I think she because she was whispering while singing so she just did them as a joke because that’s her personality when it comes to singing on insta live 😂😂😂
Whistle register is something need to be practiced property, because if not it will cause problems with the voice. Also singing alone in a whistle register isn't as pretty as a full blown power
I'm convinced that all Carpenters are really eloquent to some point. I'm only now seeing this a year later. But you wrote this so well and it makes us look so intelligent thank you😭
Why people glorify the whistles so much? I mean i love when someone do it but a whistle doesn't mean that someone sings better than another. There are so many amazing techniques, you don't need to achieve a whistle just sing the way you want to and keep upgrading your favorite technique (This comment is not specifically for this video just my opinion reading some comments)
@@aintnosunshinewhenshesgone8537 Well of course. Other vocal types can hit whistles, even basses, but sopranos has way easier access to them. sabrina just hasn't developed that skill yet, but she undoubtedly can. her not being a soprano is definitely a factor why she cant do them that easily.
why do people think singing in whistle notes is hard? it’s not... once you learn to access the register you can sing pretty much anything with enough practice. and they don’t damage your vocal chords that’s a myth. it’s impossible to hurt your voice with proper technique.
@@alinaivanov5536 whistle registers arent that assenting that every singer can access it, it depends on themselves. some professional singers can’t access the whistle note since it’s trickier for them
aurelia sorry but what do you mean by “assenting”? generally speaking if they can’t hit whistles because of their anatomy or limitations that’s a different story. i was talking about healthy vocalists, with a relative ability to hit higher notes, are more than likely to be able to sing in whistle register with practice.
@@alinaivanov5536 not true. Anybody can learn. Males, females, from basses-tenors and altos-sopranos. Its actually not that hard lmao, its all about practice. Once you figure out the right placement youre good
The ending of Raindrops you don’t use your whistle register its a mix of chest voice/head voice, falsetto if your a guy hehe it’s also sung glissando so yeah :)
@@placeholder9462 really? Lol she was trying really hard sksksks usually people who don’t know where their sweet spot of where their whistle tones are they sound like this. Once you find it you’ll never want to go back hehe
did she warm up during the live... I feel like if she hummed loud or sang low notes with a little growls she could make it easier for the whistle notes to come out. Cause a lot of the time they won't come out on your first try of that day hahahah
She has 2nd octave notes in studio so she could have 5 octaves without the 8th octave. But this is just speculation, the only notes that she has publicly displayed for now are Bb2 - E6, about 3.5 octaves.
She didn't say that she has a 5 octaves vocal range or more, in fact the person in this video say that and its false. Sabrina in the interview say that her vocal coach told her that she can do whistles, period. She didnt say anything about having a 5 vocal range or more.
I love her but the last part was funny. She looked serious in trying to whistle 😅
she was kidding…
It was a joke 😂 where's your humor 🤣🤣
I think she because she was whispering while singing so she just did them as a joke because that’s her personality when it comes to singing on insta live 😂😂😂
Whistle register is something need to be practiced property, because if not it will cause problems with the voice. Also singing alone in a whistle register isn't as pretty as a full blown power
Bro I can sing in whistle it's hard to control I can just go to like a C7 & it's harder to adjust
@@nonsensicalchatter it is really hard to control, I have been able to go up to A7 but it isn't controlled yet (at least the A7)
I still love you Sabrina Carpenter
I'm convinced that all Carpenters are really eloquent to some point. I'm only now seeing this a year later. But you wrote this so well and it makes us look so intelligent thank you😭
Yes she can do it she's so talented
Why people glorify the whistles so much? I mean i love when someone do it but a whistle doesn't mean that someone sings better than another.
There are so many amazing techniques, you don't need to achieve a whistle just sing the way you want to and keep upgrading your favorite technique
(This comment is not specifically for this video just my opinion reading some comments)
I completely agree with you !
That was Actually Funny, So cute
you really put 'blonde girl' in the description trying to get somewhere in the drama. Also she was joking around in the live but okay.
Like she said, she need to be more confident about her voice and try new things ❤️ I'm totally sure that she will do it at least one
THE LAST PART WAS A JOKE GUYS 😂 SHE WAS JUST KIDDING 🤣🤣
Thank you
I genuinely just think is bc she is an alto rather than a soprano! She can learn how to do it however but the main cause is just bc she’s alto
She's not alto she's mezzo
@@nicolasmagalhaeslussim2711 ok
It's not because of that. Some tenors and baritons can sing in whistle register too.
@@aintnosunshinewhenshesgone8537 Well of course. Other vocal types can hit whistles, even basses, but sopranos has way easier access to them. sabrina just hasn't developed that skill yet, but she undoubtedly can. her not being a soprano is definitely a factor why she cant do them that easily.
she is 100% a soprano
why do people think singing in whistle notes is hard? it’s not... once you learn to access the register you can sing pretty much anything with enough practice. and they don’t damage your vocal chords that’s a myth. it’s impossible to hurt your voice with proper technique.
Cuz a lot of people can sing in it but not a lot of people sound good doing it
if they are good singers and good musicians already chances are they are gonna sound great at it.
@@alinaivanov5536 whistle registers arent that assenting that every singer can access it, it depends on themselves. some professional singers can’t access the whistle note since it’s trickier for them
aurelia sorry but what do you mean by “assenting”? generally speaking if they can’t hit whistles because of their anatomy or limitations that’s a different story. i was talking about healthy vocalists, with a relative ability to hit higher notes, are more than likely to be able to sing in whistle register with practice.
@@alinaivanov5536 not true. Anybody can learn. Males, females, from basses-tenors and altos-sopranos. Its actually not that hard lmao, its all about practice. Once you figure out the right placement youre good
SHE'S A VERSATILE YA KNOWW 🤘❤️
Woahhh is it just me or did she sound like Ariana Grande, when she was like “you mean like whistle tones”!! I SWEAR TO GOD SHE SOUNDED LIKE ARI!!!🤯
Just you
@@placeholder9462 lmao, go listen to some of Ariana grande’s interviews, I swear to god
Right? Many parts in her song Pushing 20 also sounds like Ari. Maybe that's the effect of having a vocal coach that worked with Ari.
@@RockyRakoon idk but I’m tripping rn!! 🤣😂
She was messin round
I’m not sure if people get she was screwing around in the live..
Did anyone read the description if not read it
%lond% g%%l
Literally me trying to hit whistle note 🕳️🏃🏻♀️
The ending of Raindrops you don’t use your whistle register its a mix of chest voice/head voice, falsetto if your a guy hehe it’s also sung glissando so yeah :)
Well duh that’s how it’s recorded, but Sabrina was trying to reach the note in whistle register.
@@sarah81894 emphasis on trying haha
@@olevaldezzz5837 she was clearly kidding
@@placeholder9462 really? Lol she was trying really hard sksksks usually people who don’t know where their sweet spot of where their whistle tones are they sound like this. Once you find it you’ll never want to go back hehe
most people today use the word falsetto as a breathier and/or disconnected version of headvoice
did she warm up during the live... I feel like if she hummed loud or sang low notes with a little growls she could make it easier for the whistle notes to come out. Cause a lot of the time they won't come out on your first try of that day hahahah
I love her
Hi Sabrina- I think you nailed it baby! 🙂❤️🌻 You looked great doing it too! Love you! 😎❤️⭐️💋🥰🌺🐅🙏🕊🌻🦋
I can't with the sheer stupidity in the comments.
I think she was joking on the end part.
Yall hear the polyphonic notes?
the description annoys me
Why?
ur comment annoys me
@@cameron7644 it has an olivia song recommended by umg
Ok? You still clicked right.
@@themissileminer5494 what im a sab stan the description has nothing to do w the video dumbass
Okay, but a five octave range its a little too mutch lol
So she can reach the 8th octave or she has has 3 or 4 not 5 octaves?
She has 2nd octave notes in studio so she could have 5 octaves without the 8th octave. But this is just speculation, the only notes that she has publicly displayed for now are Bb2 - E6, about 3.5 octaves.
@@cameron7644 that’s a good I actually didn’t even know she could go that low
im wheezing pls
Leave
I remember only being able to sing up to *D6*
now I can sing up to *E7*
So sabrina has more octaves than ariana ?
Ariana
D2- Eb7
@@Ed16fs Fry doesn’t count, so wth with the D2 💀💀
@@Ed16fs ariana is D3-Bb7
@@Ed16fs C#3-Bb7
She didn't say that she has a 5 octaves vocal range or more, in fact the person in this video say that and its false. Sabrina in the interview say that her vocal coach told her that she can do whistles, period. She didnt say anything about having a 5 vocal range or more.
Alguien me lo traduce
Who?
It’s in the video title.
emmmm...
shes assuming thats shes mariah carey💀💀💀
Mariah set the blueprint for all these hoes 🦋🐑
@@Wowitzkay the blueprint literally
@@Wowitzkay periodddd 🦋🐑
Literally never said that or indicated that in the slightest. Mariah Carey does not own the whistle notes either, so what is your point?
She isn’t girl leave
Unfortunately 😂🤨she doesn't any 5 octave range and a whistle register
So the answer was no she can't
Not yet.
@@SoSeriouslyunserious lol ever
But she has the capability of singing in it, that was the point
@@jonathan_8100 in what world
@@WTFENIGMA its not that hard to sing in the whistle register lmfao