No, that would be Sutherland. When asked once why she felt the need to lay on the floor and hang her hair off the stage, in role Sutherland made famous, Netrebko said, " She didn't have to." Enough said.
Listen to the end, its complete perfection. She is the very best and will always be the best and shes divinely beautiful. I defend her on every level because there is no one better than her.
I always wanted Anna to sing fragments from Adriana and, finally, my patience is rewarded. I cannot wait for her to sing the full opera. This role is very good for her...as well as singing Magdalena in Andrea Chenier. Long overdue....
Great performance with superior technique and velvety sound. Nothing to bleat but i´m sure the busy haters will find something. I enjoyed it very much.
No operatic score belongs to any singer. That's ridiculous. Quit this opera queen drama, please. Besides, an interpretation does not get any worse or better because someone else sang better or worse.
IT is commonly believed that this role is sung by sops. who have past their "sell by" date. This may or may not be correct, (probably depending who's singing it.) In any event, she is not the first soprano to develop a tremolo and she won't be the last.
saw this live, it was spectacular.. not to mention this was an encore performance from her original piece... the only artist that got an encore at this RTG in 2016.
Such a shame, her voice has become so heavy, labored and wobbly at such a young age. Her voice was radiant just a decade ago--the dire risk of singing far too heavy repertoire too soon
yes I agree. I don't think I have ever heard her voice soooo spread. Its weirdly pushed and we all know she is trying to just beef up all round. But the overall effect is there. It's not Freni who got legitimately vocally huge but there we are.
Remember when a certain Brunhilda couldn't get a particular role? ....the role that required she fit into a "little black dress"? I don't mean this in any mean way. Unlike many of those commenting below, I AM a fan of Anna Netrebko. And as a fan who wishes her the best always, I WISH she would follow the example of that certain Brunhilda.
Follow that Brunhilda's example of losing voice and ending career sooner than expected? How dare you to call yourself a fan of Anna Netrebko?! I don't blame that Brunhilda for her choice. In fact, no one has the right to blame her for that. Firstly, it's her body that she should be the only one to decide how it should look like. Secondly, her overweight was not just a problem of her look but more serious a problem of her health, as you can read in her book. Meanwhile, Anna Netrebko is in every sense a healthy beautiful woman with a full body. I find a woman with curve quite charming.
Women shouldn't be condemned, criticized, or judged simply by, as you put it: "full body"... "her overweight." So I do agree with you that decisions about weight should be personal, not imposed by societal ideals. Responding to pressure to be thin, Maria Callas was bulimic for some years. I wouldn't want AT to resort to that pathology. There is, unfortunately, a reality that when your face is puffy and you struggle to get up from the floor (just saw her in Manon a month or so ago at the MET) people might not be as interested in buying a ticket to see/hear you. That is bad for her and it's bad for opera in general: AT has been a major draw of audiences to opera all around the world. From viewing a fairly recent post on TH-cam that shows her eating breakfast with her husband and others, I got the idea she doesn't know that fried potato patties are fattening, not "light."
Lasciamo perdere il corpo che ognuno gestisce come vuole e come si sente, se le piace essere grassa sono fatti suoi, ma una cantante che si esibisce è ovvio che si sottoponga al giudizio del pubblico e se questo non è bue e ha almeno una certa conoscenza della musica e del canto....bhè certo che muove le sue critiche o i suoi apprezzamenti. Dunque adesso la Netrebko, forse anche a causa di quella sciagura di tenore che frequenta, intuba per rinforzare e scurire la sua voce con pessimi risultati, non fosse per le smorfie e le boccacce indecenti che fa. Il suono, ovviamente, ne risente in gran misura perché perde in lucentezza, levità, grazia e soprattutto in armonici mentre l'interpretazione così caricata risulta falsata nella sua espressività in aderenza al personaggio come scritto dall'autore (ed anche come la stessa natura femminile esige.....) Mi ricorda oggi quelle matrioske russe che a Mosca spazzavano un tempo le strade con i fazzolettoni in testa e qui in occidente tutti si scandalizzavano per la perduta femminilità e i corpaccioni pesanti e sformati. Sformato il corpo, sformata l'interpretazione, sformata la voce. Ok, sono fatti suoi ma è finita. E non si venga a dire che è evoluta in un soprano drammatico e altre stupidaggini del genere perché chi sa cantare, e lei sapeva cantare, sa benissimo che queste possono essere distinzioni di timbro ma non di emissione e il timbro si può al massimo deformare caricando ed enfatizzando certe note dei registri medio e grave, mandando a rotoli il registro acuto. Oggi, ecco che al posto della Netrebko c'è una giovane donna dotata, bella e brava che canta come si deve cantare e come cantano gli angeli del cielo: Nadine Sierra. Peccato che sia andata così e amen.
Riccardo Barreca, analisi spietata ma perfetta, non potevi essere piu' preciso, praticamente "da manuale". Concordo....ma un appuntino su look?...no, meglio non infierire.
She isn't holding up too bad vocally, but she has certainly put on more than a few pounds. Doesn't seem to sing with as much ease as she use to and a bit sloppy vocally.
Beautiful, wonderful Anna Netrebko.....BRAVA!!!
Best of the Best!!!!❤❤❤
Просто пилотаж.Браво
I love how expressive she is; her voice follows her expression...as mellow and beautiful as she is!
With age, it gets much better ... (in verismo.) And that fabulous breath support/control is top-notch; bravissima.
The ending is really awesome!!!
Beautiful.Thank you for posting♫♪ ॐ¸¸.•*¨*•♫♪
Beautiful.
Beautiful, stunning, flawless. The greatest opera singer of all time.
No, that would be Sutherland. When asked once why she felt the need to lay on the floor and hang her hair off the stage, in role Sutherland made famous, Netrebko said, " She didn't have to." Enough said.
Eine wunderbare Stimme und eine sehr schöne, ausdrucksvolle Frau
How she floats the last few phrases....then comes on full blast. Brava!
Listen to the end, its complete perfection. She is the very best and will always be the best and shes divinely beautiful. I defend her on every level because there is no one better than her.
I always wanted Anna to sing fragments from Adriana and, finally, my patience is rewarded. I cannot wait for her to sing the full opera. This role is very good for her...as well as singing Magdalena in Andrea Chenier. Long overdue....
Brava Anna!
Great performance with superior technique and velvety sound. Nothing to bleat but i´m sure the busy haters will find something. I enjoyed it very much.
What in the world do you think you are hearing. She is only adequate.
@@GaryNReese It must be horrible to be tone deaf. Maybe you should try listening to Rap?
Lo máximo Anna
A vendo nella mente lo grandi cantanti del passato si può dire che è un cantare alla baiadera.
Ivana Lini, piu' che baiadera diremmo "sciantosa".
Браво!
I'm not her fan but this was SPECTACULAR!BRAVA!
Perfection! 👏👏👏
Perfect!
vu 777 perfectly horrible per usual
@@arnoldamaral7406Not for me.
Anna, una de las grandes de la lirica actual . buenisima version !
This belongs to Mirella Freni, I think too.
I think Freni has better technique, but Anna's singing is more emotional and catching. She is quite different from most opera singers.
No operatic score belongs to any singer. That's ridiculous. Quit this opera queen drama, please. Besides, an interpretation does not get any worse or better because someone else sang better or worse.
Margaret price is pure velvet
This reminds me of the sopranos of the golden age...You don't see this kind of singing anymore. Brava!
Please, everybody, just Enjoy ! I can't sing like this, do you ? . . .
Kristine Willems I said it once and I'll say it again my grandmother can and she's 86 have mercy Lord!
Brava!
This belongs to Mirella Freni.
u are perfect !! we love u
IT is commonly believed that this role is sung by sops. who have past their "sell by" date. This may or may not be correct,
(probably depending who's singing it.)
In any event, she is not the first soprano to develop a tremolo and she won't be the last.
Fabuleuse Anna ...
Her sound and technique are appealing to me but somehow she lacks the drama and attitude Adriana needs.
AMAZING, good lows
*DANIELITHO560 * when she goes low we go high! Quoting Michelle Obama can you dig it?
Qui la voce.....ha preso un'altra strada.
Serafin Carmelo, si, una strada sbagliata.
MAGNIFICA
Brava! ♥
saw this live, it was spectacular.. not to mention this was an encore performance from her original piece... the only artist that got an encore at this RTG in 2016.
bravo! 👏👏👏👏👏
Cosa ti è successo mia cara Anna?
She sounds rather like Freni after 50
Silfredo Serrano let's try more like after 60 65 whatever it takes!
I agree, very much like Mme Freni's performance from 1991 at the Met Gala.
Such a shame, her voice has become so heavy, labored and wobbly at such a young age. Her voice was radiant just a decade ago--the dire risk of singing far too heavy repertoire too soon
SteveL2012 born too late I can hear the song right now from the 1960s BORN TOO LATE oh Deary dear
she is still magnificent , stop complaining , she is extremely musical and the technique is the best , the voice is still beautiful and healthy
@@ercheche8486 clearly no ear or musical training.
@@SteveL2012 just crying , like a litle girl
@@ercheche8486 We're not lying. Sge wobbles off pitch consistently. She shouldn't have never sung lady Macbeth. It destroyed her voice.
Liric soprano has to be liric! Thanks!
sounds and look great here... I don't see anything wrong with netrebko's weight. she looks great...
Zeyn Jenkins she looks good to me but I'm dyslexic anorexic! When I look in the mirror I'm thin can you dig it!
Seems more round a sound
I'm not her fan but Netrebko is angel.
No One just keep telling yourself that it's okay.
TOP
Вульгарно
This is okay but she sounds too sloppy and artifically heavy
yes I agree. I don't think I have ever heard her voice soooo spread. Its weirdly pushed and we all know she is trying to just beef up all round. But the overall effect is there. It's not Freni who got legitimately vocally huge but there we are.
Estupenda!
Ma è fuori tempo!!!!
Just listened to Mirella Freni… unfortunately , this performance pales in comparison .
No es l' umile ancella...no.Voz pesante y pastosa,falta delicadeza.Una atleta vocal no es lo mismo que artista.
Remember when a certain Brunhilda couldn't get a particular role? ....the role that required she fit into a "little black dress"? I don't mean this in any mean way. Unlike many of those commenting below, I AM a fan of Anna Netrebko. And as a fan who wishes her the best always, I WISH she would follow the example of that certain Brunhilda.
Are you calling her fat? *eyeroll*
She's not EVEN FAT!
Follow that Brunhilda's example of losing voice and ending career sooner than expected? How dare you to call yourself a fan of Anna Netrebko?! I don't blame that Brunhilda for her choice. In fact, no one has the right to blame her for that. Firstly, it's her body that she should be the only one to decide how it should look like. Secondly, her overweight was not just a problem of her look but more serious a problem of her health, as you can read in her book. Meanwhile, Anna Netrebko is in every sense a healthy beautiful woman with a full body. I find a woman with curve quite charming.
Women shouldn't be condemned, criticized, or judged simply by, as you put it: "full body"... "her overweight." So I do agree with you that decisions about weight should be personal, not imposed by societal ideals. Responding to pressure to be thin, Maria Callas was bulimic for some years. I wouldn't want AT to resort to that pathology. There is, unfortunately, a reality that when your face is puffy and you struggle to get up from the floor (just saw her in Manon a month or so ago at the MET) people might not be as interested in buying a ticket to see/hear you. That is bad for her and it's bad for opera in general: AT has been a major draw of audiences to opera all around the world. From viewing a fairly recent post on TH-cam that shows her eating breakfast with her husband and others, I got the idea she doesn't know that fried potato patties are fattening, not "light."
schön
She used to sing better.
Hernan Zambrano so did my grandmother and she's 86 what's her excuse I asked you? The people have the right to know!
At some point, that is true of us all.
Lasciamo perdere il corpo che ognuno gestisce come vuole e come si sente, se le piace essere grassa sono fatti suoi, ma una cantante che si esibisce è ovvio che si sottoponga al giudizio del pubblico e se questo non è bue e ha almeno una certa conoscenza della musica e del canto....bhè certo che muove le sue critiche o i suoi apprezzamenti. Dunque adesso la Netrebko, forse anche a causa di quella sciagura di tenore che frequenta, intuba per rinforzare e scurire la sua voce con pessimi risultati, non fosse per le smorfie e le boccacce indecenti che fa. Il suono, ovviamente, ne risente in gran misura perché perde in lucentezza, levità, grazia e soprattutto in armonici mentre l'interpretazione così caricata risulta falsata nella sua espressività in aderenza al personaggio come scritto dall'autore (ed anche come la stessa natura femminile esige.....) Mi ricorda oggi quelle matrioske russe che a Mosca spazzavano un tempo le strade con i fazzolettoni in testa e qui in occidente tutti si scandalizzavano per la perduta femminilità e i corpaccioni pesanti e sformati. Sformato il corpo, sformata l'interpretazione, sformata la voce. Ok, sono fatti suoi ma è finita. E non si venga a dire che è evoluta in un soprano drammatico e altre stupidaggini del genere perché chi sa cantare, e lei sapeva cantare, sa benissimo che queste possono essere distinzioni di timbro ma non di emissione e il timbro si può al massimo deformare caricando ed enfatizzando certe note dei registri medio e grave, mandando a rotoli il registro acuto. Oggi, ecco che al posto della Netrebko c'è una giovane donna dotata, bella e brava che canta come si deve cantare e come cantano gli angeli del cielo: Nadine Sierra. Peccato che sia andata così e amen.
Riccardo Barreca, analisi spietata ma perfetta, non potevi essere piu' preciso, praticamente "da manuale". Concordo....ma un appuntino su look?...no, meglio non infierire.
Joan Sutherland aged 60, still sounds better than this one.
Не на кого не похожий голос ) он один такой в мире
I can't watch any production that she's in. She is so unimpressive. There are much better opera singers out there: Angela Gheorghiu.
She isn't holding up too bad vocally, but she has certainly put on more than a few pounds. Doesn't seem to sing with as much ease as she use to and a bit sloppy vocally.
Que lastima que alguien que lo tenia todo para hacer una larga y fructífera carrera haya declinado de manera tan estrepitosa
body and vocal decline (sad sight) but still a good singer
pfff ... poor and stupid comment
"Sad sight?"...you've got to be kidding me.
I agree
I agree
The voice massages every corner of Carnegie Hall. I was at this concert and it was some of the most incredible singing I’ve ever witnessed.
Laura Luke -divinely beautifull she was, lovely voice but really is she not ill having gained so much excessive weight ??
Ma è fuori tempo !!!