Hawkeye is terrible and unusable on clay. It is consistently wrong. We saw it in Madrid clearly. Hawkeye is about estimation, not real point of contact. There're significant surface and therefore bounce irregularities on clay that messes with Hawkeye's calculations big time.
Crissy Garin would throw his own mother into a fire if it'd win him an ATP tennis match, wouldn't he. I'm not even mad at it. Each to their own and all that
Seeing Momo get angry made so uncomfortable because he's such a lovely, nice, chill umpire. Faith Evans tried to get loud with him, so Layd back had to drop some sand on that fire real quick.
The mistake on Borges vs Garin its the most ridicoulous thing ive seen in tennis. I hope the umpire did get punished for it, that just can not happen. I think he did because i dont remember him umpiring after that match. As for Garin, he is dirty. Not only on that match but many others. Another player I feel happy for his downfall.
Garin missed the point twice and still won the point? Umpire was confused and Garin knew it. He made the conscious decision to NOT say anything about it. In short he CHEATED!
Over 4 hours & completely riveting. A war of attrition, really, it was a pyrrhic victory as whoever won wouldn't have enough time to recover enough to face Carlitear & put up a real fight. Indeed, Shang was fatigued & got dusted in the next round.
What happened to Evans is frightening. That Lahyani needs to be sacked, he along with all the other incompetent umpires still getting away with such ludicrous calls.
I just rewatched the Federer v. Berdych final in Madrid 2012. Even Fed got jeered when he argued that the ball had hit the ground. He was very respectful about it. If Federer got jeered, I don’t know anybody who’s going to be safe from it.
9:55 This stupid tradition of still having the umpire check to see if the ball is in or out on clay is insane. We have seen the umpires can make wrong calls. They need to start using "shot spot" or whatever it's calling these days and do away with this unnecessary drama.
it's called Hawkeye. But the French don't wanna implement, because of their... cheese eating, surrendering stupid traditional monkey bullshit government.
@@jayortiz6188 I know they are expensive,, but if smaller tournaments can afford them, then a grand slam certainly can. I know they want to save money, but it's time to stop the thinking that umpires can't make mistakes on clay and that's assuming they can reliably find the "mark" to make the call.
@@khrfx4715 I agree but the bigger tournaments have more players and more courts. You would need Hawkeye on every court so that's a big bill that they don't want to spend. Just telling you why they don't want to implement it.
@@jayortiz6188 If the other 3 can do it, then so can Rolland Garros. Audiences will continue to get upset at seeing every mistake umpires make and players getting screwed. There will come a day when Rolland Garros gives up and buys it.
Mohammed Lahyani is in every one of these videos, in which players blow up at his mistakes. He's the worst. Fire the incompetent chair umps that decide the outcome of matches! Side note: Moutet is nuts!
Sinnatra vs Olive Oil in the Money Carload SF was THE biggest travesty of the 2024 clay court swing. And no, I will NOT let Aurally Retort live that horrible umpiring down. That was a double fault which should have meant a 5-2 double break lead for Janhip. Twistypast should not have made it to the final against Ruudimentary.
He would've been serving for the match at 5-2 & could've won the whole thing, indeed. Instead what should've been 4-1 becomes 3-2 and the rest is travesty.
It was a dramatic upset that propelled Tablet to the SF. Indeed, Tableux is now a Top 20 player in 2024 off the back of his title in Auckland on hard, his Rome run to the SF, & his MyOrca run on grass. Shelton better watch out for the other star lefties coming for his gig.
Swear they just don’t wanna use Hawkeye to cause more drama every match
Hawkeye is terrible and unusable on clay. It is consistently wrong. We saw it in Madrid clearly. Hawkeye is about estimation, not real point of contact. There're significant surface and therefore bounce irregularities on clay that messes with Hawkeye's calculations big time.
@@gorkemguzel32 No.
Crissy Garin would throw his own mother into a fire if it'd win him an ATP tennis match, wouldn't he. I'm not even mad at it. Each to their own and all that
All south Americans r like that in sport
@@SonyCamry Not all of us, just the shtty ones, like in every other country with shtty people
Womp womp, cry about it😢 VIVA CHILE 🇨🇱
@@RickyBruce00 I literally said "I'm not even mad at it" you weird little freak
moutet and the coffee is hilarious!
The one of Evans was clearly out, it was a break point and both lines missed it, the hawkeye must be mandatory.
I would be pissed too lol I agree clay can be deceiving with marks close together
Evans - why unsportsmanlike conduct? Umpire u said f word ! Evans - fair enough lol
Seeing Momo get angry made so uncomfortable because he's such a lovely, nice, chill umpire. Faith Evans tried to get loud with him, so Layd back had to drop some sand on that fire real quick.
@got2bjosh the ball was clearly out so I can understand why evans was annoyed it was a massive point aswell
If the officials had made the right call, it would not have happened.
In #5, Rune should've said "What's unsportsmanlike about it? WHAT IS UNSPORTSMANLIKE ABOUT IT?"
The mistake on Borges vs Garin its the most ridicoulous thing ive seen in tennis. I hope the umpire did get punished for it, that just can not happen. I think he did because i dont remember him umpiring after that match. As for Garin, he is dirty. Not only on that match but many others. Another player I feel happy for his downfall.
Umpire has worked subsequent tournaments in 2024. Thankfully, Hubi took out Garish in Estoril.
Bro how did Shang make that shot 😂 18:48
Moutet is an angry little gremlin
Tsitsipas sinner robbery
Sinner should have stopped rally and challenged rather than challenging later
I'm so tired of watching referees lose a match to people with their decisions...
I like Moutet. He's funny. We need some humor in our lives sometimes.😂
He fired a shot at Shang when he gave up the point.
he's a twat. He's "funny" in the way schoolboys think their mates are "funny" when they bully other kids.
Garin missed the point twice and still won the point? Umpire was confused and Garin knew it. He made the conscious decision to NOT say anything about it. In short he CHEATED!
Garin is a -1000000 sportsmanship guy. He'll never be back in the top 100.
I will bet you any thing you want Garín gets back into the top 100
That Shang Moutet match was bonkers lols
Over 4 hours & completely riveting. A war of attrition, really, it was a pyrrhic victory as whoever won wouldn't have enough time to recover enough to face Carlitear & put up a real fight. Indeed, Shang was fatigued & got dusted in the next round.
poor evans... lahyani was 100% wrong
Layani Always has problems, is the worst umpire for me
@@nicozukithe worst umpire is Aurelie Tourte by far.
What happened to Evans is frightening. That Lahyani needs to be sacked, he along with all the other incompetent umpires still getting away with such ludicrous calls.
My god your feelings must be hurt you bum hahah
he's just retired, so you can stop sulking now.
@@joosiej85 No, Bernardes is retiring at the end of 2024, not Momo.
so sick of crowds just jeering and whistling whenever there’s any disagreement of any kind
I just rewatched the Federer v. Berdych final in Madrid 2012. Even Fed got jeered when he argued that the ball had hit the ground. He was very respectful about it. If Federer got jeered, I don’t know anybody who’s going to be safe from it.
Feel bad for grigor 😭
Umpires should be finded for every mistake they made
no way
Umpires don't earn enough for that to be viable.
@@noeldacosta7621then we don’t need them we should automate refs coz they ruin games more than help in all sports
9:55 This stupid tradition of still having the umpire check to see if the ball is in or out on clay is insane. We have seen the umpires can make wrong calls. They need to start using "shot spot" or whatever it's calling these days and do away with this unnecessary drama.
it's called Hawkeye. But the French don't wanna implement, because of their... cheese eating, surrendering stupid traditional monkey bullshit government.
Blame the tournaments they don't want to pay for the hawkeye systems which are quite expensive.
@@jayortiz6188 I know they are expensive,, but if smaller tournaments can afford them, then a grand slam certainly can. I know they want to save money, but it's time to stop the thinking that umpires can't make mistakes on clay and that's assuming they can reliably find the "mark" to make the call.
@@khrfx4715 I agree but the bigger tournaments have more players and more courts. You would need Hawkeye on every court so that's a big bill that they don't want to spend. Just telling you why they don't want to implement it.
@@jayortiz6188 If the other 3 can do it, then so can Rolland Garros. Audiences will continue to get upset at seeing every mistake umpires make and players getting screwed. There will come a day when Rolland Garros gives up and buys it.
The guy's reaction in the crowd at 7:28 :DD
Mohammed Lahyani is in every one of these videos, in which players blow up at his mistakes. He's the worst. Fire the incompetent chair umps that decide the outcome of matches! Side note: Moutet is nuts!
Rune vs Dimitrov was dramatic too!
16:45 The US had commentary for that juicy Shelton vs Kotex match in Rome.
I think we miss Hurkacz's moment when he asked to replace the umpire ;)
I hope that Moutet ump got a bonus for that match 🥴
Still a shame what happen in sinner match. That why clay games are terrible to watch
Sinnatra vs Olive Oil in the Money Carload SF was THE biggest travesty of the 2024 clay court swing. And no, I will NOT let Aurally Retort live that horrible umpiring down. That was a double fault which should have meant a 5-2 double break lead for Janhip. Twistypast should not have made it to the final against Ruudimentary.
Navone hits so hard
Too short, though.
7:11 my love 😍
Layani said dont raise your voice at me tf 😂😂😂
The Sinner one is so obviously out, it's sad. Boy could have won the whole thing from that position.
He would've been serving for the match at 5-2 & could've won the whole thing, indeed. Instead what should've been 4-1 becomes 3-2 and the rest is travesty.
Who can explain please, why Garin got that point?
No one can explain it. It's just wrong.
Confused, prideful umpire & poor sportsmanship from Garish.
Garin just made himself look like trash after this display. He doesnt even respect himself enough to play fair
Love this❤
21:36 so sweet😄
Garin the CHEAT! #FTP
PS adding Kotov to my shit list, lol
My main takeaway from this video is tennis umpires have the most stylish umpires/refs in sport.
That umpire Mohamed Leyhani (sp) seems to be in a lot of these dodgy line calls
Why is the crowd always booing its so annoying, you want to hear the players with the arguments but then the crowd boos the hell out of them, why?
Calling supervisor is the most stupidest thing in the world because they never overrule referre's decision and nothing changes for player.
umpire in the Borges match should never do an atp match again
The male umpire is the worst, he got it wrong and irresponsible countless of times. How is he still employed?
This is why i do not like clay court season. No challenge mechanism except madrid.
Is it legal to consume caffeine before or during a match? I thought it was considered doping.
It’s legal
the last match was just a disgrace.
such a stupid decision, incredible.
Very nice
Rune is a toddler
So many of these happen on clay. Time for electronic line calling, and remove all this BS.
Nel 2024 non si può sbagliare così tanto
so stupid to have umpires involved when a camera does the job faster, cheaper, more reliably and less controversially
If there was a challenge system in all of clay season, all those unnecessary dramas and waste of strength would have been avoided.
The umpires need help, clay is embarrassing at times
0:48 what's going on?
Do the umpires apologise after making huge mistakes? They should
Its about time we lose those umpires and let technology in.
The amount of human errors are ridiculous.
Garin most worst player in the world
one day AI will ref the games and the ref can retire early since they can't even ref to begin with
Shang Sung is too strong
Sinner was robbed it was out for a much
Djokovic tabilo Drama? He was just outplayed
It was a dramatic upset that propelled Tablet to the SF. Indeed, Tableux is now a Top 20 player in 2024 off the back of his title in Auckland on hard, his Rome run to the SF, & his MyOrca run on grass. Shelton better watch out for the other star lefties coming for his gig.
cry harder
Mohamed Lahyani is not a good umpire. Especially on clay. So many mistakes.
Why do people think leyhani is a good umpire? Guy is horrible!
garin is just a cry baby he’s always whining
Lahyani and his poor umpiring skills in highlight again.
Rune ist ständig respektlos wer hat den denn erzogen? 👎🏼👎🏼👎🏼
Rune is just a spoiled brat
One of the most shameless player ..garin
Garin … what a cheater … 👎🏿👎🏿👎🏿
That woman in Montecarlo is a disgrace..unbelievable how bad referees are in tennis..they genuinely ruin the sport
Rune and his whole team and the trash of the earth period