In my opinion for a CD box set, this set has never been surpassed for both the packaging and recording quality. Hats off to EMI and the Japanese execution of this beautiful creation. My most cherished CD box set.
Hi Christopher, Hope your well ! Yes absolutely probably my favourite one too! The Japanese involvement is what really nailed it for me perfectly miniaturised! Thanks for watching!
Gday Dave, hope I find you well. I remember visiting JBHI fi in the Hobart CBD on the 9/9/09. I was cashed up and as you would expect there was also a line up of super enthusiastic Beatles fans eager to get their hands on the Mono or Stereo CD boxsets. I recall spending around 10 minutes in line awaiting my turn to reach the cash register. Once I finally reached the checkout I was informed that if I wanted the Mono or Digital stereo cd box they had one copy of the Mono CD boxset. It was my intention to purchase both the mono & stereo boxsets, especially the digital stereo boxset because it contained ‘ Let it be ‘ & ‘ Abbey Road’. Anyway I made a spur of the moment decision to buy the Mono CD boxset and didn’t buy the digital stereo boxset until a couple of years later. I’m so glad i invested in the Mono boxset as It’s unique and there’s nothing else like it on the Beatles CD market worldwide. The digital stereo boxset was made available for years making it far less collectible in my opinion.
Hi Adam, Great story and certainly a wise move under pressure, but the right decision! Equally good sets but like you said , available for much longer and certainly not as painstakingly accurate and unique as the mono box! Stay well my friend!
I have this set and the attention to detail is wonderful. I have a few of the 2014 mono vinyl LP albums too but they are now very difficult to find and cost a king's ransom. As the Mono CD set is still available and relatively affordable it is great to have.
Hi Dennis, It’s definitely a mini masterpiece this one without doubt! Yes I’ve been watching the 2014 mono albums steadily increase , clearly demand is always gonna be there ! Stay well!
The relative portability of this set is a major reason I sprang for this set. It beats the bulky stereo set on CD, but suffers from a lack of information that the trifols stereo has. A small price to pay. I also like abandoning the jewel cease. I’m a bit clumsy and have broken some jewel in my timr.
Hi, Yeh I think a nice book would have been a great addition to the mono set and the stereo should have been more like this one! Don’t worry , Jewel case breakages is very common! Stay well!
Hi beatledave! sorry my comment is a bit late, but better late than never 😅 You’ve got some really interesting CDs here and some really great mixes on this one, one of the best ways to hear their music in my opinion! Hope you stay well! -zack
Hi Zack, Never no problem! It’s as I say a miniature masterpiece, although the vinyl box equivalent is really slightly better in sound as was taken direct from the masters as opposed to a digital source! Thanks for watching, stay well!
Hi, Dave. Been busy and just got around to watching the video. What a brilliant package of CDs and in mono. The outer covers are beautiful and nicely laminated. The only album I have in mono is the White Album and decided not to open it to keep it pristine. Very nice purchase. Cheers
Hi G, No a problem, I know exactly what it’s like to have very little time to do anything! It’s a mini masterpiece and to think it’s already 14 years old! The white album is a great set and sounds brilliant in mono especially the 2014 reissue! Thanks for watching, stay well
I didn’t know that the Beatles had mono versions of their albums, until I bought the Beatles in stereo and mono simultaneously back in 2012 atmy favorite record store here in Portland Oregon which is Music Millennium. it blew me away how amazing the sound has improved in the stereo remastered in the mono versions and it’s great to hear unlimited versions of all the Beatles songs like blue Jay Way all you need is love revolver songs like taxman tomorrow never knows and love you too with the longer fade out and also got to get you into my life with the longer fade out which I love I think the packaging in the Beatles in mono is a really fantastic site I love it it’s great. and the way that it was put together was very much well done I do wish Apple would release the pills and mono on the vinyl that’s one box that I’ve been wanting to get and I regret not getting it.
Hi jesse, Yes indeed , that’s what is truly amazing about the Beatles Mono & Stereo versions , is we get plenty of different mixes , longer fad outs and little nuances here and there, such a great set of albums! I very much doubt that Apple would reissue the vinyl set but stranger things have happened, so we wait! Thanks for watching, stay well!
Hi there mate. Well, you did pick a good box set to show this time!!! Yes, the Stereo and the good old Rock Band just fun!!! I have a question for you mate. I know you like Beatles videos do you ever collect the bootleg Beatles dvd there are a lot out there lol!!! Great to see this and you know I do still keep on going back to this box set all the time!!! I do enjoy it and thanks for showing it. I do hope all is well at home and over there. All the best to you cheers mate!!!
Hey Good Buddy, Hope your well! Love this mini masterpiece, such a beautiful little set! Actually I don’t have many Bootleg DVD’s but I do have the Anthology original edition which is a bootleg and contains quite a lot of extra material interviews not broadcast! Not too bad here at the moment, certainly not looking forward to the winter, Brrrrrr! Stay well mate !
@@beatlebrad5339 We’ve had a lot of Rain over the last 2 months and quite a few places in the U.K. have had severe flooding too. So it’s gonna start getting cold soon!
Hi Dave, I was working in Euston on 09/09/09 and nipped down to HMV on Oxford Street in my lunch hour and picked up both the Mono and Stereo CD boxes. Probably the most expensive lunch I have ever had but worth every penny. I purchased the stereo vinyl box in 2012 but missed out on the mono vinyl box, it’s still on my wish list….maybe one day. Stay well 👍
Hi Marc, Yes I remember it being a very expensive time what with the Rockband set and guitars , all which I still have ! Was that the Flagship HMV which they are reopening soon! Thanks for watching, stay well!
I have the Mono CD box as well as most of the mono LP reissues from 2014. I stupidly sold my mono copy of Sgt Pepper because I didn't think I needed it any longer, thanks to he remix. ANyway, you made me go to my record shelf and take out my mono Please Please Me and just gaze at the beauty that was the original Parlophone design.
Hi Farrell, Those 2014 vinyl editions also sounds incredible possibly even better than the CD’s as they were direct from the master tapes. Yes I feel getting rid of your original Pepper probably wasn’t a good move long term. You’ve gotta love the gold design! Stay well!
So nice,B Dave , We recall the issue day,as if we're only 4 yr.s ago. A little celebration @ the store;&:the individual stereo albums( on CD,ya know) we're being offered at only 9.99 US.$,so got several of them upon release. Wasn't 'till couple years later that knew of the Greatness of Mono set. Turned out was one o' my Best 'bay' purchases,so far. We literally placed one large great speaker out on patio,gorgeous day& proceeded to be blown away with listening to 'Pepper,MMT.& White album,1stvtime ever - in Mono sound. Two fun days ,celebrating B.recordings,from my memory vault!! BD.,are you still looking for 1,2 the ' American issued albums', original.,great condition?? And, if so, can you do 'bay'purchase,from here, with little or very reasonable s& h.?? Tell u more in diff.format communique; but found beautiful ' Beatles 2nd,that I need,& Apple badfinger, other day. And friend has more; quite the collection. Talk at 'ya bro., Mike
Hi Mike, Good to hear from you ! That’s such a cool story about listening to the mono albums. I’m not surprised you were blown away , the mono mixes on Pepper, MMT & the White album are tremendous. Yes, I’m kinda still looking for some of the USA albums although i did manage to pick up a few from the Beatles convention in August. Ok I’ll await your communion elsewhere, sounds interesting! Stay well !
I love the mono mix of Sergeant Pepper and the revolver and even the white album is great too because there is lots of treasures in there and even rubber soul is great especially when John Lennon coughs before he sings the line so I looked around and I noticed there wasn’t A chair line in the song. What are your overall feelings of the Giles Martin remixes of the Beatles box that’s enough come out and do you love the Beatles red and blue but I’ve recently been remix what are your highlights for you and what are the ones that you wished were remix better as far as songs go both on the red and the blue album
Hi jesse, As I mentioned, I first heard the Beatles stereo albums in the early 1980’s and obviously with each consecutive album, the sound and the music seemed to improve. In 1982, I brought the Mono reissues and found a completely new experience listening to the albums with many differences between both mono & stereo. Ahh yes that cough on Norwegian Wood. I’ve gotta say on the new remixes , it sounds more like an intake of breathe! Which brings me to the new Red & Blue albums. Generally, I was extremely impressed with around 95% of all the sound quality and remixes. My main thoughts are , the Andy white version of Love me do should have been kept instead of the single version like on all previous Red albums. Also yellow Submarine should have been the stereo version remixed , not the mono version into stereo with the extra strum at the start and johns life of ease comment. Not that keen on the mixes of I am the walrus and also Old Brown shoe. I actually prefer the vinyl versions with the extra tracks in the third disc rather than being within the red & blue tracks. Finally, as much as I love Now & then , it doesn’t really belong on the blue album, it should have been a stand alone release. I think my favourite remixes are definitely the early tracks like Please Please Me ,Twist & Shout, A Hard Days Night , Ticket to ride aa well as Magical Mystery Tour , Fool on the hill, Hey Jude and many others. Thanks for watching, stay well!
Hello Dave! It was great to have the full mono albums on digital format for the first time. Although this set sounds good, IMHO, I think it deserves a second remastered version for digital format, as they sound already great on analog (vinyl). There also seems to be more counterfeits of it out there than genuine ones.
Hi FBT, After 14 years technology must have moved on considerably and probably does need an upgrade. The 2014 vinyl set does have a lovely sound to it which is clearly why they are in such demand! Thanks for watching!
Hi Stephen , It’s really done to personal taste and also depending on the album. For instance , I generally prefer the mono mixes of PPM, WTB, AHDN, RS, Revolver & Pepper. Beatles for sale and Help are better in Stereo, but I love both mono & Stereo mixes of the white album! It really is a personal choice but great to have the choice of both! Stay well!
I’m starting to think my copy’s a counterfeit: No rice paper sleeves or flipbacks, all discs have the “Emitex” inners (including Pepper & White Album)… Nonetheless, it’s a great box set! Thanks Dave!👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
@@beatledavesbeatleschannel also forgot to mention MMT doesn’t have the booklet or an actual opening on the sleeve to put the contents inside. Nonetheless, the sound quality (probably sourced from the legit version) is pretty good.👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
Hello Dave, my name is George van Copeland I am from Santa Cruz, the central coast of California. I liked what I saw on your channel and you are very very precise of what you doing, and are you going to unbox the stereo, cd box set any time soon? Once again, you are doing a very very cool thing on your channel dude keep doing it!!
Hi George, What a beautiful part of the world, would love to get to California one day , I’ve been to NYC so you never know! Oh yes I’m thinking of following up with the stereo box in the new year , so keep on watching! Glad your enjoying the channel, spread the word! Stay well!
Hello Beatle Dave, This is George Van Copeland again I just saw you presenting the stereo box that came out in 2009 yesterday and I am so stoked about what you just did. I can die a happy man now because you have shown the mono and the stereo boxes!! Thank you so much for doing that. I’ll wait when you do the unboxing of the The US albums box set that came out in January 2014. Dave… you’re a line of work on TH-cam is so awesome, The Beatles freaking rule this planet!!
Hi George, Nice to hear from you ! Glad you enjoyed the videos on both box sets, ahh yes absolutely will show the US albums cd set down the line for you ! Thanks for watching!
Nice video Dave. Prompted me to pull out my Mono boxed set for the first time in years. I noticed yours don't have the resealable plastic outer sleeves. Did you discard them? I also added plastic inner sleeves though I noticed I've kept mine outside the provided inner. It's a beautiful boxed set that I should revisit. Sorry I haven't been around much. Cheers mate. 😊
Hi Peter, Hope your well mate! I actually removed them just before shooting the video to save a bit of time , otherwise can get a bit complicated lol ! Such a great miniature masterpiece and a total shame the stereo box wasn’t equally as good in design! No problem mate , I’m always here to be found! Stay well!
@@beatledavesbeatleschannel you’re right it is two virgins that had full frontal nudity in that would make it fly off the shelves in Talibans Afghanistan
*"…with very inferior set becoming available and originating from China"* I was living in Shanghai in ‘09-‘10, where I picked up fake copies of both the stereo remasters and the mono set for around US$120 for both. The stereo remasters even included the USB thumb drive with the 24-bit flacs and software. In Shanghai you can (or could) get fakes of everything (I even bought a fake iPhone) ranging in quality from atrocious to nearly indistinguishable from the genuine. My sets fall much closer to the latter. Even the USB stem is still intact. Ironically, they even reproduced the FBI warning against unauthorized copying :)
Hi nathanael, Thanks for watching! That’s pretty incredible to think how quickly they were produced there! One must assume that the music quality would actually r the same being digital. Trouble is many people may have thought they had a real set only to find out it was a fake one! Stay well!
@@beatledavesbeatleschannelYou’re absolutely correct. In my case I was well aware it was fake when I bought it. The store was quite open about it. Lots of fake stuff in China - even bought a fake iPhone. But yes, lots of scammers ought there so you have to be careful.
Hi Dave! As per usual, this was such a great review of the an area of Beatles music history in which I never experienced. At 13 or 14 in 1984 I started my beatles vinyl collection. All that were available were stereo records. So you know pretty much the vinyl I possess from that period. In my mind then, I would have shunned mono even if it were available. I would have shunned it, assuming it was not as good as stereo and kind of old fashioned. I must say I am tempted to get this after your appraisal. It looks fab and I'm sure the listen would be a revelation. Well, better late than never. Do you also possess the equivalent in original mono on vinyl and how do they compare to these cds? God bless and take care my friend. Paul
Hi Paul, Very kind to say so. We are clearly a very similar age and I actually got the reissue mono editions in 1982 and I was totally amazed by them , the new listening experience after knowing all the stereo editions. Yes I’ve got the 2014 mono box set and in honesty , I feel the vinyl version is better as they were a direct transfer from the mono tapes , so not digitised. But it’s great to have the Mono Mini masterpiece too! Thanks for watching, stay well!
The best mixes of these albums, of course, even compared to the very good remixes of Sgt Pepper and the White Album. But the other thing to mention is that these covers are exactly as the originals, not butchered like the versions in stereo. So the attention to detail goes all the way to the correct colour grading for example Sgt Pepper is not as colourful as the horrid 2009 or 2017 versions, the colour is much more subtle, as Peter Blake intended. The White Album cover is a work of art by Richard Hamilton, and should be treated as such. Even the 2018 box, which is excellent, messed this up and presented the cover as a rectangle, when it should have been a beautiful super glossy,slightly off white square box….i know this sounds a bit obsessive but it feels important to me!
Hi Peter, Oh absolutely, the miniature artwork is just as striking and glossy like the original’s which adds to the charm of this box. If they’d made the Stereo box the same , they would have been on to another winner! With the reissues , once again if more and better detail was needed like glossy and Corrected colours , but for whatever reason (probably cost) they don’t seem to bother which is a shame when you think how costly they are. Never wrong with being obsessive, they need someone like you working for Apple so they get these reissues spot on! Stay well!
Hi. I am the lucky owner of this set and as always the Japanese are amazing in reproducing the covers. The stereo set is really ugly in comparison and that's why I bought many of the stereo CD's from Japan in their SHM versions. Beautiful and lavish presentation, but I can't hear any difference in the sound quality between the ordinary CD's and the SHM ones. Have you heard any of the SHM CD's?
Hi Thomas, Definitely a mini masterpiece and yes the Japanese put a lot of care into their cd reissues. Would’ve certainly been better if they’d made the stereo box along the same lines with perhaps the Japanese could have produced that too! I must be honest I haven’t heard those but I’m thinking they’ve gotta be reasonably similar sound wise, although SHM versions are supposed to me much better! Thanks for watching!
Beatles For Sale was really unrepressnted on the new red album. They should’ve left off the covers and added from here I’m a Loser and Baby’s in Black (possibly I’ll Follow The Sun). And of course I’m Only Sleeping should’ve had Rain in it’s place. What can you do though? It’s the bloody Beatles! Shut up 😂
Hi Tyrone, Definitely another couple of BFS tracks would have been nice with maybe a Revolver track or 2 less. Definitely should have put Rain on the set thou! Hard to please everybody I guess! Stay well!
I'm about to blow everyone's minds when I say this, but Revolver is technically, in a way, the White Album BEFORE the White Album! (Seriously, just think about it)
Hi Tom, Yeh I can see where you’re coming from but the white album is so diverse in styles, whereas Revolver does have more of a definite sound running through it! Stay well!
I have a friend who knowingly purchased a fake mono box and although the discs sound fine the detail is horrible, misspellings, blurry printing just a cheap imitation all around, 2009 was a great Beatle year just the same.
Hi Sailor Sam, Generally I’ve heard that the sound quality is pretty good but as you said, the attention to detail is not as good as the original issue. 2009 was a super and expensive year! Stay well!
@@beatledavesbeatleschannelI can't understand why Apple don't reissue these boxed sets through their site & authorised dealers. At least than fans would know they were shelling out on the real thing. The Beatles Red & Blue 2023 cd fakes are already on sale through marketolaces such as Ebay
The main point I was making is no one really knows how many were produced and which territories got what, I can’t mention everyone, just a generalisation, no need to feel excluded! A more interesting comment actually about the set would be better forthcoming than just being picky about how many were made and where they went! Stay well!
Hi, That does surprise me but it actually also depends on how good your sound system is, poor speakers will not give you the dynamics of any good quality music.
I think may be the reason why it doesn’t sound as good as probably your sound system I don’t think it has anything to do with the CDs them selves I would keep on listening to the monocytes who knows maybe the music will grind you each time find a good stereo system to listen to it on.
![ILLSLICK X YOUNGOHM - We're The same [Official Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/yUJNkobYR0E/mqdefault.jpg)
In my opinion for a CD box set, this set has never been surpassed for both the packaging and recording quality. Hats off to EMI and the Japanese execution of this beautiful creation. My most cherished CD box set.
Hi Christopher,
Hope your well !
Yes absolutely probably my favourite one too!
The Japanese involvement is what really nailed it for me perfectly miniaturised!
Thanks for watching!
Gday Dave, hope I find you well. I remember visiting JBHI fi in the Hobart CBD on the 9/9/09. I was cashed up and as you would expect there was also a line up of super enthusiastic Beatles fans eager to get their hands on the Mono or Stereo CD boxsets. I recall spending around 10 minutes in line awaiting my turn to reach the cash register. Once I finally reached the checkout I was informed that if I wanted the Mono or Digital stereo cd box they had one copy of the Mono CD boxset. It was my intention to purchase both the mono & stereo boxsets, especially the digital stereo boxset because it contained ‘ Let it be ‘ & ‘ Abbey Road’. Anyway I made a spur of the moment decision to buy the Mono CD boxset and didn’t buy the digital stereo boxset until a couple of years later. I’m so glad i invested in the Mono boxset as It’s unique and there’s nothing else like it on the Beatles CD market worldwide. The digital stereo boxset was made available for years making it far less collectible in my opinion.
Hi Adam,
Great story and certainly a wise move under pressure, but the right decision!
Equally good sets but like you said , available for much longer and certainly not as painstakingly accurate and unique as the mono box!
Stay well my friend!
I have this set and the attention to detail is wonderful. I have a few of the 2014 mono vinyl LP albums too but they are now very difficult to find and cost a king's ransom. As the Mono CD set is still available and relatively affordable it is great to have.
Hi Dennis,
It’s definitely a mini masterpiece this one without doubt!
Yes I’ve been watching the 2014 mono albums steadily increase , clearly demand is always gonna be there !
Stay well!
Ahh, Love that set ! We’ll never see cds so well packaged again, Dave👍 Beautiful companion to the vinyl box ❤️ See you soon, my friend !
Hi Nick,
The perfect miniature replica and I think your right , only the Japanese continue to produce high quality CD replicas!
Stay well!
thanks for the shout out and keep up the good work!!!!!
Hi Robert,
Your very welcome my friend, thanks for watching!
The relative portability of this set is a major reason I sprang for this set. It beats the bulky stereo set on CD, but suffers from a lack of information that the trifols stereo has. A small price to pay. I also like abandoning the jewel cease. I’m a bit clumsy and have broken some jewel in my timr.
Hi,
Yeh I think a nice book would have been a great addition to the mono set and the stereo should have been more like this one!
Don’t worry , Jewel case breakages is very common!
Stay well!
Hi Dave thanks for another great video, i absolutely love the Beatles Mono box, it looks great and sounds fabulous. Stay safe mate.
Hi James,
Yeh me too, definitely one of the best Box Sets produced Beatles related , a miniature masterpiece!
You too fella!
Hi beatledave! sorry my comment is a bit late, but better late than never 😅
You’ve got some really interesting CDs here and some really great mixes on this one, one of the best ways to hear their music in my opinion!
Hope you stay well!
-zack
Hi Zack,
Never no problem!
It’s as I say a miniature masterpiece, although the vinyl box equivalent is really slightly better in sound as was taken direct from the masters as opposed to a digital source!
Thanks for watching, stay well!
Hi, Dave. Been busy and just got around to watching the video. What a brilliant package of CDs and in mono. The outer covers are beautiful and nicely laminated. The only album I have in mono is the White Album and decided not to open it to keep it pristine. Very nice purchase. Cheers
Hi G,
No a problem, I know exactly what it’s like to have very little time to do anything!
It’s a mini masterpiece and to think it’s already 14 years old!
The white album is a great set and sounds brilliant in mono especially the 2014 reissue!
Thanks for watching, stay well
I didn’t know that the Beatles had mono versions of their albums, until I bought the Beatles in stereo and mono simultaneously back in 2012 atmy favorite record store here in Portland Oregon which is Music Millennium. it blew me away how amazing the sound has improved in the stereo remastered in the mono versions and it’s great to hear unlimited versions of all the Beatles songs like blue Jay Way all you need is love revolver songs like taxman tomorrow never knows and love you too with the longer fade out and also got to get you into my life with the longer fade out which I love I think the packaging in the Beatles in mono is a really fantastic site I love it it’s great. and the way that it was put together was very much well done I do wish Apple would release the pills and mono on the vinyl that’s one box that I’ve been wanting to get and I regret not getting it.
Hi jesse,
Yes indeed , that’s what is truly amazing about the Beatles Mono & Stereo versions , is we get plenty of different mixes , longer fad outs and little nuances here and there, such a great set of albums!
I very much doubt that Apple would reissue the vinyl set but stranger things have happened, so we wait!
Thanks for watching, stay well!
Hi there mate. Well, you did pick a good box set to show this time!!! Yes, the Stereo and the good old Rock Band just fun!!! I have a question for you mate. I know you like Beatles videos do you ever collect the bootleg Beatles dvd there are a lot out there lol!!! Great to see this and you know I do still keep on going back to this box set all the time!!! I do enjoy it and thanks for showing it. I do hope all is well at home and over there. All the best to you cheers mate!!!
Hey Good Buddy,
Hope your well!
Love this mini masterpiece, such a beautiful little set!
Actually I don’t have many Bootleg DVD’s but I do have the Anthology original edition which is a bootleg and contains quite a lot of extra material interviews not broadcast!
Not too bad here at the moment, certainly not looking forward to the winter, Brrrrrr!
Stay well mate !
Winter lol. Well, you need to Move to the south in the US :). So nice and now snow lol. Great video and see you later!!!
@beatlebrad5339
I need the sun all year round Brad!
:) I wish I could send it to you. You are getting into ⛄your Winter 🌧
@@beatlebrad5339
We’ve had a lot of Rain over the last 2 months and quite a few places in the U.K. have had severe flooding too.
So it’s gonna start getting cold soon!
Hi Dave, I was working in Euston on 09/09/09 and nipped down to HMV on Oxford Street in my lunch hour and picked up both the Mono and Stereo CD boxes. Probably the most expensive lunch I have ever had but worth every penny. I purchased the stereo vinyl box in 2012 but missed out on the mono vinyl box, it’s still on my wish list….maybe one day. Stay well 👍
Hi Marc,
Yes I remember it being a very expensive time what with the Rockband set and guitars , all which I still have !
Was that the Flagship HMV which they are reopening soon!
Thanks for watching, stay well!
I have the Mono CD box as well as most of the mono LP reissues from 2014. I stupidly sold my mono copy of Sgt Pepper because I didn't think I needed it any longer, thanks to he remix. ANyway, you made me go to my record shelf and take out my mono Please Please Me and just gaze at the beauty that was the original Parlophone design.
Hi Farrell,
Those 2014 vinyl editions also sounds incredible possibly even better than the CD’s as they were direct from the master tapes.
Yes I feel getting rid of your original Pepper probably wasn’t a good move long term.
You’ve gotta love the gold design!
Stay well!
@@beatledavesbeatleschannel and you, Dave, thank you.
:)
So nice,B Dave ,
We recall the issue day,as if we're only 4 yr.s ago. A little celebration @ the store;&:the individual stereo albums( on CD,ya know) we're being offered at only 9.99 US.$,so got several of them upon release. Wasn't 'till couple years later that knew of the Greatness of Mono set. Turned out was one o' my Best 'bay' purchases,so far.
We literally placed one large great speaker out on patio,gorgeous day& proceeded to be blown away with listening to 'Pepper,MMT.& White album,1stvtime ever - in Mono sound. Two fun days ,celebrating B.recordings,from my memory vault!!
BD.,are you still looking for 1,2 the ' American issued albums', original.,great condition?? And, if so, can you do 'bay'purchase,from here, with little or very reasonable s& h.?? Tell u more in diff.format communique; but found beautiful ' Beatles 2nd,that I need,& Apple badfinger, other day. And friend has more; quite the collection. Talk at 'ya bro., Mike
Hi Mike,
Good to hear from you !
That’s such a cool story about listening to the mono albums.
I’m not surprised you were blown away , the mono mixes on Pepper, MMT & the White album are tremendous.
Yes, I’m kinda still looking for some of the USA albums although i did manage to pick up a few from the Beatles convention in August.
Ok I’ll await your communion elsewhere, sounds interesting!
Stay well !
I love the mono mix of Sergeant Pepper and the revolver and even the white album is great too because there is lots of treasures in there and even rubber soul is great especially when John Lennon coughs before he sings the line so I looked around and I noticed there wasn’t A chair line in the song.
What are your overall feelings of the Giles Martin remixes of the Beatles box that’s enough come out and do you love the Beatles red and blue but I’ve recently been remix what are your highlights for you and what are the ones that you wished were remix better as far as songs go both on the red and the blue album
Hi jesse,
As I mentioned, I first heard the Beatles stereo albums in the early 1980’s and obviously with each consecutive album, the sound and the music seemed to improve.
In 1982, I brought the Mono reissues and found a completely new experience listening to the albums with many differences between both mono & stereo.
Ahh yes that cough on Norwegian Wood.
I’ve gotta say on the new remixes , it sounds more like an intake of breathe!
Which brings me to the new Red & Blue albums.
Generally, I was extremely impressed with around 95% of all the sound quality and remixes.
My main thoughts are , the Andy white version of Love me do should have been kept instead of the single version like on all previous Red albums.
Also yellow Submarine should have been the stereo version remixed , not the mono version into stereo with the extra strum at the start and johns life of ease comment.
Not that keen on the mixes of I am the walrus and also Old Brown shoe.
I actually prefer the vinyl versions with the extra tracks in the third disc rather than being within the red & blue tracks.
Finally, as much as I love Now & then , it doesn’t really belong on the blue album, it should have been a stand alone release.
I think my favourite remixes are definitely the early tracks like Please Please Me ,Twist & Shout, A Hard Days Night , Ticket to ride aa well as Magical Mystery Tour , Fool on the hill, Hey Jude and many others.
Thanks for watching, stay well!
Hello Dave! It was great to have the full mono albums on digital format for the first time. Although this set sounds good, IMHO, I think it deserves a second remastered version for digital format, as they sound already great on analog (vinyl). There also seems to be more counterfeits of it out there than genuine ones.
Hi FBT,
After 14 years technology must have moved on considerably and probably does need an upgrade.
The 2014 vinyl set does have a lovely sound to it which is clearly why they are in such demand!
Thanks for watching!
I watch this whole thing even though i have this box set lol. Dave do you have a pepper nimbus supercut?
Hi Will,
Sadly don’t have that set, it’s getting very expensive now too!
Stay well!
Dave, which sounds better , mono or stereo version ?
Hi Stephen ,
It’s really done to personal taste and also depending on the album.
For instance , I generally prefer the mono mixes of PPM, WTB, AHDN, RS, Revolver & Pepper.
Beatles for sale and Help are better in Stereo, but I love both mono & Stereo mixes of the white album!
It really is a personal choice but great to have the choice of both!
Stay well!
@@beatledavesbeatleschannel thanks Dave, just need to decide to part with over £200 now for it.🙄
Hi Stephen ,
Be mindful of fakes!
Stay well!
I’m starting to think my copy’s a counterfeit: No rice paper sleeves or flipbacks, all discs have the “Emitex” inners (including Pepper & White Album)… Nonetheless, it’s a great box set! Thanks Dave!👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
Hi Scott,
Yes does sound like it’s a counterfeit, but it’s a great set aa m sure sound wise it must be pretty close!
Stay well!
@@beatledavesbeatleschannel also forgot to mention MMT doesn’t have the booklet or an actual opening on the sleeve to put the contents inside. Nonetheless, the sound quality (probably sourced from the legit version) is pretty good.👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
Yes I think the sound quality of the tracks makes it sit better!
@@beatledavesbeatleschannel for sure. And I still forgot; Pepper doesn’t have the cut-out sheet either.
@@BeAGoodDoga:)
Hello Dave, my name is George van Copeland I am from Santa Cruz, the central coast of California. I liked what I saw on your channel and you are very very precise of what you doing, and are you going to unbox the stereo, cd box set any time soon? Once again, you are doing a very very cool thing on your channel dude keep doing it!!
Hi George,
What a beautiful part of the world, would love to get to California one day , I’ve been to NYC so you never know!
Oh yes I’m thinking of following up with the stereo box in the new year , so keep on watching!
Glad your enjoying the channel, spread the word!
Stay well!
Hello Beatle Dave, This is George Van Copeland again I just saw you presenting the stereo box that came out in 2009 yesterday and I am so stoked about what you just did. I can die a happy man now because you have shown the mono and the stereo boxes!! Thank you so much for doing that. I’ll wait when you do the unboxing of the The US albums box set that came out in January 2014. Dave… you’re a line of work on TH-cam is so awesome, The Beatles freaking rule this planet!!
Hi George,
Nice to hear from you !
Glad you enjoyed the videos on both box sets, ahh yes absolutely will show the US albums cd set down the line for you !
Thanks for watching!
Nice video Dave. Prompted me to pull out my Mono boxed set for the first time in years. I noticed yours don't have the resealable plastic outer sleeves. Did you discard them? I also added plastic inner sleeves though I noticed I've kept mine outside the provided inner. It's a beautiful boxed set that I should revisit. Sorry I haven't been around much. Cheers mate. 😊
Hi Peter,
Hope your well mate!
I actually removed them just before shooting the video to save a bit of time , otherwise can get a bit complicated lol !
Such a great miniature masterpiece and a total shame the stereo box wasn’t equally as good in design!
No problem mate , I’m always here to be found!
Stay well!
Beatle Dave ,question is in what countries is John and Yoko the wedding album prohibited uncensored?
Hi James,
Hope your well!
I must confess I didn’t know J&Y’s wedding album set was ever censored?
Do you mean Two Virgins?
Stay well!
@@beatledavesbeatleschannel you’re right it is two virgins that had full frontal nudity in that would make it fly off the shelves in Talibans Afghanistan
*"…with very inferior set becoming available and originating from China"*
I was living in Shanghai in ‘09-‘10, where I picked up fake copies of both the stereo remasters and the mono set for around US$120 for both. The stereo remasters even included the USB thumb drive with the 24-bit flacs and software.
In Shanghai you can (or could) get fakes of everything (I even bought a fake iPhone) ranging in quality from atrocious to nearly indistinguishable from the genuine. My sets fall much closer to the latter. Even the USB stem is still intact.
Ironically, they even reproduced the FBI warning against unauthorized copying :)
Hi nathanael,
Thanks for watching!
That’s pretty incredible to think how quickly they were produced there!
One must assume that the music quality would actually r the same being digital.
Trouble is many people may have thought they had a real set only to find out it was a fake one!
Stay well!
@@beatledavesbeatleschannelYou’re absolutely correct. In my case I was well aware it was fake when I bought it. The store was quite open about it. Lots of fake stuff in China - even bought a fake iPhone.
But yes, lots of scammers ought there so you have to be careful.
Hi Dave! As per usual, this was such a great review of the an area of Beatles music history in which I never experienced. At 13 or 14 in 1984 I started my beatles vinyl collection. All that were available were stereo records. So you know pretty much the vinyl I possess from that period. In my mind then, I would have shunned mono even if it were available. I would have shunned it, assuming it was not as good as stereo and kind of old fashioned. I must say I am tempted to get this after your appraisal. It looks fab and I'm sure the listen would be a revelation. Well, better late than never. Do you also possess the equivalent in original mono on vinyl and how do they compare to these cds? God bless and take care my friend.
Paul
Hi Paul,
Very kind to say so.
We are clearly a very similar age and I actually got the reissue mono editions in 1982 and I was totally amazed by them , the new listening experience after knowing all the stereo editions.
Yes I’ve got the 2014 mono box set and in honesty , I feel the vinyl version is better as they were a direct transfer from the mono tapes , so not digitised.
But it’s great to have the Mono Mini masterpiece too!
Thanks for watching, stay well!
@beatledavesbeatleschannel I appreciate your honest comparison of the vinyl to the cd versions. Thanks Dave!
:)
The best mixes of these albums, of course, even compared to the very good remixes of Sgt Pepper and the White Album. But the other thing to mention is that these covers are exactly as the originals, not butchered like the versions in stereo. So the attention to detail goes all the way to the correct colour grading for example Sgt Pepper is not as colourful as the horrid 2009 or 2017 versions, the colour is much more subtle, as Peter Blake intended. The White Album cover is a work of art by Richard Hamilton, and should be treated as such. Even the 2018 box, which is excellent, messed this up and presented the cover as a rectangle, when it should have been a beautiful super glossy,slightly off white square box….i know this sounds a bit obsessive but it feels important to me!
Hi Peter,
Oh absolutely, the miniature artwork is just as striking and glossy like the original’s which adds to the charm of this box.
If they’d made the Stereo box the same , they would have been on to another winner!
With the reissues , once again if more and better detail was needed like glossy and Corrected colours , but for whatever reason (probably cost) they don’t seem to bother which is a shame when you think how costly they are.
Never wrong with being obsessive, they need someone like you working for Apple so they get these reissues spot on!
Stay well!
@@beatledavesbeatleschannel from what I can see the red and blue albums reissues were also messed up, non glossy covers and cheaper mayerials
Oh yes that’s also true, I looked at the detail of the pictures which isn’t that great either!
Hi. I am the lucky owner of this set and as always the Japanese are amazing in reproducing the covers. The stereo set is really ugly in comparison and that's why I bought many of the stereo CD's from Japan in their SHM versions. Beautiful and lavish presentation, but I can't hear any difference in the sound quality between the ordinary CD's and the SHM ones. Have you heard any of the SHM CD's?
Hi Thomas,
Definitely a mini masterpiece and yes the Japanese put a lot of care into their cd reissues.
Would’ve certainly been better if they’d made the stereo box along the same lines with perhaps the Japanese could have produced that too!
I must be honest I haven’t heard those but I’m thinking they’ve gotta be reasonably similar sound wise, although SHM versions are supposed to me much better!
Thanks for watching!
Beatles For Sale was really unrepressnted on the new red album. They should’ve left off the covers and added from here I’m a Loser and Baby’s in Black (possibly I’ll Follow The Sun). And of course I’m Only Sleeping should’ve had Rain in it’s place. What can you do though? It’s the bloody Beatles! Shut up 😂
Hi Tyrone,
Definitely another couple of BFS tracks would have been nice with maybe a Revolver track or 2 less.
Definitely should have put Rain on the set thou!
Hard to please everybody I guess!
Stay well!
I'm about to blow everyone's minds when I say this, but Revolver is technically, in a way, the White Album BEFORE the White Album!
(Seriously, just think about it)
Hi Tom,
Yeh I can see where you’re coming from but the white album is so diverse in styles, whereas Revolver does have more of a definite sound running through it!
Stay well!
@@beatledavesbeatleschannel It was a joke about the album cover, but good point.
I got the so called fake,for about £25 10 years ago and it certainly sounds good to me,I would never pay £300 for it that’s for Loonies
Hi Alf,
Yes that’s a very good price and you get all the digital mono mixes quality wise too!
Crazy prices these days!
Stay well!
@@beatledavesbeatleschannelCheers Dave and the same to you mate
:)
I have a friend who knowingly purchased a fake mono box and although the discs sound fine the detail is horrible, misspellings, blurry printing just a cheap imitation all around, 2009 was a great Beatle year just the same.
Hi Sailor Sam,
Generally I’ve heard that the sound quality is pretty good but as you said, the attention to detail is not as good as the original issue.
2009 was a super and expensive year!
Stay well!
@@beatledavesbeatleschannelI can't understand why Apple don't reissue these boxed sets through their site & authorised dealers. At least than fans would know they were shelling out on the real thing.
The Beatles Red & Blue 2023 cd fakes are already on sale through marketolaces such as Ebay
Hahaha why 10k for UK, EU and or USA? So the rest of the world was excluded? Now that’s funny.
The main point I was making is no one really knows how many were produced and which territories got what, I can’t mention everyone, just a generalisation, no need to feel excluded!
A more interesting comment actually about the set would be better forthcoming than just being picky about how many were made and where they went!
Stay well!
I still regret buying it. Sounds like garbage.
Hi,
That does surprise me but it actually also depends on how good your sound system is, poor speakers will not give you the dynamics of any good quality music.
I think may be the reason why it doesn’t sound as good as probably your sound system I don’t think it has anything to do with the CDs them selves I would keep on listening to the monocytes who knows maybe the music will grind you each time find a good stereo system to listen to it on.