prophet Muhammad peace be upon him is rehmatul lil alamin... This lesson by Brthr Nouman increases our love to our beloved prophet more... JazakaAllah brthr Nouman...
Ma-Sha-Allah! I have always wondered, Why would God need to change his decision? But this video cleared my doubt. Allah changed the Qibla to please his messenger. Sub-hān-Allah!
Narrated `Abdullah bin `Umar: Once I went upstairs in Hafsa's house and saw the Prophet (ﷺ) answering the call of nature with his back towards the Qibla and facing Sham. (Sahih al-Bukhari 3102)
Sir I have a question: What made you to conclude that this is the reason that Qibla was changed to Kaaba? Is this also a Hadeeh/Hadees? Kindly mention why Prophet (PBUH) wanted Kaaba as His Qibla. The only reason you mentioned is that Kaaba was build by Ibrahim (AS). But then my question is if GOD wills was AQSA then why His Messenger (PBUH) wished for KAABA. Why Prophet (PBUH) was UNHAPPY with the God's will? Your guidance is much appreciated sir. Thanks indeed..
Jarel Ahmed in sha Allah the message will reach to every human being. that is why we keep whatever we do absolutely free and available to every human being. :)
For additional info, The Holy Land that Allah commanded Nabi Musa P.B.U.H with Bani Israel to enter is not in City of Elia(Jerusalam/Baitul Maqdis) otherwise its City of Arihah(Jericho). Barokallahu fi kum.
Reading the earliest Islamic sources, they mention the location of al-Aqsa mosque: In the Book of Raids, early Muslim historian and biographer Waqidi described Muhammad’s stay in the village of Jiranah a few miles outside Mecca. He wrote, “The Prophet arrived in Jiranah on Thursday, and remained 13 nights. He then departed Jiranah after praying at the Al-Aqsa Mosque located on the shore of the river bed. The Prophet used to pray there whenever he came to Jiranah.” Another early historian, Azraqi, described in his book Mecca and its Antiquities a discussion between two men named Muhammad ibn Tariq and Mujahid. Muhammad said, “Mujahid and I agreed on Jiranah, because he informed me the Prophet used to pray at the Al-Aqsa Mosque located on the shore of the river bed. The other nearby mosque, the Al-Adna Mosque, was built by a man from the Quraysh tribe.” Another early Mecca historian, Ibn Ishaq al-Fakihi noted in his book Ancient and Modern Mecca that Muslims who wanted to perform the Umrah would first purify themselves at the neighboring villages of Tanim and Jiranah. The Al-Adna Mosque in Tanim was significant because Muhammad’s wife Aisha had purified herself there, and the Prophet himself had prayed in the Al-Aqsa Mosque in Jiranah. The above sources all indicate that the Al-Aqsa Mosque referred to by Muhammad in Quran 17:1 was the mosque in Jiranah. The famous mosque known today by the same name in Jerusalem was built almost a century later, started by al-Malik and finished by his son al-Walid in 705 AD.
Qibla is the direction of the true religion that Ibrahim built. It's not a physical house and it's not a physical direction that you face. God is saying to face the masjidul al haram wherever you're which basically means to follow the guidance (religion of Ibrahim) which was implemented in masjidul al haram wherever you're. God will not change the qibla (direction of the religion) therefore he made the prophet face the true religion which he will be pleased and redirect to us from which we turned away (we was facing the false religion) and so that we returned to the true path.
Please , please, please remove the annoying humming! This is important information being given in the lecture about the Qiblam, Kabah, The Prophet (SAW). Why oh why do people add humming / nahseed/ music etc in the background. It's actually becomes disrespectful. I'm trying so hard to understand the information and I can't.
@@battery._.low123 There is no evidence for this outside of one late text (the Quran). None of our earliest sources (the books of the OT) ever mention that Abraham built the Kaaba or went to Mecca, none of the other prophets ever mention this, say to worship the Kaaba and none of them have ever talked about or went on the pilgrimage. We have details of much shorter travels by the prophets, but they all forget to mention the ~1200km journey south, hmmm... Jesus never bothers to mentioned the Kaaba and he went to Jerusalem. There is no archaeological evidence to date Kaaba to be that old either. The ONLY source for this is the Quran, which makes this rather hard to believe since all other an d much earlier sources contradict this narrative.
When someone takes out verses from the Quran to explain a topic you MUST include from which surah it’s from and verse because there’s people learning for them selves and to make sure you’re not lying about something that’s not true because today’s leaders in Islam are quoting the Hadiths more instead of Quran, for example leaders in Islam say Quran says women must cover their heads with a hijab to be modest???? I can’t find any evidence in surah 24:31 about hijab, niqab or burka??? What i understand and in my research that women should not expose their private parts when in public and should dress modestly. Where’s covering your face,hair,hands,feet come from? When someone tells me that men should not dress like women then why do today’s Arab men wear a headscarf 🧕??? because from behind you will look like a woman in a hijab? Why do Arab men wear long dress? Why do Arab men wear gold robes? Isn’t wearing anything that looks like gold or silk forbidden for men in Islam because women wear that? Even if it’s fake gold or silk it’s still the same because it looks real from a distance. Imagine if men didn’t have beards and they are wearing a long fake silk dress with fake gold stripes and a head scarf (hijab) from a distance i would think that’s a woman approaching me??? So why do Arab men dress like women? I was always told not to dress like woman. Some Arab men look like transgender people for example a woman that has a beard? That’s why in surah 24:31 women should look like a woman but dress modestly and not to cover their heads and faces, how do I know if it’s a woman or a man under a niqab or burka???? All this confusion is because people read the corrupted Hadiths and they don’t follow the Quran correctly that’s why i will never follow corrupted Hadiths that was written 200 years after the prophets death and if there was true Hadiths then they have all been fabricated and changed. But nobody will ever change the Quran because god is protecting the Quran and not the fabricated Hadiths. The sunnah in Islam is the Quran so follow the sunnah which the prophet was teaching the people and if you follow the fabricated Hadiths then you will be following the devils path. Allah gave you on option follow god path or follow devils path. So do you want to follow the devils path (fabricated Hadiths) OR do you want to follow god path (Quran) and you cannot choose both only one because only one will get you heaven. Which one will you choose?
@Ca11MeZed Bro I'm not a quranist but something bother me and want to ask you as you look clever. 1. As you know Allah is the only judge right but why when we die 2 Angels will question us in the kabar that mean judge us and will even punish us before the day of judgement then what will be the purpose of the day of judgement. That's a big contradiction to me as it's not in the Quran. Please clarify that with solid proof as I will not reject Quran and believe bukhari on that. 2. Allah says to pray him alone so why in swalat we put prophet Muhammad pbuh side by side with Allah like reading atthiyat, darood Ibrahim, in shahada and so on. Can you show me a hadith to convince us prophet Muhammad pbuh told us what to read exactly in swalat or that come from bukhari. 3. If hadith is so important and need to follow as some people use more than Quran. So why prophet Muhammad pbuh did not allow anyone to write his hadith when he was alive and if need hadith and quran to complete islam so why prophet Muhammad pbuh did not write it himself every thing he done, that is the sunnah how he was living his life, the rules and practices outside Quran. Why a man after not 1, 20 but 200 or more years after his death should tell us what the sunnah and what to follow and now if I'm not follow this man I will be a kafir which worried me and I'm confuse and Allah said only sunnah is the sunnah of the Quran and only hadith is the hadith of the Quran. So where should I go now, Quran or bukhari or both please need help here. I'm not debating , looking for discussion or argument. I'm just looking for proof and answers to remove that stress I'm getting thinking of these all the time so please show the proof salaam.
Brothers first of all may Allah accept your efforts and may Allah accept it from all of us.. good work Jazzakumullahu Khairan. I am watching all the videos Al hamdulillah. In this video I have a doubt. The entire theme Which Bro. Nauman explained is what confused me. when I read 2:142-145. When I have heard from the seerah n understood that Allah wanted to Check them whether they are following the Prophet Muhammad Sallallahu Alaihi wa Sallam or their own desires. So in the verse 143 Allah explains it. If you read it from Baqara Verse 142 till 145. Just need clarification
Unconvincing answer. What is your source? So does that mean that pbuh was always south of mecca when he prayed towards both in the first 10 years? Logistically that was impossible.
There are logically two reasons. First of all I am not muslim so my answers are logical. 1) Muhammed prayed facing towards the jerusalem for 10 years or so. But the jewish community did not accept him as their prophet. So by changing the direction from aqsa to haram he was sending a message to Jews that this is what you get for rejecting me. And we can also see how allah revealed it so late that the pre islamic pagan shrine was actually built by abraham. Why did he not say earlier when they were facing jerusalem ? Muhammed is making his own stories as he goes along. 2) he saw pagans do it and it felt right. So facing in the direction of kabaa did not feel wrong. This is more than hilarious allah changes the direction of prayer to please a man.
Then why the early mosques in 100 years after muhammad died, are not facing mecca? There are more than 20 early mosques that are not facing mecca today 🤔 They are not facing jerussalem nor facing mecca either 🤔 Could some one explain me, please?
So zion in the holy land , is the holiest place on earth , according to the Torah , and the original Qibla was also directed to it , but you Muslims say , that it was suddenly changed by God , Allah himself ( swt ) , just to please a Human being ??? But Allah says in the Quran , that he never changes ... That was the law of Allah in the case of those who lived before and there will never be any change in the law of Allah. (Surah al-Ahzab, 33:63). {Such was Our) system in the case of those whom We sent before you {to mankind), and you will never find change in Our system. (Surah Bani Israil, 17:77). Had the disbelievers fought against you, they would take to flight and would have found no guardian or helper. This is the Sunnah (law) of Allah which existed before you, and you will never find any change in Allah's system, (Surah al-Fath, 48:23). Evil plots only affect the plotters. Do they expect anything other than (Allah's) law (torment) with those who lived before? You will never find any change in the tradition of Allah nor will you find any alteration in it. (Surah al-Fatir, 35: 43).. So what happened here with the direction of the Qibla , or with the topic of Adoption ? . Why suddenly Allah is accepting al kinds of Changes in his book , just to please people ? . If you look at Quranic terms , God is ( Al-Wahid ) and ( Al-Ahad ) , or one absolute unit. If he changes he is not constantly one. God is Al-Hayy or ever living. He cannot change to better to live more as he is already ever living. He cannot change to worse to have shortened lifespan, as he is eternal. God is ( Al-Haqq ) or The Truth. The truth doesn’t change to lesser truth. God is perfect. That means his truth is already the perfect truth. It cannot change into a better truth as it is already perfect... I left Islam 25 years ago , as i was a shia Muslim from Batumi ( the Republic of Georgia ) ... Today i am an Israelite , believing only in the first 5 books of Moses , and nothing that comes after . Meaning not the complete Tanach , but rather just the Torah ...
@@PresidentJeanAuguste Not true at all ... Cause the Quran itself is saying that the Qibla was changed in the Days of prophet Muhammad (Pbuh).. The Qibla status of the Kaaba ( or the Sacred Mosque in which it is located ) is based in the Quran , verses 144 , 149 , and 150 of the al-Baqarah chapter in the Quran , in where each verse contains a command to turn your face toward the Sacred Mosque ( Fawalli wajhaka Shatr Al-Masjid Il-Haram ). Those verses were revealed in the month of Rajab , or Shaban in the second Hijri year ( 623 CE ) , 15 or 16 months after Muhammad's migration to Medina , and Prior to these revelations , Muhammad and the Muslims in Medina had prayed towards Jerusalem as their qibla , the same direction as the prayer direction the mizrah , used by the Jews of Medina. Islam says that these verses were revealed during a prayer congregation , where Muhammad and his followers immediately changed their direction from Jerusalem to Mecca in the middle of the prayer ritual. The location of this event became the Masjid al-Qiblatayn ( The Mosque of the Two Qiblas ). To conclude , Allah changed his mind , and contadicted his first truth , to a so called better truth ...
So you could be happy ? Was he unhappy with the first Qibla ? Why dont you demonstrate by scientific evidence - archeology of the first mosques for example - it will be more convincing demonstration.
Muhammad changed the qibla because the Jews rejected his message. If Mecca is the most important place on Earth, why would Allah not make Muhammad pray towards it from the beginning, why wait over 10 years?
@@theastronomer5800 The fools among the people will say: “What has turned them from the Qiblah to which they were used?” Say: To Allah belong both East and West; He guides whom He pleases to a Way that is straight. (Quran 2:142) (P.S. “The fools” in this context are those who criticize the change of qiblah, without any understanding of the matter.)
@@cat-uq5hw Reading the tafsirs on 2:142 we find Ibn Kathir reporting al-Bukhair "Imam Al-Bukhari reported that Al-Bara' bin `Azib narrated: "Allah's Messenger offered his prayers facing Bayt Al-Maqdis (Jerusalem) for sixteen or seventeen months, but he WISHED that he could pray facing the Ka`bah (at Makkah)" In 2:144 we read "Surely, We shall turn you to a Qiblah (prayer direction) that shall PLEASE YOU, so turn your face in the direction of Al-Masjid Al-Haram " Sounds like Muhammad wanted his own qibla, and Allah delivered. Why have the Jews and Christians never prayed towards the Qiblah of Ibrahim (in Mecca)? The Jewish religion has been around for over 1500 years at the time of Muhammad, yet this is never mentioned. Not a single prophet mentions the Kaaba in Mecca or the pilgrimage to it. Why? It's funny that even back in Muhammad's time, when someone simply questioned something in Islam they were called foolish, narrow-minded, absurd, blind, misled (these are all from the Quran/tafsirs) etc. Nice god and religion!
why Qibla face changed from Jerusalem to mecca?. Political mistakes happen to mecca and medina people's and issues was created by Jews people's like forests fires. Prophet Muhammad was suffer that how to solve problems Even Umar Bin khatib and some other friends have given some good ideas to face qibla to mecca and mecca become purity in world number one holy city. finally Allah has changed problems with good politics and to face Qibla to mecca. So Mecca people's became cool down had about this news better than Jerusalem and Jews plans was destroyed.
Habeeb Aslam no doubt Quran is true . If you are a true Muslim establish it evidently to prove non Muslims wrong for that only one things need to do , that is to prove archeologicaly the city macca existed before 700 / 150 hizri . And studying and discovering is more appropriated than believing blindly. For your information, in Quran the word macca used once and bacca used once . Jerusalem is a holly city not the kibla . I must be wrong correct me with verse number so I can check it out . Changed kibla is masjidul al haram what might not be the same mosque what we know till now, because of the lacking of archeological evidence in first 100 yea rs of Islam. It’s not because the Quran is wrong or right it because we may be misguided about the city macca in some point . I am Muslim I think it’s my duty to find what happened and I am trying to find the answer, you must do so .
@@isratnipa5965Bible says idolatry is a sin... Exodus 20:2-5 KJV I am the Lord thy God, which have brought thee out of the land of Egypt, out of the house of bondage. [3] Thou shalt have no other gods before me. [4] Thou shalt not make unto thee any graven image, or any likeness of any thing that is in heaven above, or that is in the earth beneath, or that is in the water under the earth: [5] Thou shalt not bow down thyself to them, nor serve them: for I the Lord thy God am a jealous God, visiting the iniquity of the fathers upon the children unto the third and fourth generation of them that hate me; Muslims.... Go to kaba.... And kiss that black stone.. This also idolatry...
Truly amazing how extraordinary our prophet (PBUH) was, and the Kindness of Allah (SWT)
prophet Muhammad peace be upon him is rehmatul lil alamin... This lesson by Brthr Nouman increases our love to our beloved prophet more... JazakaAllah brthr Nouman...
May Allah(swt) reward you for sharing these amazing stories and knowledge. إن شاء الله Allah(swt) is pleased with us and keep us all steadfast Aameen.
Ma-Sha-Allah! I have always wondered, Why would God need to change his decision?
But this video cleared my doubt.
Allah changed the Qibla to please his messenger. Sub-hān-Allah!
Don't be too disapointed by the truth: th-cam.com/video/9TiwKUWUgJI/w-d-xo.html
Islam is for all of mankind, not just profit muhammad. God did not change the Qibla just to please one man.
This was actually very emotional, I felt that "chill" down my spine! SubhanAllah!
Narrated `Abdullah bin `Umar:
Once I went upstairs in Hafsa's house and saw the Prophet (ﷺ) answering the call of nature with his back towards the Qibla and facing Sham.
(Sahih al-Bukhari 3102)
SubhanALLAH .. Jazak ALLAh khair for sharing this video.. May ALLAH bless you.
Love the explanation, is quiet interesting!
Sir I have a question:
What made you to conclude that this is the reason that Qibla was changed to Kaaba?
Is this also a Hadeeh/Hadees? Kindly mention why Prophet (PBUH) wanted Kaaba as His Qibla.
The only reason you mentioned is that Kaaba was build by Ibrahim (AS). But then my question is if GOD wills was AQSA then why His Messenger (PBUH) wished for KAABA. Why Prophet (PBUH) was UNHAPPY with the God's will?
Your guidance is much appreciated sir. Thanks indeed..
Its coming on my exam tomorrow so i am watching. Thank you so much 🙇
If only 1.6-1.7 billion Muslims in the world subscribed to this channel.
Jarel Ahmed in sha Allah the message will reach to every human being. that is why we keep whatever we do absolutely free and available to every human being. :)
FreeQuranEducation what is the importance of Qibla?
+FreeQuranEducation Mashallah,Keep up the good work.Jazakallahu khairan.☺
For additional info, The Holy Land that Allah commanded Nabi Musa P.B.U.H with Bani Israel to enter is not in City of Elia(Jerusalam/Baitul Maqdis) otherwise its City of Arihah(Jericho). Barokallahu fi kum.
Reading the earliest Islamic sources, they mention the location of al-Aqsa mosque:
In the Book of Raids, early Muslim historian and biographer Waqidi described Muhammad’s stay in the village of Jiranah a few miles outside Mecca. He wrote, “The Prophet arrived in Jiranah on Thursday, and remained 13 nights. He then departed Jiranah after praying at the Al-Aqsa Mosque located on the shore of the river bed. The Prophet used to pray there whenever he came to Jiranah.”
Another early historian, Azraqi, described in his book Mecca and its Antiquities a discussion between two men named Muhammad ibn Tariq and Mujahid. Muhammad said, “Mujahid and I agreed on Jiranah, because he informed me the Prophet used to pray at the Al-Aqsa Mosque located on the shore of the river bed. The other nearby mosque, the Al-Adna Mosque, was built by a man from the Quraysh tribe.”
Another early Mecca historian, Ibn Ishaq al-Fakihi noted in his book Ancient and Modern Mecca that Muslims who wanted to perform the Umrah would first purify themselves at the neighboring villages of Tanim and Jiranah. The Al-Adna Mosque in Tanim was significant because Muhammad’s wife Aisha had purified herself there, and the Prophet himself had prayed in the Al-Aqsa Mosque in Jiranah.
The above sources all indicate that the Al-Aqsa Mosque referred to by Muhammad in Quran 17:1 was the mosque in Jiranah. The famous mosque known today by the same name in Jerusalem was built almost a century later, started by al-Malik and finished by his son al-Walid in 705 AD.
Masha'Allah 💚
Mashallah ummah ❤
Best video for kids❤️❤️❤️❤️
very useful thanks
Qibla is the direction of the true religion that Ibrahim built.
It's not a physical house and it's not a physical direction that you face. God is saying to face the masjidul al haram wherever you're which basically means to follow the guidance (religion of Ibrahim) which was implemented in masjidul al haram wherever you're.
God will not change the qibla (direction of the religion) therefore he made the prophet face the true religion which he will be pleased and redirect to us from which we turned away (we was facing the false religion) and so that we returned to the true path.
Is there any hadees or any other authenticated evidence which tells that muhammad (saw) used to face towards baitul muqaddas first?
beautiful :)
Please , please, please remove the annoying humming! This is important information being given in the lecture about the Qiblam, Kabah, The Prophet (SAW). Why oh why do people add humming / nahseed/ music etc in the background. It's actually becomes disrespectful. I'm trying so hard to understand the information and I can't.
After how many years/ months Qibla changes the direction?
15 shaban on monday
17 months
I have heard that hazart Adam AS build qaba and if so it was the first qibla why was it changed to Jerusalem in the first place
Ibrahim AS built the Kaaba not Adam AS
@@battery._.low123hazrat Ibrahim AS raised the walls of qaba its base was already build by Adam AS
@@battery._.low123 There is no evidence for this outside of one late text (the Quran). None of our earliest sources (the books of the OT) ever mention that Abraham built the Kaaba or went to Mecca, none of the other prophets ever mention this, say to worship the Kaaba and none of them have ever talked about or went on the pilgrimage. We have details of much shorter travels by the prophets, but they all forget to mention the ~1200km journey south, hmmm... Jesus never bothers to mentioned the Kaaba and he went to Jerusalem. There is no archaeological evidence to date Kaaba to be that old either. The ONLY source for this is the Quran, which makes this rather hard to believe since all other an d much earlier sources contradict this narrative.
subhanAllah !!
Languages .. destiny 😢 ummah
When someone takes out verses from the Quran to explain a topic you MUST include from which surah it’s from and verse because there’s people learning for them selves and to make sure you’re not lying about something that’s not true because today’s leaders in Islam are quoting the Hadiths more instead of Quran, for example leaders in Islam say Quran says women must cover their heads with a hijab to be modest???? I can’t find any evidence in surah 24:31 about hijab, niqab or burka??? What i understand and in my research that women should not expose their private parts when in public and should dress modestly. Where’s covering your face,hair,hands,feet come from? When someone tells me that men should not dress like women then why do today’s Arab men wear a headscarf 🧕??? because from behind you will look like a woman in a hijab?
Why do Arab men wear long dress? Why do Arab men wear gold robes? Isn’t wearing anything that looks like gold or silk forbidden for men in Islam because women wear that?
Even if it’s fake gold or silk it’s still the same because it looks real from a distance. Imagine if men didn’t have beards and they are wearing a long fake silk dress with fake gold stripes and a head scarf (hijab) from a distance i would think that’s a woman approaching me??? So why do Arab men dress like women? I was always told not to dress like woman. Some Arab men look like transgender people for example a woman that has a beard? That’s why in surah 24:31 women should look like a woman but dress modestly and not to cover their heads and faces, how do I know if it’s a woman or a man under a niqab or burka???? All this confusion is because people read the corrupted Hadiths and they don’t follow the Quran correctly that’s why i will never follow corrupted Hadiths that was written 200 years after the prophets death and if there was true Hadiths then they have all been fabricated and changed. But nobody will ever change the Quran because god is protecting the Quran and not the fabricated Hadiths. The sunnah in Islam is the Quran so follow the sunnah which the prophet was teaching the people and if you follow the fabricated Hadiths then you will be following the devils path. Allah gave you on option follow god path or follow devils path. So do you want to follow the devils path (fabricated Hadiths) OR do you want to follow god path (Quran) and you cannot choose both only one because only one will get you heaven. Which one will you choose?
@Ca11MeZed Bro I'm not a quranist but something bother me and want to ask you as you look clever.
1. As you know Allah is the only judge right but why when we die 2 Angels will question us in the kabar that mean judge us and will even punish us before the day of judgement then what will be the purpose of the day of judgement. That's a big contradiction to me as it's not in the Quran. Please clarify that with solid proof as I will not reject Quran and believe bukhari on that.
2. Allah says to pray him alone so why in swalat we put prophet Muhammad pbuh side by side with Allah like reading atthiyat, darood Ibrahim, in shahada and so on. Can you show me a hadith to convince us prophet Muhammad pbuh told us what to read exactly in swalat or that come from bukhari.
3. If hadith is so important and need to follow as some people use more than Quran. So why prophet Muhammad pbuh did not allow anyone to write his hadith when he was alive and if need hadith and quran to complete islam so why prophet Muhammad pbuh did not write it himself every thing he done, that is the sunnah how he was living his life, the rules and practices outside Quran. Why a man after not 1, 20 but 200 or more years after his death should tell us what the sunnah and what to follow and now if I'm not follow this man I will be a kafir which worried me and I'm confuse and Allah said only sunnah is the sunnah of the Quran and only hadith is the hadith of the Quran. So where should I go now, Quran or bukhari or both please need help here.
I'm not debating , looking for discussion or argument. I'm just looking for proof and answers to remove that stress I'm getting thinking of these all the time so please show the proof salaam.
Brothers first of all may Allah accept your efforts and may Allah accept it from all of us.. good work Jazzakumullahu Khairan. I am watching all the videos Al hamdulillah. In this video I have a doubt. The entire theme Which Bro. Nauman explained is what confused me. when I read 2:142-145. When I have heard from the seerah n understood that Allah wanted to Check them whether they are following the Prophet Muhammad Sallallahu Alaihi wa Sallam or their own desires. So in the verse 143 Allah explains it. If you read it from Baqara Verse 142 till 145. Just need clarification
Shuaib ahmed brother he said there are many reasons he highlight one of them...
Finally they r changing islam.Thank god they believe in round earth now
650 Rippin Haven
What if muhammad (saw) had to pray at his home?
Unconvincing answer. What is your source? So does that mean that pbuh was always south of mecca when he prayed towards both in the first 10 years? Logistically that was impossible.
There are logically two reasons. First of all I am not muslim so my answers are logical.
1) Muhammed prayed facing towards the jerusalem for 10 years or so. But the jewish community did not accept him as their prophet. So by changing the direction from aqsa to haram he was sending a message to Jews that this is what you get for rejecting me. And we can also see how allah revealed it so late that the pre islamic pagan shrine was actually built by abraham. Why did he not say earlier when they were facing jerusalem ? Muhammed is making his own stories as he goes along.
2) he saw pagans do it and it felt right. So facing in the direction of kabaa did not feel wrong.
This is more than hilarious allah changes the direction of prayer to please a man.
Armando Shore
nice video my brother
Why did he don't like to pray fasing Jerusalem
Its a good job dont you think, Im pretty sure the IDF would be urinating there. Allah knows the future and we dont know anything .
Sorry !Typo - that's 'Qibla' in the previous comment. That's my point, I couldn't even get the comment down properly because of the humming. :(
Kakkaka
Barton Ferry
Abbott Meadows
Then why the early mosques in 100 years after muhammad died, are not facing mecca? There are more than 20 early mosques that are not facing mecca today 🤔
They are not facing jerussalem nor facing mecca either 🤔
Could some one explain me, please?
@Sub Zero • 7 years ago 😂😂😂
I read a paper that a mosque in indonesia is changing direction, meaning its still happening.
Rubie Inlet
Dibbert Roads
5026 Kreiger Locks
The verse is nothing to do with the direction of prayers.
There was no Aksa during Mohammed's life and tbe quibila in mecca belongs to khureshis
So zion in the holy land , is the holiest place on earth , according to the Torah , and the original Qibla was also directed to it , but you Muslims say , that it was suddenly changed by God , Allah himself ( swt ) , just to please a Human being ???
But Allah says in the Quran , that he never changes ...
That was the law of Allah in the case of those who lived before and there will never be any change in the law of Allah. (Surah al-Ahzab, 33:63).
{Such was Our) system in the case of those whom We sent before you {to mankind), and you will never find change in Our system. (Surah Bani Israil, 17:77).
Had the disbelievers fought against you, they would take to flight and would have found no guardian or helper. This is the Sunnah (law) of Allah which existed before you, and you will never find any change in Allah's system, (Surah al-Fath, 48:23).
Evil plots only affect the plotters. Do they expect anything other than (Allah's) law (torment) with those who lived before? You will never find any change in the tradition of Allah nor will you find any alteration in it. (Surah al-Fatir, 35: 43)..
So what happened here with the direction of the Qibla , or with the topic of Adoption ? .
Why suddenly Allah is accepting al kinds of Changes in his book , just to please people ? .
If you look at Quranic terms ,
God is ( Al-Wahid ) and ( Al-Ahad ) , or one absolute unit. If he changes he is not constantly one.
God is Al-Hayy or ever living. He cannot change to better to live more as he is already ever living. He cannot change to worse to have shortened lifespan, as he is eternal.
God is ( Al-Haqq ) or The Truth. The truth doesn’t change to lesser truth.
God is perfect. That means his truth is already the perfect truth. It cannot change into a better truth as it is already perfect...
I left Islam 25 years ago , as i was a shia Muslim from Batumi ( the Republic of Georgia ) ...
Today i am an Israelite , believing only in the first 5 books of Moses , and nothing that comes after .
Meaning not the complete Tanach , but rather just the Torah ...
It could mean that Muslims after Muhammad (pbuh) changed the direction of the Qibla, not Muhammad (pbuh).
@@PresidentJeanAuguste
Not true at all ...
Cause the Quran itself is saying that the Qibla was changed in the Days of prophet Muhammad (Pbuh)..
The Qibla status of the Kaaba ( or the Sacred Mosque in which it is located ) is based in the Quran , verses 144 , 149 , and 150 of the al-Baqarah chapter in the Quran , in where each verse contains a command to turn your face toward the Sacred Mosque ( Fawalli wajhaka Shatr Al-Masjid Il-Haram ).
Those verses were revealed in the month of Rajab , or Shaban in the second Hijri year ( 623 CE ) , 15 or 16 months after Muhammad's migration to Medina , and Prior to these revelations , Muhammad and the Muslims in Medina had prayed towards Jerusalem as their qibla , the same direction as the prayer direction the mizrah , used by the Jews of Medina.
Islam says that these verses were revealed during a prayer congregation , where Muhammad and his followers immediately changed their direction from Jerusalem to Mecca in the middle of the prayer ritual.
The location of this event became the Masjid al-Qiblatayn ( The Mosque of the Two Qiblas ).
To conclude , Allah changed his mind , and contadicted his first truth , to a so called better truth ...
It was us who changed not the prophet
subhan Allah
Isobel Route
Kuhic Station
What about the study done by Dan Gordon where he discovered that the old mosques pointed towards Petra.
someone explain this vid to me
So you could be happy ? Was he unhappy with the first Qibla ? Why dont you demonstrate by scientific evidence - archeology of the first mosques for example - it will be more convincing demonstration.
What rational believer channel on do muslim pray towards the Kaaba
Coy Fork
Allah changed the Qibla so that we wouldn't be praying towards the zionists. I love Allah
Muhammad changed the qibla because the Jews rejected his message. If Mecca is the most important place on Earth, why would Allah not make Muhammad pray towards it from the beginning, why wait over 10 years?
@@theastronomer5800 The fools among the people will say: “What has turned them from the Qiblah to which they were used?” Say: To Allah belong both East and West; He guides whom He pleases to a Way that is straight.
(Quran 2:142)
(P.S. “The fools” in this context are those who criticize the change of qiblah, without any understanding of the matter.)
@@cat-uq5hw Reading the tafsirs on 2:142 we find Ibn Kathir reporting al-Bukhair "Imam Al-Bukhari reported that Al-Bara' bin `Azib narrated: "Allah's Messenger offered his prayers facing Bayt Al-Maqdis (Jerusalem) for sixteen or seventeen months, but he WISHED that he could pray facing the Ka`bah (at Makkah)"
In 2:144 we read "Surely, We shall turn you to a Qiblah (prayer direction) that shall PLEASE YOU, so turn your face in the direction of Al-Masjid Al-Haram "
Sounds like Muhammad wanted his own qibla, and Allah delivered.
Why have the Jews and Christians never prayed towards the Qiblah of Ibrahim (in Mecca)? The Jewish religion has been around for over 1500 years at the time of Muhammad, yet this is never mentioned. Not a single prophet mentions the Kaaba in Mecca or the pilgrimage to it. Why?
It's funny that even back in Muhammad's time, when someone simply questioned something in Islam they were called foolish, narrow-minded, absurd, blind, misled (these are all from the Quran/tafsirs) etc. Nice god and religion!
Zionism did not exist in the time of Muhammad. (pbuh) Also I hate zionism, as a Jew. I love Islam!
why Qibla face changed from Jerusalem to mecca?.
Political mistakes happen to mecca and medina people's and issues was created by Jews people's like forests fires.
Prophet Muhammad was suffer that how to solve problems Even Umar Bin khatib and some other friends have given some good ideas to face qibla to mecca and mecca become purity in world number one holy city. finally Allah has changed problems with good politics and to face Qibla to mecca. So Mecca people's became cool down had about this news better than Jerusalem and Jews plans was destroyed.
Muslims kibla was never towards Jerusalem it was towards petra. See devid Gibson’s study or book .
@@casasolita-homealone5505 why need to study book?. go to history of mecca or study holy quran clear true history
Habeeb Aslam no doubt Quran is true . If you are a true Muslim establish it evidently to prove non Muslims wrong for that only one things need to do , that is to prove archeologicaly the city macca existed before 700 / 150 hizri . And studying and discovering is more appropriated than believing blindly. For your information, in Quran the word macca used once and bacca used once . Jerusalem is a holly city not the kibla . I must be wrong correct me with verse number so I can check it out . Changed kibla is masjidul al haram what might not be the same mosque what we know till now, because of the lacking of archeological evidence in first 100 yea
rs of Islam. It’s not because the Quran is wrong or right it because we may be misguided about the city macca in some point . I am Muslim I think it’s my duty to find what happened and I am trying to find the answer, you must do so .
2nd comment
😂😂😂 hilarious
Islam is a pagan religion... not of Abrahamic
@seeker celt continue your mission as more as u non muslims humiliate islam will become more stronger
@Sub Zero • 7 years ago let's see in the end of the day who is right
@@UPCakes-hz5en Ya Rabb Ameen
Says those who r still worshipping the idol of jesus
@@isratnipa5965Bible says idolatry is a sin...
Exodus 20:2-5 KJV
I am the Lord thy God, which have brought thee out of the land of Egypt, out of the house of bondage. [3] Thou shalt have no other gods before me. [4] Thou shalt not make unto thee any graven image, or any likeness of any thing that is in heaven above, or that is in the earth beneath, or that is in the water under the earth: [5] Thou shalt not bow down thyself to them, nor serve them: for I the Lord thy God am a jealous God, visiting the iniquity of the fathers upon the children unto the third and fourth generation of them that hate me;
Muslims.... Go to kaba.... And kiss that black stone.. This also idolatry...
LOL PURE LIES
2nd comment