Karina is always been hypnotizing when she performs. Moreover, I have noticed she's more natural on this comeback. Her dance moves are so smooth like it just come out naturally without even trying + the way she gives off different facial expressions are on point that it makes viewers be at ease while watching.
Always amazed by karina visua. She gonna nail every single product she wear, every kind of hairstyle, concept and everything. Even she didn't become idol, she gonna did great on modelling and etc
Giselle is better day by day, I swear I can see it. She is way more confident than the time aespa debuted. Performing Black Mamba, there weren't much screentime for her, but when it came, she just stared at it and performed her part. But now, I can clearly see that she really enjoys the stage. This also helps me to enjoy aespa's performances more than before, cause I like Giselle the most in group, I want her to show up and shine more~ Hope one day, when covid-19 is under control, aespa can perform in front of audients/fans. I think this will help the girls so much in raising confident and stage presentation (still, they're awsome now) :D
@@loan9__nguyen9 this is why SM put her in the final lineup. despite having a very short training period, they saw huge potential, and she's definitely proving them right 💛
karina moves are prettier than the whole choreography itself. she just nailed of her moves. look at the energy she gives into this stage it's beyond perfection
She is definitely born to be a performer. I felt a little bad tho bc Karina kept having to pull down her skirt throughout the performance. She looked so uncomfortable :,(
Ningning's charisma is unmatched. Her dance looks so classy and effortless yet so addicting! Not to mention her stunning visuals, outstanding vocals, enchanting gazes and her iconic red hair. I stan an all-rounder maknae! 🔥
Winter is so beautiful and gorgeous. Her beauty is killing me and perfect about visual of Aespa. Her voice is perfect and her dance is amazing and she did perfect performance on stage and stage outside. I am so proud of you and I will support Winter forever
karina is just doing her thing and that's slaying the stage with her moves, confidence, outfit, body goals, her stage presence, face expression like everything is perfect
I hope International MYs will never ignore anyone.. Be it Winrina or Ningselle.. Every one holds a main title.. I love Vocals and presence and that's why I love NingNing.. I know some may love dance, rap, visuals or all-rounders.. We should show equal love to everyone.. And I'll too.. Even if NingNing is my bias, Winter is my bias wrecker and I really love Rina's elegance and Giselle's potential..
@love twilight omg🤦 I'm so stupid. So sorry for the confusion. I thought you doesn't like Karina that's why you didn't like this person comment. Sorry for the confusion. I'll delete my previous comment
@love twilight i've noticed that too. One comment isn't enough for him/her. Like we get it already, you're saying karina is better than the other members 😂
karina is incredible. her movements are very precise, as if she could handle every part of her body at will, her facial expression are incredible. her stage presence are remarkable, i mean she doesn't nake a false step, she has everything under control. just wow
Karina & Winter's ending fairy is sth i needed in my life now, their visual are truly next level but when will be Giselle and Ningning turn to be ending fairy? I just wanna see all of the members do it too .
Yea I wanna see them as ending fairies. Giselle looks so good with her airy bangs, she’s got that ethereal look and Ningning is a stunner w those eyes and red hair
that doesnt make sense sjkdjs maybe if you say that SM is the powerhouse of vocals then YESS they all slay those vocals i can listen to all Aespa members t_t they all sing heavenly!!
when karina performing she's always in the moment. she never missed a beat or failed to show appropriate facial expression. she's hella on point. dayum girl!
karina is always the girl never disappoint you. even when she's solo or not you will never be disappointed with her. it's given that ahe's good dancing and rapping but her energy and fluidity on stage is on another level
걸스 보다가 넥레로 넘어왔는데 걸스 카메라 무빙 보다가 이거 보니까 왜 이렇게 보는 맛이 있지 무빙이 어지럽지도 않고 안무 포인트에 맞게끔 무빙하는게 너무 좋은데?… 무빙 미쳤다….생생감 쩔어 넥레때 감독님 다시 돌아와주세여 ㅠㅠ 그래서 그런가 누나들 다른 직캠보자 넥레때 직캠이 더 영상 몰입갑이 쩔었던거 같은데 무빙 진짜 보는 맛이 있었다 ㅠㅠ
@@vanessaaddamo6876 who is Taeyon Its probably Taeyeon or Taeyong But Taemin is male Winter is female But wait a min what you mean? Taemin looks beautiful without & with makeup If you mean Taeyong then not for im a crazy & biggest stan of Taeyong cuz my friends tells me ( they dont even stan NCT ) Taeyong is so beautiful & unreal without makeup & with it , they love Taeyong everything He is just a perfact human Along with Taeminie & Winter
NingNing’s stage presence is insane!!! She’s so cute off stage but her aura totally changes ones the music starts. Great vocals beautiful face and extremely good dancing skills, a whole package!!!
Karina's dance is on the next level Winter's visuals are on the next level Giselle's rap is on the next level NingNing's vocals are the next level Aespa is on the next level
My bias is Winter and I find her face the most beautiful among them all but in this era Giselle's beauty stand out the most to me. She look so stunning today as well and i love her outfit.
i love the strong confidence and stage presence that ningning had. she's different off and on stage! cute to fierce?? and her gaze is so powerful! STOP SLEEPING ON NINGNING SHE DESERVES SO MUCH LOVE AND APPRECIATION.
Notice at 1:38 when Karina changes the flow of her hand movement? Lol what a polite queen. Also loved the fact that the cameramen focused on both rappers during the rapping part esp at 2:38. Most of the times, when "We against the villain" starts to play, cameramen won't zoom in Giselle but zoom out showing the whole group instead. This time, cameramen have done their homework.
karina never fails to give energy and charisma in every single on her performance. her consistency is not a joke. she was born to be a performer because she is the one that genuinely enjoy it
Karina is always been hypnotizing when she performs. Moreover, I have noticed she's more natural on this comeback. Her dance moves are so smooth like it just come out naturally without even trying + the way she gives off different facial expressions are on point that it makes viewers be at ease while watching.
Always amazed by karina visua. She gonna nail every single product she wear, every kind of hairstyle, concept and everything. Even she didn't become idol, she gonna did great on modelling and etc
조진현감독님 인터뷰보고 촬영현장영상 보고 영상완성본 너무 궁금해서 보러왔는데 진짜 영상도 하나의 예술작품이라는걸 느끼고갑니다 어떻게 촬영하느냐에 따라 느낌을 다 다르게 줄 수 있다는게 멋있어요!! 멋있으세요!
ㅎㅎ저도 영상완성본이 궁금해서 왔어요 ! 열심히 준비한 무대를 열심히 촬영해주시니까 더 빛이나는것같아요!!!
ㅋ저도
저도
저도요 궁금해서 왔는데 너무 멋진거 같아요
me too
I’m happy that some people aren’t sleeping on Giselle anymore, she and the whole aespa members deserve everything
Giselle is better day by day, I swear I can see it. She is way more confident than the time aespa debuted. Performing Black Mamba, there weren't much screentime for her, but when it came, she just stared at it and performed her part. But now, I can clearly see that she really enjoys the stage. This also helps me to enjoy aespa's performances more than before, cause I like Giselle the most in group, I want her to show up and shine more~
Hope one day, when covid-19 is under control, aespa can perform in front of audients/fans. I think this will help the girls so much in raising confident and stage presentation (still, they're awsome now) :D
@@loan9__nguyen9 this is why SM put her in the final lineup. despite having a very short training period, they saw huge potential, and she's definitely proving them right 💛
@@chicharia5025 exactly
Hum
ningning and winter's voice.... giselle and karina's rap... their outfits their dance EVERYTHING PERFECTTTTTT
전반적으로 머리부터 발끝 자주 잡아주고 노래포인트에 존나 각도 비틀고 줌아웃 존나 신난다
간만에 맘에드는 카메라무빙;;
0:12 근데 카리나 다리짧아보임.. 그리고 골반이 다른 멤버보다 더 커보이는 건 나뿐임?
@@rndfelice7372 너뿐임
@@rndfelice7372 너뿐임
@@rndfelice7372 지금 니 모습이랑 비교 해봐
@@rndfelice7372 골반커보이는건 좋은거 아님?
Giselle's "to hot to hot" hair flip. She definitely brings the attitude to the group
"That's hot!"
Ikr my ultimate bias
AND THAT LITTLE WINK OMG
Giselle chose Paris Hilton's most famous quote as grad quote, it's just normal to be the one with hotness attitude like that 😇💅🏻
my fav part
Aespa's stage presence is insane for a new group; they're literally slaying with their performance like veteran groups.
I don’t expect any less from SM groups 😌 💅
4분짜리 노래안에 여러 전조를 이용한 섹션들이 나눠져있는데 들을때마다 조화롭고 신선해서 4분이 어떻게 가는지 모르겠음 ㄷㄷ 노래 좋다. 간만에 이런 풍의 음원 좋은 걸그룹 노래 나왔네
th-cam.com/video/GTKm0mnZgp8/w-d-xo.html
Click
karina moves are prettier than the whole choreography itself. she just nailed of her moves. look at the energy she gives into this stage it's beyond perfection
Agree
and thats why shes the MAIN dancer
Which one is karina
@@sbl1744 0:10, Karina is the girl with dark hair
She is definitely born to be a performer. I felt a little bad tho bc Karina kept having to pull down her skirt throughout the performance. She looked so uncomfortable :,(
THEIR OUFIT, THEIR VOCAL, THEIR RAP, THEIR BACKGROUND IS ANOTHER LEVEL.
LEST I FORGET, THEIR AMAZING VISUAL.
"vocals" they're barely even moving their lips
이노래는 대박날 수 밖엔 없는 곡임 스타일링도 역대급임
Ningning's charisma is unmatched. Her dance looks so classy and effortless yet so addicting! Not to mention her stunning visuals, outstanding vocals, enchanting gazes and her iconic red hair. I stan an all-rounder maknae! 🔥
Winter is so beautiful and gorgeous. Her beauty is killing me and perfect about visual of Aespa. Her voice is perfect and her dance is amazing and she did perfect performance on stage and stage outside. I am so proud of you and I will support Winter forever
She reminds me of taeyeon
노래가 들을수록 심하게 좋네 특히 이 무대는 전부다 겁나 이쁘고 카메라 무빙이 일품이다 진짜..
th-cam.com/video/GTKm0mnZgp8/w-d-xo.html
Click
No but like Winter really slays this hairstyle. She’s so stunning I can’t take my eyes off of her. WinRina ending fairy killed me 🙏🏻
Forever winrina 🙄
Yes, i love her hair style
Same
True
Winrina😳💔
winter's visual, aura, vocals, and dancing are insane for a rookie.
Her next level pronounce is amazing
Facts
Agree!
Trueee
이런 무대세트는 예산이 얼마나 들어갈까..? 단순히 디스플레이랑 조명만 있는게 아니라서 디자인하고 기획한사람들 진짜 대단한듯...
이 맛에 대형빨지..
Cbds
레벨 트와 블핑은 바닥까지 싹 새로깔고 하던데 ㄹㅇ무섭다 비용
기본적으로 업체 정하는데만 계약금이 십수억 할듯.
Winter really serves us that superior look. And her moves are so sharp and clean.
Best dancer
Winter is so pretty.
th-cam.com/video/3YRj2uNfgMo/w-d-xo.html
요새아이돌 관심도없고 잘못르는데 우연히듣고 나무좋아서 직접 찾으러옴 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ노래 겁나 좋네 역시 에스엠
저도요!ㅎㅎ
Ningning is not lying when she said she feels the most confident and most beautiful when she's singing. I can't with her, so attractive on stage.
Finally something I can relate to w ningning. I feel on top of the world when I sing too. 😊
4th gen vocal queen!!!
@@user-hs6rl7io6i facts !!
Soo true
Shes obviously lipsyncing though
....
Giselle improved so much this cb... She's truly in her own next level
This performance remains ICONIC. Everyone had their time to shine, camerawork, outfits. Everything ON POINT❤️🌙⭐️🦋
Winter's charisma is not a joke.
Tru
Ikr!
(I don't mean any hate please don't be mad)
Winter's hair remind me of Taeyeon(GG) for some reason :)
@@crystallily9968 yes because winter her daughter :p
Fact
karina is just doing her thing and that's slaying the stage with her moves, confidence, outfit, body goals, her stage presence, face expression like everything is perfect
The ace
와 하나의 곡에 여러개의 노래가 있는거같다
Winter's Visual, vocal, and charisma is on another level!
And addicter with winter say “NEXT LEVEL”
*addicted
@@sellaagustina910 you are not alone
Facts
This the reason why she is the ace in group
Black is really aespa's colour, they are extremely gorgeous here, especially Karina omg her presence and aura just... arghhh😭❤
WINTER! She's always gorgeous but her look here is unreal. She looks like a game character!
Winter’s charisma, visual, dance skills, vocals are so mesmerizing
I think this is winter's best outfit for this comeback, best-suited with the concept
I hope International MYs will never ignore anyone.. Be it Winrina or Ningselle.. Every one holds a main title.. I love Vocals and presence and that's why I love NingNing..
I know some may love dance, rap, visuals or all-rounders..
We should show equal love to everyone..
And I'll too..
Even if NingNing is my bias, Winter is my bias wrecker and I really love Rina's elegance and Giselle's potential..
Ningning and Giselle slay..their facial expression really on point for this song especially Ningning..she is the real visual
Yah
Ning is my bias yes
For me all of aespa member is visual
karina is one of the chillest main dancer. she is so relaxed and makes the dance looks so easy, which show how talented she is
Agree
Exactly
@love twilightWhat do you mean??
@love twilight omg🤦 I'm so stupid. So sorry for the confusion. I thought you doesn't like Karina that's why you didn't like this person comment. Sorry for the confusion. I'll delete my previous comment
@love twilight i've noticed that too. One comment isn't enough for him/her. Like we get it already, you're saying karina is better than the other members 😂
유퀴즈 보다가 궁금해서 찾아들어와서 봤는데
이건뭐.... 예술 작품이네요 완전~
감사합니다^__^~~ 좋은 영상 찍어주셔서요
karina is incredible. her movements are very precise, as if she could handle every part of her body at will, her facial expression are incredible. her stage presence are remarkable, i mean she doesn't nake a false step, she has everything under control. just wow
Agree
Really? I feel like all of aespa look bored when they perform
ㅇㅈ
use this as a giselle appreciation button. My girl needs love too but people her barely compliment her
모처럼 신기한 노래를 듣네
에프엑스로 시작해서 H.O.T 나오다가
SES 나오더만 동방신기가 튀어나오더니
천상지희로 끝나는 희한한 노래.
듣자마자 유영진 작곡인걸 알아낸 내가 레전드.
윈터가 유영진 딸 ㄷㄷ
@@고인물-g8c 진짜 딸은 아니고 그만큼 애정한다는 의미같아요 ㅎㅎㅎ
원곡 따로있음요
@@BKSONG-z9f 네 제가 말한건 원곡 중간에 유영진이 새로 작곡해서 넣은 부분이에요 그 부분은 원곡과 다름
저도 그 부분 뭔가 되게 어디서 들어본거같고 비슷하다 생각했는데 쓰니님이 그 느낌을 표현해주시네요 !!
Karina & Winter's ending fairy is sth i needed in my life now, their visual are truly next level but when will be Giselle and Ningning turn to be ending fairy? I just wanna see all of the members do it too .
Yea I wanna see them as ending fairies. Giselle looks so good with her airy bangs, she’s got that ethereal look and Ningning is a stunner w those eyes and red hair
True. They can't always left Ning Ning and Giselle out like that
Feels like winter and karina are the members sm wants to promote the most
@@ashleyd7425 ending fairy is decided by the SBS staff, SM doesn't decide which one to be ending fairy
@@spacesoftime ofc ! I m just saying that they are the members that are promote the most everywhere
*Karina so charismatic and attractive she look like she have been an idol for years her and ningning always overflowing with charisma* 🖤
카감님 이거 진짜 줌인 줌아웃 무빙 다 미쳤따리오졌다리~~~~~~~ 카감도 당근 중요하지만 그때마다 적재적소에 컷인 컷아웃 넣은 pd도 생방 편집 조온나게 잘한거임.. 진짜 간만에 역대급 음방 편집이였음~😍👍
Winter's duality is driving me INSANEEEEE. Also her high notes and her sharp movements. Truly an ace!
4 main vocal
4 main dancer
4 main rapper
4 visual
It's aespa!!
th-cam.com/video/WQYciFzN518/w-d-xo.html
옛날거 느낌도 있고 요즘거 같기도 하고 노래가 묘하고 파트구성도 재밌고 춤도좋고 애들 너무 방긋방긋 안웃고 카리스마있어서 또 좋고.. 할미가 맨날 찾아 보넹....
I really like winter she’s very angry and clean, Karina never failed for me she’s my ult bias all the members are beautiful in this performance😍
Giselle’s charisma is Next Level.
그냥 퀄이 다르네.. 비교대상 자체가 없다.
독보적이다. 앞으로는 에스파의 시대가 될거란 생각밖에 안든다.
그리고 카리나는 타고났다. 아우라가 그냥.. 와
I could stare at ningning’s eyes forever. They’re so mesmerizing and expressive.
Yez
Yes
RIGHT SHE HAS THAT GAZE🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩
Ikr
Everyone agrees that aespa’s voices are Powerhouses.ALL of them. Such a versatile group.
that doesnt make sense sjkdjs maybe if you say that SM is the powerhouse of vocals then YESS they all slay those vocals
i can listen to all Aespa members t_t they all sing heavenly!!
@@pinkinmybloodd oh really sorry English isn’t my first langage😔
Yall liking without correcting me 😭😭
@@miriam232 lmao it’s not that bad your English is perfect ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
Winter is so captivating
i'll say it whenever i have a chance, Karina is just unbelievably gorgeous.
Karina in the thumbnail is so pretty and i love Winter charisma
WINTER IS SOO GORGEOUS 😍😍😍😍
YESSS She looks like a game character here
when karina performing she's always in the moment. she never missed a beat or failed to show appropriate facial expression. she's hella on point. dayum girl!
The ace
karina is always the girl never disappoint you. even when she's solo or not you will never be disappointed with her. it's given that ahe's good dancing and rapping but her energy and fluidity on stage is on another level
The ace
걸스 보다가 넥레로 넘어왔는데 걸스 카메라 무빙 보다가 이거 보니까 왜 이렇게 보는 맛이 있지 무빙이 어지럽지도 않고 안무 포인트에 맞게끔 무빙하는게 너무 좋은데?… 무빙 미쳤다….생생감 쩔어 넥레때 감독님 다시 돌아와주세여 ㅠㅠ 그래서 그런가 누나들 다른 직캠보자 넥레때 직캠이 더 영상 몰입갑이 쩔었던거 같은데 무빙 진짜 보는 맛이 있었다 ㅠㅠ
i just love how karina is all charismatic on stage even not on her part. she's doing her very best
Winter's Visual is on the next level
I couldn't take my eyes off WINTER. She is so beautiful
Winter is beautiful with make up she's like taemin not taeyon
I'm a Karina stan but can't deny Winter looks so fine here
@@vanessaaddamo6876 who is Taeyon
Its probably Taeyeon or Taeyong
But Taemin is male
Winter is female
But wait a min what you mean?
Taemin looks beautiful without & with makeup
If you mean Taeyong then not for im a crazy & biggest stan of Taeyong cuz my friends tells me ( they dont even stan NCT ) Taeyong is so beautiful & unreal without makeup & with it , they love Taeyong everything
He is just a perfact human
Along with Taeminie & Winter
Ikr???
@@vanessaaddamo6876 what? who's 'taeyon' bestie? and then before you said winter 'pretty with make up', make sure you see her photos without make up🤡
NingNing’s stage presence is insane!!! She’s so cute off stage but her aura totally changes ones the music starts. Great vocals beautiful face and extremely good dancing skills, a whole package!!!
what stage presence...... she's just blank faced the entire with her mouth hanging open.. no facial expressions for more than 5 seconds
What extremely good dancing skills
She is the weakest in dance
NingNing is the queen
@@queenruby5286 sure
@@pinkypinky-wo1du okay and? She’s a main vocal
진짜 소녀시대, 티아라, 오렌지카라멜, 여자친구이후로 맘에 드는 걸그룹 처음이야ㅠ
Karina's dance is on the next level
Winter's visuals are on the next level
Giselle's rap is on the next level
NingNing's vocals are the next level
Aespa is on the next level
Ikr
No
@@haerin052 why
@@haerin052 why
@@haerin052 why b*i
ningning did not lie when she said that she is not shy. this girl knows how to be confident
Winter's visuls and vocals are no joke
Wow ok Winter looks so good omgggg. Ningning's stage presence is crazy. The confidence. The facial expressions. Her eyes. Makes me think of Haechan.
KARINA hits different when shes performing shes like a different beast as opposes to her cute and shy personality off stage.
this quality is same like jennie , I am not comparing them but feels nice that they have so much professionalism even as a rookie group
Jennie and karina ACES!
Ikr
Yes
yeah
무대가 미쳤는데…컨셉에 맞게 예쁘게 잘 꾸몄다
karina dance are so smooth that it looks like she is not even trying
Winter knows how to catch the camaraman with her handddddd.
유퀴즈 보고 왔는데 시작 부분 진짜 ㄹㅈㄷ
KARINA's stage presence and visuals is just overflowing, she is born to be on stage. Damn!
Fact
valid
Winter pulls off the move at 3:01 so well! So much attitude in her moves
Karina look so GORGEOUS ✨✨
I can't stop looking at her 😭
WINTER's hair suits her so much!
My bias is Winter and I find her face the most beautiful among them all but in this era Giselle's beauty stand out the most to me. She look so stunning today as well and i love her outfit.
카메라 감독님 인터뷰 듣고 오니 더 대단하게 보이네요.
ningning always catches my attention, her charisma is sooo irresistible
Karina and winter ending fairy queens.
th-cam.com/video/3YRj2uNfgMo/w-d-xo.html
Yup
Ikr..they are soo pretty😭😭
Omgee a swifty and a My ♥️♥️
I’m so confused ending fairy? What are you guys talking about
No one talking about ningning? She so pretty, i love her facial expression..
winter is very pretty and i wish she works on her facial expressions more when dancing!!
winter short hair is everything!
like-how can she be so beautiful in that hairstyleeeee????
춘시기 영상때메 이 곡의 매력을 알아버려따……👍
I'm obsessed with Giselle and Karina's rap part. It makes them extra cooler.
NingNing's vocal, visual and charisma is another level
역시 이때가 최고다 공장에서 찍어낸 여자아이돌들과는 다른 에스파만의 독보적느낌 근데 이수만이랑 유영진 나가서 이제 이느낌 또 가능할까
Winter is serving so hard today with her visual, outfit, and stage presence! Short hair looks so good on her. I'm obsessed with her
i love the strong confidence and stage presence that ningning had. she's different off and on stage! cute to fierce?? and her gaze is so powerful! STOP SLEEPING ON NINGNING SHE DESERVES SO MUCH LOVE AND APPRECIATION.
카감님 역대급입니다. 넘 잘 찍으셨어요 무빙 넘 좋습니다
WINTER IS GODDAMN BEAUTIFUL!
they’re all so *chef’s kiss* honestly. truly queens
Aespa really suit this style of music bcs the vocals are strong
Notice at 1:38 when Karina changes the flow of her hand movement? Lol what a polite queen. Also loved the fact that the cameramen focused on both rappers during the rapping part esp at 2:38. Most of the times, when "We against the villain" starts to play, cameramen won't zoom in Giselle but zoom out showing the whole group instead. This time, cameramen have done their homework.
Ningning understood the assignment, aced the exam, and graduated with the highest distinction! 😌❤
사랑이 안들어가는 노래중에 가사도 와닿는다.. 너무 더우면 여름에 까만 긴옷이자는 전 그룹 보다..
the way winter does the move at 3:03 is my favourite ever
omg karina performance is not joke. she's literally a stage monster. i can't describe this girl, she's amazing
유영진이 여자 HOT 노래를 만들어 줬네. 역시 유영진 스타일~중독성 있음
만들었다고 하기에는 원곡이랑 거의 똑같아서 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
멀만들어 완전 똑같은디 ㅋ 안무가가 열일했지
어휴 답댓들 이꼬라지일 줄 알았더.,,
ㅇㅈ😮
karina dance is hypnotising. there is no other word to describe it
karina never fails to give energy and charisma in every single on her performance. her consistency is not a joke. she was born to be a performer because she is the one that genuinely enjoy it