The Chinese community in Kolkata is an important part of city's history. We must acknowledge that and accept them with love and respect. This is a wonderful video and a nice tribute to the Chinese community of Kolkata.
We left India because we were afraid of being sent to the concentration camps in Rajasthan, in 1962, not because of economic opportunities. Please set the record straight. Many Chinese people were arrested and taken to Deoli concentration camps because the Indian government thought they were spies. Not a single person turned out to be a spy. The Indian government needs to apologize for this heinous crime against its citizens of Chinese origin.
As it's been quoted : " history can't be erased but can only be forgiven " The chinese diaspora around the globe must be pretty "pissed off" with the chinese govt. for not helping the chinese indian when they were ostracized, mistreated and tortured after the 1962 war. Same misfortune & tragedy happened to the chinese indonesian in the late 1990's before the fall of suharto's govt. Why didn't the chinese govt voiced out strongly remains anyone's guess !!! Had the chinese govt. conveniently forgotten that it was the total collective assistance of the diaspora chinese in south east asia that send monies back to their motherland to support the chinese govt in their fight against the japanese during WW2 ????
As a Hong Kong Chinese born and raised in the UK, I never knew this until now. Thank you for sharing this. I wish more people would speak up about this and there were more platforms to do so.
@@samgooi1905 Ethnic overseas Chinese were very divided during the Cold War era too. A faction supported the KMT, another was integrating into host country and the newer batch was influenced by CCP. It just take a few CCP sympathisers to make all of them guilty. Ethnic Chinese leaders of Malaysia had to sign the New Economic discriminatory policy in 1970 to appease the Malay Ultranationalist for 20 years. The dateline was ignored till now.
Similar but not exact, ethnic Indians are suffering in South Africa’s looting and burning of Indian businesses. The locals have targeted Indians. This is different as it is not government directed. What India did to ethnic Chinese is what the US government did to American-Japanese during WW2 Internment camps. The Indian government and some indian citizens are not that noble and freedom-minded. Such hypocrisy!
.Kolkata will always be my hometown.Even though I moved out 41 years ago.I guess I'm deeply rooted in the city's culture.Other indian cities don't come close to the diversities of kolkata's cultures in the early days.....I was very fortunate to grow up there among all the wallahs.
Thank you for the beautiful video about Chinese born and living in India. There are so many nice comments by Indians. I hope the friendship between India and China improve. No more war. Living in India during my childhood, actually, Indian and chinese get along very well in the school. The Indian teachers love Chinese students. It is only these stupid politics that made Chinese people immigrate to other countries. JaiHind.
Such a beautiful presentation.! Loved it. Please god I don't want them to fade away. We have old history with this Chinese community. These people are just amazing.
I would say this documentary is a very good attempt. The narration failed horribly. The reasons for the "Fading Away" were not dealt with adequately. There is the complete silence of the India-China war of 1962. And how the Chinese community suffered from it. Many were jailed without trial among the many horrible things done to them. Till today the government of India has not apologised for its actions.
I already knew India was very diverse but I never knew India was this much diverse... 😅 India has Hakka Chinese in Kolkata and African Indians in Gujarat... Good to see this much diversity😁😁 It's so nice to see their culture here in India
I am Hakka born in Calcutta in Chandni Chowk but moved to the US some 45 years ago. I miss the place dearly and my friends from St. Joseph's in Bowbazar. So much diversity in everyday school and home life. In fact I spend considerable time looking for my former classmates. On my bucket list is to go back some day but I take understand things are no longer the same. I have met Hakka people from other countries and even from Moi Yen or Mei Shen, and I cannot understand them. Hakka language is in its purest from in Kolkata so I fear the language itself is fading. I personally have not used the language having no one to use it with.
Yup it's more or less the same here but the pronunciation is a little bit different. I can understand most of what hakka ppl from other countries say. The words and all r the same only a little bit difference in pronunciation.
I had the opportunity to visit Kolkata in 2018. Spoke to a few Chinese at Chinatown. I was told many had left, remaining a great many elderly folks stateless despite being born there. Is this ill-treatment of a people worthy Indian citizenry?
I had many Chinese friends that i miss in Calcutta, i used to live near tiratii bazzar as a little kid i used to have many Chinese friends they were amazingly good human beings, they were a gem to calculatta , theres even a Chinese school over there . I really miss my Chinese friends 😢😢. Lots of love to all the Chinese family friends and community from my side .❤❤❤❤❤
I lived in Hong Kong for a few years in the early 1970’s and it is horrible at what is happening there now. Those of us who are fortunate to live abroad in freedom are the lucky ones. I am forever grateful to the British government who helped a lot of Chinese to leave India by issuing us with travel passports because we were all made stateless by the Indian government.
Sayak Dey : Hello , I am Chinese was born in Indonesia, I live in San Francisco now. My parent from China spoke hakka, My father knew how to make shoe, so he opened the shoes & bags , luggages factury. some of my father's frends own the lather facturies too. I love to watch your video, Thank you.
There're lot of people mix up the terms of Chinese and Hakka. In fact, the term 'Chinese' is quite similar to the term 'Indian', it means those who live in or come from China. Chinese is not a particular ethnic group, it is an identity of nationality. Hakka people themselves have their own identity, culture and custom which are very diverse with the northern Chinese (Mardarin). The relationship between Mandarin Chinese and Hakka is similar to the relationship between Hindi and Tamil.
Agree. Personally I believe the Hakka people are separate ethnic group, different from the Mandarin speaking chinese. Also when I visited Tianjin and Beijing many years ago, I noticed the Mandarin speaking chinese tend to look down on the cantonese and hakka-speaking chinese. That could explain the uprising in Hong Kong.
@@bluestar2253 Hakka, Cantonese and Hokkien are the ethnic groups which have their own cultures, customs and languages that are diverse from Mandarin speaking ethnic group. In China, only Mandarin is considered as official language. Speaking Hakka, Cantonese or other languages in public are regarded as uncivilized behavior in China. In fact, Chinese government is trying to eliminate all regional culture except for Mandarin culture
@@francischan9574 As a tamil person, I understand why you mentioned tamil and Hindi now. I hope the same situation of being looked down upon if people don't speak the official language doesn't come to India. But as someone who doesn't speak Hindi, this is slowly happening here in tamilnadu.
I am a Hakka and it's good to learn about how other Hakka communities thrive or survive. It will be helpful if captions are provided. But it's an enjoyable video nonetheless.
It would be very sad to hear of the dwindling community. I hope they will stay on and be protected. By right, their settlement should be safeguarded, allowin only ppl of their community to live there, so as to protect its cultural heritage value. Indian government should do something concrete about this, or they stand to lose out in tourism prospective income.
Every where around the world it is not uncommon to find Chinatown; But India with such a vast country and population, left the only this so called "Chinatown", of which is fast vanishing due to systematically and cowardly discriminating its own citizen of Chinese ethnic, till today. What an incredible shame practice.
I have visited Kolkata twice but I didn't know there is a Chinatown there, why didn't the Indian government promote it? It will attract more tourists. Which other place in India has a Chinatown?
@@kerrywangnao7354 is Assam where the largest Buddhism monastery of India is located? I want to visit it together with Sikkim but find it very troublesome.
@@truth8307 what is your nature of your visit to northeast India? Are Buddhism your research work, if so, I have a friends in northeast hill university,shillong who is doing research on that. Might I know what's your background, I can even help you talk virtually.
Calcutta/kolkota India China shall always be intact, the way they shared their many traditional manners, food, designs, as well as culture. The way Chopsticks are from China to India, and so as Wrappers and leaves from India for food. Planted by the waters by the word. KJV 1611. In all righteousness be it left and right. Qui lai Gong Xi ni Kolkota.
Can't believe they are still bringing up another human being into this country, knowing the economy is not that great. I feel bad for the babies being born and live their forever, hope they're moving out.
This video about Hakka in Chinatown seems really shallow, and lacks the real understanding of the Hakka people living in Kolkata Chinatown. It doesn't carry the voice of the Hakka living in this city, and it is surprising that the sociologist, Dr Ananda can blatantly say that he wishes to see Chinatown becoming a tourist spot. The question is: Without the Hakka (or Chinese) living in Chinatown, there is nothing for tourists for tourists who come here to see or hear. There could be many more reasons why Hakka are leaving for other parts of the world besides the reason given that these people are going for more developed countries. For instance, are the Hakka people in Kolkata being discriminated against? Do they feel a sense of belonging in this city? Does India-China relationship have an impact on these Hakka people living in Kolkata? Hakka leaving Kolkata is certainly a loss for this city; you have only the shell of Chinatown, not the people living in Chinatown and the culture they bring to enrich the city.
I was just visited the place last week, I was surprised how terrible is the area although the Chinese places looks really well taken care Bt surrounded are was total slump .. mainly Govt doesn’t even care their own ppl n thinking how to improve
The south Hakka came to Jamaica and now we are mixed and a lot of us Jamaicans looking for our family it’s from south China Hakka . A lot of others that’s not in Chinese don’t even know the history still and they messed a lot of history too . My Jamaican great grandmother was a quarter south Chinese Hakka . People need to look more before starting to tell us about my ancestors
Unfortunately most of them do not speak Chinese. I made a trip there and spoke to some, none of the traders could read Chinese. They speak Bengoli & Hindi like the Indians do. Maybe the older generations could still do.
I don't think they speak Mandarin . Hakka is a dialect of Gan language . There are other languages in China like Wu (Shanghainese), Min (Hokkien, Hainanese,Teochew) and Yue (Cantonese).
@@zephure88 Han Chinese is a fake concept, indeed there's no ethnicity called Han. The word 'Han' is used to describe those who live in China and ruled by Chinese empire.
@M t Han Chinese is much more like a large cultural ethnic group likes Germanic and Slavic. Every sub-groups have their own languages, identities and traditional festivals. Due to the political reason in China, they are classified as the same ethnic group. However, Cantonese, Hakka, Mandarin and even other Sino languages like Wu(Shanghaiese), Hokkien and Fuzhou are unintelligible among themselves.
@M t The ethnic classification in China does not base on the scientific methods of linguistics and anthropology. They have their own standard to definite an ethnic group, which its definition is ambiguous and unclear. There're not only 56 ethnic groups in China, there're also a lot of ethnic groups that are not recognized by Chinese government.
@M t The term 'Han Chinese' is not precise enough. China prefers to use 'Han Chinese' to describe these bunch of people while overseas Chinese (Taiwan, Malaysia, Singapore etc.) tends to classify themselves as a smaller group likes Hakka, Cantonese, etc.
They are not chinese people .They are people of chinese origin and very much part of our bengali culture. We should make them feel comfortable as much as possible and see that they donr move away ...Their culture of togetherness and warmth more or less similar to us....If they move out of kolkata it will be great loss to us in terms of food culture etc.Its a ridiculous statenent that tangra be made tourist spot .Either leave them alone or treat whole of kolkata as a tourist spot.
Sad for india usa and other foreign countries making nice china town that why nowadays we saw many Chinese people too play for their country if india did as that same they also would join in sport for india.
The Chinese community in Kolkata is an important part of city's history. We must acknowledge that and accept them with love and respect. This is a wonderful video and a nice tribute to the Chinese community of Kolkata.
Bengalis love them. Bcs we have been with each other for decades.
We left India because we were afraid of being sent to the concentration camps in Rajasthan, in 1962, not because of economic opportunities. Please set the record straight. Many Chinese people were arrested and taken to Deoli concentration camps because the Indian government thought they were spies. Not a single person turned out to be a spy. The Indian government needs to apologize for this heinous crime against its citizens of Chinese origin.
As it's been quoted :
" history can't be erased but can only be forgiven "
The chinese diaspora around the globe must be pretty "pissed off" with the chinese govt. for not helping the chinese indian when they were ostracized, mistreated and tortured after the 1962 war.
Same misfortune & tragedy happened to the chinese indonesian in the late 1990's before the fall of suharto's govt.
Why didn't the chinese govt
voiced out strongly remains anyone's guess !!!
Had the chinese govt. conveniently forgotten that it was the total collective assistance of the diaspora chinese in south east asia that send monies back to their motherland to support the chinese govt in their fight against the japanese during WW2 ????
As a Hong Kong Chinese born and raised in the UK, I never knew this until now. Thank you for sharing this. I wish more people would speak up about this and there were more platforms to do so.
@@samgooi1905 Because the CCP doesn't care. That is why. Look at what is happening to the world now. Look at what they are doing to Hong Kong.
@@samgooi1905 Ethnic overseas Chinese were very divided during the Cold War era too. A faction supported the KMT, another was integrating into host country and the newer batch was influenced by CCP. It just take a few CCP sympathisers to make all of them guilty. Ethnic Chinese leaders of Malaysia had to sign the New Economic discriminatory policy in 1970 to appease the Malay Ultranationalist for 20 years. The dateline was ignored till now.
Similar but not exact, ethnic Indians are suffering in South Africa’s looting and burning of Indian businesses. The locals have targeted Indians. This is different as it is not government directed. What India did to ethnic Chinese is what the US government did to American-Japanese during WW2 Internment camps. The Indian government and some indian citizens are not that noble and freedom-minded. Such hypocrisy!
.Kolkata will always be my hometown.Even though I moved out 41 years ago.I guess I'm deeply rooted in the city's culture.Other indian cities don't come close to the diversities of kolkata's cultures in the early days.....I was very fortunate to grow up there among all the wallahs.
Please watch Gabriel Traveller's latest video in Kolkata. I'm sure you'll love it.
Thank you for the beautiful video about Chinese born and living in India. There are so many nice comments by Indians. I hope the friendship between India and China improve. No more war. Living in India during my childhood, actually, Indian and chinese get along very well in the school. The Indian teachers love Chinese students. It is only these stupid politics that made Chinese people immigrate to other countries. JaiHind.
You are right sir .
I agree too. Its the same stupid politics in Malaysia and South Afrika too.
Such a beautiful presentation.! Loved it.
Please god I don't want them to fade away. We have old history with this Chinese community. These people are just amazing.
Have you vsiisted this place?
I love ❤CHINESE PEOPLE IN CHINA TOWN CALCUTTA. Please don't fade away😢
Yes, i was amazed. I never knew there were a Chinese population in India!!
Same 😢
I would say this documentary is a very good attempt. The narration failed horribly. The reasons for the "Fading Away" were not dealt with adequately. There is the complete silence of the India-China war of 1962. And how the Chinese community suffered from it. Many were jailed without trial among the many horrible things done to them. Till today the government of India has not apologised for its actions.
更可怕的是打不还手，骂不还嘴。 更不会跑离。 只能说是自找的。
Govt must step in to promote...n keep the heritage....of Chinatown...
Only the new gen can do something. Bcs our cm won't do a thing. Bcs she doesn't has a brain to rule or govern a state.
Born in Kolkata, of Chinese descent, been back a few times, still have family there. Love the place 🙏❤️
Gabriel Traveller has a new video out in Kolkata, I'm sure you will love it.
Love you dear brother. I am from Kolkata we love you as a part of ours
I already knew India was very diverse but I never knew India was this much diverse... 😅 India has Hakka Chinese in Kolkata and African Indians in Gujarat... Good to see this much diversity😁😁 It's so nice to see their culture here in India
Thanks for that amazing introduction about the Hakkai there and wish them good luck after the immigration
I am Hakka born in Calcutta in Chandni Chowk but moved to the US some 45 years ago. I miss the place dearly and my friends from St. Joseph's in Bowbazar. So much diversity in everyday school and home life. In fact I spend considerable time looking for my former classmates. On my bucket list is to go back some day but I take understand things are no longer the same. I have met Hakka people from other countries and even from Moi Yen or Mei Shen, and I cannot understand them. Hakka language is in its purest from in Kolkata so I fear the language itself is fading. I personally have not used the language having no one to use it with.
Very well presentation looking forward to more such videos all the best
I just found out that there is a china town in Calcutta. Is the hakka language is it same as the Hakka language in Indonesia?
Saya juga ingin tau... saya juga keturunan Hakka. Kamu tinggal dmn?
Yup it's more or less the same here but the pronunciation is a little bit different. I can understand most of what hakka ppl from other countries say. The words and all r the same only a little bit difference in pronunciation.
I had the opportunity to visit Kolkata in 2018. Spoke to a few Chinese at Chinatown. I was told many had left, remaining a great many elderly folks stateless despite being born there. Is this ill-treatment of a people worthy Indian citizenry?
We new generation will do something. Whatever mess was created by our govt and Chinese communists.
I had many Chinese friends that i miss in Calcutta, i used to live near tiratii bazzar as a little kid i used to have many Chinese friends they were amazingly good human beings, they were a gem to calculatta , theres even a Chinese school over there . I really miss my Chinese friends 😢😢. Lots of love to all the Chinese family friends and community from my side .❤❤❤❤❤
What is the origin of the name Tangra? Knowing the Southeen chinese are likely to call themselves the "Tang"people after the late Tang dynasty .
I lived in Hong Kong for a few years in the early 1970’s and it is horrible at what is happening there now. Those of us who are fortunate to live abroad in freedom are the lucky ones. I am forever grateful to the British government who helped a lot of Chinese to leave India by issuing us with travel passports because we were all made stateless by the Indian government.
You should thank the Brits for supplying opium to China and stealing HK and brainwashing the HKers you fool
Was this about only Chinese? Congress did same with every community.
Sayak Dey : Hello , I am Chinese was born in Indonesia, I live in San Francisco now. My parent from China spoke hakka, My father knew how to make shoe, so he opened the shoes & bags , luggages factury. some of my father's frends own the lather facturies too. I love to watch your video, Thank you.
the narrater's audio sounds really bad. I stopped watching after 1 min cos I cant hear the voice properly
such a good video but why did you mess up and mess with the audio so much!!!
The Prime Minister of Singapore, Lee Hsien Loong is a Hakka Chinese.
REALLY? BUT HE SPEAKS TEOCHEW
@@anakitiktokwi2939 Hakkas are minority in Singapore. Majority of ethnic Chinese in Singapore are Hokkien and Teochew.
Chinese Singaporean can speak many Chinese dialects ..
Don't think PM of Singapore is a Hakka. Never heard him speak Hakka at all. Even his spoken Mandarin sounds weird.
@@singalong9177 yes. Lee kuan yew is hakka! So his son is hakka! Story ends. I am hakka from Malaysia.
Do those people start eating curry?
Kolkata is the real asian town. Mix of west and east asian cultures
There're lot of people mix up the terms of Chinese and Hakka. In fact, the term 'Chinese' is quite similar to the term 'Indian', it means those who live in or come from China. Chinese is not a particular ethnic group, it is an identity of nationality. Hakka people themselves have their own identity, culture and custom which are very diverse with the northern Chinese (Mardarin). The relationship between Mandarin Chinese and Hakka is similar to the relationship between Hindi and Tamil.
Your explanation using India as a comparison doesn't appear convincing. At best, your idea is just too simplistic.
@@singalong9177 Then share your own view, it's better than just judging my point without any explanation.
Agree. Personally I believe the Hakka people are separate ethnic group, different from the Mandarin speaking chinese. Also when I visited Tianjin and Beijing many years ago, I noticed the Mandarin speaking chinese tend to look down on the cantonese and hakka-speaking chinese. That could explain the uprising in Hong Kong.
@@bluestar2253 Hakka, Cantonese and Hokkien are the ethnic groups which have their own cultures, customs and languages that are diverse from Mandarin speaking ethnic group. In China, only Mandarin is considered as official language. Speaking Hakka, Cantonese or other languages in public are regarded as uncivilized behavior in China. In fact, Chinese government is trying to eliminate all regional culture except for Mandarin culture
@@francischan9574 As a tamil person, I understand why you mentioned tamil and Hindi now. I hope the same situation of being looked down upon if people don't speak the official language doesn't come to India. But as someone who doesn't speak Hindi, this is slowly happening here in tamilnadu.
I am a Hakka and it's good to learn about how other Hakka communities thrive or survive. It will be helpful if captions are provided. But it's an enjoyable video nonetheless.
Is there any census, how many is the population?
It would be very sad to hear of the dwindling community. I hope they will stay on and be protected. By right, their settlement should be safeguarded, allowin only ppl of their community to live there, so as to protect its cultural heritage value. Indian government should do something concrete about this, or they stand to lose out in tourism prospective income.
Every where around the world it is not uncommon to find Chinatown; But India with such a vast country and population, left the only this so called "Chinatown", of which is fast vanishing due to systematically and cowardly discriminating its own citizen of Chinese ethnic, till today.
What an incredible shame practice.
@@techte7604did Bengalis did it ? No we never hate Chinese of Bengal . We rather love you.
I have visited Kolkata twice but I didn't know there is a Chinatown there, why didn't the Indian government promote it? It will attract more tourists. Which other place in India has a Chinatown?
In Assam and meghalaya states
@@kerrywangnao7354 is Assam where the largest Buddhism monastery of India is located? I want to visit it together with Sikkim but find it very troublesome.
@@truth8307 what is your nature of your visit to northeast India? Are Buddhism your research work, if so, I have a friends in northeast hill university,shillong who is doing research on that. Might I know what's your background, I can even help you talk virtually.
@@kerrywangnao7354 yes, I am doing research work on Buddhism.
@@truth8307 from which university if I may ask? Which part of China you are from, by the way?
Calcutta/kolkota India China shall always be intact, the way they shared their many traditional manners, food, designs, as well as culture. The way Chopsticks are from China to India, and so as Wrappers and leaves from India for food. Planted by the waters by the word. KJV 1611. In all righteousness be it left and right. Qui lai Gong Xi ni Kolkota.
Thank you for your information
shit thats me in the video Jesus Christ 😂😂❤️
I like Chinese culture. Can you give me your phone number please
Can't believe they are still bringing up another human being into this country, knowing the economy is not that great. I feel bad for the babies being born and live their forever, hope they're moving out.
This video about Hakka in Chinatown seems really shallow, and lacks the real understanding of the Hakka people living in Kolkata Chinatown. It doesn't carry the voice of the Hakka living in this city, and it is surprising that the sociologist, Dr Ananda can blatantly say that he wishes to see Chinatown becoming a tourist spot. The question is: Without the Hakka (or Chinese) living in Chinatown, there is nothing for tourists for tourists who come here to see or hear. There could be many more reasons why Hakka are leaving for other parts of the world besides the reason given that these people are going for more developed countries. For instance, are the Hakka people in Kolkata being discriminated against? Do they feel a sense of belonging in this city? Does India-China relationship have an impact on these Hakka people living in Kolkata? Hakka leaving Kolkata is certainly a loss for this city; you have only the shell of Chinatown, not the people living in Chinatown and the culture they bring to enrich the city.
I was just visited the place last week, I was surprised how terrible is the area although the Chinese places looks really well taken care Bt surrounded are was total slump .. mainly Govt doesn’t even care their own ppl n thinking how to improve
Love from Hakka Medan
Nice 👌
The south Hakka came to Jamaica and now we are mixed and a lot of us Jamaicans looking for our family it’s from south China Hakka . A lot of others that’s not in Chinese don’t even know the history still and they messed a lot of history too . My Jamaican great grandmother was a quarter south Chinese Hakka . People need to look more before starting to tell us about my ancestors
Unfortunately most of them do not speak Chinese. I made a trip there and spoke to some, none of the traders could read Chinese. They speak Bengoli & Hindi like the Indians do. Maybe the older generations could still do.
I don't think they speak Mandarin . Hakka is a dialect of Gan language . There are other languages in China like Wu (Shanghainese), Min (Hokkien, Hainanese,Teochew) and Yue (Cantonese).
Hakka of Mauritius
Me too
Hello from Toronto Canada
Background music is too loud; cannot hear the narrator's voice.
Calcutta Chinese is a good thinking and good about wonder and do not hurt
India China people culture is a very beautiful jab aap Calcutta treaty market mein jaaoge injoy Baki bhai aapki samajh ke upar
Awesome
Bro please fix your sound ...it's terrible...seriously we love your videos ...but the sound is killing mate
Wow , i always wanted to know this
Love hakka from bangka . . . Cia yau
The audio is very bad .. so hollow n soft
They must be hakka mostly
The Sociologist man needs vicks tablet for his Throat when he speaks in english accent he is struggling alot 😁
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 too funny but i agree
🤣🤣🤣🤣
It was torture listening to him.
Very good
..it would not be long before there are all gone.
You are born my India culture and India is a love you do not think anything
Mostly old generation....their future don't know....
It's our negligence that , we are losing our cultures .
我們客家人苦了！
到那時才可找到自己的”家“？
Hakka people endure no Homeland 🏡.
When Are we going to find our own?
Our home is in China .. we are ethnic Han Chinese .
@@zephure88 Han Chinese is a fake concept, indeed there's no ethnicity called Han. The word 'Han' is used to describe those who live in China and ruled by Chinese empire.
@M t Han Chinese is much more like a large cultural ethnic group likes Germanic and Slavic. Every sub-groups have their own languages, identities and traditional festivals. Due to the political reason in China, they are classified as the same ethnic group. However, Cantonese, Hakka, Mandarin and even other Sino languages like Wu(Shanghaiese), Hokkien and Fuzhou are unintelligible among themselves.
@M t The ethnic classification in China does not base on the scientific methods of linguistics and anthropology. They have their own standard to definite an ethnic group, which its definition is ambiguous and unclear. There're not only 56 ethnic groups in China, there're also a lot of ethnic groups that are not recognized by Chinese government.
@M t The term 'Han Chinese' is not precise enough. China prefers to use 'Han Chinese' to describe these bunch of people while overseas Chinese (Taiwan, Malaysia, Singapore etc.) tends to classify themselves as a smaller group likes Hakka, Cantonese, etc.
Who say you out of India
They are not chinese people .They are people of chinese origin and very much part of our bengali culture. We should make them feel comfortable as much as possible and see that they donr move away ...Their culture of togetherness and warmth more or less similar to us....If they move out of kolkata it will be great loss to us in terms of food culture etc.Its a ridiculous statenent that tangra be made tourist spot .Either leave them alone or treat whole of kolkata as a tourist spot.
Sad for india usa and other foreign countries making nice china town that why nowadays we saw many Chinese people too play for their country if india did as that same they also would join in sport for india.
Ya lumaya
A
Which people mind wash you not indian you born all India people