James Fisher Nicole went half a note lower on the first high note. And then at 2:44 she hit a D6, which is higher than what Mariah hit on that part of the song. But there are background high notes on the original track up to A6 I think... so Mariah still went higher on the song lol
+Nicholas Vincent It doesn't really make sense to compare a live performance to a recorded track. Did Mariah do those A6 notes live (not in whistle register?)
Richard Big She actually has hit an A6 live in the song. She did it at least twice on the Charmbracelet tour in 2003 And the OP wasn't talking about head voice or whistle register, he was just talking who went higher... so the answer is Mariah.
In my opinion, Nicole's voice is the best voice to sing this song. It just sounds so natural, I like Mimi's version and all but I prefer Nicole's voice for this song, and plus that head voice at the end, that makes it that much better because that was not in the original! Wish it was just Nicole who sang it, Mel B not so hot
Richard Big Tbh, she probably could if she wanted to. The highest note Nicole hit in this is a D6. Mariah sustained the same note in head voice live in her song Infinity a few times the other year.
Well maybe so...my point was I like this better...I've never been very impressed or blown away by Mariah's head voice or upper chest voice for that matter, it's her whistle register that's really impressive
Nicole is a package multi talented girl.GOD BLESS you more Nicole
beautiful girl with a beautiful voice love nicole
I would LOVE a Christmas album from her!! that would be the best Christmas present ever.
Nicole is definitely the best singer on that stage.
Nicole is so beautiful and talented🥰🥰🥰
Nicole is awesome saw her on her way up at the Kentucky State Fair in her home town Louisville Kentucky and knew she was headed for stardom.
Nicole is just like Kelly Clarkson, they both can literally sing anything
Nicole nailed it❣️❣️
Please Nicole, more of this
Nicole is just a star
Meu Deus, reuniu uma das Spice e a Nicole pra cantar a música "number one" de natal da Diva Mariah?! É muito amor em um só vídeo!! 🎵❤🇧🇷👏✌🎅
Beautiful talented lovely gorgeous Nicole Hamilton! Woah talented woman!!
Nicole SCHERZINGER not Hamilton! She and Lewis broke up. He didn't deserve her anyways.
Samanta Rizzi hes gay anyway
Wow! PCD and Spice Girls on one stage 💖
Ricky Wilson and Nicole they look so compatible hahahahahaa
@
2:40
How can such a beautiful sound come out of someone's mouth!
Is it me, or did she go higher than Mimi?
James Fisher Nicole went half a note lower on the first high note.
And then at 2:44 she hit a D6, which is higher than what Mariah hit on that part of the song.
But there are background high notes on the original track up to A6 I think... so Mariah still went higher on the song lol
+Nicholas Vincent
"But there are background high notes on the original track up to A6 I think"
Yeah...in whistle register?
+Nicholas Vincent It doesn't really make sense to compare a live performance to a recorded track. Did Mariah do those A6 notes live (not in whistle register?)
Richard Big She actually has hit an A6 live in the song. She did it at least twice on the Charmbracelet tour in 2003
And the OP wasn't talking about head voice or whistle register, he was just talking who went higher... so the answer is Mariah.
+Nicholas Vincent I was actually talking about head voice...
In my opinion, Nicole's voice is the best voice to sing this song. It just sounds so natural, I like Mimi's version and all but I prefer Nicole's voice for this song, and plus that head voice at the end, that makes it that much better because that was not in the original! Wish it was just Nicole who sang it, Mel B not so hot
Nicole could never do this song as well as Mariah did at Tokyo Dome in 1996
Mariah couldn't do the upper head voice like that at the end, but her lower voice is stronger
Richard Big Tbh, she probably could if she wanted to.
The highest note Nicole hit in this is a D6.
Mariah sustained the same note in head voice live in her song Infinity a few times the other year.
Mariah lip-syncs now days most of the time so I wouldn't use one of her performances of recent years.
Well maybe so...my point was I like this better...I've never been very impressed or blown away by Mariah's head voice or upper chest voice for that matter, it's her whistle register that's really impressive
Luv ya Nicole 😍
nicole :)
Spice Girl & Pussycat Doll at one night, in the same show.
It's June, why am I here
Is that David walliams from BGT at 2:21 the person she locked arms with?
I've just noticed Joel play piano 😂
1:33 that was rough
1:47 that confused look on her face looking at Mel.
Hahahaha love this
👍🏼
eu foz🎅
the way no one can sing it even half as good as mariah
stevie cant sing
Wtf? It's terrible 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣