I think fenty pulled you together. Your chest, arm and face seemed to blend together better and got consistent in color. A life Lesson for makeup I've discovered is that I'm far more light then I thought I'd be. I think you lowkey felt the same because you got a lot of light mediums and the few light you tried were the best matches.
Girl, fenty is it. You have pinker undertones than you think. Your face, neck and chest are different, your face sees more sun than your neck and your neck sees more sun than your chest. That is why there is such a drastic difference. The happy medium between all three is your jaw bone. Fenty is the best choice.
I think the fenty beauty is a fantastic match. Maybe try mixing in oils or like some dewy drops to make it a more dewy foundation versus drying. I do agree with a previous commenter that you lean towards foundations that are too dark because your arms are tanned than the rest of your body and the redness of your face makes it seem darker. You can always darken a foundation with bronzer but you cant lighten a base that is too dark.
I know you may not have meant it this way, but if James were to read this it may come off as hate and not constructive criticism, which he is all about.
Oh, definitely Dior and Fenty. They were perfect matches. The Too Faced one was a little orange imo, the best foundations were those with pink undertones and not yellow.
james: "everyone i convinced im not warm toned" Also him: trying warm tones and them not matching him me: your not warm toned your a little darker than pale
"Do I literally not have warm undertones, have I been lying to myself this whole time?" YES. Yes sis you have. You are literally Cool / Pink undertones. You need cool or neutral shades, with a peachy tone.
Fenty hands down! you look freaking amazing. Second would be the Dior Flash. I know you said you don't like spraying it but you can spray it on your hand and then pick it up with your blender. Then the Morphe foundation.
Dior spray and milk foundation goes PERFECT for your neck and chest and I love the born this way for your face as well as morphe and fenty but you’d have to see how it matches with your neck using the dior spray or milk foundation! Using two different colors for your face and neck would be better for you since the color looks differently in both areas❤️
I vote Fenty shade 170. Also your hair is really cool James! edit: thanks for all the likes. lets see if we can get to 1K likes Also what does highlighted comment mean?
The Dior spray and Fenty matched perfect! You're alot paler than you think.. you need to stop using yellow tones sis your skin is PINK on your face! Also the Mac one you swatched by your eye was a rlly good match so why wasn't it in the finals? XO
I really wanted you to blend out all of the swatches just to see which shade came from all of the swatches lol. the FENTY and the MORPHE looked the best I think. This was a cool video
Yas! Couldn’t he have like mixed multiple foundations together to find the perfect one. Imagine if he mixed all the final ones together!!! It probably could have made a perfect match!!!
When you first applied the foundation my list was: 1. fenty 2. dior 3. makeup forever 4. too faced 5. milk 6. morphe But AFTER oxidization: 1. fenty 2. too faced 3. dior 4. morphe 5. makeup forever 6. milk I wish you would have given the nars foundation a chance at the full face tryout Love you sister ❤️
Let's scream together...FENTY! That definitely matched flawlessly. Then too faced and finally makeup forever. Such a great video. The struggle is real. I hate playing the matching game with foundation. Does fenty make a dewy foundation? Xoxo
Fenty isn't dewy unfortunately. It dries down fast so you don't have to use powder much. It works well with oily skin or if you are in an area which has high humidity. If you are in a dry area, use a sticky primer or a primer that doesn't mattify your face because it will be super dry on your skin especially for combi skin.
Too faced and Fenti look amazing! Thanks for the video. I find that I can’t match mine either because, like you, my neck, arm, hand, chest, and face are all different colors. Makeup artists find it incredibly difficult to match me. xo
James: "let's try this one, it's a little more pinky toned. Ooh, it blends right in, it's literally almost a perfect match!" Also James: "I do NOT have pink undertones"
Imagine you work at whatever store he is at and seeing 2 sketchy people in hoodies and then looking closer and realizing it’s james charles and his cameraman/camerawoman
tbh james should start matching to his neck, cuz thats what mostly gets hiim caught, and along with using orange color corrector for his beard should use some green color corrector for the pink in his face. i know we’ve all been picking this forever
The Fenty Beauty foundation looked the best on you James. Milk was too pale and so was the Morphe foundation. Dior was a little too pale as well. The Makeup Forever foundation looked good but it gave off an oily look. Too faced was nice also but, it gave off a oily look as well and it was close to your neck color but Fenty was the best. Hope you see this Sister James. Love ya!!☀️💕
FENTY IN THE SHADE 170!!! I really love it and don’t let them haters get in your way you can make whatever shade you want look GREAT!!!! I love you! ❤️ Omg thanks for all of the likes
I completely understand him. His body and his face have two completely different skin shades and undertones. I'm a person of color and I'm the same as well. My face is lighter and has a warmer undertone while my body is darker and more cooler. So I love you and don't listen to the step sisters
You’re so right he shouldn’t have a care in the world it’s him we’re all different and all know him but he knows him the best and you shouldn’t care what other people say
I loved the Too Faced and the Fenty Beauty one but I think no matter what foundation you have on you will always look sister snatched!!!!! And I also thing that the NARS foundation was a good one too I forgot to mention that!!!!
I think fenty pulled you together. Your chest, arm and face seemed to blend together better and got consistent in color. A life Lesson for makeup I've discovered is that I'm far more light then I thought I'd be. I think you lowkey felt the same because you got a lot of light mediums and the few light you tried were the best matches.
*I think the fenty beauty color was honestly the best match, you can't even see a color difference between the neck and face*
Kat Chartreux yeah I agree
Timestamp?
True
Vyansyah 20:40
Totally agree
Girl, fenty is it. You have pinker undertones than you think. Your face, neck and chest are different, your face sees more sun than your neck and your neck sees more sun than your chest. That is why there is such a drastic difference. The happy medium between all three is your jaw bone. Fenty is the best choice.
The Fenty one was literally a perfect match! Imagine that!
YES IT REALLY WASSSSSSS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! sorry let me stop yelling!😭
❤I agree
fenty 170 is definetly your perfect shade
The Fenty was the best shade match in my opinion. Second would be the Dior AirFlash Spray.
Who wanted to see James blend all the foundations together on his face
YES I WAS THINKING THAT EXACT THING WHILE WATCHING THIS!
I did
Like this sis
Same
I did too!! 😀
he swears he doesnt have pink undertones, but im a first time watcher and i see it immediately
I think the fenty beauty is a fantastic match. Maybe try mixing in oils or like some dewy drops to make it a more dewy foundation versus drying. I do agree with a previous commenter that you lean towards foundations that are too dark because your arms are tanned than the rest of your body and the redness of your face makes it seem darker. You can always darken a foundation with bronzer but you cant lighten a base that is too dark.
Elizabeth Rose , I totally agree the fenty beauty is a fantastic match :)
The fenty foundation looks the absolute best and looks like you’re not wearing anything. Otherwise the dior looked fairly close
Anyone else here binge watching James during the corona outbreak
Too relatable...
MEEEEE
how did you know
Meeeee!!!
ME
not him thinking he has a warm undertone this man is a strawberry🤚
literally
Lol y’all watching this in 2021
I know you may not have meant it this way, but if James were to read this it may come off as hate and not constructive criticism, which he is all about.
Gees leave him alone he is trying his best
He said he isn't
Oh, definitely Dior and Fenty. They were perfect matches. The Too Faced one was a little orange imo, the best foundations were those with pink undertones and not yellow.
the fenty one DEFINITELY matched the best
sunset shine yea ur right
Sunset shine very true
Too faced, Fenty and Dior. I feel like you should match to your neck because that's the most noticeable part to where it wouldn't match.
jessxbabyy I totally agree
Yup
jessxbabyy I feel you!
james: "everyone i convinced im not warm toned"
Also him: trying warm tones and them not matching him
me: your not warm toned your a little darker than pale
Undertones have nothing to do with how dark or pale you are
Fenty is the match sister..maybe try mixing it with face mosturiser or something if you think the formula is too dry for you
just another human I feel like one of the Farsali elixir or essence would mix great with the Fenty foundation
The fenty foundation looked best on you. Looked fresh and honestly like nothing on skin.
I think the Fenty one is the best mach!
Same!
The Dior flash, spray one IS his match!!
James: *puts on the lightest foundation*
People who remember Flashback Mary:
I remember the flashback Mary and his foundation picking is not that great, he could have just asked someone to give him a foundation match
@@olivia-jayde3766 okay mhm
"Do I literally not have warm undertones, have I been lying to myself this whole time?" YES. Yes sis you have. You are literally Cool / Pink undertones. You need cool or neutral shades, with a peachy tone.
Fenty hands down! you look freaking amazing. Second would be the Dior Flash. I know you said you don't like spraying it but you can spray it on your hand and then pick it up with your blender. Then the Morphe foundation.
Manal Elbarhoumi I love all of those too but the morphe looks a little light and can kinda cause flashbacks
Yes sister that's what I said 😅
Treall Bartholomew no u didn’t 😐😶
Manal Elbarhoum
Fenty looks so perfect ahh
the problem he’s having is his undertones are pink, and the he’s choosing some foundation that has a yellow undertone. try an ivory shade!
I wish james blended all of the colors together at the end
Plus imagine it was his perfect shade
ikr
omg yea!!!
So everytime he has to do this lol
Same
@@thelifeofimi4214 lmao
1. Fenty
2. Too Faced
3. Dior
4. Makeup Forever
5. Morphe
6. Milk
Adri _2789 yeah u right
Agreed
Adri _2789 agreed
agreed fenty was the best match
Yess
FENTY 170 LOOKS SO BEAUTIFUL ON YOU SISTER!
2 faced and fenty looked the best in my opinion!❤
Fenty was the best considering how it matched your face and chest
The too faced really does match you well, but personally I think the fenty brings the warmth you prefer while also withholding your actual color.
I think Fenty looked liked it matched the best! 💕
BritanyRaquell kk
Dior spray and milk foundation goes PERFECT for your neck and chest and I love the born this way for your face as well as morphe and fenty but you’d have to see how it matches with your neck using the dior spray or milk foundation! Using two different colors for your face and neck would be better for you since the color looks differently in both areas❤️
Fenty was the best color match, but Too Faced was also very close! You could try mixing them maybe?
Madison & Her trashy art That is EXACTLY what I was thinking!!!
I think the Fenty looks closest to the skin tone but Too Faced is a very close match as well. He honestly could go either way
You’re definitely more cool toned than warm. The fenty foundation is the best match
okay the fenty 170 looks like an absolute perfect match
Time stamp plz?
Beeboo Phan yAes SHiSTar
30:22 is the timestamp :3
Clara Rodriguez check my reply
James: “It is officially 2019 I hope everyone is having a great start to the brand new year~”
Me: “it is officially 2021 and I’m slowly dying~”
xd
Haha🤣
Sorry
I vote Fenty shade 170. Also your hair is really cool James!
edit: thanks for all the likes. lets see if we can get to 1K likes
Also what does highlighted comment mean?
The born this way or Fenty matched best! You have a very pink undertone and I think nude in born this way matched that almost perfectly!
The 2 in the middle are the best matches
Yeah, I agree. As much as you may hate to admit it, *cough* karma *cough*, Fenty beauty matched you the best.
Yess those were my two picks that's I kept going back and forth on. I picked fenty finally
Nah that shade was to dark
The Dior spray and Fenty matched perfect! You're alot paler than you think.. you need to stop using yellow tones sis your skin is PINK on your face!
Also the Mac one you swatched by your eye was a rlly good match so why wasn't it in the finals? XO
Paul Collins preach I agree with you 100% and was thinking the same thing
i know i’m 4 years late but why is james gaslighting himself into thinking he’s tan
You know he has lightning in the studio right? He obv looks way paler than in real life 🤧.
I really wanted you to blend out all of the swatches just to see which shade came from all of the swatches lol. the FENTY and the MORPHE looked the best I think. This was a cool video
Was thinking he was going to do that
Time for safiya nygard to step in 😂
Yas! Couldn’t he have like mixed multiple foundations together to find the perfect one. Imagine if he mixed all the final ones together!!! It probably could have made a perfect match!!!
I know same
Honestly I'm always so self conscious of my foundation color even tho I try to get as close as possible, but this video made me feel a lot better 😀
I think the Fenty Beauty and the Dior Foundation were the best matches and your skin does look like it has a pink undertone BUT It’s your decision
Fenty was the best
I loved how the Dior looked on him it was so beautiful
weird sis he definitely has pink undertones
Fenty actually looks best on you!
Kris the Cat I agree!!
I 100% agree!
Yes
Yeah 👌
For sure
I think it would be fun if you all blended all the foundations together and find the perfect match
He puts so much work into his videos its incredible
Fenty 170 and Dior air in 200 are it sis
And the nars one
The fenty one was perfectttt for your skin tone
SexyAngel dude , get off of yt
@@vivianyork2488 right
Lmfao , she deleted her comment!
The morphe matches you so well ( I’m not good at makeup) but it matches your skin so well!
When you first applied the foundation my list was:
1. fenty
2. dior
3. makeup forever
4. too faced
5. milk
6. morphe
But AFTER oxidization:
1. fenty
2. too faced
3. dior
4. morphe
5. makeup forever
6. milk
I wish you would have given the nars foundation a chance at the full face tryout
Love you sister ❤️
Fenty really matched well with your overall skin tone.
Fenty totally killed it. You look slightly orange with most of the other ones.
Agreed
I think James should have mixed all of the colors on his face, to see what foundation color that would have made
Fenty! Also you arent warm toned you're definitely pink toned!
Sarah Kimberling pink toned *is* warm toned
bagel boys no, pink is considered cool and yellow is considered warm. Those are the 2 main undertone categories
I was shook that he thought he was warm toned!
FENTI was the best!! I think you're a lot lighter and pinker than you think 😂😂😂
Yeah, he just really wants to look more warm toned as opposed to rosy. Oh well
HAHA THATS MEEEEE I am wayyyyy pinker than I think
I love your videos America!! ❤️
Agreed! Love your videos America!
I agree
Fenty is LITERALLY perfect on you!!!
Alanah Fulop I like that, Dior and Too Faced. I think Morphe and Milk are too pale and I think makeup forever is too orange
Amen sis fenty
2 faced in the color nude looks really good! Morphe looks perfect too! Sorry if I’m late! 😊
Fenty and too faced is the perfect match
I think the Fenty looks the best. It didn't even look like you were wearing makeup
Azuree Nikole that’s what I was thinking
Shyohbi Xxx same
it looks orange
@@kivamama3454 you're orange. There was no reason you had to reply to my comment if you thought it was orange like for real? Bruh
I agree
Fenty is literally a perfect match
I love that fenty one! A perfect match, James!
Fenty is the best it looks natural
FENTY WAS THE ONLY SHADE THAT PROPERLY MATCHED HIM AND THE FINISH WAS SO BEAUTIFUL
YASSSSSS SIS
rainbow lollipops rightttt ❤️
Fenty was the beeeeesssstttt match! It literally blended into your skin tone 😘
Aiden Formyvalentine a
James used to think he was so tan😭
Fenty. It's the best match by the looks. Doesn't even look like you're wearing anything.
34:29 Your best match of them all is Fenty Beauty, definitely.
Fragile As Glass definitely!
I think so to
Yessss
I agree with you
Fragile As Glass yup
the morphe one was my fav, but I think you look fab in any shade of foundation. love you.
I think the fenty one was the best (sorry sister James 😅)
Nethara Fernando same
same
Nethara Fernando the Fenty was good but the two lighter matchsticks I think would have been perfect if he blended them together!
Yes definitly the fenty one
Fenty😍x
Here's my opinion
1: Fenty
2: Too Faced
3: Dior
4: Makeup Forever
5: Morphe
6: Milk
Exactly what I was thinking
shahida popal yes
shahida popal i agree
But dior looked like the full face of sister highlighter challenge, Like, Sister sneATChaqdE
Fenty for sure
you should do a “3 different makeup stores match my foundation” type video
alex slack smart
so trueeee
James Charles if you are looking at this you got me into makeup!
Let's scream together...FENTY! That definitely matched flawlessly. Then too faced and finally makeup forever. Such a great video. The struggle is real. I hate playing the matching game with foundation. Does fenty make a dewy foundation? Xoxo
Fenty isn't dewy unfortunately. It dries down fast so you don't have to use powder much. It works well with oily skin or if you are in an area which has high humidity. If you are in a dry area, use a sticky primer or a primer that doesn't mattify your face because it will be super dry on your skin especially for combi skin.
fentyyyy but if you don’t like the consistency then definitely too faced
Shannon Schollaert yep agree 💯
FENTY LOOKS SO GOODDDDD
F Rhianna
Too faced and Fenti look amazing! Thanks for the video. I find that I can’t match mine either because, like you, my neck, arm, hand, chest, and face are all different colors. Makeup artists find it incredibly difficult to match me. xo
James: "let's try this one, it's a little more pinky toned. Ooh, it blends right in, it's literally almost a perfect match!"
Also James: "I do NOT have pink undertones"
april his face was a like sooooooo pink
omg i just saw your profile pic and was like ‘OMG IS LOUIS’
His whole body is pink 😂 look at his hands
Your profile’s pic 🤤❤️❤️❤️
april lol
Dior and fenty look pretty nice and make you slightly tanner like you wanted
The fenty foundation is literally ur perfect match
Imagine you work at whatever store he is at and seeing 2 sketchy people in hoodies and then looking closer and realizing it’s james charles and his cameraman/camerawoman
Fenty and Morphe for sure, don’t worry about it looking a lil pale bc u can always add bronzer sis
Angela León my thoughts exactly!!!
Agreed!
Angela León yeah and even Dior but the packaging in so annoyed
Pro tip: if you don’t like how the Fenty looks more matte, it will look Perfect and a lil dewy with some setting spray trust me
Too faced and fenty looks tha best
I’d definitely say Fenty’s foundation looks the best on you Sister James!!!💛💛💛
Lacey J My grandpa told me if I got 3.5K subscribers on TH-cam by the end of this week that he will stop smoking.
Please help me guys......
ImDriven ur soo close 🤞🏼
Agreed
Tiger kittens123 Cute don’t fall for it he/she just trying to get subs
tbh james should start matching to his neck, cuz thats what mostly gets hiim caught, and along with using orange color corrector for his beard should use some green color corrector for the pink in his face. i know we’ve all been picking this forever
In my opinion, I think Dior and fenty really matches your skin color.
Totally agree
Fenty was THE BEST match. It also looked GORGEOUS on your skin!
now you can try the new Fenty powder and concelers!
The Fenty Beauty foundation looked the best on you James. Milk was too pale and so was the Morphe foundation. Dior was a little too pale as well. The Makeup Forever foundation looked good but it gave off an oily look. Too faced was nice also but, it gave off a oily look as well and it was close to your neck color but Fenty was the best. Hope you see this Sister James. Love ya!!☀️💕
Lexie NoneYa well since they aren’t set some are gonna look oily
Ya sis he didn’t use powder, it’s all about shades here not finish 💖
2 years later, I’m going to say the Fenty one 😂 Born this way was a really good match too.
the fenty one looked BOMB 🤯💗
Rosa McNeil he likedddd was
Fenty was by far the best, but too faced was a good second option if you like the formula more!
Al bw agree
i totally agree
Fenty
Its def the fenty and two faced
Yessss
Litterally the 2 I was gonna comment
@@kikac2292 omg hi sisterr
@@Flowersinatub Hey Sister c:
James should blend them all in at the end and add a little pink
FENTY IN THE SHADE 170!!! I really love it and don’t let them haters get in your way you can make whatever shade you want look GREAT!!!! I love you! ❤️
Omg thanks for all of the likes
Fenty for sure. Hands down. No tea, no shade. All love
Rachel Manns agreed
Fenty or Too Faced
I think Fenty, overall, looked VERY natural. I haven’t tried it yet, but now I want too. The first 2 options were great, as well.
...no pink lemonade
Lol that too!
I completely understand him. His body and his face have two completely different skin shades and undertones.
I'm a person of color and I'm the same as well. My face is lighter and has a warmer undertone while my body is darker and more cooler. So I love you and don't listen to the step sisters
He's like...
🔴
🌟⬜🌟
🌟🌟
My legs, , stomach and chest are all really pale but my face, and neck and arms are like warmer tone then my rest of my body
Coronavirus
Yeah he shouldn't listen and care
You’re so right he shouldn’t have a care in the world it’s him we’re all different and all know him but he knows him the best and you shouldn’t care what other people say
i know it has been 3 years but the milk fenty and the morphe look really good on you
Fenty and too faced for sure!! Too faced is literally perfect!!!
too faced oxidized orangey on him
1. Fenty
2. Too faced
3. Morphe
The Morphy looks awful
Dia Abdul I agree
My top two are:
1. Fenty 170
2. Too Faced Nude
Tessykinz me too
Samee
YESS!!
Same
I loved the Too Faced and the Fenty Beauty one but I think no matter what foundation you have on you will always look sister snatched!!!!! And I also thing that the NARS foundation was a good one too I forgot to mention that!!!!
I feel like fenty and too faced foundation matched the best
Lacy High OMG YES
trueee
YESSSSS!!!! I agree fenty and too faced were the best matches