Excellent. Job well done. It's not easy to explain your own narrative but you have done a hard job explaining other person (Dr. Bassam saeh) narratives. Good control and authority over off trake conversation with others participant during streaming.
It’s really interesting and mind boggling to explore this miraculous angle of holy Quran, I watch Dr Basam video in this regard it’s more clear and detailed
Dr. Sb. Salamun alaikum ek chenal sachwala ke nam se youTube me gardish hai wo kahta hai ki quraan arbi tuangh(boli) me hai arbi language me nahi hai mashaallah aap arbi scholar hain samjha dete to karam hota.
Kya Quraan ko bagair ahadees k,,nuzool ki wajoohat,aur us waqt paida hue haalaat,sanehat,waqeaat,k reference bagair sahi taur se samjha ja sakta hai ..
Dear Al Moses At the end of streaming you touched a sensitive but important topic and escaped intelligently. AllahuAkbar. Sometime back I came to know that during pre islamic time, Pagans used to say AllahuAkbar as Allah is Akbar as comparative statement amongst their idols as asghar elah. Simply it means to me is committing shirk. It worried me and started thinking that I am committing a shirk by saying AllahuAkbar unintentionally but shirk. That concept bothered me a lot. My thought process were intruppted realizing that in Azan and namaz rituals we listen and say repeatedly AllahuAkbar but still not satisfied and convinced my self. Duscussion with others people made me embarrassed and no positive feedback to think and share ideas but discouraging. I decided not to discuss with nobody but seek the help From Allah. Then two ideas came with Allah's willing are, first is to check Allah's 99 attributes list, could not see Akbar or Al Akbar in that list, that is the positive vibe. Second while reciting Quran check carefully where Allah declares that Allah is Akbar, couldn't find any ayah says AllahuAkbar but found Allahul Kabeer as read ayah 22:62, annullaha howel aleeyul kabeer. This the last part of ayah. I feel satisfied now and stop using Allau Akbar but people still not buying this approach at all as Quran Says Abaa Akum. Request to guide me regarding my approach, if you agree please let me know how to make people understand regarding this shirk. Sorry for a long msg but I hope that I conveyed my msg as not a good writer and expected you follow my viewpoint. Thank much for your time.
Salam, This is why I don't use Allah Akbar either. The intention is good, but gramatically weak when trying to describe God's limitlessness. You can tell people once. If they don't want to listen, it's best to move on.
@@AlMosesPhD: Talking of linguist's take - after hearing Dr. Hany Atchan's linguist take - all I foresee in these linguist takes, is a heavy leaning towards the Arab hegemony being endorsed by the God of this Universe through these so called linguist expertise. Can you please in a few words without any linguist foreplay: Quran mein aisa kya khaas hay - which other sacred scripture don't have ?
@@masihemuslim8327 hmm, that's a pretty subjective question, as ultimately there is no way to 'prove' even God, much less His word. This guy's book is a good empirical research into why the linguistic style of the Quran is 'miraculous'. Instead of just believing it, he's offered tests / hypothesis that could be applied to other scriptures in other languages. It could be a route that 'your' journey might take you on
@@AlMosesPhD: All of us are from Adam - Be black, brown or white Got to learn how to live together Not to hate - let love abide Diversity is a beauty - We got to realize No matter what's your race or religion - Walk side by side We got to prove that we are human and God has made us wise. Not challenging the Quranic linguistic style or for that matter any others, the above is something I wrote recently and would like to know where would you place it both message and linguist wise - I would have expressed it in Arabic if I was from that area or knew the language. With your study of the Quran, could you please point to a Surah/verses that projects such a message in just a few lines.
@@AlMosesPhD quran ki zaban ke bary men arab baddu jante they kisi ek shaks ko koi masla na howa hatta ki Alf lam mem jesy lafz ko bhi woh samjhte they app ki batuon se naie bachy confuse honge mera kheyal he ki abhi bohat mozo hen jin par lecture ho sakta he zaban men na oljhen sorry agar bora lage tu
Link to download Dr Bassam Saeh's book:
www.jstor.org/stable/j.ctvk8w237.5?seq=1
Bohat achhi knowledgeable video banaaeey hay....
Excellent. Job well done. It's not easy to explain your own narrative but you have done a hard job explaining other person (Dr. Bassam saeh) narratives. Good control and authority over off trake conversation with others participant during streaming.
Shukrya.
It's never possible to be 100% during sessions like these...
Best knowledge
It’s really interesting and mind boggling to explore this miraculous angle of holy Quran, I watch Dr Basam video in this regard it’s more clear and detailed
Yes, do watch Dr Bassam on YT and recommend to others.
His findings are very interesting.
Dr. Sb. Salamun alaikum ek chenal sachwala ke nam se youTube me gardish hai wo kahta hai ki quraan arbi tuangh(boli) me hai arbi language me nahi hai mashaallah aap arbi scholar hain samjha dete to karam hota.
Sachwala sb kay ghair ilmi aitrazat pe pe meri 8 videos hain agar aap dekhna chahain.
Moses kabhi moqa mily tu nawab chitari ki Jangal ki haweli zaror parhye ga app ko kafi madad mily ge
Such a great book and religion, why peoples are leaving Islam so fast in this present time ?
Are they? Hard to say either way without stats.
People always leave religions. It used to be a private affair, now it's more public.
Salam Mosa Bahi yeh jo logo k pass halal haram ki lists hen in k bary mein Quran kya kehta hy
Salam, bilkul ghalat cheez hay yeh. Completely wrong
Assalam o Aliakum
Sir Ye Pochna Chahta hu Kay Nikah mn 2 Gawah bnana lazmi hay Rehnomai Farmaye ga JazzakAllah
SA, nikah shadi nahi hay.
Mein nay is pe videos ke hain.
Aap ke according Alif lam mem ka kya meaning ho sakh tha hai ¿‽
Meray paas kuch zaati arai hain, aur kuch mushadat. Lekin abhi un pe aur ghor karna hay.
"Men Allah sab janane Wala"
Ya Arabic zuban ka usloob tha that time or ya Allah k sifati names k abbreviations hain
Kya Quraan ko bagair ahadees k,,nuzool ki wajoohat,aur us waqt paida hue haalaat,sanehat,waqeaat,k reference bagair sahi taur se samjha ja sakta hai ..
Bilkul. Yah wa'da to Khuda nay khud apnay Quran mein kya hay.
Dear Al Moses
At the end of streaming you touched a sensitive but important topic and escaped intelligently. AllahuAkbar.
Sometime back I came to know that during pre islamic time, Pagans used to say AllahuAkbar as Allah is Akbar as comparative statement amongst their idols as asghar elah. Simply it means to me is committing shirk. It worried me and started thinking that I am committing a shirk by saying AllahuAkbar unintentionally but shirk. That concept bothered me a lot. My thought process were intruppted realizing that in Azan and namaz rituals we listen and say repeatedly AllahuAkbar but still not satisfied and convinced my self. Duscussion with others people made me embarrassed and no positive feedback to think and share ideas but discouraging. I decided not to discuss with nobody but seek the help From Allah. Then two ideas came with Allah's willing are, first is to check Allah's 99 attributes list, could not see Akbar or Al Akbar in that list, that is the positive vibe.
Second while reciting Quran check carefully where Allah declares that Allah is Akbar, couldn't find any ayah says AllahuAkbar but found Allahul Kabeer as read ayah 22:62, annullaha howel aleeyul kabeer. This the last part of ayah. I feel satisfied now and stop using Allau Akbar but people still not buying this approach at all as Quran Says Abaa Akum. Request to guide me regarding my approach, if you agree please let me know how to make people understand regarding this shirk. Sorry for a long msg but I hope that I conveyed my msg as not a good writer and expected you follow my viewpoint. Thank much for your time.
Salam,
This is why I don't use Allah Akbar either. The intention is good, but gramatically weak when trying to describe God's limitlessness.
You can tell people once. If they don't want to listen, it's best to move on.
@@AlMosesPhD Then just saying AllahulKabir is like infinite as you said limitlessness.
@@AfsarKhan-gb1og yes, that'd be better to say and more reflecting God's majesty
@@AlMosesPhD Good, Thanks
Do you have a plan to vlog on this topic?. I don't recommend a live stream but watch out.
@@AfsarKhan-gb1og maybe one day. Too much else in the pipeline
dr bassem saeh ke book ka link kaha milega?
www.jstor.org/stable/j.ctvk8w237.5?seq=1
thank you
Al Moses: That was a long stream - Can you please in a few words:
Quran mein aisa kya khaas hay - which other sacred scripture don't have ?
I might do a short 10 min summary video sometime.
Best would be to read that book I've pinned if you were keen on a linguist's take
@@AlMosesPhD: Talking of linguist's take - after hearing Dr. Hany Atchan's linguist take - all I foresee in these linguist takes, is a heavy leaning towards the Arab hegemony being endorsed by the God of this Universe through these so called linguist expertise.
Can you please in a few words without any linguist foreplay:
Quran mein aisa kya khaas hay - which other sacred scripture don't have ?
@@masihemuslim8327 hmm, that's a pretty subjective question, as ultimately there is no way to 'prove' even God, much less His word.
This guy's book is a good empirical research into why the linguistic style of the Quran is 'miraculous'. Instead of just believing it, he's offered tests / hypothesis that could be applied to other scriptures in other languages. It could be a route that 'your' journey might take you on
@@AlMosesPhD:
All of us are from Adam - Be black, brown or white
Got to learn how to live together
Not to hate - let love abide
Diversity is a beauty - We got to realize
No matter what's your race or religion - Walk side by side
We got to prove that we are human and God has made us wise.
Not challenging the Quranic linguistic style or for that matter any others, the above is something I wrote recently and would like to know where would you place it both message and linguist wise - I would have expressed it in Arabic if I was from that area or knew the language.
With your study of the Quran, could you please point to a Surah/verses that projects such a message in just a few lines.
Aap se live baat ho sakti he?
Acha khasa deen ki taleem dety dety canada waly sb ki trha idhar odhar ho rahy hen yeh ibteda hoti he mat karen yeh baat
Konsi baat?
@@AlMosesPhD quran ki zaban ke bary men arab baddu jante they kisi ek shaks ko koi masla na howa hatta ki Alf lam mem jesy lafz ko bhi woh samjhte they app ki batuon se naie bachy confuse honge mera kheyal he ki abhi bohat mozo hen jin par lecture ho sakta he zaban men na oljhen sorry agar bora lage tu
@@almasjafri hmm, Arab 'badu' ki zaban ka Quran ki lisan say zero connection hay.
Mein is pe 'Quran aur aurat' series mein baatkar chuka hoon
@@AlMosesPhD acha sorry mainy nahi sona main zaror sonoo ge
Lekin app ko bhi agarmoqa mily to jangal ki haweli zaroor parhy ga