RWBY Volume 9 Episode 6 'Confessions Within Cumulonimbus Clouds' - Discussion, Analysis & Review

แชร์
ฝัง
  • เผยแพร่เมื่อ 10 ธ.ค. 2024

ความคิดเห็น • 58

  • @HASHMAL_The_mobile_chicken
    @HASHMAL_The_mobile_chicken ปีที่แล้ว +8

    I'm that zwei man in twitter!! Thank you so much for using my transcript (although it's not perfect, I think) on your amazing stream!! I really enjoyed it!!

  • @Sasrael
    @Sasrael ปีที่แล้ว +24

    I think that Jayne might be only about 30-40 years old. The white hair could have been caused by the stress of him getting poisoned and surviving

    • @Sasrael
      @Sasrael ปีที่แล้ว +3

      He could even be in his 20s

    • @darkking7025
      @darkking7025 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      ​@@Sasrael yes it could be that he looks older instead of aging

  • @majors8052
    @majors8052 ปีที่แล้ว +8

    I can see the desire for a more clear “I’m ready to confess” on Yang’s part but I feel like the whole scene is that she wasn’t ready. Not for lack of feelings but for lack of thinking her feelings mattered in a sense? Yang has always shown love through actions and she is not super vulnerable so the idea of Talking about her love for Blake and being confident about them is what brought them to their own crossroad. We see that Blake is ready and eager and encourages Yang the entire time because she has full trust in her. And it’s not that Yang doesn’t trust Blake but she still afraid regardless. This is the first person she’s loved romantically or at least in such a big way and she Does Not Know if things will be fine. And it feels so grounded despite the magical realism because she knows she cares about Blake and is Pretty Sure Blake cares about her too. But she even says “I think I love you” when Blake tells her to say it First. She’s uncertain and afraid of the free fall but Blake being the one to encourage her to say it makes her the more confident one in the moment which I think is the opposite of a hypocritical Weiss and Yang talk. Because I don’t think Yang would have mentioned it at all if not for this storm. Blake wanted to say it but was waiting for Yang. Yang was waiting on Herself to gain the courage. Blake being the one to give her that courage I think fits their relationship and highlights Yang’s vulnerability better than a set up scene. Even if she would tell Weiss she’s just waiting for the right time but is lying I think her “this can’t be what this is about” shows that she didn’t plan on a big love confession due to her fears. But Blake gives her the room to say it and then immediately follows up with her own assurance which is why the scene is so meaningful. They didn’t say it for anyone but themselves and Yang, who acts bravely when she’s afraid, got to be vulnerable and not punished for it. Blake took the lead but wasn’t mean about it. It was all very soft and showed such a rarely seen side of Yang I really appreciate

    • @LilpnuthaterOfficial
      @LilpnuthaterOfficial ปีที่แล้ว +3

      It's like the whole hand holding thing from episode 2. Blake was reaching for Yang but Yang wasn't quite ready to meet her there.

  • @gnomiegnome9415
    @gnomiegnome9415 ปีที่แล้ว +11

    3:16:11 What if, during a previous ponderstorm, Alyx was shown the specific moment that Jaune kills Penny. Without any of the context, Alyx assumes that they've been traveling with a child murderer. Would anyone really trust a child murderer?

  • @kikitiki6305
    @kikitiki6305 ปีที่แล้ว +6

    I feel like the whole summer thing is because as stated in the hallucination fog she saw huntress’s as unstoppable hero’s and she had summer above all else, she was her idol, but now with the knowledge off the gimmified people and her own failings she’s having doubts and that image of summer, most likely when she was young, around their age, and becoming a huntress, is weighing on her.
    Also the I feel like the shocked faces of blake and Yang is because they’re shocked that once they confessed they were right there in front of each other, very poetic, that all it took was those three words to bring them together

  • @viridian8786
    @viridian8786 ปีที่แล้ว +3

    Arryn, you responding "It does not come up again" to the bees confession just answers the question that there will be a 2nd ponderstorm
    Well well well

  • @klarafrejinger7192
    @klarafrejinger7192 ปีที่แล้ว +6

    Lewis writing the book instead of Alyx is actually a great theory in my opinion : D Imma belive that from now on

    • @calxiyn
      @calxiyn  ปีที่แล้ว +5

      THANK YOU!!!!!

  • @austinsebben1402
    @austinsebben1402 ปีที่แล้ว +12

    LONGEST STREAM!

  • @lauraechevarria425
    @lauraechevarria425 ปีที่แล้ว +4

    I donkt know if anybody here watched Once Upon a Time but Jaune's attitude this episode is very similar to Jefferson's (Mad Hatter) attitude towards Wonderland.

  • @princeOpalite3650
    @princeOpalite3650 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Something people tend to forget about tiren...is that's his semblance is temporarily destroying peoples aura from places he hits them...implying he can see aura so he can easily remember where to hit (and to people who will say...he will just memorize it...Renner tire fights like an unpredictble lunatic its why he's so dangerous ...so I think he's too busy doing back flips to rember stuff like that)

  • @Vandalieu
    @Vandalieu ปีที่แล้ว +11

    What I believed is Alyx eventually grew to regret what she did, and wrote Jaune to have drunk poison in her place, and left out her brother because she didn't want to admit what she did to him.

    • @EvanHambrook-yi6zs
      @EvanHambrook-yi6zs ปีที่แล้ว +3

      I actually think that Alyx never went back and the brother did. She made the sacrifice to allow him to back and got herself "ascended". The brother then wrote the story about Alyx in order to remember her and left himself out. Unfortunately I would also wager that Alyx is likely the Jabberwalker due to not ascending properly given that she is not from Ever After.

    • @Vandalieu
      @Vandalieu ปีที่แล้ว +1

      @@EvanHambrook-yi6zs unfortunately there are zero signs or reasons for Lewis to have been the one to go back and Alyx to have sacrificed herself.
      Altx was the one who poisoned Jaune and told him nothings stopping her from getting home.
      Alexis the one who pissed off the members of the Ever After.
      The Jabberwocker has a guy's voice and not a girls voice.
      Lewis writing himself out makes absolutely no sense, while someone as selfish as Alyx doing so fits her character perfectly.
      The only way I'll believe that Alyx was the one who stayed behind is if Alyx tried to sacrifice Lewis but that he moved out of the way and she became the sacrifice instead, and that Lewis was completely clueless about what she tried to do and thought she sacrificed herself for him.

  • @sortascouseace
    @sortascouseace ปีที่แล้ว +7

    I think the reason Jaune has been so angry and frustrated is because he has like 20 years on them at this point and RWBY are just like oh these darn kids.

  • @yaoskahansak8743
    @yaoskahansak8743 ปีที่แล้ว +4

    definitely agree with the whole telepathy part i definitely thought it was just like yang thinking something and we cut to blake and her thought process completed it.

  • @AZDfox
    @AZDfox ปีที่แล้ว +4

    Cal, you made a theory that Jaune was a butterfly. You have never cared about concrete evidence.

  • @Vandalieu
    @Vandalieu ปีที่แล้ว +6

    It's impossible for Jaune to go back a second time. When time rewound all the clock fruits also went back in time and weren't ripe until the time Jaune first arrived.
    Jaune was nervous about whether team RWBY were real or not, when they confirm they are he's completely relieved.
    Jaune blamed himself for what happened with Alyx and Lewis.

    • @calxiyn
      @calxiyn  ปีที่แล้ว +3

      But I mean right now, since the time has passed and the clocks should be ripe again, could he go back in time again?

    • @Vandalieu
      @Vandalieu ปีที่แล้ว +2

      @@calxiyn the other problems with him having gone back multiple times already is that one he wasn't sure RWBY was real or not, something he'd be sure of if this really wasn't his first time, and two he should know what actually happened to Lewis at the tree as there would have been at least one time he pretended to drink the poison and then secretly follow them to find out what actually happened at the tree, but he doesn't know. So there is no way he went back and plucked another fruit to turn back time. Finally unless Jaune stopped aging completely there is no way he turned time back multiple times.

    • @Vandalieu
      @Vandalieu ปีที่แล้ว +2

      Alyx staying behind also doesn't make any sense as she outright told Jaune that nothing would stop her from getting home. She also became paranoid of her brother as well as Jaune.

  • @ariahcodes
    @ariahcodes ปีที่แล้ว +4

    Honestly I think Hunter's notion that Jaune would end up in Alyx's time if he left with her IS the simpler explanation. It seems like a leap in logic to assume that time works differently in each place. Not like, a big leap, it's still a workable theory I just think it's not simpler than Hunter's idea. Love you both!

  • @AZDfox
    @AZDfox ปีที่แล้ว +2

    I mean, both Jaune and the Cat are present. To use your example, it's like if you're in love with two people, and they both come with you.

  • @yaoskahansak8743
    @yaoskahansak8743 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    4:16:18 I absolutely adore the scene we got but i’ve gottta say a moment in the market where blake and ruby are interacting and yang and weiss are walking together and yang is like smiling at blake and weiss giving her advice would’ve been so good and I feel like the way they could’ve made the parallel from volume 5 to now is that Yang isn’t angry at Blake this time around, she’s not angry but she’s also still scared to fully open herself up because realistically yang has deep abandonment issues and we all know she hasn’t forgotten being left behind by blake

  • @kokopuffs7618
    @kokopuffs7618 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    Regarding the whole were May’s parents transphobic thing. I always interpreted that May got disowned and then came out after she left for Mantle. So they lost a son but they also lost a daughter they never even got to know

  • @jerrybeard8995
    @jerrybeard8995 ปีที่แล้ว +7

    Will everyone be pissed "if" they have them all lose their memories when they return, so essentially erase the kiss? I hope they don't do that, but as weird as things are here, it could happen.

  • @darkking7025
    @darkking7025 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    Hey Cal I think jaune didn't touch the stopwatch after not liking being able to stop it from reversing and decided to wait for team rwby to land after finding ruby's scythe and I think the stopwatch only affects the island and the tree brings you to your own time period no matter if you reverse time on the island!
    Also Jaune looks like wiess's Grandfather and I like wiess X Dilf Jaune and I think they will get together (jaune is handsome! cal) plus I don't think you knock other people's taste in men or women!

  • @ema7011
    @ema7011 ปีที่แล้ว +3

    looks like she's not that enthusiastic with the bees because she's not that attached to either character (or like the relationship they have. and other pairings are preferred) and that's okay but it's kinda hilarious to see cal and hunter (? sorry im not really familiar with their names) be a mess at that part loll
    im with hunter in this btw 😂 i just really enjoyed the bees. we've been waiting so long,, i did not cry but i got so excited and a bit emotional seeing them happen

  • @dominant1009
    @dominant1009 ปีที่แล้ว +5

    I really like that Blake&Yang finally confessed and r together...wish the kiss was longer though and i feel like Yang was afraid to confess because she never was in a romantic relationship & so she didn't know how2...& i think that Blake knew how Yang felt but was being patient with her because she knew Yang never dated any1 b4...Blake is the one with the experience and Yang is more of a dominant nature so i guess Blake was following Yangs lead even though Yang was shitty at flirting Blake let her do her little thing and responded eachtime...heck i myself know about being dominant/masculine lesbian with no experience and trying to date and experienced femm...i hard to learn about relationshiping from her 😂😂...fear & nervousness i always had that..but korassami for me is still the best...maybe bumblebee took a bit too long so the impact for me was not as strong as i thought it would be especially after Caitlin&Vi progressing a bit faster and maybe even Val&Yazmin...so glad kazu died 🙄🙄🙄

  • @tokubenanimations6506
    @tokubenanimations6506 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    I've been watching the kiss scene on TH-cam. And BOY was I happy.

  • @greyworld6242
    @greyworld6242 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    Calling it now jaune will get new armor with his older appearance looking like a fucking king and no longer as a knight and his sword will be reforged with the time clock merged with the scabbard of his sheath. Especially since his symbol has always been two crescent moons with would be interesting.
    Rise of the Crescent King!

  • @GreatSageEqual
    @GreatSageEqual ปีที่แล้ว +2

    Also Cal was based. The bmblb moment was like the Final Fantasy House. Lol

  • @yaoskahansak8743
    @yaoskahansak8743 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    the theory of neo and ruby communicating via telepathy kinda made me laugh bc i just picture neo seeing ruby and just automatically trying to kill her and with the way ruby’s headspace has been kinda portrayed i don’t imagine ruby putting up too big of a fight😬

  • @RonquixoteDIII
    @RonquixoteDIII ปีที่แล้ว +1

    5:25:31 anyone know what the name of this ost is

  • @emilie77260
    @emilie77260 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    Sorry for my english, even if i understand it, it's still complicated to write. I think Lewis was like following Alyx just before they felt so she is the reason her brother is here with her. And as a little sister who is very protective with my oldest sister because well her health is fragile and all. I think that herb make her realised that he is here because of her and that she can't protect him. Maybe she learned about the Jabberwalker or something.
    I know that one day i felt like my sis was really in danger and i know that i was litteraly just thinking about protecting her. So maybe when she realised that she was just in survival mode and the fact that she knew that the cat wanted something from them, she was more prone to trust him because they all need each other to get what they wanted. But Jaune was more reluctant to to do what they think they need to survive so she might chose to poisoned him for that.
    And yeah i totally agree with the theory of Lewis was the one to get out of the ever after, because the name of the original author and well, i'm persuaded that Alyx would do anything to protect him.

  • @Vandalieu
    @Vandalieu ปีที่แล้ว +1

    The season story was completely true, and the tale of the two brothers was also true.

  • @willanrac
    @willanrac ปีที่แล้ว +2

    I dont really buy that jaune is bad/evil/crazy. From the way jaune described everything he was ok with the cat until the cat offered him ascension. It sounds like none of the kids nor jaune knew about ascension, likely until alex found out during her hooka episode. She probably saw jaune as one of the natives the way he kept trying to keep them to the story he knew.
    Jaune only found out about ascension when the cat found he lost his purpose and offered him ascension.
    I dont think jaune ascended, but i think he did find a purpose and will be stuck in ever after when rwby leaves.

  • @AZDfox
    @AZDfox ปีที่แล้ว +1

    I am the STRONGEST defender of Fashion Crimes (Ilia x Coco x Emerald)

  • @GreatSageEqual
    @GreatSageEqual ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Wanna read this Crack theory of mine?
    What if Ambrosius created the portals above the Ever After? What if Alyx became Summer Rose? I have strong evidence for both these things. Here's my explanation:
    Jaune used the fruit which allowed him to time travel backwards. He became old enough to essentially be the same age as Summer, Raven, Tai, and Qrow. (Given he has the old people face marks that Kali and Raven have.) This proves that there aren't any wacky rules regarding the order of who fell and that time flows at the same rate in remnant as it does in the Ever After. The order in falling was essentially a red herring. There is strong evidence that the portals that led to Vacuo is high above the Ever After, and that Ambrosius warned them to not fall as he knew that the Ever After was a place that is almost inescapable. But high above the ever after would be the best place to connect every portal without issue to allow safe passage to Vacuo. Now onto Alyx....
    Jaune lived the events of Alyx and found out the truth. Alyx betrayed both him and her brother and gave Luis' life to return to Remnant. But as we've seen with the tree, nobody returns as the way they once were. The Red King ascended by power of the tree to become the Red Prince and he was reborn with a different role or purpose. By this ruleset, this would allow Alyx to become someone else. It is commented by Ozpin that she "wasn't the same girl anymore", implying the journey changed her. This would put Summer around the age to be able to have Ruby. Summer must have discovered the truth somehow about where she came from (perhaps by asking Jinn? The lamp had 2 wishes left in the past 100 years right?) SO SUMMER FOUND A WAY TO RETURN TO THE EVER AFTER. AND THERES PROOF IN THE WEAPON THAT HAD HER REFLECTION IN IT. Ruby also saw the reflection of Alyx in the dagger she was drawn to. Alyx was mentioned having a dagger right? Anyways..... there's a few minor kinks that would need to be worked out I think, such as Jaune being as old as he is right now as compared to when he traveled with Alyx, and we need information on his actual journey on how he became the Rusted Knight. The second bit being the purpose of the Blacksmith, and what that means as far as Ruby's encounter with her. If we didn't see what's speculated to be Summer's weapon, I'd have guessed Alyx became Neo. But if the reflection of Alyx and Summer in the Blacksmith's tent works in any way like that trash shoehorn of a plot device known as a ponderstorm, then it's off to the races and by bet is on Summer. Now, for my question:
    Was it just me or was that some foreshadowing about Jaune possibly giving up his life to send the girls back to Remnant? (And please let me know if my theory is solid. I'm almost sold on it.)

  • @Animaniac0451
    @Animaniac0451 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    The subtitles aren't broken, as I understand it, Crunchyroll never provides subtitles for English 'dubs'

    • @calxiyn
      @calxiyn  ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Yeah, but they’ve been trying to get them working just for rwby for a couple weeks ago.

  • @dominant1009
    @dominant1009 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    As for Jaune i wonder if he will leave the ever after well if Jnpr is actually Lewis and he can't leave the place either...maybe Jaune will stay to fight the jabawakies with him and the bird and whoever else he teams up with...i always felt like Nora would have been a better leader anyway...guess the cat might run into Neo next and who knows maybe seeing how terrible she is as she might try to kill ruby and he gives her some of his heart like the prince and herb...hopefully Neo don't team up with the prince with her jabawakies and destroy everything while trying to kill team RWBY 😂😂

  • @Vandalieu
    @Vandalieu ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Blake wasn't the one who wanted to tell Robyn it was Yang.

    • @MC_5
      @MC_5 ปีที่แล้ว

      No, it was Blake, you can rewatch the episode.

    • @Vandalieu
      @Vandalieu ปีที่แล้ว +2

      @@MC_5 I did rewatch the episode before I even posted, yes it was Yang that came up with the idea not Blake.
      Blake: I'm not thrilled about ambushing a huntress that's just trying to help.
      Yang: Then maybe we shouldn't.
      Blake looks at Yang in surprise.
      That is literally what happens in the episode. Yang was literally the one who came up with the idea.
      The one who should actually rewatch the episode is you, because you're clearly confused.

    • @lucasdias4412
      @lucasdias4412 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      That's true

  • @bootay2835
    @bootay2835 ปีที่แล้ว +3

    what if the reason Herb acted the way he did with team RWBY was because the cat manipulated him when Alyx came by the first time and he had been running on the cats orders since then.

  • @joelmills4304
    @joelmills4304 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    "I opened origin" that's your first mistake

  • @Spaijit
    @Spaijit ปีที่แล้ว

    Can someone direct me to the cut line from Arryns part?

  • @supattreewatanawong5025
    @supattreewatanawong5025 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    when J go black in time we see time fruit got smaller and gone of couse J can't use it anymore even it still there how you sure that it can go forward if he try again he rick to go black even more there no way I take that mush risk he can't control and no way to knowe how long he go black he can stop time fruit by only broke it. Are you will take that mush risk ?

  • @sasukeleonomt8068
    @sasukeleonomt8068 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Where are the background character who fell

    • @Denizozzzy003
      @Denizozzzy003 ปีที่แล้ว

      They all died from Cinders attack on the bridge.

  • @AZDfox
    @AZDfox ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Miss "Butterfly Jaune" thinks HUNTER is making something too complicated?

  • @RaventheRevanchist
    @RaventheRevanchist ปีที่แล้ว

    Can’t believe Yang is the heterophobic dog