Great points all, though I disagree with the "fair randomization" being redundant: It makes a significant distinction to a non-randomized "fair" game by removing the ability to memorize the entire game, forcing you to think on your feet all the time.
It's really impressive that you can say so much about a little game like this, I'm honestly considering making a video in this genre thanks to your work.
Matt!!! What's your thoughts on Breath of the Wild? Do you feel it adressed at least some of your complaints with the Zelda franchise? Are you hyped? Will you review it? Please respond!
I think no matter what game you decide to review you will always deliver a very interesting outlook. I really enjoyed your review of the original DMC, and I love re-watching all of your videos even if it's just for background noise while I'm working.
www.patreon.com/matthewmatosis "Thanks to the generous support of everyone over the years I'm now focusing on creating videos full-time instead of just as a side project. As long as we can maintain enough pledges to keep me alive I'm happy to continue making videos as my job for the foreseeable future."
You are honestly the best video game reviewer I have ever seen. You give such thought into your videos and you really give the impression that you know much about game design, which is more than most reviewers can say. Keep doing what you're doing!
This comment was made three years ago. Since now therw have been many YTers to challenge MatthewMatosis, lile Anderson and Raycevick. But back in the day, Matosis was by far the leading figure.
@@majestic3992 I wasn't replying to you because it was indeed a 3 year old comment. But the other guy was only 2 months. Yes, Matt was basically first, but that doesn't give him a free pass.
@Aria Khalaji If saying "horseshit", makes you assume I am angry, then brother, there are greater issues with you than just disagreement. I'm not an expert of Joseph yet, he is only now in my playlist, I get him and hbombr confused as well, but as a major critiquer myself (not on youtube), I've enjoyed and remembered both of them way more than Matthew for a some time. Length != quality dude come on now. This is an old video but Matt did spend far more time talking about the goddamn graphics of downwell than anybody should have. Jesus.
Matt, thank you for all your hard work. making content can't be easy, and even if you've been media silent for a while, the people who know you as a proprietor as quality and thoughtful and heart filled reviews know the next video will always comes when it's ready.
Can't wait to see what you do next. Loved everything you've done so far. Your playlists are often on repeat for me for my own enjoyment and to also help give you the view count you deserve. Looking forward to that playlist getting even longer
I was also in a really bad mood when he uploaded. But, now I feel much better. Not just because of him, but also my history class. I love history, and the three hour class time seriously felt like 20 minutes. Watching this is basically the icing on the cake of how great I feel right now compared to earlier. Thank you for the video Matt. Always look forward to your videos, and I like the feeling of being surprised by your uploads. I hope you put however much time is needed to get a really in depth analysis like you always have.
I feel like the randomization is there for the same reason all music players have a shuffle option. Sometimes you want to listen to the songs you already know, just not in completely the same way.
I think the randomisation is the way it is to prevent memorisation. In most simple linear games like this, it's entirely possible to just practice a very precise set of inputs. This leaves you not really "playing" the game, but just going through that same set of memorised actions. The result of Downwell's design is that the levels are fundamentally what they were intended to be, but the player has to always be paying attention to the map itself instead of relying on memory. I'm surprised Matthewmatosis was critical of the randomisation without considering that aspect. That said, I agree that this game would benefit from an additional, more random mode.
Great video as always Mr. Matosis. Im actually really happy that you chose this game to review, I played it a while back and had a very similar experience to yours, but all Ive heard from other people is nothing but love and praise so I was hesitant to speak my mind that I found the game a bit under"well"ming. Mainly because I saw gameplay of it on youtube and realized that due to lag, my iPhone 4 had been running the game at half speed, so I wasn't sure if my perception of the game was due to that.
Hey Matthew it's great to see you again! I loved the DMC1 review, I just finished playing through the series with a friend at the time of release and it was a great road trip companion. Can't wait to hear more from you in the future! Once i'm in a better financial situation i'll be on your patreon list asap.
I appreciate the laconic nature of your phrasing, it feels very on point. Also you know the video is coming to an end when the puns and metaphors in the theme of the analyzed game intensify.
In regards to your patreon post, I for one am glad you opt to take things slowly to ensure more quality videos get posted. Nowadays people who copy your style are a dime a dozen but because it's your own original style, you come off as more genuine than a lot of other 'serious gaming reviewer youtubers'. I'm looking forward to your future videos,, large or small. Also I really fucking loved your DMC1 video, not only did you make me see the game's design philosophy in a different perspective I would've never thought of, your footage capturing the bosses' behavioral patterns inspired me to look at how I should design my bosses.
WOW... this is an incredibly thought out review... I have no idea how any other review could top this. I don't do reviews, and I was thinking about doing one... but after see ing this... no way Jose. Subscribed.
Matthew, while going through some very psychologically hard times and trying to make meaning of a world that I am still trying desperately to see as anything but futile and pointless, your videos have had a profound effect on my life. I have re-watched many of your videos more times than I can keep track of, and the dedication and passion that you put into these is inspirational. Keep doing what you are doing, the news of your more frequent releases is a breath of fresh air!
I don't think Hyper Light is complex enough to need a review by matthew. He usually does games which are exceptional at one thing, or mechanically very optimized/perfect. He focuses more on games with unique gameplay. Hyper Light looks great, has good music and atmosphere, but its gameplay (combat) is very standart and has a lot of flaws. And as for the tone and atmosphere, it is quite similar to Dark Souls, which he has covered extensively.
Hey, just found your channel through the caddicarus recomendation, and love it! I was already getting the urge to make a game and this channel pushed me over the edge, now I just need a new laptop. Anyway, just felt like saying that if you ever need artwork, like a profile picture or something, I'll do it!
My biggest issue with the iOS version is that since the buttons are on the bottom of the screen it can make it hard to see what's coming next because your hands block it. This could have been easily fixed with optional gyroscope controls or possibly shrinking the play screen and placing the buttons underneath it. Still really fun to play on the go but makes me want to buy a different version
Of all the games out there I didn't expect you to review Downwell. That said, it's a nice little rounded experience that I really enjoyed. I'm more of a Towerclimb type of guy tho!
Hey man, thanks for the awesome videos you make. I keep watching the Dark Souls 2 critique and Bioshock Infinite review over and over because I find them very entertaining. I can't wait to see your thoughts on Dark Souls 3 and Bloodborne!
I have never heard of this game before nor do I care to ever play it but dammit if I wasn't captivated by this video. If you made a video reviewing different brands of paint it would probably be fascinating honestly.
And here I thought Downwell was that one small game that became the precursor for Portal. Downwell seems fun, thanks for the short but sweet video. I can understand your desire to avoid P5 spoilers as I've already seen a few things I wish I hadn't, but that's the "lovable charm" of the video game related website I mainly browse.
I'd love it if the next video was MGSV. I have a lot of problems with the game but I suck at articulating my thoughts. We tend to have almost identical taste in games/game design so I can't wait until you tackled that title!
I was just watching the Devil May Cry commentary for like the 5th time yesterday thinking, "Wonder when he's gonna upload his next video" I am now very happy. :)
wow I really liked the combo system, and basically everything about downwell. I never really got to World 3, so you're probably a lot better than me at the game and you're hitting ceilings that I'm not seeing.
Interesting what you say about the combo system, and pragmatism vs satisfaction. I feel a number of character action games do have similar problems as well, though. That health/weapon mechanics seems quite interesting. I'll probably try out this game at some point.
Holy fuck, okay I did not see this in my feed, I was thinking "I wonder if Mathew Matosis has made anything in the past month or two that I may have missed" and BAM something was uploaded 15 mins ago! WTF
I was briefly obsessed with this game on iPhone (to the point where my hand got so sore I could hardly play guitar some nights). Personally, this was probably the only iOS game I enjoyed at any length, but it's true that it was, like a Gem High, an ultimately limited affair.
Fun fact: this is one of the few games that uses a single super-texture with everything the game can display on it.
Minecraft pocket edition used to do this
That’s so cool! What other games act like this?
@@gusonian8637 The first Rage game did this.
"Who watches a Matthewmatosis video at 3AM?"
Me: "Oh boy it's 3AM!"
5am.
Get on my level, scrub.
11 PM mophuka. And, I waited 6 hours. He uploaded at about 5 PM for me.
I sincerily don't even care which game he reviews at this point. I'd watch a Bad Rats review if Matthewmatosis made one.
That would be the most fun thing ever.
After looking at the comments of the Zachtronics review series, I've come to the sad realisation that many others do not share our opinion.
After a thousand years it is you, it is really you. Hroooaaagggh! Hroaaagh!
Brilliant
Sir, I want you to have this cookie.
and with a video on such a great game.
Lol thats hilarious.
Fuckin' brilliant!
Great points all, though I disagree with the "fair randomization" being redundant: It makes a significant distinction to a non-randomized "fair" game by removing the ability to memorize the entire game, forcing you to think on your feet all the time.
The most ambitous of cross-overs
Being a distinction doesnt makes it better in itself. And being able to memorize the game doesnt makes experience bad.
Hi :-)
@@TheElectricUnderground HOLYYYYY SHIT ITS THE ELECTRIC UNDERGROUND, BIG FAN!
The purpose of the randomness isn't to make a new experience every time. It's to avoid map memorization.
Those aren't mutually exclusive, you could accomplish both at the same time.
He's alive, he's alive
"I CAN SIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIING"
i like you.
What's this from?
@@thebombsauce Simpsons, Dr. Zaius
It's really impressive that you can say so much about a little game like this, I'm honestly considering making a video in this genre thanks to your work.
Well?
@@aero9710 Yeah not happening, I hate video production lol
I did make two little videogames though
@@DeoMachinavery fair haha
are you a steam curator?, i would like to follow you there
That's a great idea, I second this!
Yeah, I'd love to see him as a Curator. His opinions are pretty valuable to me.
I'll have to ask you to remove the worm in my brain that you planted. Between here and patreon I keep reading comments in your voice.
You're alive, rejoice!
Hope you've got some more videos brewing :D
Your thumbnail perfectly represents my reaction to seeing Matthew make another video.
Next video coming soon. Have a read of this if you want more info: www.patreon.com/posts/hello-again-6829626
So no Bloodborne or DS3 anytime soon? Cool, cya in 3 years.
Matt!!! What's your thoughts on Breath of the Wild? Do you feel it adressed at least some of your complaints with the Zelda franchise? Are you hyped? Will you review it? Please respond!
I think no matter what game you decide to review you will always deliver a very interesting outlook. I really enjoyed your review of the original DMC, and I love re-watching all of your videos even if it's just for background noise while I'm working.
DO MORE LIVE STREAMS, OR JUST ANY CONTENT IN GENERAL YOU IRISH FUCK.
www.patreon.com/matthewmatosis
"Thanks to the generous support of everyone over the years I'm now focusing on creating videos full-time instead of just as a side project. As long as we can maintain enough pledges to keep me alive I'm happy to continue making videos as my job for the foreseeable future."
One of my favorite games. I've been playing this game on iOS since the game came out, and i have yet to beat it. It's an absolute must.
You are honestly the best video game reviewer I have ever seen. You give such thought into your videos and you really give the impression that you know much about game design, which is more than most reviewers can say. Keep doing what you're doing!
I disagree. More emotions are vital for a game reviewer. I mean games are meant to be fun.
@@Dornpunzel You don't need to display emotions to analyze the quality of art.
MatthewMatosis is, in my humble opinion, the greatest youtuber who does intelligent analytical videos on games by far.
Majestic watch Josephanderson
Aria Khalaji horseshit. This guy spent 3 minutes talking about the graphics of fucking Downwell.
This comment was made three years ago. Since now therw have been many YTers to challenge MatthewMatosis, lile Anderson and Raycevick. But back in the day, Matosis was by far the leading figure.
@@majestic3992 I wasn't replying to you because it was indeed a 3 year old comment. But the other guy was only 2 months. Yes, Matt was basically first, but that doesn't give him a free pass.
@Aria Khalaji If saying "horseshit", makes you assume I am angry, then brother, there are greater issues with you than just disagreement. I'm not an expert of Joseph yet, he is only now in my playlist, I get him and hbombr confused as well, but as a major critiquer myself (not on youtube), I've enjoyed and remembered both of them way more than Matthew for a some time. Length != quality dude come on now. This is an old video but Matt did spend far more time talking about the goddamn graphics of downwell than anybody should have. Jesus.
it's awesome to watch such a constructive critical reviews on game design aspect. brilliant!
Matt, thank you for all your hard work. making content can't be easy, and even if you've been media silent for a while, the people who know you as a proprietor as quality and thoughtful and heart filled reviews know the next video will always comes when it's ready.
Can't wait to see what you do next. Loved everything you've done so far. Your playlists are often on repeat for me for my own enjoyment and to also help give you the view count you deserve. Looking forward to that playlist getting even longer
was considering suicide but a new Matthewmatosis video just came out so it can wait
I was also in a really bad mood when he uploaded. But, now I feel much better. Not just because of him, but also my history class. I love history, and the three hour class time seriously felt like 20 minutes. Watching this is basically the icing on the cake of how great I feel right now compared to earlier. Thank you for the video Matt. Always look forward to your videos, and I like the feeling of being surprised by your uploads. I hope you put however much time is needed to get a really in depth analysis like you always have.
Your history classes last 3 hours? Are you in college or high school?
+jmiquelmb College.
NOOOOOOO TOO MUCH POSITIVITY ON THE INTERNET THAL SHALL NOT BE HAPPY ON OUR GRACIOUS PLATFORM SO IF MY KEYBOARD SHALL TASTE BLOOD I CHOOSE THE
This is one review that i have to watch on my phone for a better video experience
I feel like the randomization is there for the same reason all music players have a shuffle option.
Sometimes you want to listen to the songs you already know, just not in completely the same way.
I think the randomisation is the way it is to prevent memorisation.
In most simple linear games like this, it's entirely possible to just practice a very precise set of inputs. This leaves you not really "playing" the game, but just going through that same set of memorised actions.
The result of Downwell's design is that the levels are fundamentally what they were intended to be, but the player has to always be paying attention to the map itself instead of relying on memory.
I'm surprised Matthewmatosis was critical of the randomisation without considering that aspect. That said, I agree that this game would benefit from an additional, more random mode.
Great video as always Mr. Matosis.
Im actually really happy that you chose this game to review, I played it a while back and had a very similar experience to yours, but all Ive heard from other people is nothing but love and praise so I was hesitant to speak my mind that I found the game a bit under"well"ming. Mainly because I saw gameplay of it on youtube and realized that due to lag, my iPhone 4 had been running the game at half speed, so I wasn't sure if my perception of the game was due to that.
i love what you have to say in your reviews. you always bring up things i never would've thought about
Hey Matthew it's great to see you again! I loved the DMC1 review, I just finished playing through the series with a friend at the time of release and it was a great road trip companion. Can't wait to hear more from you in the future! Once i'm in a better financial situation i'll be on your patreon list asap.
I appreciate the laconic nature of your phrasing, it feels very on point. Also you know the video is coming to an end when the puns and metaphors in the theme of the analyzed game intensify.
Great vid as always! I've practically marathoned your entire channel twice.
even in the few instances where I've never heard of the game, it's always nice to hear something analyzed in a thoughtful way.
I'm always glad to see a video on this channel. Keep up the great work!
In regards to your patreon post, I for one am glad you opt to take things slowly to ensure more quality videos get posted. Nowadays people who copy your style are a dime a dozen but because it's your own original style, you come off as more genuine than a lot of other 'serious gaming reviewer youtubers'. I'm looking forward to your future videos,, large or small.
Also I really fucking loved your DMC1 video, not only did you make me see the game's design philosophy in a different perspective I would've never thought of, your footage capturing the bosses' behavioral patterns inspired me to look at how I should design my bosses.
Fantastic analysis as always Matt. You are a true gem in the TH-cam gaming community. Can't wait for the next video.
It always warms me heart to see that 1 next to your name in my sub list. It's always a neat game too.
WOW... this is an incredibly thought out review... I have no idea how any other review could top this. I don't do reviews, and I was thinking about doing one... but after see ing this... no way Jose. Subscribed.
You finally awake from your aeonic slumber and yet again bless us with your infinite wisdom!
Good stuff. Always happy to see an upload from you.
And you as well, namesake. Upload soon, ya?
wwwoooah that's awesome! Easily my fave review channel here, awesome to see you active again!
I knew subscribing to this guy even though he hadn't uploaded in a while was a good idea!
Matthew, while going through some very psychologically hard times and trying to make meaning of a world that I am still trying desperately to see as anything but futile and pointless, your videos have had a profound effect on my life. I have re-watched many of your videos more times than I can keep track of, and the dedication and passion that you put into these is inspirational. Keep doing what you are doing, the news of your more frequent releases is a breath of fresh air!
Hope you’re doing well!
I managed to beat Downwell at last. It took me fucking 10 hours of failing over and over, but I finally managed to beat it. Time to try hard mode.
Good to see you again.
By chance have you heard of/played Hyper Light Drifter? I would be interested in hearing your thoughts on it.
I don't think Hyper Light is complex enough to need a review by matthew. He usually does games which are exceptional at one thing, or mechanically very optimized/perfect. He focuses more on games with unique gameplay. Hyper Light looks great, has good music and atmosphere, but its gameplay (combat) is very standart and has a lot of flaws. And as for the tone and atmosphere, it is quite similar to Dark Souls, which he has covered extensively.
Love your content man! Always happy to see a new video from you! :D
Just when I miss your content, and you are back with a video !
Nice job Matt. Keep up the good work. I always love your videos.
Unexpected reform to form, Matt, I guess you were busy with other responsibilities. Nice to have you back.
Hey, just found your channel through the caddicarus recomendation, and love it! I was already getting the urge to make a game and this channel pushed me over the edge, now I just need a new laptop. Anyway, just felt like saying that if you ever need artwork, like a profile picture or something, I'll do it!
Here's my page to find if I am worthy enough! luigipunch.deviantart.com/
glad to watch your videos again! great review
My biggest issue with the iOS version is that since the buttons are on the bottom of the screen it can make it hard to see what's coming next because your hands block it. This could have been easily fixed with optional gyroscope controls or possibly shrinking the play screen and placing the buttons underneath it. Still really fun to play on the go but makes me want to buy a different version
Great video, love the content. Thank you for all you do
Matt is back!
UUUUUUMBASA!
Hey! You're finally back! Great review, missed your videos
Great to see your uploads again, yo. keep it up!
I've been very addicted to this game. Great to see a review from you.
the unlockable characters aren't epic cameos of western indie clique protagonists? disgusting.
It's a good day when there's a new mathewmatosis video.
Of all the games out there I didn't expect you to review Downwell. That said, it's a nice little rounded experience that I really enjoyed.
I'm more of a Towerclimb type of guy tho!
great review i agree on pretty much all points you made and felt the same way after playing the game for quite a while
Hey man, thanks for the awesome videos you make. I keep watching the Dark Souls 2 critique and Bioshock Infinite review over and over because I find them very entertaining. I can't wait to see your thoughts on Dark Souls 3 and Bloodborne!
Ayyy new upload! Love your videos.
Oh god a new matthewmatosis video. Is it a problem that I don't
feeeeeeeeeel compleeeeete without youuuu?
I caaaan't live without your voooooooice??
good to have you back!
Love your content, Matt!!! Please keep it coming. ;)
I have never heard of this game before nor do I care to ever play it but dammit if I wasn't captivated by this video. If you made a video reviewing different brands of paint it would probably be fascinating honestly.
Video length 13:37. I see you big dog.
And here I thought Downwell was that one small game that became the precursor for Portal. Downwell seems fun, thanks for the short but sweet video. I can understand your desire to avoid P5 spoilers as I've already seen a few things I wish I hadn't, but that's the "lovable charm" of the video game related website I mainly browse.
Everyone is like "omg you're back" and I'm just like "Welcome to Matthewmatosis' TH-cam channel, this is normal"
Really good critiques! Great video
Fantastic review! You're a really good reviewer.
He hath returned, Rejoice!
I'd love it if the next video was MGSV. I have a lot of problems with the game but I suck at articulating my thoughts. We tend to have almost identical taste in games/game design so I can't wait until you tackled that title!
good times are afoot people! Time to watch this until his next video comes out!
Good to know you're still alive
Well, I guess a Phatom Pain review isnt happening, same as Super Bunny Hope doing a MGS4 review...
The exact same 2 I'm waiting for
This is very impressive, I'm glad I found it.
i don't care what you do, i enjoy hearing you talk about games.
Wow I sub and then you upload the next day, considering how rarely you seem to upload that's damn lucky.
I was just watching the Devil May Cry commentary for like the 5th time yesterday thinking, "Wonder when he's gonna upload his next video" I am now very happy. :)
Been lurking his page for the last 2 days, its like I felt a disturbance in the force.
An analysis of Spelunky would make my year.
Oh my god you are back!
unlocked every achievement kamige imo
wow I really liked the combo system, and basically everything about downwell.
I never really got to World 3, so you're probably a lot better than me at the game and you're hitting ceilings that I'm not seeing.
I now want to hear your thoughts on Nuclear Throne
This game seems like a nice mobile time-killer, something to play while you're on a bus ride.
missed this guy
Interesting what you say about the combo system, and pragmatism vs satisfaction. I feel a number of character action games do have similar problems as well, though. That health/weapon mechanics seems quite interesting. I'll probably try out this game at some point.
Damn I love your content Matthew.
Yayayay, I don't even care what game it is I'm just happy for a new video
Is about to watch the new Some Call Me Johnny review, but then sees Matthew Matosis uploaded a new video. "I'm sorry, Johnny."
Holy fuck, okay I did not see this in my feed, I was thinking "I wonder if Mathew Matosis has made anything in the past month or two that I may have missed" and BAM something was uploaded 15 mins ago! WTF
man why don't I get notified for these I just found it on my recommendations
I'm glad you still exist.
I was briefly obsessed with this game on iPhone (to the point where my hand got so sore I could hardly play guitar some nights). Personally, this was probably the only iOS game I enjoyed at any length, but it's true that it was, like a Gem High, an ultimately limited affair.
Oh hell yea, new video from you.
Guess I'll just rewatch all your videos while I wait for the next one.. again.
IT SURE IS FRIDAY, thanks matthew!!
Hey Matt. Do you plan on doing a review for Scalebound? I loved your TW101 review and would like to hear your opinion on Kamiya's next game.
holy shit a new vid! its 3am but i have to watch now
I'll wait months to hear your voice mate, but every two weeks is even better, I just hope it doesn't burn you out like a candle.
I finally beat this game! Hard mode seems really fun so far!
a new MM Video??? the wait is always worth it
this looks perfect for an arcade machine i must have it!
Great as always.