I would say X-Plane by almost every count, the only thing is MSFS (2020) has a more realistic feeling on the landing (to me), but of course neither of these will completely simulate an actual landing experience. X Plane is great for practicing IFR since it lets you very easily map all the controls of a 430/530/1000 to physical hardware so you are not trying to use a mouse while flying an approach.
I love this! Give me more!
Which simulator (feels) more realistic for GA ?
I would say X-Plane by almost every count, the only thing is MSFS (2020) has a more realistic feeling on the landing (to me), but of course neither of these will completely simulate an actual landing experience. X Plane is great for practicing IFR since it lets you very easily map all the controls of a 430/530/1000 to physical hardware so you are not trying to use a mouse while flying an approach.
What is the name of the game?
This is X-Plane 12 and also Microsoft Flight simulator 2020