He's not in the Democratic Party. He's not part of the team of his own choosing. So saying he got pushed aside for party positions that he is not part of....
@@benjaminclegg7109 Funny how there's way more people still supporting Bernie and nobody talking about Hillary anymore. He did join with dems for his presidential campaign, and they gave him the shaft. Now they're reaping what they sow.
Except those two things aren't related. CU let big money into politics. Residential homes owned by corporations account for a small % of home purchases. The imbalance in the real estate market was caused by zoning laws and under-building after 2008.
This is also a capitalist society so tell us how would you stop corporations from buying property?? I can see the Government getting sued over and over again!
Obama was Savage attacking Bernie in 2016 to destroy his Campaign.. then put in Clinton that lost to Trump. Obama also picked Garland for supreme court, failed and then Biden puts Garland as AG. Garland does nothing to prosecute the criminal and both Obama and Biden let him do just nothing. Country should have been protected from a criminal but both Biden and Obama failed us. They are only strong on destroying Populist Campaigns like Bernie sanders. Then they have no fear to strike to ashes.
@luxboss2388 Stop lying! Btw you LOST in 2020 so don't act like you've been winning all along AND Republicans lost all over the country in 2018,2019,2020, 2021, 2022 and 2023rd!!🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 Did you get tired of ALL that winning???😆😆😆😆
@@chashue6032Clinton was the one who created NAFTA, normalized trade relations with China, outsourced all the good blue collar jobs overseas. Obama and Hilary wanted to take it a step further by doing the TPP. Please entertain me. Tell me how the Dems have been standing up for the working class??
Yes, he is right and we need to get money out of politics. The billionaires keep buying up media outlets and finance both parties at this point. We need real reforms now, no more identity politics or other distractions to protect the rich. We need real reforms.
@captainnutsack8151 I am not against successful people. Without successful hard working individuals we'd be living in the stone age still. Don't misrepresent me like that please.
No. Biden supported unions and allot of other things that benefits workers. The problem is that the working class doesn't care about policies that help them economically. They just want culture wars that makes them flee better. Can Democrats do better? Yes of course. But not without having a 2/3 majority in the house and senate. Biden did as good as he could consider all the Republicans trying to stop him.
Bernie is absolutely correct. He consistently polled better against Trump than Hillary in 2016, but the Democrats ignored him and it cost them an election. I voted for Harris in spite of the fact her speeches left me quite underwhelmed. They were way too vague and concentrated on Trump way too much. She just wasn’t terribly appealing to me.
The Democrats DID NOT ignore Bernie, they deliberately sabotaged and subterfuged his campaigns in 2016 and 2020. DNC == Despicable Neoliberal Criminals.
remember: Bernie is not in the Democratic Party. Hard to kick someone to the curb who is not even wanting to be part of the team in first place. He'd be more effective pushing for change in the party by being on the team.
@@namegoeshere1 You don't know how primaries work. People RUN for office in the primary based on the amount of signatures they can get to be on the ballot in each states primary. The party doesn't select them and make them run. Seriously are you a child? Learn how the system works before you criticise it.
@@namegoeshere1 Yeah, and even then the primary was the most competitive, with a siting President, in the last 30 years. If the voters had an issue with Biden, there were opportunities to sound the alarm bells, but they never came.
He's absolutely right and we've been saying this for years. Noone is listening to the voters... the middle class... at all. Maybe we need to band together and create our own 3rd party...
We have multiple other parties and none of them are getting real votes. So no, thats not it. We need to replace the nuts in the DNC and start over. We might not win in 2028 either, cuz it will take years to rebuild and do everything right. But maybe we can save our nation in 2032. Thats assuming Donald doesnt wreck democracy over the next 4 years and I'm pretty sure he will.
The middle class have the money to own McMansions, drive 80,000$ pickups with Maga flags, and buy 100 guns. They hate progressive activists telling em their just like them cause they still work minimum wage after 40.
LOL! No one is listening, but you blame the Democrats and vote for Republicans who haven't supported a single working class policy in over 40 years. Do you see the stupidity in that? How does voting for Republicans solve that issue, even if you believe Democrats have abandoned the working class?
Of course they are and have been. Weve been screaming for help for years and told to shut and like it. The blue party has turned so many of us independent. Somewhere along the line they forgot they are serving the people not political messaging and power grabs.
nice they finally admitted Sanders was right.... when he's too old and going to retire. This will probably be his last term. Not that we should hitch all out hopes on one guy. Sanders is human, not superman. But who among the Dems has the fortitude to not cave to the billionaires?
The left doesn't want to admit it, but they are the greed. Using multi millionare celebrities to try and relate to the American middle class. In league with most corporate ceos, and clearly their side lives in pampered lifestyles concerning their ignorance of the economy. The hypocrisy is outstanding
They're perfectly 'in touch' with who cashes their cheques and funds their galas. There is no reform for the Dem party, as long as they simp for billionaire interests.
Just exposes what her class thinks about the rest of us. It's all about Guns Gays and... ya whatever. It was about a whole lot of fear and anger and frustration that got capitalized on by someone.
@GMCTIM God that is tired old cliche. Where exactly did they go? Please enlighten me how trump and maga are going to better address the need s of the American people than the Dems. Dems have a lot to answer for but compared to the pukes and trump they are 1,000% better.
Bernies right. Stop trying to make deadbeat college activists the main core of your party. Most reliable voters are adults 30 and older. Not naive youths 2yrs out from high school.
I’m not sure if they abandoned the working class or just forgot how to talk to them? Telling people how uneducated they are shouldn’t be the way they choose to communicate with people.
😂😂 you have to ask this then you don't know facts look up everything she did in her past lol and they kicked joe when he had a old brain but these people said he was fine
Good luck with that. Are you young? BOTH parties must be PRO-israel! It's a prerequisite for getting into the White House. israel in nothing more than WHITE IMPERIALISM in a slightly different shade. It is a strategic military outpost of white america that allows them to be closer in order to keep tabs on ALL "arab" nations in that region. Nothing can stop israel except stop funding them, which will NEVER happen, or Putin and China teaming up to demanding the people boot out netanyahoo, to start healing and compromising.
He is right! Not only that they also need to acknowledge that there are 50 states and not just 7 swing states. Yes, I understand that those states are important to win the election because of the electoral college but when a party decides to ignore the Midwest which is considered the flyover section of the country no one has to wonder too hard why the middle of the country is red. I’m in a flyover state and Missouri used to be democratic. Hasn’t been since Claire McCaskil lost to Hawley and he is the same ilk of Trump and not only that state reps and local reps are not democratic as well. So I hope the democrats really mean that they are wanting everyone to come to the table, we’ll see.
When you have a good amount of voters searching what a tariff is after the election or digging deeper into the policy of their candidate, you need to look at the voters. Americans chose not to be informed, they chose hate against their neighbors, they chose the promise of lower gas prices and eggs even if racism is rampant or women’s rights were the price. The finger needs to be pointed in one direction and it’s us.
Of course hes right. Nancy has been about money her whole time. Hes been fairly right for some time now. Nancy is mad cause shes exactly the problem. Look how rich she is, has hundreds of millions
Well, almost everyone in the RNC is about money but somehow they won two elections with a real monster. Think about that. Maybe being all about money is the key to success. You can afford better propaganda.
Carter was Rethuglican light. Clinton was a more obviously lethal brew of Reaganism and corporatism, Obomber the consummate snake oil salesman and militarist, and Biden the demented liar and murderer true to his corporatized rotting mind (like his predecessors); Hillary and Kamala the anointed sacrificial women to play out the endless and end-times deceit of the Democratic Party, the most inauthentic "opposition."
Bernie saying that the Biden administration “was the most progressive” in modern American history isnt a compliment, it’s a bare minimum low bar… Don’t misunderstand him. Biden should’ve and could’ve done way more. Thus the criticism still holds for the party as a whole.
First of all, Biden is still president and he has a couple of months to fast track some things… secondly, three of the four markers of a healthy economy have been accomplished during his term (the only thing they weren’t able to really tackle was interest rates) - Im trying to figure out what more could you want?
Yeah it's not to say he's good for working people as much as it is an indictment of every candidate that came before him somehow being even worse. If FDR is 100, every candidate between him and Biden gets a 0, with Biden scoring a 10. Statement is still true, best for working class people since FDR, but it's not a compliment. He was literally a Reagan Democrat who personally helped Reagan destroy unions, not sure what anyone was expecting.
Bernie must have hung around Biden a bit too long to make such a claim (as in, he got a temporary - I hope - case of senility). Biden is the consummate corporatist, racist, and militarist, and now, genocidal war criminal.
lol yeah, it’s definitely the donors fault It can’t be the fact that everyone on the left has completely lost their minds, and most of Americans see that. Which is why Trump won the popular vote
I'd personally say they are more bound by the fed alphabet agencies agenda than the CEO of burger king. Money is nothing to them, they literally own the printers the that make the money. There is a line out the door of billionaires throwing cash at them, they don't need to kneel to a few donors whims. I think its a lot deeper then just money. I don't think they blink a eye when Elon (richest man in the world) starts giving exclusively to the right. Doesn't seem to worry them in the slightest. Controlling fed agencies that can lock Elon up on a whim or sue him into oblivion is far more powerful than a few donations.
And follow the $$$, the Democrats have foreign donors who have an interest in America failing. If the Dems ever want relevance in the country again they need to abandon Hollywood, Woke ideologies, and Foreign interests. Focus on US citizens not illegals. Even then, I'm skeptical to ever vote for them again.
As a Republican latino, we aren’t scared of Kamala and Biden and Obama. They’ve lost touch. We are scared of Bernie. I don’t agree with him on pretty much anything, but dude is the real deal. He an old-school liberal, not about the flash and dance and identity politics but about helping the common man.
That isn’t gonna change anything if the Democrats don’t change themselves all the Trump supporters see is the Democrats being hypocrites and just trying to tear their candidate down. They need to actually change back to the party of FDR. A lot of the Trump supporters were former Democrats.
They dont want to be sued for creating false narratives that have no factual evidence now that they wont be protected under Harris. In other words they are fear mongering cowards and so are you if you believe this nonsense. The people have overwhelmingly spoken 🇺🇸. Sit the next few rounds out and watch how a country is supposed to be run.
I have left the Democratic Party. I will not join the GOP. I am looking for a home. We need a 3rd party. There are millions of us waiting to join a party that represent the people not the Billionaire donor class.
I’m registered as unenrolled in my state. I can vote for whoever I choose. Parties are a problem in my opinion. Senators and Congressmen should be working for the people, not a party.
@@vibesmom They are all working for their own financial benefit. Most of the Congress men and women go in and when thy come out they are millionaires with prospect of high paying lobbying jobs post service in Congress.
I have great admiration for Bernie however, the dems have been good for the union I retired from. I think the Republicans were just good at lying about what the real problem are.
Middle class? What middle class? Nations in Europe such as France, Germany, Sweden, Norway the income tax is very high - yet the population, for the most part, is not complaining; the systems are not perfect. Why? Because those countries give back to the population is services. Here in the U.S. taxpayers pay pay and pay and receive substantially less than what is being paid. furthermore, here in the States people enter politics for power and money. Very few politicians give a rat's rear about the people they are supposed to represent. When someone wins an election in any capacity from the Hamlet, City, County, State, Federal, President - they usually leave quite well off, so they have no clue what the average Joe is doing or caring what he is doing financially, medically, etc. For a nation that is smoke and mirrors, it should not declare itself as being Democratic. It is not, its every politician for themselves. I had in the past great respect and regard for the Supreme Court - NO MORE!
It should have always been Bernie. Most people in this country are just too far gone. Both democrats and republicans for that matter. These people get caught up in the ridiculous party wars instead of looking at the bigger picture on what's actually best for our country.
It was all lies crazy they should be locked up the people on news if not facts you need to do a we are sorry we got it wrong Stat being news again look who pays these people
😂😂 so party has all the power because the people vote soooo shut up stop the Democrat lie machine George soros paid for all left news they all say the same crap
Good sense is way better than common sense. Republican voters have "common" sense and look what it got them. Democrats have neither so it doesnt matter.
@@daydoe40s Well, you don't know AwkwardTruths is a MAGAT based on that one post. He could have been a non-voter or could have voted Democrat this time but became disillusioned after the election. Like me. Unless the dems make MASSIVE changes in the next 4 years I have no plans to ever vote for them again.
@@SafetySpooon She literally said Orange man bad, and Abortion that's it! She never separated herself from current administration in which working class people of all races are not doing good economically.
They do not ignore them, they cater to them with platitudes, which somehow is 'more' than Democrats are willing to muster through gritted teeth and contempt for the working class. Trump lied about the cause of the issues, and Trump lied about even being willing to do anything about it. But he at least was willing to say something to it. Meanwhile Democrats campaigned on 'everything is doing great'.
Bernie should have been our 2020 president. It was the reason I went from Independent to Democrat. I wanted to vote for his nomination but obviously that never happened.
For that you can thank the Clinton cabal, Debbie Wassermann Schultz, Jaime Harrison, Nancy Pillosi [sic], and the entire consortium of deceit in the dismally derelict democratic dumpster fire.
Working families/ working citizens party is that third party !!! Small steps to better align the dems and WF/WC would be radical and maybe it’s welcomed at this point! 😊
Bernie pill!!! Finally!!! The amount of media coverage that Bernie is getting makes me optimistic where the attention is finally moving to tackle the right cause!!! The progressive movement is coming Strong!!!
If Bernie's the only reference anyone can make to 'progressive,' we in deep dung and doo. He sold out to the DNC, he sold out to Biden, and he betrayed his supporters by caving in to the criminals in his own party.
Absolutely Sanders would've defeated Trump in 2016. He would've pulled the white workers who twice voted for Obama but wanted some kind of shake-up so they voted for Trump. The DNC hacks used their super-delegates to thwart the will of the people and are responsible for Trump and the 1000 of kids who have still not been reconnected with their families. Hooray for Sanders speaking out, albeit way too late. But unless he uses his bully pulpit to call for a break from the 2-party system + help usher in an independent political party based on the foundation of organized labor, he is merely serving as the jester in the king's court.
I’m impressed MSNBC (a large conglomerate) is at least discussing the issue Bernie Sanders calls out. They need to do a better job, but I’ll take what I can get.
The point here is ... Most of us DON'T CARE!!! We wish you well, but there are far more important issues in our lives - get over yourselves. You were all so busy vilifying J.K.Rowling and making us all be "supportive" of you - now we all live under the Xian Taliban. Let's see how real it starts getting for you !!!
MSNBC News knows the answer is YES. Imagine Obama begging for a few bucks, every other commercial? Not talking about WORKING CLASS ISSUES, (just money).
Clinton, Obama, Biden sowed the seeds of Trumpian dystopia. They are all contributors to the cult of deceit and treachery, corporatism and perpetual warfare, formerly known as the Democratic Party.
Even as a faithful Trump voter through and through. I've always liked Bernie. I may not agree on his stances, but his heart is absolutely in the right place. And not just because he said this.
I appreciate Sanders' devotion to getting progressive policies passed, but I also feel he's always had a HUGE blind spot for the role of political/cultural identity in election races. Sanders and Biden are old friends and Sanders had a significant seat at the table when Biden's term began. Biden's policy was as progressive as you could expect with Manchin and Sinema making the final call on what got through the senate. It may not have been perfect, but it was still vastly preferable to Trump, who was joking to his billionaire buddy Musk about just getting rid of striking workers. It should have made a bigger difference than it did. This wasn't the working class taking a long hard and detached look at both candidates and picking the option that held the most economic benefit for them. The working class are just as vulnerable to demagoguery as their fellow citizens.
Clinton was a Moderate. He signed Welfare Reform, Security modernization Act, Defense of Marriage, Crime Bill, “don’t asked don’t tell” and bunch of right wing leaning legislation. Obama never signed anything that,wasn’t left wing.
If we had real Democracy, then Ralph Nader would have been US President long back and America would not be in such deep ditch today killing people everywhere on this planet. We need people like Ralph Nader in politics who think about public good.
Thank you for this comment. The Democrats (Gore, et al.) caved in to the Supremely Corrupt Court at the behest of the Bush Bros. criminal syndicate in 2000. Nader -- one of the greatest Americans of my lifetime -- was then pilloried and scapegoated for the massive cowardice and capitulation of the Democrats. Subsequent analyses have long since demonstrated no relationship between Gore's loss and Nader's candidacy, but Democratic shills -- who aren't worthy of feeding from the dung pile in a zoo -- continue to blaspheme Nader. Of course, they circled the wagons around pretty boy Wet Willie, whose side-kick and protegé turned out to be nothing more than a poorly designed hot-air balloon.
There's dark money in BOTH camps. As long as they cater to the elite and behave as such and talk down to the average worker, they will continue to lose traction
@Taino505 Bernie did an internship with George Washington (sarcasm). He shut his mouth for 4 years and campaigned hard for Biden and Harris while they were complicit of mass murder. I understand he did it to keep the little power he had, but now he comes out huffing and puffing.
you guys, you guys, you guys, you guys, you guys, you guys, you guys, you guys, you guys, … Basic elementary school grammar teaches that the pronoun ‘you’ can be used for both singular and plural. There is no reason to exclude girls, women and people who identify as female from the conversation.
@ firstly, you didn’t answer my question. Secondly, i’m not sure who made you the grammar police. Thirdly, “YOU GUYS” can be used to refer to or address two or more people.
@@Bigchangues- exactly, and with such a massive umbrella, different issues are going to resonate with different audiences. It’s difficult to find a unified and unifying message in that… Obama found it with ACA, consumer protection legislation, and education- and then Biden/Harris elevated that last one with student loan forgiveness
No he is not. There are over 10 million jobs OPEN. Farmers who need workers to pick their fields HAVE TO advertise the openings for Americans FIRST at the same salary they end up paying Visa immigrants they have to get because AMERICANS refuse to take the jobs, same happens with hotel jobs. Also, there are always job openings in the military. Democrats got the ACA passed and have pushed for higher minimum wages, have fought to feed poor children etc. Biden literally helped the unions and their pensions. Also Consumers made the rich richer they need to wrap there head around that fact. No one voted for trump because of the price of eggs, they voted for him because of their own self hate, and petty jealousy. No politicians controls prices, consumers do. Keep buying at the higher prices the prices will go higher.
Yeah but the Dems didn’t market that. They didn’t market a working class agenda going into 2025. It’s also true that this election was very anti-incumbent. The only country to have their party stay the same post CoVid so far is Mexico, because AMLO was basically Mexico’s Bernie Sanders
Your realize about 50% of those 10 million jobs are fake right? Anti union areas are the biggest winner of build back better and IRA…. Ended the train strike, homelessness and poverty still rampant. Technically I believe Trump dropped childhood poverty more with the covid money, I think the R blocked extending this but Dems aren’t getting that message out. He did nothing significant to protect our democracy, continued to spend billions supporting a genocide of a man who was trying to make him lose.
Finally someone else willing to speak the truth. The poor are always poor no matter the president. But this time the poor and uneducated did what they often do, vote for perceived self interests instead of actual self interests. But we have to stop ignoring their perceptions no matter how silly we think they are.
They ignored Bernie in 2016 and pushed him aside. This is a reason Americans are tired of establishment politics. He’s right.
He's not in the Democratic Party. He's not part of the team of his own choosing. So saying he got pushed aside for party positions that he is not part of....
Bernie would have gotten killed in this election with his everyone should get everything agenda. Kidding me????
Wish Bernie was on the ballot since he’s an independent.
@@benjaminclegg7109 Funny how there's way more people still supporting Bernie and nobody talking about Hillary anymore. He did join with dems for his presidential campaign, and they gave him the shaft. Now they're reaping what they sow.
They didn't push him aside, they offered him a 3rd vacation home on Lake Champlain and some rides on Air Force One and he sold out.
Reverse Citizens United! Do something about investors buying single family homes and the rise of rents across the country.
Since the start of Airbnb the rental market and home ownership has suffered ! If Americans would STOP using Airbnb it might reverse itself !
YES, This!! They are swooping in with cash offers squeezing out the working man! Where are the laws protecting citizens?
Blackrock should not be able partner with the Federal Reserve and use their money to compete with American home buyers. No bank should!
Except those two things aren't related. CU let big money into politics. Residential homes owned by corporations account for a small % of home purchases. The imbalance in the real estate market was caused by zoning laws and under-building after 2008.
This is also a capitalist society so tell us how would you stop corporations from buying property?? I can see the Government getting sued over and over again!
YES! YES! YES! Of COURSE BERNIE is RIGHT! From , a Public School Teacher who lives paycheck to paycheck
Bye bye Dept of Education -project 2025
@@GG-kt2uk GOOD
you make entirely too much money. And your health plans should be downgraded to what private workers get.
@captainnutsack8151 nut sack is correct. 👍
Obama was Savage attacking Bernie in 2016 to destroy his Campaign.. then put in Clinton that lost to Trump. Obama also picked Garland for supreme court, failed and then Biden puts Garland as AG. Garland does nothing to prosecute the criminal and both Obama and Biden let him do just nothing.
Country should have been protected from a criminal but both Biden and Obama failed us. They are only strong on destroying Populist Campaigns like Bernie sanders. Then they have no fear to strike to ashes.
Bernie is 10000% correct
Why doesn't he win??
@@kevinjackson2314 Because the Big Money goons torpedoed his campaign. They're terrified of Bernie.
@@kevinjackson2314 your establishment won’t let him that’s why just like 2016 and we love it 😂
@luxboss2388 Stop lying! Btw you LOST in 2020 so don't act like you've been winning all along AND Republicans lost all over the country in 2018,2019,2020, 2021, 2022 and 2023rd!!🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Did you get tired of ALL that winning???😆😆😆😆
@@kevinjackson2314 Dems brag how they rigged 2016 primary, so Bernie wouldn't win.
YES, He’s right. Is this even a debate?
It’s a fact, I respect his honesty
Total nonsense, if anything the working class abandoned the Dem Party, going back to Reagan. The working class is still paying for that.
@@chashue6032Clinton was the one who created NAFTA, normalized trade relations with China, outsourced all the good blue collar jobs overseas. Obama and Hilary wanted to take it a step further by doing the TPP. Please entertain me. Tell me how the Dems have been standing up for the working class??
@@chashue6032You can't be serious?🤦🏿♂️
@@chashue6032 lol nice satire!
Yes, he is right and we need to get money out of politics. The billionaires keep buying up media outlets and finance both parties at this point. We need real reforms now, no more identity politics or other distractions to protect the rich. We need real reforms.
100%.
billionaires!!! successful people!! REEEEEEEEE
@captainnutsack8151 I am not against successful people. Without successful hard working individuals we'd be living in the stone age still. Don't misrepresent me like that please.
Easy said, impossible to do, now that will have a one party dictatorship !
Bernie is right
No. Biden supported unions and allot of other things that benefits workers. The problem is that the working class doesn't care about policies that help them economically. They just want culture wars that makes them flee better. Can Democrats do better? Yes of course. But not without having a 2/3 majority in the house and senate. Biden did as good as he could consider all the Republicans trying to stop him.
He’s not. White supremacy won the day. The disinformation and propaganda won the day.
Was wrong to butt into the 2016 election, costing HRC the win.
Quiet part out loud: Many in the Democratic Party establishment would rather see a Trump win than build an economy that works for working people.
Dumb.
There's truth to this
@@Celestial_Reach “no” truth there i fixed your comment.
@@billythekid916Fox??
@@kevinjackson2314 “facts”
Bernie is absolutely correct. He consistently polled better against Trump than Hillary in 2016, but the Democrats ignored him and it cost them an election. I voted for Harris in spite of the fact her speeches left me quite underwhelmed. They were way too vague and concentrated on Trump way too much. She just wasn’t terribly appealing to me.
He was the perfect Man for the job .. but America is all about lower self ..
The Democrats DID NOT ignore Bernie, they deliberately sabotaged and subterfuged his campaigns in 2016 and 2020. DNC == Despicable Neoliberal Criminals.
Kicked Bernie to the curb, then didn't have open primaries. Clown show.
I mean, they did though. And the Dem voters chose Biden
@@GTA5Player1it was not an competitive primary. Trump ran a competitive primary, Biden only had dean phillips or whatever his name is.
remember: Bernie is not in the Democratic Party. Hard to kick someone to the curb who is not even wanting to be part of the team in first place. He'd be more effective pushing for change in the party by being on the team.
@@namegoeshere1 You don't know how primaries work. People RUN for office in the primary based on the amount of signatures they can get to be on the ballot in each states primary. The party doesn't select them and make them run. Seriously are you a child? Learn how the system works before you criticise it.
@@namegoeshere1 Yeah, and even then the primary was the most competitive, with a siting President, in the last 30 years. If the voters had an issue with Biden, there were opportunities to sound the alarm bells, but they never came.
He's absolutely right and we've been saying this for years. Noone is listening to the voters... the middle class... at all. Maybe we need to band together and create our own 3rd party...
Hahaha and you still haven't figured it out. MSDNC and the elites run the party. Over 1 billion spent. Where do you think the money came from.
We have multiple other parties and none of them are getting real votes. So no, thats not it. We need to replace the nuts in the DNC and start over. We might not win in 2028 either, cuz it will take years to rebuild and do everything right. But maybe we can save our nation in 2032. Thats assuming Donald doesnt wreck democracy over the next 4 years and I'm pretty sure he will.
The middle class have the money to own McMansions, drive 80,000$ pickups with Maga flags, and buy 100 guns.
They hate progressive activists telling em their just like them cause they still work minimum wage after 40.
LOL! No one is listening, but you blame the Democrats and vote for Republicans who haven't supported a single working class policy in over 40 years. Do you see the stupidity in that? How does voting for Republicans solve that issue, even if you believe Democrats have abandoned the working class?
He is wrong it wasn’t about working people it was about white people becoming the minority
Of course they are and have been. Weve been screaming for help for years and told to shut and like it. The blue party has turned so many of us independent. Somewhere along the line they forgot they are serving the people not political messaging and power grabs.
nice they finally admitted Sanders was right.... when he's too old and going to retire. This will probably be his last term.
Not that we should hitch all out hopes on one guy. Sanders is human, not superman.
But who among the Dems has the fortitude to not cave to the billionaires?
Bernie is training people to take up his mantle - I’m not too worried… Hopefully he’ll start installing them in high positions during his last term
What Americans love billionaires.
In case you missed it.
But who among the MAGA has the fortitude to not cave to the evil despotic tyrant ?
The left doesn't want to admit it, but they are the greed. Using multi millionare celebrities to try and relate to the American middle class. In league with most corporate ceos, and clearly their side lives in pampered lifestyles concerning their ignorance of the economy. The hypocrisy is outstanding
@@booley Bernie needs to go home and get his pacifier! He is lost in the sauce!
Americans can always be trusted to do the right thing, once all other possibilities have been exhausted.” - Winston Churchill
Churchhill had no idea we would elect Americas Hitler
Our last possibility is the collapse of earths greatest nation. And we won't recover from it.
Facts!!!! Winston is correct
@@nishashawn2021yeah, that’s why the U.S. had to save Britain and still does.
You can always count on a Brit to deflect with that idiotic and deceitful quote. You can also count on the Brits to blame others.
They are so out of touch it's sick. And the real dagger is they do not care.
They're perfectly 'in touch' with who cashes their cheques and funds their galas. There is no reform for the Dem party, as long as they simp for billionaire interests.
Nancy talking about the working class is laughable 😂
How many millions does she have?
I K R ...
Just exposes what her class thinks about the rest of us. It's all about Guns Gays and... ya whatever. It was about a whole lot of fear and anger and frustration that got capitalized on by someone.
Obama : "They like their guns and bibles"
Pelosi " Hold my wine glass and medications"
Bernie sounds like Trump selling sneakers and Bibles! He says he sam eging every time they lose! He makes absolutely no sense!
Sen. Sanders message has not changed much, he has always been a champion of the working class... Neither party listened or are listening.
Bernie has a sharper mindset and work ethic than Biden and trump
PPL DIDNT LEAVE DEMOCRATS, DEMOCRATS LEFT THE PPL ! BERNIES 100% ON TARGET !
@GMCTIM God that is tired old cliche. Where exactly did they go? Please enlighten me how trump and maga are going to better address the need s of the American people than the Dems. Dems have a lot to answer for but compared to the pukes and trump they are 1,000% better.
And Republicans won your vote despite hate , racism, and lies. Great job getting the people Republicans smh
Bernies right.
Stop trying to make deadbeat college activists the main core of your party.
Most reliable voters are adults 30 and older.
Not naive youths 2yrs out from high school.
I’m not sure if they abandoned the working class or just forgot how to talk to them? Telling people how uneducated they are shouldn’t be the way they choose to communicate with people.
They forgot the working class exists.
They abandoned them. They do not fight for working class at all.
That's because you can't reason with "deplorables." /s
He’s absolutely right
why didn't we have these discussions before elections?
We skipped it. That’s what the primary is for.
Because the centrists and moderates control the party.
😂😂 you have to ask this then you don't know facts look up everything she did in her past lol and they kicked joe when he had a old brain but these people said he was fine
@@artgarde.gardelandscapingl5585 The irony of your word salad is paramount.
The working class has been screaming for 4 years. The democrats were more concerned about giving free stuff out and fruity lifestyle bull.
💰 it's the distribution of wealth, Nancy. She's a disappointment.
YES, He is. When you abandon the majority of people that vote for you, you can't act surprised when they abandon you.
I will vote Dems if they create a party of economic populism and who isn’t beholden to Israel.
Exactly
Both parties are beholden to Israel but one has better propaganda.
Good luck with that. Are you young? BOTH parties must be PRO-israel! It's a prerequisite for getting into the White House. israel in nothing more than WHITE IMPERIALISM in a slightly different shade. It is a strategic military outpost of white america that allows them to be closer in order to keep tabs on ALL "arab" nations in that region. Nothing can stop israel except stop funding them, which will NEVER happen, or Putin and China teaming up to demanding the people boot out netanyahoo, to start healing and compromising.
But most American's if you travel around, do support Israel.
Most don't want involvement with the Middle East.
So Bernie said listen to them.
I hope I am never in the same party as a maroon who thinks Israel is even the problem over there, much less THIS BIG an issue for American voters.
He is right! Not only that they also need to acknowledge that there are 50 states and not just 7 swing states. Yes, I understand that those states are important to win the election because of the electoral college but when a party decides to ignore the Midwest which is considered the flyover section of the country no one has to wonder too hard why the middle of the country is red. I’m in a flyover state and Missouri used to be democratic. Hasn’t been since Claire McCaskil lost to Hawley and he is the same ilk of Trump and not only that state reps and local reps are not democratic as well. So I hope the democrats really mean that they are wanting everyone to come to the table, we’ll see.
I voted for Kamala. I said from the beginning she needed to focus on working class
To much twerking.
Less abortion, more economic populism
Populism? Like what started N azism ?
@@nmarie822 Or the New Deal
@@nmarie822thats rightwing populism. Left wing populism got us civil rights
Thank you for this messaging. A big part of MSNBC is getting it SO wrong.
One of the few Senators not owned by AIPAC.
He is not just right he is ABSOLUTELY right!!! Period. And they continue(dems) to not learn and they keep returning to the same stories
When you have a good amount of voters searching what a tariff is after the election or digging deeper into the policy of their candidate, you need to look at the voters. Americans chose not to be informed, they chose hate against their neighbors, they chose the promise of lower gas prices and eggs even if racism is rampant or women’s rights were the price. The finger needs to be pointed in one direction and it’s us.
Why could we not get through to voters how dangerous despotic tyrant really is ??
and government chose to defund schools and keep them in school as little as possible.
What you are missing is how badly the democrats have let down the people they expected to vote for them.
He's right. He has been right about the Democrats his whole professional life.
Also, if you look at this comment section, bernie is obviously on point
LOL. That's like saying that because Donald trump won the popular vote, he's right, too.
Of course hes right. Nancy has been about money her whole time. Hes been fairly right for some time now. Nancy is mad cause shes exactly the problem. Look how rich she is, has hundreds of millions
Well, almost everyone in the RNC is about money but somehow they won two elections with a real monster.
Think about that.
Maybe being all about money is the key to success. You can afford better propaganda.
Boy, this was spot on! Why didn't she talk about helping the working class? I felt like she became "Republican light" as the campaign went along.
Carter was Rethuglican light. Clinton was a more obviously lethal brew of Reaganism and corporatism, Obomber the consummate snake oil salesman and militarist, and Biden the demented liar and murderer true to his corporatized rotting mind (like his predecessors); Hillary and Kamala the anointed sacrificial women to play out the endless and end-times deceit of the Democratic Party, the most inauthentic "opposition."
This young man actually gets it.
Bernie saying that the Biden administration “was the most progressive” in modern American history isnt a compliment, it’s a bare minimum low bar… Don’t misunderstand him. Biden should’ve and could’ve done way more. Thus the criticism still holds for the party as a whole.
First of all, Biden is still president and he has a couple of months to fast track some things… secondly, three of the four markers of a healthy economy have been accomplished during his term (the only thing they weren’t able to really tackle was interest rates) - Im trying to figure out what more could you want?
Yeah it's not to say he's good for working people as much as it is an indictment of every candidate that came before him somehow being even worse. If FDR is 100, every candidate between him and Biden gets a 0, with Biden scoring a 10. Statement is still true, best for working class people since FDR, but it's not a compliment.
He was literally a Reagan Democrat who personally helped Reagan destroy unions, not sure what anyone was expecting.
Bernie must have hung around Biden a bit too long to make such a claim (as in, he got a temporary - I hope - case of senility). Biden is the consummate corporatist, racist, and militarist, and now, genocidal war criminal.
MSNBC think that the working class have simply been misinformed, and haven't been abandoned at all 😂
They did nothing but lie and fear monger for 9 fricken years ! And people still believe them ! Astounding
Bernie Sanders is right!!!
The problem with the Democrats is they're bound by the Donors that contribute to the party, that keeps the leadership rich.
lol yeah, it’s definitely the donors fault
It can’t be the fact that everyone on the left has completely lost their minds, and most of Americans see that.
Which is why Trump won the popular vote
I'd personally say they are more bound by the fed alphabet agencies agenda than the CEO of burger king. Money is nothing to them, they literally own the printers the that make the money. There is a line out the door of billionaires throwing cash at them, they don't need to kneel to a few donors whims. I think its a lot deeper then just money. I don't think they blink a eye when Elon (richest man in the world) starts giving exclusively to the right. Doesn't seem to worry them in the slightest. Controlling fed agencies that can lock Elon up on a whim or sue him into oblivion is far more powerful than a few donations.
And follow the $$$, the Democrats have foreign donors who have an interest in America failing.
If the Dems ever want relevance in the country again they need to abandon Hollywood, Woke ideologies, and Foreign interests. Focus on US citizens not illegals. Even then, I'm skeptical to ever vote for them again.
Bahahahahahahaha!!!!
@@daydoe40s What's funny?
As a Republican latino, we aren’t scared of Kamala and Biden and Obama. They’ve lost touch.
We are scared of Bernie. I don’t agree with him on pretty much anything, but dude is the real deal. He an old-school liberal, not about the flash and dance and identity politics but about helping the common man.
MSNBC and CNN should still call Trump Hitler and should still tell Americans how bad Trump is for America.
That isn’t gonna change anything if the Democrats don’t change themselves all the Trump supporters see is the Democrats being hypocrites and just trying to tear their candidate down. They need to actually change back to the party of FDR. A lot of the Trump supporters were former Democrats.
Yea but they won't. The dollar is still the driving force.
So does Vance
@@melanieearly3450 Vance is no better. Probably worse.
They dont want to be sued for creating false narratives that have no factual evidence now that they wont be protected under Harris. In other words they are fear mongering cowards and so are you if you believe this nonsense. The people have overwhelmingly spoken 🇺🇸. Sit the next few rounds out and watch how a country is supposed to be run.
I have left the Democratic Party. I will not join the GOP. I am looking for a home. We need a 3rd party. There are millions of us waiting to join a party that represent the people not the Billionaire donor class.
I’m registered as unenrolled in my state. I can vote for whoever I choose. Parties are a problem in my opinion. Senators and Congressmen should be working for the people, not a party.
@@vibesmom They are all working for their own financial benefit. Most of the Congress men and women go in and when thy come out they are millionaires with prospect of high paying lobbying jobs post service in Congress.
Thank you, Mister Sanders !
Did the right acknowledge the lower and middle class? Did I miss something????? Tf
Absolutely not. I was born and raised Republican and they couldn’t care less about working people
they did... with fear mongering to drive h8 and get people not thinking critically and therefore voting against their own interests
Always have? I find the difference in the sides where Harris used multi millionare celebrities completely out of touch to draw support
@@StephenBartlett-n3xMy condolences but how can you not see the struggle?
I have great admiration for Bernie however, the dems have been good for the union I retired from. I think the Republicans were just good at lying about what the real problem are.
He's right.
Middle class? What middle class? Nations in Europe such as France, Germany, Sweden, Norway the income tax is very high - yet the population, for the most part, is not complaining; the systems are not perfect. Why? Because those countries give back to the population is services. Here in the U.S. taxpayers pay pay and pay and receive substantially less than what is being paid. furthermore, here in the States people enter politics for power and money. Very few politicians give a rat's rear about the people they are supposed to represent. When someone wins an election in any capacity from the Hamlet, City, County, State, Federal, President - they usually leave quite well off, so they have no clue what the average Joe is doing or caring what he is doing financially, medically, etc. For a nation that is smoke and mirrors, it should not declare itself as being Democratic. It is not, its every politician for themselves. I had in the past great respect and regard for the Supreme Court - NO MORE!
Thank you, Malaika, for noticing Harris' seeming refusal to ever say "working class." Got so under my skin.
Abandoned the poor!
Yes, he is.
It should have always been Bernie. Most people in this country are just too far gone. Both democrats and republicans for that matter. These people get caught up in the ridiculous party wars instead of looking at the bigger picture on what's actually best for our country.
YES
You're actually asking that question?
Democrats abandoned common sense.
It was all lies crazy they should be locked up the people on news if not facts you need to do a we are sorry we got it wrong Stat being news again look who pays these people
😂😂 so party has all the power because the people vote soooo shut up stop the Democrat lie machine George soros paid for all left news they all say the same crap
Good sense is way better than common sense.
Republican voters have "common" sense and look what it got them.
Democrats have neither so it doesnt matter.
maybe; but so did you guys. You voted for someone that incited an insurrection.
@@daydoe40s Well, you don't know AwkwardTruths is a MAGAT based on that one post. He could have been a non-voter or could have voted Democrat this time but became disillusioned after the election.
Like me. Unless the dems make MASSIVE changes in the next 4 years I have no plans to ever vote for them again.
Yeah... that's why we were upset when he got squished, and they forced us to swallow Biden if we were opposed to Trump.
All they talked about was abortion. Most people care about the economy.
That's just a lie. You only listened to one thing.
@@SafetySpooon every serious question kamel toe was asked about how she would do something started with” But Donald Trump…” winning strategy,
@@SafetySpooon She literally said Orange man bad, and Abortion that's it! She never separated herself from current administration in which working class people of all races are not doing good economically.
Both parties abandoned the working class, they love war and deficit spending
He may be correct but the GOP has been ignoring the American worker for decades.
Democrats have been in office 12 of past 16 years ! Nice try!
Look like the Dems have caught up with the GOP.
That does NOT excuse the Democrats!
They do not ignore them, they cater to them with platitudes, which somehow is 'more' than Democrats are willing to muster through gritted teeth and contempt for the working class.
Trump lied about the cause of the issues, and Trump lied about even being willing to do anything about it. But he at least was willing to say something to it. Meanwhile Democrats campaigned on 'everything is doing great'.
REEEEEEEEEEEEE
Let's listen to Nancy Pelosi, who has made how much since becoming a politician?
Yes. He is correct.
Bernie sandees has been saying the same thing for about 50 years he has never changed his message that makes it a consistent message and I like that!
Yup spot on, they traded supporting Americans for standing with celebrities. Bunch of idiots………..
Oh, the problem was A-list celebrities instead of E-list celebrities that Trump brought out?
Bernie should have been our 2020 president. It was the reason I went from Independent to Democrat. I wanted to vote for his nomination but obviously that never happened.
For that you can thank the Clinton cabal, Debbie Wassermann Schultz, Jaime Harrison, Nancy Pillosi [sic], and the entire consortium of deceit in the dismally derelict democratic dumpster fire.
It's been time for a 3rd party. When 3rd parties come around networks like MSDNC shout them down and act like they shouldn't exist
They don't have funding
Working families/ working citizens party is that third party !!! Small steps to better align the dems and WF/WC would be radical and maybe it’s welcomed at this point! 😊
Bernie pill!!! Finally!!! The amount of media coverage that Bernie is getting makes me optimistic where the attention is finally moving to tackle the right cause!!! The progressive movement is coming Strong!!!
The democrats are done they won’t recover for the next 12 years 😂
Wellll… I have also seen lots of coverage that presents the opposite perspective… But I hope that you’re right😊
@@luxboss2388 yes I agree there is something new brewing no Democratic Party a new movement Social Democratic!!
If Bernie's the only reference anyone can make to 'progressive,' we in deep dung and doo. He sold out to the DNC, he sold out to Biden, and he betrayed his supporters by caving in to the criminals in his own party.
Yes!! If Bernie would have won in 2016 we wouldnt be in this situation now.
Then there would never have been a president Trump! Imagine that!
Absolutely Sanders would've defeated Trump in 2016. He would've pulled the white workers who twice voted for Obama but wanted some kind of shake-up so they voted for Trump. The DNC hacks used their super-delegates to thwart the will of the people and are responsible for Trump and the 1000 of kids who have still not been reconnected with their families. Hooray for Sanders speaking out, albeit way too late. But unless he uses his bully pulpit to call for a break from the 2-party system + help usher in an independent political party based on the foundation of organized labor, he is merely serving as the jester in the king's court.
I’m impressed MSNBC (a large conglomerate) is at least discussing the issue Bernie Sanders calls out. They need to do a better job, but I’ll take what I can get.
Really? You can trust Media Sells Nothing But Crap?
Yes.
Working citizens party. I’ll register.
FYI, there is a Woking Families Party.
Repeat. Gays and trans ARE NOT the same thing.
The point here is ...
Most of us DON'T CARE!!! We wish you well, but there are far more important issues in our lives - get over yourselves. You were all so busy vilifying J.K.Rowling and making us all be "supportive" of you - now we all live under the Xian Taliban.
Let's see how real it starts getting for you !!!
What's the difference?
Who cares
@BOlek-j6q you're right. I don't care either
Lets hear it for round 3 of Bernie would have won.
MSNBC News knows the answer is YES. Imagine Obama begging for a few bucks, every other commercial? Not talking about WORKING CLASS ISSUES, (just money).
Clinton, Obama, Biden sowed the seeds of Trumpian dystopia. They are all contributors to the cult of deceit and treachery, corporatism and perpetual warfare, formerly known as the Democratic Party.
Even as a faithful Trump voter through and through. I've always liked Bernie. I may not agree on his stances, but his heart is absolutely in the right place. And not just because he said this.
Do we know what a woman is again ?
Yes he's correct. We can thank the democratic strategists, Biden and the DNC for this mess we're in now.
I appreciate Sanders' devotion to getting progressive policies passed, but I also feel he's always had a HUGE blind spot for the role of political/cultural identity in election races.
Sanders and Biden are old friends and Sanders had a significant seat at the table when Biden's term began. Biden's policy was as progressive as you could expect with Manchin and Sinema making the final call on what got through the senate. It may not have been perfect, but it was still vastly preferable to Trump, who was joking to his billionaire buddy Musk about just getting rid of striking workers. It should have made a bigger difference than it did. This wasn't the working class taking a long hard and detached look at both candidates and picking the option that held the most economic benefit for them.
The working class are just as vulnerable to demagoguery as their fellow citizens.
Audit that 1 billion dollars 😅
Yes. Next question
They abandoned them in 2008. Way to catch up.
More like 1992, but I catch your drift.
Clinton was a Moderate. He signed Welfare Reform, Security modernization Act, Defense of Marriage, Crime Bill, “don’t asked don’t tell” and bunch of right wing leaning legislation. Obama never signed anything that,wasn’t left wing.
They were never on the side of the working class. Neither party.
If we had real Democracy, then Ralph Nader would have been US President long back and America would not be in such deep ditch today killing people everywhere on this planet. We need people like Ralph Nader in politics who think about public good.
Thank you for this comment. The Democrats (Gore, et al.) caved in to the Supremely Corrupt Court at the behest of the Bush Bros. criminal syndicate in 2000. Nader -- one of the greatest Americans of my lifetime -- was then pilloried and scapegoated for the massive cowardice and capitulation of the Democrats. Subsequent analyses have long since demonstrated no relationship between Gore's loss and Nader's candidacy, but Democratic shills -- who aren't worthy of feeding from the dung pile in a zoo -- continue to blaspheme Nader. Of course, they circled the wagons around pretty boy Wet Willie, whose side-kick and protegé turned out to be nothing more than a poorly designed hot-air balloon.
When we fight, YOU win.
I ❤ Bernie 🇺🇸
Christmas is early once again today watching MSNBC implosion 24/ 7 since November 5th.
There's dark money in BOTH camps. As long as they cater to the elite and behave as such and talk down to the average worker, they will continue to lose traction
This was an excellent segment. Thank you.
Yes. Most obviously yes. The Democrats took their traditional base for granted to the point that they became invisible except to be blamed for losses.
He is 100% right, but too late. Now he grew a pair. 🤷♂️
He spoke as soon as she started
Bernie started when he was still in school in Brooklyn. RBG, Bernie and Schumer went to competing High Schools, at different times of course.
@Taino505 Bernie did an internship with George Washington (sarcasm). He shut his mouth for 4 years and campaigned hard for Biden and Harris while they were complicit of mass murder. I understand he did it to keep the little power he had, but now he comes out huffing and puffing.
Homan isn’t breaking up families.
They can take their children with them.
Next time they come, come legally. 🇺🇸
You can post yes a million times on here MSDNC doesn't listen. They only hear Orange Man Bad!
When you guys are talking about the working class, what do you guys mean?
you guys, you guys, you guys, you guys, you guys, you guys, you guys, you guys, you guys, …
Basic elementary school grammar teaches that the pronoun ‘you’ can be used for both singular and plural. There is no reason to exclude girls, women and people who identify as female from the conversation.
@ firstly, you didn’t answer my question. Secondly, i’m not sure who made you the grammar police. Thirdly, “YOU GUYS” can be used to refer to or address two or more people.
People that aren't millionaires lol
@@Lsutiger300fast food workers, baristas, retail workers, anyone that sells their labor for wages. Working class is a massive umbrella.
@@Bigchangues- exactly, and with such a massive umbrella, different issues are going to resonate with different audiences. It’s difficult to find a unified and unifying message in that…
Obama found it with ACA, consumer protection legislation, and education- and then Biden/Harris elevated that last one with student loan forgiveness
Is less than $100k considered "working class"? Last time I checked, less than 15% has such income..
No he is not. There are over 10 million jobs OPEN. Farmers who need workers to pick their fields HAVE TO advertise the openings for Americans FIRST at the same salary they end up paying Visa immigrants they have to get because AMERICANS refuse to take the jobs, same happens with hotel jobs. Also, there are always job openings in the military. Democrats got the ACA passed and have pushed for higher minimum wages, have fought to feed poor children etc. Biden literally helped the unions and their pensions. Also Consumers made the rich richer they need to wrap there head around that fact. No one voted for trump because of the price of eggs, they voted for him because of their own self hate, and petty jealousy. No politicians controls prices, consumers do. Keep buying at the higher prices the prices will go higher.
Yeah but the Dems didn’t market that. They didn’t market a working class agenda going into 2025. It’s also true that this election was very anti-incumbent. The only country to have their party stay the same post CoVid so far is Mexico, because AMLO was basically Mexico’s Bernie Sanders
Your realize about 50% of those 10 million jobs are fake right? Anti union areas are the biggest winner of build back better and IRA…. Ended the train strike, homelessness and poverty still rampant. Technically I believe Trump dropped childhood poverty more with the covid money, I think the R blocked extending this but Dems aren’t getting that message out. He did nothing significant to protect our democracy, continued to spend billions supporting a genocide of a man who was trying to make him lose.
Finally someone else willing to speak the truth. The poor are always poor no matter the president. But this time the poor and uneducated did what they often do, vote for perceived self interests instead of actual self interests. But we have to stop ignoring their perceptions no matter how silly we think they are.
I had scroll down pretty far to find this comment. Good job.
😂 That's not even remotely true
I don't know. But i'm done with both parties.
Yay. That makes 2 of us!
"Dear American Peasants,
It's all your fault I Iost. Not mine.
Sincerely,
Madam Vice President"
Bernie is right.
MSDNC and their NPC's are on suicide watch.😿
As one of those NPCs, you ain't wrong (figuratively speaking)
When the despotic tyrant, lawless monstrous, criminal conman Billionaire talks about the working class it is loathsome and despicable !
What Now? Prosecution for those who "Called To Harm" Trump. Joy is going down with Rachael.
The answer is NO! My dad turned to Reagan and he came back voting for Trump. Bernie is spot on.