Years ago when "Please don't" released, they all became insanely famous because everyone loved the twist. It was practically unheard of to have gay representation in MVs, so it was received really well especially by international fans. K.Will has said that due to the love of the original MV's plot, he made a gift of a second storyline with his friends - the original actors. He also hinted that if fans really loved it a lot then he'd consider doing a part 3 and fans are dreading whether that means another 12 years until the next update.
The funny thing is, the actors themselves were not aware of the twist until the very end of the shoot. K.Will was the only one aware of it. Seo In-guk and Ahn Jae Hyun thought it was just the typical love triangle. Seo In-guk seriously thought his character was in love with the girl and didn't figure it out until he was told to rip up the photo and cover the girl up near the end of the shoot. And Ahn Jae Hyun was just oblivious as to why he was sitting in the car at the end with Seo In-guk. The three of them had an interview released to Seo In-guk's TH-cam channel where they discussed all of this after the second song's release! Seo In-guk also earned the nickname "Mr. World Gay" and had people questioning his sexuality as a result of the music video 😂
@@fleur_and_flowerthank you for this insight I didn't know about. It doesn't matter whether any of them are gay or not, one doesn't have to be gay to feel their overwhelming pain & loss. In the end he says "pogo shipeo" (I miss you) and that says everything. I root for part #3.
Inguk and jaehyun were already famous actors and dasom had been in sistar a very famous girl group for years even k.will had already established himself before please don't
13:34 PLEASE THIS MAKES SO MUCH SENSE NOW, I'M GONNA CRY EVEN MORE😭 17:05 idk if you noticed but his wedding ring is gone, meaning he got divorced from the woman in "Please Don't..." 20:18 "I miss you.."
FOR. REAL. It all makes sense now I've always tried to interpret it in a logical and actual way but them imagining how they would like things to turn out is sooo much better
We’re very lucky we got a sequel but at what cost! Ahn Jae-hyun, the friend who married in the mv, was in a 5 year hiautis due to a public messy divorce with his ex-wife (another very famous actor). They both fell out of love with each other and both looked down upon by the public because of their divorce. Jaehyun finally felt comfortable this year to come out to the public. He came to In-Guk’s (the other man in the music video) show with K.will, who revealed that he will have a comeback this year. They talking about having a sequel due to the impact of ‘Please don’t’. Jaehyun revealed to the public that he struggled financially while being in a 5 year hiatus and learn to adapt to his financial situation. This shocked the public, a very well know actor in industry was in this type of financial situation; he sell all his lavish items for money, went thrifting and was only eating home cooked meals. It seems like he’s doing well now, spending lots of time with friends and In Guk. I hope the best for him.❤
K. Will is the mastermind of both MVs For your info K.Will said that he will do a third part. He got so many messages from many many fans that was sad of the ending of No Sad Song For My Broken Heart. He said in Seo In Guk in his YT channel. So the 2 actors are : Seo In Guk (white butterfly) and Ahn Jaehyun. And with K. Will they are best friends. They are super fun together. In the tunnel Seo In Guk say : There's something I wanted to ask your for a long time .... Can I hug you just this once... At the end Ahn Jaehyun say: I miss you. (That hug was, to me, the most powerful hug I've ever seen. The acting of both was outstanding.) They did a preview of this song before the release. You should watch it.
The theory is the watch in beginning is 10:12 which is show us when the first mv are out (2012.10.10). And the phone, anh jaehyun's phone is blackberry but soe in guk has iphone that why he's from 2024. When they're in tunnel, the train's way is backward and seo in guk time in the past has end. He hug jaehyun for the last time and when he walk away, jaehyun call his name but in guk already back to 2024. At the end of this mv is 2024, the time is 06:20 (2024.06.06) when seo in guk die and jaehyun know his bf has gone. In the teaser they almost kiss each other but in the mv not. I think kwill will release the 3rd part of this sequel. Anh jaehyun will be back from 2024 to 2013 or something, bcs he has the watch to comeback
12:22 Yeah, that butterfly is in fact...random, just total coincidence 😂 K.Will the singer of the song himself revealed it in his fanmeeting and everybody's reaction was wild that day. Btw I like how you theorized SIG's passed away with the camera angle, always love an educational theory.
Wow I think what you've said about the second MV is the closest to what the director intended, she did Q&A on her IG story before, based on what I understood, he did confess at the tunnel and then died from an accident then and there. But many people made up theories as they watched the MV (partly from in denial lol) and because of how many things looked like hints. So in the end, we're told to just enjoy theorising from the singer himself XD
18:28 Underneath the railroad, inside the tunnel: Seo Inguk: “There’s something I never asked/told you before… Is it okay to hug you (for once)?” ---- An Jaehyun: (after Inguk walks away) “HEY!!”
Man LOVED your interpretation of the music video, I was so confused but now EVERYTHING makes sense about the second one!!!! One of my favorite songs, I've never seen anyone pay such attention to details, thanks for helping me understand it!! LOVED IT
FIRST - Bro I can’t wait to see your reaction to the twist at the end of Please Don’t 😅😅❤ this made my gay heart happy when I was a teenager but also sad as fuck lol
I was looking for YOU to react to those songs. These songs are absolute MASTERPIECE. Sorry to hear that you are in a low state. You are not alone. I have ATEEZ to help me get through my low days. Music is the best therapy.
Not only are the music videos a work of art in visuals and storyteller, but K.Will's voice is something out of this world!!! May be the saddest songs in the world but just listening to it gives me immense euphoria and I always have to sing along.
I searched a subtitled mv, and in the part of the tunel, InGuk (The guy with the iphone) said: "I want to say you one more thing, can i hug you one more time?" and he proced to hug him, and the look in JaeHyun (the one with the blackberry) it's seems to me like he is struggle with his emotions and feeling. When InGuk watch him sleeping and stare at his lips, but then look away... JaeHyun open his eyes, and to me it seems like he knows what in guk feel for him, and he feel the same way in part, but he have fear of his feelings... if you notice, like says in another commentary, JaeHyun no longer have the ring, and show it to InGuk... So for me: the one who regrets no chosing to be happy, or follow his heart is JaeHyun... thats why he imagine all those moments with InGuk. PS: Sorry if the comment is a little confusing, English is not my first language...
오늘 가수의 콘서트에서 얘기해줬는데 흰나비는 cg가 아닌 우연히 찍힌것.😅 많은이들이 상상했는데ㅎ 실제로 3편 나온다고 합니다. 첫 뮤직비디오찍고 두배우는 친하게 잘 지내오다가 2편 찍길 원했고 가수와 셋이 합작만들어냄. 찍으면서 다시 셋이 친해져서 반응도 좋으니 다음앨범에 3편 나온다고 가수가 얘기함. 2편 티저보세요 키스할뻔한 장면 찍으면서 두배우는 실제로 키스할수있다고 매우 의지가 넘쳤지만 현장에서는 저정도로😂 실제 두배우는 커플잡지화보도 찍고 술도 자주 마시며 가까이 살면서 자주 오가고 이번에 마카오여행까지 협찬받아서 갔어요. 둘사이를 진짜라고 의심하는 팬덤이 있음~ 아무튼 3편이 곧 나올예정이라 기대중
Hi! Thanks for checking these mvs out :) I really enjoyed your analysis of both. Idk if you check out content beside mvs on your channel, but you should definitely watch the teaser for "No Sad Song for My Broken Heart." There are scenes that weren't included in the mv and many suspect it's because of the possible time travelling aspect of the mv with the watches. K.will also uploaded a behind the scenes of the mv, so you can see him, Seo In Guk (the actor who died in the mv) and Ahn Jae Hyeon (the actor who married Dasom in the first mv) discuss the storyline. Edit: I hope things get better for you!
As cool and sad as the ending of "Please don't..." was, I couldn't help myself thinking of this funny Japanese commercial about Long Long Man. If you know, you know 😅
I enjoy watching you reacted to these 2 mvs so much and couldn't agree more about the M.night vibes XDD btw I really want to see you react to "ยื้อ - ปรีชา ปัดภัย : เซิ้ง|Music Ost. สัปเหร่อ Story" (a Thai song) since your commentary is so much fun to watch, I hope you will take this into consideration, thank you 🥲🥲💕
Let me introduce you to the actors So the one with iPhone is Seo Inguk and the one with Blackberry is Ahn Jaehyun Some said this 2nd MV is about Jaehyun who died first and then Inguk turn back time (?).. he back to the past to save Jaehyun.. As you can see from their phone, Inguk is iPhone and Jaehyun is BB.. Unfortunately the way to save Jaehyun is by Inguk's death.. That's why at the end of the MV the one who died is Inguk.. I don't know if it's right but really the MV and the song are awesome.. Thanks for the reaction.. You're genius too.. Like you help us to understand the symbolism in every MV.. Thank you
4:54 i get too excited to see what's your next reaction in that moment and about second video i salute you bro you get all thing in first and yeah i cry again
Honestly the time travel theory is more plausible than just In Guk being dead the whole MV just because of the phone differences and the watch. If In Guk was just dead the whole video, then it doesnt make sense that Jaehyun is the one with the old phone rather than In Guk having it. Also if K. Will is thinking of a part 3 then I don't see what the plot could be if there is only one person remaining?
Hi, además de estos dos vídeos está el teaser de No sad song... que agrega algunas imágenes y significado al contexto general, te lo recomiendo. También, en el canal de uno de los actores está la historia de cómo surgió la idea del segundo MV que fue cuando se cumplieron años del lanzamiento del primer mv. Es un gran material para reaccionar, te lo recomiendo. Son dos vídeos si mal no recuerdo y aparecen los dos actores y el cantante.
Thank to kwill we now have the ahnguk couple. They now become like gaycouple knets want them to be. and they have something cooking as of now. I think a macau vlog is coming their way. they did couple photoshoots and interviews on youtube too..And now we demand 16 eps of their bl drama.😂
Dammit Daniel you're too good at interpreting things, you spoiled the reveal for yourself! Also, another evil thing about this mv (besides having to wait 12 years for it) is that in the teaser for the mv they show a scene where they almost kiss but the scene is not in the actual mv!
![[SUB] Close friends who even shared a kiss(?) / Jaefriends Ep.35 / K.will Kim Jaejoong](/img/n.gif)
Thank you, I now hate myself for always thinking about death... But both MVs are masterpieces, wow!
Years ago when "Please don't" released, they all became insanely famous because everyone loved the twist. It was practically unheard of to have gay representation in MVs, so it was received really well especially by international fans. K.Will has said that due to the love of the original MV's plot, he made a gift of a second storyline with his friends - the original actors. He also hinted that if fans really loved it a lot then he'd consider doing a part 3 and fans are dreading whether that means another 12 years until the next update.
The funny thing is, the actors themselves were not aware of the twist until the very end of the shoot. K.Will was the only one aware of it. Seo In-guk and Ahn Jae Hyun thought it was just the typical love triangle. Seo In-guk seriously thought his character was in love with the girl and didn't figure it out until he was told to rip up the photo and cover the girl up near the end of the shoot. And Ahn Jae Hyun was just oblivious as to why he was sitting in the car at the end with Seo In-guk.
The three of them had an interview released to Seo In-guk's TH-cam channel where they discussed all of this after the second song's release! Seo In-guk also earned the nickname "Mr. World Gay" and had people questioning his sexuality as a result of the music video 😂
@@fleur_and_flowerthank you for this insight I didn't know about. It doesn't matter whether any of them are gay or not, one doesn't have to be gay to feel their overwhelming pain & loss. In the end he says "pogo shipeo" (I miss you) and that says everything. I root for part #3.
Inguk and jaehyun were already famous actors and dasom had been in sistar a very famous girl group for years even k.will had already established himself before please don't
18:26
“there’s something I can’t tell you…
can I hug you just once?”
The collective "Is Dasom dead?" of the fandom while watching the 2nd mv was so funny honestly
13:34 PLEASE THIS MAKES SO MUCH SENSE NOW, I'M GONNA CRY EVEN MORE😭
17:05 idk if you noticed but his wedding ring is gone, meaning he got divorced from the woman in "Please Don't..."
20:18 "I miss you.."
Ohhhhh I didn't notice the ring!!
FOR. REAL.
It all makes sense now
I've always tried to interpret it in a logical and actual way but them imagining how they would like things to turn out is sooo much better
I need a Kdrama of 16 episodes.
We've been waiting for a 'killing love story', not a 'killing him story' 😂😂
We’re very lucky we got a sequel but at what cost!
Ahn Jae-hyun, the friend who married in the mv, was in a 5 year hiautis due to a public messy divorce with his ex-wife (another very famous actor). They both fell out of love with each other and both looked down upon by the public because of their divorce. Jaehyun finally felt comfortable this year to come out to the public. He came to In-Guk’s (the other man in the music video) show with K.will, who revealed that he will have a comeback this year. They talking about having a sequel due to the impact of ‘Please don’t’.
Jaehyun revealed to the public that he struggled financially while being in a 5 year hiatus and learn to adapt to his financial situation. This shocked the public, a very well know actor in industry was in this type of financial situation; he sell all his lavish items for money, went thrifting and was only eating home cooked meals. It seems like he’s doing well now, spending lots of time with friends and In Guk. I hope the best for him.❤
K. Will is the mastermind of both MVs
For your info K.Will said that he will do a third part. He got so many messages from many many fans that was sad of the ending of No Sad Song For My Broken Heart. He said in Seo In Guk in his YT channel.
So the 2 actors are : Seo In Guk (white butterfly) and Ahn Jaehyun. And with K. Will they are best friends. They are super fun together.
In the tunnel Seo In Guk say : There's something I wanted to ask your for a long time .... Can I hug you just this once...
At the end Ahn Jaehyun say: I miss you.
(That hug was, to me, the most powerful hug I've ever seen. The acting of both was outstanding.)
They did a preview of this song before the release. You should watch it.
I'm scared tho of the 3rd MV cos I think K-Will hinted it'll be set in hell or afterlife? LOL we might end up with them both dead ☠
@@eldagreat LOL Yes he does have the talent to shader our hearts.
The theory is the watch in beginning is 10:12 which is show us when the first mv are out (2012.10.10). And the phone, anh jaehyun's phone is blackberry but soe in guk has iphone that why he's from 2024. When they're in tunnel, the train's way is backward and seo in guk time in the past has end. He hug jaehyun for the last time and when he walk away, jaehyun call his name but in guk already back to 2024. At the end of this mv is 2024, the time is 06:20 (2024.06.06) when seo in guk die and jaehyun know his bf has gone. In the teaser they almost kiss each other but in the mv not. I think kwill will release the 3rd part of this sequel. Anh jaehyun will be back from 2024 to 2013 or something, bcs he has the watch to comeback
12:22 Yeah, that butterfly is in fact...random, just total coincidence 😂 K.Will the singer of the song himself revealed it in his fanmeeting and everybody's reaction was wild that day. Btw I like how you theorized SIG's passed away with the camera angle, always love an educational theory.
I love how you mentioned the symbolism of the tunnel😭
Wow I think what you've said about the second MV is the closest to what the director intended, she did Q&A on her IG story before, based on what I understood, he did confess at the tunnel and then died from an accident then and there. But many people made up theories as they watched the MV (partly from in denial lol) and because of how many things looked like hints. So in the end, we're told to just enjoy theorising from the singer himself XD
And the director also confirmed that there's no time travel lol
18:28 Underneath the railroad, inside the tunnel:
Seo Inguk: “There’s something I never asked/told you before… Is it okay to hug you (for once)?”
----
An Jaehyun: (after Inguk walks away) “HEY!!”
The butterfly in the music video is not a composite but a butterfly taken by accident
Man LOVED your interpretation of the music video, I was so confused but now EVERYTHING makes sense about the second one!!!!
One of my favorite songs, I've never seen anyone pay such attention to details, thanks for helping me understand it!!
LOVED IT
i could literally listen to you talking about video interpreations, they're always logical and well put! great video as always!
FIRST - Bro I can’t wait to see your reaction to the twist at the end of Please Don’t 😅😅❤ this made my gay heart happy when I was a teenager but also sad as fuck lol
AAH OMG I WANTED YOU TO REACT TO THESE FOR SO LONG, I'M SO EXCITED (I might comment more when I finished the vid-) LOVE YOU BTW
amazing that you watched these mvs! literal masterpieces! also i hope we'll get another mv without waiting another 12 years for it lol
this too shall pass. Hang in there you touch many peoples lives and send you hope and joy!
I was looking for YOU to react to those songs. These songs are absolute MASTERPIECE.
Sorry to hear that you are in a low state. You are not alone. I have ATEEZ to help me get through my low days. Music is the best therapy.
PART 3 IS CONFIRMED BY K WILL TO BE COMING...
BOTH ACTORS AGREED IMMEDIATELY.
Not only are the music videos a work of art in visuals and storyteller, but K.Will's voice is something out of this world!!! May be the saddest songs in the world but just listening to it gives me immense euphoria and I always have to sing along.
Oohhh.... I love your interpretation of the 2nd mv... It's more makes sense..
Yep, the girl is Dasom from Sistar.
Also, I think you've seen K.Will before as a short cameo in Mamamoo's debut "Mr. Ambiguous".
THE WAY YOU EASILY CLOCKED TWISTTTT 😭😭
I searched a subtitled mv, and in the part of the tunel, InGuk (The guy with the iphone) said: "I want to say you one more thing, can i hug you one more time?" and he proced to hug him, and the look in JaeHyun (the one with the blackberry) it's seems to me like he is struggle with his emotions and feeling. When InGuk watch him sleeping and stare at his lips, but then look away... JaeHyun open his eyes, and to me it seems like he knows what in guk feel for him, and he feel the same way in part, but he have fear of his feelings... if you notice, like says in another commentary, JaeHyun no longer have the ring, and show it to InGuk... So for me: the one who regrets no chosing to be happy, or follow his heart is JaeHyun... thats why he imagine all those moments with InGuk.
PS: Sorry if the comment is a little confusing, English is not my first language...
오늘 가수의 콘서트에서 얘기해줬는데 흰나비는 cg가 아닌 우연히 찍힌것.😅 많은이들이 상상했는데ㅎ
실제로 3편 나온다고 합니다. 첫 뮤직비디오찍고 두배우는 친하게 잘 지내오다가 2편 찍길 원했고 가수와 셋이 합작만들어냄. 찍으면서 다시 셋이 친해져서 반응도 좋으니 다음앨범에 3편 나온다고 가수가 얘기함.
2편 티저보세요 키스할뻔한 장면 찍으면서 두배우는 실제로 키스할수있다고 매우 의지가 넘쳤지만 현장에서는 저정도로😂
실제 두배우는 커플잡지화보도 찍고 술도 자주 마시며 가까이 살면서 자주 오가고 이번에 마카오여행까지 협찬받아서 갔어요. 둘사이를 진짜라고 의심하는 팬덤이 있음~
아무튼 3편이 곧 나올예정이라 기대중
그리고 시계로 타임루프라고 생각함. 요즘 k드라마는 타임루프물이 인기. 실제 폰기종이 블랙베리와 아이폰최신형으로 달라서~ 3편이 나오려면 살려야해ㅎㅎ
올해 3월에 셋이 유투브에서 만나서 2편찍자! 하고 5월말 촬영에 들어감. 두배우는 뮤직비디오공개이후 인기로 매우 바빠져서 인터뷰도 많이 하는데 둘사이 애정이 많음. 밈도 많이 생겨서 이상황을 두배우 모두 신나서 즐기는중이라고 했어요
헐 나비가 우연이라니ㅠㅠ
@@멩이곰돌 cg쓸 예산이 없었는데 얻어걸린🫠
Its like the girl from the first video died..and he still in love with him...😂
I love the songs so much. They make me cry each time I hear them. The plot broke our heart because I'm so emotionally invested in it.
Great reaction!!
loved your oh, oH , OH!
Hi! Thanks for checking these mvs out :) I really enjoyed your analysis of both. Idk if you check out content beside mvs on your channel, but you should definitely watch the teaser for "No Sad Song for My Broken Heart." There are scenes that weren't included in the mv and many suspect it's because of the possible time travelling aspect of the mv with the watches. K.will also uploaded a behind the scenes of the mv, so you can see him, Seo In Guk (the actor who died in the mv) and Ahn Jae Hyeon (the actor who married Dasom in the first mv) discuss the storyline.
Edit: I hope things get better for you!
As cool and sad as the ending of "Please don't..." was, I couldn't help myself thinking of this funny Japanese commercial about Long Long Man. If you know, you know 😅
I was so hoping for this like forever. Hahahha im glad.. and it made my entire day! ❤❤❤
By the way, I hope you're doing well, you're not alone I'm also in a weird mood but your video lightened up my mood
This too shall pass
Omg! Yeeeeeeees! Finally!
I've been looking forward to this since de 2nd MV came out. I'm glad you finally reacted to this 💜
Need Inguk and Jaehyun to release a kdrama or a movie together 😭
I love how you forgot that there was a wife before. At first the 2nd mv I thought it was the girl
I enjoy watching you reacted to these 2 mvs so much and couldn't agree more about the M.night vibes XDD
btw I really want to see you react to "ยื้อ - ปรีชา ปัดภัย : เซิ้ง|Music Ost. สัปเหร่อ Story" (a Thai song) since your commentary is so much fun to watch, I hope you will take this into consideration, thank you 🥲🥲💕
Let me introduce you to the actors
So the one with iPhone is Seo Inguk and the one with Blackberry is Ahn Jaehyun
Some said this 2nd MV is about Jaehyun who died first and then Inguk turn back time (?).. he back to the past to save Jaehyun.. As you can see from their phone, Inguk is iPhone and Jaehyun is BB.. Unfortunately the way to save Jaehyun is by Inguk's death.. That's why at the end of the MV the one who died is Inguk.. I don't know if it's right but really the MV and the song are awesome..
Thanks for the reaction.. You're genius too.. Like you help us to understand the symbolism in every MV.. Thank you
God whyyyy Please Don't was sad enough 😂😭
If K.Will does a part 3 he better somehow give it happy ending or else 🤣
Imagine waiting 11-12 yrs for In Guk to be dead. I cried real tears of rage and frustration 😂
Seo in guk is also a singer and actor ,Ahn jae hun is an actor
4:54 i get too excited to see what's your next reaction in that moment and about second video i salute you bro you get all thing in first and yeah i cry again
I realised the last thing he saw was the other one walking away and what they both did not say.
Wow you were so quick to realise what what's going on man.
You reacted the same exact that I did! Practically destroyed me.
6:00 i didnt realize that scene earlier ...
Oh you have found this video :))
you really figured it quickly i thought it was his wife who died till i saw the ending😭😭
Honestly the time travel theory is more plausible than just In Guk being dead the whole MV just because of the phone differences and the watch. If In Guk was just dead the whole video, then it doesnt make sense that Jaehyun is the one with the old phone rather than In Guk having it. Also if K. Will is thinking of a part 3 then I don't see what the plot could be if there is only one person remaining?
The mv teaser has one more scene that can add some points to the story I guess
❤️🔥 👑 🛐
oh 😮 oh 😮 oh 😮 oh 😮 lmao
Hi, además de estos dos vídeos está el teaser de No sad song... que agrega algunas imágenes y significado al contexto general, te lo recomiendo. También, en el canal de uno de los actores está la historia de cómo surgió la idea del segundo MV que fue cuando se cumplieron años del lanzamiento del primer mv. Es un gran material para reaccionar, te lo recomiendo. Son dos vídeos si mal no recuerdo y aparecen los dos actores y el cantante.
Thank to kwill we now have the ahnguk couple. They now become like gaycouple knets want them to be. and they have something cooking as of now. I think a macau vlog is coming their way. they did couple photoshoots and interviews on youtube too..And now we demand 16 eps of their bl drama.😂
Can you react to Schadenfreude by ALEPH? There is no translations in the mv but you can search them up before.
Dammit Daniel you're too good at interpreting things, you spoiled the reveal for yourself! Also, another evil thing about this mv (besides having to wait 12 years for it) is that in the teaser for the mv they show a scene where they almost kiss but the scene is not in the actual mv!
This isn’t just k-trauma it’s gay-trauma
I won't watch if someday they release a movie or drama 😐