Reflections on Quatre Bras
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 31 ก.ค. 2024
- Looking back on the epic Quatre Bras game we had at the weekend. I look at some strategies, and the tactics we used as French commanders to take the battle to the enemy!
This is the first part of General Ian's mini series! Not sure he's got the review out yet... • The (Brunswickers) Roa... - เกม
![บุษบา - เมนทอล [Official MV]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/IGnWPokSEis/mqdefault.jpg)
I saw the stream. Well put together. The terrain looked like Quatre Bras. I don`t play Black Powder but I picked up what was going on. You guys did a great job. Thanks
Congrats on 7k been here since 1769 subs awesome content love the channel and love the vids have a great week great work!
Part of the post game discussion we had centered on what would happen next. I don't think Tim was there for most of it. It went something like this. Uxbridge takes command of the allied army and following the defeat heads back to the channel ports for embarkation back to Britain. (my post discussion comments in brackets. Prince of Orange might have refused to join him because he wasn't a Field Marshal in the army of the Netherlands, which was the sole reason Wellington was given command of the Dutch/Belgians) He would have been harrased all the way probably by a single corps and not allowed to rally. Following the defeat at Ligny, Gniesenau now has no reason to keep close to Wellington and instead of directing the Prussians North to Wavre, in the absence of Blucher who is still missing, directs the Prussians to fall back on its supply lines and heads back to Prussia. The Netherlands goes over to Napoleon. This was basicly what Napoleon had intended, to prevent the Allies from joining and defeating them separately, and take the Netherlands back. (Then either use the time it would take for the Russian and Austrian armies to reach France to rebuild his army or use diplomacy to persuade them from attacking him again.)
Nice review . Then the Russians and Austrians were coming for him next
Epic coverage of an epic battle!
Looked like a cracking game, I haven’t watched it all yet but what I did watch was spectacular
Great recap and AAR. I'm going to go watch the stream now. Thanks!
A great looking game! Thanks for the report 👍. Totally agree about the camaraderie of gaming together. Fascinating to speculate what would happen if Wellington dies at Quatre Bras! 🤔
Great review, Tim!
Excellent refight, fingers crossed for 10k
It’s awesome having you back to Tim.
Thanks man! Never forget you're the OG!
brilliant inspiring
Dont talk abut winter! I haven’t seen my summer yet! Lol barely any vacations! Ph......UCK..... !!!! « voice over, Matt Berry »
Another great set of videos and the analysis was good. Something to add, perhaps, were some annotated, still-photos of the concepts and key moments - would really make the tactics come alive.
Couldn't hear very well for the live recording and I really appreciate you making this reflection video :)
dude you killed Wellington!!!! the mind boggles.
My god some of my 15mm games dont have that many figures on.
Really enjoyed all parts, however, have a couple of questions. Was wondering why the the battle in the "Forest" was done in line formations rather than skirmish formation as per B P Rules or did ya'll agree it being lightly forested ? Do wish the camera could have been on your end of the table ( realizing it'd largely be an obstacle to traffic ) as that was where most of the action took place, in particular a lot of the maneuver you were talking about. Really loved all the stills you were talking over in this video and the lessons you described through this video. Well done Tim, really really well done.
Thanks man! Yeah we used the open woods rule from Clash of Eagles. I'll be 100% honest, I don't know a huge amount about Quatre Bras, so I was more than happy to go with the other guys on that!
Yeah, it's a shame about the camera position, as you can see when I tilted the camera up, there was no where to really secure the camera on the other side of the table. One thing I could have done is more taking the camera on a flyby of the table, so that's some really useful feedback, thanks!
If (when!) we do Ligny, I think the table will have to be at 90 degrees to how it was at QB so hopefully that'll give a better shot of the table, though the camera will have to be higher to stop it being a 4 hour video of people's backs! 😅
Thank you so much for the support bud! Tim
@@NapoleonicWargaming If you get enough members, maybe you could get a drone with a camera for actual fly overs ? Yea, I know, the propeller blades could be a serious problem. What about a Helium Balloon ? No REALLY ! They actually had observation balloons demonstrated to Boney but he turned his nose up at the idea. I'll bet Suolt or Messina or Boney himself would have given their left testicle to see over the top of the ridge lines where Lord Nosey had hidden his battalions. Actually, there was a book of rules for using balloons during the Black Pow age but I was busy with my LotR figures & Renaissance games & models, fearful of the painting challenge of Napies. But I'm working on a custom balloon model myself and thinking about how it'd work on the table as more than just a vignette. But you could actually use a miniature with a camera. I know, so much work on experimentation and probably a dozen or more helium balloons, but think of the acclaim and you tube video glory ; ) So glad you're back in the game. I'll be doing a bit of miniature photography for you and the group to peruse, hopefully sooner than later. Oh, try and find the book "On Wellington at Waterloo" by Carl von Clausewitz. I think this is far and away his best work but he goes into great detail about Ligny, Quatre Bra & Waterloo. He's really kind to Marshal Ney , Scathing of Napoleon and more than objective regards the Prussians. I've checked it out from our Library 3 times and want to buy one of my own as soon as I can finc it at a descent price. That book on Napoleonic Balloons, around 100 pounds.!
Please can you tell me the best way to base napoleonic miniatures, each one with a 20 mm round base, but all inserted in 20 mm diameter recessed movement trays? Thanks
We call them 'sabot bases' you can either use movement trays with round holes in, although you can also just use a standard one. If you're basing on 20mm round bases and using units of 24, and 'line formation' would be a movement tray that's 240mm by 40mm
Hi
You mentioned General Andy doing a stream of this game but from the Allied perspective,unfortunately I cannot find his TH-cam domain site i d so I was hoping you could provide it for me ??
Regards John
Unfortunately he never got round to it before his passing. I think it would have been 'Tim bullied me!' 🤣
The Friday night game was set in the First Boer War, not Sudan :)
That's the one! 🤣
@@NapoleonicWargaming I know. I was there :0)
Nice summary but I would argue that there was very little of the Allied army present at Quatre Bras, there was really a division plus a few other brigades so waterloo might still be interesting albeit without our Arthur 😢
did you ever find from richie where his terrain was from hills river etc etc ?
I forgot to ask 🤣 but I have just asked and he said Geoff Lacey who trades as Purple Lion Creations
@@NapoleonicWargaming Brilliant thank you very much
Peter
Is it pronounced in Belgique " katra -Bra " ?
A Waterloo without Wellington would be an interesting scenario in itself- with an Allied army low on morale,
Worst case scenario for the allies is a total rout for the British while the Prussians watch from afar, but that would mean Blucher would have to be bedridden and the British would have had to somehow slight or cheat the Prussians.
Napoleon would eventually lose anyways after being surrounded by enemies who learned his art of war but maybe Belgium would be part of France if he could force a surrender.
Are you still putting out content ? I have not seen anything lately
I certainly am! Nothing last week as I was in London, but today is something a little different (and late!)
Can you put up a link for General Ian please
This is the first part of his mini series! Not sure he's got the review out yet... th-cam.com/video/Y9G5JhIHdvc/w-d-xo.html
Try to do an updated Hastings, but with Napoleonics instead of Normans and Saxons... A Campaign with Napoleon invading the British Isles? How are British factions going to behave? any traitors within the isles?