Style 🤝 Perfect Out of the Woods 🤝 Two Ghosts Wildest Dreams 🤝 Him Cardigan 🤝 Falling (even tho Wildest Dreams wasn't for him he was there when she wrote it. Go listen to "Him") THIS TWO ARE THE FREAKING MUSIC INDUSTRY. They're definitely amazing songwriters. They used what they felt and lived while they're were together and created masterpieces. 👏👏👏👏
Perfect talks about things that they both like about each other and how they’re perfect for eachother. “And if you like midnight driving with the windows down. And if you like going places we can't even pronounce. If you like to do whatever you've been dreaming about. Then baby, you're perfect. Baby, you're perfect” Style again, talks about things that they like about each other and how they’re so perfect that they would never go out of style “You got that James Dean daydream look in your eye - I got that red lip classic thing that you like - you got that long hair, slick back, white t shirt - I got that good girl fit/faith and a tight little skirt - and when *we* go crashing down we come back everytime. Cause we never go out of style, we *never* go out of style.”
They are friends. The song "I wish you would" in 1989, Taylor said she wrote it after she and an exbf (harry of course) got to be friends after the relationship was over. She said that it was the first time she was comfortable enough to talk with the person about why everything ended. So basically they were in good terms even before 1989 was released. And they were seen a couple of times in parties with the same group of friends. But they are both so damn private 😂
@@stefcoll2972 I really wish people would stop shipping them. They've both moved on and matured. It's just as annoying as the people who ship Taylor and Karlie. Taylor and Karlie both had relationships during the time people said they probably dated. Like no. And they aren't even friends anymore I'm pretty sure, because Karlie is friends with Scooter and his wife.
I love that the water in Harry's video is coming out the piano when he plays it. He can stop the water at any time but he chooses to keep playing and by the time he stops playing its too late. The room is already filled with water. In TS video the water is also coming from the piano and she chooses to leave, and ends up in a worse situation ( in the middle of the ocean) Sometimes there is no right or wrong decision and things are just meant to happen.
It's just like Peter Pan(Harry) lives in Neverland, and Wendy(Taylor) lives in the real world. Instead, Wendy didn't stayed in Neverland hence the combination of lyrics of their songs, and their music videos.
Here’s a thought what if the waterfall from Taylor’s piano is falling in Harry’s room and then he starts to drown . It’s fits so perfect that at 2:26 when Harry started singing Taylor looked down as if she could hear him singing(or crying for help) . So maybe she goes to save him but she doesn’t find him and they both start to drown. Taylor tries to live , but Harry excepts his defeat and is ready to die . But fate saves them both . Taylor comes back home and because she couldn’t find Harry she think her friend didn’t make it . And the sweater is the only thing that reminds her of him .So she wears it as a tribute to him . Wow now that’s a beautiful story. I would love to see a short film like this....
I had this thought also! I also think it’s important to note that Taylor’s water is spilling away from her, a waterfall. Whereas Harry’s is pouring out from the piano around him and becoming all consuming. Then when she goes into the piano bench she is close to drowning also…a symbol for not being able to go back to harry.
May God bless you and your family and help you Give your life to Jesus Christ and repent. I pray that God will lead on the path to Jesus Christ and send the Holy Spirit to be your helper. I pray this in the mighty name of Jesus Christ I pray Amen! Jesus Christ loves you. Give your life to Jesus Christ and ask for forgiveness for ALL OF YOUR SINS. Even the ones committed in the past and repent. He’s coming soon. Please pray and repent.
@@ansleybrooke4915 I think it's a song about moving on, if it's about the assault, what does she mean by the "the flower that we'd grown together died of thirst". Taylor and the dj doesn't seem to be close, or in a friendly relationship
It's like two sides of a story cardigan: she's in love with him and tells him how much she wants them to be together again falling: he's scared that what if she doesn't want him back and he falls again for her with no way out this time
It also looks like the water falling from her piano is filling his piano/room. She also swims out of the water while he drowns. They make it both back to their pianos, where they find each other. She climbs back into her piano while he drowns.
At 2:28, this is just so clever and soft !! Taylor looking down and seeing Harry drawing so she went to help him but he was already drawn and she couldn't find him...
Omg there is a paper plane in the cardigan video it seels through the piano seat with her then she goes in the water (plane like the necklace she and harry shared)
IMAGINE THEY PERFORMED THIS AT THE GRAMMYS. BOTH OF THEM FACING EACH OTHER WHILE PLAYING THE PIANO. AND RAIN POURING OVER THEM. BRAINS WOULD EXPLODE. WIGS WOULD BE SNATCHED. THE MUSIC INDUSTRY WOULD BRAKE. THEIR VOICES WOULD CURE DEPRESSION. Edit: BOTH ARE PERFORMING AT THE GRAMMYS 🤩👀👀
I want them to both be on their own turntables, and in the beginning they're facing away from each other and then slowly the pianos circle and they face each other when H belts "And I get the feeling you'll never leave me agaiiiiin" *cries in Haylor* (the friendship ship)
The water is an euphemism for depression . Harry lets it consume him and accepts it instead of fighting. Taylor fights and breaks free, and becomes a stronger person in the process. Who will you be?
Judging by 1989 I think their relationship was too serious for them to be able to collab. But then again, there is this theory going around the fandom that Harry is the secret co-writer of exile and that they've written it about their previous relationship
the fact that kendall and harry are still friends even tho they are exes, why can't tay and harry too😭, me and my ex are friends tho lmao, i want tay and harold to collab af
Adiba Tahsin basically the songs betty and cardigan are based on the same sequence of events but from two different perspectives! so betty is from the perspective of ‘james’ and cardigan is from the perspective of ‘betty’ :)
so the teenage trilogy is basically a story of james-betty-and the other woman. cardigan is from Betty's pov, August from the other woman's pov and Betty is from James' pov. Well, falling by harry styles is I think about cheating on someone so it can also be applied to James' pov
UPDATE AFTER GRAMMYS: THEY TALKED. THEY FREAKING INTERACTED AFTER YEARS OUT FROM THE PUBLIC IVE RESURRECTED. CAN WE GET HIM NOW FOR TAYLORS VERSION OF 1989 edit: this kinda blew up ig
I'm not shipping Taylor and Harry, I'm shipping the characters they played on Falling MV and Cardigan MV because how powerful the connection of this two songs in terms of lyrics, context, music video and the artist who wrote it. Damn, maybe H and Tay did really had a collaboration secretly.
I kind of wonder if this is kind of her feelings after he did this song. The change the ending as if he was trying to not be Peter losing Wendy aka Taylor. She knew he would come back to her but it is too late. The memories were bittersweet. But she doesn't look back in pain, but more reminiscence. With her love for Joe she has healed and is ok with him being her past, but acknowledging his missing her and not being over her. I could be wrong but just some of the impressions I got.
It already made sense. James in "Betty" just puts a bunch of excuses on why he cheated and says that he is just 17 and doesn't know anything, he is immature, while Betty in "Cardigan" shows growth and maturity from the experience and says that she knew everything when she was young. This parallels to Peter pan when Peter decides to not grow up and stay in Neverland while Wendy decides to go back to earth and grow, therefore he loses her for not wanting to grow up, just like James lost Betty.
Nice theory! but I just meant Peter loosing Wendy in the sense of the music video, Taylor looks like Wendy coming back from Neverland - the dust and all, both belong in this magical music world, and Harry looking like Peter Pan in the context of the imagery - but in reality he really ended up loosing Taylor.
Around 2:29 Harry says "I get a feeling that you'd never need me again" and she looks down and follows where the voice is coming from. Which might mean that she do need him. She ends up inside water while Harry is already submerged under water. While she struggles to save herself, he lays there as if expecting her complains and his mistakes. She suddenly finds some balance and save herself. On the other hand Harry stays sitting on the floor while water fill up his room. In the end, Taylor goes back to her room hoping he'd come back to her but he doesn't. Then Taylor looks at the cardigan which could be there token of love and realises that they'd never be together ever again but their memories would be safe and sound. Note : These are just some thoughts that came to my head while watching this. I happen to love the mind of a creater of this mashup! Beautiful!
your average commenter taylor confirmed that she and harry are still friends. In recent interview Harry praised taylor’s songwriting. idk about joe jonas but yeah i think they’re friends too.
na .19 Taylor Said In Burning questions with ellen degeneres that she and Joe laughs off the fact that taylor roasted him in 2008, so they’re still friends 😊
@@Cherie_by I personally don't think the names have to do with Ryan and Blake's kids. I know a lot of people think it's about them, but I think it would be weird to base a love triangle names based off of three children who are siblings. Plus we still don't know the 3rd kids name
I am not saying the song is about Harry styles, all these small-small things are details that she picked up from her past relations. Also, her whole album is a reflection on personal stories that also in together make up a fictional story. So, James, the daughters name is just that one string that reflects so many aspect in her life. It’s like no. 13. It has multiple significance. I have so many theories that I feel are not just random details like in song Betty, James telling his as 17 was the same age of Harry when they first went out. There are other lyrics where there is a reflection from I knew you were trouble song.
This and Style/Perfect mashups are gonna kill me if it'll actually be performed by the two legendary songwriters. This is like a glimpse if ever they'd co-write.
"Sometimes soulmates aren't supposed to stay together. Sometimes they go through a part of life and move on. You'll know who that person is when they don't leave."
@@christineharris7950 The whole Folklore and Evermore era is extremely suspicious 🤔 😳 👀, she is still emerged in the woods, it's like she never made it out.
@@christineharris7950 yuh, hear me out: y'know why Taylor said wb is joe? cuz she just didn't wanna get hated on *AGAIN* I mean, thInk AbOUt It!! can someone like Joe Alwyn, who Isn't EvEn A sOngwRItER write songs AS AMAZING AS betty and *exile* ?!?! ABSOLUTELY NOT!! remember how she also said "musical heroes"? can someone like Joe, who dOEsnt EvEn dO mUsIc be someone's "musical hero"? NO
@@ninni2824 yuh, hear me out: y'know why Taylor said wb is joe? cuz she just didn't wanna get hated on *AGAIN* I mean, thInk AbOUt It!! can someone like Joe Alwyn, who Isn't EvEn A sOngwRItER write songs AS AMAZING AS betty and *exile* ?!?! ABSOLUTELY NOT!! remember how she also said "musical heroes"? can someone like Joe, who dOEsnt EvEn dO mUsIc be someone's "musical hero"? NO
I think cardigan is the answer song for falling. There are a lot of similar things. Taylor says "I knew you'd haunt all of my "what-ifs"" Harry says many "what if" Harry says "I'm falling again" Taylor says "I knew you'd come back to me"
In other parts, he says "I'm well aware I write too many songs about you" "It kills me cause I know we run out of things we can say" Taylor wrote a lot of songs about Harry and these days we can't find a song about Harry so he think they have nothing more they can say Taylor loves Joe so Harry think you'll never need me
@@にゃ-s3l I honestly wanna believe that you're right, I really do, I'm a HUGE Haylor shipper, but the truth hurts that Falling is actually about Camille Rowe 😒
Let's take it this way. Harry's thoughts are about today where they're not together anymore whereas Taylor's about when they were together. So the water means thoughts which saves her but drowns him.
apparently the water is hatred by people and one took it into them and made something beatiful and one went through the storm with it and came out CLEAN
Harry - What am I now? What am I now? What if I'm someone I don't want around? I'm falling again, I'm falling again, I'm falling What if I'm down? What if I'm out? What if I'm someone you won't talk about? I'm falling again, I'm falling again, I'm falling Taylor - I knew you'd haunt all of my what-ifs ~This mashup was meant to be~
This is a beautiful work of art. It’s clear the amount of emotion and hurt poured into these songs by Taylor and Harry. What’s crazy about it is how much they parallel one another. Tragic but beautiful.
I’m kinda sad, it’s obvious there isn’t any bad blood between and they are on good terms but I’m still seeing some directioners hating on Taylor. Honestly, it’s been years I’m a directioners as well but some of them need to grow up. Edit: I’ve seen some Swifties insulting Harry, when his fans were hating on Taylor. I just want to say; We don’t claim them.
@Daniela - That kinda goes without saying, there’s definitely some Swifties who only like Harry but they have no reason to just like directioners. We don’t claim them.
Beautiful mashup! Never been a haylor shipper but I love them both musically. As a Harry’s big fan, Falling MV is what came into my mind when I first saw Cardigan MV. Imagine the powerful music they could make together 😳😳
I like how this seems similar because it's a post break up song and they are bith playing piano. One is a piano waterfall, representing letting go of a past ex, and the other is pouring water in the room, represent the guilt the other feels for knowing they've hurt their past lover. It just works so well!
The reason these videos match up so well is because it was done on purpose. The song Falling is about Taylor and she responded back to him with Cardigan. They did this once before with Style and Perfect. Like me, the artist CosmicMashups noticed the obvious relationship between the songs and put this mashup together so the rest of you could figure it out too.
TAYLOR SWIFT: THE ERAS MASHUP
- A Mashup of 30+ Songs from Various Albums
- th-cam.com/video/SMsHaW-TmYw/w-d-xo.html
The piano and the water scene is so poetic in this video. What saves her drowns him.
NuNchie whoa 😮
Really wise picked words
Wow
your comment is really beautiful wow
🤯
An amazing fact is that folklore was released on one direction's 10th anniversary and fine line was released on taylor swift's 30th birthday.
Ikr
10 : 30 = 1 : 3 = 13 lmao
@@atlf3357 omg, that's so true
wait whats
@@yakisieras9468 ya that's true
I'm gonna pretend this is an actual collaboration
Me too
Ofc
Me to
Me too😔
Same
Im not a shipper but I have to say that an actual collab between this two would definitely break the internet AND the universe
Agree
how can you be a shipper when they've already dated lol
@@zaixn4131 in the sense that I want them back together lol not that
I love ur PFP
@@ReggiesVersion thaaanks😚
The only difference that Taylor saves herself by clinging on to the piano while Harry accepts his fate and drowns in solitude…
He doesn’t drown. If you watch the beginning scene is actually the end where he survives it.
this comment hurts
ouch
AEIOU15 not really tho, the first scene implies that he keeps drowning over and over again
@@samaloai2510 now this is new..thank you for the new perspective, this says so much more
It's like the waterfall from Taylor's piano was falling down into Harry's room.
Omaigod yes please
Yeees...i also thought of this 😢💔
this is so good
i thought of this too.
blessed comment
if floklore and fineline were real people, they would be best friends
I love this comment 😭❤️😭❤️😭❤️
They would probably be married already!!🤭
@@hannahstyles8848 😭😭 sometimes your heart needs more time to accept what your mind already knows 😭😭
@@BlondynCh that was really deep wow
as louis would say: ObViOsLy
Anyone get Rose and Jack vibes with Harry drowing and Taylor holding on to the piano
Never thought about that but it matches perfectly!!
Yes me 😭
Oh my days!!! Yes I’ve just realised
Hell ya i just realized it now!!!
hdjhdjsk THIS COMMENT
Lady's and gentleman's you're not watching an ordinary mashup, you're watching 5 grammy nominations at the same time
✨✨✨✨
Yazz
👏👏👏👏👏
Yesss
How?? Please explain 🙏🏻
Then: Style & Perfect
Now: Falling & Cardigan
😭❤️❤️
😭😭😭😭
UNDERRATED COMMENT,IM CRYING
miss them ...
they are soooooo much mature now
i swear harry and taylor are one of the artists who'd never go out of style
Unintended pun😏
yes my two favourites 🥰
LOL
A h a h a h a h a . . .
TOO MANY PUNS BYE-
Style 🤝 Perfect
Out of the Woods 🤝 Two Ghosts
Wildest Dreams 🤝 Him
Cardigan 🤝 Falling
(even tho Wildest Dreams wasn't for him he was there when she wrote it. Go listen to "Him")
THIS TWO ARE THE FREAKING MUSIC INDUSTRY. They're definitely amazing songwriters. They used what they felt and lived while they're were together and created masterpieces. 👏👏👏👏
Where is wildest dreams and him available ?
woman 🤝 exile
yeah she apparently started wildest dreams as a song about harry but then changed it
You did NOT say two ghosts-
Perfect talks about things that they both like about each other and how they’re perfect for eachother.
“And if you like midnight driving with the windows down. And if you like going places we can't even pronounce. If you like to do whatever you've been dreaming about. Then baby, you're perfect. Baby, you're perfect”
Style again, talks about things that they like about each other and how they’re so perfect that they would never go out of style
“You got that James Dean daydream look in your eye - I got that red lip classic thing that you like - you got that long hair, slick back, white t shirt - I got that good girl fit/faith and a tight little skirt - and when *we* go crashing down we come back everytime. Cause we never go out of style, we *never* go out of style.”
Not a haylor shipper. I just want them to be friends because IMAGINE THE MUSIC THE CONTENT THE MAGIC
YES!! 😭 ❤️
TRUEEE YASSS
YESSS PLS
YES! is so powerful!
Then we'll not get awesome outcomes like these...
they are both so powerful,how i wish if they were friends at this time of their lives...
I think they are but they don’t make it obvious cuz ppl will ship them
Lucía Frank it’s like u read my mind
YES I'm always wondering if they're friends...
They are friends. The song "I wish you would" in 1989, Taylor said she wrote it after she and an exbf (harry of course) got to be friends after the relationship was over. She said that it was the first time she was comfortable enough to talk with the person about why everything ended. So basically they were in good terms even before 1989 was released. And they were seen a couple of times in parties with the same group of friends. But they are both so damn private 😂
@@stefcoll2972 I really wish people would stop shipping them. They've both moved on and matured. It's just as annoying as the people who ship Taylor and Karlie. Taylor and Karlie both had relationships during the time people said they probably dated. Like no. And they aren't even friends anymore I'm pretty sure, because Karlie is friends with Scooter and his wife.
I love that the water in Harry's video is coming out the piano when he plays it. He can stop the water at any time but he chooses to keep playing and by the time he stops playing its too late. The room is already filled with water.
In TS video the water is also coming from the piano and she chooses to leave, and ends up in a worse situation ( in the middle of the ocean)
Sometimes there is no right or wrong decision and things are just meant to happen.
in the piano scene taylor was holding onto the piano meaning music was always there for bed when people weren’t
omg thats so smart and deep!!!!
you're brilliant.
Yup.. that’s the Poke... the meant to be’s and the is what it is’s....
OKAY WOW
The fact that these two Mvs are like twins... astonishingly similar to each other
Had they collaborated, TH-cam would have crashed the very moment.
Totally agree!!
for real AHH
fact
Truth 😅
@@burgerpatty I feel like I’ve seen you in some other comment section but I can’t remember if it was you or someone else
Well, Taylor was definitely right for one thing they never go out of style.
Why this comment has only 100 likes 😭
i don't know how to react to this!!! ouch...
Omg 😭😭
and now she meant this by saying "i knew everything when i was young".
💓
It feels like Taylor is a magical fairy in the forest while Harry styles is prince singing on his castle
I can't breathe ❤️❤️
Omg I DONT THINK THIS!!!
NOW I BELIEVE IN HAYLOR (but i believe more in Larry Stylinson hahahaha)
@@nay7973 i beleive in both of them
@@lindavaleriaparischinchill2279 me too, :'D
It's just like Peter Pan(Harry) lives in Neverland, and Wendy(Taylor) lives in the real world. Instead, Wendy didn't stayed in Neverland hence the combination of lyrics of their songs, and their music videos.
Here’s a thought what if the waterfall from Taylor’s piano is falling in Harry’s room and then he starts to drown . It’s fits so perfect that at 2:26 when Harry started singing Taylor looked down as if she could hear him singing(or crying for help) . So maybe she goes to save him but she doesn’t find him and they both start to drown. Taylor tries to live , but Harry excepts his defeat and is ready to die . But fate saves them both . Taylor comes back home and because she couldn’t find Harry she think her friend didn’t make it . And the sweater is the only thing that reminds her of him .So she wears it as a tribute to him . Wow now that’s a beautiful story. I would love to see a short film like this....
I had this thought also! I also think it’s important to note that Taylor’s water is spilling away from her, a waterfall. Whereas Harry’s is pouring out from the piano around him and becoming all consuming. Then when she goes into the piano bench she is close to drowning also…a symbol for not being able to go back to harry.
I wanted to cry🥲
You broke me but I loved it :')
yeah that makes a lot of sense and pov and thats also what i'm thinking
Omggg
Imagine if they both saw this and actually performed this live when it was safe again
Don’t do this to me
Imagine they see this and *collab*
ill die....
Amen
Thats wat i was thinking...
If they collaborated, the power. JUST IMAGINE IT
It would break records!!!
Ah we wish. ❤️
You got 1000 likes iam 1000th like
@@allanpeter6819 oh shit I did get 1k like omg
It would end everyones career
And that particular song will be #1 on billboard chart for ages
@@zt2552 We swifties and harry stans would break all records of streaming🤩♥️💙
In a parallel universe these songs were meant for each other
I bet this universe IS that "parallel universe"
Tbh, I think it is...
@@existance143 I think that too
the number of likes equals 13 i
Amen brother
The way the narratives of these songs fit together so well is just insane.
It’s not an accident 😉
if taylor and harry didn't have so much history, I feel like they could be best friends
they are pretty close. taylor has said that in 2015 even lol
@@laibakazmi6627 When?
They just talked at an awards show they seem like they are in a good place.
They are like friends now and they respect each other. They even had an interaction in the Grammy's this year!
@@laibakazmi6627 When?
Cause of death: Harry Styles and Taylor Swift collaboration.
Lol
I want this song playing in my funeral... Unpopular openion.
Yup...
U immortal??
Haha true
just hear me out, what if they performed this mashup at the grammys together? it would be POWERFUL!
I would die-
Never in a million years lmao
I only wish
@@enesjesty848 gosh I'll die
This would be✨e v e r y t h i n g✨
Why does these sound like falling and cardigan were made for each other 🥺💙✨
Because they were!!
WHY DOES IT FIT SO FUCKING WELL
Exactly!!!
Same with StylexPerfect
ikr
Please don’t swear God wouldn’t like that and there are children here
May God bless you and your family and help you Give your life to Jesus Christ and repent. I pray that God will lead on the path to Jesus Christ and send the Holy Spirit to be your helper. I pray this in the mighty name of Jesus Christ I pray Amen! Jesus Christ loves you. Give your life to Jesus Christ and ask for forgiveness for ALL OF YOUR SINS. Even the ones committed in the past and repent. He’s coming soon. Please pray and repent.
"When I was drowning that's when I could finally breathe"
-Clean by Taylor Swift
That gave me chills
Thanks for the Clean reference😭 Underrated lyrics!!
The song clean isn’t about Harry tho... it’s about her sexual assault case.
@@ansleybrooke4915 I think it's a song about moving on, if it's about the assault, what does she mean by the "the flower that we'd grown together died of thirst". Taylor and the dj doesn't seem to be close, or in a friendly relationship
Cat Swift ☝️ of my favorite songs by her and that line ..... glad to see im not alone 👏🎼🙌
imagine taylor putting a bonus 'style ft. harry styles' track in 1989 re-recording deluxe, i'd genuinely die
omg i am deceased just thinking about it, the internet would break
Besties... I had the same thought. Iam prepared for my funeral.
YES... ISTG I WON'T SURVIVE THAT
i always think about that
I would pass away
Who’s here after that Haylor interaction at the Grammys?? 🥺✨
Wahhh I've been searching for this comment
Me
‘ME ME ME HO HO HO HO’
Meee
ME HE HEE
are the swifties and harries dead this was what i thought when i saw cardigan
Same
um
I thought the exact same thing!!!
SAME OMG
No i noticed that and mentioned it as well😂
It's like two sides of a story
cardigan: she's in love with him and tells him how much she wants them to be together again
falling: he's scared that what if she doesn't want him back and he falls again for her with no way out this time
it fits so well with "I wish you would" she wrote their pov in that song
@@ahya.c yes! she explained it in 1989 concerts as well.
You just said what I didn't have the words to explain properly. Thank you
It also looks like the water falling from her piano is filling his piano/room.
She also swims out of the water while he drowns.
They make it both back to their pianos, where they find each other.
She climbs back into her piano while he drowns.
@@brittanyhopkins5385such a underated replay
Plot twist: this is actually the collaboration, they just didn’t state it as official
I wish that in my wildest dreams ✨
What if they performed this at the grammys oh God I would just die right there
@@anija2767 yes the world would be shock
I wish it was man😢😢
Wish they reunite as friends ❤🥺 and collab
At 2:28, this is just so clever and soft !! Taylor looking down and seeing Harry drawing so she went to help him but he was already drawn and she couldn't find him...
True
It's like titanic movie
Harry drawn himself and saved taylor
Drown* but yesss!
@@roseover340 drowned*
Nevaeh Howell oh haha, yeah.
How did you get that idea🤭 brilliant 🦋
@@roseover340 th-cam.com/video/CwKMkQ2JGgU/w-d-xo.html
It’s like when Harry was drowning the piano floated upwards and saved Taylor who had come to help him but was too late😢
Omg there is a paper plane in the cardigan video it seels through the piano seat with her then she goes in the water (plane like the necklace she and harry shared)
Right when she is going into the initial piano above her on the wall then when she is in the magical place one shows up under the bench 2:18 ish 🤗
Its between 2:43 and 2:44 it just appear very quick and disappear righ after
@@devega2877 it's a part of the dress.
Right?!
IMAGINE THEY PERFORMED THIS AT THE GRAMMYS. BOTH OF THEM FACING EACH OTHER WHILE PLAYING THE PIANO. AND RAIN POURING OVER THEM. BRAINS WOULD EXPLODE. WIGS WOULD BE SNATCHED. THE MUSIC INDUSTRY WOULD BRAKE. THEIR VOICES WOULD CURE DEPRESSION.
Edit: BOTH ARE PERFORMING AT THE GRAMMYS 🤩👀👀
why is this such a good idea omg now i need this wtf
I want them to both be on their own turntables, and in the beginning they're facing away from each other and then slowly the pianos circle and they face each other when H belts "And I get the feeling you'll never leave me agaiiiiin" *cries in Haylor* (the friendship ship)
@@TheMidnightcool you mean
*need* me again?
God stop it I'm crying
they write too many songs about each other.. this is literally a romance converse between the two
I wish they never dated. They could be good friends, and make an amazing song together.
Literally
but their relationship created 1989 album sooo i love them both so much i wish they were close friends rn
They are so horny that time
But Taylor wouldn’t have written a lot of songs like Styles and Out of the Woods.
what I wish too
Gonna tell my kids that this was Jack and Rose
THIS DESCRIPTION IS PERFECT I-
This comment is great
Noooo jack and rose is TAYLOR AND JOE🥵
@@selindakaktaylorsversion3738 ik v all should b happy 4 Tay n Joe, but OUR hAYlOR hEARt hURts thAt's whY wE'RE hERE
PLEASE DONT DO THIS TO ME 😭
The water is an euphemism for depression . Harry lets it consume him and accepts it instead of fighting. Taylor fights and breaks free, and becomes a stronger person in the process. Who will you be?
Your comment made me question my existence 😅
@@chandrikasrinithya9139 no fr 😭😭
+ the Piano is the metaphor for her music/fans.
But Harry doesn't drown!
Actually Harry survives in the music video. The first shot is actually the ending.
2:27-2:34 : That moment when it seemed like a real collab and they could look at each other❤️
Heavenly 💗
Imagine Harry starting to sing this and Taylor coming out of the piano to join while onstage!
Omg omg omg omg
😭
It would be a terrific idea.
Judging by 1989 I think their relationship was too serious for them to be able to collab. But then again, there is this theory going around the fandom that Harry is the secret co-writer of exile and that they've written it about their previous relationship
Omg if that happened the world would have goosebumps
Well it’s been six years since they last dated. And who says exes can’t be friends or in this case, collab? Just imagine the content out of these two.
Idk...they were seen in 2014 at a Hotel party. Maybe they got better at hiding? Taylor sings “I Know Places”.
the fact that kendall and harry are still friends even tho they are exes, why can't tay and harry too😭, me and my ex are friends tho lmao, i want tay and harold to collab af
imagine the haylor moment we would get, IMAGINE THE COLLABS 😭
THE COLLAPSE 😭
hope they perform at the grammys together
Why do tay and harry's song have the perfect mash-up always?
1 simple answer: Haylor is real
Yes is real
bc they never go out of style
Coz they always reply to each other's song
bcs they don’t go out of style
JUST IMAGINE WHAT MAGIC THEY COULD CREATE IF THEY COLLABED 😭
Moral of this video;
Learn how to swim.
😂😂😂
LOL.
Moral of this video:
Water 💦 👁👄👁
Enter Maynard James Keenan
BEST COMMENT
the ‘peter losing wendy’ part when they’re both floating underwater as they let go of the piano... cinematic excellence
Cardigan is Betty's perspective while Falling is james perspective.
Will you please explain! I'm lost here
Adiba Tahsin basically the songs betty and cardigan are based on the same sequence of events but from two different perspectives! so betty is from the perspective of ‘james’ and cardigan is from the perspective of ‘betty’ :)
@@serenamarisa1503 owh okay.thanks
so the teenage trilogy is basically a story of james-betty-and the other woman. cardigan is from Betty's pov, August from the other woman's pov and Betty is from James' pov. Well, falling by harry styles is I think about cheating on someone so it can also be applied to James' pov
Wait that makes a lot of sense
UPDATE AFTER GRAMMYS: THEY TALKED. THEY FREAKING INTERACTED AFTER YEARS OUT FROM THE PUBLIC IVE RESURRECTED. CAN WE GET HIM NOW FOR TAYLORS VERSION OF 1989
edit: this kinda blew up ig
styles ft. harry styles would blow the internet
@@toriljain1659 (Taylor's Version)
Grammy's cameraman knew what he was recording 💀💀
maybe that's the reason 1989 TV was delayed and red TV was put out first instead?👀
When she get MTV award, she said to fans: "I adres you" so maybe. I hope they would sing together.
I get jack and rose vibes when Harry is drowning and taylor is holding onto the piano 😭💔
OH MAY GAWS🙃😭
ME TOO 😭 AND THE FACT IT’S MY FAVOURITE MOVIE I CAN’TT 😭😭
lol yes
YES😭😭
omg wow
*"And I get the feeling that you'll never need me again"*
*"It was all I needed"*
ouch
Can I just say Taylor’s cardigan looks like something Harry would wear😅
i said that as soon as i saw it!! 🙌🏻
Grandpa Styles strikes again
Literally
Exactly
And his outfit looks like something she would wear
I don't usually like mashups..cause they are like so noisy but this is a MASTERPIECE!
Petition for Taylor and Harry to actually do a song together. Anyone else?
LezzzGooo!!!!👾
Yessss please
i say YES but they were exes so it would be a bit awkward
Ya Taylor wrote a song a song for him
Just imagine them preforming this at an award show or something
I'm not shipping Taylor and Harry, I'm shipping the characters they played on Falling MV and Cardigan MV because how powerful the connection of this two songs in terms of lyrics, context, music video and the artist who wrote it. Damn, maybe H and Tay did really had a collaboration secretly.
I kind of wonder if this is kind of her feelings after he did this song. The change the ending as if he was trying to not be Peter losing Wendy aka Taylor. She knew he would come back to her but it is too late. The memories were bittersweet. But she doesn't look back in pain, but more reminiscence. With her love for Joe she has healed and is ok with him being her past, but acknowledging his missing her and not being over her. I could be wrong but just some of the impressions I got.
beautiful theory
Same
i ship fine line and folklore tbh
I'm telling my soul:
THIS IS A COLLABORATION
THIS IS A COLLABORATION
THIS IS A COLLABORATION
THIS IS A COLLABORATION
THIS IS A COLLABORATION
Harry : “I got the feeling that you’ll never need me again”
Taylor : “was all we needed...”
This is Real life's Peter Pan and Wendy Story.
AMEN.
😩😭
I-I.........🧍🏻♀️.......
that fits so well T^T
@@peachesncream7890 I know right. T.T
"i had the feeling you'd never need me again"
"all we needed"
ok you are genius for putting those lines together round of applause.
I KNOW RIGHT
Peter loosing Wendy - makes so sense now!
Omg you are right
Ikr
wHAT 👁️👄👁️
It already made sense. James in "Betty" just puts a bunch of excuses on why he cheated and says that he is just 17 and doesn't know anything, he is immature, while Betty in "Cardigan" shows growth and maturity from the experience and says that she knew everything when she was young. This parallels to Peter pan when Peter decides to not grow up and stay in Neverland while Wendy decides to go back to earth and grow, therefore he loses her for not wanting to grow up, just like James lost Betty.
Nice theory! but I just meant Peter loosing Wendy in the sense of the music video, Taylor looks like Wendy coming back from Neverland - the dust and all, both belong in this magical music world, and Harry looking like Peter Pan in the context of the imagery - but in reality he really ended up loosing Taylor.
I think T.S and H.S fandom should gather up request for them to sing this mash up for once...cuz this is too good that driving me crazy
tbh harry styles falling MV is like the line from Taylor's song Clean.
"When I was drowning that when I could finally breathe"
OMG YAS
Yall....making my mind go places...
😳
oh my !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
@@doesitmatter143 what a marvelous tune
I know most fans hates on her because most are Larry shippers. But if Harry and Taylor would make a duet they would end everyones careers.
Who’s Larry? Harry and?
im a hardcore larry but i love taylor and NEED them to collab
@@lilysann4012 louis tomlinson
@@Ramisa-l2v SAME
@@sophiewoodruff8055 tbh i want a collab between louis and taylor lol 😅
Ok, this fake mash up just made me cry...
Lol. Sorry for you but this comment made me laugh a bit 🙈
This isn't fake tho, it's a Mashup in the entire sense of the word.
Mood
same.....i now have big streaks down my fake tanned face....
Same🥺
This hits different after seeing Taylor & Harry talking after the Grammys. 😭 (And I don't ship them by the way).
Around 2:29 Harry says "I get a feeling that you'd never need me again" and she looks down and follows where the voice is coming from. Which might mean that she do need him. She ends up inside water while Harry is already submerged under water. While she struggles to save herself, he lays there as if expecting her complains and his mistakes. She suddenly finds some balance and save herself. On the other hand Harry stays sitting on the floor while water fill up his room. In the end, Taylor goes back to her room hoping he'd come back to her but he doesn't. Then Taylor looks at the cardigan which could be there token of love and realises that they'd never be together ever again but their memories would be safe and sound.
Note : These are just some thoughts that came to my head while watching this. I happen to love the mind of a creater of this mashup! Beautiful!
I agree with you, except taylor hoping he'd come back, bcs she's already know that he came back to her inside the lyric "you'd come back to me"
This comment is so beautiful.❤(ӦｖӦ｡)
Wow you’re great at fantasizing
I'm cries in haylor
girl you need to write a book i see that you are talented 😂😂
i wish so badly that they were friends 😭
Hannah Welch they are friends! i think taylor’s said that he’s the only ex that she’s remained friends with
they’re still friends
Noah E isn’t taylor still friends with joe jonas?
your average commenter taylor confirmed that she and harry are still friends. In recent interview Harry praised taylor’s songwriting. idk about joe jonas but yeah i think they’re friends too.
na .19 Taylor Said In Burning questions with ellen degeneres that she and Joe laughs off the fact that taylor roasted him in 2008, so they’re still friends 😊
Taylor called the guy as James in her folklore album, and who else was James Dean character in 1989 album style song?
James is Ryan Rheynold's child name
@@Cherie_by I personally don't think the names have to do with Ryan and Blake's kids. I know a lot of people think it's about them, but I think it would be weird to base a love triangle names based off of three children who are siblings. Plus we still don't know the 3rd kids name
AAAAAHHHHHH
I am not saying the song is about Harry styles, all these small-small things are details that she picked up from her past relations. Also, her whole album is a reflection on personal stories that also in together make up a fictional story. So, James, the daughters name is just that one string that reflects so many aspect in her life. It’s like no. 13. It has multiple significance.
I have so many theories that I feel are not just random details like in song Betty, James telling his as 17 was the same age of Harry when they first went out. There are other lyrics where there is a reflection from I knew you were trouble song.
Hope I thought that at first too but Inez isn’t part of the love triangle.
This and Style/Perfect mashups are gonna kill me if it'll actually be performed by the two legendary songwriters. This is like a glimpse if ever they'd co-write.
"Sometimes soulmates aren't supposed to stay together. Sometimes they go through a part of life and move on. You'll know who that person is when they don't leave."
@@christineharris7950 I believe William Bowery is actually Harry Styles
They will trust me they "never go out of style "
@@christineharris7950 The whole Folklore and Evermore era is extremely suspicious 🤔 😳 👀, she is still emerged in the woods, it's like she never made it out.
@@christineharris7950 yuh, hear me out:
y'know why Taylor said wb is joe? cuz she just didn't wanna get hated on *AGAIN*
I mean, thInk AbOUt It!! can someone like Joe Alwyn, who Isn't EvEn A sOngwRItER write songs AS AMAZING AS betty and *exile* ?!?! ABSOLUTELY NOT!! remember how she also said "musical heroes"? can someone like Joe, who dOEsnt EvEn dO mUsIc be someone's "musical hero"? NO
@@ninni2824 yuh, hear me out:
y'know why Taylor said wb is joe? cuz she just didn't wanna get hated on *AGAIN*
I mean, thInk AbOUt It!! can someone like Joe Alwyn, who Isn't EvEn A sOngwRItER write songs AS AMAZING AS betty and *exile* ?!?! ABSOLUTELY NOT!! remember how she also said "musical heroes"? can someone like Joe, who dOEsnt EvEn dO mUsIc be someone's "musical hero"? NO
I think cardigan is the answer song for falling. There are a lot of similar things.
Taylor says "I knew you'd haunt all of my "what-ifs"" Harry says many "what if"
Harry says "I'm falling again"
Taylor says "I knew you'd come back to me"
In other parts, he says "I'm well aware I write too many songs about you" "It kills me cause I know we run out of things we can say"
Taylor wrote a lot of songs about Harry and these days we can't find a song about Harry so he think they have nothing more they can say
Taylor loves Joe so Harry think you'll never need me
@@にゃ-s3l I honestly wanna believe that you're right, I really do, I'm a HUGE Haylor shipper, but the truth hurts that Falling is actually about Camille Rowe 😒
@@muhammadahsan4959 Thank you! Sorry for Taylor but I think Taylor's misunderstanding. These are truly connected a lot😆
@@にゃ-s3l maybe she knows it ain't about her. We'll never know...
i believe your opinion is correct
Let's take it this way. Harry's thoughts are about today where they're not together anymore whereas Taylor's about when they were together. So the water means thoughts which saves her but drowns him.
OMG! That's amazing, you explained this the best way possible, I even took a screenshot of this.
@@isabeluchoa6257 haha omg I thought that was just me who took a screenshot
genius. yes
apparently the water is hatred by people and one took it into them and made something beatiful and one went through the storm with it and came out CLEAN
Harry -
What am I now? What am I now?
What if I'm someone I don't want around?
I'm falling again, I'm falling again, I'm falling
What if I'm down?
What if I'm out?
What if I'm someone you won't talk about?
I'm falling again, I'm falling again, I'm falling
Taylor -
I knew you'd haunt all of my what-ifs
~This mashup was meant to be~
Harry and Taylor need to see this and realize how powerful their collab would be....
This is a beautiful work of art. It’s clear the amount of emotion and hurt poured into these songs by Taylor and Harry. What’s crazy about it is how much they parallel one another. Tragic but beautiful.
sad, beautiful tragic
only swifties will understand😏
simple but effective
This mash up is a sad beautiful tragic
@@prajavathireddy310 It is devistatingly beautiful. It wrecks me.
I totally agree, audra.
It's like harry is peter and taylor is wendy, their song is awsome, the video is like they're in a magic places also look at their clothes
Now go listen to Illicit Affairs in Folklore 🙌💘
And Peter choose Wendy
@@mariflix13 You're the reason why no one would actually want to listen to it because of such comment lmao
Horny Cini Minis
Not really, she’s just saying that because the comment probably reminds her of illicit affairs
@@imanadil9065 Exactly 🤷♀️
The fact that these two scenes connect perfectly. THEY WERE MEANT FOR THIS MASHUP!
imagine haylor as best friends... yup i can’t even wrap my head around how powerful they’d be
We all know they saw this .🧐
They did?!
Ugh I wish
I like to think that as well
Let's make this real pleasee
@@ziapanaligan4818 i agree
I’m kinda sad, it’s obvious there isn’t any bad blood between and they are on good terms but I’m still seeing some directioners hating on Taylor. Honestly, it’s been years I’m a directioners as well but some of them need to grow up.
Edit: I’ve seen some Swifties insulting Harry, when his fans were hating on Taylor. I just want to say; We don’t claim them.
True. There's a lot of them over there the comment's section in Harry's Falling mv
swifties hate on harry too, I've seen it. some people need to be kinder to each other. harry and taylor are both great
@Daniela - That kinda goes without saying, there’s definitely some Swifties who only like Harry but they have no reason to just like directioners. We don’t claim them.
most of harries love taylor and stan her, maybe directioners don't like her bcs of their past idk
@Gayatri Marchia I think a lot of harries seem to be fine with Taylor since it’s been 8 years now and they seem more mature then some directioners.
It got to the point that I can't listen to the originals on their own anymore. This version is so good. Yin and Yang.
They dated because the universe is not ready for their collaboration
what a plot
Lol true
Harry and Taylor is the couple that doesn't last that long but remained in our hearts up until now😞👌
Beautiful mashup! Never been a haylor shipper but I love them both musically. As a Harry’s big fan, Falling MV is what came into my mind when I first saw Cardigan MV. Imagine the powerful music they could make together 😳😳
Torsha Sanyal same!!
i agree
Same here!
It baffles me how musically and visually these two songs are in sync! ❤️💜
I like how this seems similar because it's a post break up song and they are bith playing piano. One is a piano waterfall, representing letting go of a past ex, and the other is pouring water in the room, represent the guilt the other feels for knowing they've hurt their past lover. It just works so well!
I love this! The similarity was the first thing I thought about when I saw her video
Saame
YES SAME!
yess
me too
Also thought this too
i'm happy bcos taylor already have joe but but but , haylor never goes out of style.
Joe is a decoy
@@cherylreinell857 ABSOLUTELY YESSSSSS
Tay n hazza just don't wanna get hated on again days wut joe dere 4
OMG…this version is so beautiful. Those two need to sing together. They’re perfect!
When will this collab become real? 🥺
I guess never 😫
Never in a million years🥺😭
In my wildest dreams
falling song its already sad, and they added cardigan:
Double The sad
Im already crying i want them back but joe alwin is there for taylor
Unpopular opinion: Harry and Taylor called each other and secretly collabed
Edit: Fanks so much for the likes luv
I hope this is true
@@nataliemoreira6594 They make a great duo don't they?
@@mahekchoudhary yes, their voices sound really good together
@@nataliemoreira6594 Hmm let's keep dreaming
Is that an opinion lol?
I love how water is flowing out of both their pianos and they both are surrounded by water
She found someone else and he saved her, but that drowned him...
Oh my gosh 😭
ppl in this comment section are just staight up brilliant smh
@@floaty_potato3546 yeah that's right
@@floaty_potato3546 actually 😭😭
That's pretty much the climax scene of Titanic! Atleast saving her & him drowning part.
It's crazy how to this day haylor is still relevant
They have a strong chemistry.
They never go out of style
@@chenevanniekerk2019 yupp
They'll never go out of style
ikr, haylor and jelena are both such iconic talked about couples its kinda amazing the impact they had
I know they didn't work out as a couple but I seriously feel like they would be power bffs.
The reason these videos match up so well is because it was done on purpose. The song Falling is about Taylor and she responded back to him with Cardigan. They did this once before with Style and Perfect. Like me, the artist CosmicMashups noticed the obvious relationship between the songs and put this mashup together so the rest of you could figure it out too.
Rightttt! They parallel each other too well to be a coincidence