Treloar trade happened. He won 0 premierships since and Collingwood went on to win a premiership within 3 years of his departure. I’d say a good long term trade
That was my first thought too. Fremantle also got Trent Croad as well as McFarlane in the deal, and to rub salt into Fremantle's wound, Croad went back to Hawthorn 3 years later K
Chris Groom for Andrew McLeod is forever talked about in South Australia. Thompson and Jacobs were also utterly one-sided pickups for Adelaide but McLeod is legendary. Feel that Port Adelaide paying so little to North Melbourne for Jason Francis-Horne being a #1 pick in very recent years was also a steal.
The Tom Harley trade was maybe the worst trade for Port, because he went on to become a 2 time premiership captain and Port got 3 games out of "Adam Morgan" in return.
And Port chose him as their 1 x 17 year old over Matthew Pavlich, who went unselected and would be one of the hottest prospects in the country 12 months later.
I have for some time now considered Fremantle as the worst underachievers in the AFL era. Lucas, Lloyd & Mcleod are three names that solidify my opinion. When Chris Fagan arrived at Brisbane the culture of letting good young talent walk out the door stopped. The rewards of that policy have been realised.
Thats Jordan McMahon trade wasn’t a bad trade really in reality, because of McMahon Richmond didn't finish last and ended up with the 3rd overall pick in the draft which became Dustin Martin and to be fair he had a way better career than Ward has had to date and I doubt that will change.
Fremantle trade for Hawthorn Trent Croad trade has to be one of the biggest blunders. Freo ended up with nothing, Hawks setup their premiership dynasty.
Collingwood was able to break even on the Treloar debacle in 2021 trading in Patrick Lipinski for a mid 40s pick. Maybe not as good as Treloar’s best, but he’s 4 years younger, lest injury prone, although has had some shoulder issues, a premiership player, and a very important player in the team structure.
@@Comatosedpeanut I never again want to hear Collingwood complain about players leaving ever again, or players' lack of loyalty. Treloar and Grundy both wanted to stay at Collingwood, but you pushed them out the door because you didn't want to pay them what you agreed to in their contracts. You pushed two players who wanted to stay, out of the door mid-contract because of your own poor accounting, yet then complain when a player leaves you mid contract to another club for more money. Oh, the hypocrisy.
What the hell, this video is just littered with errors. The pronunciation of Treloar, Tom Bellchambers’s photo instead of Scott Lucas, saying Jordan McMahon kicked the winning goal against Melbourne, when it was in fact Richard Tambling (which btw meant dusty came to Richmond, so a big win for the tigers)
we rectified that in the years after, as evidenced by the recent trading in of jordan clark, shai bolton, adam mcphee,keplar bradley and the drafting of really good players
@@avgfree21 They have improved, but they still make some howlers. Bolton is going to be another HUGE flop imo. Not hard to look good in that Richmond team, at the dockers I reckon he might be all ego. There is a reason why the Eagles and Dockers never drafted him in the first place, gifted, but troubled. Best of luck to him though, maybe he has grown up >3
Still wondering why essendon off loaded him (a fringe player at the time) and kept players that were clearly at the end or on the downside at best. Honestly I could question nearly every draftee in the last 10 years. Hard to be a member when they seem to be a boys club rather that a competitor
@@clintoneddy2860he wanted to leave, it was either get some value from him or he walks in free agency. He was out of contract and wasn’t gonna resign, Essendon offered him a 2 year deal
And also Essendon was ridiculously over the salary cap fitting in both Lucas and Lloyd. Cheaters never win except in the AFL where it happens commonly!
It’s pronounced Jerrod Nesheim And that wasn’t Scott Lucas in the picture when you said his name. Pretty sloppy and unprofessional for somebody that can get 13,000 views.
Fair dinkum that fake SA private schoolboy poncy accent. Sounds like a 16 yo boy version of Penny Wong. Pre season “DROFT” “Tray-lor” “Stork” contrast. This crap is littered through the whole show. Get some speech therapy dude!
How did you say Treloar incorrectly in 6 different ways
treyloar
treelore
Hahahahahaha absolute muppet
Treloar trade happened. He won 0 premierships since and Collingwood went on to win a premiership within 3 years of his departure. I’d say a good long term trade
@1:56 pretty sure that's big Tommy Bellchambers, not Scotty Lucas
can't see Lucas beating up Cam Mooney
Can’t forget the 2001 Fremantle/Hawthorn luke McFarland trade for pick 1 (L.Hodge), 20 and 36 (S.Mitchel)
That was my first thought too. Fremantle also got Trent Croad as well as McFarlane in the deal, and to rub salt into Fremantle's wound, Croad went back to Hawthorn 3 years later K
@@karmanho4501 Did Trent Croad end up playing in the 08 Grand Final?
@@patrickmaclean1524yeah, he broke his foot in the 1st quarter I think I remember.
Think you will find that it was Trent Croad for exchange No.1 pick,
Chris Groom for Andrew McLeod is forever talked about in South Australia. Thompson and Jacobs were also utterly one-sided pickups for Adelaide but McLeod is legendary.
Feel that Port Adelaide paying so little to North Melbourne for Jason Francis-Horne being a #1 pick in very recent years was also a steal.
The Tom Harley trade was maybe the worst trade for Port, because he went on to become a 2 time premiership captain and Port got 3 games out of "Adam Morgan" in return.
And Adam Morgan was the selection directly before Brendan Fevola
And Port chose him as their 1 x 17 year old over Matthew Pavlich, who went unselected and would be one of the hottest prospects in the country 12 months later.
I have for some time now considered Fremantle as the worst underachievers in the AFL era. Lucas, Lloyd & Mcleod are three names that solidify my opinion. When Chris Fagan arrived at Brisbane the culture of letting good young talent walk out the door stopped. The rewards of that policy have been realised.
the best afl vids on yt ngl
real
Lol not even close
do you lie normally?
@@hotkeyafl ok buddy
Nah Stoody
Thats Jordan McMahon trade wasn’t a bad trade really in reality, because of McMahon Richmond didn't finish last and ended up with the 3rd overall pick in the draft which became Dustin Martin and to be fair he had a way better career than Ward has had to date and I doubt that will change.
Fremantle trade for Hawthorn Trent Croad trade has to be one of the biggest blunders. Freo ended up with nothing, Hawks setup their premiership dynasty.
I love your videos
McMahon got us dusty. Well worth it
Adam TrayLore has been a good pick up for the Bulldogs
Collingwood was able to break even on the Treloar debacle in 2021 trading in Patrick Lipinski for a mid 40s pick. Maybe not as good as Treloar’s best, but he’s 4 years younger, lest injury prone, although has had some shoulder issues, a premiership player, and a very important player in the team structure.
Yeah we came out a better side after letting treloar and Grundy go.
@@Comatosedpeanut Grundy a better ruckman than Darcy Cameron or Billy Frampton.
@@Comatosedpeanut I never again want to hear Collingwood complain about players leaving ever again, or players' lack of loyalty.
Treloar and Grundy both wanted to stay at Collingwood, but you pushed them out the door because you didn't want to pay them what you agreed to in their contracts.
You pushed two players who wanted to stay, out of the door mid-contract because of your own poor accounting, yet then complain when a player leaves you mid contract to another club for more money.
Oh, the hypocrisy.
No McMahon, No Dusty, No Dynasty.
Bulldogs were compensated for losing Ward with the rights to Jack Macrae
Traylor? Macman? Two-e?
one of the worst was Kaleen trading his voice for normal footage.
How does this guy only have 9k subs
What the hell, this video is just littered with errors. The pronunciation of Treloar, Tom Bellchambers’s photo instead of Scott Lucas, saying Jordan McMahon kicked the winning goal against Melbourne, when it was in fact Richard Tambling (which btw meant dusty came to Richmond, so a big win for the tigers)
Peter Bell? Trent Croad? Fremantle shouldn't even be allowed to trade :D someone qualified should be appointed to do it for them :P
we rectified that in the years after, as evidenced by the recent trading in of jordan clark, shai bolton, adam mcphee,keplar bradley and the drafting of really good players
@@avgfree21 They have improved, but they still make some howlers. Bolton is going to be another HUGE flop imo. Not hard to look good in that Richmond team, at the dockers I reckon he might be all ego. There is a reason why the Eagles and Dockers never drafted him in the first place, gifted, but troubled. Best of luck to him though, maybe he has grown up >3
How about Massimo D’Ambrosio from Essendon
Still wondering why essendon off loaded him (a fringe player at the time) and kept players that were clearly at the end or on the downside at best. Honestly I could question nearly every draftee in the last 10 years. Hard to be a member when they seem to be a boys club rather that a competitor
because that's a bold claim after one season
@@clintoneddy2860he wanted to leave, it was either get some value from him or he walks in free agency. He was out of contract and wasn’t gonna resign, Essendon offered him a 2 year deal
@@futaussie2365That was a one year deal. It was Hawthorn who offered the two year deal.
Freo never had access to Matthew Lloyd......
And also Essendon was ridiculously over the salary cap fitting in both Lucas and Lloyd. Cheaters never win except in the AFL where it happens commonly!
Is it just me or the Luka trade made this video happen
Just you. The trades in basketball are more interesting than the actual sport.
Jeremy cameron trade
Drorft.
Adam TREYlor
This whole thing could be Fremantles early trades tbh
Kolton?
It’s pronounced Jerrod Nesheim
And that wasn’t Scott Lucas in the picture when you said his name. Pretty sloppy and unprofessional for somebody that can get 13,000 views.
Fair dinkum that fake SA private schoolboy poncy accent. Sounds like a 16 yo boy version of Penny Wong. Pre season “DROFT” “Tray-lor” “Stork” contrast. This crap is littered through the whole show. Get some speech therapy dude!
Alistair Clarkson letting Josh Kennedy go, was a disaster. He went on to become a champion, at the Swans.
Yeah they only won three premierships