The point is that it won't benefit the down n under Citizen. There won't be job creation coz those jobs exist n will be filled by ppl associated. What this country needs is invest to create, not indulgence on a niche sport
@nyamekohali7284 not really... If you know and understand the business of Formula 1 you know that there will be a huge job creation, both short and long term. Tourism industry will boom as well
@17_wm I don't doubt tourism will boom but it will be momentary. I'm stating that besides sports to change the economy we need to look inward. F1 won't even make a mark on our quarterlies
Black people don't need tourist, they need sports grounds. You blame your ministers for being incompetent but it seems like y'all are incompetent yourselves.
Younger kids needs, dance studios in Kasi, they need swimming pools, they need cricket fields, they need rugby fields, they don't need inspiration, they need tangible infrastructure. Black people will blame their government for incompetence and wasteful expenditure but support wasteful expenditure when given chance to do so. I really fail to understand how black people think. Why must a minister facilitate an event instead of facilitating solid infrastructure that will out last him and some of y'all are sensationalising that stupid thinking
sounds awesome when you say it but it's a pipe dream in reality, when the F1 leaves so does the inspiration. we can barely accommodate for other sports (even regular sports) especially in towns
He's totally right soccer in model C schools and lower is not taken seriously they barley have srs games and tournaments . Soccer is basically not taken seriously in most schools that don't have the financial backing and the soccer system compared to rugby system in majority of SA schools is about 7 years behind tbh.
I think you are missing the point … formula one is multi billion dollar industry it will bring dollars in the country, it will create lots of jobs albeit mostly casual as it is seasonal….it will bring Technology … and other benefits… tourism etc … I think the initial investment of course will be huge but I reckon in the long run it would make economic sense … of course develop other sports too …
Wat technology exactly will F1 bring. Those billions go to F1 not the host nation. Gayton said it could cost 2 billion to host the event. This a one week event. And the infrastructure will used for a niche sport that few have the resources to participate in. I think if the benefit of this even was quantified then I'd be more optimistic but at the moment. It's people are just giving the generic "it'll bring tourism"
Harsh truth... His job isn't to uplift south Africa. His mandate is to develop and manage of sport, interms of infrastructure, and participation. So what these guys are talking about is just reversed farts.
FIFA rules are against government interference in football and Football Associations. Article 17 of the FIFA Regulations[2], provides that: “Each member shall manage its affairs independently and with no influence from third parties.” So there's very little Gayton can do about soccer. Corruption and laziness must end at SAFA.
My friend, you think Brazil, Spain, England, France, Argentina etc don't interfere? those governments definitely interfere, it's how you do it, we don't do it properly
FIFA is not against government programs to uplink early childhood soccer development which is where the minister must step, in all sporting codes. The reason why we send few people in the Olympics is because we have few wyt people in South Africa and we always send them. Black people must also get the necessary infrastructure so that they will show the world that we are also capable
The teachers in Kasi schools don't think about sport it only happens one week on the year and that's it. Make Kasi school sport competitive then we'll see some change.
So true, we need to bring in Sports with impact. There is a whole economy behind the masses sports and we need to refine it better. It is no harm bringing in F1 which will probably boost a niche economy but in the end it will put South Africa on the tourist positive side. But masses sports benefit the whole of South Africa. For those not from the hood or rural areas, schools have no sports experience like we had in the suburbs. I have lived in all places
It's a very big harm bringing F1 in South Africa, infact it's a wasteful expenditure.. R200 m will be gone, the same money could have helped to build small sporting grounds in some of the most underprivileged areas where you tend to find skillful talent
This will boost South African Motorsport as a whole. F1 is the penacle of this genre, the sport invests a lot in developing the sport eg karting and other relevent sport. Those who are interested in Motorsport will definitely benefit from their programmes. There is a big impact in terms of tourism and so forth. This comment is biased.
@TumeloMonare-w1w The return of F1 to South Africa could have numerous benefits for the country. Here are some reasons why: 1. Economic Boost: Hosting a Formula 1 race can generate significant revenue for South Africa through tourism, sponsorship, and merchandise sales. 2. Job Creation: The event would create temporary and permanent jobs, both directly and indirectly, in areas like hospitality, transportation, and event management. 3. Infrastructure Development: To host an F1 race, South Africa might need to upgrade or develop new infrastructure, such as roads, hotels, and the racing circuit itself. This could lead to long-term improvements in the country's infrastructure. 4. Promoting South Africa Globally: The Formula 1 World Championship is a global event, broadcast in over 180 countries. Hosting a race in South Africa would showcase the country's beauty, culture, and capabilities to a massive international audience. 1. Motorsport Development: The return of F1 could also boost motorsport development in South Africa, inspiring young drivers and teams, and potentially leading to increased participation and success in international motorsport competitions. 2. Social Benefits: Hosting an F1 race could also have social benefits, such as promoting unity and national pride, and providing a platform for social and community initiatives. Overall, the return of Formula 1 to South Africa could have a significant, positive impact on the country's economy, infrastructure, and global reputation. The fact is any global sport will have a positive impact on this debilitating excuse for a country. I am highly perplexed that there is a person who is a public figure and yet is clueless on such matters.
SA gains nothing from hosting these events, only places next to where the events are hosted benefit from it. we need to work on whatever we have potential in so that we know money won't be waisted
It is as useless as Brazil's stadiums for the World Cup. It'll boost tourism for a certain amount of time. What we need is lasting investment as F1 is not a stationary organization and will have to bid to insure we can host everytime. Its USELESS.
Imagine R200m will be gone for that 1 week only. Gayton is not about empowering the black and coloured child. He wants to be popular and famous so that he will grow his party, that's why he speaks of events like an artist management company
Where do you get people who have immature minds to come speak on your platform beats me…the other day i was listening to Sbu talking a whole lot of bull about poor kids and why his so called kids wont Be married to such people blah blah blah…..i guess you see something in such people or inspired by them somehow because aint no way i spent time with a grown little adults talking nonsense….
They said world cup will benefit south africa. In the end, the disadvantages outweigh advantages. Formula 1 is not benefitting Saudi Arabia at the moment.
That's just not true. Our infrastructure benefited hugely from hosting the Fifa world cup and it would be in an even better level if our government maintained it and further invested in it.
@sizwemendu5278 the same infrastructure that is costing government millions without profits. Examples include Royal bafokeng and Cape Town stadia which are barely used
Atleast Saudi Arabia have oil money to waste, South Africa desperately need that R200+ m that he will waste for that 1 week. This guy just wants to be popular at an expense of the underprivileged
@@sizwemendu5278we don't own the stadiums, government don't own them, they belong to few families who controls our economy and country so how did we benefit really?
Yes I think naturally the vast majority of us are negative buoyant … means we sink rather than float because of our bone structure … I would think we won’t dominate in swimming same as Europeans won’t be dominating long distance running anytime soon … just some body composition and physics
@@Japo29 private companies will benefit from this, that's money going to wyt people's businesses and they already have employees in place, who are paid peanuts
@siphamandlagiftmbewu8081 hate consumes to the point that one would or could seek to absolve ones self but in the same token it renders you powerless by making the hated all powerful.Thus they will forever rule because the power vested in you has voluntary been handed over.
This guy think Formula 1 is just about the driver. Each team in Formula 1 employs about 2000 people that just work on the development of the car. Unlike your rugby and football, motorsports encourages kids to do STEM subjects in schools. He should just say he doesn't know about the sport. 😂🤷♀ There's a much bigger picture in the motivation in bringing Formula 1 to the forefront to the country.
Formula 1 teams have their own formula one guys, no new employment will be there, you speak as if you will be one of the people who will get employed and what's the use of the job that is not sustainable?🎉
Bringing F1 To SA means absolutely nothing if you know nothing about F1. SA will make lots of money in just one weekend by hosting F1
The point is that it won't benefit the down n under Citizen. There won't be job creation coz those jobs exist n will be filled by ppl associated. What this country needs is invest to create, not indulgence on a niche sport
@nyamekohali7284 not really... If you know and understand the business of Formula 1 you know that there will be a huge job creation, both short and long term. Tourism industry will boom as well
@17_wm I don't doubt tourism will boom but it will be momentary. I'm stating that besides sports to change the economy we need to look inward. F1 won't even make a mark on our quarterlies
We said the same thing about the Soccer World Cup?
@@defumane6670 it's not like we'll be hosting F1 for the first time like the Fifa World Cup
Tourism will boom if he brings f1 in SA
Yet some people are just pessimists.
Why then does the Department of Tourism not foot the bill? Gayton has plenty of sports facilities to refurbish.
Black people don't need tourist, they need sports grounds.
You blame your ministers for being incompetent but it seems like y'all are incompetent yourselves.
This the truth we not talking about , it’s a lot of underprivileged kids in SA that could benefit from sports inclusion than expansion
Younger kids will inspire to be Lewis so bringing F1 to mzansi will be a big thing
Where will they practice?
Younger kids needs, dance studios in Kasi, they need swimming pools, they need cricket fields, they need rugby fields, they don't need inspiration, they need tangible infrastructure.
Black people will blame their government for incompetence and wasteful expenditure
but support wasteful expenditure when given chance to do so. I really fail to understand how black people think.
Why must a minister facilitate an event instead of facilitating solid infrastructure that will out last him and some of y'all are sensationalising that stupid thinking
sounds awesome when you say it but it's a pipe dream in reality, when the F1 leaves so does the inspiration. we can barely accommodate for other sports (even regular sports) especially in towns
Hosting the world cup , olympics and hosting formular 1is a beneficial for the rainbow nation 🇿🇦
He's totally right soccer in model C schools and lower is not taken seriously they barley have srs games and tournaments . Soccer is basically not taken seriously in most schools that don't have the financial backing and the soccer system compared to rugby system in majority of SA schools is about 7 years behind tbh.
This thing is dom😂😂😂😂😂😂
I think you are missing the point … formula one is multi billion dollar industry it will bring dollars in the country, it will create lots of jobs albeit mostly casual as it is seasonal….it will bring Technology … and other benefits… tourism etc … I think the initial investment of course will be huge but I reckon in the long run it would make economic sense … of course develop other sports too …
Wat technology exactly will F1 bring. Those billions go to F1 not the host nation. Gayton said it could cost 2 billion to host the event. This a one week event. And the infrastructure will used for a niche sport that few have the resources to participate in.
I think if the benefit of this even was quantified then I'd be more optimistic but at the moment. It's people are just giving the generic "it'll bring tourism"
He is the Minister of Sports not the Minister of Rugby and Soccer
Danko
Harsh truth... His job isn't to uplift south Africa.
His mandate is to develop and manage of sport, interms of infrastructure, and participation.
So what these guys are talking about is just reversed farts.
That's a childish response, so he must name every sport for your to understand?
FIFA rules are against government interference in football and Football Associations.
Article 17 of the FIFA Regulations[2], provides that:
“Each member shall manage its affairs independently and with no influence from third parties.”
So there's very little Gayton can do about soccer. Corruption and laziness must end at SAFA.
My friend, you think Brazil, Spain, England, France, Argentina etc don't interfere? those governments definitely interfere, it's how you do it, we don't do it properly
FIFA is not against government programs to uplink early childhood soccer development which is where the minister must step, in all sporting codes.
The reason why we send few people in the Olympics is because we have few wyt people in South Africa and we always send them.
Black people must also get the necessary infrastructure so that they will show the world that we are also capable
I’d stay with re introducing leagues for the different codes. District/ regional, up to provincial. But all districts would be represented
The teachers in Kasi schools don't think about sport it only happens one week on the year and that's it. Make Kasi school sport competitive then we'll see some change.
So true, we need to bring in Sports with impact. There is a whole economy behind the masses sports and we need to refine it better. It is no harm bringing in F1 which will probably boost a niche economy but in the end it will put South Africa on the tourist positive side. But masses sports benefit the whole of South Africa. For those not from the hood or rural areas, schools have no sports experience like we had in the suburbs. I have lived in all places
It's a very big harm bringing F1 in South Africa, infact it's a wasteful expenditure..
R200 m will be gone, the same money could have helped to build small sporting grounds in some of the most underprivileged areas where you tend to find skillful talent
@@siphamandlagiftmbewu8081 🙏
What are you focusing on in your community ?
This will boost South African Motorsport as a whole. F1 is the penacle of this genre, the sport invests a lot in developing the sport eg karting and other relevent sport. Those who are interested in Motorsport will definitely benefit from their programmes. There is a big impact in terms of tourism and so forth. This comment is biased.
we should've seen that in the 90's after hosting it in 1993, it sounds good on paper
@TumeloMonare-w1w The return of F1 to South Africa could have numerous benefits for the country. Here are some reasons why:
1. Economic Boost: Hosting a Formula 1 race can generate significant revenue for South Africa through tourism, sponsorship, and merchandise sales.
2. Job Creation: The event would create temporary and permanent jobs, both directly and indirectly, in areas like hospitality, transportation, and event management.
3. Infrastructure Development: To host an F1 race, South Africa might need to upgrade or develop new infrastructure, such as roads, hotels, and the racing circuit itself. This could lead to long-term improvements in the country's infrastructure.
4. Promoting South Africa Globally: The Formula 1 World Championship is a global event, broadcast in over 180 countries. Hosting a race in South Africa would showcase the country's beauty, culture, and capabilities to a massive international audience.
1. Motorsport Development: The return of F1 could also boost motorsport development in South Africa, inspiring young drivers and teams, and potentially leading to increased participation and success in international motorsport competitions.
2. Social Benefits: Hosting an F1 race could also have social benefits, such as promoting unity and national pride, and providing a platform for social and community initiatives.
Overall, the return of Formula 1 to South Africa could have a significant, positive impact on the country's economy, infrastructure, and global reputation. The fact is any global sport will have a positive impact on this debilitating excuse for a country. I am highly perplexed that there is a person who is a public figure and yet is clueless on such matters.
SA gains nothing from hosting these events, only places next to where the events are hosted benefit from it. we need to work on whatever we have potential in so that we know money won't be waisted
It is as useless as Brazil's stadiums for the World Cup. It'll boost tourism for a certain amount of time. What we need is lasting investment as F1 is not a stationary organization and will have to bid to insure we can host everytime. Its USELESS.
Imagine R200m will be gone for that 1 week only.
Gayton is not about empowering the black and coloured child. He wants to be popular and famous so that he will grow his party, that's why he speaks of events like an artist management company
Where do you get people who have immature minds to come speak on your platform beats me…the other day i was listening to Sbu talking a whole lot of bull about poor kids and why his so called kids wont Be married to such people blah blah blah…..i guess you see something in such people or inspired by them somehow because aint no way i spent time with a grown little adults talking nonsense….
Watching people talk about things their have no idea of is baffling.
These gents are tired. They need a nap.
They said world cup will benefit south africa. In the end, the disadvantages outweigh advantages. Formula 1 is not benefitting Saudi Arabia at the moment.
That's just not true. Our infrastructure benefited hugely from hosting the Fifa world cup and it would be in an even better level if our government maintained it and further invested in it.
@sizwemendu5278 the same infrastructure that is costing government millions without profits. Examples include Royal bafokeng and Cape Town stadia which are barely used
Atleast Saudi Arabia have oil money to waste, South Africa desperately need that R200+ m that he will waste for that 1 week.
This guy just wants to be popular at an expense of the underprivileged
@@sizwemendu5278we don't own the stadiums, government don't own them, they belong to few families who controls our economy and country so how did we benefit really?
Sorry Pen but swimming and us black people don't go together. Greetings from Namibia.
Yes I think naturally the vast majority of us are negative buoyant … means we sink rather than float because of our bone structure … I would think we won’t dominate in swimming same as Europeans won’t be dominating long distance running anytime soon … just some body composition and physics
Some people are always negative does he doesn't know F1 this one
Ek se, As the word he used at the beginning... "fokol" guareneteed he knows fokol...
Cause you don't understand tourism and putting us on the world calender creates lasting jobs
What jobs?
How can an event create a job?
@siphamandlagiftmbewu8081 you will never know 😆 🤣
@@Japo29 private companies will benefit from this, that's money going to wyt people's businesses and they already have employees in place, who are paid peanuts
@siphamandlagiftmbewu8081 hate consumes to the point that one would or could seek to absolve ones self but in the same token it renders you powerless by making the hated all powerful.Thus they will forever rule because the power vested in you has voluntary been handed over.
This guy think Formula 1 is just about the driver. Each team in Formula 1 employs about 2000 people that just work on the development of the car. Unlike your rugby and football, motorsports encourages kids to do STEM subjects in schools. He should just say he doesn't know about the sport. 😂🤷♀ There's a much bigger picture in the motivation in bringing Formula 1 to the forefront to the country.
Formula 1 teams have their own formula one guys, no new employment will be there, you speak as if you will be one of the people who will get employed and what's the use of the job that is not sustainable?🎉