in writing gs papers both in pre nd mains ... As they have studied subjects already be it in 11th 12th or in graduation ... Optional was there to provide an edge somehow in mains to those who are from non humanities bg...they can write smart and effective in paper of there respective backgrounds or interests... And to maintain level playing field optional hona chaheye but with Scaling ... And those who are saying ki optional remove hone ke baad there ll be equal Competition ... I just want to knw Equal kese hoga for those having science background Kyuki civil services mein arts mein jo pdha h vo toh same hi pucha jata h atleast the basic but science ke toh topic b different hi h (say AI , cyber security) No science student study these topics in early education (without specialization basically) So my question is how come this ll be an equal Competition
Yes humanities students do study these subjects because they opt arts and since starting they choose arts because they want to go in this profession.... They can't just change there mind after 12th or graduation and choose to mbbs or btech..but btech and medical side students even commerce are allowed to sit for this examination...... The fact is they decided on the time and choose stream accordingly....... If someone want to become an officer they want to study about the society, governance,economy etc ...and basic maths and science ( no need to master these subjects) so agar civil services m Jana hi h to ye subject pr emphasis to Krna hi pdega..... Humanities ko neet exam me koi optional nhi milta ..demand us paper ki science h to vhi shi h ase hi tha pr exam ki demand yhi h to science students ki koi complain honi nhi chahiye
Please do not get optional removed. Those who do not want to get it removed please mail for it. The committee sir mentioned for removing optional is for UPSC, if they remove then it's fine. Otherwise kindly don't get it removed.
what is the point of removing the optional subject ? 1. Doing your graduation in any of the subject whether its economics , history , chemistry , mathematics or any subject your study for three years makes your proficient in that subject . 2. Secondly just focusing on general studies will make it more easier of the students of humanities because they have invested their three years of graduation there as compared to medical , non medical and commerce
By only eliminating optionl plz dnt make this xam hlwa...substitute this optionl with 4 gs pprs nd two for hr related gs...for optnl if we can mention uppcs then why not in this way...demand for right not only for 'light'.
OPTIONAL remove hona chaahiye kyon ki 1 jinko zyaada marks mil rahe hain wo kyon object karenge . 2 science optional waale jab arts subject lenge to unko bhi kam marks hi milenge then they will understand the pain of getting lesser marks than others 3 jinhone arts subject prepare kiya hai aur wo keh rahe hain ki optional remove nahi hona chaahiye . then i understand your natural attachment because you prepared the subject . but in practical , don't worry marks aako kam hi milne waale hain 4 agar hpsc waalon ko lagta hai ki science side behtar civil servants saabit hogi . to science side bina optional ke bhi better hi perform karegi exam me . 5 jo science , commerce , engrs , DRs etc arts subject lete hain un sabko kam marks hi milte hain . so here also , hpsc is being not only non - fair but also missing out on the talent too . 6 so more marks are for SCIENCE GRADUATEs WITH SCIENCE OPTIONAL only . 7 SO optional remove hona hi chaahiye .TO HAVE A FAIR GAME . ya fir hpsc sabko equality se marks de . THANK YOU
Optional should be removed All aspirants should be assessed on parity. Exam should be same for all , jb same post k liye exam h to, i don't think optional is required.
It is right to remove optional sir. I have scored good marks in geography optional in upsc mains but I am not able to score good marks in geography optional in 3 hcs mains. Worse is that I am still not able to figure out what wrong I am doing in hcs optional. Thus high disparity in optional marks.
Isme koi khushi ki bat nhi h.. Jin logo ki kisi ek subject me experty h ve log baher ho jaege.. Jo log competitive exams ki preparation krre h unke liye csat and gs ho gya.. Jo kisi ek subject ki experty rkhte h unke liye option helpful ho jata h.. To sbke liye competition equal ho jata h. Optional ki wjh se agr problem aa rhi h to problem htao optional nhi. Ye to whi bat hi gyi k paper me govt. Cheat krti h to paper krwane hi bnd krdo.. Bhai optional me Jo problem aa rhi h use htao.. Optional ko nhi.. Ye koi ssc ja exam nhi.. Or jinhe aisa paper chahiye unke liye ssc and hssc bne hue h.. Unhe civil service me aane ki koi jrurt nhi h
In my opinion optional is saviour for those aspirants who are lacking behind in GS.There are multiple reasons for not having mastery in GS subjects. In this situation expertise over some techincal subjects really help many aspirants to sail through the exam. We have also seen the similar kind of trend in UPSC even. Every year marks in optional subjects varies a lot. So based solely on criteria that aspirant having XYZ optional clear the mains exam and even get a good rank should not be the reason for removing optional from HCS. If this is the only criteria that XYZ optional aspirants are selected, then why the commission itself give a list to chose optional subject of our own choice. Though there may be some biasedness but removal of optional impact lot many aspirants specially having the techinal subjects as their optional.
Hello sir Maine apki videos dekhi aur mai bahut motivate hui hu.. Sir mera sapna tha ias banane ka.. par mai pura nahi payi.. zimmedariyaan thi bahut saari.. Par ab mai hpsc exam nikalna chahti .. kya mai kar sakti hu? I am 37 now
"Hello! It's never too late to chase your dreams. You've shown great strength in handling responsibilities, and that same determination will help you succeed in the HPSC exam. Believe in yourself, and you can achieve anything!" All The Best🙌
For all science background students:- Please mail this agr aap optional remove nhi krana chahte ho to :- Dear Sir, I am writing to express my concern regarding the proposals to remove optional subjects in the HPSC(HCS) examination. General Studies already requires significant effort from SCIENCE BACKGROUND STUDENTS, as it primarily benefits humanities students. Humanities students can select subjects that align with their academic background, while science students must study General Studies in addition to their specialized subjects. Eliminating optional subjects places science students at a disadvantage by removing the opportunity to excel in their strongest subjects. The optional subject system ensures fairness by allowing students to demonstrate their strengths. If science students are expected to study humanities subjects for better scores, it is only fair for humanities students to consider studying science subjects. I urge you to reconsider this decision to ensure a balanced and fair examination process. Otherwise, it may become UNFAIR FOR SCIENCE STUDENTS, potentially hindering their ability to qualify if there are no optional subjects. Thank you for your understanding. Sincerely Your name
Optional must be removed, but strong campaign is needed, what effective steps you will take? Except making videos which increases your popularity, business, profit only
You are doing next level campaigns for optional removal.....others optional k paper halwa hota ya bina padh kar sab select hote h..........better ye hona chaye cutoff bataye hpsc prelims ki......representation ki fees minimum ki jaye......come with positive reforms............
Optional should be removed 💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯❤️🔥💯❤️🔥💯❤️🔥💯❤️🔥💯❤️🔥💯❤️🔥💯❤️🔥💯💯❤️🔥💯❤️🔥❤️🔥💯❤️🔥💯💯❤️🔥💯❤️🔥💯❤️🔥💯❤️🔥💯💯❤️🔥💯💯❤️🔥💯❤️🔥💯❤️🔥💯💯❤️🔥💯❤️🔥💯❤️🔥💯❤️🔥💯💯❤️🔥
Hlo sir ..sir mainy last year hcs ka exam dia tha but nhi ho paya pre ..is saal bhi preparation kr rhi hu ..sir meri beti choti h ..mujy advice dijiye m kis tarike s apni study kru ..mujy job bhut jaruri h ..plzz sir guide me
Dekhiye preparation me we have to strategize for both sure and unsure things , jo information h wo correct h , ab jske hisab se you have to plan your preparation, take decision how much time to give for optional ,balancing both outcome if it's removed and even if it is not removed, I hope this helps in giving some clarity .
Sir final year student KO bhi apply krne ki eligibility honi chahiye kyoki phir eske bad Hume 2,3 sal tk rukna PD Santa hai . Please eske bare mai bhi bat kare
bpdaba , bhai ek to ni hua sach bataun to usse jada hi hue h ,is bar ki list me check kar lo , bharti , satish , rohit kumar , shabnam , kavita , ye kuch naam h jo abhi yaad aaye ,. baki list available h videos me bhi , agar dekhayi aur sunai deta h to plz search and see on youtube , kyunki dimag to mujhe lag ni raha ki kam karta h :) just kidding .take care
Sahi pakde h 😀 Process start ho chuka h raghav hpsc ki taraf se , agar lucky rahe to ho bhi jayega , sarkar serious h , baki agar aapko samajh aya ho ki hum kya kehna chahte h to plz like the comment , agar ni aya to feel free to comment 😀
Bilkul..ab agr hum dusre tarike se dekhein to science walo k sath na insaafi hai ab...kyunki gs mein sare subjects to arts k the hi already..sirf optional hi unka apna hota hai...
I qualified thrice upsc mains with zoology as optional and I wrote 3 mains in hcs with zoology as optional , in Haryana botany and zoology are less opted optionals , like in 2023 results announced in feb it was a jackpot for students with anthropology optional, these ppl got really lucky :) obviously they worked hard but others also worked v hard with different optional I was shocked to see many students in final list with anthropology as optional ., u never know what is with optional .. there is no scaling and rationalisation., and there is huge disparity wrt to marks .. one of my friend is topper from LSR and her optional was English literature and she never made it in hcs , she scored less marks in English nevertheless she is IAS now , under 50 rank So in our state services we aren’t v sure when it comes to optionals .. so it can be on lines of uppsc .. add extra papers.. make the paoer tough , let the most deserving and best win 🏆.. it can be level playing field and students will not feel betrayed by seeing the optional marks , THANKU and THANKU Amit sir for voicing the opinions in most genuine way🤗🙏🏻
Can u help me in zoology optional about resources plzz it's humble request to u
Can you help me for hpsc
Kya aap bta skte ho ki previous years paper ki pdf kaha se download kre
Optional remove nhi hona chahiye sirrr....bulki ethics paper add hona chahiye...hindi or english me se ik hatta kar
Respected sir i'm also mathematics background student
But if you want remove optnl sub,my suggestion is plz take haryana g.k sub so haryana students take benefits
Haryana ka students hi haryana ko smjhta h .. yha k culture ko smjhta h
Jb other states khud ka GK ppr add kr k indirectly other students ki favour le rhi h to Hry govt ko b yhi krna chahiye
Vrna saare UP Bihari hi ho jayega Hry m
Removal of option is partiality for science students...now they will only have to study only arts subjects..their graduation subjects seems waste now in civil services
Bhai public service ma laymen sa interact karna hota h vaha science kam nhi ati 😅
Civil services are not meant for science background students since beginning. Still they appear and have a lot on their plates.
If you are a science student and opting for civil services and that too in this is age of technology has already failed in my opinion and just trying to get employed
@@Look73689 why??
Kyun binaa baat peeche padd gye ho optional hatwaane m... Itne time preparation ki... Saari waste krwa doge aap ....
Yess u r right phir alg subj add honge
Konya hov remove..
Those who are in favour of removing optional hit 👍🏻
@@TusharSharma-gy3qb level playing field word apne aap me hi ik mythic hai......hindi medium wale fir gye kaam se agar optional httt gya....👀👀👀
It shouldnt be removed but the difference of marks among various subjects can be reviewed….after all students have prepared alot for optional…it would be like waste of time and energy.
Optional shudnt be removed but its weightage can be decreased to 100 marks and there can be two papers of GS of either 150 marks or as it is now(200) of 2 hrs each
Gunaah kiya hai ldka, general, middle class mei paida hoke. Pichle janam mei bohot bure karm kiye honge. Aaj tak khoon ke ansu ro rha hu
Mission shakti - Ladko ne kya gunah kiya hai...unki life mein struggle nhi hai kya😢😢
Sahi bola aapne
@@ajaynain88 right
We will plan something for boys in next batch or soon
Online nhi de skte test???
@@DrAmitAcademy Thank you Amit sir for your response.
Q. Sir, mere gaon me ek bahan hai wo Hindi medium se preparation krna chahti hai.. kya aap Hindi medium se bhi HCS ya UPSC ka preparation me help krte hai ?
Optional should not be removed
Plz 45 percent wali condition bhi remove k liye initiate kre sir
Instead of talking about removal of optional.....I think we must talk about removing the discrepencies in evaluation process!!
They can't
No of candidates are less
@@Hr11rock students k less hone se kya hota h? Humanities k Paper checkers ko bolna chahiye k agar answer theek h, and is covering every required aspect, then full marks should be given. Aaj kal +2 cbse arts ka result dekha karo, 500 me se 499 marks bhi aate hain.
Sirf checking theek karne ki jarurat hai, na ki optional hatane ki.
@@P.S....
Aaisay 😂 nhi hota
There is no perfect answer in humanities
But in maths 2*2=4
So for scaling u need particular numbers of candidates like above 200 in every optional
@@Hr11rock scaling ki baat kar hi nhi rhe hain bhai.optional k paper checkers ka mindset theek karne ki jarurat h, pura answer theek hone par bhi 10 me se max 6-7 hi milta h. So this thing needs to be changed. Checkers ko model answer milna chahiye, and agar kisi student ne un sare points ko apne answer me include Kiya h, to use bhi 10/10 milna chahiye.
@@Hr11rock2019, cbse +2 topper Hansika shukla( Arts stream) scored 499/500. In history, pol sc, psychology her score was 100/100. Ye sabhi subjects humanities k hi hain.
2×2=4, I agree.
Write a short note on F Duties. If you are writing all the duties, source, amendment, everything...then don't you think the answer also deserves 10/10.
So the only need is to provide a model answer to the paper checkers and tell them to give full marks if all points are covered. Why maximum marks in humanities answer is 7/10 not 10/10.
So, proper step by step marking is needed. That's all.
Optional removal is not wise solution according to me bcoz fir toh civil services will only be about humanities subjects ... There can be other solutions like Scaling...
See ase toh non humanities background vale bol skte h ki arts valo ko undue advantage h in writing gs papers both in pre nd mains ... As they have studied subjects already be it in 11th 12th or in graduation ...
Optional was there to provide an edge somehow in mains to those who are from non humanities bg...they can write smart and effective in paper of there respective backgrounds or interests...
And to maintain level playing field optional hona chaheye but with Scaling ...
And those who are saying ki optional remove hone ke baad there ll be equal Competition ...
I just want to knw Equal kese hoga for those having science background
Kyuki civil services mein arts mein jo pdha h vo toh same hi pucha jata h atleast the basic but science ke toh topic b different hi h (say AI , cyber security)
No science student study these topics in early education (without specialization basically)
So my question is how come this ll be an equal Competition
Yes humanities students do study these subjects because they opt arts and since starting they choose arts because they want to go in this profession.... They can't just change there mind after 12th or graduation and choose to mbbs or btech..but btech and medical side students even commerce are allowed to sit for this examination...... The fact is they decided on the time and choose stream accordingly....... If someone want to become an officer they want to study about the society, governance,economy etc ...and basic maths and science ( no need to master these subjects) so agar civil services m Jana hi h to ye subject pr emphasis to Krna hi pdega..... Humanities ko neet exam me koi optional nhi milta ..demand us paper ki science h to vhi shi h ase hi tha pr exam ki demand yhi h to science students ki koi complain honi nhi chahiye
Please do not get optional removed.
Those who do not want to get it removed please mail for it.
The committee sir mentioned for removing optional is for UPSC, if they remove then it's fine. Otherwise kindly don't get it removed.
I will mail bro, please others also do the same
ha nhi hona chaiye
Hmm ,nhi hona chaaiye yar remove
What is your concern???
Optional should not be removed
अगर ऑप्शनल हटेगा तो हिंदी माध्यम का एक ही स्लेक्सन नही होगा
Shi kha brother😢
Haan jaise abhi tho bahut ho rhe h . Sab tho math physics .... walo k ho rhe h
Hindi medium Group D mein hi theek hai, gawar HCS nahi chahiye 😂
@@exoticindiaa ,💩💩 soch ke swami
what is the point of removing the optional subject ?
1. Doing your graduation in any of the subject whether its economics , history , chemistry , mathematics or any subject your study for three years makes your proficient in that subject .
2. Secondly just focusing on general studies will make it more easier of the students of humanities because they have invested their three years of graduation there as compared to medical , non medical and commerce
By only eliminating optionl plz dnt make this xam hlwa...substitute this optionl with 4 gs pprs nd two for hr related gs...for optnl if we can mention uppcs then why not in this way...demand for right not only for 'light'.
I don't think optional htana chahiye
OPTIONAL remove hona chaahiye kyon ki
1 jinko zyaada marks mil rahe hain wo kyon object karenge .
2 science optional waale jab arts subject lenge to unko bhi kam marks hi milenge then they will understand the pain of getting lesser marks than others
3 jinhone arts subject prepare kiya hai aur wo keh rahe hain ki optional remove nahi hona chaahiye . then i understand your natural attachment because you prepared the subject . but in practical , don't worry marks aako kam hi milne waale hain
4 agar hpsc waalon ko lagta hai ki science side behtar civil servants saabit hogi . to science side bina optional ke bhi better hi perform karegi exam me .
5 jo science , commerce , engrs , DRs etc arts subject lete hain un sabko kam marks hi milte hain . so here also , hpsc is being not only non - fair but also missing out on the talent too .
6 so more marks are for SCIENCE GRADUATEs WITH SCIENCE OPTIONAL only .
7 SO optional remove hona hi chaahiye .TO HAVE A FAIR GAME . ya fir hpsc sabko equality se marks de .
THANK YOU
thank you Dr . amit
Optional remove nhi ho skta 100% Guarantee 😅
@@UPSC_1008 because all state civil services exam mother are upsc
@@RiaKhan-lp3tt hii riya can u help me.....
Optional should be removed
All aspirants should be assessed on parity.
Exam should be same for all , jb same post k liye exam h to, i don't think optional is required.
It is right to remove optional sir. I have scored good marks in geography optional in upsc mains but I am not able to score good marks in geography optional in 3 hcs mains. Worse is that I am still not able to figure out what wrong I am doing in hcs optional. Thus high disparity in optional marks.
Same here, how much u got this time in hcs geography?
@@amitpal510977
bhai apka roll no. 1805 tha kya?
@@insights1330 nhi bhai 1838
bhai pata nhi kaise check karte hai. mere bhut acha hua tha paper. i was expecting atleast 100.
Optional remove karke ethics k paper ana chahiye yeh Sare future officers or students k liye benificial hoga
Optional remove ho k ethics ka paper add hona chahiye ya ethics + haryana gs ka paper add hona chahiye
Isme koi khushi ki bat nhi h.. Jin logo ki kisi ek subject me experty h ve log baher ho jaege..
Jo log competitive exams ki preparation krre h unke liye csat and gs ho gya.. Jo kisi ek subject ki experty rkhte h unke liye option helpful ho jata h..
To sbke liye competition equal ho jata h.
Optional ki wjh se agr problem aa rhi h to problem htao optional nhi.
Ye to whi bat hi gyi k paper me govt. Cheat krti h to paper krwane hi bnd krdo..
Bhai optional me Jo problem aa rhi h use htao.. Optional ko nhi..
Ye koi ssc ja exam nhi.. Or jinhe aisa paper chahiye unke liye ssc and hssc bne hue h.. Unhe civil service me aane ki koi jrurt nhi h
Sir optional remove nahi hona chahiye kyoki science wale students upsc,hcs ki jab preparation karte hai to har topic 0 se start krna pdta hai
Kam se Kam question mark toh laga dete..removed ke baad..
Right
Optional Should be removed
HCS optional must be removed... Thank you sir for your efforts
Option should not be removed,,Hcs exam should be equivalent to Upsc..
Bilkul Shi sir,,, optional remove hona chahiye,, kyunki select krne me hi dikkt hone lgti h 😢
In my opinion optional is saviour for those aspirants who are lacking behind in GS.There are multiple reasons for not having mastery in GS subjects. In this situation expertise over some techincal subjects really help many aspirants to sail through the exam.
We have also seen the similar kind of trend in UPSC even. Every year marks in optional subjects varies a lot. So based solely on criteria that aspirant having XYZ optional clear the mains exam and even get a good rank should not be the reason for removing optional from HCS.
If this is the only criteria that XYZ optional aspirants are selected, then why the commission itself give a list to chose optional subject of our own choice. Though there may be some biasedness but removal of optional impact lot many aspirants specially having the techinal subjects as their optional.
Sir ko bohot dukh hai ki maine galat optional le liya ab hataane ko bolre hain
Hello sir
Maine apki videos dekhi aur mai bahut motivate hui hu..
Sir mera sapna tha ias banane ka.. par mai pura nahi payi.. zimmedariyaan thi bahut saari..
Par ab mai hpsc exam nikalna chahti .. kya mai kar sakti hu?
I am 37 now
"Hello! It's never too late to chase your dreams. You've shown great strength in handling responsibilities, and that same determination will help you succeed in the HPSC exam. Believe in yourself, and you can achieve anything!" All The Best🙌
bahut jabardast information guruji nice👍👍👍👍👍
Bihar me optional ko mcq based Kar diya gaya hai. This is a good step.
Mt htaoo ... Govt. Na sune aapki ye bat bhgwn kre... optional subject hona hi chiye yar
For all science background students:-
Please mail this agr aap optional remove nhi krana chahte ho to :-
Dear Sir,
I am writing to express my concern regarding the proposals to remove optional subjects in the HPSC(HCS) examination.
General Studies already requires significant effort from SCIENCE BACKGROUND STUDENTS, as it primarily benefits humanities students. Humanities students can select subjects that align with their academic background, while science students must study General Studies in addition to their specialized subjects.
Eliminating optional subjects places science students at a disadvantage by removing the opportunity to excel in their strongest subjects. The optional subject system ensures fairness by allowing students to demonstrate their strengths. If science students are expected to study humanities subjects for better scores, it is only fair for humanities students to consider studying science subjects.
I urge you to reconsider this decision to ensure a balanced and fair examination process. Otherwise, it may become UNFAIR FOR SCIENCE STUDENTS, potentially hindering their ability to qualify if there are no optional subjects.
Thank you for your understanding.
Sincerely
Your name
Optional must be removed, but strong campaign is needed, what effective steps you will take? Except making videos which increases your popularity, business, profit only
Optional shouldn't be removed 😕😞
You are doing next level campaigns for optional removal.....others optional k paper halwa hota ya bina padh kar sab select hote h..........better ye hona chaye cutoff bataye hpsc prelims ki......representation ki fees minimum ki jaye......come with positive reforms............
Notification kab tak aayega or minimum age kya hoti h sir...?
Ethics add hona chahiye optional ko remove kr k
Optional should be removed 💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯❤️🔥💯❤️🔥💯❤️🔥💯❤️🔥💯❤️🔥💯❤️🔥💯❤️🔥💯💯❤️🔥💯❤️🔥❤️🔥💯❤️🔥💯💯❤️🔥💯❤️🔥💯❤️🔥💯❤️🔥💯💯❤️🔥💯💯❤️🔥💯❤️🔥💯❤️🔥💯💯❤️🔥💯❤️🔥💯❤️🔥💯❤️🔥💯💯❤️🔥
Optional should be remove
Not be removed🎉🎉🎉
Hlo sir ..sir mainy last year hcs ka exam dia tha but nhi ho paya pre ..is saal bhi preparation kr rhi hu ..sir meri beti choti h ..mujy advice dijiye m kis tarike s apni study kru ..mujy job bhut jaruri h ..plzz sir guide me
Optional remove nhi hona chahiye
Removing optional is not good option.
hi skta h kya hota h ,agar sure ho to hi aisi information Deni chahiye isse students ki optional ki tayari pr impact padta h
Dekhiye preparation me we have to strategize for both sure and unsure things , jo information h wo correct h , ab jske hisab se you have to plan your preparation, take decision how much time to give for optional ,balancing both outcome if it's removed and even if it is not removed, I hope this helps in giving some clarity .
yes , plz we are in support
Optional nhi remove hona chaiye yr plss sir tk ye bat phunchao nhi remove hona chaie
Group B walo ka bhi departmental paper hona chahiye
Includes Haryana Special in place of Optional
Optional to be removed at any cost so that everyone gets equal opportunity
Please do not get the optional removed, it will reduce diversity in services
Plz remove optional
Ab hoga level playing field
Optional should not be removed and Haryana Gk paper must be introduced.
But marks distribution must be rational.
No need to remove optional
Remove optional. Bring justice.
Optional should be removed as soon as possible.
Great sir we are with you
Why didn't u join hcs sir
Sir hcs officer sa jada kama rha h 😂that's why
Optional must be removed to bring parity
Good achievement sir. It's because of your hard work.
Sir if optional remove ho jata hai to kya alg paper add hoga ?
For level playing field optional removal is necessary......
Sir final year student KO bhi apply krne ki eligibility honi chahiye kyoki phir eske bad Hume 2,3 sal tk rukna PD Santa hai .
Please eske bare mai bhi bat kare
Sir online form fill kiya hai, ragistration nh kiya kunki online hona chahiye
optional nhi htna chahiye sir ...........
Optional ko remove kar k haryana gs k do paper introduce kar diye jaane chahiye
Sch sch batana jabse tumne coaching institute open Kiya h . Aaj Tak ek bhi selection hua h kya tumhare class se 😂😂
bpdaba , bhai ek to ni hua sach bataun to usse jada hi hue h ,is bar ki list me check kar lo , bharti , satish , rohit kumar , shabnam , kavita , ye kuch naam h jo abhi yaad aaye ,. baki list available h videos me bhi , agar dekhayi aur sunai deta h to plz search and see on youtube , kyunki dimag to mujhe lag ni raha ki kam karta h :) just kidding .take care
Removing optional is an irreparable damage and a mistake
Don't remove optional subject
Sir ....ek test series leke aye jiske sath mentorship bi ho plz
Ok Poonam We Will Work On It
Optional.should be remobed
Haa bol to aise rhe ho jaise ki aapne bol diya or HPSC ne maan hi liya ho😂
Sahi pakde h 😀 Process start ho chuka h raghav hpsc ki taraf se , agar lucky rahe to ho bhi jayega , sarkar serious h , baki agar aapko samajh aya ho ki hum kya kehna chahte h to plz like the comment , agar ni aya to feel free to comment 😀
Sir. Aapke app pe nya batch higa start? Jb notification ayegi
And pre and mains exam kb tk hine ki umeed h
Nishu, kindly reach us @ 9996337109
Yes optional must be removed.
It should not be removed
Hatna chahiye optional
Sir mujhe aapse baat karni thi please sir
Sir kitne attempt total de skta hai general category se??
There are no limit for attempts in HCS, You can fill the form on every notification.
Kyon hataaye optional....hr ek ki apni hard working
Bilkul..ab agr hum dusre tarike se dekhein to science walo k sath na insaafi hai ab...kyunki gs mein sare subjects to arts k the hi already..sirf optional hi unka apna hota hai...
Optional hatna chaiya
Ab kya update hai sir
To optional ke liye padhe ya nhi
OPTIONAL Should be removed
समाजशास्त्र hcs mains ❤❤
Remove hcs optional 👍👍👍👍
everyone has to be atleast one strong subject.
Agar optional hataa to Haryana gk ka peper leke aao
New exam pattern kya hoga ab if optional remove ho gya to
I am qualified Chartered Accountant but not graduate. Am I eligible for HCS exam? Please let me know.
Yar CA acha khasa kamate h..easily 10 lakh se above kama lete h ..toh kya baki reh gya jo hcs mei aana h
@@devendragupta5831 Agree. But govt. job ki baat hi kuch aur h job security, perks, respect…. aur apne state ke liye kuch krna h.
Marks kab declare kiye?
It shouldn’t be removed
Great efforts sir
What about 45 percent criteria
Optional remove karo