The Battle of Stalingrad was the bloodiest and deadliest battle in *human history.* The Axis (Germans, Hungarians, etc.) suffered around 800,000 casualties. The Soviets suffered around 2,600,000 casualties. I want you to count up to 3,400,000, and just imagine that every number that you counted was a human person, with their own morals, ideals, and lives. Husbands, fathers, and sons. The average life expectancy in Stalingrad was *twenty-four hours.* ...
Firstly, the average human lifespan was 15 minutes. Secondly: not the bloodiest, the most bloody was the Rzhev slaughterhouse (as I remember, but this may be real)
“The street is no longer measured by meters but by corpses ... Stalingrad is no longer a town. By day it is an enormous cloud of burning, blinding smoke; it is a vast furnace lit by the reflection of the flames. And when night arrives, one of those scorching howling bleeding nights, the dogs plunge into the Volga and swim desperately to gain the other bank. The nights of Stalingrad are a terror for them. Animals flee this hell; the hardest stones cannot bear it for long; only men endure.” ― Officer of the 24th Panzer division
Во время войны моему дедушке было где-то 16 лет. Он жил в Сталинградской области в 70 км. от Сталинграда. Немцы не смогли дойти до его деревни но один раз один самолёт збросил бомбы. Он сам работал повозчиком и возил продовольствие и воду. Практически всю войну через его деревню вели пленных немецких солдат, некоторые из них умирали по дороге и оставались лежать на обочине. Зимой когда выпал снег вдоль дороги были тысячи бугорков и детям было страшно ночью там идти. То есть трупы были даже в тылу. Потом их собрали и скинули в силусную яму. В 70-х в деревню приехали родственики немецих солдат и искали свидетелей, дедушка знал где их закопали. Они ездили по всем полям, балкам, тыкали в землю, дедушка пытался вспомнить, смотрел по карте, так и не нашли. До сих пор не нашли. То есть если где-то начать копать то можно найти сотни скелетов с обмундированием.
Так и немцы тоже в этой битве потеряли больше чем американцы во всей войне. Сталинград , это памятник человеческой глупости и жестокости. 1000000 душ навечно заперты в этом городе герое
Yes, it was a battle between two of the strongest and most developed countries of that time (in a military sense). Despite the fact that the German army was more experienced and had good tactics, the Soviet army quickly learned how to fight too. And Stalingrad was an proof of that.
@@myhonorwasloyaltyThat's your only argument, and the dude who answered you just destroyed it. By the way, the Americans who landed in France had the same numerical superiority. P.S. I forgot to mention General Frost, who won the whole war on his own
the west front was a war so big it would shadow every war since 1945. But the East was so much more people, so much more extreme policies, so much less brotherhood between the sides. the weather, the scale, the swiftness, no mercy@@VideoBee_YT
My man you really have just said respect to nazis and commies who were commiting horiffic war crimes and were just covering themselves with "I was just following orders"
stop generalizing people, not all of them were nazis and in fact majority of war crimes commited by the Wehrmacht were commited by ordinal soldiers because of orders of their officers and generals. Winners are writting the history and many thing are told only in generalities, without any details.
quick question, is the lesson to respect soldiers or not follow orders blindly or something like that? or to not invade Russia when it is cold as fuck?
As my grandmother told me (she was 8 years old during the war in Stalingrad), the Germans there, who were disappointed in the policies of Hitler, sided with civilians and the USSR, they helped quietly, who could do what they could, one German soldier brought bread to my grandmother (there was not much, about 30 grams) but this piece of bread was just happiness, brought milk, brought hay to put under clothes in the cold season. As a result, they somehow noticed him and decided to execute him in front of my grandmother (my grandmother Chu barely understood German, but she remembered the last words), stop crying, you're good for surviving, and I pray and I will pray to God that I would live on "... after which shots were fired and the body of the good And the generous soldier fell to the cold ground. Rest in peace, soldiers of all countries who fought for humanity. Thanks to that soldier who saved my grandmother's life, because without my grandmother, there would be no dad and mom, and there would be no me. Thank you to everyone who read my long but very sincere message, I wish peace and goodness all over the world, may all wars end, because we are given a language to speak and negotiate, and not to raise a gun against a person. P.s tnx from Crimea
If there's pne thing we can be certain of, it's that the germans were literally praised as heroes in many areas of the eastern front. Your story Is a steaming pile of rancid fowl excrement pouring from the gutter of wretched evil that is your mouth
@@Burningwhisky96 if they weren't evil then they wouldn't have commited so many war crimes on Jews and Slavic people and this movie just tries to humanise nazis and show that "not all of them were bad" which is really stupid because just because that 0.1% wasn't evil doesn't mean anyone should even shed a single tear for those bastards
Why are people arguing in the comments about who lost more people, who made the biggest contribution to the victory, I am from Russia and all my life I was taught to honor all the victims of the Second World War, like the Russians, the Germans and the Allies.
This movie looks like someone came to Stalingrad during the battle in 1942 and recorded everything with a color camera. This movie is too realistic and historically authentic.
If anyone hasn't seen this film yet, watch it, its far better than any other movies about stalingrad like the awful dogshit Enemy at the Gates or the state-propaganda-esque Stalingrad 2014. Like Das Boot its in the same vein of extremely realistic brutal nihilistic war movies that don't hold back, although I don't doubt Stalingrad was 1000x more brutal. The Eastern Front has been neglected in the more mainstream big-budget movies (specifically Hollywood, predictably) though obviously there's plenty great Russian/German/Polish/Ukrainian films on it (and ofc other Eastern European countries, but these made the most well known films on that front). Importantly though the practical effects in this film are just fantastic, I mean expansive bleak landscapes or cityscapes, and ofc all the real vehicles with pyrotechnics. But surprisingly the narrative and characters stand out amidst all the chaos, and it doesn't pull any punches into the end of the film.
Right on. I think there is a reason why Germans produced such deep, soulful movies such as Stalingrad and Das Boot - when your nation was on the losing side, it's impossible to sneak in any of that idolizing heroism which is often hiding in Hollywood movies. Here are no heroes, no artificial naratives of a happy end, just raw despair, with such a humane characters. I thought this movie was not very well known, so I'm glad I'm not the only one who was deeply touched by Stalingrad!
I think the soviet movie stalingrad made in the 50s can also be interesting to watch, using tons of real military equipment, and the movie under supervision of general von paulus himself for the most realism.
I don’t know if a person can make a film, even with a budget of a billion dollars, a complete picture of Stalingrad, or even any battle of WW2, it was complete fucked up, one soldier died every 7 seconds
One of the best edits I've seen. At 0:56 when he asks "And how's he supposed to pay if he's dead?" followed by silence, and then the insanely brutal fighting in the factories. Gives me goosebumps every time.
This battle is not taught in Western Schools and as a American who studies WW2 as a hobby in High School, I think it is a shame and disappointment that this one battle is not stated as the turned point of the war, and that it is being forgotten.
You act like the battle of Stalingrad is a niche event during the war that only few talk about lol when in fact most people would immediately mention it whenever the topic of the Eastern Front is brought up.
You should see the battle of Kursk it was the true turning point in the war. It was the most decisive battle which determined the future of the third reich. A point of no return.
dude its a common talk you cannot talk about WW2 whitout these massive event Dunkerk, Pearl Harbor, the battle of Moscow, Lenigrad, Stalingrad, Okinawa, Midway, D Days and the battle of Berlin that pretty much standard teaching in pretty much the entire Western World
@logangoulet7522 what are you on about we do acknowledge everyone that fought during the great war your just yapping i littrealy pointed the fact that almost in every western country when it come from ww2 your are mostly learning from important point most of it on the Eastern Front western education is mostly on the contribution of each country like you know the fact the allies helped the soviet get there industry back in track while if your in russia you will be mostly teach How the Soviet fought alone and pretty much only learn the eastern front whit probably a small part on the Japanese defeat but that it whitout going into why there so many millions dead in the eastern front
@logangoulet7522 dude i aint american im Canadian from a people that did a lot for Europe while not having any real reason to help my grand father volunteered before the conscription was even in place and fought during D-days so i dont want any crap from a dude that think that the soviet are the reason Europe was liberated when they put dictatorships on half the continent and build a iron curtain that to this day still remain in Europe
@@BigJo95 lmao they have never been friends, the US/western gov has been trying to interfere with Russia for ages, blaming Russia for random garbage like your elections and later trying to expand natos borders and their treatment of Russian speakers
Most people abuse it. I've never met a deep thinker over my 73yrs, 56yrs living in the U.S. (especially so), and visiting, living in some 40 countries. Most people, mindless robots living in the moment. 'People are to stupid, degenerate to save' AH
@@lectorkaveli2816 You speak very generally. Also u speak very confident about yourself, it seems that you have met everyone in person to know what they really want to do 🤣🤣
Многие не осознают, что СССР потерял 26,6 млн человек во второй мировой войне.... Update: Для сравнения, население Австралии оценивается в 25 млн человек.
@@Зауральеэто не минимальные, а официально подтверждённые, до сих пор, иногда, находят остатки или сведения о погибших. Минимальные были у СССР сразу после войны, где возможности подсчитать количество жертв не было и назвали только военные потери, вроде как 18 миллионов.
The Eastern Front in WW2 Was So Bloody Litterally A war of Annihilation between two Giants it's the closest thing us humans ever got to hell, Stalingrad And Kursk Were Hell On Earth May All Good Souls Who were lost in ww2 Rest in peace especially the ones lost on the eastern front
да. подписываюсь под каждым словом! Вся эта неблагодарная европа должна восхвалять и чтить, всех советских солдат, положившие головы в этой войне! Только благодаря ним (а не какой то ублюдской америке. - которая, как обычно прилетела в конце, как коршун глодать труп), они живут сейчас более менее хорошо. А вместо этого, они по указке очередных фашистов, сносят памятники великим героям. Учите историю, ублюдки! Вы следующие! Ничто не будет забыто, никто не будет забыт!
Франция пала за 38 дней - в Сталинграде за 38 дней немцам удалось перейти улицу. France fell in 38 days - in Stalingrad the Germans managed to cross the street in 38 days.
@@Rainnyash да никто не спорит. Просто Франция не достойна столько унижений. Все страны в начале войны терпели одни поражения от немцев, просто СССР большой, поэтому было время прийти в себя.
"Typically, the way a war works is one side runs out of ammo, food, or men; for the unlucky ones it's all three at the same time. So what happened in Stalingrad? It's simple. It's what happens when one side has a near unlimited supply of men, and the other unlimited bullets. You get Stalingrad, a war that raged for 3 bloody years over crumbling ruins, with neither side truly winning.
Thank you for your services and your sacrifices. I hope life has treated you well since then. 🫡 (I’m sorry if you’re not able to translate this comment, I had to translate yours)
One of the best war films I’ve ever watched. Truly depicts the horrors of war instead of sugarcoating it like many other movies. This, Das Boot, Land of Mine are some of my favourite.
This was the perfect edit ı had ever seen about World War II. Putting the original music of movie in ending was perfect. Words can't describe what happened in Stalingrad.
@maulfickmanfred1796 Какая победа?! Это победа над самым главным врагом белых людей - нацистской германией. Но для выживания белой расы еще предстоит победить великое замещение. В Дании уже есть подвижки по этому поводу. В России и Германии пока не вижу таковых, следовательно если ничего не сделать самому ничего не изменится. Привет из России
@maulfickmanfred1796это была защита славян и всей восточной Европы, немцы к сожалению сделали только хуже для всего белого населения, истребив миллионы его лучших сынов
@@st_oop Many Nazi soldiers surrendered to the American army and many lived to an older age in the United States. Even engineers and scientists. Argentina hosted Nazi engineers and technicians to modernize the army Something not very different from what the United States did. The German immigration dates back long before Hitler...
When he said how's he supposed to pay you if he's dead, then he stops smiling right after that and it goes into the grosome fighting, you did really good editing right there ngl. Easily one of the best edits I've ever seen.
Ксати, офигенный фильм. Когда я был еще маленьким у меня был диск этого фильма. P.s. жалко что герои умерли также просто и бессмысленно, как и самая война.
Only thing that really bothers me is the translation ant 03:27 The Hauptmann (Captain) says: "Jetzt ist aber schluss mit der rumjuderei" Which literally translates into "Enough jewing around". An important little note just to mirror the antisemitism in his mind.
@@Alpha-bo1xh this is good translation, "bottles of water" would not make much sense in this case in english, for english speaker milk is brought up as drink for children. Translation must make sense to viewer, it can't be literal. Now this "jewing around" being omitted is obviously attempt to censor the dialogue, which is awful and translator should never do it.
Only one side invaded on another's territory, destroyed cities, burned down villages and killed over 10 million civilians. No, they're not the same. Get your "everyone's equally bad" garbage out of here.
@@kindlingking The Russians did the same thing all accros Europe when the war turned in their favor, and some European countries remained enslaved to the USSR until its fall. Even before the war, the Soviets invade Poland and tried to do the same thing in Finland, before the outnumbered Finns threw the commies and their tanks out woth their tails low. The USSR also killed significantly more people than Germany did. They absolutely were just as horrible as the Nazis. Hell, at least the Nazis had the decency to mostly kill foreigners, while the commies gleefully genocided their own people.
@@SkeletonXinThe Russians had the right to do it after all the evil from Germans in my country. Nevertheless, Russian never destroyed the population based on the nationality.
весь ссср был таким в моментах было не так жестко но даже те кто находились рядом с японией ощущали всю войну хоть война и была рядом с москвой жалко что я не помню как погиб мой прадед но знаю ток то что он убил и ранил не малу нацистов
My uncle’s was an officer in the German army from 1938 to 1945 and his last words were:Fritz, Erik look at what we all died for , the world is now a place of constant and abominations…
There’s a reason as a 20 something-year-old girl I wear rings from Germans, Romanians, Russians, and Hungarians at Stalingrad on all fingers. I also wear a dog tags. I have three on right now taken from the zaritysia Balka gumrak and Rosschonka- also one from pitomink - these items have incredible energy and I get to carry a little piece of Stalingrad grad with me every day. It’s nice because it makes me think well if people could survive that I can pretty much survive anything and they’re beautiful trench art jewelry pieces
Remember! Through the centuries, through the years - remember! About those who will never come again - remember! Don't cry! In the throat, restrain the moans, bitter moans. Be worthy of the memory of the fallen! Eternally worthy! Be worthy with bread and song, Dreams and poems, a spacious life, every second, every breath! People! As long as hearts are pounding, remember! At what price happiness was won - please remember! When you send your song flying, remember! About those who will never sing again - remember! Tell your children about them so that they will remember! Tell the children's children about them so that they will also remember! At all times of the immortal Earth , remember! Leading ships to the twinkling stars - remember the dead! Meet the trembling spring, people of the Earth. Kill the war, curse the war, people of the Earth! Carry your dream through the years and fill it with life!.. But for those who will never come again, I conjure you, remember!
I'm half German, my Belgian side had a doctor who made radio scans for the Germans (which got him 4 years in prison, which sucked considering the hospital that accused him of colaboration sent the Germans to his clinic instead of helping them), the other were resistance fighters. On my German side there was just a guy who got drafted, stepped near a landmine, survived and became overly sensitive to loud noise, which didn't sit well with his son who played violin proffesionally (who played so much Gypsie jazz it got the familly in trouble). The last one I never personally met. He was a German surgeon who helped in France but was quickly sent to Stallingrad, where he was pulled away and sent to Finland as they feared a Gas attack and he was requested (a specialist on eyes). He was born in a pretty poor family but must've been incredibly intelligent and ambitious competing with a society that usually preffered rich people. Keep in mind that this guy was very much a nazi. He had a lot of friends who, all used to be nazis. He shared a lot of similarities with the other doctor in my family. Both agreed with Nazis on a certain amount (although the Belgian wasn't on par with the racial part, the healthy attitude, vegetarianism and no smoking were all things he was vocal on (he sent Jews to England before Belgium capitulated)). Both were disliked by colleagues (German one hated everyone rich and the Belgian one hated everyone French). Both helped Germans in the war, and the biggest difference is their punishment. The German one got absolutely nothing. He admitted to knowing what happened in camps, using research he knew that was tested on victims but he also promised to aid the Americans if they needed any Surgeons (which they really, really did).
The fate of your German family member shouldn’t come as much surprise. The US shielded many, many ardent nazis from prosecution because it thought them valuable in the coming Cold War against the soviets. Going so far as to send special OSS detachments into the war to rescue high ranking nazis from being killed or captured by their own forces. This involved collaboration with any number of absolutely revolting war criminals and mass murderers. I recommend the TH-cam channel Eyes Wide Open, especially their video on Operation Paperclip. Their work is incredibly well researched and cited, and it exposes mass audiences to some of the dirtiest deeds of the US intelligence establishment before, during and after the war.
@@andreilucan1803 He coöperated with Germans because he offered to make scans for them. The city hospital (who had a bit of a hate relationship with him) told on him during the trials at the end of ww2. He was someone who was for Flanders and the Flemish language (not an ethnic thing) (in modern Belgium that political party dominates the alt right), this is a pro-Germanic movement that the Germans endorsed. Generally that's pretty bad but it also makes sense in the context. At the time, the 'elite' of Belgium was all French or French speaking. This led to an elitist French speaking population and in Flanders a majority of people who didn't speak French. The city hospital, which was the only one in the city only gave advice and administration in French. My great grandfather didn't like that so he started his own practice in the late 30's. Once the Germans roll up, the hospital sends the Germans to him. and after the war, you've got an independent doctor with a lot of anti-French/Pro Germanic centiment (the fact that this was a completely different issue is something they didn't really take into account, and who also helped the Germans. Therefore, he was a collaborator and got some time. That entire period was pretty rough here, a friend of mine had a great grandfather who was appointed major of his town by the Germans and after the war, the only reason he didn't get time as well was because his wife still found two letters in which he specifically stated he'd prefer they'd pick someone else.
@@chibble3591 Я не люблю коммунистов, но к сожалению с точки зрения того, что это все же часть истории моей страны обязан тебе сообщить, что СССР с социальной точки зрения был абсолютным добром на фоне всей западной Европы где право голоса женщинам выдали в пределах 50-80 годов двадцатого века или к примеру введение 8-ми часового рабочего дня
That's a very horrible fate. I hope he is somewhere better now. My great-grandfather was also a volunteer in Stalingrad, but he lost his left arm from a grenade. War is hell.
Действительно Сталинград битва как по мне самая важная битва в второй мировой войне это была самая трудная война после сталинградский битва идет Курская битва очень важный этап этой войне хотелось всем Ветераном сказать спасиба что они сразились и порой героический умирали чтобы защитить свой Страну свою родную землю Огромное спасиба вам за ваш героизм за вашу смелость Если в тексте будет ошибки извините я писал это с помощью Гугл переводчика Indeed, the Battle of Stalingrad, for me, is the most important battle in the Second World War, it was the most difficult war after the Battle of Stalingrad, the Battle of Kursk is underway, a very important stage in this war, I wanted to say thank you to all the Veterans that they fought and sometimes heroically died to defend their Country, their native land Thank you so much for your heroism and your courage. If there are any errors in the text, sorry, I wrote this using Google translator
На мой взгляд именно Курская битва является важнейшей. Сталинград хоть и был очень важной победой, но инициативу Красная Армия получила именно после Курской дуги
@@mikhailmaylin8193 Сталинград был важной опорой с моральной точки зрения, единственная отбитая битва на тот момент была битва за Москву а Сталинград поднял боевой дух аж до самого конца войны
@@АнтонЛариков несомненно, но стоит разделять моральный аспект и тактический. Отстояв Москву, Отбив Сталинград, и выстоявший в блокаде Ленинград однозначно подняли боевой дух советского народа, но руки развязала именно Курская битва
my 2 great grandparents fought for the axis, both survived one was captured in france in 1944 and the other barely survived being in the medic part of the 6th army, idk if he was flown out of stalingrad or not but he survived barely
The irony is, my grandma's brother was in the Reichsmusik Chor of the Wehrmacht. He wants to study Music before the war . Then after so much losses, first time in German history the musican part of an army was implemented in the army and had to fight. So he died in France some weeks later without any combat experience. He never wants to fight or was in nazi party. He was a man who loved music and was born in the wrong time. 😢
It was hell... My great-grandfather fought there and he died, my great-grandmother worked in a hospital, shortly before my grandfather was born, my great-grandfather died...
I first watched this movie over 2 years ago. At first I expected it to be a move about the Russian side of the war or the Allies like it always is. However after viewing it, I was surprised as to how good this movie was. It portrays the war from the German side of the war in Stalingrad. And instead of seeing how cruel the German soldiers are, I saw how they were being sent to their deaths. It really made me think of how these people who were basically forced to join this war and if they really knew what they were fighting for? This movie humanizes the Germans as if we were supposed to be rooting for them like we do with every other war movie. And it does work. When watching other movies with the Allies being the main characters, you think of how big and bad those Germans are. When watching a movie from the perspective of a German you feel how they really experienced it. This is what makes this movie a masterpiece
Believe me, when you watch this film and understand that your great-grandfather is standing against this German, who wants his country to survive and his children to survive and we now live happily, then you don’t feel any sympathy for the Germans
Its kind of weird how one of the main reasons soviets got decimated in the beginning of Barbarossa is because most of their armour and planes were placed in positions that benefitted being on the offensive, similar to the lead up of battle of the bulge and invasion of France with Germans troops being in terrible defensive positions but great offensive positions. Its disputed but there is a fair amount of evidence that USSR was going to invade Germany.@@superspy-xv9sx
Т-34-85 в Сталинградской битве - это сильно. Суть как раз в том, что до появления этого танка главным оружием против немецков Тигров 1 были буксируемые пушки или самоходные орудия, а танкистам Т-34 и КВ-1 приходилось тяжко. Что лишний раз подчёркивает подвиг, совершённый на Курской дуге и в целом в Битве за Сталинград.
"We went in the building,Heavy gunfire took place,10 of our boys died,i got shot in the leg,but our commanders said that not a single step back." My grandfsther's experience in ww2 in stalingrad
If I am correct, the scene where he cradles his friends head talking about the desert is a real story, where a german cradled his friend after death since he could not let it go.
I've heard that 9th of May - Victory Day/Remembrance Day was never meant to be celebrated, but people celebrated it regardless. For the people who are no longer alive, this day meant the end of horror.
War is the most horrible thing. We should teach a lot of young people of today about this horror. Reminder that fascism succeeded because the young people then had to carry on them back the crysis and wanted an alternative, but didn't knew the horrors of the war...
Honestly, the scene of the execution broke me down... Imagine being forced to take away someones live and happiness because of stupid orders. Even if they were uprising sabotaging etc.
The Soldier said... "Please, someone help me Dear god, I am suffering Please I need your help God said... "I hear your pleading I lift you from this nightmare your hell is over..."
btw the english subtitles are the official english subtitles for the movie so sorry for the wrong translations in some parts
Bro you’re totally underrated I like you’re edits very much a big thank you from Germany mein Bruder 🤝🏼🇩🇪🫡
he said water in german and the translation said milk kinda funny
Movie name?
@@Thetruetoast1816 Stalingrad
@@7858-z2h I heard that too, wasser became "milk"
The Battle of Stalingrad was the bloodiest and deadliest battle in *human history.*
The Axis (Germans, Hungarians, etc.) suffered around 800,000 casualties.
The Soviets suffered around 2,600,000 casualties.
I want you to count up to 3,400,000, and just imagine that every number that you counted was a human person, with their own morals, ideals, and lives. Husbands, fathers, and sons.
The average life expectancy in Stalingrad was *twenty-four hours.*
...
Firstly, the average human lifespan was 15 minutes. Secondly: not the bloodiest, the most bloody was the Rzhev slaughterhouse (as I remember, but this may be real)
@@Giaccio896 no it was 24 hours not 15 minutes...
@@Giaccio896 Battle of Rzhev was much longer than Battle of Stalingrad, so Stalingrad is more deadly if we count per day
I heard it was 72 hours for the average soldier
😂😂😂Count yourself mouse😂
“The street is no longer measured by meters but by corpses ... Stalingrad is no longer a town. By day it is an enormous cloud of burning, blinding smoke; it is a vast furnace lit by the reflection of the flames. And when night arrives, one of those scorching howling bleeding nights, the dogs plunge into the Volga and swim desperately to gain the other bank. The nights of Stalingrad are a terror for them. Animals flee this hell; the hardest stones cannot bear it for long; only men endure.”
― Officer of the 24th Panzer division
1. I was wtf. Then i saw u speaking about Tanks haha
@@martinal-almani3192wha
Based - bloodiest battle in mankind's history
Tooth and nail fighting
Во время войны моему дедушке было где-то 16 лет.
Он жил в Сталинградской области в 70 км. от Сталинграда. Немцы не смогли дойти до его деревни но один раз один самолёт збросил бомбы.
Он сам работал повозчиком и возил продовольствие и воду.
Практически всю войну через его деревню вели пленных немецких солдат, некоторые из них умирали по дороге и оставались лежать на обочине. Зимой когда выпал снег вдоль дороги были тысячи бугорков и детям было страшно ночью там идти.
То есть трупы были даже в тылу.
Потом их собрали и скинули в силусную яму.
В 70-х в деревню приехали родственики немецих солдат и искали свидетелей, дедушка знал где их закопали. Они ездили по всем полям, балкам, тыкали в землю, дедушка пытался вспомнить, смотрел по карте, так и не нашли. До сих пор не нашли.
То есть если где-то начать копать то можно найти сотни скелетов с обмундированием.
Its crazy when u realize the Russians lost more men on Stalingrad than America during the entire war
большим безумием является то что часть нынешнего поколения тех советских людей не ценит ту жертву, которую принесли их предки, чтобы они жили
Because America was Not a strong enemy.
Like Russia nd England.
Так и немцы тоже в этой битве потеряли больше чем американцы во всей войне. Сталинград , это памятник человеческой глупости и жестокости. 1000000 душ навечно заперты в этом городе герое
@@D3LmoneyD3L yeah it was stronger
Germans lost a lot of men too.
America fought with weak and small.
All great battles were on the eastern front.
“A lot of men praise the cold when they think of the Nazi defeat, meanwhile they forget we fought in those same cold conditions”
-Marshal Zhukov
"always do your own research and don't believe anything on the internet"
- Neville Chamberlain
''skibidi dom dom dom yes yes''
-Hermann Goering
@@Emir-om9tn bruh
"nickgas in paris" - Wiston Churchill
communist trash
Many do not realize how bloody the eastern front was and what grandiose military clashes took place there
the war was fought on the eastern front, the allied invasion of normandy was just a paid dlc
Yes, it was a battle between two of the strongest and most developed countries of that time (in a military sense). Despite the fact that the German army was more experienced and had good tactics, the Soviet army quickly learned how to fight too. And Stalingrad was an proof of that.
@@Leantenant soviets outnumbered germans and had lendlease
@@myhonorwasloyalty barely outnumbered and lend-lease wasn't even 5% of Soviet GDP for a year. You lost bud, get over it
@@myhonorwasloyaltyThat's your only argument, and the dude who answered you just destroyed it. By the way, the Americans who landed in France had the same numerical superiority.
P.S. I forgot to mention General Frost, who won the whole war on his own
“Considering your age... two bottles of milk”. That is peak german comedy.
Very well, but how do you expect him to pay you if he is dead?
He offers two crates of water, which is worth nothing
he said 2 bottles of water not milk
Ja he said Wasser which means water in german instead of milch which means milk
Which is the inaccurate translation
the eastern front was something else
respect to all soldiers, let it be a lesson for the generations to come
And everyone says west was important when they fell in like 2 days...
the west front was a war so big it would shadow every war since 1945. But the East was so much more people, so much more extreme policies, so much less brotherhood between the sides. the weather, the scale, the swiftness, no mercy@@VideoBee_YT
My man you really have just said respect to nazis and commies who were commiting horiffic war crimes and were just covering themselves with "I was just following orders"
stop generalizing people, not all of them were nazis and in fact majority of war crimes commited by the Wehrmacht were commited by ordinal soldiers because of orders of their officers and generals. Winners are writting the history and many thing are told only in generalities, without any details.
quick question, is the lesson to respect soldiers or not follow orders blindly or something like that? or to not invade Russia when it is cold as fuck?
Why has nobody ever recommended this movie ! It looks great, really drives home the horror of Stalingrad
whole movie is on youtube (don't tell anyone) search for stalingrad 1993
free on youtube my brother
It’s not in English so nobody knows it
absolutely brutal
@@eoin382 well everyone knows Das Boot, or even Come and See, and this is just as good.
As my grandmother told me (she was 8 years old during the war in Stalingrad), the Germans there, who were disappointed in the policies of Hitler, sided with civilians and the USSR, they helped quietly, who could do what they could, one German soldier brought bread to my grandmother (there was not much, about 30 grams) but this piece of bread was just happiness, brought milk, brought hay to put under clothes in the cold season. As a result, they somehow noticed him and decided to execute him in front of my grandmother (my grandmother Chu barely understood German, but she remembered the last words), stop crying, you're good for surviving, and I pray and I will pray to God that I would live on "... after which shots were fired and the body of the good And the generous soldier fell to the cold ground. Rest in peace, soldiers of all countries who fought for humanity. Thanks to that soldier who saved my grandmother's life, because without my grandmother, there would be no dad and mom, and there would be no me. Thank you to everyone who read my long but very sincere message, I wish peace and goodness all over the world, may all wars end, because we are given a language to speak and negotiate, and not to raise a gun against a person.
P.s tnx from Crimea
I am so very sorry that happened to your grandmother, I’m glad she survived all of that🙏 what city is your family from in Crimea btw?
If there's pne thing we can be certain of, it's that the germans were literally praised as heroes in many areas of the eastern front. Your story Is a steaming pile of rancid fowl excrement pouring from the gutter of wretched evil that is your mouth
@@WatchmyPlaylist. You okay, buddy? You hit your head or something?
@@SkeletonXintalking to ghosts
@@ShortContent853deleted comment
The ending was crushing the first time i saw it, i literaly cried, i never cry for any movie
Then u felt it, thats good, You should know Germany literally lost their soul in this City. After that big murdering against Jews and others began.
Nah you cried for nazis bruh 😭
@@0ofland if u give reactions like that i know u didnt feel the story they tried to tell you, they werent all evil, you should check your history...
@@Burningwhisky96 if they weren't evil then they wouldn't have commited so many war crimes on Jews and Slavic people and this movie just tries to humanise nazis and show that "not all of them were bad" which is really stupid because just because that 0.1% wasn't evil doesn't mean anyone should even shed a single tear for those bastards
@@0oflandthey were german soldiers not nazis
im not sure many people know this but Stalingrad was literally the bloodiest war in human history.
Не войной, а битвой за один город
Battle
battle*
Battle, and yes it was a meat grinder
not really, Rjev was much more brutal
Why are people arguing in the comments about who lost more people, who made the biggest contribution to the victory, I am from Russia and all my life I was taught to honor all the victims of the Second World War, like the Russians, the Germans and the Allies.
Agreed
Thank you and stay well. I am American and wish the Russians to be safe.
new generation egoists discuss numbers and their reasons for feeling important.
Never lose your smile :)
@@pedrofernandes4941 Thank you Americans, there are still Russians who also wish you safety and peaceful skies above your head!
With love from Russia!
@@mierapennthanks comrade! We are all brothers! 🫡🇷🇺🇺🇸
This movie looks like someone came to Stalingrad during the battle in 1942 and recorded everything with a color camera. This movie is too realistic and historically authentic.
If anyone hasn't seen this film yet, watch it, its far better than any other movies about stalingrad like the awful dogshit Enemy at the Gates or the state-propaganda-esque Stalingrad 2014. Like Das Boot its in the same vein of extremely realistic brutal nihilistic war movies that don't hold back, although I don't doubt Stalingrad was 1000x more brutal. The Eastern Front has been neglected in the more mainstream big-budget movies (specifically Hollywood, predictably) though obviously there's plenty great Russian/German/Polish/Ukrainian films on it (and ofc other Eastern European countries, but these made the most well known films on that front). Importantly though the practical effects in this film are just fantastic, I mean expansive bleak landscapes or cityscapes, and ofc all the real vehicles with pyrotechnics. But surprisingly the narrative and characters stand out amidst all the chaos, and it doesn't pull any punches into the end of the film.
I watched Cross of Iron recently, might give Stalingrad a go- they sound similar and I loved CoI.
Right on. I think there is a reason why Germans produced such deep, soulful movies such as Stalingrad and Das Boot - when your nation was on the losing side, it's impossible to sneak in any of that idolizing heroism which is often hiding in Hollywood movies. Here are no heroes, no artificial naratives of a happy end, just raw despair, with such a humane characters.
I thought this movie was not very well known, so I'm glad I'm not the only one who was deeply touched by Stalingrad!
I think the soviet movie stalingrad made in the 50s can also be interesting to watch, using tons of real military equipment, and the movie under supervision of general von paulus himself for the most realism.
I don’t know if a person can make a film, even with a budget of a billion dollars, a complete picture of Stalingrad, or even any battle of WW2, it was complete fucked up, one soldier died every 7 seconds
Есть фильм режиссёра Ларисы Шепитько "Смотри и иди".
One of the best edits I've seen. At 0:56 when he asks "And how's he supposed to pay if he's dead?" followed by silence, and then the insanely brutal fighting in the factories. Gives me goosebumps every time.
😢
This battle is not taught in Western Schools and as a American who studies WW2 as a hobby in High School, I think it is a shame and disappointment that this one battle is not stated as the turned point of the war, and that it is being forgotten.
You act like the battle of Stalingrad is a niche event during the war that only few talk about lol when in fact most people would immediately mention it whenever the topic of the Eastern Front is brought up.
You should see the battle of Kursk it was the true turning point in the war. It was the most decisive battle which determined the future of the third reich. A point of no return.
dude its a common talk you cannot talk about WW2 whitout these massive event Dunkerk, Pearl Harbor, the battle of Moscow, Lenigrad, Stalingrad, Okinawa, Midway, D Days and the battle of Berlin that pretty much standard teaching in pretty much the entire Western World
@logangoulet7522 what are you on about we do acknowledge everyone that fought during the great war your just yapping i littrealy pointed the fact that almost in every western country when it come from ww2 your are mostly learning from important point most of it on the Eastern Front western education is mostly on the contribution of each country like you know the fact the allies helped the soviet get there industry back in track while if your in russia you will be mostly teach How the Soviet fought alone and pretty much only learn the eastern front whit probably a small part on the Japanese defeat but that it whitout going into why there so many millions dead in the eastern front
@logangoulet7522 dude i aint american im Canadian from a people that did a lot for Europe while not having any real reason to help my grand father volunteered before the conscription was even in place and fought during D-days so i dont want any crap from a dude that think that the soviet are the reason Europe was liberated when they put dictatorships on half the continent and build a iron curtain that to this day still remain in Europe
Можете себе представить, немцы полностью уничтожили город, абсолютно полностью..И даже так не смогли его взять.
Вечная память защитникам Сталинграда 🥀
Слава СССР, Слава наши предки!
Yes so we cool now and frends ok!
@@martinal-almani3192 No the roles have changed now back in 2021 we were friends until another dictator threw it away again
@@BigJo95роли поменялись только в вашем больном воображении, изнасилованным телевидением
@@BigJo95 lmao they have never been friends, the US/western gov has been trying to interfere with Russia for ages, blaming Russia for random garbage like your elections and later trying to expand natos borders and their treatment of Russian speakers
"Everyone has the right to be stupid, but some people abuse the privileges."
--- Joseph Stalin
Сталин-людоед и преступник
Most people abuse it. I've never met a deep thinker over my 73yrs, 56yrs living in the U.S. (especially so), and visiting, living in some 40 countries. Most people, mindless robots living in the moment. 'People are to stupid, degenerate to save' AH
" i never said that "
“Don’t trust random quotes you hear on the internet.” -Abraham Lincoln
I have already listened to it
I think there's too many people these days who idolize war in the wrong ways, particularly younger folks
Playing Steel Division and War Thunder is also idolizing war
it's easy for kids nowadays to sit there and be wehraboos in their moms basement, it'd be alot harder for em to actually walk the walk though.
@@Watchembleed211 A game is a game, not larping on HOI4 or wanting to actually be there in combat because they "think it's cool."
@@lectorkaveli2816 You speak very generally. Also u speak very confident about yourself, it seems that you have met everyone in person to know what they really want to do 🤣🤣
@@Watchembleed211 What's your point in starting crap on the internet?
Вечная слава СОВЕТСКИМ СОЛДАТАМ! Умирали, но не сдавались!
Сломан,но не сломлен
Not glory fuck this red menace
Slava Ukraini 🇺🇦
@@eddy4935 причём здесь это?
😂😂😂
"We'll capture that town in 3 days!" Famous last words
Edit: Thank you guys for not having a war in the reply section, keep it up or else...
Fr
"Home by Christmas".
Well, it’s worth listening to the ever-shouting propagandist. He's tired of screaming.
"Special Military Operation" moment
@@carcotasu081 Nah, ruzzians took motivation from these guys actually.
I watched this movie as a child and loved it because it fascinated me and I felt the feeling of the Battle of Stalingrad.
Perfect and Great Edit!
Movie name ?
@@HistoricallyAccurate247 Stalingrad 1993
Этот фильм клюква.
Многие не осознают, что СССР потерял 26,6 млн человек во второй мировой войне....
Update: Для сравнения, население Австралии оценивается в 25 млн человек.
По самым минимальным подщётам, на самом деле они были гараздо больше...
@@Зауральеmuch lower*
Khazarian Zionist revenge on Russia
@@Зауральеэто не минимальные, а официально подтверждённые, до сих пор, иногда, находят остатки или сведения о погибших. Минимальные были у СССР сразу после войны, где возможности подсчитать количество жертв не было и назвали только военные потери, вроде как 18 миллионов.
Ага, а большая часть от этой цифры скончалась не от военных действий, а по вине СССР
The Eastern Front in WW2 Was So Bloody Litterally A war of Annihilation between two Giants it's the closest thing us humans ever got to hell, Stalingrad And Kursk Were Hell On Earth May All Good Souls Who were lost in ww2 Rest in peace especially the ones lost on the eastern front
Two sides, both hate eachother, both have a bunch of men and both forgot about morals.
What could go wrong?
Спасибо нашим солдатам за всё что они тогда сделали в эти трудные дни войны.
Спасибо им за победу
да. подписываюсь под каждым словом! Вся эта неблагодарная европа должна восхвалять и чтить, всех советских солдат, положившие головы в этой войне! Только благодаря ним (а не какой то ублюдской америке. - которая, как обычно прилетела в конце, как коршун глодать труп), они живут сейчас более менее хорошо. А вместо этого, они по указке очередных фашистов, сносят памятники великим героям. Учите историю, ублюдки! Вы следующие! Ничто не будет забыто, никто не будет забыт!
Volgograd is the city in which I was born (formerly Stalingrad)
Nice! 🤠👍
@logangoulet7522, у меня дед воевал под Сталинградом и на Курской дуге в 1943, отправили домой по ранению, дальше не воевал. Умер в 2005
@@zazazu2218 что он получил травму и где?
@@criticalboi4387 , отправили домой, есть орден 1 степени за уничтожение тигра
@@zazazu2218 Мой прапрадед освобождал Беларусь, Литву и Восточную Пруссию. Под Кёнигсбергом был ранен, вышел из госпиталя только в июле 1945
Франция пала за 38 дней - в Сталинграде за 38 дней немцам удалось перейти улицу.
France fell in 38 days - in Stalingrad the Germans managed to cross the street in 38 days.
в 1941 немцы захватили территорию СССР равную 3 Франциям.
@@romanaleksandrovich8219 А потом получили по ебалу. Слава советским воинам!
@@romanaleksandrovich8219 Немцы готовились к войне несколько лет
@@Rainnyash да никто не спорит. Просто Франция не достойна столько унижений. Все страны в начале войны терпели одни поражения от немцев, просто СССР большой, поэтому было время прийти в себя.
@@romanaleksandrovich8219убил 😂
I watched this movie and it was so good It's so accurate It's sad and makes you feel like you're there yourself
@AndrewTateFan_TopG stalingrad
@Hitler1945_ woah i think i read once that's called the swastika is it ironic or are you like a real neo-nazi?
"Typically, the way a war works is one side runs out of ammo, food, or men; for the unlucky ones it's all three at the same time. So what happened in Stalingrad? It's simple. It's what happens when one side has a near unlimited supply of men, and the other unlimited bullets. You get Stalingrad, a war that raged for 3 bloody years over crumbling ruins, with neither side truly winning.
Я была в Сталинграде. Там до сих пор помнят о всех ужасах войны..
Thank you for your services and your sacrifices. I hope life has treated you well since then. 🫡
(I’m sorry if you’re not able to translate this comment, I had to translate yours)
One of the best war films I’ve ever watched. Truly depicts the horrors of war instead of sugarcoating it like many other movies. This, Das Boot, Land of Mine are some of my favourite.
This was the perfect edit ı had ever seen about World War II. Putting the original music of movie in ending was perfect. Words can't describe what happened in Stalingrad.
Спасибо деду за победу
Im Krieg gibt es nur Verlierer.
@maulfickmanfred1796
Какая победа?! Это победа над самым главным врагом белых людей - нацистской германией. Но для выживания белой расы еще предстоит победить великое замещение. В Дании уже есть подвижки по этому поводу. В России и Германии пока не вижу таковых, следовательно если ничего не сделать самому ничего не изменится. Привет из России
@maulfickmanfred1796 че ту хуйню несешь ?
@maulfickmanfred1796 Who asked nazi?
@maulfickmanfred1796это была защита славян и всей восточной Европы, немцы к сожалению сделали только хуже для всего белого населения, истребив миллионы его лучших сынов
Когда один дом стоял дольше Европы
Ага, только штурмовали его сто немцев, а не миллион с лишним)
Идиот
А обороняли 50 человек, а не полтора миллионная армия@@jeanneslepeshau
ага конечно там же не было танков, самолетов, и все возможных пушек и тд этот дом не имел ни какой ценности для Немцов @@Maximilian-o2k
@@jeanneslepeshau сопоставить масштабы ума не хватает.Сравнил идиот
Descansen en paz las víctimas de esta guerra que nunca debió existir Saludos desde Argentina 🇦🇷
Saludos desde tierra del Fuego
LMAO si fueron tus abuelos quienes invadieron
@@albertoolivomtz5827 Mis abuelos son argentinos no entiendo tu comentario 🤔
@@FrankS88812a lot of high ranking German officers escaped to Argentina. He is making a joke.
@@st_oop Many Nazi soldiers surrendered to the American army and many lived to an older age in the United States. Even engineers and scientists. Argentina hosted Nazi engineers and technicians to modernize the army Something not very different from what the United States did. The German immigration dates back long before Hitler...
"alle sieben sekunden stirbt ein deutscher soldat. stalingrad - massengrab"
Sovietische sokdaten jede Sekunde 💀💀💀💀💀
@@fuxihutterer8088blödsinn
Слава Героям Советского Союза!
When he said how's he supposed to pay you if he's dead, then he stops smiling right after that and it goes into the grosome fighting, you did really good editing right there ngl. Easily one of the best edits I've ever seen.
Кто с мечом к нам придёт...
Фильм огонь конечно, просто ужасы войны
Вот-вот, и поэтому мне нравится как умирают руские захватчики пришедшие в Украину с огнем и мечом.
Да...
как фильм называется, скажите пожалуйста?
@@gamerx5999Вроде Сталинград
1993 года
Цитата из фильма «Александр Невский» 1938 года)
Goddamn I ain’t even gonna lie I slept on this edit and now I regret it because this damn near made me cry bruh
straight up. reliving the raw emotions of this film in 5 minutes.
"The magic power of art"
RIP to all the brave people who fought in these conditions.
Ксати, офигенный фильм. Когда я был еще маленьким у меня был диск этого фильма.
P.s. жалко что герои умерли также просто и бессмысленно, как и самая война.
Невероятно хорошо подобраны сцены с музыкой,
Как помне получилось очень хорошо
the "where are my boots?" is terrifying
nice edit one of the best i seen yet
Only the dead have seen the end of war
Centura references
Only thing that really bothers me is the translation ant 03:27
The Hauptmann (Captain) says: "Jetzt ist aber schluss mit der rumjuderei"
Which literally translates into "Enough jewing around". An important little note just to mirror the antisemitism in his mind.
also the part at 0:43 where he said 2 kisten wasser which is not 2 bottles of milk
@@Alpha-bo1xh this is good translation, "bottles of water" would not make much sense in this case in english, for english speaker milk is brought up as drink for children. Translation must make sense to viewer, it can't be literal.
Now this "jewing around" being omitted is obviously attempt to censor the dialogue, which is awful and translator should never do it.
"the only mercy in war is death"
✅
Vielen Dank. Wir sind in Brasilien und wir lieben diesen Film
Was sind die Namen?
Both countries suffered the same fate, they were just on different sides wearing different uniforms. The other team was just known as the “enemy.”
Only one side invaded on another's territory, destroyed cities, burned down villages and killed over 10 million civilians. No, they're not the same. Get your "everyone's equally bad" garbage out of here.
@@kindlingking The Russians did the same thing all accros Europe when the war turned in their favor, and some European countries remained enslaved to the USSR until its fall. Even before the war, the Soviets invade Poland and tried to do the same thing in Finland, before the outnumbered Finns threw the commies and their tanks out woth their tails low.
The USSR also killed significantly more people than Germany did. They absolutely were just as horrible as the Nazis. Hell, at least the Nazis had the decency to mostly kill foreigners, while the commies gleefully genocided their own people.
@@SkeletonXinThe Russians had the right to do it after all the evil from Germans in my country. Nevertheless, Russian never destroyed the population based on the nationality.
Porfin esta obra tiene mas likes y visitas saludos desde 🇨🇱 Chile
Aguante chilito!! 🔥
It’s crazy that this shows the brutality of war and how Stalingrad was actually like this
весь ссср был таким в моментах было не так жестко но даже те кто находились рядом с японией ощущали всю войну хоть война и была рядом с москвой
жалко что я не помню как погиб мой прадед но знаю ток то что он убил и ранил не малу нацистов
Спасибо всем павшим советским героям, мы никогда вас не забудем
сорри забыл
@@ivangovnov8827 а ты смешной
😂
when some house in Stalingrad lasts longer the the entirety of France
Durante el primero mes y medio de la guerra, la Unión Soviética perdió más territorios que toda Francia🥴
@@maximiliaanxiv188but did not give up
@@maximiliaanxiv188линия можено )
My uncle’s was an officer in the German army from 1938 to 1945 and his last words were:Fritz, Erik look at what we all died for , the world is now a place of constant and abominations…
Meiner war auch Offizier.
The end is so terrifying
Has it really been 8 years.. remember watching this when it came out. Good times
Наверное это так..
I lived in volgograd (stalingrad) when i was child. There was small forest next to the house, in which there were the remains of a german armored car
wir werden sie nicht vergessen 🫡
There’s a reason as a 20 something-year-old girl I wear rings from Germans, Romanians, Russians, and Hungarians at Stalingrad on all fingers. I also wear a dog tags. I have three on right now taken from the zaritysia Balka gumrak and Rosschonka- also one from pitomink - these items have incredible energy and I get to carry a little piece of Stalingrad grad with me every day.
It’s nice because it makes me think well if people could survive that I can pretty much survive anything and they’re beautiful trench art jewelry pieces
wtf
@@sellnhos5419 idk if she is larping but she probably got them from her grandma?
Remember!
Through the centuries, through the years -
remember!
About those
who will never come again -
remember!
Don't cry!
In the throat, restrain the moans,
bitter moans.
Be worthy of the memory of the fallen!
Eternally
worthy!
Be worthy with bread and song,
Dreams and poems,
a spacious life,
every second,
every breath!
People!
As long as hearts are pounding,
remember!
At what
price
happiness was won -
please remember!
When you send your song flying,
remember!
About those
who will never sing again -
remember!
Tell your children about them
so
that they will remember!
Tell the children's children about them
so that they will also
remember!
At all times of the immortal Earth
, remember!
Leading ships to the twinkling stars -
remember the dead!
Meet the trembling spring,
people of the Earth.
Kill the war,
curse
the war,
people of the Earth!
Carry your dream through the years
and
fill it with life!..
But for those
who will never come again,
I conjure you,
remember!
p.s Robert Rozhdestvensky
Remember (excerpt from the poem "Requiem")
France,America, uk,belgum thinking they had the most casualties
Soviet union and Japan:☠️
I know the both sides had casualties but the soviet union has the hardest google it
@@AQ.solider 27 Millionen
China had the 2nd most amount of casualties
@RytheCodplayer oh yeah I forgot but thanks
"We'll take the city in three days!" Famous last words
I'm half German, my Belgian side had a doctor who made radio scans for the Germans (which got him 4 years in prison, which sucked considering the hospital that accused him of colaboration sent the Germans to his clinic instead of helping them), the other were resistance fighters. On my German side there was just a guy who got drafted, stepped near a landmine, survived and became overly sensitive to loud noise, which didn't sit well with his son who played violin proffesionally (who played so much Gypsie jazz it got the familly in trouble). The last one I never personally met. He was a German surgeon who helped in France but was quickly sent to Stallingrad, where he was pulled away and sent to Finland as they feared a Gas attack and he was requested (a specialist on eyes). He was born in a pretty poor family but must've been incredibly intelligent and ambitious competing with a society that usually preffered rich people. Keep in mind that this guy was very much a nazi. He had a lot of friends who, all used to be nazis. He shared a lot of similarities with the other doctor in my family. Both agreed with Nazis on a certain amount (although the Belgian wasn't on par with the racial part, the healthy attitude, vegetarianism and no smoking were all things he was vocal on (he sent Jews to England before Belgium capitulated)). Both were disliked by colleagues (German one hated everyone rich and the Belgian one hated everyone French). Both helped Germans in the war, and the biggest difference is their punishment. The German one got absolutely nothing. He admitted to knowing what happened in camps, using research he knew that was tested on victims but he also promised to aid the Americans if they needed any Surgeons (which they really, really did).
The fate of your German family member shouldn’t come as much surprise. The US shielded many, many ardent nazis from prosecution because it thought them valuable in the coming Cold War against the soviets. Going so far as to send special OSS detachments into the war to rescue high ranking nazis from being killed or captured by their own forces. This involved collaboration with any number of absolutely revolting war criminals and mass murderers. I recommend the TH-cam channel Eyes Wide Open, especially their video on Operation Paperclip. Their work is incredibly well researched and cited, and it exposes mass audiences to some of the dirtiest deeds of the US intelligence establishment before, during and after the war.
Why did he got 4 years in prison i dont relly get it?
@@andreilucan1803 He coöperated with Germans because he offered to make scans for them. The city hospital (who had a bit of a hate relationship with him) told on him during the trials at the end of ww2. He was someone who was for Flanders and the Flemish language (not an ethnic thing) (in modern Belgium that political party dominates the alt right), this is a pro-Germanic movement that the Germans endorsed. Generally that's pretty bad but it also makes sense in the context. At the time, the 'elite' of Belgium was all French or French speaking. This led to an elitist French speaking population and in Flanders a majority of people who didn't speak French. The city hospital, which was the only one in the city only gave advice and administration in French. My great grandfather didn't like that so he started his own practice in the late 30's. Once the Germans roll up, the hospital sends the Germans to him. and after the war, you've got an independent doctor with a lot of anti-French/Pro Germanic centiment (the fact that this was a completely different issue is something they didn't really take into account, and who also helped the Germans. Therefore, he was a collaborator and got some time. That entire period was pretty rough here, a friend of mine had a great grandfather who was appointed major of his town by the Germans and after the war, the only reason he didn't get time as well was because his wife still found two letters in which he specifically stated he'd prefer they'd pick someone else.
If you haven't watched this movie, I suggest you do not watch this edit and see spoilers. Definitely watch the movie.
That's how good the edit is! It captures the movie so well that it totally spoils its essence.
whats the name?@@lafeeshmeister
Where can i whatch it? (Apart from yt, i don't want to give those basterds anymore money)
@@thelockerrocker450stalingrad 1993
В Сталинграде была такая заварушка, что средняя длительность жизни человека там была 15 минут
Прямо как Бахмутом и Авдеевой
@@Neoner777 даже не сравнивай
Best movie I’ve seen Stalingrad, recommend a watch of it if you haven’t seen it
Its really sad because my grand grand father died in stalingrad Rest In Peace he fought for the USSR
he was on the right side
he was(
@@redcityyy
@@redcityyy i mean i guess. They were both pretty bad sides. Glad the Western nations didn't suffer as much as the Communists.
@logangoulet7522no, he is right because somehow this "good side" managed to kill more People than germans
@@chibble3591
Я не люблю коммунистов, но к сожалению с точки зрения того, что это все же часть истории моей страны обязан тебе сообщить, что СССР с социальной точки зрения был абсолютным добром на фоне всей западной Европы где право голоса женщинам выдали в пределах 50-80 годов двадцатого века или к примеру введение 8-ми часового рабочего дня
My grandmom's mother brother died there. He was only 21. He was wounded and smashed by russian tank. This gives me chills tbh. R. I. P Otto
That's a very horrible fate. I hope he is somewhere better now. My great-grandfather was also a volunteer in Stalingrad, but he lost his left arm from a grenade. War is hell.
soldier huh?
@@justacat2 yep, Wermacht.
@@nikolametal2001 yes, i hope. Greetings men.
@@sympatycznyjanek8500 rip
4:59 over 2 million
Действительно Сталинград битва как по мне самая важная битва в второй мировой войне это была самая трудная война после сталинградский битва идет Курская битва очень важный этап этой войне хотелось всем Ветераном сказать спасиба что они сразились и порой героический умирали чтобы защитить свой Страну свою родную землю
Огромное спасиба вам за ваш героизм за вашу смелость
Если в тексте будет ошибки извините я писал это с помощью Гугл переводчика
Indeed, the Battle of Stalingrad, for me, is the most important battle in the Second World War, it was the most difficult war after the Battle of Stalingrad, the Battle of Kursk is underway, a very important stage in this war, I wanted to say thank you to all the Veterans that they fought and sometimes heroically died to defend their Country, their native land
Thank you so much for your heroism and your courage.
If there are any errors in the text, sorry, I wrote this using Google translator
На мой взгляд именно Курская битва является важнейшей. Сталинград хоть и был очень важной победой, но инициативу Красная Армия получила именно после Курской дуги
@@mikhailmaylin8193 Сталинград был важной опорой с моральной точки зрения, единственная отбитая битва на тот момент была битва за Москву а Сталинград поднял боевой дух аж до самого конца войны
@@АнтонЛариков несомненно, но стоит разделять моральный аспект и тактический. Отстояв Москву, Отбив Сталинград, и выстоявший в блокаде Ленинград однозначно подняли боевой дух советского народа, но руки развязала именно Курская битва
2 дауна выше. Курская битва - битва которой не было, судя по свидетельствам немцев.
من اجمل الافلام ❤
P E R F E C T edit !!!
Why wont aliens visit us?
Average human disagreement:
Those brave Soviet men fighting for there country no matter the cost. that is true unity
Und das muste mein Großvater miterleben 😢
What did he see
@@Mantogodsa bullet
my 2 great grandparents fought for the axis, both survived one was captured in france in 1944 and the other barely survived being in the medic part of the 6th army, idk if he was flown out of stalingrad or not but he survived barely
И мои дво деда там были и к счастью они выжили
I watched this edit a thousand times and it still gives me chills 😬
The irony is, my grandma's brother was in the Reichsmusik Chor of the Wehrmacht. He wants to study Music before the war . Then after so much losses, first time in German history the musican part of an army was implemented in the army and had to fight. So he died in France some weeks later without any combat experience. He never wants to fight or was in nazi party. He was a man who loved music and was born in the wrong time. 😢
Perfect edit
This movie is one of the greatest war movies ever
this is the thing, we all think about the future but never think of the past
It was hell... My great-grandfather fought there and he died, my great-grandmother worked in a hospital, shortly before my grandfather was born, my great-grandfather died...
Amazing edit. 👍 👌
I first watched this movie over 2 years ago. At first I expected it to be a move about the Russian side of the war or the Allies like it always is. However after viewing it, I was surprised as to how good this movie was. It portrays the war from the German side of the war in Stalingrad. And instead of seeing how cruel the German soldiers are, I saw how they were being sent to their deaths. It really made me think of how these people who were basically forced to join this war and if they really knew what they were fighting for? This movie humanizes the Germans as if we were supposed to be rooting for them like we do with every other war movie. And it does work. When watching other movies with the Allies being the main characters, you think of how big and bad those Germans are. When watching a movie from the perspective of a German you feel how they really experienced it. This is what makes this movie a masterpiece
Believe me, when you watch this film and understand that your great-grandfather is standing against this German, who wants his country to survive and his children to survive and we now live happily, then you don’t feel any sympathy for the Germans
@@hikolasha4746 Both the Soviets and the Germans were horrible, but the Germans fired the first shot.
Its kind of weird how one of the main reasons soviets got decimated in the beginning of Barbarossa is because most of their armour and planes were placed in positions that benefitted being on the offensive, similar to the lead up of battle of the bulge and invasion of France with Germans troops being in terrible defensive positions but great offensive positions. Its disputed but there is a fair amount of evidence that USSR was going to invade Germany.@@superspy-xv9sx
So if a movie was about the Russian side of the war, it would be bad? You're sick
@@MeinungMann are you retarded? i never said that, i said that i expected it do be another generic movie about the allied perspective
As a german, i love it
As a Canadian, I can appreciate that.
@@lafeeshmeister the always bad boy German meets the always nice guy Canadian
You love humanising nazis and commies don't you
@@jonasf1275Canadians are war criminals
Мне как русскому, похуй на все.
Т-34-85 в Сталинградской битве - это сильно. Суть как раз в том, что до появления этого танка главным оружием против немецков Тигров 1 были буксируемые пушки или самоходные орудия, а танкистам Т-34 и КВ-1 приходилось тяжко. Что лишний раз подчёркивает подвиг, совершённый на Курской дуге и в целом в Битве за Сталинград.
"We went in the building,Heavy gunfire took place,10 of our boys died,i got shot in the leg,but our commanders said that not a single step back."
My grandfsther's experience in ww2 in stalingrad
If I am correct, the scene where he cradles his friends head talking about the desert is a real story, where a german cradled his friend after death since he could not let it go.
Rest in peace
War is hell
"We'll take that city in three days"
last word.
born to be human, forced to be a killer
in blind eye, soldier have no mercy, but remember, they are still human
I've heard that 9th of May - Victory Day/Remembrance Day was never meant to be celebrated, but people celebrated it regardless.
For the people who are no longer alive, this day meant the end of horror.
The ending was brutal and soul crushing, simply a beautiful telling of such a tragedy.
I mean, yes. You nailed the movie.
Мой прадед участвовал в Сталинградской битве, горжусь им
War is the most horrible thing. We should teach a lot of young people of today about this horror. Reminder that fascism succeeded because the young people then had to carry on them back the crysis and wanted an alternative, but didn't knew the horrors of the war...
The turning Tide on Eastern Front....
Honestly, the scene of the execution broke me down... Imagine being forced to take away someones live and happiness because of stupid orders. Even if they were uprising sabotaging etc.
The Soldier said...
"Please, someone help me
Dear god, I am suffering
Please I need your help
God said...
"I hear your pleading
I lift you from this nightmare
your hell is over..."