@@JeffreySaxophoneTallNewton I honestly can't comment because I haven't tried the 130. My guess is that most people could live without the SRT system, but hopefully someone else will comment on it . .
@@guitar-academy Thank you for your replies! The 200 series is 2015, now 6 years into the product cycle. I wonder if Yamaha is soon going to release the successor?
@@JeffreySaxophoneTallNewton I was thinking that when I bought the this one, but if there is a successor, Yamaha are keeping it close to there chests . . 🤔
@@guitar-academy They did the same thing with the "silent sax" (YDS-150). First, it never existed. Then, some promo - but no product to buy (for months). Still not generally available in the USA - I somehow found one on Amazon. They know what they're doing for marketing - and instrument making. My soprano sax is a 1987 Yamaha. As to the silent guitars, it looks like 2002 for the first gen, with the latest at 2015. So, maybe not for a while!
These guitars are hard to find on TH-cam. This is a solid technical review that answered many questions I’ve had over the years. The demos were clear and direct. Fantastic overview. Very pleased with the quality of the sounds on here. Again I will be doing some guitar hunting! Cheers.
Audio engineer tip for you - when running audio in to another device, e.g. a desk… pop the input device to max level / output and alter the recording / receiving device as you wish to kill the hiss. This means the pre-amps in your desk won’t need to up the signal received. Loved the video and liked it, thanks
I was recently "bequeathed" a number of guitars and peddles by an acquaintance who left the state. (Hawaii) One of the guitars was a perfectly preserved Yamaha SLG200S in it's original case. I was really quite amazed by it's multitude of functions and particularly by it's very unique sound quality. No less am I impressed by this video and your very thorough and clear review of this guitar. Mahalo Nui Nui !! (Hawaiian for BIG BIG Thanks!!)
Had this guitar 3 years. It was a bargain and a truly good buy. very usable and no problems gigging very regularly. Much better than an electro acoustic at high volumes
I have one of the early steel string models - the 100. Love it. I even put electric strings on it - .010's, and it plays like a Les Paul, and sounds like an acoustic all the way. I'd like to get one of the nylon string models, too. Doesn't matter where you go with it, on stage, in the studio, around the house - it's completely functional. I have no complaints at all.
Thank you . . I haven't had it long enough to judge on the battery situation, but that would explain the power in socket. I may need to do an update in a future video . . thanks for the heads up. 🙂
I absolutely love my SLG. Had it for 2 years and it has been great. Holds tuning and handles travel really well. I am thinking about the nylon version now as well.
@@oldgrayfox How many hours do you think the AA batteries last in all while using this guitar until you have ti change them? Also, do you use rechargeable, or normal AA batteries? Thanks! :)
It’SO important to have purchased a guitar that you’re going to review yourself. I was searching for travel guitars and every single channel, the person doing the review said it was given to them to review and/or also that guitar company was their sponsor… they didn’t have a single word of criticism which I find suspicious. I think had they spent their own money and they weren’t swayed by who was actually sponsoring the video that their review would likely have been different.
Thank you very much . . I need to do a follow up video, because I've been using both the steel and nylon guitars now for a while and they both perform really well . .
Thanks, I hope yamaha updates the guitar models mic and pickup, DSP, and effects including delay. Technology has gotten so much better with the fender acoustisonic and others and smartphones being more powerful than laptops. Now is the time for a major upgrade, including the latest bluetooth codecs, and built in speaker system updated electronics, hiss reduction, and computer models for different guitars etc. Way more presets and customizations are possible, even with sharing users settings. Along with built in drums and backing tracks for practice, higher quality headphone dac and amp, and 2 of them.
Well if you think about it my fernandes nomad from 20 yrs ago does almost all of this? Amp/pickup/mic modeling, drum machine, effects. Does it sound as good as this for acoustic settings and in general? Definitely not but point is technology is there. I will also be waiting on a Yama update to this machine it’s been untouched for at least 10 yrs if I recall.
Best purchase ever. Only two things: 1) Does not sound good at all with acrylic nails. 2) The pieces you can separate are not solid after a few years screwing and unscrewing.
@@guitar-academy Yeah the removable part becomes a bit shaky after a few years. And not sure if it's weather or what other reason, in several occasions one of the screws gets completely stuck for a few days even though its not holding the piece. But anyway, I love the guitar.
Thanks for the review. I own the nylon string wide neck version. LOVE it!! I plan to sell my Taylor 710CE and buy one of the steel string SLG versions. The onboard sound quality/versatility of these guitars is amazing. You can play straight through a PA system or enhance the sound through computer apps. Not to mention the difference in price. Who has $3,000 - $5,000 to spend on an acoustic guitar that can provide the same sound quality?
Yes I agree with you. If you record or would like to record your guitar it's a challenge getting the sound just right with microphones but the Yamaha makes it easy. 😊😀
Hi, Indeed a fantastic review and demo. Thanks! This guitar seems so amazing 'versatile'. I'm surprised by the sustain even with the lack of 'wood around'. Your style of playing is in top harmony with this guitar. Thanks for sharing and I hope you enjoy this fine instrument to the full. Greetings.
I heard Lee Ritenour playing one. It sounded great! I saw Nathan East playing the silent bass with fourplay. That bass sounded great! Yamaha’s silent series are great! Little pricey, but good. If you can get pass the looks, you’ll be fine.😌
Thank you very much for this outstanding review. You covered everything beautifully and now I know I want to purchase one myself. "The Troubled Heart" was just beautiful too. It's impressive how good the tone on this guitar is. Liked and subscribed!
I'm glad it was helpful and thank you for the like and sub . . here's how to play 'the troubled hear' if you're interested th-cam.com/video/LCCNs5pvYRA/w-d-xo.html
@@guitar-academy Thank you so much! This is wonderful. I am just checking out the tutorial now, registered for the Fingerstyle course, etc. I am looking forward to the learning and being able to play this lovely song. It is so good of you to freely share your talent and instruction this way. I really appreciate it.
Hello I want to buy this guitar but still I cant be sure if i can adjust the volume like i want because i am living an apartment and my neighbors may be disturbed.Could you help me about this how was your experince ?
Sounds really lovely, and thank you for such a detailed (and calm...) overview of this instrument. I have one question just out of curiosity; do you think one of these guitars would be a reasonable choice for someone looking to pick up guitar playing in general? Especially if they aren't sure whether they really want to play acoustic or electric.
Thank you very much 😃 That's a good question . . Honestly, all I can do is give you things to consider, the decision will be very personal to yourself and depend on you budget, music tastes and determination to learn guitar. If you have the money, then this is a good middle ground as it has a similar feel to an electric guitar. However, normally I would suggest getting a cheaper guitar to start with, then you can buy an electric and an acoustic. I've been teaching for over 30 years and it's amazing how many times I've taught people who like to listen to one style of music but prefer to play another . . 🤔
@@guitar-academy That is a good point! I haven't played an instrument for almost 20 years, and never a guitar, but lately feel inspired to tinker. Just for my own enjoyment. Initially I was convinced I wanted to get an electric, but I've been a bit fascinated by other alternatives as I was researching. But you are quite right I suppose; I could probably get two decent instruments for the price of one of these, if I wasn't happy with my first choice! Thank you.
@@Mythricia1988 I really hope you have a great time with any guitar. I think it's a great way to relax and they recon if you learn an instrument it can help prevent Alzheimer's later in life . . 😃
Thank you so much for the clear and precise review. I wish all the reviews about guitars were so accurate as yours. I'll have a look to see if you have a review of the nylon string model for I'm thinking about buying it.
Thank you so much, as your review on this guitar is by far the best that I've seen. Please could you advise on which strings to use as I find the originals to heavy and hard as I am 69 and trying to learn a few chords. 10/10 for your clear review.
Thank you very much for your encouraging comment. I like light strings which are easy to press down and a go between 'Elixir Polyweb Extra Light Acoustic' and 'Adagio extra light acoustic strings'. 😊😃
I honestly can't believe the sound coming from a guitar without a body. lol Does it take long or very had to learn finger picking? I just started to play when I was young, but gave it up. I only knew chording, no bar chords or anything straight chords. As I said on your nylon video, I will say it again, you play beautiful. I could listen to you play all day and never want you to stop. Thank you.
That's really nice of you, thank you very much. 😊😊 Finger picking isn't hard at all. I've written a free fingerstyle guitar course. It's completely free, here's the play lists for book 1 and 2. Book 1 th-cam.com/play/PLIQJcXCYbgO2q9hDUBT0E5z1JZDk3bowI.html Book 2 th-cam.com/play/PLIQJcXCYbgO1uyExG1qS2puZ6aC11cA-M.html
Excellente! A superbly enjoyable video demonstration of another Yamaha icon. Always liked these since I tried one some years back, but for some reason, it hasn't materialised.... Yet. That could change. Or I might just make one. . I have to agree with someone else here, Your (exquisite) playing style sounds well at home on the SLG200S.
Nice review. Can you hear through the headphones if you are plugged into the amp as well? I am struggling with monitors and this seems like an easy solution. I get that I won't get a mix (vocals, bass other), but at least my guitar would be in my ear.
Is a great guitar. I removed the molded urea saddle and replaced with a bone saddle and that helped balance out the bass and all strings with improved clarity.
I've already replaced the strings but I will play with it a bit first before changing anything else so I can better judge the standard guitar. 🙂 But it's nice to know the bone saddle is an improvement in advance. 🙂
Great review. I’ve had spinal fusion surgery and I’m looking for the lightest guitar I can find. Amazon says it weighs 4.6 pounds. Is it a featherweight when you’re wearing a strap or more like a millstone?
How loud is it if you strum it with a pick when it’s not plugged into anything? I live in an apartment building and I’d love to be able to practice without disturb my neighbors.
@@JustinTrudeau1971 The guitar isn't silent as the name suggests but there's no way you'd disturb your neighbors with one of these. You can hear them as you play of if you're in the same room but I doubt you could hear it through a wall or door. 😊
Would this guitar sound as nice plugged into an acoustic amplifier or an electric guitar amp, or is it more for the way your using it? It sounds wonderful and I’m sure your playing it doesn’t hurt. Really enjoyed this video, cheers.
and i'm not the only one who wondering and waiting for the part that this guitar is REALLY SILENT. But thank you for the review man, great review love the picture quality, per parts details, sound. and it was yamaha who gave the name 'silent' for this guitar.
They haven't released a new one for years and they aren't saying anything about a new version. But they might have something going on in the background . . 🤔
great review , thank you , i have an older version of this guitar and the pickup as just stopped working for some reason , but its been brilliant , debating wether to try getting it fixed or buying a new one
Would really appreciate it if I could have some questions answered. 1. Is it neck heavy, i.e. does it neck dive? 2. Where is it made? 3. Does it take acoustic guitar strings or electric guitar strings? Thanks in advance.
You show plugging this into the line-in on the mixer. The guitar is almost certainly a Hi-Z instrument level output. That may have contributed to the hiss and possibly made the sound quality suffer, as the mixer would be expecting a much higher signal level. I would be curious if there is a difference if plugged into an instrument input or through a DI box.
It is a standard line out on the guitar 1k ohm impedance and the input on the desk is switchable. It sound a lot worse through Hi-Z because of the impedance mismatch, but good thought . . 🙂
Hi, great video! Quite certainly the best one. I am thinking on buying one. Significant time has passed since you made this video. What are your impressions now and how does it sound through headphones? Cheers!
Glad it was helpful! I've had it for a month now and I really love it. The headphones sound is very good but all round I can''t get the chime you expect from a steel strung guitar being strummed. The sound is very rich, almost too rich . . but as I use the guitar virtually exclusively for fingerstyle it really sounds nice to me. . . I hope this helps 🙂
Thank you for this amazing video I am planning to buy this guitar can u tell me how good is this guitar for professional recordings and how it's sounds ?
It's good, very good . . If you look at the last half of my Christmas giveaway video it is was recorded on the Yamaha th-cam.com/video/m5Lp0T2LqWM/w-d-xo.html
A great and succinct video. I've always wanted to know how this guitar is made and sounded. Now I know. I find it a bit quacky sounding, almost harpsichord like. I'm not sure if this sounds like this only in the video or if it differs live? Pretty cool nonetheless. Thanks for the time and effort put into making this video. Cheers!!
You didn’t find the 200s to buzz on the A and D or any strings for that matter. Mine is less than a day old. I thought it may be the factory strings. I replaced them with ddadario 12s and still buzzes. It does without and with the electronics. Maybe I am playing too hard. I am used to a 90s d28. Thx for reading.
No, I never had a buzz on any of the string on either the N or the S version. If anything more people complain that the action is too high. It could be that the neck isn't straight because that can cause a buzz. I've done a video on lowering the action (which you don't want to do) but the first part of the video shows you how to straighten the neck. th-cam.com/video/QRSAQocR_rY/w-d-xo.html
Wonderful review, well done. I wsh you would have discussed the nech shape and feel. Also the size and feel of the frets. You opinion of the factory set up would be nice also. I respect your opinion. Thank you.
Thank you . . I haven't finished yet so I will bare your questions in mind. I'll be doing a review soon of how I've found the guitar over time and comparing it with it's brother (the SLG200N) . .🙂
@@geneschulp8598 It does play really nicely, but after a couple of hours the top wing sticks into your ribs. But I've 3D printed a round edge to help prevent it digging in.
Hi man! Thank you very much fir the review. The video itself is also very good quality, and I'm really considering this guitar now. I also have a question regarding the video itself.) What gear do you use? I mean camera, lens and lights like here - 6:24. Thanks!
Thank you very much . . the camera is a canon 90d with a stock 18-135 lens, and I just use cheap eBay LED panel lights. At 6:24 I backlit the guitar and under exposed it by 2 stops . . I hope this helps. 😊
@@guitar-academy Thank You! That is good to know. I have bought guitars online, the Lava Me 2, for example, where it was indicated that the action was set at 2.5mm ... only to find out after getting it, that the action was 1/4 inch+ at the 12th fret. Thanks again!
Hey GCH Guitar Academy! Thank you so much for this thorough and meticulous review! I was wondering, when you plug in headphones directly, do you find yourself turning the volume all the way up to hear the guitar? I find that below ~70% volume I don't hear anything from the headphones. Thanks
No I didn't have to do that. Perhaps you should try different headphones to check there isn't a problem with the provided ones. I use my big headphones now and they also work well but are more comfortable to use . .
@@guitar-academy Thanks for replying so quick! I see that you've replied to most of the comments here. I imagine that takes a bit of time and diligence so I appreciate that. Just one clarifying question: if you look at 7:48, the volume knob has 7 "ticks," if you will; when plugging headphones directly into the "PHONES" output, at what "tick" do you begin to hear sound? Also, at this point in the video the volume knob is at "tick" 5. Is this the volume you generally play at (specifically when using headphones)? Thanks
@@user-jj9gi1ci5n On any acoustic guitar I very rarely go above 7 on the volume because I don't want the risk of signal distortion and the higher the volume the greater the chance of the signal being clipped. When playing normally on headphones I don't take the volume much above 5 because it gets too load, 6 is about right. Also remember when using headphones that you have to turn the guitar on and turn the tuner off, the headphone socket isn't a switching socket.
@GHC Guitar Academy I've been searching about reviews of this guitar, because I consider to buy it. And I have to say, your video is the best! Generaly, I think you are great player. Also, I have subscribe to your channel. Thank you 👍
@@guitar-academy yes, you did. I finaly bought this guitar, and its amazing. I will just try to put new bone saddle because the action is just a little bit too high for me.
@@guitar-academy I watched that video before. And I already order new bone saddle. I think this guitar will be perfect when I put a little bit lower bone saddle.
Hi, Thanks for the great review. I was wondering if lighter strings had much impact on the tone? The strings on mine came with may be 11 and I can only play it an hour max! Lighter strings might help but thought it may impact the quality of the sound was my dilemma. Thanks in advance.
Good question . . I like light strings because I go between electric and acoustic a lot and I like them to feel similar. Standard this guitar has too much bass and so putting lighter lighter strings on actually improves the tone. I have 10s on now and I might even experiment with 9's I hope that's helpful 🙂🙂
Nothing, but they brake all the time. It can be a real pain if they brake in the middle of a recording job or music commission. When I started playing fingerstyle professionally I put 'stop n grow' on because I bit my nails badly, but it stopped me biting my nails (it tastes really nasty) 🙂.
Review of the nylon strung version of this guitar th-cam.com/video/WIhrob7t600/w-d-xo.html
Is the SRT system worth getting the new version, as opposed to a used 130 (which does not have the SRT system)? Thanks..
@@JeffreySaxophoneTallNewton I honestly can't comment because I haven't tried the 130. My guess is that most people could live without the SRT system, but hopefully someone else will comment on it . .
@@guitar-academy Thank you for your replies! The 200 series is 2015, now 6 years into the product cycle. I wonder if Yamaha is soon going to release the successor?
@@JeffreySaxophoneTallNewton I was thinking that when I bought the this one, but if there is a successor, Yamaha are keeping it close to there chests . . 🤔
@@guitar-academy They did the same thing with the "silent sax" (YDS-150). First, it never existed. Then, some promo - but no product to buy (for months). Still not generally available in the USA - I somehow found one on Amazon. They know what they're doing for marketing - and instrument making. My soprano sax is a 1987 Yamaha. As to the silent guitars, it looks like 2002 for the first gen, with the latest at 2015. So, maybe not for a while!
Didnt notice my volume was off, thought it was an actual silent guitar
LOL . . 😂
@@guitar-academy 😂🤭🤭🤭
These guitars are hard to find on TH-cam. This is a solid technical review that answered many questions I’ve had over the years. The demos were clear and direct. Fantastic overview.
Very pleased with the quality of the sounds on here. Again I will be doing some guitar hunting! Cheers.
Thank you very much . . 🙂
Audio engineer tip for you - when running audio in to another device, e.g. a desk… pop the input device to max level / output and alter the recording / receiving device as you wish to kill the hiss. This means the pre-amps in your desk won’t need to up the signal received. Loved the video and liked it, thanks
I was recently "bequeathed" a number of guitars and peddles by an acquaintance who left the state. (Hawaii) One of the guitars was a perfectly preserved Yamaha SLG200S in it's original case.
I was really quite amazed by it's multitude of functions and particularly by it's very unique sound quality. No less am I impressed by this video and your very thorough and clear review of this guitar.
Mahalo Nui Nui !! (Hawaiian for BIG BIG Thanks!!)
Not the happiest way of acquiring a guitar but a great guitar. thank you very much . . from a far colder Wales and more . . 😂
Not to fret (haha)
The Gent traded in some wood with strings attached for a pulse and an opinion.
Al the best to Aberystwyth.
Lovely port...
@@TerenceTreeLowery808 😊😊 take care
Best part of the review is how you made it sound, thank you.
Glad you liked it! thank you 🙂
the gig bag looks like it holds a giant tennis racket
I thought a riffle . . but yeah . . 🙂
A standar tunning tennis racket
@@guitar-academy lol
it could be used that way
Very complete and useful review, combined with thoughtful and articulate commentary and playing. Thank you!
thank you very much 😊😃
Had this guitar 3 years. It was a bargain and a truly good buy. very usable and no problems gigging very regularly. Much better than an electro acoustic at high volumes
Yes, electro acoustic still have feedback issues . . 🙂
I want this silent guitar, if only to play John Cage's 4'33'' on it . . .
Those piano chords are way trickier on guitar though! ;)
I have one of the early steel string models - the 100. Love it. I even put electric strings on it - .010's, and it plays like a Les Paul, and sounds like an acoustic all the way. I'd like to get one of the nylon string models, too. Doesn't matter where you go with it, on stage, in the studio, around the house - it's completely functional. I have no complaints at all.
Nice one . . 🙂🙂
Very thorough review. I have seen mentioned elsewhere that these guitars go through batteries extremely quickly. Thanks for doing it.
Thank you . . I haven't had it long enough to judge on the battery situation, but that would explain the power in socket. I may need to do an update in a future video . . thanks for the heads up. 🙂
I absolutely love my SLG. Had it for 2 years and it has been great. Holds tuning and handles travel really well. I am thinking about the nylon version now as well.
🙂
Hi! How is the battery holding in these guitars?
@@aleksandarmarkovic4913 it uses two AA batteries. I change them about every 2 months or so.
@@oldgrayfox How many hours do you think the AA batteries last in all while using this guitar until you have ti change them? Also, do you use rechargeable, or normal AA batteries? Thanks! :)
I wish all review's were like this! Instead of idiots trying to be comedians, and not answering the basic questions, well done very professional 👍🙏
Thank you very much . . 😊😀
@19:00 sounds like it could be the intro to a Metallica song
I guess it does . . 🙂
Which song tho??
@@guitar-academy Please tell me the song name, I really wanna play it. Its so
pleasant😌 😌
@@TusharGS007 he left a link for the tune used to test the guitar in the description
It’SO important to have purchased a guitar that you’re going to review yourself. I was searching for travel guitars and every single channel, the person doing the review said it was given to them to review and/or also that guitar company was their sponsor… they didn’t have a single word of criticism which I find suspicious. I think had they spent their own money and they weren’t swayed by who was actually sponsoring the video that their review would likely have been different.
Thank you for your feedback 😊😃
I'm extremely interested in this guitar, this video covered every single one of my questions, awesome review and awesome guitar
Glad I could help! thank you . . 🙂🙂
It looks and sounds absolutely gorgeous, Yamaha indeed delivers top notch products & innovations, love the brand ❤️ Great review 👍
Thank you very much . . I need to do a follow up video, because I've been using both the steel and nylon guitars now for a while and they both perform really well . .
Congrats for this video! Sound, Camera, Lights are very professional. It was a pleasure to have a look at. Thanx!
Thank you very much! 🙂🙂
A VERY nicely done, THOROUGH exploration of the whole Guitar. I was amazed at how absolutely "Acoustic" the pickup sounded.
They do don't they and a little bit of reverb seems to emulate body resonance . . 🙂🙂
Thank you for a fantastic review of this guitar. I am about to order one and after watching and listening to your review I can't wait to get it.
Glad I could help! 😊😊
Thank God you showed us how to open the boxes I never would have figured it out on my own
well at least you admit it . . 😂
Thanks, I hope yamaha updates the guitar models mic and pickup, DSP, and effects including delay.
Technology has gotten so much better with the fender acoustisonic and others and smartphones being more powerful than laptops.
Now is the time for a major upgrade, including the latest bluetooth codecs, and built in speaker system updated electronics, hiss reduction, and computer models for different guitars etc.
Way more presets and customizations are possible, even with sharing users settings.
Along with built in drums and backing tracks for practice, higher quality headphone dac and amp, and 2 of them.
That's quite a request list . .
Well if you think about it my fernandes nomad from 20 yrs ago does almost all of this? Amp/pickup/mic modeling, drum machine, effects. Does it sound as good as this for acoustic settings and in general? Definitely not but point is technology is there. I will also be waiting on a Yama update to this machine it’s been untouched for at least 10 yrs if I recall.
This review and the one you did for the nylon version of this guitar are absolutely brilliant. Thanks a lot.
Glad you liked it! thank you very much . . 😊
Love it. I'm a huge Yamaha fan, drums, strings, brass. Owned 3 acoustics, best inexpensive guitar you can buy..IMO!!
Totally agree!
I got a $130 yamaha classical and I find myself playing it more than my prs, my Ibanez and my strat combined lol they make fantastic instruments
I loved the way you demonstrated the whole thing. And videography was wonderful. Thumbs up. Cheers
Thank you very much! I am still learning the videography so that's really nice of you to say . . 🙂
Thank you very much for your efforts in producing such an excellent review. After watching, I'm definitely going to buy one of these.
Glad I could help! 😊😊
Best review ever. Thanks!
Wow, thanks! 😊😃
Best purchase ever. Only two things: 1) Does not sound good at all with acrylic nails. 2) The pieces you can separate are not solid after a few years screwing and unscrewing.
Interesting . . the screws feel really solid from new . . I'll have to watch that . .
@@guitar-academy Yeah the removable part becomes a bit shaky after a few years. And not sure if it's weather or what other reason, in several occasions one of the screws gets completely stuck for a few days even though its not holding the piece. But anyway, I love the guitar.
@@AC-he8ln Thanks for that information. I'll worn people about it in a future video . . 🙂
The playing, the on-point features, and the mixing were excellent. Thanks!
Thank you very much . . 🙂
Best review of this guitar on the web!
Thank you very much 😊😊
Thanks for the review. I own the nylon string wide neck version. LOVE it!! I plan to sell my Taylor 710CE and buy one of the steel string SLG versions. The onboard sound quality/versatility of these guitars is amazing. You can play straight through a PA system or enhance the sound through computer apps. Not to mention the difference in price. Who has $3,000 - $5,000 to spend on an acoustic guitar that can provide the same sound quality?
Yes I agree with you. If you record or would like to record your guitar it's a challenge getting the sound just right with microphones but the Yamaha makes it easy. 😊😀
I'm far to much a traditionalist (old guy) to give this guitar a chance. That being said I can appreciate it for what it is.
🙂
Wow what an amazing piece of work. The most in-depth informative beautiful and relaxing video.
Thank you
Thank you very much! 😊
Its a great guitar. I have the nylon also. My constant companion at night.
🙂
The onley use i have for mine is to practice quietly, and in that mather it doesn't have to sound like my Martin...great solution.
😊
Very thorough review. The sound of this guitar is very nice.
Thank you kindly! 😊😃
Great review! So glad I found your channel today!!
thank you very much . . 😊😃
Sir I really love the way u teach us. From ur video I start learning guitar. N thank u alot .
Thank you very much . . . . 🙂
Thanks for reviewing the hole guitar!
thank you very much . . . 🙂🙂
Fantastic review, thank you so much. I'm probably going to get one to start playing guitar.
Have fun! 🙂🙂 . . but as a first guitar, I'd suggest something cheaper to start with . . but that's just me
Fantastic review and I really enjoyed your playing. Informative and nice to listen to.
Glad you enjoyed it, thank you very much 😊😃
Stunning instrument, stunning and skillful playing - great quality. Thanks for sharing.
Thank you very much . . . 🙂🙂
Thank you for uploading it. I am acoustic guitar geek but I could know silent guitar much better and found interesting.
no problem, thank you . . 🙂
Hi, Indeed a fantastic review and demo. Thanks! This guitar seems so amazing 'versatile'. I'm surprised by the sustain even with the lack of 'wood around'. Your style of playing is in top harmony with this guitar. Thanks for sharing and I hope you enjoy this fine instrument to the full. Greetings.
It is a different looking but beautiful sounding instrument . . Thank you very much for your comments . . very uplifting 🙂🙂
Freaking AWESOME! Beautiful and very unique. Thanks for sharing.
My pleasure! thank you . . 🙂
Brilliantly played and explained. Well done
Thank you kindly! 😊😃
I heard Lee Ritenour playing one. It sounded great! I saw Nathan East playing the silent bass with fourplay. That bass sounded great! Yamaha’s silent series are great! Little pricey, but good. If you can get pass the looks, you’ll be fine.😌
Yeah! agreed . . the guitars are cheep compared to the violins and violas though the SV-255 is £1500 . . ouch !
Thank you very much for this outstanding review. You covered everything beautifully and now I know I want to purchase one myself. "The Troubled Heart" was just beautiful too. It's impressive how good the tone on this guitar is. Liked and subscribed!
I'm glad it was helpful and thank you for the like and sub . . here's how to play 'the troubled hear' if you're interested th-cam.com/video/LCCNs5pvYRA/w-d-xo.html
@@guitar-academy Thank you so much! This is wonderful. I am just checking out the tutorial now, registered for the Fingerstyle course, etc. I am looking forward to the learning and being able to play this lovely song. It is so good of you to freely share your talent and instruction this way. I really appreciate it.
@@crazyoldcatman318 No problem . . it's my pleasure to teach . . thank you 😊😊
i have the slg200s and its a great guitar, love it
🙂
Hello I want to buy this guitar but still I cant be sure if i can adjust the volume like i want because i am living an apartment and my neighbors may be disturbed.Could you help me about this how was your experince ?
Awesome review and wonderful playing thanks for the effort 🤙🏽
Thank you kindly! 😊😊
Sounds really lovely, and thank you for such a detailed (and calm...) overview of this instrument.
I have one question just out of curiosity; do you think one of these guitars would be a reasonable choice for someone looking to pick up guitar playing in general? Especially if they aren't sure whether they really want to play acoustic or electric.
Thank you very much 😃
That's a good question . . Honestly, all I can do is give you things to consider, the decision will be very personal to yourself and depend on you budget, music tastes and determination to learn guitar. If you have the money, then this is a good middle ground as it has a similar feel to an electric guitar. However, normally I would suggest getting a cheaper guitar to start with, then you can buy an electric and an acoustic. I've been teaching for over 30 years and it's amazing how many times I've taught people who like to listen to one style of music but prefer to play another . . 🤔
@@guitar-academy That is a good point! I haven't played an instrument for almost 20 years, and never a guitar, but lately feel inspired to tinker. Just for my own enjoyment. Initially I was convinced I wanted to get an electric, but I've been a bit fascinated by other alternatives as I was researching.
But you are quite right I suppose; I could probably get two decent instruments for the price of one of these, if I wasn't happy with my first choice!
Thank you.
@@Mythricia1988 I really hope you have a great time with any guitar. I think it's a great way to relax and they recon if you learn an instrument it can help prevent Alzheimer's later in life . . 😃
thank you for the review it was excellent and your playing is just wonderful
Thank you kindly! 🙂🙂
Very good review, I have the nylon version and will now go for this one.
They'll make a nice matching set and give you a choice of sounds and feels to go between . . . 🙂🙂
I saw this guitar on Star Trek TOS (1966)
🙂
Thank you so much for the clear and precise review. I wish all the reviews about guitars were so accurate as yours. I'll have a look to see if you have a review of the nylon string model for I'm thinking about buying it.
Glad it was helpful! The nylon one is one the way and the review will go up in the next couple of weeks . . 🙂🙂
Thank you so much, as your review on this guitar is by far the best that I've seen. Please could you advise on which strings to use as I find the originals to heavy and hard as I am 69 and trying to learn a few chords. 10/10 for your clear review.
Thank you very much for your encouraging comment. I like light strings which are easy to press down and a go between 'Elixir Polyweb Extra Light Acoustic' and 'Adagio extra light acoustic strings'. 😊😃
Absolutely excellent review! GAS!!
Thank you kindly! 🙂🙂
I honestly can't believe the sound coming from a guitar without a body. lol Does it take long or very had to learn finger picking? I just started to play when I was young, but gave it up. I only knew chording, no bar chords or anything straight chords. As I said on your nylon video, I will say it again, you play beautiful. I could listen to you play all day and never want you to stop. Thank you.
That's really nice of you, thank you very much. 😊😊
Finger picking isn't hard at all. I've written a free fingerstyle guitar course. It's completely free, here's the play lists for book 1 and 2.
Book 1 th-cam.com/play/PLIQJcXCYbgO2q9hDUBT0E5z1JZDk3bowI.html
Book 2 th-cam.com/play/PLIQJcXCYbgO1uyExG1qS2puZ6aC11cA-M.html
Excellente! A superbly enjoyable video demonstration of another Yamaha icon.
Always liked these since I tried one some years back, but for some reason, it hasn't materialised.... Yet.
That could change. Or I might just make one.
.
I have to agree with someone else here, Your (exquisite) playing style sounds well at home on the SLG200S.
Wow . . thank you very much . . 🙂🙂
Thank you for the lovely review
Thank you and thanks for watching! 😃
Excellent in depth review!
Thank you kindly! 🙂🙂
Nice review. Can you hear through the headphones if you are plugged into the amp as well? I am struggling with monitors and this seems like an easy solution. I get that I won't get a mix (vocals, bass other), but at least my guitar would be in my ear.
Is a great guitar. I removed the molded urea saddle and replaced with a bone saddle and that helped balance out the bass and all strings with improved clarity.
I've already replaced the strings but I will play with it a bit first before changing anything else so I can better judge the standard guitar. 🙂 But it's nice to know the bone saddle is an improvement in advance. 🙂
Thank you for that tip, I will change mine asap
perfect guitar，just got it recently，love it
🙂
Great review. I’ve had spinal fusion surgery and I’m looking for the lightest guitar I can find. Amazon says it weighs 4.6 pounds. Is it a featherweight when you’re wearing a strap or more like a millstone?
It's very light, and the fact that the body is thin and small means you don't have to reach your arms over which might help you. 😊
@@guitar-academy Thanks for the response. I think I'm sold on it, I just need to get the money together. :)
@@JustinTrudeau1971Yeah, sadly they are expensive 🤔🤔
How loud is it if you strum it with a pick when it’s not plugged into anything? I live in an apartment building and I’d love to be able to practice without disturb my neighbors.
@@JustinTrudeau1971 The guitar isn't silent as the name suggests but there's no way you'd disturb your neighbors with one of these. You can hear them as you play of if you're in the same room but I doubt you could hear it through a wall or door. 😊
With the nylon string the volume level changes when you're using the effects. Does the same happen to the steel strings?
That is strange 🤔 Not on this one . . the volume stays very stable . . 🙂
Yes, please test the nylon string variant!
Will do! 🙂
Would this guitar sound as nice plugged into an acoustic amplifier or an electric guitar amp, or is it more for the way your using it? It sounds wonderful and I’m sure your playing it doesn’t hurt. Really enjoyed this video, cheers.
Good suggested test . . I'll have to try for you. I think I might have to do a follow up video at some point anyway . . 🙂
what does it sound like not plugged in? I'm guessing like an electric not plugged in...?
very solid review. Thanks man
No problem! thanks for watching . . 🙂
Great review! Will it sound great using a Fender GTX 50 amp?
Thank you . . I can't answer that honestly because I don't use Fender amps, but maybe someone else will read the question who does . . 🙂🙂
An absolutely excellent review!! Thank you!!
Thank you . . . 🙂
Hello, does the sticker on the back have the year of manufacture of the guitar?
Not directly, but there's a serial number that might have the year of manufacture encoded into it. 🤔
@@guitar-academy I went to the yamaha website and I can't find how to know the year of manufacture
@@shai2875Sorry I don't know either 🤔
and i'm not the only one who wondering and waiting for the part that this guitar is REALLY SILENT.
But thank you for the review man, great review love the picture quality, per parts details, sound.
and it was yamaha who gave the name 'silent' for this guitar.
Thank you . . 🙂
very good review, I'm planning to get one when funds are in.
Thank you very much 🙂🙂 The Yam is a good choice!
Well done sir. What string gauge and brand did you replace with? I have one now and the strings are a bit heavy.
Thank you . . the strings I've got on it now are Adagio extra light 10's 😊
Wicked playing... Lovely guitar... I like all Yamahas...
Thank you . . . they make great instruments . . 🙂
Does anyone know when a new guitar of this model is scheduled to be released
They haven't released a new one for years and they aren't saying anything about a new version. But they might have something going on in the background . . 🤔
great review , thank you , i have an older version of this guitar and the pickup as just stopped working for some reason , but its been brilliant , debating wether to try getting it fixed or buying a new one
that's a shame . . if it is just the pickup, they can be replaced easily enough. unfortunately, If the electrics have gone it could be expensive. 😒
I.ll see can i find someone to take a look at it . see what can be done . thank you for replying and advice . much appreciated 👍
@@bbfeign1 That really depends where you live . . most countries have musical instrument shops or luthiers who could fix something like that . .
Would really appreciate it if I could have some questions answered.
1. Is it neck heavy, i.e. does it neck dive?
2. Where is it made?
3. Does it take acoustic guitar strings or electric guitar strings?
Thanks in advance.
yes it does neck dive slightly. China. Acoustic . .
@@guitar-academy Thank you.
@@GoldenToothBrush sorry for the short message . . I can't keep up at the moment . . 😊
@@guitar-academy No worries at all mate, I appreciate it.
Beautiful review, many thanks
Thank you very much . . 😊
Clearly there is alot that goes into music and playing styles. Which did you like more; the steel or nylon ?
After playing both guitars for a while I definitely prefer the nylon strung version. I can't get used to the sound the steel strum one produces. 😊😊
You show plugging this into the line-in on the mixer. The guitar is almost certainly a Hi-Z instrument level output. That may have contributed to the hiss and possibly made the sound quality suffer, as the mixer would be expecting a much higher signal level. I would be curious if there is a difference if plugged into an instrument input or through a DI box.
It is a standard line out on the guitar 1k ohm impedance and the input on the desk is switchable. It sound a lot worse through Hi-Z because of the impedance mismatch, but good thought . . 🙂
Hi, great video! Quite certainly the best one. I am thinking on buying one. Significant time has passed since you made this video. What are your impressions now and how does it sound through headphones? Cheers!
Glad it was helpful! I've had it for a month now and I really love it. The headphones sound is very good but all round I can''t get the chime you expect from a steel strung guitar being strummed. The sound is very rich, almost too rich . . but as I use the guitar virtually exclusively for fingerstyle it really sounds nice to me. . . I hope this helps 🙂
How does the silence of this guitar compare to the silence of a typical solid-body electric guitar, regarding not bothering your neighbors?
it's about the same . .
17:10 ur welcome
name of this diddy? Stuck in my head since i clicked this a week ago.
I really want to know the name of this song, if it is composed by someone
Thank you for this amazing video
I am planning to buy this guitar can u tell me how good is this guitar for professional recordings and how it's sounds ?
It's good, very good . . If you look at the last half of my Christmas giveaway video it is was recorded on the Yamaha th-cam.com/video/m5Lp0T2LqWM/w-d-xo.html
A great and succinct video. I've always wanted to know how this guitar is made and sounded. Now I know. I find it a bit quacky sounding, almost harpsichord like. I'm not sure if this sounds like this only in the video or if it differs live? Pretty cool nonetheless. Thanks for the time and effort put into making this video. Cheers!!
Thank you . . Glad it was helpful! I agree with you about the sound.
Lots of love from India
lots of love back . . . 🙂
You didn’t find the 200s to buzz on the A and D or any strings for that matter. Mine is less than a day old. I thought it may be the factory strings. I replaced them with ddadario 12s and still buzzes. It does without and with the electronics. Maybe I am playing too hard. I am used to a 90s d28. Thx for reading.
No, I never had a buzz on any of the string on either the N or the S version. If anything more people complain that the action is too high. It could be that the neck isn't straight because that can cause a buzz. I've done a video on lowering the action (which you don't want to do) but the first part of the video shows you how to straighten the neck. th-cam.com/video/QRSAQocR_rY/w-d-xo.html
@@guitar-academy thank you. I will watch again. Need to get a steel ruler. Cheers.
@@tannertucker22 no problem 😊😊
Wonderful review, well done.
I wsh you would have discussed the nech shape and feel. Also the size and feel of the frets.
You opinion of the factory set up would be nice also. I respect your opinion.
Thank you.
Thank you . . I haven't finished yet so I will bare your questions in mind. I'll be doing a review soon of how I've found the guitar over time and comparing it with it's brother (the SLG200N) . .🙂
Very cool, thank you
The guitar looks and sounds fabulous.
But it's all about playability as you know.
You play wonderfully by the way
@@geneschulp8598 It does play really nicely, but after a couple of hours the top wing sticks into your ribs. But I've 3D printed a round edge to help prevent it digging in.
Hi man! Thank you very much fir the review. The video itself is also very good quality, and I'm really considering this guitar now.
I also have a question regarding the video itself.) What gear do you use? I mean camera, lens and lights like here - 6:24. Thanks!
Thank you very much . . the camera is a canon 90d with a stock 18-135 lens, and I just use cheap eBay LED panel lights. At 6:24 I backlit the guitar and under exposed it by 2 stops . . I hope this helps. 😊
@@guitar-academy wow, for a kit lens and just LED lights that’s stunning.) Thanks!
@@random-style wow thank you very much . . 😊😊
THANKS, GCH!
thank you too 😊😃
Thank you for your excellent review... it was very thorough. Can you tell me how the action is on this guitar?
It is set fairly low at about 2.5mm at the 12th fret with room to take it lower at the saddle . .
@@guitar-academy Thank You! That is good to know. I have bought guitars online, the Lava Me 2, for example, where it was indicated that the action was set at 2.5mm ... only to find out after getting it, that the action was 1/4 inch+ at the 12th fret. Thanks again!
@@ooochakalaka ouch . . that's pretty much unplayable . . 😒
Hey GCH Guitar Academy! Thank you so much for this thorough and meticulous review! I was wondering, when you plug in headphones directly, do you find yourself turning the volume all the way up to hear the guitar? I find that below ~70% volume I don't hear anything from the headphones. Thanks
No I didn't have to do that. Perhaps you should try different headphones to check there isn't a problem with the provided ones. I use my big headphones now and they also work well but are more comfortable to use . .
@@guitar-academy Thanks for replying so quick! I see that you've replied to most of the comments here. I imagine that takes a bit of time and diligence so I appreciate that. Just one clarifying question: if you look at 7:48, the volume knob has 7 "ticks," if you will; when plugging headphones directly into the "PHONES" output, at what "tick" do you begin to hear sound? Also, at this point in the video the volume knob is at "tick" 5. Is this the volume you generally play at (specifically when using headphones)? Thanks
@@user-jj9gi1ci5n On any acoustic guitar I very rarely go above 7 on the volume because I don't want the risk of signal distortion and the higher the volume the greater the chance of the signal being clipped.
When playing normally on headphones I don't take the volume much above 5 because it gets too load, 6 is about right. Also remember when using headphones that you have to turn the guitar on and turn the tuner off, the headphone socket isn't a switching socket.
@@guitar-academy Thanks again!
@@user-jj9gi1ci5n 😊
@GHC Guitar Academy I've been searching about reviews of this guitar, because I consider to buy it. And I have to say, your video is the best! Generaly, I think you are great player. Also, I have subscribe to your channel. Thank you 👍
Glad I could help! thank you and thanks for the sub 😊😃
@@guitar-academy yes, you did. I finaly bought this guitar, and its amazing. I will just try to put new bone saddle because the action is just a little bit too high for me.
@@antonio.lovric Yes, that's a common thing. I've done a video to help if you need it th-cam.com/video/QRSAQocR_rY/w-d-xo.html
@@guitar-academy I watched that video before. And I already order new bone saddle. I think this guitar will be perfect when I put a little bit lower bone saddle.
agreed 😃😃
Hi, Thanks for the great review. I was wondering if lighter strings had much impact on the tone? The strings on mine came with may be 11 and I can only play it an hour max! Lighter strings might help but thought it may impact the quality of the sound was my dilemma. Thanks in advance.
Good question . . I like light strings because I go between electric and acoustic a lot and I like them to feel similar. Standard this guitar has too much bass and so putting lighter lighter strings on actually improves the tone. I have 10s on now and I might even experiment with 9's I hope that's helpful 🙂🙂
Thanks a lot. Just ordered some D'addario EJ15 10s. Need to experiment :!)
@@tgmyladoor 🙂
great video,i love my silent guitar.
Thank you . . me too . . 😃
I wish i had that kind of guitar. I have a cheap one (30$) and i bought it 5 years ago and still using it now 😂
Btw nice review!!
Thank you . . 🙂
They can be surprisingly good for the money can't they 🙂
What do you use on your nails to get them so nice and long without breaking?
Nothing, but they brake all the time. It can be a real pain if they brake in the middle of a recording job or music commission. When I started playing fingerstyle professionally I put 'stop n grow' on because I bit my nails badly, but it stopped me biting my nails (it tastes really nasty) 🙂.