Coming back to this almost year later now that the sequel is being put out. I’ve seen at least one person suggest that the ending is supposed to be ambiguous. Is Twilight awakening from a nightmare? Is Celestia taking her to the other side? Or perhaps these are the last thoughts in her mind as she dies? An interesting dilemma to be sure, but somehow, I think the sequel might answer that.
You do realize this is kind of the twilights fault is that she kind of rarity‘s fault that she commit suicide, and now no matter if you like it or not, it is very‘s fault that she made the choices that she made. Everyone has a choice so they should always make the one that they need to not to survive, but also just because she made the choices is why she lost a friend. She made the wrong ones. You always have a choice and you should pick the right one not the wrong even bad people deserve a lifestyle that’s why everyone deserves a life God wouldn’t like it if no one I mean, no one would believe in him I will always believe in him no matter what But twilight sparkle. It was not her fault in the fanfic. It was very for making the choices she made and don’t even try to fight back. OK please just agree on me on this OK
You do realize it’s kind of not twilights fault it is rarities she chose to make twilight commit suicide is basically it’s not that she had a hard time. Everyone has a choice they should make the right one just because rarity that twilight was Dad. She didn’t have to blame her for it. She has choices that she can make. You should always pick the right ones no matter what you should always forgive no matter what, so she shouldn’t forgive twilight. Please agree with me on this and please don’t try to fight back. I know that twilight was crying in that it’s not her fault and that where she put yes, twilight was going through a harder time then her friend should jerk and selfish, and she should’ve not to pick the choices that she made always forgive no matter what I would if I gave twilight for the for the moment I met her that’s why you should pick three choices God Not like it if you were bad, and you chose the wrong choices
It has been an honor to voice Angerjack for this. Seriously, there is so much love and passion poured into this. Everyone, from the artists, to the VAs, to you Scribbler. This production has been amazing to see come to fruition, and everyone should be proud. Thank you
What I love about this is that Pinkie hasn't turned into some crazed murderer with a vendetta against anyone or anything. She's just....sick. The death of Celestia and the "abandonment" from Twilight really hit her harder than anyone that it made her Pinkie sense glitch out and kept her alive for so long, waiting for the moment when Twilight would actually come back. I honestly think had Twilight not shown up, Pinkir would've lived to an old age with a broken body, still holding that endless party, waiting for the real Twilight to return.
I love this angle too. It made the entire scene with Pinkie so much more powerful, especially since they were able to properly talk about everything in the end.
To those wondering about the ending: It's meant to be ambiguous and viewers can pick the explanation they prefer: Did Twilight ascend into alicornhood, did Celestia's ghost come to fetch her soul as she died, was it a dream (the line echoes Celestia waking her up in the carriage in Ep1), or was it the last throes of a dying mind?
After this conclusion, Scribbler definitely deserves her break. We love and respect all the effort she and her team put into this thrilling project. Whatever she has planned next for us, I’m sure it will be amazing! Great job on this, Scribbler Productions.
i had a feeling AJ was harboring feelings, which only made it all the more heartbreaking when she quite literally lost her love TWICE her home, her family, her friends, her crush, all gone.
@@zarrinbari3542 well, idk if this could be true or I’m just being silly, but remember the guard that died protecting Twilight in the first episode of this? Blue mane, yellow fur, royal guard armour, sounds like Flash Sentry? He was also shown in the song at the start of this episode, where Twi and Celestia are by the cooking pot
Everypony handled trauma as their worst self. Twilight's anxiety, Luna's wrath, Applejack's anger, Rainbow's gloat, Rarity's vanity & Pinkie's pinkie, led to their declines. Except Fluttershy who flat out just, had her life just fu**ing ruined but stayed her true, kind self. Even Spike and his hoarding. It was all very well thought out from the perspective of the characters and starting the story out earlier on in the series before they overcame these faults was a smart way to explore them.
I think Fluttershy's flaw was that she never learned to truly trust other ponies, shutting herself off from the pony world and isolating herself in dangerous places. It was not her fault she ended up in a slave cage, but if it wasn't slavers, *something* would have eventually happened. Maybe she would have gotten eaten by the evil horses that killed the Princess, or burned by dragons (which she was still afraid of when encountering them alone), or an illness that turns you into a tree, or any number of other things in the wild Everfree. The point is that she allowed her shyness to pull her away from her friends and the rest of society.
The whole story of Friendship is Tragic was a ride filled with all kinds of emotions. Every episode had a reason for us to stick around. Everybody who was involved in this project I want to thank. The story itself was a interesting way of doing an AU but also in it's own cannon. Being in between Season 2 and Season 3, was an interesting idea and it works. Even though the ending was VERY sad and emotional, I'm glad that it done and scared of doing so. Rather than everything was just something Twilight was experiencing in her 6 year coma or it was all a nightmare Twilight had before her trip with Celestia. Scribbler Productions this is why we the MLP Fandom Love you. I'm excited that there is going to be a sequel and can't wait for whenever that happens but for now I hope you enjoy your deserved break.
Cozy Glow: "...The End!" And that was my creative writing project! Everypony: ...O_O?! Starlight Glimmer: Um, Cozy Glow please see me and Headmare Twilight after class.
Holy... I knew Pinkie would have been far gone, but then to see her die right after admitting to her craziness... Wow... Just wow... This series is hitting really hard in the feels...
Pinkie’s death is on Luna. If Luna had been truthful to Pinkie, if Luna had just told her friends what had happened to Twilight earlier, Pinkie wouldn’t have gone down the road she did.
Arguably the state of Spike and the main six's lives are all Luna's fault; if from the moment she had learned about Twilight's state, Luna had let them know Twilight was in a coma, then they'd have strong enough resolve to stick together for her sake, then maybe they could have helped each other out and prevented the various tragedies and decisions that led them to end up the way that they did.
@@crassweller11 Dude, do you even listen to yourself? Did you watch season 2 of FiT at all? Alright, let me help you understand. As far as I can understand, the events of the whole drama started shortly after Luna was freed. 1000 years is huge amount of time, it is not something that you can catch up even in few months. And learning to rule this new world? Forget it. And yet, Luna was faced with an ultimate challenge. Not only her sister's death was a strong emotional distraction, but she also had to rule a world and ponies she doesn't know. Ponies that mostly don't know or trust her too. And there also were ponies who tried to use Celestia's death for their own profit and income, being inside enemies. Luna had a few trusted advisors at the best. Oh, and the war just started, just to make things more challenging. Considering all of that, the fact that Equestria didn't fall was a very amazing feat done by Luna. So, yeah, Luna didn't fail at all. As for mane 6... read again what I wrote above. Economy is trembling, the war just starter, everypony is scared, her sister is dead... and Luna yet should worry about some five ponies? For all she knew, Twilight was dead and Elements of Harmony were useless without her, so those ponies weren't important to her at all. She had no time or reason to look out for them.
In general, I wouldn't fully blame Luna for what happened to the main 6. BigMac would still get a loan from the wrong ponies, Rainbow dash would still ended up hurting herself for being too cocky, Rarity would probably had not found Fluttershy, and AppleJack tried to stop Twilight from seeing Pinkie. If she didn't see Pinkie, she would had still been alive, and like what Pinkie said, she was happy like that. And Celestia was wrong for putting Luna in her position. It was only a few months from being imprison and haven't gotten used to the new era. I'm not excusing what Luna did, but seeing people blaming Luna alone is messed up.
At last, the finale has arrived. This series has been a whirlwind from start to finish and has quickly become a personal favorite. Kudos to everyone who participated in making this project great-Scribbler, for fleshing out the story and the countless hours of editing she put into each video. Vermillion, for writing the original. The voice actors and actresses, for giving life to the characters, both big and small. And, of course, let’s not forget the artists responsible for creating every scene. You all should feel proud of the work you’ve done here.
At the end, I got vibes that Celestia ascended into ethereal godhood, and now she's taking Twilight to ascend into godhood too. She said "Would you like to continue our journey?" Because for them, death is only the beginning...
The finale of Friendship is Tragic was indeed sad and I legit cried. Well done on the Friendship is Tragic series to you and your friends, Miss Scribbler
I think Rarity is actually redeemable, but just barely. Her generosity to Fluttershy, what she endured to free her, was very big, even if she let herself become very corrupted by her trauma. She will still need to make some major changes before she deserves to be forgiven.
"A wise man once said friendship was magic" "The way I see it, it's been nothing but tragic." -PrinceWhateverer, "Between Fairytales and Happy Endings"
This series was really well written, and I really love how the Thumbnail throws you for a loop about what actually happens. The story left me in tears.
I'm manly enough to admit that this one made me cry. I was afraid that this would end with the "It was all a dream" cop-out or the whole "And they all lived happily after", but you stick with the tragic ending worthy of the Shakespearean or Greek tragedies.
@@oldeskul well she did make a part 2 to this and she said that in part two it would describe what happens after the first part so who know mabie it might all be a dream
You are very sneaky including my creation of Angerjack from PonyTown during the credits. But jokes aside, I am truly grateful to be a part of this production. Just remember that we will always love you, boss. Thanks for bringing us and the crew together to bring all of this to life. It has been an honour working with you, Scribbler. ^^
It is so hard to make me cry, but this. This. This make me openly sob, and in the best way possible. The story was amazing, the art, the sounds, the animation! You all did so amazing with this project and I'm glad I was able to watch it! Thankyou Scribbler! Thankyou, everyone who worked on this masterpiece!
Indeed the story alone is a tear jerker but the art the sounds the vocals all of that put together with such emotions you just get caught up in it and them tears come flowing
If Twilight can somehow get her friends back together (No idea what she would do about Rarity, and possibly Pinkie too) she might be able to become the princess of friendship still, and fix things. Or maybe we'll get another downer ending! Either way, love the story! Thank you everyone who worked on it! -- The above was written while the episode was premiering, so it is off, spoilers ahead. Can I just say, for one, again, thank you everyone who worked on this! It really is a fantastic piece. I also just wanted to say, while Twilight maybe gone now, she died truly being the spirit of friendship. She knew going to see Pinkie was possibly dangerous for herself, yet she was there for her friend when no one else was. She would've fought Applejack, knowing she would've almost definitely lost for her. She held her while she died, when no one else had seen her in years. She loved all her friends, and even wished Rarity well, and a relationship with the others still. If there is a sequel, I really hope her remaining friends can take to heart what Twi always stood for. Friendship can be tragic, but it is also magic, and in that spirt, she has gone to continue her friendship with Pinkie, Celestia, and her family.
sadly twilights dead the original story she steps out of the window and falls and in the end it all goes dark. tis why friendship is tragic. best case is that the rest of them settle their differences to honor their lost friends
Guess not all stories have happy endings. Out of all those stories, this one hurts me the most right now. Goodbye friendship. Goodbye Pinkie Pie. And Goodbye Twilight Sparkle. On the bright side, anyone can rewrite a story so it would have a happy ending. There are so many ways to tell a story. And different versions is what makes them interesting. Sometimes, you could never predict how'd they all turn out
This series is truly one of the most beautiful and heart-wrenching masterpieces I have ever had the pleasure of viewing. Well done to Scribbler and all the cast & crew who brought this wonderful creation to life. You're all remarkably gifted and talented. God bless you all😘
This project was absolutely wonderful. It made me cry so many times, but I just had to come back for each and every episode. The writing, the voice acting, the art, the music, everything was absolutely wonderful and helped made this piece have so much impact and beauty. No matter how sad and, of course, tragic this was, it is truly a masterpiece that everyone should experience. To every single person who had a hand at creating this wonderful work of art, I want to give you a thank you from the bottom of my heart. Friendship is Magic means the world to me, and seeing people put so much work and love into making amazing works like these truly puts a tear to my eye. Once again, thank you so much.
Thank you for this honour of having me play Luna for you in this! It's been such a journey, you've poured so much love and dedication into this project and your performance utterly SHINES. Breathtaking, breathtaking 👏👏👏👏
As a Brazilian fan, I started seeing things from the MLP community recently. I'm proud to say that I followed this series from beginning to end. Scribbler, I must say that your work was not in vain, your hours editing each part of the video for us to deliver an extraordinary story, were not in vain. Know that like me other Brazilian fans follow your work and I must say for them that you excelled in this story. and that you and all this amazing team deserve a rest haha. Now speaking for me, I came from the Lion King community, I even have a fanfic. however I entered the last few months in the MLP community after finishing the series. and i must say, it was one of the best things i ever did, just like the lion king, my head explodes with fanfic ideas and stories to write, like adventures, novels, and scary. But anyway, I disperse with a thank you for your dedication and affection, after all this is something that we Brazilians easily notice hahaha. now rest, you deserve (Actually anyone with good eyes, but I think we Brazilians are used to bad things in our country, that we appreciate any jewel that appears, and for sure, this channel and this story, it's a diamond) (and I used google translator, any error is because of that, I'm not very good at writing in english hahaha)
This was a wild ride. Wow. Everyone did an amazing job just...wow. I can't even begin to express my feelings here (without it going into spoiler territory for those who've not watched this yet). I will say this (without spoiling it): Twilight's fate makes sense. I'm excited for a possible sequel, but don't worry. I won't go crazy on ya like everyone else was doing in the chat. But seriously, I'd buy everyone who worked on this drinks! Amazing! Bravo! This was a wild ride, and I look forward to watching it all again from the beginning, and to more future content here.
Wait there's going to be a sequel?! Awesome! I can't wait to see more of what happened/happens to them. Also humugazoid thanks and kudos to Scribbler and everypony who worked on this, your friendship Is magic 🧡
@@roukerasati9611 Agreed! But unfortunately I don't think we'll see Spike waking up anytime soon, dragons sleep for a hundred years remember? So I think he'll be out for a while ☹️
A very fitting end to something with tragic in the name. Man I can't believe the series is over already, feels like it was yesterday whenever I got the invitation to come and help work on this project. That being said, this reeks of love and talent, what an amazing adventure. Of course i owe it all to you Scribbler, thank you so much for giving me this opportunity to show off my skills, you've truly made a kids dream come true. Here's hoping for more collaborations in the near future :)
This storyline felt like the epitome of demoralizing Twilight's character. I seriously applaud you on how you paced her deconstruction throughout to the very end along with a stellar performance! All of you did an incredible job with the artwork along with the voice performances! Well done 👏
This was probably my favorite audio drama I’ve EVER seen! Great job Scribbler, you did an amazing job. And good job all the VAs, for bringing these broken characters to life! This was truly a masterpiece!! I really wish there was an epilogue, cause I can’t imagine how Flutters, Rainbow and AJ are gonna go on after this. Especially Applejack! This episode broke me. It had all the feels, mostly sadness. When Pinkie died, it was so sad 😭 and when Twilight broke down, blaming herself, I felt so bad for her. She’s been through so much in the past couple days, and I can’t imagine how she felt about it all. And when Applejack tried to stop her, I was praying she would succeed, but sadly...she didn’t...and when Twilight fell from the window, Applejack’s reaction broke me! It was heart wrenching! 😭😭 Lost did an AWESOME job as her, as always 😉 *(Along with all other VAs like I said, of coarse!)* The saddest part for me was definitely when Twilight committed suicide. I loved Twilight and Applejack’s relationship throughout the whole series. How, even though Applejack seemed hard as stone, she obviously still cared about Twilight a lot. She wanted nothing more than to protect her, and make sure she didn’t lose her again. Now that her family wasn’t there anymore, Twilight was probably the pony she cared about most in her life. Thinking about that during that part makes it so much harder to watch! Poor AJ...): Overall, this was a flawless masterpiece, and I’m so happy you decided to do this! You never fail to impress, Scribbler. None of the cast and crew does. Great job to you, Lost, Cloud9, MuseScript, Magpie, BasicallyBB, and all the other VAs! And all the artists did an awesome job, too! I always love looking at the art cause it’s always so pretty and helps bring it to life along with the voicing. Everyone did an amazing job, and I really hope to get more amazing stuff from you soon! Thank you for bringing this tragic story to life in the most amazing way possible :)
I’ve seen Bride of Discord, Princess Trixie, The Moon Rises, Remembrance, Daughter of Discord, Rogue Diamond, Time Fades, Confrontation and The Count of Monte Christo but this, this was just outstanding. A favorite
This was such an amazing and heart wrenching production. All of the VAs and artists did such an incredible job with these 7 episodes. I'm so glad I could help out in the production as Pinkie Pie 🎈
This is what Inspired me to make the my own Projects. People like these who make stuff like this touch my heart. People like, Ashley H, Magpiepony, Scribbler Productions, thelostnarrator, and others thank you for making videos over the years you guys really helped me when I was down when I first moved and MLP has helped me with this too but thank you.Continue what your doing and do your best.
So heartbreaking for Twilight and her friends this was so hard to watch I ended up crying so hard. Although this is an alternate reality of how Twilight's journey ended up. This story is very depressing and emotional. Twilight's being gone and coming back really affects her friend's outcome. I will like to give a round of applause to Scribbler, the voice actors, and the rest of the crew. This was a masterpiece and this story was well done.
I don't think words can describe the feelings that went through me through out this whole series. I knew it wouldn't have a happy ending but damn, the scene with Pinkie managed to break me fully. I haven't openly sobbed that hard over a series in a long time. Truly remarkable and amazing work everyone. From the VAs, the Artists, the Writers and you, Scribbler. Thank you for all the hard work, dedication and love you've all put into this series! 💜👏
Oh, oh that ending. That son of a gun silhouette fall from the very beginning. You foreshadowed that fall, from the very beginning. SCRIBBLER YOU GENIUS! (Incredible work everyone, incredible work. This was quite the journey, and I'm happy that it was seen through and through. Till the next adventure Scribbler, I tilt my hat to you...)
Oh please, please, PLEASE don’t let Pinkie kill them all... Edit: Okay, good news, it’s didn’t go down like that. Bad news? It...went down like it did. This really was a heartbreaking story. 😢
I remember thinking back to when I first caught wind of this project *months* ago: ‘Wow, this is gonna feel so amazingly crazy when it’s over.’ And now here we are. This series was some of the most fun and (work lol) I’ve ever put into a project, and I loved it every single step of the way. So much heart, love, and passion went into every detail from every person on the team and it absolutely shows. Thank you so much for allowing me the honor of voicing Rainbow Dash in this series, it truly was an amazing experience. And major props to all the voice actors and artists and EVERYONE who brought this to life, you all should be super proud of yourselves and I appreciate you all!!
Thank you for your talent. The voice acting totally brought us into this series and helped us identify with the Mane 6. And how many times did you have to say "Luna's hairy butthole" before the final take? I don't know how you could say that without bursting out laughing.
God this was amazing, I wasn't expecting it to end as such... I swear I wish I could see if the others at all will change... Poor Pinkie... Friendship is Tragic, and twilight couldn't handle being responsible for everything that had happened in her absence... I am glad she found enternal peace with celestia, and maybe someday the other ponies as well
This was quite the ride. Impressed by the voice acting, like seriously. I could tell Scribbler's Twilight voice was breaking towards the end of her big monologue.. but that's expected honestly. I'm more impressed everyone was able to hold their character voices for so long while crying, screaming, coughing, etc. Fantastic work from everyone involved. You made me ugly cry on my birthday
❤️❤️Holy crap... That was amazing! The story, the flash backs, the way the characters turned out in the end. Incredible job to everyone who worked on this. 10000/10! ❤️❤️
And with this ending, you all deserve a nice break, you all did a fantastic job and put so much effort in this! Thank you all for this amazing thrilling story of Friendship is Tragic. 👏 👏 👏 👏 👏
It was a real pleasure to be a part of this series! Thank you very much! Seeing it all come together has been absolutely incredible, and you deserve a well earned rest for all your hard work!
My HEART is completely DECIMATED! Why do you make me feel this way about pastel colored ponies? I’m gonna go CRY for a LONG while now. Everypony who helped put this together did an excellent job! We all wouldn't be feeling this way if it was a mediocre production! Scribbler, since SuperChat wasn't working, is there an alternate way to donate for such an excellent production?
oh boy this was a depressing ride. i got to the end almost in tears just thinking "say sike right now, please for the love of everything say sike right now" I loved it, wonderful voicing from the whole cast, excelent writing and directing on scribblers side im gonna go cry myself to sleep now. this was a blast
Scribbler, I honestly cannot thank you enough for including me on such a wonderfully emotional journey with Friendship is Tragic. My heart was literally shattered with this final episode… I went into this video with high expectations and I was not, in the slightest, disappointed. Absolutely marvellous work once again! 😍 This was just the perfect ending for such a beautiful series. I will always be grateful for being part of a lovely project with a ton of delightful people. Many new friends have been made and I hope to stick along with you for the potential future of Friendship is Tragic. I loved every single second of this series. 🙌 From, Faolan and Cortez. 💚
This was depressing, but I loved the whole audio series the whole time. Hope to see more glorious works like this come in the future. And save those settlements!
I think, for a brief second, that my heart stopped. I'm in tears. This was a fantastic and heartbreaking story. Again, you all did so amazing! It even inspires me to go and speak to some of my old long lost friends.
This was incredible! Every moment of it was truly a Rollercoaster of emotion, A round of applause to everyone who participated and to Scribbler who brought us this incredible series!
Ngl, i cried the entire time i was watching this😭, but overall i really enjoyed this audio drama Scribbler thank you so much for giving us this emotional rollercoaster of an amazing series, and huge congrats to all the talented artists and VA's who participated in this project everyone did such a magnificent and incredible job on this masterpiece!!! And even though i can't believe Pinkie Pie died, i'm glad she was able to forgive Twilight but sadly Twilight couldn't forgive herself so she thought taking her own life was the only way she could punish herself but also redeem herself at the same time...but anyway i loved this series!
Thank you Ms. Scribbler and everyone involved for this, even though it was sad and heartbreaking. And thank you for portraying my beloved Pinkie the way you did. May the ponies never die.
My GOODNESS!! This has been simply amazing! From the fantastic VAs to the incredible artists! But I must say, the Oscar has to go to you Scribbler for Twilight's heart-wrenching monologue! ;_; It has been such an honor to work on this project with all these talented people!
Scribbler, you and the crew are amazing. I'm glad Friendship is tragic exists. This was an amazing yet heartbreaking experience to see unfold. Thank you❤😊 Edit: The change of song almost had me in tears. I was not expecting that at all. I was ready to hear the other one from previous episodes, but man this made the episode a tearjerker even before it started. Good job scribbler. The fluid moving animation was a very nice touch👍 This really was just...tragic.
3 ปีที่แล้ว +7
this is genuinely the best MLP fanfic/story I've heard in awhile, Scene brought a tear to me eye.
Okay, finally finished after a few delays and all I can say is, what an ending! This whole series was an emotional Rollercoaster and the ending... Aj crying her love for twilight... Pinkie dying... Relationships damaged quite possibly beyond repair... Chills...
This has been a really awesome series! From the whole begining, it has been really cool! I didnt expect the ending at all. And awesome job to the people who voiced the characters. This whole series was really cool! I cant wait to see what you have planned for the future.
Amazing job on the adaptation everyone involved, the art was great, the voice acting was amazing. You all did a great job hope you are able to take a well deserved break scribbler, you earned it.
And then Princess Luna discovered the time travel spell in the Canterlot Achieves, used it to go back in time, and convinced Twilight and Celestia not to go on their doomed journey. Thus, she and her tragic timeline vanished from existence, and everypony went on living their lives through Season 3 and beyond, never knowing the terrible fates that could've befallen them. (I'm sorry, I couldn't bear this painful ending - don't judge me.)
I knew something was wrong with her. Didn't think she go full cupcakes on ponies now. Edit: Also can't wait for the Sequel!! Edit 2: Ok, so I went back to where twilight was braking down while holding pinkie pie, if you listen closely you can hear celestia whispering to twilight: The window twilight. jesus.
The first time I’ve been seeing this, I wasn’t even prepared on what I was going to put myself into, this story was everything to wake some emotions you didn’t even know you had for these characters, seeing them all in this tragic timeline till the very end, tears won’t stop getting out and lots of thoughts are running around in my head, other than that, this was an amazing, the performances, the fanarts, the story, everything! I really like seeing how people can come and work together to make a this kinda of series possible, I wish you the best for your future content, I’ll be sure to look out on newest videos from you!
I just wanted to say thank you from the bottom of my heart! It has been an absolute pleasure to make artwork for this series. It does a fantastic job of tackling some tough topics, and to help bring that to life has been nothing but an honor. Everybody truly gave their all, and you can see the love and time devoted to this project. It's breathtaking. Thank you. #applethicc
Oh my goddesses what a way to end a series. Thank you Scribbler & Friend’s. I really enjoyed this with all my heart. Keep up the good work. Have a wonderful day.
SCRIBBLER! I have no words. this absolutely made my cry at the end, just seeing twilight's flashbacks and AJ crying just makes me sad. "Friendship Is Tragic" indeed :( You deserve a good month break, or more. Just seeing you do all of this makes me wonder if you even sleep lol. Anyways, in otherwise tones, I love your videos, been subbed for a very long time, and I wish you have a beautiful and peaceful day. much love!
Joker and/or Pinkamena Diane Pie: “I used to think my life was a tragedy… but now I realize it’s a bucking comedy!” (This was perhaps the best audio drama I have had the pleasure to listen to! Phenomenal job all of you! Thank you All for this, ALL OF THIS!)
That gut wrenching scream of "I love you" broke my heart. Everyone did amazing, but Lost really managed to shatter me. I was just recovering from the crying after Pinkie's Song. This was beautiful, seriously
I'm crying, the best MLP story I've ever seen (applause for everyone who's done a great job on this one) I really liked this mic (definitely keep doing this great job, I think it has a future) 😖😖❤️
Angerjack has my heart forever! LOL This was such a wonderful watch! I enjoyed every episode! Its such a wonderful piece in the MLP community! All the hard work that went into this and all the support is so amazing to see. Much love to everyone involved in this!
Man I always ignore the best videos 😅 This is undoubtedly one of the best audiodramas I've ever listened to. The writing and voice acting were absolutely superb. Everyone did a wonderful job! ❤❤❤
My God........ I'm just in tears from the ending. These episodes were so amazing but heartbreaking at the same and this ending just broke me into tears. Good job Scribble. Good job
Mega props to everypony involved, as usual. I super mean it. I really think that showing up at the finale is my gimmick. Regardless, I loved how this turned out. Brilliant artwork and everything. *squeals* ❤️
Just a reminder to y'all, one amazing person from the FiT team has posted our final reactions of this particular episode, you can check it out here: th-cam.com/video/zRIUe0d6ld8/w-d-xo.html
Without giving too much away, lets just say that the thumbnail isnt what you'd expect the tragic story to go 😢😢😢 Thank you Scribber and everyone else involved for putting your all into this series!
Wow that was great, well done to everyone! Love listening to dark stories like these while I work on art! (All my predictions were wrong, even the one on a pony being chubby after the time skip! XD)
This series is honestly the most terrifyingly haunting thing related to MLP I've ever seen, and I mean that in the best way. The horror only serves to elevate the emotion and weight of the scene, it's not just thrown in your face suddenly to get a cheap scare out of you. This story is simply a look into the psyches of each of these characters as a result of the situation they were thrown into, and like it says on the tin, it's a tragedy. You see them all change from the ponies you knew them to be, and while you will definitely won't agree with the decisions they make throughout this, you can understand what drove them to that point, especially Twilight. It's not in your face, it approaches you slowly, giving you time to fully process what's happening. To sum it up, this is probably the best piece of MLP horror ever put onto the internet. Spoilers Below!!: This is probably the most inspired choice of what to do with Pinkie in a piece of MLP horror fiction. We've all read Cupcakes at some point, and I honestly have never been more relieved that the thumbnail lied to me. I mean Pinkamena was a thing seen in the show itself so it makes sense people would default to just dialing up that to a million for horror, but you've honestly covered the two aspects that I've never seen in MLP horror: Her selflessness, and her love of her friends. Rarity may be the element of Generosity, but Pinkie is the most selfless. We saw in the show that she cares about others much more than herself; she is willingly to leave Ponyville to because she harmed Dash in the goof-off, she puts herself through so much trouble to keep Shining Armor and Cadence's secret because she knows how important it is to them, etc. She will willingly put herself aside for her friends, because she cares for them so much. This story simply takes that selflessness and dials it up, combining it with that Pinkamena element so that she literally runs herself to her grave to keep Twilight happy, even if she didn't keep her promise. She never went off the deep end, but she went too far in trying to keep her own promise to Twilight, and ends up losing herself in the process. Her death was such a poignant moment, and the dread you feel as soon as she starts coughing is palpable. As for Twilight, while I can never condone su1cide, I will admit the sequences showing her broken mind, the trap she falls into thinking that this was all her fault, and following the apparent hallucinations of Celestia are very well written. I'll admit I would've personally preferred Spike to catch her as she fell or something, but I understand that would take away from the main focus on tragedy that this series has. I understand why Twilight isn't saved, and I accept that. It does fit the tone, and I respect that decision, though I don't support the decision she ended up making. However, on a more positive note, I'm very happy Applejack was there to remind the audience that what Twilight did at the end was wrong; she was right, none of what happened in the series was Twilight's fault, and you should never blame yourself for things that happen that are beyond your control. Sometimes people don't realize that, and make terrible decisions because of that. Mental health is very important, and I'm glad that was acknowledged. It makes it even more fitting that it comes from Applejack, the pony who in this series has lost the most people in her life, especially those close to her. It allows that mental health reminder to be present without breaking immersion or character, and I love that. Sorry for writing such a long comment, but I felt like getting my thoughts out was the best way for me to process this episode and this series in general, especially due to its dark tone and heavy themes, which is something I don't usually dabble in. The writing in this series was amazing, and it is definitely one of the best horror stories in the fandom. Great job and rest easy.
So, it's over.... It's been said plenty of times, but the hard work pulled off by everyone involved is nothing short of masterful. Everyone here should be proud of what they accomplished! The talent in this production is simply amazing.
My god that was so well written, literally put me to tears at 20 years old hahah. So happy to be able to hear this. Losts scream at the end is what did it for me. That “I love you” was intense. Everybody did such a good damn job! 👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾
this makes me cry every time I watch this, this story is a masterpiece that has such strong emotions it has you hanging on to the last second its beautiful, I love this series. scribbler you are so talented with this series and your other stories. And I love the ending even with it being sad it is also so touching.
My words fail me to describe how Incredible this was XD this has brought me to tears and shattered my heart, to be able to do that alone shows how amazing this was😭 I had high expectations for this just from the trailer alone and I was still blown away XD THANK YOU all from the bottom of our hearts to those who are involved in this project and this will stay in my heart forever ❤
this series TRULY had such a huge impact on me, that a tear slipped out of my eye. I'm actually choking up trying to too cry right now, especially at the part where pinkie pie's death and Twilights.
I have two theories on how pinkie pie died 1. Due to her environment that she was living in for the past four years, she might’ve developed a parasite living in her stomach, but due to malnutrition, the parasite would just eat what it could get, that and the cause of malnutrition, might have been the reason why I think your pie was so skinny and have lost a bit of hair, now the reason why pinkie pie have been coughing up blood, might have been that the parasite had crawled up into her lungs and started eating them, and due to the lack of nutrients, pinkie pie’s body wasn’t able to fight off the parasite, she died from a parasitic infection, and malnutrition. 2. Over the years, pinkie pie might have developed either a leukemia or lung cancer, because she hasn’t been getting treatment, she hasn’t been getting better over the years, and the shock of seeing twilight might’ve made of the cancer spread a lot faster, causing her to cough up blood, and pass away. Which theory do you think is more accurate?
Delay? pfft. The finished product is what matters and it is fantastic. I love that we can still get such quality content based off a show that ended in 2019. Its a shame Luna's actions had to be a huge plot device for this story BUT is like season 2 continuity so I get it. The moment Luna knew that Twilight was alive and in a coma she would have told her friends through letters or in person. Knowing what we know now through dreams too but I digress. This in no way takes away from this whole thing and all the excellent hard work and dedication put into it. In conclusion; *Luna best princess*
![[MLP Comic Dub] Cutie Mark Crusaders and the Jelly Guy (comedy)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ft013FTncKw/mqdefault.jpg)
![[MLP Comic Dub] Cutie Mark Crusaders and the Jelly Guy (comedy)](/img/tr.png)
![History Repeats: Episode 04 - Always Darkest [Full Cast Audio Drama]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/qoNjLU_Y_7U/mqdefault.jpg)
![Friendship is Tragic: EPISODE 6 - Friends Like These Are a Rarity [Full Cast MLP Audio Drama]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ZACGb4SUhoY/mqdefault.jpg)
Coming back to this almost year later now that the sequel is being put out. I’ve seen at least one person suggest that the ending is supposed to be ambiguous. Is Twilight awakening from a nightmare? Is Celestia taking her to the other side? Or perhaps these are the last thoughts in her mind as she dies? An interesting dilemma to be sure, but somehow, I think the sequel might answer that.
You do realize this is kind of the twilights fault is that she kind of rarity‘s fault that she commit suicide, and now no matter if you like it or not, it is very‘s fault that she made the choices that she made. Everyone has a choice so they should always make the one that they need to not to survive, but also just because she made the choices is why she lost a friend. She made the wrong ones. You always have a choice and you should pick the right one not the wrong even bad people deserve a lifestyle that’s why everyone deserves a life God wouldn’t like it if no one I mean, no one would believe in him I will always believe in him no matter what But twilight sparkle. It was not her fault in the fanfic. It was very for making the choices she made and don’t even try to fight back. OK please just agree on me on this OK
You do realize it’s kind of not twilights fault it is rarities she chose to make twilight commit suicide is basically it’s not that she had a hard time. Everyone has a choice they should make the right one just because rarity that twilight was Dad. She didn’t have to blame her for it. She has choices that she can make. You should always pick the right ones no matter what you should always forgive no matter what, so she shouldn’t forgive twilight. Please agree with me on this and please don’t try to fight back. I know that twilight was crying in that it’s not her fault and that where she put yes, twilight was going through a harder time then her friend should jerk and selfish, and she should’ve not to pick the choices that she made always forgive no matter what I would if I gave twilight for the for the moment I met her that’s why you should pick three choices God Not like it if you were bad, and you chose the wrong choices
@@jacobanderson6053 twilight was dad???
At first I thought right after pinkie died discord would show up and or would at least come in the sequel and fix everything
@@mrmorningstar4216 I wish 🥲
It has been an honor to voice Angerjack for this. Seriously, there is so much love and passion poured into this. Everyone, from the artists, to the VAs, to you Scribbler. This production has been amazing to see come to fruition, and everyone should be proud. Thank you
Amazing job Lost
You're voice is pretty
Pog
Great voice acting btw
You did great Lost. All of you did. ❤️
*Luna:* Hey guys so how's Twilight doing? Haven't heard from her in a while
*Everyone:*
*Luna:* ...Guys?
No... Just No.
Too soon
What's the moral of the story children
Dude that was way too soon way too soon
She dead.
What I love about this is that Pinkie hasn't turned into some crazed murderer with a vendetta against anyone or anything. She's just....sick. The death of Celestia and the "abandonment" from Twilight really hit her harder than anyone that it made her Pinkie sense glitch out and kept her alive for so long, waiting for the moment when Twilight would actually come back.
I honestly think had Twilight not shown up, Pinkir would've lived to an old age with a broken body, still holding that endless party, waiting for the real Twilight to return.
I love this angle too. It made the entire scene with Pinkie so much more powerful, especially since they were able to properly talk about everything in the end.
I can’t Imagine having to see your friends lose her grip on Reality and being unable to do anything about it. 9:18
To those wondering about the ending:
It's meant to be ambiguous and viewers can pick the explanation they prefer: Did Twilight ascend into alicornhood, did Celestia's ghost come to fetch her soul as she died, was it a dream (the line echoes Celestia waking her up in the carriage in Ep1), or was it the last throes of a dying mind?
I think it actually happened, man. Twilight actually died. I personally think she's done.
@@FriendsOfSon-uvaDash she dead it show in the original fanfic that has the video title name
she had to have dreampt it hope so anyways
it's pretty clear that she died. even the original story said she died,.
I couldn't tell if twilight's pupil at the end was her at the bottom of the castle or if i was seeing things.
After this conclusion, Scribbler definitely deserves her break. We love and respect all the effort she and her team put into this thrilling project. Whatever she has planned next for us, I’m sure it will be amazing! Great job on this, Scribbler Productions.
I agree they put so much effort in it’s amazing
100% agree
Agreed. Everyone deserves a break. There's never a need to rush things.
We've seen a lot of darkness, we really deserve some light
Definitely agree with that!!! You deserve it scribbler for all the work you did!
*Applejack:* WAIT TWILIGHT!
*Twilight:* ...?
*Applejack:* ....DO A FLIP
Too soon bro. But I can't lie that did kinda make me laugh and cry at the same time
Im maybe kind of retarded but is this a small nod to twjack
This just makes me think of that Tumblr thread where a user’s teacher got kicked out of the theater for yelling diving scores during Titanic.
LMFAO
I'm dead! XD XD XD
i had a feeling AJ was harboring feelings, which only made it all the more heartbreaking when she quite literally lost her love TWICE
her home, her family, her friends, her crush, all gone.
What about twilight’s crush
I thought that too, she said something about wanting to impress Twilight before. :/
@@zarrinbari3542 did she even have one in this I can't remember????
Gald to see it wasn’t just me thinking AJ had feelings for twi
@@zarrinbari3542 well, idk if this could be true or I’m just being silly, but remember the guard that died protecting Twilight in the first episode of this? Blue mane, yellow fur, royal guard armour, sounds like Flash Sentry? He was also shown in the song at the start of this episode, where Twi and Celestia are by the cooking pot
Everypony handled trauma as their worst self. Twilight's anxiety, Luna's wrath, Applejack's anger, Rainbow's gloat, Rarity's vanity & Pinkie's pinkie, led to their declines. Except Fluttershy who flat out just, had her life just fu**ing ruined but stayed her true, kind self. Even Spike and his hoarding.
It was all very well thought out from the perspective of the characters and starting the story out earlier on in the series before they overcame these faults was a smart way to explore them.
Owlowiscious: So... Uh...
I think Fluttershy's flaw was that she never learned to truly trust other ponies, shutting herself off from the pony world and isolating herself in dangerous places. It was not her fault she ended up in a slave cage, but if it wasn't slavers, *something* would have eventually happened. Maybe she would have gotten eaten by the evil horses that killed the Princess, or burned by dragons (which she was still afraid of when encountering them alone), or an illness that turns you into a tree, or any number of other things in the wild Everfree. The point is that she allowed her shyness to pull her away from her friends and the rest of society.
@@jacksquatt6082 illness that turns a pony into a tree 🤔 hmm sounds a little familiar 😥
you're wrong on the luna one, you cant have peace with houses that want to eat you alive.
Yeah but they were all alive AFTER. Pinkie never got the fucking chance to do that. She died due to wasting away.
The pain in Applejack's voice at the end just broke my heart into a thousand tiny pieces
I know my heart literally shattered at that part 😭
The tone in her voice… She didn’t want to lose her too…
yeah poor applejack rip twilight
The whole story of Friendship is Tragic was a ride filled with all kinds of emotions. Every episode had a reason for us to stick around. Everybody who was involved in this project I want to thank. The story itself was a interesting way of doing an AU but also in it's own cannon. Being in between Season 2 and Season 3, was an interesting idea and it works. Even though the ending was VERY sad and emotional, I'm glad that it done and scared of doing so. Rather than everything was just something Twilight was experiencing in her 6 year coma or it was all a nightmare Twilight had before her trip with Celestia. Scribbler Productions this is why we the MLP Fandom Love you. I'm excited that there is going to be a sequel and can't wait for whenever that happens but for now I hope you enjoy your deserved break.
Wait is there gonna be a sequel?! I really hope so
@@burknat6550 there is. Scribbler said there will be
Did she say when? I’m guessing it might be next year
@@burknat6550 No but probably
A Sequel!! 😲😱😀
Cozy Glow: "...The End!" And that was my creative writing project!
Everypony: ...O_O?!
Starlight Glimmer: Um, Cozy Glow please see me and Headmare Twilight after class.
This is going to be what I believe actually happened.
If it was as good as this, I’d personally give that project an A+
Congratulations Miss glow you are the winner of mlp's grimdark story of 2021
Ok this definitely happened at some point
Even better
Nighsay:"..... The End!"
Me: dude you need help.
Holy...
I knew Pinkie would have been far gone, but then to see her die right after admitting to her craziness...
Wow...
Just wow...
This series is hitting really hard in the feels...
Yeah. I got emotional when I first watched this
Pinkie’s death is on Luna. If Luna had been truthful to Pinkie, if Luna had just told her friends what had happened to Twilight earlier, Pinkie wouldn’t have gone down the road she did.
Arguably the state of Spike and the main six's lives are all Luna's fault; if from the moment she had learned about Twilight's state, Luna had let them know Twilight was in a coma, then they'd have strong enough resolve to stick together for her sake, then maybe they could have helped each other out and prevented the various tragedies and decisions that led them to end up the way that they did.
Sloso
It's all Luna. Her failure to rule created the world that changed the mane 6. Her failure to look out for the 6 ponies who saved her.
@@crassweller11 Dude, do you even listen to yourself? Did you watch season 2 of FiT at all? Alright, let me help you understand.
As far as I can understand, the events of the whole drama started shortly after Luna was freed. 1000 years is huge amount of time, it is not something that you can catch up even in few months. And learning to rule this new world? Forget it. And yet, Luna was faced with an ultimate challenge. Not only her sister's death was a strong emotional distraction, but she also had to rule a world and ponies she doesn't know. Ponies that mostly don't know or trust her too. And there also were ponies who tried to use Celestia's death for their own profit and income, being inside enemies. Luna had a few trusted advisors at the best. Oh, and the war just started, just to make things more challenging. Considering all of that, the fact that Equestria didn't fall was a very amazing feat done by Luna. So, yeah, Luna didn't fail at all.
As for mane 6... read again what I wrote above. Economy is trembling, the war just starter, everypony is scared, her sister is dead... and Luna yet should worry about some five ponies? For all she knew, Twilight was dead and Elements of Harmony were useless without her, so those ponies weren't important to her at all. She had no time or reason to look out for them.
In general, I wouldn't fully blame Luna for what happened to the main 6. BigMac would still get a loan from the wrong ponies, Rainbow dash would still ended up hurting herself for being too cocky, Rarity would probably had not found Fluttershy, and AppleJack tried to stop Twilight from seeing Pinkie. If she didn't see Pinkie, she would had still been alive, and like what Pinkie said, she was happy like that. And Celestia was wrong for putting Luna in her position. It was only a few months from being imprison and haven't gotten used to the new era. I'm not excusing what Luna did, but seeing people blaming Luna alone is messed up.
At last, the finale has arrived. This series has been a whirlwind from start to finish and has quickly become a personal favorite. Kudos to everyone who participated in making this project great-Scribbler, for fleshing out the story and the countless hours of editing she put into each video. Vermillion, for writing the original. The voice actors and actresses, for giving life to the characters, both big and small. And, of course, let’s not forget the artists responsible for creating every scene. You all should feel proud of the work you’ve done here.
Damn right
Painful too watch but beautiful in a sense
This aged well
At the end, I got vibes that Celestia ascended into ethereal godhood, and now she's taking Twilight to ascend into godhood too.
She said "Would you like to continue our journey?" Because for them, death is only the beginning...
This was a heartbreaking ending Scribbler, and I'm actually crying right now because of the deaths of Pinkie and Twilight, RIP to both of them
yeah no kidding
The finale of Friendship is Tragic was indeed sad and I legit cried. Well done on the Friendship is Tragic series to you and your friends, Miss Scribbler
I think Rarity is actually redeemable, but just barely. Her generosity to Fluttershy, what she endured to free her, was very big, even if she let herself become very corrupted by her trauma. She will still need to make some major changes before she deserves to be forgiven.
I hate that my favorite character turned to that, although im
not surprised.
Wow just wow just who does that rarity thinks she is
@@morgiemango6242 she is my favorite too. But yes you can tell where they fell from.
@@zarrinbari3542 yes
Well she was Turned into those Griffins Play Things in case you forgot still she should have seen a Therapist.
"A wise man once said friendship was magic"
"The way I see it, it's been nothing but tragic."
-PrinceWhateverer, "Between Fairytales and Happy Endings"
I actually like how Pinkie Pie wasn’t a cannibal in this version, and just lost in her own mind
This series was really well written, and I really love how the Thumbnail throws you for a loop about what actually happens. The story left me in tears.
I'm manly enough to admit that this one made me cry. I was afraid that this would end with the "It was all a dream" cop-out or the whole "And they all lived happily after", but you stick with the tragic ending worthy of the Shakespearean or Greek tragedies.
@@oldeskul well she did make a part 2 to this and she said that in part two it would describe what happens after the first part so who know mabie it might all be a dream
You are very sneaky including my creation of Angerjack from PonyTown during the credits. But jokes aside, I am truly grateful to be a part of this production. Just remember that we will always love you, boss. Thanks for bringing us and the crew together to bring all of this to life. It has been an honour working with you, Scribbler. ^^
Your Pony Town Angerjack is a work of art! 👍
@@maybehawthorn Heh, thanks. It was pretty simple to create Angerjack on Pony Town as I thought it would be.
It is so hard to make me cry, but this. This. This make me openly sob, and in the best way possible. The story was amazing, the art, the sounds, the animation! You all did so amazing with this project and I'm glad I was able to watch it! Thankyou Scribbler! Thankyou, everyone who worked on this masterpiece!
Indeed the story alone is a tear jerker but the art the sounds the vocals all of that put together with such emotions you just get caught up in it and them tears come flowing
@@ArcCahlon Yes! It's so beautiful, I could barely put it into proper words!
I was at work when I listened to this finale. It took every in my power to not cry. Fanfics don't make me cry, but hearing it ripped out my heart.
I'm genuinely surprised that Pinkie has stayed alive in the castle for multiple years with such conditions, but Rip
My guess is she had party food to eat. Prob very unrealistic lol.
@@morgiemango6242 Nope you got a point. Pinkie probably took soo much party food because she had hope she would find Twilight at that castle.
She says that miss and mr cake came to drop off food outside the castle door
If Twilight can somehow get her friends back together (No idea what she would do about Rarity, and possibly Pinkie too) she might be able to become the princess of friendship still, and fix things. Or maybe we'll get another downer ending! Either way, love the story! Thank you everyone who worked on it!
-- The above was written while the episode was premiering, so it is off, spoilers ahead.
Can I just say, for one, again, thank you everyone who worked on this! It really is a fantastic piece.
I also just wanted to say, while Twilight maybe gone now, she died truly being the spirit of friendship. She knew going to see Pinkie was possibly dangerous for herself, yet she was there for her friend when no one else was. She would've fought Applejack, knowing she would've almost definitely lost for her. She held her while she died, when no one else had seen her in years. She loved all her friends, and even wished Rarity well, and a relationship with the others still.
If there is a sequel, I really hope her remaining friends can take to heart what Twi always stood for. Friendship can be tragic, but it is also magic, and in that spirt, she has gone to continue her friendship with Pinkie, Celestia, and her family.
Remember Pinkie's Gone
Her Health And Sanity Is What Brought Her To A Painful End
Twilight's Gone Too And Rarity Isn't Changing Any Time Soon
sadly twilights dead the original story she steps out of the window and falls and in the end it all goes dark. tis why friendship is tragic. best case is that the rest of them settle their differences to honor their lost friends
@@bushytwee3333
That will be no sequel I afraid
@@zarrinbari3542 What You Talkin Bout
Guess not all stories have happy endings. Out of all those stories, this one hurts me the most right now. Goodbye friendship. Goodbye Pinkie Pie. And Goodbye Twilight Sparkle.
On the bright side, anyone can rewrite a story so it would have a happy ending. There are so many ways to tell a story. And different versions is what makes them interesting. Sometimes, you could never predict how'd they all turn out
48:00
57:27
1:00:06
All this for reason that eipsode 6 is come to close was what would rarity would have wanted this whole time
after rocket to insanity i thought this would have a happy ending :'
Damn right.
This series is truly one of the most beautiful and heart-wrenching masterpieces I have ever had the pleasure of viewing. Well done to Scribbler and all the cast & crew who brought this wonderful creation to life. You're all remarkably gifted and talented. God bless you all😘
Totally agree with you ! And love that Profile picture! Where is it from ? :D
It was from Pixie of the Miraculous Ladybug universe. I've changed my Pic though.
This project was absolutely wonderful. It made me cry so many times, but I just had to come back for each and every episode. The writing, the voice acting, the art, the music, everything was absolutely wonderful and helped made this piece have so much impact and beauty. No matter how sad and, of course, tragic this was, it is truly a masterpiece that everyone should experience.
To every single person who had a hand at creating this wonderful work of art, I want to give you a thank you from the bottom of my heart. Friendship is Magic means the world to me, and seeing people put so much work and love into making amazing works like these truly puts a tear to my eye. Once again, thank you so much.
Thank you for this honour of having me play Luna for you in this! It's been such a journey, you've poured so much love and dedication into this project and your performance utterly SHINES. Breathtaking, breathtaking 👏👏👏👏
You did great! I enjoyed your discussion with Twilight. I also love Luna!
@@AlabasterRadiance aww that's so nice Dennis, thank you! 😭❤️
You do incredible as Luna!!! XD!! 10/10!!!
You made me sob like a baby. You were all so amazing but something about your performance as Luna took my breath away
As a Brazilian fan, I started seeing things from the MLP community recently. I'm proud to say that I followed this series from beginning to end. Scribbler, I must say that your work was not in vain, your hours editing each part of the video for us to deliver an extraordinary story, were not in vain. Know that like me other Brazilian fans follow your work and I must say for them that you excelled in this story. and that you and all this amazing team deserve a rest haha. Now speaking for me, I came from the Lion King community, I even have a fanfic. however I entered the last few months in the MLP community after finishing the series. and i must say, it was one of the best things i ever did, just like the lion king, my head explodes with fanfic ideas and stories to write, like adventures, novels, and scary. But anyway, I disperse with a thank you for your dedication and affection, after all this is something that we Brazilians easily notice hahaha. now rest, you deserve (Actually anyone with good eyes, but I think we Brazilians are used to bad things in our country, that we appreciate any jewel that appears, and for sure, this channel and this story, it's a diamond) (and I used google translator, any error is because of that, I'm not very good at writing in english hahaha)
BRAZILIAN GANG!
This was a wild ride. Wow.
Everyone did an amazing job just...wow. I can't even begin to express my feelings here (without it going into spoiler territory for those who've not watched this yet). I will say this (without spoiling it): Twilight's fate makes sense.
I'm excited for a possible sequel, but don't worry. I won't go crazy on ya like everyone else was doing in the chat. But seriously, I'd buy everyone who worked on this drinks! Amazing! Bravo! This was a wild ride, and I look forward to watching it all again from the beginning, and to more future content here.
Wait there's going to be a sequel?! Awesome! I can't wait to see more of what happened/happens to them. Also humugazoid thanks and kudos to Scribbler and everypony who worked on this, your friendship Is magic 🧡
@@ahugefan8279 I know, right? Like I wanna see what'd go down once Spike woke up. Yeah, they all did such an amazing job!
@@roukerasati9611 Agreed! But unfortunately I don't think we'll see Spike waking up anytime soon, dragons sleep for a hundred years remember? So I think he'll be out for a while ☹️
@@ahugefan8279 True, but anything can happen, as we've seen in this alternate universe.
@@roukerasati9611 True 🤔 I guess we'll just have to wait and see! 😄
A very fitting end to something with tragic in the name.
Man I can't believe the series is over already, feels like it was yesterday whenever I got the invitation to come and help work on this project. That being said, this reeks of love and talent, what an amazing adventure. Of course i owe it all to you Scribbler, thank you so much for giving me this opportunity to show off my skills, you've truly made a kids dream come true.
Here's hoping for more collaborations in the near future :)
This storyline felt like the epitome of demoralizing Twilight's character. I seriously applaud you on how you paced her deconstruction throughout to the very end along with a stellar performance! All of you did an incredible job with the artwork along with the voice performances! Well done 👏
This was probably my favorite audio drama I’ve EVER seen! Great job Scribbler, you did an amazing job. And good job all the VAs, for bringing these broken characters to life! This was truly a masterpiece!! I really wish there was an epilogue, cause I can’t imagine how Flutters, Rainbow and AJ are gonna go on after this. Especially Applejack!
This episode broke me. It had all the feels, mostly sadness. When Pinkie died, it was so sad 😭 and when Twilight broke down, blaming herself, I felt so bad for her. She’s been through so much in the past couple days, and I can’t imagine how she felt about it all. And when Applejack tried to stop her, I was praying she would succeed, but sadly...she didn’t...and when Twilight fell from the window, Applejack’s reaction broke me! It was heart wrenching! 😭😭 Lost did an AWESOME job as her, as always 😉 *(Along with all other VAs like I said, of coarse!)*
The saddest part for me was definitely when Twilight committed suicide.
I loved Twilight and Applejack’s relationship throughout the whole series. How, even though Applejack seemed hard as stone, she obviously still cared about Twilight a lot. She wanted nothing more than to protect her, and make sure she didn’t lose her again. Now that her family wasn’t there anymore, Twilight was probably the pony she cared about most in her life.
Thinking about that during that part makes it so much harder to watch! Poor AJ...):
Overall, this was a flawless masterpiece, and I’m so happy you decided to do this! You never fail to impress, Scribbler. None of the cast and crew does. Great job to you, Lost, Cloud9, MuseScript, Magpie, BasicallyBB, and all the other VAs! And all the artists did an awesome job, too! I always love looking at the art cause it’s always so pretty and helps bring it to life along with the voicing. Everyone did an amazing job, and I really hope to get more amazing stuff from you soon! Thank you for bringing this tragic story to life in the most amazing way possible :)
I would read the whole thing but I agree with you
I’ve seen Bride of Discord, Princess Trixie, The Moon Rises, Remembrance, Daughter of Discord, Rogue Diamond, Time Fades, Confrontation and The Count of Monte Christo but this, this was just outstanding. A favorite
This was such an amazing and heart wrenching production. All of the VAs and artists did such an incredible job with these 7 episodes. I'm so glad I could help out in the production as Pinkie Pie 🎈
This is what Inspired me to make the my own Projects. People like these who make stuff like this touch my heart. People like, Ashley H, Magpiepony, Scribbler Productions, thelostnarrator, and others thank you for making videos over the years you guys really helped me when I was down when I first moved and MLP has helped me with this too but thank you.Continue what your doing and do your best.
Scribbler that was absolutely incredible. This episode had me crying 😭. Everyone did a truly phenomenal job on this series
This is the best, saddest, and memorable audio drama ever. I love the story, everyone who worked on this did AMAZING.
*sees the title card*
Knuckles: “Oh, no.”
Eggman:what I can’t believe this
This has to be the most darkest fanfic of mlp I have ever read/heard. Well done scribble.
Vampiolence was released a year ago and was arguably sadder and darker.
@@tudoraragornofgreyscot8482 wait WHAT i'm going to watch it
@@kajetus0688 It’s tagged “grimdark” and “tragedy” so it’s not really a spoiler to say that things are not gonna go well.
So heartbreaking for Twilight and her friends this was so hard to watch I ended up crying so hard. Although this is an alternate reality of how Twilight's journey ended up. This story is very depressing and emotional. Twilight's being gone and coming back really affects her friend's outcome. I will like to give a round of applause to Scribbler, the voice actors, and the rest of the crew. This was a masterpiece and this story was well done.
Perfect song perfect voices... I am not an emotional person but this whole story and voice acting was a hell of a roller coaster.
I don't think words can describe the feelings that went through me through out this whole series. I knew it wouldn't have a happy ending but damn, the scene with Pinkie managed to break me fully. I haven't openly sobbed that hard over a series in a long time.
Truly remarkable and amazing work everyone. From the VAs, the Artists, the Writers and you, Scribbler. Thank you for all the hard work, dedication and love you've all put into this series! 💜👏
Oh, oh that ending. That son of a gun silhouette fall from the very beginning. You foreshadowed that fall, from the very beginning.
SCRIBBLER YOU GENIUS!
(Incredible work everyone, incredible work. This was quite the journey, and I'm happy that it was seen through and through. Till the next adventure Scribbler, I tilt my hat to you...)
Oh please, please, PLEASE don’t let Pinkie kill them all...
Edit: Okay, good news, it’s didn’t go down like that. Bad news? It...went down like it did. This really was a heartbreaking story. 😢
no she didn’t went that crazy….WHATS CRAZY WAS THAT PINKIE WAS THE ONE THAT DIED!!
Oh the irony
IT IS HEARTBREAKING 💔 😢
I remember thinking back to when I first caught wind of this project *months* ago: ‘Wow, this is gonna feel so amazingly crazy when it’s over.’
And now here we are. This series was some of the most fun and (work lol) I’ve ever put into a project, and I loved it every single step of the way. So much heart, love, and passion went into every detail from every person on the team and it absolutely shows.
Thank you so much for allowing me the honor of voicing Rainbow Dash in this series, it truly was an amazing experience. And major props to all the voice actors and artists and EVERYONE who brought this to life, you all should be super proud of yourselves and I appreciate you all!!
Thank you for your talent. The voice acting totally brought us into this series and helped us identify with the Mane 6. And how many times did you have to say "Luna's hairy butthole" before the final take? I don't know how you could say that without bursting out laughing.
God this was amazing, I wasn't expecting it to end as such... I swear I wish I could see if the others at all will change...
Poor Pinkie...
Friendship is Tragic, and twilight couldn't handle being responsible for everything that had happened in her absence... I am glad she found enternal peace with celestia, and maybe someday the other ponies as well
This was quite the ride. Impressed by the voice acting, like seriously. I could tell Scribbler's Twilight voice was breaking towards the end of her big monologue.. but that's expected honestly. I'm more impressed everyone was able to hold their character voices for so long while crying, screaming, coughing, etc.
Fantastic work from everyone involved. You made me ugly cry on my birthday
❤️❤️Holy crap... That was amazing! The story, the flash backs, the way the characters turned out in the end. Incredible job to everyone who worked on this. 10000/10! ❤️❤️
And with this ending, you all deserve a nice break, you all did a fantastic job and put so much effort in this!
Thank you all for this amazing thrilling story of Friendship is Tragic.
👏 👏 👏 👏 👏
It was a real pleasure to be a part of this series! Thank you very much! Seeing it all come together has been absolutely incredible, and you deserve a well earned rest for all your hard work!
My HEART is completely DECIMATED! Why do you make me feel this way about pastel colored ponies? I’m gonna go CRY for a LONG while now.
Everypony who helped put this together did an excellent job! We all wouldn't be feeling this way if it was a mediocre production! Scribbler, since SuperChat wasn't working, is there an alternate way to donate for such an excellent production?
Um, my KoFi would probably be the best alternative? ko-fi.com/obabscribbler
@@ScribblerProductions101
Dont do this to us!!!!
Plz continue!!!!!!!
CONTINUE!!!!!!!
oh boy this was a depressing ride. i got to the end almost in tears just thinking "say sike right now, please for the love of everything say sike right now"
I loved it, wonderful voicing from the whole cast, excelent writing and directing on scribblers side im gonna go cry myself to sleep now. this was a blast
Scribbler, I honestly cannot thank you enough for including me on such a wonderfully emotional journey with Friendship is Tragic. My heart was literally shattered with this final episode… I went into this video with high expectations and I was not, in the slightest, disappointed. Absolutely marvellous work once again! 😍
This was just the perfect ending for such a beautiful series. I will always be grateful for being part of a lovely project with a ton of delightful people. Many new friends have been made and I hope to stick along with you for the potential future of Friendship is Tragic. I loved every single second of this series. 🙌
From,
Faolan and Cortez. 💚
This was depressing, but I loved the whole audio series the whole time. Hope to see more glorious works like this come in the future. And save those settlements!
We appreciate you making this project for us and I can’t wait to watch the episode you making for us ❤️💕❤️😆
That entire series was a ride! Im legit tearing up over the ending. Thank you for bringing this story to life!
I think, for a brief second, that my heart stopped. I'm in tears. This was a fantastic and heartbreaking story. Again, you all did so amazing! It even inspires me to go and speak to some of my old long lost friends.
This was incredible! Every moment of it was truly a Rollercoaster of emotion, A round of applause to everyone who participated and to Scribbler who brought us this incredible series!
Ngl, i cried the entire time i was watching this😭, but overall i really enjoyed this audio drama Scribbler thank you so much for giving us this emotional rollercoaster of an amazing series, and huge congrats to all the talented artists and VA's who participated in this project everyone did such a magnificent and incredible job on this masterpiece!!!
And even though i can't believe Pinkie Pie died, i'm glad she was able to forgive Twilight but sadly Twilight couldn't forgive herself so she thought taking her own life was the only way she could punish herself but also redeem herself at the same time...but anyway i loved this series!
Thank you Ms. Scribbler and everyone involved for this, even though it was sad and heartbreaking. And thank you for portraying my beloved Pinkie the way you did. May the ponies never die.
My GOODNESS!! This has been simply amazing! From the fantastic VAs to the incredible artists! But I must say, the Oscar has to go to you Scribbler for Twilight's heart-wrenching monologue! ;_;
It has been such an honor to work on this project with all these talented people!
This was such an amazing project to be a part of! Thank you so much for the opportunity!!! I have loved this so much!!!
Thank you for being a part of it! Seriously, you rescued this project so many times!
@@ScribblerProductions101 I was happy to do it!!!
Thank you for letting me work on your project!
I think I had most fun painting Angerjack!
Scribbler, you and the crew are amazing. I'm glad Friendship is tragic exists. This was an amazing yet heartbreaking experience to see unfold. Thank you❤😊
Edit: The change of song almost had me in tears. I was not expecting that at all. I was ready to hear the other one from previous episodes, but man this made the episode a tearjerker even before it started. Good job scribbler. The fluid moving animation was a very nice touch👍 This really was just...tragic.
this is genuinely the best MLP fanfic/story I've heard in awhile, Scene brought a tear to me eye.
Okay, finally finished after a few delays and all I can say is, what an ending!
This whole series was an emotional Rollercoaster and the ending...
Aj crying her love for twilight...
Pinkie dying...
Relationships damaged quite possibly beyond repair...
Chills...
That was absolutely incredible. Heartbreaking beyond belief, but incredible.
This has been a really awesome series! From the whole begining, it has been really cool! I didnt expect the ending at all. And awesome job to the people who voiced the characters. This whole series was really cool! I cant wait to see what you have planned for the future.
Amazing job on the adaptation everyone involved, the art was great, the voice acting was amazing. You all did a great job hope you are able to take a well deserved break scribbler, you earned it.
A truly beautiful and sad series. I am actually crying. A big round of applause for everyone who helped to create this masterpiece!
And then Princess Luna discovered the time travel spell in the Canterlot Achieves, used it to go back in time, and convinced Twilight and Celestia not to go on their doomed journey. Thus, she and her tragic timeline vanished from existence, and everypony went on living their lives through Season 3 and beyond, never knowing the terrible fates that could've befallen them.
(I'm sorry, I couldn't bear this painful ending - don't judge me.)
It’s okay dude, my hearts breaking too.
*starts hugging and back patting*
This was so amazingly done. The artwork, the story, and so much passion in the voice acting. My heart is broken, but this was a great project.
I knew something was wrong with her. Didn't think she go full cupcakes on ponies now.
Edit: Also can't wait for the Sequel!!
Edit 2: Ok, so I went back to where twilight was braking down while holding pinkie pie, if you listen closely you can hear celestia whispering to twilight: The window twilight. jesus.
there's a sequel?
@@HuskDust666 yeah boi
@@CT-BONITA how you know?
@@stuffandthangs9893 scribbler said so in the stream if you watched it.
The first time I’ve been seeing this, I wasn’t even prepared on what I was going to put myself into, this story was everything to wake some emotions you didn’t even know you had for these characters, seeing them all in this tragic timeline till the very end, tears won’t stop getting out and lots of thoughts are running around in my head, other than that, this was an amazing, the performances, the fanarts, the story, everything! I really like seeing how people can come and work together to make a this kinda of series possible, I wish you the best for your future content, I’ll be sure to look out on newest videos from you!
I just wanted to say thank you from the bottom of my heart! It has been an absolute pleasure to make artwork for this series. It does a fantastic job of tackling some tough topics, and to help bring that to life has been nothing but an honor. Everybody truly gave their all, and you can see the love and time devoted to this project. It's breathtaking. Thank you.
#applethicc
Oh my goddesses what a way to end a series. Thank you Scribbler & Friend’s. I really enjoyed this with all my heart. Keep up the good work. Have a wonderful day.
SCRIBBLER! I have no words. this absolutely made my cry at the end, just seeing twilight's flashbacks and AJ crying just makes me sad. "Friendship Is Tragic" indeed :( You deserve a good month break, or more. Just seeing you do all of this makes me wonder if you even sleep lol. Anyways, in otherwise tones, I love your videos, been subbed for a very long time, and I wish you have a beautiful and peaceful day. much love!
Joker and/or Pinkamena Diane Pie: “I used to think my life was a tragedy… but now I realize it’s a bucking comedy!” (This was perhaps the best audio drama I have had the pleasure to listen to! Phenomenal job all of you! Thank you All for this, ALL OF THIS!)
That gut wrenching scream of "I love you" broke my heart. Everyone did amazing, but Lost really managed to shatter me. I was just recovering from the crying after Pinkie's Song. This was beautiful, seriously
I'm crying, the best MLP story I've ever seen (applause for everyone who's done a great job on this one) I really liked this mic (definitely keep doing this great job, I think it has a future) 😖😖❤️
Angerjack has my heart forever! LOL This was such a wonderful watch! I enjoyed every episode! Its such a wonderful piece in the MLP community! All the hard work that went into this and all the support is so amazing to see. Much love to everyone involved in this!
Man I always ignore the best videos 😅
This is undoubtedly one of the best audiodramas I've ever listened to. The writing and voice acting were absolutely superb. Everyone did a wonderful job! ❤❤❤
My God........ I'm just in tears from the ending. These episodes were so amazing but heartbreaking at the same and this ending just broke me into tears. Good job Scribble.
Good job
Mega props to everypony involved, as usual. I super mean it. I really think that showing up at the finale is my gimmick. Regardless, I loved how this turned out. Brilliant artwork and everything. *squeals* ❤️
Just a reminder to y'all, one amazing person from the FiT team has posted our final reactions of this particular episode, you can check it out here:
th-cam.com/video/zRIUe0d6ld8/w-d-xo.html
Ah yes, the saddest time of our lives in this series. My throat hurts still.
1:00:36 what’s with a small black hole crack in her eyes
hこp
Without giving too much away, lets just say that the thumbnail isnt what you'd expect the tragic story to go 😢😢😢
Thank you Scribber and everyone else involved for putting your all into this series!
Wow that was great, well done to everyone! Love listening to dark stories like these while I work on art! (All my predictions were wrong, even the one on a pony being chubby after the time skip! XD)
I was screaming when the song came on and Twilight was running animated, that was such a good sequence!
Very nostalgic. Been waiting a long time to her that Aviators song used in something like this.
I know
What can I even say that hasn't already been said. Just plain amazing, a literal MASTERPIECE.
This series is honestly the most terrifyingly haunting thing related to MLP I've ever seen, and I mean that in the best way. The horror only serves to elevate the emotion and weight of the scene, it's not just thrown in your face suddenly to get a cheap scare out of you. This story is simply a look into the psyches of each of these characters as a result of the situation they were thrown into, and like it says on the tin, it's a tragedy. You see them all change from the ponies you knew them to be, and while you will definitely won't agree with the decisions they make throughout this, you can understand what drove them to that point, especially Twilight. It's not in your face, it approaches you slowly, giving you time to fully process what's happening. To sum it up, this is probably the best piece of MLP horror ever put onto the internet.
Spoilers Below!!:
This is probably the most inspired choice of what to do with Pinkie in a piece of MLP horror fiction. We've all read Cupcakes at some point, and I honestly have never been more relieved that the thumbnail lied to me. I mean Pinkamena was a thing seen in the show itself so it makes sense people would default to just dialing up that to a million for horror, but you've honestly covered the two aspects that I've never seen in MLP horror: Her selflessness, and her love of her friends.
Rarity may be the element of Generosity, but Pinkie is the most selfless. We saw in the show that she cares about others much more than herself; she is willingly to leave Ponyville to because she harmed Dash in the goof-off, she puts herself through so much trouble to keep Shining Armor and Cadence's secret because she knows how important it is to them, etc. She will willingly put herself aside for her friends, because she cares for them so much.
This story simply takes that selflessness and dials it up, combining it with that Pinkamena element so that she literally runs herself to her grave to keep Twilight happy, even if she didn't keep her promise. She never went off the deep end, but she went too far in trying to keep her own promise to Twilight, and ends up losing herself in the process. Her death was such a poignant moment, and the dread you feel as soon as she starts coughing is palpable.
As for Twilight, while I can never condone su1cide, I will admit the sequences showing her broken mind, the trap she falls into thinking that this was all her fault, and following the apparent hallucinations of Celestia are very well written. I'll admit I would've personally preferred Spike to catch her as she fell or something, but I understand that would take away from the main focus on tragedy that this series has. I understand why Twilight isn't saved, and I accept that. It does fit the tone, and I respect that decision, though I don't support the decision she ended up making.
However, on a more positive note, I'm very happy Applejack was there to remind the audience that what Twilight did at the end was wrong; she was right, none of what happened in the series was Twilight's fault, and you should never blame yourself for things that happen that are beyond your control. Sometimes people don't realize that, and make terrible decisions because of that. Mental health is very important, and I'm glad that was acknowledged. It makes it even more fitting that it comes from Applejack, the pony who in this series has lost the most people in her life, especially those close to her. It allows that mental health reminder to be present without breaking immersion or character, and I love that.
Sorry for writing such a long comment, but I felt like getting my thoughts out was the best way for me to process this episode and this series in general, especially due to its dark tone and heavy themes, which is something I don't usually dabble in. The writing in this series was amazing, and it is definitely one of the best horror stories in the fandom. Great job and rest easy.
So, it's over....
It's been said plenty of times, but the hard work pulled off by everyone involved is nothing short of masterful. Everyone here should be proud of what they accomplished! The talent in this production is simply amazing.
My god that was so well written, literally put me to tears at 20 years old hahah. So happy to be able to hear this. Losts scream at the end is what did it for me. That “I love you” was intense. Everybody did such a good damn job! 👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾
this makes me cry every time I watch this, this story is a masterpiece that has such strong emotions it has you hanging on to the last second its beautiful, I love this series. scribbler you are so talented with this series and your other stories. And I love the ending even with it being sad it is also so touching.
My words fail me to describe how Incredible this was XD this has brought me to tears and shattered my heart, to be able to do that alone shows how amazing this was😭 I had high expectations for this just from the trailer alone and I was still blown away XD THANK YOU all from the bottom of our hearts to those who are involved in this project and this will stay in my heart forever ❤
this series TRULY had such a huge impact on me, that a tear slipped out of my eye. I'm actually choking up trying to too cry right now, especially at the part where pinkie pie's death and Twilights.
I have two theories on how pinkie pie died
1. Due to her environment that she was living in for the past four years, she might’ve developed a parasite living in her stomach, but due to malnutrition, the parasite would just eat what it could get, that and the cause of malnutrition, might have been the reason why I think your pie was so skinny and have lost a bit of hair, now the reason why pinkie pie have been coughing up blood, might have been that the parasite had crawled up into her lungs and started eating them, and due to the lack of nutrients, pinkie pie’s body wasn’t able to fight off the parasite, she died from a parasitic infection, and malnutrition.
2. Over the years, pinkie pie might have developed either a leukemia or lung cancer, because she hasn’t been getting treatment, she hasn’t been getting better over the years, and the shock of seeing twilight might’ve made of the cancer spread a lot faster, causing her to cough up blood, and pass away.
Which theory do you think is more accurate?
I think 1 is more accurate in my mind atleast. They are really good theories!
i also agree that the first theory makes way... more sense
@@nixynightmares thank you!
It’s definitely the first one
They’re both good sad choices but I think the second one wins.
Rest In Peace Pinkie Pie
Delay? pfft. The finished product is what matters and it is fantastic. I love that we can still get such quality content based off a show that ended in 2019. Its a shame Luna's actions had to be a huge plot device for this story BUT is like season 2 continuity so I get it. The moment Luna knew that Twilight was alive and in a coma she would have told her friends through letters or in person. Knowing what we know now through dreams too but I digress. This in no way takes away from this whole thing and all the excellent hard work and dedication put into it. In conclusion; *Luna best princess*