Very interesting and informative discussion. The panel members know a lot about the topic they are discussing here. I’ll not be surprised if none of these three is a Punjabi.
Dear sir, vast area of thal (Punjab) lying near the banks of river Indus,Chenab is barren due to shortage of water. Local people are poor shepherd. Thal irrigated area was allotted to settlers belonging to east Punjab and local people were ignored. It is very astonishing that people living near rivers since centuries are thirsty. Why are some people against already thirsty people of thal?
پنجاب کے اُس وقت کے وزیراعظم خضر حیات ٹوانہ نے حکومت سندھ سے ایک معاہدہ کیا تھا جس کے تحت دریاۓ سندھ پر صوبہ سندھ کاحق تسلیم کیا گیا تھا اور پنجاب (تھل کینال )کیلئے محدود پیمانے پر ماہانہ بنیاد پر پانی کی منظوری دی تھی۔ اس معاہدہ کو تلاش کرنے سے سندھ کا کیس مضبوط ہو گا۔
The biggest looser in Pakistan is kpk the agreement in 1992. There were four canals one each for each province..The three for the other three provinces were completed. The chashma right bank lift canal which was for Kpk is still Not started yet. That share of the Indus water which belongs to kpk is still used freely by Punjab and sind.
42 MAF is the average annual water flow into the sea. If sea is encroaching, it is because most of the water flows into the sea during the few months of monsoon. Why, because we have failed to build dams to store that water for use post monsoon. No one is willing to tell the truth. India is already planning to ask for amendments in Indus Water treaty because we are wasting so much of water annually into the sea. Land & people of delta are important but has anyone thought about millions of acres of land that has been lost under the dams in Punjab, KP & Azad Kashmir & people that lived on those lands for centuries. All for the collective good of Pakistan especially Sindh. Have these Sindhi nationalist dokandars ever said anything about those people let alone thank them for their sacrifice. Most recently 100 sq km land will submerge in Bhasha dam lake. Mangla dam was submerged 250 sq km, the whole city of Mirpur went under the water. Remember, GB & Azad Kashmir fought war to join Pakistan.
42 MAF ??? Dam's are out-dated technology nowadays having less advantages with high disadvantages. Dam's produce methane gas it's ill effect for water quality itself in upstream. Water reaching into sea is not a wastages first you should clearly know, it's delta security and aquatic needs plus ecology circumstances also for mangroves safety because mangroves are main features of Oxygen For Karachi as well as countries need. Because of Dam's construction in upstream Indus River is dying every year & Deltaic region like Thatta and Badin District fertile lands merging into Sea because of no ample water coming to Sea where 8_20 acres of fertile lands merging every day because Deltaic regions not needs Fresh Sweat Water but also Silt & clay for it's security and Because of Dam's Silt+clay remains upstream of Rivers so We are losing Our Lands. Pakistani Govt have 80% budge on defense to save it's inch inch of lands BUT You foolished Man don't think about Sindh's lands ? Not inch but acre's of lands going to Sea Area , ??? Pakistani Gernels sold Punjab's 3 Rivers because of Loan's to India by world Bank brokery,,, So You were sleeping that time??? When we have need of water for Kharif season You people's Stops out water in Dam's and shifting to Punjab,, later When Dam's are filling then you have limited use then Rains are starting so Sindh is flooded because you Save Dam's for collapse, extra water lifting to us plus river water and also Rain water makes Sindh as flooded.. Make some sense
In Pakistan Pharos era irrigation system is going on So it's better to change irrigation system in Pakistan where 60% water wastage occurs because of Old irrigation system,,, it's better to save Rivers and Ecology and Environment and without any quarrel you can lift water in Barren lands by Latest technology and latest irrigation systems where water wastage becomes nealy zero 0 , so it's better choice to demolish all Dam's where they existed in Pakistan or India,,, India is threating to your thinking not they will do that because You lost your 3 River's in world's bank decieve and Gernels hypocrisy. Go to International Criminal Court and make Dr Hassan Abbas in this team we will achieve our 3 lost rivers actually these Rivers are Punjab's River's but also INDUS River tributories,,, So we can achieve our Goals also Destroying All Dams for River's Ecology Safety
@@KurulushOsmanSeriesUrduLIVE just check the number of canals added during in past 70 years & area brought under cultivation in Sindh. All that has been possible due to dams. Rest is just nonsense & rhetoric.
صاحب فرما رہے ہیں کہ دریائے سندھ پر سندھ کا حق ہے اور باقی چار دریا پر پنجاب کا حق ہے،یہ کیسے؟جب کہ سارے دریا چین سے شروع ہوتے ہیں اور انڈیا سے ہوتے ہوئے پنجاب آتے ہیں، یہ اس کا نام دریائے سندھ ہے اس لئے سندھ کا حق ہے؟جب کہ صوبہ سندھ کا نام دریائے سندھ کے نام پر ہے ،نا کہ سندھ دریا کا نام سندھ کے نام پر، اور پنجاب کے جو نام صاحب گنتی کر رہے ہیں وہ تو ایوب خان نے بیچ دئے ان میں تو مٹی ہی ہےاور ایوب خان نے بجائے کالاباغ ڈیم کے جو آسان اور سستہ بھی تھا فائدہ مند بھی تربیلا ڈیم سے زیادہ تھا، اپنے زاتی فائدہ کے لئے اور پنجاب کو نقصان کرنے کہ لئے تربیلا ڈیم بنا دیا، ،اور راجستھان کی کنال اب بھی چل رہی ہے،لاکھوں لوگوں کی اس سے زندگی ہے،
ہر چیز متنازعہ بنا دو
انڈیا میں غدار ہوتے تو پیاسے صحرا میں اندرا گاندھی کینال کبھی نہ بنتی
Very interesting and informative discussion. The panel members know a lot about the topic they are discussing here. I’ll not be surprised if none of these three is a Punjabi.
excellent, very informative program thanks
Very nice and informative talk thanks Hassan Abbas
❤❤❤🎉
Very informative and timely
Dear sir, vast area of thal (Punjab) lying near the banks of river Indus,Chenab is barren due to shortage of water. Local people are poor shepherd. Thal irrigated area was allotted to settlers belonging to east Punjab and local people were ignored. It is very astonishing that people living near rivers since centuries are thirsty. Why are some people against already thirsty people of thal?
Befior 1947 pungab had five river now we lost three river accoding to sind tas agrement dont reffer befor 147 aggre.ents 20:23
پنجاب کے اُس وقت کے وزیراعظم خضر حیات ٹوانہ نے حکومت سندھ سے ایک معاہدہ کیا تھا جس کے تحت دریاۓ سندھ پر صوبہ سندھ کاحق تسلیم کیا گیا تھا اور پنجاب (تھل کینال )کیلئے محدود پیمانے پر ماہانہ بنیاد پر پانی کی منظوری دی تھی۔ اس معاہدہ کو تلاش کرنے سے سندھ کا کیس مضبوط ہو گا۔
Gub PReasdeant Asif Zardareay neay in Fouear Cannleas ke Manzoureay Dey heay Tou Sindh keay Danshvears or PolteChieans in Seay Qoustioun kourean
Does Ranjit Singh army still work?
There is 1991water accord between provinces.This should be implemented in letter and spirit.
جس طرح سندھ اور پنجاب کے درمیان mistrust ہے بلکل اسی طرح بلکہ اس سے زیادہ کا mistrust دیہی اور شہری سندھ کے درمیان ہے
Jo indian migrate aai thay pakistan main un ko aik sazish k tehat sindh main abad kiyay hay
Waah, intellectual Waah...
کچھی کینال بہت ہی اہم پروجيکٹ ہے
✌️
The biggest looser in Pakistan is kpk the agreement in 1992. There were four canals one each for each province..The three for the other three provinces were completed. The chashma right bank lift canal which was for Kpk is still
Not started yet. That share of the Indus water which belongs to kpk is still used freely by Punjab and sind.
Save Pakistan from civil engineers mafia.......who continue to frighten people of water scarcity and proposing dams in Pakistan.
42 MAF is the average annual water flow into the sea. If sea is encroaching, it is because most of the water flows into the sea during the few months of monsoon. Why, because we have failed to build dams to store that water for use post monsoon.
No one is willing to tell the truth.
India is already planning to ask for amendments in Indus Water treaty because we are wasting so much of water annually into the sea.
Land & people of delta are important but has anyone thought about millions of acres of land that has been lost under the dams in Punjab, KP & Azad Kashmir & people that lived on those lands for centuries. All for the collective good of Pakistan especially Sindh. Have these Sindhi nationalist dokandars ever said anything about those people let alone thank them for their sacrifice.
Most recently 100 sq km land will submerge in Bhasha dam lake. Mangla dam was submerged 250 sq km, the whole city of Mirpur went under the water. Remember, GB & Azad Kashmir fought war to join Pakistan.
42 MAF ???
Dam's are out-dated technology nowadays having less advantages with high disadvantages.
Dam's produce methane gas it's ill effect for water quality itself in upstream. Water reaching into sea is not a wastages first you should clearly know, it's delta security and aquatic needs plus ecology circumstances also for mangroves safety because mangroves are main features of Oxygen For Karachi as well as countries need. Because of Dam's construction in upstream Indus River is dying every year & Deltaic region like Thatta and Badin District fertile lands merging into Sea because of no ample water coming to Sea where 8_20 acres of fertile lands merging every day because Deltaic regions not needs Fresh Sweat Water but also Silt & clay for it's security and Because of Dam's Silt+clay remains upstream of Rivers so We are losing Our Lands. Pakistani Govt have 80% budge on defense to save it's inch inch of lands BUT You foolished Man don't think about Sindh's lands ? Not inch but acre's of lands going to Sea Area , ???
Pakistani Gernels sold Punjab's 3 Rivers because of Loan's to India by world Bank brokery,,, So You were sleeping that time???
When we have need of water for Kharif season You people's Stops out water in Dam's and shifting to Punjab,, later When Dam's are filling then you have limited use then Rains are starting so Sindh is flooded because you Save Dam's for collapse, extra water lifting to us plus river water and also Rain water makes Sindh as flooded..
Make some sense
In Pakistan Pharos era irrigation system is going on So it's better to change irrigation system in Pakistan where 60% water wastage occurs because of Old irrigation system,,, it's better to save Rivers and Ecology and Environment and without any quarrel you can lift water in Barren lands by Latest technology and latest irrigation systems where water wastage becomes nealy zero 0 , so it's better choice to demolish all Dam's where they existed in Pakistan or India,,, India is threating to your thinking not they will do that because You lost your 3 River's in world's bank decieve and Gernels hypocrisy. Go to International Criminal Court and make Dr Hassan Abbas in this team we will achieve our 3 lost rivers actually these Rivers are Punjab's River's but also INDUS River tributories,,, So we can achieve our Goals also Destroying All Dams for River's Ecology Safety
@@KurulushOsmanSeriesUrduLIVE just check the number of canals added during in past 70 years & area brought under cultivation in Sindh. All that has been possible due to dams.
Rest is just nonsense & rhetoric.
@@hshakeem
You have not read my article well, again read & then reply
CANAL DAMS KI BAT
BUKHAAR
صاحب فرما رہے ہیں کہ دریائے سندھ پر سندھ کا حق ہے اور باقی چار دریا پر پنجاب کا حق ہے،یہ کیسے؟جب کہ سارے دریا چین سے شروع ہوتے ہیں اور انڈیا سے ہوتے ہوئے پنجاب آتے ہیں، یہ اس کا نام دریائے سندھ ہے اس لئے سندھ کا حق ہے؟جب کہ صوبہ سندھ کا نام دریائے سندھ کے نام پر ہے ،نا کہ سندھ دریا کا نام سندھ کے نام پر،
اور پنجاب کے جو نام صاحب گنتی کر رہے ہیں وہ تو ایوب خان نے بیچ دئے ان میں تو مٹی ہی ہےاور ایوب خان نے بجائے کالاباغ ڈیم کے جو آسان اور سستہ بھی تھا فائدہ مند بھی تربیلا ڈیم سے زیادہ تھا، اپنے زاتی فائدہ کے لئے اور پنجاب کو نقصان کرنے کہ لئے تربیلا ڈیم بنا دیا، ،اور راجستھان کی کنال اب بھی چل رہی ہے،لاکھوں لوگوں کی اس سے زندگی ہے،
Sind wants that all water of indus to be wasted in sea .. shame
Shame on you
Jab tak ppp ka saekar hi canal kabi nahi banighi seraf khan is ko bna sakta hi
No brother
Hussain bux thebo belongs with JM Sayd party not Rasool bux paleejo.
انگلش بولنے کا زیادہ شوق ھے تو ویلاگ انگلش میں بناؤ اردو انگلش ملا کر دونو زبانو کا بیڑہ غرق نہ کرو خالص اردو پورا پاکستان سمجھ لے گا