Bro HUGGY WUGGY is returning bc he’s not dead if you watch gameplay after the vhd hour of yoj you can see HUGGY WUGGY standing on the stairs for 3 sekunds after he disappears, he attacked kissy missy. For more proof in chapter 2 you can find in the room with the puzzle where you need to get a toy to scan in, you can see blue fleece and blood from HUGGY WUGGY and on the other side of the room you can see blood and blue fleece like he was climbing back up in an vent go check it out yourself
I think Yarnaby given that his role is fixing stuff and broken parts might be aiding 1006 in building him his new body. the 1006 claw dragged mommy's head, this could mean yarnaby would stich it up to 1006s body?
0:58 yarnaby could be a toy made out of yarn but from the info about the kid removing toys and putting them in different places could mean that yarnaby could be a amalgamation of the nightmare critters
I think something really cool they could do would be for yarneby to be dragging huggys dead body around like a puppet using the yarn as puppet strings and huggy as the dead puppet that would be really cool and creepy
So I'm now assuming that, due to Quinn's "restorative" nature, Harley wanted to deem him as a sort of "Nurse". Huggy is put back together neatly, no aggressive over-stitching or head separating. Quinn wanted to "make the world prettier". So did Harley.
Here’s my theory. Harley Sawyer is dead. Last chapter we found out that the prototype can mimic voices. Since the whole plot of PP is the prototype and how everyone is “under his control” my guess is that Yarnaby thinks the prototype is Harley because he can mimic his voice. Idk 🤷🏼♀️ That’s just what makes sense to me.
Makes sense to me too, especially since Yarnaby seems to have trusted Sawyer (even though he shouldn't have, since Sawyer is clearly a sociopath), and mimicking the doctor would be logical if the Prototype wants Yarnaby under his metaphorical thumb.
When the Smiling Critters released: Everyone:WHOHOOOO 8 ANIMALS! IN A GROUP! THIS IS THE BEST THING I'VE EVER SEEN IN MY LIFE! When the Nightmare Critters released: Everyone:Meh they shouldn't be even here!
@@aur537 fr I don’t hate the nightmare critters but it feels like they’re just filler for the next chapter. Sure they’re the supposed “villains” of the smiling critters tv show. But idk how well they’ll fit into the story. We’ll see.
Could be a Huggy/Missy combination.. gotta remember we dont who/what attacked Missy at the end of ch. 3 and we know Yarnaby was swapping toy parts around
Think about it.. if Yarnaby wants to repair Huggy then he would need another toy similar in size and the only other Big Body Huggy type we know of is Missy who we can assume was killed at the very least attacked.
Wild idea: Sawyer is dead but the Prototype has integrated Harley onto himself like he does with Mommy Long Legs possibly foreshadowed by the shrine where we see the human skeleton sticking out at the top.
fr. The game takes place 10 years after the events, like even if Harley survived what he was doing these 10 years in the factory alone? so stupid I just can't... besides, in the orientation notebook, there is a death date for some employees, including Sawyer. don't remember the exact number, but the fact that he's DEAD. (ignore this, i wasnt right ig)
Yes, but if you see the incineration video for project playtime, it’s hinted that Harley may have made himself immortal. Most likely turning himself into a toy
My yarnaby description: button eyes, a terrifying smile with a deep mouth gaping open with jagged teeth. Hair made of yarn and obviously his skin is also made of yarn. And he has a hat, a bee themed “knit” hat. ( that’s all from the silhouette you showed us )
There's this youtuber called Ei Nerd who theorized about Mephisto being in the MCU for years. It became a joke in his channel, as if he was a crazy old man thinking about ghosts. I'm starting to see some of him in you when you talk about Huggy...
@@spyderreis39 oh cause funny enough new rockstars main we’ll star Eric Voss had CONSTANTLY been sayin mephisto would end up in the mcu and it sort of became a running joke among marvel fans
@@AdamSwyvern101 And they were both right, since not only has he been mentioned several times in Agatha All Along but is still supposedly cast in the Ironheart series by everyone's favorite rude middle eastern, Borat
@@silvernick65Yes, I know that.. But it would honestly be stupid if the devs just brought him back 3 chapters later, He was only the main antagonist for chapter one line everybody else
@@HumblePersonality again that chapter was way too short and we barely know anything about huggy Wuggys background. 3 chapters in builds up the hype too
2:17 it’s gotta be the prototype. He is known to be watching us and known to mimic voices, and we were shown he knows Harleys. Also there is no way Harley is alive and in the factory. If the prototype didn’t see Harley dead he would tear up the whole factory looking for him.
I've thought that riddle has been about Huggy since the beginning because of the "paths turning clear" part. You see Huggy's fur and blood around the Bunzo puzzle of the water treatment facility area of Chapter 2. That part being in the Chapter 2 video would also be quite thematic as well. The big first part being in the Chapter 1 video would also be thematic, because it's Huggy we are talking about. Then the smallest part being in Chapter 3's video talking about having already met would be thematic because he wasn't physically in the chapter (so he gets the smallest part), but also because his part in Chapter 3 of being a nightmare tied to the player's history with the facility packs more of a punch when tied together with "for we have already met". And as you brought up, it was Huggy in the box and he was stitched back together by yarn. That itself brings these ties to Huggy over to Chapter 4. Is this speculative? Yes. Could I be wrong? Also yes. But, any other option wouldn't have the same narrative relevance in my eyes.
Yarnaby being this kind of medic for the toys makes sense, it would also explain why Harley “The Doctor” wanted that connection with him so badly. If harley is the prototype (or the prototype is mimicking Harley) it makes sense that he needs someone to be able to piece him together like a medic would a wounded soldier.
If you’re theory of Harley Sawyer being alive and commanding Yarnaby like a guard dog to protect him is true, then that would mean that Yarnaby stuck into Playcare without Prototype or Catnap knowing and attack Kissy Missy at the end of Chapter 3. I have a theory that if Harley is alive he might be like a ringmaster kind of villain, commanding his creatures to follow his orders. Which would align with animal villains 0:01 like Nightmare Critters and Piano Dinosaurs. Yarnaby design been revealed but so far all of antagonists of Ch4 have animal themes. Harley Sawyer could be a ringmaster who commands them to do his bidding and protect him for Prototype and his followers. That or Prototype is mimicking Harley to control Yarnaby which a more likely scenario.
I think that Huggy might return in this chapter because they could have gave us a leak trough Poppy Playtime Forever. Alongside the Halloween event there are new skins like the zombie ones for Mommy and Huggy. Huggy’s are obviously inspired by Project Playtime, but the one that costs more is the pink and blue one which is that of Huggy and Kissy that have been tight up together with yarn… My theory is that the Prototype wanted Huggy’s body but seeing that it was too damage he attacked Kissy, knowing that she wouldn’t have help him he mimicked Sawyer’s voice and he tricked Yarnaby into “fusing” them into a zombie “Kissy Wuggy” ( plus, we know Quinn liked swapping toys body parts with others…)
5:25 a possible theory is that if Harley Sawyer’s still alive, he might be in a toy, and the very specific job that Yarnaby had was a surgeon/doctor. That’s why Harley made him dependent on him so that when he was turned into a toy he would always have a contingency plan if he were to get hurt (yarn him back together)
Man, this is gonna be interesting. Yarnaby and his backstory have been confirmed and we have so much evidence hinting at Boxy Boo, too. It's too poetic to not have them both in the same chapter. The Doctor's Pride & Joy and his Greatest Disappointment in the same chapter hunting us down. Boxy in his inherent nature and Yarnaby in an attempt to earn Sawyer's approval and attention once more. We're gonna be in for a ride with this one.
What if Yarnaby is only the 3 colors of the squares from the first trailer now? Like he used to have all the colors found with Huggy, but something happened that removed some of them.
The chapter description also mentions how we will get new allies as well as enemies. I wonder if perhaps Yarnaby will be one of our allies. If so, that would provide such a unique dynamic between us the player and a character. Yarnaby could help us for a while, but if the Doctor shows up, it could cause Yarnaby to switch sides. But then, maybe Yarnaby will go back to helping us after Sawyer leaves. It would provide a tense relationship with a character, knowing we can trust them up to a certain point.
This explains why he wasn’t shocked by anything that happened in Chapter 3. Except for The first tape the scenes with CatNap in the Counselors Office and the tape with Stella with the Hartmans
Yarnaby being able to stitch things together and repair stuff makes me think that he might work for the experiment 1006, stitching all of the body parts he collects to his body
That would fit with the "for we have met before" part... And I think maybe The Prototype will be using its voice-mimicking powers to manipulate Yarnaby via Sawyer's voice.
6:58 Tom (from Game Theory) We got some LOOOOOOOOOORRRRRRREEEEEEEEE Me: So 🐑 used to work at the factory and is and calls Huggy and Yarnaby “friends”, maybe he was aware about the BBI and was maybe was the nicest to the experiments and treated them with kindness and respect, to the point he calls them friends, I bet even Mommy liked him cause we know she was hostile towards the staff, but unfortunately his friends have been driven by hunger that they probably forgot how nice he was to them, and that’s why they now try to kill him, and in the dream sequence in Home Sweet Home we see the phrase “guilt haunts you” and when reversing that radio also in Home Sweet Home we hear someone say we come and murder, referring to us Killing Huggy and Mommy, our former friends and if Yarnaby is the main villain, we’ll be carrying even more guilt my killing him, and the other antagonists
I get the feeling this next chapter is going to have even more active toys to contend with. So many clues and hints from Mob games. One of the development heads mentioned being most scared of "The doctor", so I honestly think Harley Sawyer isn't dead but went through the procedure to become a toy, whether he'll have all of his mental facilities will be seen. But I think he'll make an appearance in chapter 4. I agree with sheeprampage regarding Yarnaby fixing huggy wuggy, but under The doctors lead. I feel Yarnaby will be an important character, but not as important as Catnap was in chapter 3. And that huggy wuggy will make an appearance but as a stitched together monstrosity using yarn and other toy parts. I'm reminded of all of the headless toys seen throughout teasers in chapter 3 and chapter 4 and believe that was mostly the work of yarnaby. I'm curious to see what's in store.
I have to desagree with your theory regarding the YGP. The logo they use in the documents that talk about it is the old Playtime Co. logo, first saw in Poppy's VHS from 1950. Yarnaby was created in 1990. The timeline here doesn't work
A great surprise would be to see a fixed Bron in Chapter 4. Of course the experiment with him didn't work, but that could make it scary if he's running around in a bad state
This is just confirming my theory: Harley Sawyer and Yarnaby are dual antagonists and Yarnaby might even be attacking because Harley asks it to. The Prototype will somehow become involved. I think Huggy Wuggy WILL return, but possibly to be united with Kissy Missy and made less an antagonist - Kissy might act as a soothing presence and he might turn "good", as it seems the Huggy line doesn't WANT to be evil by design. It's possible Huggy was even just acting as security when he chased us in Chapter 1. Alternately both have become part of the Prototype, or are somehow in trouble due to Yarnaby who likes to swap things around remember. The Nightmare Critters OPPOSE Harley and Yarnaby, and will be protagonist side characters as a foil to the way the Smiling Critters got used more antagonistically as side characters or died before the events of the game (except Dogday), and as a foil to their antagonistic role in the greater Smiling Critters universe. I foresee a big climactic battle at the end that involves the Nightmare Critter as an army, you, and Poppy all facing off against Yarnaby and Harley, and possibly another antagonistic force, before the Prototype comes in and changes all that.
Bruh its not actually Harley its the Prototype using Harleys voice that will most likely be controling Yaraby. The voice in the three videos were most definitely the prototype talking too.
Honestly I think Sawyer is one of the experiments we will meet in this chapter or future chapters. I also think that the Prototype might be emulating his voice to control Yarnaby.
I am almost 100% sure he will be controlled by Yarnaby as a puppet. The prototype is not yet complete as we saw in chapter 3, so the thing attacking Kissy Missy in the end can only be Huggy or a new toy. Yarnaby probably found Huggy first, fixed him and is now controlling him for his own cause.
The geniuses program has the old playtime logo we see in Poppy Commercial and there isn't any mention of it in the game so far or in the book so we can assume its very old stuff, like before the 80's. it could be related to the protagonist past
I think what would be cool is if Yarnaby doing all the attacking thinking he’s been ordered round by Dr Sawyer only to find out it’s the prototype mimicking his voice. Maybe he discovers the body or we discovered the body and lead him to it and he turns from en eenemy to an ally or a worst enemy thinking we caused it.
Yarnaby sounds like the definition of a donor baby(i believe thats the term) meaning you are born as an extra supply of organs for someone else who could be suffering. Yarnaby being a creation that could be used as materials for other bigger bodies as a way to save money on materials is quite possible. If he was a success, his toy version couldve been more of a customizable toy like what they did to Mangle in FNAF 2. Also the fact that hes nothing but yarn means either his organs are just being dragged around or are wrapped up with other pieces of yarn, think about that for a second
@@simoneblasiotti4817 Eh, sounds like a bit of a stretch. I know we have very little info on Pianosaurus (That's not even the official name lol), but I kinda doubt he and Yarnaby will be the same character.
my therory: chapter 4 main villain will be Yarnaby and huggy will be returning as a side main villain and other villains might be doey the dougman( pianosauras) and the nightmare critters willl be at theri small form just like thoes smilling critters from ch 3 .CHAPTER 5 main villain might be dr harley sawer and lastly ch6 we will face of against the prototype...BUT HEY ITS JUST A GAME THEORY!!!
No, mommy litterally screamed "don't make me a part of him" Huggy might not be on any of the sides, because the prototype made him guard poppy when she was in her case
This is just a thought, but could Ollie be revealed as the "Pianosaurus" toy we're being teased? Or was Ollie's name only colored green to distinguish them from other characters?
I guess the goal was to be Dr Sawyer's bodyguard. Yarnaby 'design was flawed by paranoia and ego' said a document and Sawyer mentioned that his own life was a great asset and he wanted to keep Yarnaby around to be amused by its sounds. I feel he felt threatened and wanted a Bigegr Body to protect him in case of his experiments (Prototype included) got fed up with his BS and tried to murder him.
If we look at Game Theory, they made a very similar theory, just that they were talking about Harley Sawyer. So if we look at your video and game theory's, it will ALL connect together.
I’ll agree with your theory because it’s been a while since we seen the real huggy Wuggy and it would make sense that yarn B can you repair damage toys because he is like a doctor of some kind of toy that is meant to readParis some of the damage toys and even stitch them back together when their insides get out 7:41
Something ive wondered for awhile now is did Kissy Missy eat the dead bodies to stay alive because there wont have been nearly enough food to sustain her in the factory for 10 years.
I just had a realization! The chapter 4 teaser trailer was the first teaser where they didn’t depict a Huggy Wuggy being murdered. Maybe it’s because yarnaby saved him.
When they reveal about Yarnaby using other parts of toys to use on other toys. I was thinking he attacked Kissy Missy for hers part and use it to repair Huggy Wuggy. Since they are similar in design.
Yarnaby, messing with the heads of other toys, reminds me of the Dark Souls 2 cutscene where The Rotten was trying to put heads back onto the poison statues before the fight 😂
We know that Huggy hit his head and other parts of his body several times. What if the one who attacks Kissy Missy in chapter 3 is Yarnaby to get body parts to put on Huggy so he can recover?
yo i just got a theory.it was leaked that the setting for chapter 4 is a prison.now if you google it, "aby" means "to suffer a penatly for something".jail is literally a penalty given to people who do crime and yarn+aby is yarnaby.so with this evidence my theory is that yarnaby purpose was to be a jail guard who was supposed to protect this prison.and he is also mostly refered to as a dog like so he could be a "jail guard yarn dog".i mean with the evidence its possible but its just a theory.i really like your vidios and would appreciate it if you put my theory in the next video with a shoutout.
I HAVE A THEORY So basically after finding the box in the woods u can see huggy is covered in yarn what is later know to be yarnabys build SO WHAT IF yarnaby will sew (FIX) huggy and bring him back to life ? (As we know huggy is a giant plush so using yarn he can get fixed)
So my theory is that the prototype will control Yarnaby using the voice of Harley Saywer (since he can mimic voices) we don't know yet, and i don't know if Harley is alive or not, but if he's not then the theory is correct.
My theory is that yarnaby is not going to die, if Harley Sawyer is alive, and if yarnaby is under the control of Harley Sawyer, then maybe at the end of the chapter, yarnaby is going to realize that Harley is not the good guy that he thinks he is, and kills him and just walks off at the end of the chapter. But if you do a little backtracking, you'll find the dismantled and murdered corpse of yarnaby, killed by the Prototype for not killing the player
Also here's another theory, I think that there's going to be plenty of villains, I think that there's going to be yarnaby, maybe the pianosaurus, and a bigger body of baba chops and maybe a few other nightmare Critters
Is the Prototype, for a lack of a better way to say, the prototype of Yarnaby? The Prototype has the fingers of the Beldam from Coraline, in which the Beldam repurposed a doll to match the titular protagonist of the movie.
If I had a nickel for every time sheeprampage thought huggy wuggy would return I would have so many nickels that I don’t know the exact number I have
LOL I would think 20
Enough to buy something cheap
Lol same 😭ඩා
Lol same 😭ඩා
LOL So true lmao
Things that are infinite:
1. our universe
2. numbers
3. sheeprampage thinking huggy wuggy will return
And how do you know that our universe is infinite, huh?
The multiverse is infinite
Not the universe
idk wtf yall be talking about the universe is infinite or close to infinity, its constantly expanding
that's true
Bro HUGGY WUGGY is returning bc he’s not dead if you watch gameplay after the vhd hour of yoj you can see HUGGY WUGGY standing on the stairs for 3 sekunds after he disappears, he attacked kissy missy. For more proof in chapter 2 you can find in the room with the puzzle where you need to get a toy to scan in, you can see blue fleece and blood from HUGGY WUGGY and on the other side of the room you can see blood and blue fleece like he was climbing back up in an vent go check it out yourself
My theory is The Prototype has been impersonating Harley using his voice to manipulate Yarnaby to his side and keep him under his command
When, as far as we know, the only sentence it would be able to say in Harley's voice is "I learn something new about you every day"?
@@Max1996YT Unless of course he had time to practice with his voice after Log 24459
@@Max1996YTno he was able to fully copy it regardless
@@YCLCrush There's no proof of that, though. In contrast to what that VHS tape actually showed.
@@Max1996YTno hro he cloned his voice
I think Yarnaby given that his role is fixing stuff and broken parts might be aiding 1006 in building him his new body.
the 1006 claw dragged mommy's head, this could mean yarnaby would stich it up to 1006s body?
0:16 y’all do this every chapter😭
This deserves more likes
fr 😭
Ok@@wetburntbagel
@@t0rcl.YOUR HERE?
At least in chapter 3 it made sense
0:58 yarnaby could be a toy made out of yarn but from the info about the kid removing toys and putting them in different places could mean that yarnaby could be a amalgamation of the nightmare critters
and the parts are connected by yarn!!
That makes a lot of sense
That'd be disappointing if that was so.
@@greydummy2702 really why?
@@orlastarburstyou are a GENIUS
I think something really cool they could do would be for yarneby to be dragging huggys dead body around like a puppet using the yarn as puppet strings and huggy as the dead puppet that would be really cool and creepy
That's what I was thinking too! :)
I think he'll use huggy as a skin suit
Agreed !
If huggy is alive and teaming up with Yarnaby that would be so cool!
Yarnaby would have to be massive to do that
So I'm now assuming that, due to Quinn's "restorative" nature, Harley wanted to deem him as a sort of "Nurse". Huggy is put back together neatly, no aggressive over-stitching or head separating. Quinn wanted to "make the world prettier". So did Harley.
Here’s my theory. Harley Sawyer is dead. Last chapter we found out that the prototype can mimic voices. Since the whole plot of PP is the prototype and how everyone is “under his control” my guess is that Yarnaby thinks the prototype is Harley because he can mimic his voice. Idk 🤷🏼♀️ That’s just what makes sense to me.
Makes sense to me too, especially since Yarnaby seems to have trusted Sawyer (even though he shouldn't have, since Sawyer is clearly a sociopath), and mimicking the doctor would be logical if the Prototype wants Yarnaby under his metaphorical thumb.
I like how everyone forgot about the nightmare critters… lol
They didn’t, it just has like 0 lore atm
When the Smiling Critters released:
Everyone:WHOHOOOO 8 ANIMALS! IN A GROUP! THIS IS THE BEST THING I'VE EVER SEEN IN MY LIFE!
When the Nightmare Critters released:
Everyone:Meh they shouldn't be even here!
@@aur537 fr I don’t hate the nightmare critters but it feels like they’re just filler for the next chapter. Sure they’re the supposed “villains” of the smiling critters tv show. But idk how well they’ll fit into the story. We’ll see.
So true lol ik I did
Could be a Huggy/Missy combination.. gotta remember we dont who/what attacked Missy at the end of ch. 3 and we know Yarnaby was swapping toy parts around
Yup
Think about it.. if Yarnaby wants to repair Huggy then he would need another toy similar in size and the only other Big Body Huggy type we know of is Missy who we can assume was killed at the very least attacked.
Wild idea: Sawyer is dead but the Prototype has integrated Harley onto himself like he does with Mommy Long Legs possibly foreshadowed by the shrine where we see the human skeleton sticking out at the top.
But the skull is wearing a fan hat so its a child
That sawyer voice could be the prototype mimicking sawyers voice .
fr. The game takes place 10 years after the events, like even if Harley survived what he was doing these 10 years in the factory alone? so stupid I just can't... besides, in the orientation notebook, there is a death date for some employees, including Sawyer. don't remember the exact number, but the fact that he's DEAD. (ignore this, i wasnt right ig)
@@ertyyy_0 bruh this is Harley the psychopath why don't you understand 😂😂
Yes, but if you see the incineration video for project playtime, it’s hinted that Harley may have made himself immortal. Most likely turning himself into a toy
@@rocketbrorocky3249 oh... really? i mean that probably explains it
i think the prototype is harley saweyer him self
My yarnaby description: button eyes, a terrifying smile with a deep mouth gaping open with jagged teeth. Hair made of yarn and obviously his skin is also made of yarn. And he has a hat, a bee themed “knit” hat. ( that’s all from the silhouette you showed us )
Now we got the design and you were right for most of it
@@Oni_Yashi🤦
@LeafLetForge ??
"Huggy is RETURNING in CHAPTER 4? (Huge Evidence) "Huggy is BACK in CHAPTER 3? (New Teaser) "CHAPTER 2 PROVES that HUGGY is RETURNING? (Huge Proof?)"
okay well this one is obv gotta be confirmed and huggy did return in 3rd chapter as a hallucination and his lore drop was in chap 3
There's this youtuber called Ei Nerd who theorized about Mephisto being in the MCU for years. It became a joke in his channel, as if he was a crazy old man thinking about ghosts.
I'm starting to see some of him in you when you talk about Huggy...
Do mean Eric Voss? Who’s Ei nerd?
@@AdamSwyvern101 Ei Nerd is a brazilian channel that does theories on movies and other stuff
@@spyderreis39 oh cause funny enough new rockstars main we’ll star Eric Voss had CONSTANTLY been sayin mephisto would end up in the mcu and it sort of became a running joke among marvel fans
@@AdamSwyvern101 Him too! Lol
@@AdamSwyvern101 And they were both right, since not only has he been mentioned several times in Agatha All Along but is still supposedly cast in the Ironheart series by everyone's favorite rude middle eastern, Borat
7:49 Just noticed the flyer has huggies colour scheme I think
I hope swapimals will finally have a use.
There is like only 2 of them when Tere is supposedly 7 bruh
Fr we want a new swapimal.
3:41 maybe he takes orders from the prototype because he will mimic Harley sawyer
If Huggy isn’t in this chapter, there holding on to him until the prototype boss battle
Huggy back counter: 99999
I mean he has to be right?
hes been teased so many times before.
@@kaivalyajoshi5595He already showed up in chapter 3, isn't that enough?
@@HumblePersonality that wasn't even huggy. That was a hallucination of him
@@silvernick65Yes, I know that.. But it would honestly be stupid if the devs just brought him back 3 chapters later, He was only the main antagonist for chapter one line everybody else
@@HumblePersonality again that chapter was way too short and we barely know anything about huggy Wuggys background. 3 chapters in builds up the hype too
2:12 I think the prototype is mimicking Harley’s voice to get control over yarnaby
2:17 it’s gotta be the prototype. He is known to be watching us and known to mimic voices, and we were shown he knows Harleys. Also there is no way Harley is alive and in the factory. If the prototype didn’t see Harley dead he would tear up the whole factory looking for him.
I've thought that riddle has been about Huggy since the beginning because of the "paths turning clear" part. You see Huggy's fur and blood around the Bunzo puzzle of the water treatment facility area of Chapter 2. That part being in the Chapter 2 video would also be quite thematic as well. The big first part being in the Chapter 1 video would also be thematic, because it's Huggy we are talking about. Then the smallest part being in Chapter 3's video talking about having already met would be thematic because he wasn't physically in the chapter (so he gets the smallest part), but also because his part in Chapter 3 of being a nightmare tied to the player's history with the facility packs more of a punch when tied together with "for we have already met". And as you brought up, it was Huggy in the box and he was stitched back together by yarn. That itself brings these ties to Huggy over to Chapter 4.
Is this speculative? Yes. Could I be wrong? Also yes. But, any other option wouldn't have the same narrative relevance in my eyes.
Huggy coming back is craazy 💀
Sut ub
huggy wuggy returns every chapter
chapter 1 : main villain
chapter 2 : wack-a-wuggy
chapter 3 : nightmare huggy
chapter 4 : fixed huggy wuggy?
Hopefully yarnaby works like a yarn kit
Huggy could return because we didn’t see the prototype take him away and we didn’t see any part of him on the shrine
Tbh I thought it was obvious that Huggy would be back in chapter 4….
Also I didn’t know if anybody noticed but usually when we see the outside perspective for when he kills someone or something it’s usually at the head
lol brains are toys fave snacks
Yarnaby being this kind of medic for the toys makes sense, it would also explain why Harley “The Doctor” wanted that connection with him so badly. If harley is the prototype (or the prototype is mimicking Harley) it makes sense that he needs someone to be able to piece him together like a medic would a wounded soldier.
3:00 I could very well be the prototype using harley's voice
Ohhh yeah that's true
If you’re theory of Harley Sawyer being alive and commanding Yarnaby like a guard dog to protect him is true, then that would mean that Yarnaby stuck into Playcare without Prototype or Catnap knowing and attack Kissy Missy at the end of Chapter 3. I have a theory that if Harley is alive he might be like a ringmaster kind of villain, commanding his creatures to follow his orders. Which would align with animal villains 0:01 like Nightmare Critters and Piano Dinosaurs. Yarnaby design been revealed but so far all of antagonists of Ch4 have animal themes. Harley Sawyer could be a ringmaster who commands them to do his bidding and protect him for Prototype and his followers. That or Prototype is mimicking Harley to control Yarnaby which a more likely scenario.
I think that Huggy might return in this chapter because they could have gave us a leak trough Poppy Playtime Forever.
Alongside the Halloween event there are new skins like the zombie ones for Mommy and Huggy. Huggy’s are obviously inspired by Project Playtime, but the one that costs more is the pink and blue one which is that of Huggy and Kissy that have been tight up together with yarn…
My theory is that the Prototype wanted Huggy’s body but seeing that it was too damage he attacked Kissy, knowing that she wouldn’t have help him he mimicked Sawyer’s voice and he tricked Yarnaby into “fusing” them into a zombie “Kissy Wuggy” ( plus, we know Quinn liked swapping toys body parts with others…)
5:25 a possible theory is that if Harley Sawyer’s still alive, he might be in a toy, and the very specific job that Yarnaby had was a surgeon/doctor. That’s why Harley made him dependent on him so that when he was turned into a toy he would always have a contingency plan if he were to get hurt (yarn him back together)
Within 20 seconds anyone. No? Just me? Ok.
YEAH I KNEW IT MAN!!!!!!!
THEY CANNOT LEAVE HIM LIKE THAT!!
Okay, they didn't said he'll be here officially but i have faith ;-;
Man, this is gonna be interesting. Yarnaby and his backstory have been confirmed and we have so much evidence hinting at Boxy Boo, too. It's too poetic to not have them both in the same chapter. The Doctor's Pride & Joy and his Greatest Disappointment in the same chapter hunting us down. Boxy in his inherent nature and Yarnaby in an attempt to earn Sawyer's approval and attention once more. We're gonna be in for a ride with this one.
Thank you for letting me know the lore I really/ appreciate it
What if Yarnaby is only the 3 colors of the squares from the first trailer now? Like he used to have all the colors found with Huggy, but something happened that removed some of them.
The chapter description also mentions how we will get new allies as well as enemies. I wonder if perhaps Yarnaby will be one of our allies. If so, that would provide such a unique dynamic between us the player and a character. Yarnaby could help us for a while, but if the Doctor shows up, it could cause Yarnaby to switch sides. But then, maybe Yarnaby will go back to helping us after Sawyer leaves. It would provide a tense relationship with a character, knowing we can trust them up to a certain point.
WAKE UP SHEEPRAMPAGE (THE GOAT) UPLOADED
This explains why he wasn’t shocked by anything that happened in Chapter 3. Except for The first tape the scenes with CatNap in the Counselors Office and the tape with Stella with the Hartmans
Yarnaby being able to stitch things together and repair stuff makes me think that he might work for the experiment 1006, stitching all of the body parts he collects to his body
I hope Huggy DOES return in chapter 4. He's my favorite monster.
I love it how he just talks about Laura meanwhile, huggy is screaming while falling to his death😭🙏 6:56
That would fit with the "for we have met before" part...
And I think maybe The Prototype will be using its voice-mimicking powers to manipulate Yarnaby via Sawyer's voice.
6:58 Tom (from Game Theory) We got some LOOOOOOOOOORRRRRRREEEEEEEEE Me: So 🐑 used to work at the factory and is and calls Huggy and Yarnaby “friends”, maybe he was aware about the BBI and was maybe was the nicest to the experiments and treated them with kindness and respect, to the point he calls them friends, I bet even Mommy liked him cause we know she was hostile towards the staff, but unfortunately his friends have been driven by hunger that they probably forgot how nice he was to them, and that’s why they now try to kill him, and in the dream sequence in Home Sweet Home we see the phrase “guilt haunts you” and when reversing that radio also in Home Sweet Home we hear someone say we come and murder, referring to us Killing Huggy and Mommy, our former friends and if Yarnaby is the main villain, we’ll be carrying even more guilt my killing him, and the other antagonists
AYO @copper youtuber said the same thing 5:05 💯 good catch
I get the feeling this next chapter is going to have even more active toys to contend with. So many clues and hints from Mob games. One of the development heads mentioned being most scared of "The doctor", so I honestly think Harley Sawyer isn't dead but went through the procedure to become a toy, whether he'll have all of his mental facilities will be seen. But I think he'll make an appearance in chapter 4. I agree with sheeprampage regarding Yarnaby fixing huggy wuggy, but under The doctors lead. I feel Yarnaby will be an important character, but not as important as Catnap was in chapter 3. And that huggy wuggy will make an appearance but as a stitched together monstrosity using yarn and other toy parts. I'm reminded of all of the headless toys seen throughout teasers in chapter 3 and chapter 4 and believe that was mostly the work of yarnaby. I'm curious to see what's in store.
I have to desagree with your theory regarding the YGP. The logo they use in the documents that talk about it is the old Playtime Co. logo, first saw in Poppy's VHS from 1950. Yarnaby was created in 1990. The timeline here doesn't work
A great surprise would be to see a fixed Bron in Chapter 4. Of course the experiment with him didn't work, but that could make it scary if he's running around in a bad state
Prototype could also imitate harley's voice to manipulate yarnaby to stop us!
This is just confirming my theory:
Harley Sawyer and Yarnaby are dual antagonists and Yarnaby might even be attacking because Harley asks it to.
The Prototype will somehow become involved. I think Huggy Wuggy WILL return, but possibly to be united with Kissy Missy and made less an antagonist - Kissy might act as a soothing presence and he might turn "good", as it seems the Huggy line doesn't WANT to be evil by design. It's possible Huggy was even just acting as security when he chased us in Chapter 1. Alternately both have become part of the Prototype, or are somehow in trouble due to Yarnaby who likes to swap things around remember.
The Nightmare Critters OPPOSE Harley and Yarnaby, and will be protagonist side characters as a foil to the way the Smiling Critters got used more antagonistically as side characters or died before the events of the game (except Dogday), and as a foil to their antagonistic role in the greater Smiling Critters universe.
I foresee a big climactic battle at the end that involves the Nightmare Critter as an army, you, and Poppy all facing off against Yarnaby and Harley, and possibly another antagonistic force, before the Prototype comes in and changes all that.
I think the guy in the trailer isnt the play but dr sawyer himself
Bruh its not actually Harley its the Prototype using Harleys voice that will most likely be controling Yaraby. The voice in the three videos were most definitely the prototype talking too.
Hey, maybe The Experiment is getting the corpses of all the bosses we defeated (MML, CatNap...) so that Yarnaby can fix them up ?
Imangine if the yarn person grabbed kissy missys head and put it on huggy wuggy lol
Honestly I think Sawyer is one of the experiments we will meet in this chapter or future chapters. I also think that the Prototype might be emulating his voice to control Yarnaby.
Girlfriend: What about our date!?
Me:SHUT SHEEPRANGE UPLOADED!!
Auglur how did you leave the workshop 💀 🙏
@@lasanandbros i don’t have much time i’m going to melt i gotta g
AUGLUR??!!!
@@PlantCipher3 no this is Yoreek auglur melted we are in the workshop we are prepararing his funeral
@@AuglurREAL_ Nauurrr 😭😭😭😭😭😭
I think Huggy might be part of prototype instead of being a normal character
I am almost 100% sure he will be controlled by Yarnaby as a puppet. The prototype is not yet complete as we saw in chapter 3, so the thing attacking Kissy Missy in the end can only be Huggy or a new toy. Yarnaby probably found Huggy first, fixed him and is now controlling him for his own cause.
The geniuses program has the old playtime logo we see in Poppy Commercial and there isn't any mention of it in the game so far or in the book so we can assume its very old stuff, like before the 80's. it could be related to the protagonist past
I think what would be cool is if Yarnaby doing all the attacking thinking he’s been ordered round by Dr Sawyer only to find out it’s the prototype mimicking his voice. Maybe he discovers the body or we discovered the body and lead him to it and he turns from en eenemy to an ally or a worst enemy thinking we caused it.
I think Quinn was just pretending to be less intelligent after experimentation so they wouldn’t test his limits
Stopping "first" people
too late people have already said it before u were even here
You still said it
I’ll start reporting them if you do.
@@CreationSGame01 false reporting
Mine and your huggy wuggy theory are identical
Yarnaby sounds like the definition of a donor baby(i believe thats the term) meaning you are born as an extra supply of organs for someone else who could be suffering. Yarnaby being a creation that could be used as materials for other bigger bodies as a way to save money on materials is quite possible. If he was a success, his toy version couldve been more of a customizable toy like what they did to Mangle in FNAF 2. Also the fact that hes nothing but yarn means either his organs are just being dragged around or are wrapped up with other pieces of yarn, think about that for a second
Shame Game Theory didn't watch all your videos. They think Harley is going to be Yarnaby.
...I'm sorry, what? How would that even work?
@@Max1996YT Well its theorized that Harley is no longer human anymore and reached immortality
Through what? Even as a toy he can still die and the prototype killed him anyway @@Frostwolf_103
@@Frostwolf_103 So how does that show Harley could be Yarnaby?
@@Max1996YT I didn't say it's gotta be on Yarnarby itself
I think yarnaby is the pianosaurus,because one of the documents said that he had a lot of strenght but a reduced inteligence
There's literally no document about pianosaurus.
@@KattyKitten69 i just got it from my mind,because dinosaurs are strong,but not smart
@@simoneblasiotti4817 Eh, sounds like a bit of a stretch. I know we have very little info on Pianosaurus (That's not even the official name lol), but I kinda doubt he and Yarnaby will be the same character.
Also how is he pianosaurus If yarnaby is made of yarn?
Reopening the avalability for 'first' people
my therory: chapter 4 main villain will be Yarnaby and huggy will be returning as a side main villain and other villains might be doey the dougman( pianosauras) and the nightmare critters willl be at theri small form just like thoes smilling critters from ch 3 .CHAPTER 5 main villain might be dr harley sawer and lastly ch6 we will face of against the prototype...BUT HEY ITS JUST A GAME THEORY!!!
Thanks for watching
Nice theory theory by the way
I can't believe I've been watching your channel for a hot minute now. And wasn't subscribed 😕
Well I fixed that and I'm subscribed now.❤🎉
So huggy is on Harley's side,
While mll and catnap are on proto's side.
No, mommy litterally screamed "don't make me a part of him" Huggy might not be on any of the sides, because the prototype made him guard poppy when she was in her case
@@XandiusProjectPlaytime oh okay
Harley is literally dead dude
@@YCLCrush theory bro
@@YCLCrush Proof?
This is just a thought, but could Ollie be revealed as the "Pianosaurus" toy we're being teased? Or was Ollie's name only colored green to distinguish them from other characters?
Will Poppy playtime be on the Steam deck?
I guess the goal was to be Dr Sawyer's bodyguard. Yarnaby 'design was flawed by paranoia and ego' said a document and Sawyer mentioned that his own life was a great asset and he wanted to keep Yarnaby around to be amused by its sounds. I feel he felt threatened and wanted a Bigegr Body to protect him in case of his experiments (Prototype included) got fed up with his BS and tried to murder him.
If we look at Game Theory, they made a very similar theory, just that they were talking about Harley Sawyer. So if we look at your video and game theory's, it will ALL connect together.
I’ll agree with your theory because it’s been a while since we seen the real huggy Wuggy and it would make sense that yarn B can you repair damage toys because he is like a doctor of some kind of toy that is meant to readParis some of the damage toys and even stitch them back together when their insides get out 7:41
quinn = yarnaby
harley sawyer = doey the doughman
hopefully im right, date today 22.10.24, if im right by the time we find out then im sigma
I could also be possible that the Prototype could be manipulating Yarnaby by using Harley Sawyer’s voice.
Something ive wondered for awhile now is did Kissy Missy eat the dead bodies to stay alive because there wont have been nearly enough food to sustain her in the factory for 10 years.
A while back somebody in the Discord said "Huggy is to Darth Vader" We knew it was only a matter of time before Huggy Wuggy returned.
Personally, I think CatNap is more Darth Vader than Huggy, given his devotion to the Prototype.
After all, given what we saw in the prequels...
I just had a realization! The chapter 4 teaser trailer was the first teaser where they didn’t depict a Huggy Wuggy being murdered. Maybe it’s because yarnaby saved him.
When they reveal about Yarnaby using other parts of toys to use on other toys. I was thinking he attacked Kissy Missy for hers part and use it to repair Huggy Wuggy. Since they are similar in design.
No Way 7 minutes Ago 🎉
I wouldn't be surprised if Yarnaby is the one who is attacking Kissy Missy, might take some parts from her to fix Huggy Wuggy
Yarnaby, messing with the heads of other toys, reminds me of the Dark Souls 2 cutscene where The Rotten was trying to put heads back onto the poison statues before the fight 😂
The most recent Game Theory PPT theory was sooooooooooooooooooo interesting
We know that Huggy hit his head and other parts of his body several times. What if the one who attacks Kissy Missy in chapter 3 is Yarnaby to get body parts to put on Huggy so he can recover?
Ohh, more arg for poppy playtime🎉
Huggy be like :what I do to get bullied😢
Id be cool to see huggy fixed up with parts from kissy missy. Id be dark, and they said they wanted a darker game.
yo i just got a theory.it was leaked that the setting for chapter 4 is a prison.now if you google it, "aby" means "to suffer a penatly for something".jail is literally a penalty given to people who do crime and yarn+aby is yarnaby.so with this evidence my theory is that yarnaby purpose was to be a jail guard who was supposed to protect this prison.and he is also mostly refered to as a dog like so he could be a "jail guard yarn dog".i mean with the evidence its possible but its just a theory.i really like your vidios and would appreciate it if you put my theory in the next video with a shoutout.
ALL SHALL WORSHIP LORD HUGGY
Early I Like your vids and Making alot of thoerys thanks❤ you deserved 300k subs
I HAVE A THEORY
So basically after finding the box in the woods u can see huggy is covered in yarn what is later know to be yarnabys build SO WHAT IF yarnaby will sew (FIX) huggy and bring him back to life ? (As we know huggy is a giant plush so using yarn he can get fixed)
So my theory is that the prototype will control Yarnaby using the voice of Harley Saywer (since he can mimic voices)
we don't know yet, and i don't know if Harley is alive or not, but if he's not then the theory is correct.
My theory is that yarnaby is not going to die, if Harley Sawyer is alive, and if yarnaby is under the control of Harley Sawyer, then maybe at the end of the chapter, yarnaby is going to realize that Harley is not the good guy that he thinks he is, and kills him and just walks off at the end of the chapter.
But if you do a little backtracking, you'll find the dismantled and murdered corpse of yarnaby, killed by the Prototype for not killing the player
Also here's another theory, I think that there's going to be plenty of villains, I think that there's going to be yarnaby, maybe the pianosaurus, and a bigger body of baba chops and maybe a few other nightmare Critters
Never miss a sheeprampage video. It's a philosophy
Is the Prototype, for a lack of a better way to say, the prototype of Yarnaby? The Prototype has the fingers of the Beldam from Coraline, in which the Beldam repurposed a doll to match the titular protagonist of the movie.
HUH????🤨🤨
But bro, Yarnby is also one of the failures and I don't think 1006 would be a prototype of him.