Red Dawns and the End of Stories

แชร์
ฝัง
  • เผยแพร่เมื่อ 7 พ.ย. 2024

ความคิดเห็น • 93

  • @toby4700
    @toby4700 ปีที่แล้ว +40

    One interesting difference between the two versions is product placement. Red Dawn originally had a scene were the Wolverines go to McDonalds when they first sneak back into town, only to find it's now a hangout spot for rowdy Soviets. It was featured in a lot of the promo material, but was ultimately cut from the movie. Conversely, Dead Wrong features a scene were its Wolverines burst into a Subway and proceed to rob the place. Just something I find interesting to think about.

  • @darrenrenna
    @darrenrenna 5 หลายเดือนก่อน +44

    "Aged like a bucket of fish"--stealing that line!

    • @silverjohn6037
      @silverjohn6037 4 วันที่ผ่านมา

      Don't insult a rotten bucket of fish by comparing it to Hollywood. At least you can get garum from that bucket.

    • @YadraVoat
      @YadraVoat วันที่ผ่านมา

      Making garum?

    • @silverjohn6037
      @silverjohn6037 วันที่ผ่านมา

      @@YadraVoat A type of sauce popular in ancient Rome. Supposedly a bit like Worcestershire sauce.

  • @awsumguy-bh9pz
    @awsumguy-bh9pz ปีที่แล้ว +33

    this channel is so underrated u deserve 1 million subs already

    • @baahcusegamer4530
      @baahcusegamer4530 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

      Agreed. A year after your comment, sadly it is only at 13K. This gentleman is thoughtful and articulate. Even if I don’t agree with absolutely everything he says, he dishes out an enormous amount of food for thought.

  • @KhanTrav
    @KhanTrav 7 หลายเดือนก่อน +21

    As a kid in the 80s I loved the film. I never even bothered with the remake.

    • @slappy8941
      @slappy8941 13 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

      The remake could've been a lot better with just a little effort, but it was just a typical Hollywood cash-grab, with no feeling.

  • @antherthalmhersser7239
    @antherthalmhersser7239 ปีที่แล้ว +20

    With enough money and hubris, you can fix anything in post.
    This is the bumper sticker.

  • @MM22966
    @MM22966 9 วันที่ผ่านมา +7

    Talking about Red Dawn while walking in snowy, rural Rocky Mountain landscapes. Life is good.

  • @procopiusaugustus6231
    @procopiusaugustus6231 ปีที่แล้ว +19

    In the early’90s I showed the original to a Russian GRU major I knew. He loved it 😊

  • @ImperatorZor
    @ImperatorZor 6 หลายเดือนก่อน +52

    This video is overlooking an important point: in both Vietnam and the Afghanistan the resistance fighters were not just random peasants with a can-do attitude. Rather they were both quasi-state entities which were well organized and reasonably professional. They were also supported and backed by the Soviet Union and the US respectively, who provided materiel as well as training.

    • @comentedonakeyboard
      @comentedonakeyboard หลายเดือนก่อน +2

      And after the (complete and catastrophic failure of the) Tet Offensive South Vietnamese Guerillas where more and more replaced with regular North Vietnamese soldiers.

    • @dansmith1661
      @dansmith1661 8 วันที่ผ่านมา

      @@comentedonakeyboard Tet Offensive was a yearly thing. Why did they call it Tet?

    • @comentedonakeyboard
      @comentedonakeyboard 8 วันที่ผ่านมา +3

      @@dansmith1661 Tet is the traditional Vietnamese New Year. And traditionaly a time of Peace, a bit like Christmas. And both sides had agreed to a cease fire over the Hollydays, which the Comunists then violated.

    • @Yurihoodjr1975
      @Yurihoodjr1975 วันที่ผ่านมา

      Yeah not true!

    • @Yurihoodjr1975
      @Yurihoodjr1975 วันที่ผ่านมา

      He might not come out and mention the state backing he mentions how the Dead Wrong remake conflates the characters

  • @robertlehnert4148
    @robertlehnert4148 ปีที่แล้ว +24

    1984 Red Dawn made director-writer John Millus persons non grata in Hollywood

    • @Sedgewise47
      @Sedgewise47 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      🤔Really?(!)…

    • @robertlehnert4148
      @robertlehnert4148 ปีที่แล้ว +3

      @@Sedgewise47 per a documentary I saw on Millus, with his cooperation

    • @Diakron79
      @Diakron79 6 หลายเดือนก่อน

      @@Sedgewise47 Yeppity. Yep. 😐

    • @ImperatorZor
      @ImperatorZor 6 หลายเดือนก่อน +3

      Apparently he was a huge asshole and people did not want to work with them.

    • @DarthNicky
      @DarthNicky 3 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      No, it didn't. Just look at his filmography after 1984

  • @CamelNotation222
    @CamelNotation222 21 วันที่ผ่านมา +5

    I listened the opening remark multiple times, brilliant. One remark, Red Dawn always felt to me like an homage to old Yugoslav Partisan films. There are quite a few of them, some are monumental.

    • @MM22966
      @MM22966 9 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

      Yes, but how many Americans or even Westerners period, have seen these Yugoslav films? Even I only know they probably exist, as various East Bloc countries were known for making large-cast/state-supported military and historical patriotic films.

  • @discerningmood2674
    @discerningmood2674 9 วันที่ผ่านมา +4

    It’s fine, I struggle to imagine the modern Hollywood producer’s mind being able to comprehend and internalize the themes that resounded throughout the original. I’m sure he watched it at got “this is a war action movie, I will remake it by doing all the action war movie things.”
    Ideas of citizenship, individual action, and the American spirit are foreign to the Hollywood man.
    The subversion of some scenes is so deep as to be malicious. Displaying not only a lack of understanding, but almost an understanding and hatred. The blood drinking rite of passage scene, a rite that is ancient going back thousands of years - maybe more, being perverted into a joke is a stand out example.
    In the end, they were never capable of making a remake that understood the spirit of the original. I truly believe that only a beautiful mind can make beautiful art

  • @michaelfodor6280
    @michaelfodor6280 4 วันที่ผ่านมา +2

    The end of stories seems apt considering one scene in both movies. When the Wolverines become too much of a problem for the local forces, the special forces are called. In the original, you see a band of soldiers marching into town wearing their distinctive light blue berets and striped shirts. If you know your Soviet uniforms, you know they're Spetsnaz. The next scene is where the Spetsnaz Colonel delivers a speech in Russian on how to really fight guerillas. This cements their status as real bad-ass opponents, and that the battle between the two in going to be decisive
    In Dead Wrong, they just pan to a slavic looking person in a plain olive drab uniform and say, "The special forces are here". And the rest is just as inconsequential.

  • @mojrimibnharb4584
    @mojrimibnharb4584 5 วันที่ผ่านมา +2

    We have become the children in Mad Max - Beyond Thunderdome.

  • @BoraHorzaGobuchul
    @BoraHorzaGobuchul 8 หลายเดือนก่อน +48

    Old red dawn is much better story-wise, though its realism is subpar. The new one is worse on both accounts.

    • @mitchellsmith4690
      @mitchellsmith4690 8 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

      I think the reaIism thing needs one caveat: the quality of the east block mockups. In the Army, at the time, we watched Red Dawn and the trainer would interupt the film and have us identify the vehicle depicted, because they were better than the mockk ups we had.

    • @michaelfodor6280
      @michaelfodor6280 5 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

      @@mitchellsmith4690 Apparently the CIA was snooping around the set to find out how Milius got a Soviet T-72. Milius had to explain that he only had a US M-48 and a really, really good prop guy.

    • @terryxperry
      @terryxperry 17 ชั่วโมงที่ผ่านมา

      The remake have jed a marine teaching them made more sense then the 80s one. The problem was for the older movie watcher they couldn't relate because the new storyline was aim at young people at the time. Just like the 80s one was aim at us.

  • @comentedonakeyboard
    @comentedonakeyboard หลายเดือนก่อน +6

    Original Red Dawn has a lot of inverted Western vibes.

  • @ColonelHess
    @ColonelHess ปีที่แล้ว +11

    I have yet to see the 2012 version of the movie, to be honest, I thought it looked bland at the time, seems like a good movie to laugh at with friends but little else. I guess the problem with our new movies is, like you said in your last video, an issue with the experience of the writers- the first writers cared about independence and self reliance, the new writers value other things.

  • @Gruntvc
    @Gruntvc ปีที่แล้ว +7

    I have seen both versions and I definitely preferred the 1984 original. Movie remakes, especially ones based on 1980s films, rarely if ever are as good as the original.
    Both Homefront games were decent and are usually pretty cheap now, though like the Red Dawn remake they used North Korea as the antagonists over China.

    • @crusader2112
      @crusader2112 4 หลายเดือนก่อน

      A fantastic “Red Dawn” video game is Freedom Fighter. A fantastic game where you play as a resistance fighter taking back New York from the Soviets. The soundtrack is also fantastic, definitely top 3 game soundtracks. Hope you had a Happy 4th. 🇺🇸👍

  • @mastpg
    @mastpg 9 วันที่ผ่านมา +2

    "What you said was wrong"...well, not really, but dont forget that the....uhhh, realism of a military invasion was FULLY characterized, at least somewhat obliquely but VERY clearly if you're over 15yrsold, for the female Wolverines through dialogue. Cannot imagine any studio being brave enough for that level of honesty today.

    • @MM22966
      @MM22966 9 วันที่ผ่านมา

      What?! The female lead is a not a stronk woman who overcomes all challenges, is a veritable Rambo that shows up all her male counterparts, and actually gets treated like a woman in wartime, good & bad???!
      Heresy! You're going to Feminist Judge Court!

    • @mastpg
      @mastpg 9 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

      @MM22966 "Adapted" today, Deader Wrongest's lead would be a 15yrold girl of mixed race and ambiguous sexual orientation with a similarly diverse set of friends in the Wolverines. She'd already be amazing at everything...maybe a throwaway line about Delta Force and SAD being interested in her projects, but the casting would the by far the most complex thing about the movie, and of course, in the finale, our hero would take down a battalion of Iranian and Russian special forces singlehandedly.
      I can't wait for Ironheart!

  • @jaegarviking3846
    @jaegarviking3846 ปีที่แล้ว +13

    I remember that I was 14 years old when the movie was released and I didn't see Red Dawn 1980s before, however, it didn't call me as much as the 1980s. Precisely, because the movie was released a couple of years after a game called Homefront that basically, I'm not kidding. Is that. A North Korean Red Dawn who had annexed South Korea and conquered Japan and built an Asian Co-Prosperity Sphere by driving out the American presence. By the way, could you give your opinion on the factions of the video game Fallout New Vegas: The New California Republic and Caesar's Legion? I admit to being Pro-Legion of Cesar but because of my displeasure for the corruption and the "laxity" of the NCR.

    • @feralhistorian
      @feralhistorian  ปีที่แล้ว +8

      I vaguely remember that Homefront game existing.
      Thanks for the New Vegas suggestion, I'm adding that to the planned lineup.

    • @jaegarviking3846
      @jaegarviking3846 ปีที่แล้ว +5

      @@feralhistorian They even made a book. Homefront La Voz de la Libertad that personally explained a lot about the events.

  • @bombfog1
    @bombfog1 ปีที่แล้ว +6

    Were you, once upon a time, a US Soldier, Airman, Marine, or a Sailor

  • @padawanmage71
    @padawanmage71 11 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

    That you said ‘Dead Wong’ till I saw the closed captioning 🤣

  • @kborak
    @kborak 6 หลายเดือนก่อน +3

    God, did you ever nail it!

  • @LegendStormcrow
    @LegendStormcrow 9 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

    Homefront was basically Red Dawn 2012, but way better, until the last few missions. You can see where funds ran out.
    And yes, they got forced to change the Chinese to NK.

  • @ExoSquadOffical
    @ExoSquadOffical 5 หลายเดือนก่อน +4

    What city was this apartment at the end in?

    • @feralhistorian
      @feralhistorian  5 หลายเดือนก่อน +5

      Pontiac, Michigan.

  • @byron2FZ
    @byron2FZ 7 วันที่ผ่านมา +2

    I'd be really curious to hear your thoughts on what I would call Australia's Red Dawn equivalent, Tomorrow When The War Began. Similar plot conceit but with a nebulous unnamed South-East Asian force as the enemy invaders. It's a 7 book series, though I'm pretty sure both goes at adapting it only bothered with the first book.

  • @robertkreutzer4107
    @robertkreutzer4107 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

    So glad I didn't see the remake!

  • @andrewlancaster7083
    @andrewlancaster7083 11 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

    Agree with this take.

  • @produccionesquino
    @produccionesquino ปีที่แล้ว +8

    The 2012 version Red Dawn was the movie me and my old brother saw, and to be honest we like it specially me since I just noticed like it was a movie version of the videogame homefront. It sucks they change the chinese for the north koreas in fear of offending china, I'm tired of movie producers bending the knee to china like yeah I know their population is up to the billions but they are not the entire world. You still have India, Russia and South America. Anyways it was later that I discover it was a remake from the 1984 version and though I have yet to see it full (since I only watch some scene and catch on the final in TV) it's way better than the 2012 version. And since we are talking about early 2010's movies I would like to see your take on "world invasion battle los angeles"

    • @feralhistorian
      @feralhistorian  ปีที่แล้ว +4

      Yes, Battle of Los Angeles or whatever they ended up calling it. That's worth another look.

  • @DavidBrown-wo9ip
    @DavidBrown-wo9ip 3 วันที่ผ่านมา

    In the last 40 years I’ve watched the original over 100 times. I’ll be honest I was sort of expecting an 80’s “training montage” showing the Wolverines transitioning from high school kids to guerrilla fighters, but John Milius wasn’t that kind of a movie maker, thank G-d.
    I’ve seen the remake twice, the second time likely to remind myself why I hated it the first time! Though I did like the “training montage.” Still it, and all of the other criticisms you pointed out are on POINT!!!
    I DESPISE the Matt character in the remake. He is genuinely a character of his time, an emo millennial that is somehow the star quarterback, but should have really been the frontman for a Blue October cover band. The latter is way more believable. Of course this culminates in him going off script severely compromising a mission, and gets a team mate killed, to go rescue his girlfriend. AND then without ANY sense of accountability yells at his brother saying “what else was I supposed to do!” How about your F**CKING job! A more fitting end to the character would be him pleading for his life, followed by the “North Korean” captain looking square at the audience and putting a bullet in Matt’s head, followed by a collective “thank you” from the audience, followed by the “North Korean” saying “you’re welcome.”😎✌️

  • @brendanhoens2035
    @brendanhoens2035 17 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

    At the very least, with the North Koreans in the remake-which-shall-not-be-named, the Chinese are still on the table as an appropriate villian if a decent remake is ever considered. Today's US/China dynamics would make it more relevant than ever, too.

  • @ideologybot4592
    @ideologybot4592 หลายเดือนก่อน +4

    I would never argue anything positive for the remake, but for once, I think you're off base in the analysis.
    The degree to which the original is about an independent band or tribe, with shades of Native American influence, going up against an industrialized power is overstated. The intro to that movie made it very clear that it wasn't so much a frontier as rural Anytown USA, the invasion seen from the vantage of kids at a high school, and the Wolverines were receiving radio messages from an obviously government-run freedom station. The self-identification was obviously American, the goals were resistance against invaders of America, and the little tribe took on a name taken from a school mascot. There's national identification, the boys reflecting a clearly American character and self-image loaded with capable good guy-isms, and while changing the protagonist from a boy to a Marine looks statist to a cynic (no offense), just having a little bit of earnest respect for the military and cops lets you see them as community members, friends, as well as The System. Then you can take it for how it was intended: the training is a plot convenience, they have skills the others need. The boys in the original RD had skills taught by their fathers; in the modern age, with survivalism being a fringe activity that might valorize some paramilitary preppers in Montana, this would be, ah, slightly un-PC. The times, they are a-changin'.
    The new film sucks for a lot of reasons, not the least of which is that this generation doesn't have a Milius sitting around to make it. But its chief failure is simply that it's safe and lazy. It's not any more statist than any other action movie with Americans as heroes, and in a way, the suits were right: it's junk, and it's not worth pissing off the Chinese. We can find a better vehicle for that.

  • @saiga12commander
    @saiga12commander 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Totally agree.

  • @Zundfolge
    @Zundfolge หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    I always refused to watch the 2012 remake over the Chicom to Norko swap nonsense. I can see now that was a wise decision.

  • @davidlee4068
    @davidlee4068 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

    The remake did indeed suck. I got turned onto the original via John Steinbeck’s The Moon Is Down which I believe was inspiration for the original. It’s a 1942 book and 1943 film in which a town is overrun by an aggressive neighbor and the villiagers slowly learn how to resist.

  • @ssyn6626
    @ssyn6626 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Never seen the remake but geez you have a great point the awful modern propaganda pours of it. The west is done what happens when you let a bunch of rich fools rule you too long.

  • @jasonthorpe7087
    @jasonthorpe7087 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    Your So cool!

  • @RikkiSan1
    @RikkiSan1 5 วันที่ผ่านมา

    It's funny how in the early 2010's Hollywood was so obsessed with getting that Chinese movie money

  • @hugh-johnfleming289
    @hugh-johnfleming289 20 ชั่วโมงที่ผ่านมา

    Third time watching and I can't get past your bitter nature...

  • @zamoragera13
    @zamoragera13 ปีที่แล้ว +6

    The 84 movie was way better.

  • @PulpHerb
    @PulpHerb 10 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Never saw the remake because I never saw the point of it. The original was a thing of its time (and kinda flopped initially) and should be appreciated as what it was. While perhaps the underlying beats are timeless the story itself is not.

  • @wynfrithnichtwo8423
    @wynfrithnichtwo8423 12 วันที่ผ่านมา

    I am like 666. Granted it is just a number, but i needed something to bug the algorithm and AI with. . . GWOT was a thing at the time; so, the older brother being a sandbox vet is not so abnormal.

  • @George_M_
    @George_M_ 3 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Original RD is pre-election Reagan, 2012 is post-election Reagan.

  • @pestulio07
    @pestulio07 ปีที่แล้ว +4

    *timidly raises hand*
    I....didn't hate the remake. The original is obviously 100x better, but as a basic action movie, Dead Wrong wasn't nearly as bad as I thought it would be.

    • @feralhistorian
      @feralhistorian  ปีที่แล้ว +10

      On its own merits, Red Dawn 2012 is a decent but forgettable action movie. Like so many movies these days, it probably would have been better received if it tried to be its own thing instead of riding the coattails of a classic with name recognition.

    • @ab5olut3zero95
      @ab5olut3zero95 7 หลายเดือนก่อน +7

      Seems to me the Dead Wrong version suffered from what the Critical Drinker would call ‘remastered for Modern Audiences’ failure. People rarely hunt now. Most people have never held a gun. Most people have no idea how to fight anything. Most people don’t read about classic survivalists or trappers making their way in the harsh frontier. All the changes made reflect these as modern tropes that tried to bring the original into the modern era, but obviously failed miserably for those very reasons.

    • @ideologybot4592
      @ideologybot4592 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      @@ab5olut3zero95 and that's why the protagonist and his dad were military and police, respectively. It's not statism. It's just that normal people in America today wouldn't have had fathers that taught them how to fight. If that had been held over, the movie would have looked like it was glorifying prepper gun nuts.

    • @gustavoalmanza2673
      @gustavoalmanza2673 6 วันที่ผ่านมา

      @@ideologybot4592You just gave me an idea dude. Hear me out: Red Dawn in the hood

  • @LtColwtf
    @LtColwtf 3 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Good analysis. The remake was soulless.

  • @ambushbob5383
    @ambushbob5383 21 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Ya, the North Korea thing was too much for my suspension of disbelief.

  • @jasoncornell1579
    @jasoncornell1579 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Wolverines!!!

  • @lachlanwilliams5818
    @lachlanwilliams5818 6 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Dead Wrong, the remake noone asked for.

  • @cynbartek9324
    @cynbartek9324 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    See your points. Definitely prefer the original!

  • @ricardoaguirre6126
    @ricardoaguirre6126 3 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Is it weird that im a millennial liberal who likes Red Dawn?😅 (The original of course)

    • @laramyelliott2903
      @laramyelliott2903 3 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

      Not at all. The truth is there are "libertarian" and "authoritarian" elements both on the left and right and sometimes those elements have more in common with each other than with people on their own side.

  • @tedyoung7715
    @tedyoung7715 5 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Trade the russian helmets 4 blue ones and its not so far fetched

  • @JanJansen985
    @JanJansen985 12 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Dont take this the wrong way but you look like Zack Wards dad

  • @hellsonly8908
    @hellsonly8908 ปีที่แล้ว +6

    Red Sawn the remake, is a byproduct of the triumph of capitalism