Editorial With Sujit Nair | CEA: “Govt. Can’t Solve Problems Like Unemployment”
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 9 พ.ค. 2024
- In this editorial segment, Mr. Sujit Nair discusses a pressing issue facing India: unemployment, along with a statement made by the Chief Economic Advisor. On March 27, Chief Economic Advisor V. Anantha Nageswaran emphasized that government intervention couldn't solve all social and economic challenges, stating that diagnosing problems like unemployment is easier than finding solutions. At the unveiling of the "India Employment Report 2024: Youth Employment, Education and Skills," co-authored by the International Labour Organisation and The Institute for Human Development (IHD), Nageswaran questioned the government's role in tackling unemployment beyond increasing its own workforce. He highlighted the importance of the private sector in job creation and outlined government initiatives like skill development and the National Education Policy of 2020, emphasizing the need to shield them from political influence. Nageswaran also mentioned corporate tax breaks and subsidies aimed at promoting employment over capital accumulation. Drawing parallels with a satirical film from the 1970s, he questioned whether governments globally were inadvertently discouraging work through welfare policies meant to alleviate the consequences of unemployment, potentially disrupting the labor market. He highlighted the unintended consequences of public policy interventions and questioned whether individuals, particularly the youth, were sufficiently motivated to work and equip themselves with the necessary skills.
#Unemployment #Youth #ChiefEconomicAdvisor #VAnanthaNageswaran #IndiaEmploymentReport2024 #InformalSector #FormalSector #SelfEmployment #LabourParticipation #InternationalLabourOrganisation #ILO
To get the latest news updates at your fingertips, download the HW News Shorts app: onelink.to/85hk86
To Join TH-cam Membership - / @hwnewsenglish
SUBSCRIBE to HW News English Here ► bit.ly/Subscribe-HWNews-English
Connect With Us On:
→ Facebook: / hwnewsenglish
→ Twitter: / hwnewsenglish
→ Instagram: / hwnewsenglish
→ Dailymotion : www.dailymotion.com/hwenglish
For More Videos Visit Here:
hwnews.in/
Chief Economic advisor should be awarded Padma Bhushan!
Yes , he will get it ! He will get Nobel, Bharath Rathna , Oscar, Filmfare etc.. keep chanting please , he will get all of them for sure 👍
tell me this is sarcasm
No Direct Bharat Ratna❤... but after 40 years..anyway this films 🎥 🎞 wisdom after 40 years turns out is still valid 🎉...so Bharst after 40 years 😅
Bharat Ratna😂😂😂
@@karanashish7144 : Yes dear! It is sarcasm... What was he doing these many years , he could have said this before right ! Moreover , his statement is like saving some culprits ! That's why my sarcasm 🤦
Great CEA! He should be given Nobel Prize 😅😅 Fantastic editorial!
Modiji ne recommend kya hai.
😂@@hirobhojwani4432
We should be happy that atleast chief advisor of our uneducated PM Modi speaks truth regarding unemployed.
We don't want such PM and govt if he can't solve unemployment!🤔
@@Omnamahshivaya010Don't elect any PM. Only private sector can create job. But people like to hate private.
@@rajx7120 : Not making any sense dear, say something practicle! No PM in democratic country , how will it be possible 🤔
@@Omnamahshivaya010 then why did Modi promised 2crs jobs per year.
@@sathishkumark911 : Who said he didn't promise ! What are you trying to tell me Sathish ? Reply relevantly ...
🎉 I admire you for your views expressed in this blog. You cannot blame the Chief Economic Advisor. If you vote for the current regime, you cannot depend upon the Government which is true 100%. Your reference to the demonetisation and it's ill effects on 85% of the small trade and industries are also true and the right reminder before elections. Instead of discussing religion and creating hatred which is the only thing this government does, a new narrative should be created by those opposing.
Ha Ha. The chief economic advisor should be given the Nobel Prize for Economics. He puts John Maynard Keynes to shame. Surely the BJP can recommend his nomination
Sujit Nair is right!
Most probably he got his qualifications through jugaad and the power of reservation.
😅@@drsawma
Actually THIS government can't do this.
We don't want to admit that we lack skill set. We don’t want to move out of our comfort zone and do an extra course which can boost our career.
And here is the easiest way out. Blame the Government.
@@TechWizardGinu copy paste job aaa😂😂🏏🙏
Which govt can do this? Please tell. No govt can do this.
@@rajx7120 what kind of thought is this.... govermint is functioning with tax payments....not from any private bank.... education,health and employment is governance to reach the need...stop reading WhatsApp University degree 😁
@@ramakrishna284 he has taken his masters frm there dude
MSME is the most neglected sector by the BJP govt. Many of them closed due to Demonetisation and GST apart from banks not giving loans to them.
True brother I m a victim too & still suffering.
Govt gave mudra loans and emergency loan scheme to MSME.
The only solution is do labour reforms. But your communist Nair, will not agree.
Our PM also explained all of us, selling pakodas is also awesome😅
Demographic Dividend has been destroyed in 10 years of Modi-Shah rule.
❤
Sir I also presume it is employability the biggest problem. I hire lot of people in software co. And I can say that 70% of them are waste candidates. They have multiple backlogs, their resume is just waste toilet paper and when they come to interview with zero preparation. How can we hire them. When I asked them basic questions like who is the president of india, one guy mentioned Abdul Kalam. When I asked what's the name of the rover landed on moon South pole, one guy told NASA. I mean how can we give job when they are not serious.
@@sandeshtg3289 Am curious, why should a potential software employee know about moon landings? Shouldn’t their capacity to do the job or fit into the company values be tested?
@@SodaPop275 No, when a fresher is been interviewed we ask these questions just to make him comfortable with easy questions and understand his simple general knowledge and also his communication. Very simple questions till that fear of an interview is gone and he becomes comfortable with the interviewer. We are not asking rocket science like what was the terminal velocity of the rocket and the ratio of the same if it was landed on Saturn 🤣🤣. And then we go to the resume and then ask technical questions and projects which he has done in his college. So that will be around 20 to 30 mins. But we will get to know in first 5 mins if he is In or out.
If Govt. can't solve the problems like unemployment then they should make policies for Population control or a One child policy. This is a serious matter and needs immediate attention. Please promote this through your channel.
Mr Nair. One of your best episode. An eye opener for all educated citizens.
Sir I also presume it is employability the biggest problem. I hire lot of people in software co. And I can say that 70% of them are waste candidates. They have multiple backlogs, their resume is just waste toilet paper and when they come to interview with zero preparation. How can we hire them. When I asked them basic questions like who is the president of india, one guy mentioned Abdul Kalam. When I asked what's the name of the rover landed on moon South pole, one guy told NASA. I mean how can we give job when they are not serious.
Thank you for bringing this episode to the people of India.
Govt cannot put an end to unemployment problem, correct & agreed... But govt can create policy, provide incentives, reduce taxation, launch Infra projects, encourage PPP model schemes, allow the small companies to move forward into midcap are very few things govt need to do... What have they done in last 10 years that they are stating they cannot provide employment to all.. 🤷🏼♀️🤦🏼♀️More sad story is, India today there is a real scarcity of good civil engineers... Best examples are money wasted on a bridge in Mumbai where both ends were constructed & unable to join in the middle & collapse of various bridges across country.. While the dams constructed by the Indian kings still serve its purpose... From there as a country we have fallen flat today.. 🤷🏼♀️
6
Exactly ! The Prime Minister announced in BJP Manifesto - 2 crore jobs a year. If employment is only announcing and announcing , the staistics of employment talking by PM reached 20 crores ever since 2014.
Credit goes to PM.
Modi govt is having all inefficient fellows running the govt like finance,home, agriculture, railways, social welfare etc etc.
Our blind voters please wake up
Piketty is one of the world renowned economists and What he says about INCREASE IN Inequality us Real
How much did you donate from your salary to reduce inequality? You can get 50% tax rebate on donations, did you know that? Do your bit to reduce inequality. Save taxes and donate to poor.
Prior to 2019 general election, union labour minister made a statement that reason for unemployment was the youth didn't have the required skill sets.
What a shame on Indians.
Still the same government has come to power.
What a pity.
SHAME.
CURRENT CENTRAL GOVT MOTIVE IS ENTRUST ALL TYPE OF WORK TO PVT ENTITY LIKE ADANI AMBANI BIRLA TATA ALONE
I wish, I could share this with people, but un fortunately they refuse to listen any reason.
CEA Anantnageswaran should be thanked for his honesty. But what is he himself doing about it?
yakaty yak
This advisor must be sent to Tihar jail and kept there to learn about cottage industries.
What a shame for the CEA say government has no say on reducing unemployment. Cant policy level changes be made,
Your style is inimitable ...power to you sir ....keep this urja on...
Just vote them out, choose the govt that can solve the real issues
What is the right govt ? What is the solution provided by opposition?
If you observe, Modi govt has been helping private sector by cleaning up NPAs. But you guys, yourself don't have any idea, but only know blame game.
Superb rendition
Fantastic Sir
My late father qualification was S.S.L.C. with Higher Typing , Higher short hand ENGLISH and Tamil. Retired as SR UNDER SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT OF TAMILNADU. Believe me he STARTED as a state government employee (STENO TYPIST )under BRITISH INDIA.
2 crores jobs in one year like 15 lacs.
Thank you
ex RBI GOVERNOR RAGHURAMRAJAN ALSO EMPASIS THIS NOTE IN HIS REPORT FEW DAYS BACK-HOWEVER BJP MINSTERS EVEN FM AND EDUCATION MINISTER EVEN PM FAIL TO SOLVE THE PROBLEMS -
He was the RBI governor during bjp rule.
Go through all the previous years and find out if at any time every one is emplyed. What CEA says is correct. Govt can only fill up vacancies in govt jobs and provide assiistance to those who start an enterprise.
The CEA of lndia has said that Govt cannot provide jobs, well a very fine revelation...Then, what can the Govt give to the people?
Do you how many start ups there now and what activity they are doing.How many of them have become unicorns
How many startups were there during upa rule .
Good reporting
If 8 hours job is converted to 12 hours then one shift will go and one shift work force will get un employed and will lead to more retrenchment of workers
We don't want to admit that we lack skill set. We don’t want to move out of our comfort zone and do an extra course which can boost our career.
And here is the easiest way out. Blame the Government.
So much problems
Then why was Modi viscerally critical of the then UPA Government of steering a "job less growth". He on the other hand not only has led a "job loss growth", but through his Chamchas in institutions is propogating a narrative abnegating the responsibility of a Govt., to generate jobs through prudent economic management.
You are good in explaining the content sir
Sunit ji you are good in bringing out the govt lapses for public awareness, but try to bring out the govt failure in facilitating drug lobby and preventing drugs in schools and collages some states ?
Beyond Modi,d capabilities to Govern India for development & stability but other way around he is extremely capable.
No netas No godi economist disappoints me sir.. the Common people the common voters Disappoints me.. they disappoint India.. all all r in front of them.. this govt. Openly doing steps of dictatorship.. cruhed any desents..this regime working day and night for onli rich and tycoons and openly saying cant do anything for us youth as the PM already said.. jao graduate hogaye ab jaa k pakoda becho.. bt this blind janta of us dnt see anything... govt. Cant solve unemployemnt govt. Cant solve peoples life social disgrace.. govt. Cant do anything for safty and dignity of women as seen in manipur govt cant show where thier money comming soo why hell peple needs a govt. Only to make enimity between people in name of Hindi muslim and working for thier tycoons lords... the biggest disaappointment "we the blind people of India"
Y we have unlimited terms 4 MLAs MPs instead of fixed terms of 2 max? How common man can become CM or PM if unlimited terms continue? Will reserved leaders get seats if reserved constituencies don't exist? Jai Hind 🙏🏼🧿!
After so many days after viewing the video I realised all people are not fools😂 kudos to cea
True sir
Ask this CEA to resign. Why does he need this job. What is the point of paying taxes, CEA and the government now?
Make and sell bakoda for self employment
We don't want to admit that we lack skill set. We don’t want to move out of our comfort zone and do an extra course which can boost our career.
And here is the easiest way out. Blame the Government.
@@TechWizardGinu pakada gaya.... gobar Gandhi gang 😂😂😂😂
@@TechWizardGinuThis is why I have always felt that India is not ready for democracy. We do not know what we are electing a government for. We pay through our noses for sub standard education that does not equip us adequately for any proper job and instead of demanding better, we take pride in our jugaad mentality. We are promised jobs before elections, but when the govt blatantly refuses to provide them, instead of questioning them and holding them to their promises, we accept their incompetence and blame ourselves for not being good enough.
We deserve to be ruled by monarchs and autocrats. We deserve to be slaves.
@@ShirazHansen - In this era of the 21st century, we as a society and as a nation has become habitual to criticize and blame the government for our every problem. We blame the government for corruption, for dry tabs, for load shedding, for illiteracy, for poverty, for unemployment, even for mosquitoes, and many more. The reason behind it is that we live in a democratic country, whose constitution gives us some fundamental rights for the expression of our thoughts, and hence we blame the government. Before blaming the government for our problems, we need to realize our civic responsibilities and duties. We blame the government for illiteracy but first, we need to realize that we are the people who do not send our children to government schools (which provide education, books, and even uniform for free). We blame the government for uncleanliness, dirty roads, and filthy public places but we should think about it who threw the litter. Surely authorities are responsible for daily cleanliness but civilians are responsible for that dirt and uncleanliness when they throw garbage instead of putting it in a dustbin thinking that sweepers are responsible for that mess when they don’t do their duty.
@@ShirazHansen - We blame the government for territory, but do honor killings ourselves. We blame the government for corruption but we give bribes to police and officials, we use pirated movies, software, and music, we don’t pay taxes, we hide our income during the calculation of income taxes and we prefer to buy exam papers and grades of studying the whole year. Directly or indirectly almost every person is involved in corruption but we have a problem with only corrupt politicians. So, before blaming officials and politicians, we need to correct ourselves and realize our civic responsibilities.
Chief economic advisor atleast accepts that modi govt is unable to do anything about unemployment to the point that its not govt. duty to solve unemployment their duty is to do communal politics and that they are doing perfectly. Well under this govt. FDI is at 15 year low
If one is getting a degree to German a job ,you are wasting your time and money. In stead of that learn a skill and get self employed. Follow the German model where majority don't go to college.Majority go to vocational schools and learn working skills
We don't want to admit that we lack skill set. We don’t want to move out of our comfort zone and do an extra course which can boost our career.
And here is the easiest way out. Blame the Government.
you want to make India a labour factory for the world... no higher education and high profile jobs but take vocational training and do low profile jobs for the west which this govt keeps on criticizing ....
latest eg of India becoming a labour factory for the world... is the Israel labour migration....
right now I see vloggers from developed and even developing countries come and give tips as if they are doing some favour for our poor population and we take proud in it...
this is the India we have created in the past ten years.... the rupee is so much shrinked that even developing countries come and behave as if they are giving donation.... and some people out of necessity take the money without an ounce of shame of what they are doing.
Your two bits are very revealing.
With AI coming , youth need different skill sets. PSU s like mtnl , air india etc were inefficient and had to be hired off.
Our youth want government jobs which don't exist with a fixed salary.
MSME and small businesses want loans which they will not return.
Bal Thackeray ultimately opened shiv vada pao which same as pakoda.
Female labor want to work for 4 to 5 hours , no night job.
@@vsansanv29101_sd - Atleast they are much better than congress who has done a PhD in corruption and scams that's why they are voted out of power 🤣🤣
This is why I have always felt that India is not ready for democracy. We do not know what we are electing a government for. We pay through our noses for sub standard education that does not equip us adequately for any proper job and instead of demanding better, we take pride in our jugaad mentality. We are promised jobs before elections, but when the govt blatantly refuses to provide them, instead of questioning them and holding them to their promises, we accept their incompetence and blame ourselves for not being good enough.
We deserve to be ruled by monarchs and autocrats. We deserve to be slaves.
Absolutely, people get the kind of government that they deserve. It's our fault, we have failed as a nation
It's about time you should do your share,not yakety yak
If govt cant solve then we dont want such govt ! Let them resigne by stating the same...🤔
No govt can solve the unemployment problem in any country. If that was so in seventy years gone by all people should have been employed. Do you know the unemplyment percentage in do called advanced countries.
This unemployment problem is a stick used by opposition parties.
If this government' s job is not to solve unemployment problems, why did PM promise 2crore jobs. Was it also a jumla.
People should elect an alternative government who will take the responsibility of providing employment and solve other issues faced by the people.
By making this statement , is CEA trying to prove that he is bigger than the PM.
People should decide whom to listen to , the PM Or CEA.
इंटराइजिंग
If you are incapable to make arrangements for the economics welfare of the country , soften the overall health of the environmental. We, the secular Indian, are enough living agent to move the economy smoothly. Resign the post.
In any good economy like USA unemployment is variable tackled by federal Bank in their quarterly report.
Govt cant solve unemployment problem
Govt cannot control inflation
Govt cannot solve education problem
Govt cant protect borders properly
Etc etc
Then why the hell there is a Govt.
Sir, you gave an example of Bal Thakre, but when the same thing was said by Narendra Modi( Raste peh thela lagao), the entire left kabal pounced on him.
No use Sujitji. They never want to do anything....
Are we any better than what Cho said...we are living in the same euphoric world that Mr Cho suggested 😅😂
Small companies cannot donate to the party in crores. Why should the party promote such companies?
We do not any Government
In that movie, Tughlak had suggested that to eradicate corruption, legalise the corruption and fix the amount as per designation like councillor, MLA, MP and ministers which is true in today's scrnario
How SBI have raised credit/debit card prices by 65% + GST
50 CR account in SBI
More than 1/2 VOTER election2024 suffering
Largest PSU BANK
Employee lakh lakh PM salary
Free AC workspace
SBI credit/debit card will cost 65% more + GST
50 CR account
Calculate reason SBI employees gets lakh lakh salary and how
Opposition silent , why ????
Mr Nagraj seems to be following his majesty Modi s footsteps ,
Pagar chalu hai jhumla feko ,
Whose father what goes 😂😂
CEA’s red flag for whom? I believe it’s the people of this country who should take cognisance of this red flag and exercise their electoral power. Jai hind
This is possible to give more employment . But what will the government do? What is the duty
How much employment generated by Adani Enterprise compared to its Market Cap? How much tax it pays? Nobody against any Corporates? show your results ...you are using National and tax payers Wealth...8% annual growth is not possible even till 2047 this kind of unemployment of our millions of youth...without proper education...
Send an RTI enquiry to adani group.
@@ravindranmokkilmaruthur23RTI Only for Government bodies.
Why did Modi campained in 2014 with the promise of 2 crore jobs every year. If Modi can't generate the jobs then he should quit. It is the responsibility of Govt to provide jobs as well as device policies which generate jobs. Problem is Modi's policies r to reduce no. Of jobs in govt sectors and device policies favourable to corporates which again reduces jobs in private sector as well. Entire unorganised sector is affected by Modis policies and therefore impacted negatively the sector which provided 90% of the jobs in India. If CEA says ir is not the job of govt to generate jobs then he doesn't even understand the basics of Economics.
But He knew how to please Modi and govt.
He is genuine person, telling truth. but why Modi promised 2 crore job per year? why then 10% reservation for Economically affected forward community?
all government enterprises sold to pvt, military and govt providing contract Service for certain years. Corporate getting tax exemption. Common people Dieing for food Water and medical.
Where😅 this prime minister and minister want to take india?
If India top 3 richest people develope , and growth and earn amount that will be tell India developed , growthed, earned...this is our India economy calculation
What is reflecting is the concern the govt has for its citizens. It's what Rahul Gandhi has been saying. The govt is only for Udyogpatis not for aam aadmi.
Sir, I want to do ground reporting for the new army of the youtube reporters fighting to show true journalism, nothing yellow...I am from assam.
East India Company employed most educated Indians not so long ago.. Adani and Ambani will provide same service for new India.
I completely agree with you.. these kind of government and CEA are dangerous to our country.
He would have been transferred by now for calling pm tuglak 😂
It’s not true that government cannot solve the unemployment problem. Pls see short article by G Singh in Business Standard, 9 January 2024.
'Chakkikkotha chankaran' is a proverb in Malayalam. A chief economic advisor to a thief minister, what else to say. Hwnews has hit the nail. Keep it up
Sir I also presume it is employability the biggest problem. I hire lot of people in software co. And I can say that 70% of them are waste candidates. They have multiple backlogs, their resume is just waste toilet paper and when they come to interview with zero preparation. How can we hire them. When I asked them basic questions like who is the president of india, one guy mentioned Abdul Kalam. When I asked what's the name of the rover landed on moon South pole, one guy told NASA. I mean how can we give job when they are not serious.
Governments since independence have killed agriculture which was the biggest employment generator. Land reforms have only worsened the condition of small and marginal farmers. MSPs are just a lollipop, look how the cooperatives are dying. Who has taken the pain to strengthen the farmer cooperatives ?
It's the lack of spending money. As simple as that.
Why so? Cascading and interrelated reasons. Which is enoromously complicated. Quite out of the ambit of rhe PMO and this PM.
Use your ☝ Vote them out.
If u study economy then u understand this is the truth, economy is driven by consumption by masses
The unemployment problem is firstly created by this government.
Just giving electoral speeches, playing Hindu-Muslim politics and being only a credit monger will surely not solve the problem.
Now they say they cannot solve the problem. Well, then, get lost and let someone else who is more capable handle it!!
When Business Man become a Politician, Evey thing happening , the government property become private and Govt, Military job become a contract work, corporate get tax exemption, self employment is killed, because of corporate interference and Finally the business man loose the election, he leave the country and Common peoples found the New leader and they stay here without any benefits 😂😂😂
Make in India made for India?
👍💪 sujit
We don't want to admit that we lack skill set. We don’t want to move out of our comfort zone and do an extra course which can boost our career.
And here is the easiest way out. Blame the Government.
Then on what basis did BJP claim to give 2 cr jobs in manifesto?
In knataka cong govt is giving 3000 to the unemployed person till he gets employment share some insights about this scheme
No re-employment post retirement, one Nation one pension, one Nation onetime PMship?
In Covid times : the people die on their own and Govt was not responsible for their death , right ? Similarly, govt . is not expected to solve all the problems including the unemployment. ??
Sir, We are busy with collection of Electoral bonds. We killed MSME & small businesses through GST. Self employmet, we can open PAKODI STALLS. The Chief Advisor is perfectly correct. Provding Employment is not Govt's job. Sell PAKORIES.
Modi was correct… pakoda selling is also good option… sandwiches pav bhaji omleti fruit juice rtc rtc similar… but overall 82% unemployment is something askew…
Government can't solve Socio economic problems or Unemployment 😮 this is Comic .
Mother of all ironies. Govt needs no political enemies when bureaucratic snakes are loitering in their own backyard.😂
2024 general elections to appoint PM & the group of ministers for coming five years. Mr. Modi is as PM for ten years & trying to become PM for five more years. This is also appointments about what Mr. Chief economic advisor speak?
Problems created by whom??
2014 manifesto of bjp government....Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) would aim to create 250 million jobs over the next 10 years as part of an economic development programme that could create 100 new 'smart' cities, its election manifesto will say.
Then what for this CEA is sitting and plucking in position.
People of India has been put to blind with Hindutva... Now 80% of population has been look over... Hindu first then neglecting our meal .. fighters and defenders will ultimately disappear...till such time when we lost our thinkers and philloshopers
Just fill up all the government jobs, automatically finance is generated and starts trickling down to other businesses .The economy will automatically grow.