This is the result if SM actually lets their artists sing live instead of getting them lip sync. Ever since 4th gen they started to just lip sync almost all the time to show perfection.
@@ljiu I think the montage of sherlock view dream girl and everybody is lipsync because I think I heard Jonghyun's voice(or it could be a very loud backtrack im not sure). But their dont call me and hard is definitely live because i can hear them breathing as they sang. Also some parts they sound louder or softer as they adjusted the mic. doing all that dance and still sounding like you swallowed a cd is incredible
@@mypotionoflove yes, I do think most of it was lip synced as they seem to be focusing more on the dancing. The last 2 songs was live and it was a pleasure to watch ❤️
@@AllureALERT I watched more carefully, and yeaa... definitivamente a loot of live vocals... amazing. they are just 3 people and with that hard choreography, they did it so well!
The best show ever. SHINee has always been legends for 15 years, even at the beginning of 2024. Everything is wonderful. The dancing and the performance. They always deserve the best. SHINee are the precious jewel of K-Pop. In my opinion, this show deserves to be the best.
@@Hahahahahaleuleuleu I hope so too! There're now rumours that Taemin and Onew leave SM, I hope they will stay in Shinee though and will have another comeback 🩵
솔직히 멜뮤 멋진 친구들 너무 많았지만 조금씩 아쉬움이 남았었는데 역시 내 음악 입맛은 샤이니인가보다.. 샤이니 그냥 평생을 좋아해도 받은 이 카타르시스를 어떻게 보답할까 싶어ㅠㅠ 너무 고맙고 사랑해.. 오래오래 보자 멋진 구성, 편곡 해준 2센터 a&r 감사해요 덕분에 눈물흘리구.. 손덜덜떨면서 이시간만큼은 10년 전 멜뮤를 보며 샤이니 응원하고 울고웃던 12살의 저로 돌아갔던 기분이었어요!❤
![K-EVER KPOP LIVE [VOD]](http://yt3.ggpht.com/YhDtK8W3RWH-Qmh6XEwFor9ukQOhnLg3vdm55wMb3zxJbgv9FzJqN5X-0wwLS72005yyEEUu3w=s48-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj)
![[4K/공간음향] 샤이니 - 셜록, HARD, Lucifer, 링딩동 (현장중계 풀버전) / SHINEE](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/bKn-CVh7D2o/mqdefault.jpg)
![[4K/공간음향] 샤이니 - 셜록, HARD, Lucifer, 링딩동 (현장중계 풀버전) / SHINEE](/img/tr.png)
![[MMA2023] SHINee FULL Performance | #Sherlock #View #DreamGirl #Everybody #DontCallMe #HARD #MMA2023](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/C8mU9iHnbus/mqdefault.jpg)
이건 걍 진짜 기강잡으러 나온거 아니냐ㅋㅋㅋ
This is the result if SM actually lets their artists sing live instead of getting them lip sync. Ever since 4th gen they started to just lip sync almost all the time to show perfection.
I dont wanna be rude, but for me it was mostly lip singing... idk, no? I dont want to be rude
@@ljiu I think the montage of sherlock view dream girl and everybody is lipsync because I think I heard Jonghyun's voice(or it could be a very loud backtrack im not sure). But their dont call me and hard is definitely live because i can hear them breathing as they sang. Also some parts they sound louder or softer as they adjusted the mic. doing all that dance and still sounding like you swallowed a cd is incredible
@@mypotionoflove yes, I do think most of it was lip synced as they seem to be focusing more on the dancing. The last 2 songs was live and it was a pleasure to watch ❤️
@@AllureALERT I watched more carefully, and yeaa... definitivamente a loot of live vocals... amazing. they are just 3 people and with that hard choreography, they did it so well!
Shinee devoured the stage just as 15th year veterans should!👏👏
Correct!🎉
저 날은 모든 가수 팬들 다 입모아 말했다
샤이니가 레전드였다고
The best show ever. SHINee has always been legends for 15 years, even at the beginning of 2024. Everything is wonderful. The dancing and the performance. They always deserve the best. SHINee are the precious jewel of K-Pop. In my opinion, this show deserves to be the best.
They just awakened my soul. Now that's how you do an awards show performance!
15년째 춤 완빡으로 핸드마이크로 라이브까지 진짜 너무 멋있다고 2008년데뷔인데 2023에도 얼굴들봐..
그냥 케이팝의 근본임. 15년차 였는데도 계속 성장 중이며. 형들의 자리였던 메인, 리드 보컬 없이 동생들로 독기 서린 무대만 봐도 끝났음. 퍼포먼스 다 하고 마지막 라이브만 봐도 끝났지~~💚🩵
12분동안 숨못쉬면서봄
무대를 찢는게 아니라 아주 두들겨패네
샤이니 팬 아닌데 샤이니 오늘 무대보니까 참 찡하네
팬들이 뭘 좋아하는지 알기에 연차가 쌓여도 그 흐트러지지않는 무대 센스? 가 여전히 돋보이네
마지막 HARD 진짜 HARD하게 가셨네 이 무대를 준비할때 그 느낌으로 쭉 가주시길 부탁
All of them covered Onew's parts very well! The stage presence as always was fire, and so are they! 🔥 Shinee's back!
Did he leave the group?
@@fatimanasr3888 on hiatus for health reasons
@@fatimanasr3888 no, he's on hiatus due to some health issues
Hope Onew can comeback soon. Miss him much 😢
@@Hahahahahaleuleuleu I hope so too! There're now rumours that Taemin and Onew leave SM, I hope they will stay in Shinee though and will have another comeback 🩵
와 태민이 몸 부숴져라 추는데 찐 아이돌이다. ㅠㅠ 샤이니 스키니진 입던때부터 응원해!!!
와 미쳤따......이 연차에 이 열정과 빡셈 말이 되나......입 벌리고 봤다....
개쩐다 진짜
하,,, 진심 이 무대 케이팝에 의미있고 역대급이고,,, 그런 레전드 무대다
SHINee is everything. Without them I wouldn’t know what K-pop is!
The definition of real and pure kpop nothing can surpass this perfection
와 2세대가 k-pop의 근본이다
빛나는 샤이니가 샤이니 했네 역시!!
Really looked like Taemin was fired up💥... the energy from the crowd must've got em all going💥 They're forever amazing
The stage present is unmatched❤ LEGENDS ❤
Even as 3 pieces, they're still amazing. So glad that Onew is back now.
The 2nd generación demostrando por que fue, es y sera la mejor generaclon del K pop
지독하게 잘하고 지독하게 멋있다 샤이니ㅜㅜㅜㅠㅠ
솔직히 멜뮤 멋진 친구들 너무 많았지만 조금씩 아쉬움이 남았었는데 역시 내 음악 입맛은 샤이니인가보다..
샤이니 그냥 평생을 좋아해도 받은 이 카타르시스를 어떻게 보답할까 싶어ㅠㅠ 너무 고맙고 사랑해.. 오래오래 보자
멋진 구성, 편곡 해준 2센터 a&r 감사해요 덕분에 눈물흘리구.. 손덜덜떨면서 이시간만큼은 10년 전 멜뮤를 보며 샤이니 응원하고 울고웃던 12살의 저로 돌아갔던 기분이었어요!❤
I hope onew comes back i miss seeing him with them but I put his health first so I hope he heals soon and feels better
셜록탬부터 미쳣다 여전히 멋있네여
멜론 공계에는 하이라이트만 있어서 찾아헤매다가 이제야 만났네요ㅠㅍㅍ
선배님들 기강 제대로 잡고 가시네 ❤ 역시 샤이니..... 내 시절 아이돌이라 그런거 아니고 정말로 멋쪄부러
Legends will always be legends MY GOD
Hard is the best stage performance song for MMA 2023.
I love this so much. They’re doing Onew so well. ❤ I can’t wait for the group to be together again.
역시 샤이니는 비교불가다
Theres no one can beat them!!!!
미쳤다.. 소름
멋잇따 샤이니❤
Seriously this is pure gold!
태민 처음에 날아다니네..ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
Congratulations our lovely SHINEE 💕✨🥀💫🎉💐🙏❣️
셋이라고 무대안비게 더 열심히하네ㅜ
Congratulations SHINee🎉
Shinee called a legend for a reason 👌 it proved
Eles sustentam performance demais!!! ✨🤍 Deuses demais
ЛУЧШИЕ
bro was really curious 😭🙏
종현이까지 있는 5명 완전체 셜록무대 다시보고싶다
PERFEITOS
the crowd isn't turnt up enough 😭 id be levitating
아 눈물나냐 ㅠㅠ
요즘 아이돌들은 진짜 보고 배워라 저게 15년차 아이돌들이 맞냐? 한곡한곡 마이크 떨어져라 무대하는데 요즘은 걍 설렁설렁 ar만 입힐줄 알고 라이브는 개판이고ㅋㅋ
지금 보니까 키 눈썹 상처 그렸네요 어쩐지 비주얼이 달라보이더라니... 이래저래 빛나는 키 빛나는 샤이니에요^^
Our Best Choice - MINHO! 🍀 See you at the Multi-Choice 2024 ✨
Shinee самые лучшие ❤❤❤❤❤
Boss shinee❤
AMOOOOOO
Вау❤️🔥❤️🔥❤️🔥
I hope Onew gets better soon 🥺
👏👏👏
❤❤❤
다 아는노래구먼..
absolutely devoured
민호도 장발했으면 좋겠다....
Where is Onew ?
Wait wheres ONEW
Where is onew
He's on a break to take care of his health :)
@@aaaz1872 oh
Gws
But where was Onew 😮?
He is recuperating physically and mentally and will come back when he recovers
I’m suprise no Lucifer
온유는 어디감
Where is onew i love them together 😢
he's on hiatus due to health issue
그냥 케이팝의 근본임. 15년차 였는데도 계속 성장 중이며. 형들의 자리였던 메인, 리드 보컬 없이 동생들로 독기 서린 무대만 봐도 끝났음. 퍼포먼스 다 하고 마지막 라이브만 봐도 끝났지~~💚🩵
😍😍😍😍